POLITICS & ECONOMICS IN LATE MEDIEVAL SOCIETY (JOAN OF ARC & THE HUNDRED YEARS’ WAR) I. LATE MEDIEVAL SOCIETY A. GENERAL REMARKS 1. WAR, VIOLENCE, LAWLESSNESS & CRIME ENDEMIC TO LATE MEDIEVAL SOCIETY 2. EVEN RECREATION FOR ALL CLASSES REFLECTED THIS 3. LATE MIDDLE AGES WILL SEE WAR BETWEEN FRANCE & ENGLAND 4. CIVIL WAR IN ENGLAND KNOWN AS WAR OF THE ROSES 5. PEASANT REVOLTS IN FRANCE & ENGLAND B. LEGEND OF ROBIN HOOD 1. TALE OR LEGEND OF ROBIN HOOD 2. SYMBOLIC OF LAWLESSNESS OF LATE MEDIEVAL WORLD 3. SCHOLARS DEBATE WHETHER ROBIN HOOD REAL OR NOT 4. WHETHER ROBIN HOOD FRIEND OF GENTRY OR PEASANT a. ROBIN HOOD BEING HERO OF GENTRY & NOT PEASANT HAS NOW BEEN ACCEPTED BY MOST MEDIEVALISTS 5. TODAY WE SEE ROBIN HOOD AS STEREOTYPE FOR ROBBING RICH & GIVING TO POOR a. SHERWOOD FOREST, LITTLE JOHN ADDED OVER YEARS b. LIKE MERLIN, LANCELOT, GUINIVERE, ROUND TABLE & KNIGHTS ADDED TO KING ARTHUR TALES c. THANKS TO EVOLUTION OF LEGEND OVER CENTURIES & HOLLYWOOD 6. IN LATE MEDIEVAL ENGLAND ROBIN HOOD STOOD FOR SOMETHING MORE 7. HAD ELEMENTS WE FIND FAMILIAR TO OUR OWN SOCIETY a. GLORIFICATION OF VIOLENCE b. SOCIETY WHERE MEN TOOK TO ROBBERY & PILLAGE (1) UNDER PRESSURE OF FAMINE & OTHER ADVERSE CIRCUMSTANCES c. SOCIETY WHERE CRIME TOLERATED d. ALBEIT LOCAL JURIES PROTECTED CRIMINALS e. GANGS OF KNIGHTLY BANDITS MIGHT GAIN ROYAL PARDON FOR EXTORTION, KIDNAPPING & MURDER f. CONCEPT OF FUR-COLLAR CRIME (1) OR TODAY WHITE COLLAR CRIME 8. ROBIN HOOD DECKED WITH CONVENTIONS OF DAY: a. CHIVALRY TOWARDS WOMEN b. GENEROSITY c. COURTESY d. LOYALTY e. OBEDIENCE 9. BUT STILL VIOLENCE 10. WHEN ROBIN KILLS SHERIFF OF NOTTINGHAM BY BEHEADING HIM a. & SHOOTS OTHERS WITH BOW & ARROWS 11. VIOLENT DEATH IS ACCEPTED WITH ALMOST CASUAL BRUTALITY 12. FROM EARLIEST TIMES LEGEND RESPONDED TO A NUMBER OF PROBLEMS & CONCERNS IN SOCIETY a. ANTI-FEELING AGAINST MONASTIC WEALTH b. AGAINST ROYAL FOREST LAW THAT PROHIBITED ALL BUT MONARCHS TO HUNT IN FORESTS c. AGAINST POWER OF LOCAL SHERIFF 13. ROBIN BELONGS TO WORLD OF HEROES & VILLAINS 14. LIKE JESSE JAMES & BILLY THE KID IN AMERICA 15. IN TIME TALE BECAME HARMLESS & FIT FOR CHILDREN 16. IN ITS ORIGIN IT SERVED BLOODIER PURPOSE C. VIOLENCE & CRIME IN ITALIAN CITIES 2 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. II. LATE MEDIEVAL VIOLENT SOCIETY TOO EVEN MORE SO THAN MODERN AMERICA AT NIGHT NO ONE VENTURED OUT IF COULD