Creative Engagement Title Two lines Pursuing youth outcomes through the arts across Subtitle one line the Victorian Government PREFACE This project has been conducted as a requirement of the 2011 Victorian Public