HELP IT IN FLORENCE CURFEW IMPOSED AT SUNSET a. AFTER WHICH ONLY MUNICIPAL POLICE ALLOWED IN STREETS b. SPECIAL PASS NEEDED TO AVOID ARREST c. MANY WOMEN SLEPT W/THEIR SMALL CHILDREN IN BED W/THEM AS OBSTACLE TO RAPISTS POISONING BY FAMILY & FRIENDS CONSTANT CONCERN, ESPECIALLY FOR POWERFUL a. GREAT TECHNICAL ADVANCES HAD BEEN MADE IN POISONS PUNISHMENT FOR CRIMES VERY SEVERE & DESIGNED TO DETER CRIMINALS AS WELL AS RESTORING STATE'S HONOR VENICE HAD ESCALATING SERIES OF PUNISHMENTS FOR ROBBERY WHICH DEPENDED ON VALUE OF STOLEN ITEMS 100 YRS WAR A. GENERAL REMARKS 1. IN LATE M.A. FRANCE & ENGLAND FOUGHT EACH OTHER OFF AND ON FOR OVER 100 YRS. a. 100 YEARS WAR 2. BUT REALLY SERIES OF SPORADIC SKIRMISHES, UNEASY TRUCES PUNCTUATED BY SPELLS OF INTENSE & SAVAGE COMBAT LASTING FROM 1337-1453 3. SOME INTERESTING EYE WITNESS ACCOUNTS OF BATTLES a. FROISSART'S CHRONICLES 4. WHY WOULD TWO COUNTRIES FIGHT EACH OTHER FOR SO LONG A TIME? 5. EXPENDING MILLIONS OF POUNDS & FRANCS? 6. KILLING & MAIMING THOUSANDS? B. CAUSES OF CONFLICT 1. SEVERAL REASONS a. ECONOMIC, CULTURAL, POLITICAL 2. BUT PRIMARILY FOR ECONOMIC GAINS 3. 14TH C ENGLISH KINGS STILL RULED MUCH SOUTHERN FRENCH LANDS a. GASCONY & AQUITAINE AREA b. BECAME PART OF ENGLISH MONARCH'S LAND W/ELEANOR OF AQUITAINE MARRIAGE TO HENRY II 12TH C. c. AREA WHERE WINE NOT ONLY PRODUCED d. BUT ALL WINE GATHERED, LOADED & TAXED e. AS CARGOES PASSED THROUGH ENGLISH-HELD PORT OF BORDEAUX FOR ALL OF EUROPE 4. BUT ENGLISH KINGS HELD AREA AS VASSAL OF FRENCH CROWN 5. ENGLISH KING THUS A FRENCH ARISTOCRAT a. & OBLIGED TO DEFEND INTERESTS OF HIS FRENCH OVERLORD (1) FOLLOWING FEUDAL LAW 6. IN BEGINNING OF CONFLICT 7. EDWARD III AS KING OF ENGLAND DECLARED FEUDAL CONTRACT NULL & VOID 8. FRENCH RULERS WANTED THIS RICH AREA 9. BUT EXPELLING ENGLISH WOULD MAKE WAR INEVITABLE 10. ENGLAND ALSO DEPENDED FOR ITS SALT ON MARSHES OF BRITTANY & POITOU IN FRANCE 11. ANOTHER ECONOMIC REASON a. WOOLEN TRADE IN FLANDERS 12. FLANDERS PRODUCED CLOTH PROVIDED BY ENGLISH SHEEP 13. THESE ECONOMIC CONCERNS INSEPARABLE FROM STRATEGIC CONSIDERATIONS 14. CRUCIAL FOR FRANCE TO CONTROL SEA TRAFFIC ALONG ITS COASTS 3 15. C. TO GUARD AGAINST POSSIBILITY OF FRENCH PORTS FALLING INTO ENGLISH HANDS 16. PHILIP OF FRANCE HAD BEGUN TO FORGE LINKS WITH ENGLAND'S HOSTILE NEIGHBOR a. SCOTLAND 17. ENGLAND & SCOTLAND HAD BEEN WARRING ALMOST CONTINUOUSLY SINCE LATE 13 THC. a. WHEN EDWARD I TRIED TO SUBDUE SCOTS AS HE HAD WELSH b. HIS SUCCESSOR EDWARD II HAD SUFFERED HUMILIATING DEFEAT AT BATTLE OF BANNOCKBURN c. SCOTS LED BY THEIR FAMOUS KING ROBERT BRUCE 18. EDWARD III HAD IMPOSED HIS OWN PUPPET ON SCOTTISH THRONE AFTER BRUCE'S DEATH 19. THIS SCOTTISH-FRENCH ALLIANCE WILL CONTINUE FOR MANY CENTURIES 20. WAR ALSO GREAT PLACE TO SEEK ONE'S FAME & FORTUNE 21. GENERATIONS OF ENGLISHMEN WENT TO FRANCE IN LATE MIDDLE AGES 22. WAR BOTH AVOCATION AND VOCATION FOR MANY DURING THIS TIME a. SOMETHING IN IT FOR EVERYONE 23. ALSO MANY POLITICAL REASONS 24. FLANDERS CONSIDERED VASSAL STATE OF FRENCH KINGS 25. RESULTED IN READY-MADE OPPORTUNITY FOR FLEMISH BURGHERS TO REBEL AGAINST FRENCH RULE 26. POLITICAL REASONS ALSO HAD TO DO W/WHO WOULD RULE FRANCE, a. A FRENCH NEPHEW b. OR AN ENGLISH GRANDSON DESCENDED FROM A WOMAN, 27. WHEN CAPETIAN LINE TO FRENCH THRONE DIED OUT IN 1328 28. FRENCH BARONS CHOSE FRENCH NEPHEW BEGINNING VALOIS DYNASTY 29. NO WOMAN WILL EVER BE FRENCH QUEEN IN HER OWN RIGHT 30. BUT ENGLISH GRANDSON, EDWARD III, AS KING OF ENGLAND a. HIS MOTHER SISTER TO DEAD FRENCH KING 31. DECIDED HE WOULD LAY CLAIM TO FRENCH CROWN 32. HOW SERIOUS HE WAS ABOUT HIS CLAIM WE DO NOT KNOW 33. BUT IT DID ASSURE HIM OF ONE THING 34. IT ALLOWED HIM TO CALL ENSUING CONFLICT JUST WAR a. NECESSARY TO OBTAIN FEUDAL AIDS IN MEN & MONEY b. TAXING DEVICE FOR WAR 35. EQUALLY NB FOR SECURING GOD ON ONE'S SIDE 36. ALSO JUSTIFIED TAKING FRENCH PROPERTY a. BOOTY REWARD FOR RISK OF LIFE IN A JUST CAUSE 37. ALSO ALLOWED FRENCH LORDS WHO SIDED WITH ENGLAND a. TO SHUN THEIR ALLEGIANCE TO THEIR FEUDAL LORD, (1) FRENCH KING 38. ALLEGIANCE IN 14TH C STILL GIVEN TO PERSON, NOT NATION 39. & IN SOME WAYS THIS CONFLICT COULD BE CLASSIFIED AS A FRENCH CIVIL WAR 40. ANYTHING TO KEEP FRENCH MONARCH'S POWER FROM GROWING 41. WHILE IT IS EVIDENT TO HISTORIANS TODAY MONETARY RETURN THAT SPARKED CONFLICT a. ENGLISHMEN AT TIME OF WAR b. BELIEVED THEY FIGHTING BECAUSE EDWARD III DENIED HIS LEGAL RIGHT TO FRENCH CROWN WHO WERE THE FIGHTING MEN? 1. FRENCH & ENGLISH KNIGHTS FORMED CAVALRY 2. KNIGHTS NOT ONLY FROM LOWER ARISTOCRACY 3. LOYALTY OF ENGLISH NOBLES TO ENGLISH KING, a. ONE OF ENGLAND'S MOST CONSPICUOUS ADVANTAGES IN CONFLICT 4 4. 5. 6. D. E. F. MANY NOBLES IN FRANCE IN IT FOR THEMSELVES PEASANTRY SERVED AS INFANTRYMEN, PIKEMEN & ARCHERS INDICATES LATE MA WARFARE STARTING TO RESEMBLE WARFARE OF MODERN TIMES METHODOLOGY OF FIGHTING 1. FRANCE SHOULD HAVE HAD NO DIFFICULTY IN DEFEATING ENGLAND a. RICHEST COUNTRY IN EUROPE b. OUTNUMBERED ENGLAND 15 MILLION PEOPLE TO LESS THAN 4 MILLION 2. NEVERTHELESS THRU 3/4 OF THE 100 YRS WAR ENGLISH WON MOST OF PITCHED BATTLES 3. WHY a. ENGLISH HAD LEARNED SUPERIOR MILITARY TACTICS b. THANKS TO FIRE-POWER OF LONG-BOW 4. IN 3 GREATEST BATTLES OF LONG CONFLICT a. CRECY, POITIERS, AGINCOURT b. OUTNUMBERED ENGLISH RELIED ON NEW TACTICS, TIGHT DISCIPLINE & EFFECTIVE USE OF LONGBOW 5. CANNONS - NEW WEAPONS - FIRST USED IN 100 YEARS WAR a. BEGINNING W/SIEGE OF CALAIS IN 1356 6. BUT WAR AS WHOLE WAS ONE OF ATTRITION 7. WITH RAIDS, GUERILLA WARFARE & LOOTING MOST COMMON 8. TROOPS PILLAGED & BURNED THEIR WAY ACROSS COUNTRYSIDE 9. MUCH OF WAR WAGED AGAINST CIVILIANS 10. & LONG SIEGES AGAINST WALLED TOWNS 11. CONDUCTED FOR EXPRESS PURPOSE OF STARVING INHABITANTS INTO SUBMISSION 12. SUCH WAS CASE IN SIEGE OF CALAIS 13. 1 OF REASONS FOR ENGLISH SUCCESSES a. WAR ALWAYS FOUGHT ON FRENCH SOIL b. & ENGLISH ABLE TO TAKE RICH PLUNDER 14. FRENCH OFTEN BADLY DIVIDED 15. BOTH SIDES RESORTED TO NEGATIVE PROPAGANDA TO WIN SUPPORT & MONEY FOR THEIR CAUSE MAJOR BATTLES 1. CRECY - 1346 2. POITIERS - 1356 3. AGINCOURT 1415 a. HENRY V, KING OF ENGLAND GAINED LONG-LASTING FAME FOR HIS VICTORY AT AGINCOURT (1) TODAY CONSIDERED EPITOME OF ENGLISH KNIGHTHOOD TOGETHER W/BLACK PRINCE & RICHARD THE LIONHEARTED JOAN OF ARC 1. WHEN IT APPARENT ENGLISH WINNING 2. HEROIC FIGURE OF JOAN OF ARC CAME FORTH TO RALLY FRENCH 3. JOAN, AN ILLITERATE BUT EXTREMELY DEVOUT PEASANT GIRL 4. SOUGHT OUT UNCROWNED FRENCH RULER, CHARLES VII 5. TO ANNOUNCE SHE HAD BEEN DIVINELY COMMISSIONED TO DRIVE ENGLISH OUT OF FRANCE a. SHE CLAIMED SHE HEARD GOD'S VOICE GIVING HER INSTRUCTIONS 6. CHARLES PERSUADED TO LET HER TAKE COMMAND OF HIS TROOPS 7. HER PIETY & SINCERITY MADE SUCH A FAVORABLE IMPRESSION ON SOLDIERS a. THEIR MORALE RAISED IMMENSELY 8. IN A FEW MONTHS JOAN HAD LIBERATED MUCH OF CENTRAL FRANCE FROM ENGLISH DOMINATION & 9. BROUGHT CHARLES TO RHEIMS 5 G. H. I. a. WHERE HE CROWNED KING 10. BUT IN MAY 1430 SHE CAPTURED BY BURGUNDIANS 11. & HANDED OVER TO ENGLISH a. WHO ACCUSED HER OF BEING A WITCH 12. TRIED FOR HERESY BY FRENCH INQUISITION 13. JOAN'S WEARING OF MEN'S CLOTHES & HAIR CUT SHORT 14. NOT ONLY SCANDALIZED PEOPLE AT TIME 15. BUT INDICATIVE OF HER BEING IN CONTACT W/DEVIL 16. FOUND GUILTY AFTER LONG PREDETERMINED TRIAL 17. SHE PUBLICLY BURNED AT STAKE IN MARKET SQUARE AT ROUEN 18. PAPACY MADE HER A SAINT IN 1920 END OF WAR 1. FRENCH INSPIRED BY JOAN & THEIR INITIAL VICTORIES CONTINUED ON OFFENSIVE 2. WHEN DUKE OF BURGUNDY WITHDREW FROM ENGLISH ALLIANCE IN 1435 3. & ENGLISH KING HENRY VI PROVED TO BE TOTALLY INCOMPETENT a. HAD MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS 4. SERIES OF TRIUMPHS FOR FRENCH SIDE ENSUED 5. 1453 CAPTURE OF BORDEAUX, LAST OF ENGLISH STRONGHOLDS IN SW FRANCE 6. FINALLY BROUGHT LONG WAR TO END 7. ENGLISH NOW HELD NO LAND IN FRANCE 8. EXCEPT FOR CHANNEL PORT OF CALAIS a. CALAIS REMAINED ENGLISH UNTIL 1558 CONSEQUENCES FOR FRANCE 1. GREATLY STRENGTHEN POWERS OF FRENCH CROWN 2. REPRESENTATIVE ASSEMBLY LIKE ENGLAND'S DID NOT EVOLVE IN FRANCE 3. MONARCHS AGAINST CENTRALIZED REPRESENTATION 4. CROWN REIGNED SUPREME 5. & ABLE TO CONTINUE LEVYING TAXES & MAINTAINING ARMY W/O PEOPLE'S OK 6. FRANCE WOULD KEEP THIS POWERFUL MONARCHY UNTIL FRENCH REVOLUTION 1789 7. BUT ECONOMICALLY FRANCE SUFFERED GREATLY a. TRADE, AGRICULTURE ALL ADVERSELY EFFECTED CONSEQUENCES FOR ENGLAND 1. FINANCIALLY PAINFUL EXPERIENCE FOR ENGLAND TOO 2. COSTLY IN TERMS OF MONEY & MANPOWER 3. BUT ULTIMATELY MEANT ENGLAND WOULD START PRODUCING CLOTH HERSELF INSTEAD OF SENDING WOOL ABROAD 4. INTERNAL INSTABILITY DURING & AFTER WAR YRS 5. 9 ENGLISH KINGS WHO RULED FROM 1307-1485, 6. 5 DIED VIOLENTLY BECAUSE OF REVOLTS OR CONSPIRACIES 7. MOST OF THESE SLAIN KINGS HAD PROVEN THEMSELVES TO BE INCAPABLE RULERS 8. HOWEVER, IDEA OF A CENTRAL GOVT CONTROLLED BY A MONARCH TOO STRONG IN ENGLAND TO SUFFER ANY LONG-TERM CONSEQUENCES 9. HOUSE OF COMMONS IN ENGLAND BECAME VIABLE INSTITUTION 10. RECOGNIZED AS SEPARATE FROM HOUSE OF LORDS 11. FORCED TO MEET OFTEN TO GRANT MONARCHS OK TO LEVY TAXES FOR WAR 12. THEY GRADUALLY REALIZED THEY HELD COUNTRY'S PURSE STRINGS 13. EVEN WON RIGHT TO DETERMINE LEVYING OF TAXES FOR NON-WAR PURPOSES 14. MONARCH OF ENGLAND COULD NO LONGER TAX W/O PARLIAMENT'S CONSENT 15. PARLIAMENT ALSO OBTAINED POWERFUL CAVEAT 16. GRIEVANCES WERE TO BE ADDRESSED FIRST 17. THEN MONEY WOULD BE FORTHCOMING 18. THANKS TO 100 YRS WAR & FRENCH VICTORY WE NOW SPEAK ENGLISH INSTEAD 6 OF FRENCH III. PEASANT REVOLTS LATE MIDDLE AGES A. GENERAL REMARKS 1. PEASANTS, AS USUAL IN LATE MEDIEVAL WARFARE 2. SUFFERED MOST FROM PILLAGING & BURNING BY WARRIORS & SOLDIERS 3. THEY ALSO BORE HEAVIEST SHARE OF MONETARY BURDEN 4. OTHER REASONS CAN BE OFFERED FOR WHY PEASANTS REVOLTED IN LATE MIDDLE AGES 5. IN STATES WITH INCREASINGLY STRONG CENTRAL GOVTS SUCH ENGLAND & FRANCE 6. LOCAL LORD NOT NEEDED AS PROTECTOR 7. PEASANTS FELT HE OBTAINING TOO LARGE A 'RAKE-OFF' FOR FUNCTIONS HE PERFORMING ON THEIR BEHALF 8. ALSO CAUSED BY RISING EXPECTATIONS 9. & IN THIS WAY REVOLT IN ENGLAND DIFFERENT THAN JACQUERIE REVOLT IN FRANCE 10. WHERE ABJECT DESPERATION FUELED THAT REVOLT 11. PEASANTS WERE ENJOYING A RISING STANDARD OF LIVING 12. IN ENGLAND ESPECIALLY PEASANTS NO LONGER WORKING ON LORD'S DEMESNE LIKE IN EARLIER TIMES 13. & THEY LIKE FREEDOM TO WORK HARD & REAP REWARDS THEMSELVES 14. & IN REAL TERMS WAGE EARNERS ENJOYED A SUBSTANTIAL RISE a. OFTEN IN ORDER OF 200-250% 15. INCREASED CONSUMPTION OF WINE & MEAT 16. PLUS BETTER CLOTHING a. AS CONTINUAL ATTEMPT TO REGULATE THIS BY SUMPTUARY LEGISLATION 17. PEASANTS ALSO BECOMING ARTICULATE IN THEIR PROTESTS a. WILLING TO VOICE GRIEVANCES & DEMAND THEIR RIGHTS 18. TWO UPRISINGS KNOWN AS a. PEASANTS REVOLT IN ENGLAND b. & JACQUERIE REVOLT IN FRANCE 19. CAUSED BY WAR & ITS MONETARY DRAIN B. ENGLISH PEASANTS' REVOLT OF 1381 1. MOST SERIOUS LOWER-CLASS REBELLION IN ENGLISH HISTORY 2. SPARK THAT IGNITED 1381 REVOLT IN ENGLAND 3. AT ATTEMPT TO COLLECTION NATIONAL TAX LEVIED EQUALLY ON EVERY HEAD - POLL TAX 4. RATHER THAN PROPORTIONAL TO ONE'S WEALTH 5. THIS WAS UNPRECEDENTED DEVELOPMENT THAT PEASANTS FOUND UNFAIR 6. 2 EARLIER TAXES LEVIED IN 1377 AND 1379 MET WITHOUT ANY RESISTANCE 7. BUT WHEN AGENTS TRIED TO COLLECT THIRD IN 1381 PEASANTRY ROSE UP TO RESIST 8. & SOUGHT REDRESS OF ALL THEIR GRIEVANCES 9. PART OF THEIR GRIEVANCES a. ATTEMPT BY THEIR LANDLORDS TO RETURN TO WAGES b. OF PRE-PLAGUE LEVELS 10. PEASANTS EXPECTATIONS HAD GONE UP & THEY DID NOT WANT TO RETURN TO LOWER WAGES 11. PEASANTS BURNED RECORDS, SACKED RESIDENTS OF EXPLOITERS & MURDERED HIGH OFFICIALS 12. RICHARD II, YOUNG 15 BOY KING PROMISED REDRESS OF THEIR GRIEVANCES 13. BUT RENEGED ON HIS PROMISES 14. & TROUBLE-MAKERS EXECUTED 7 15. 16. 17. WHILE INITIALLY REVOLT ACCOMPLISHED NOTHING OVER NEXT SEVERAL DECADES SERFDOM DISAPPEARED FROM ENGLAND & TIMES GOT BETTER FOR THEM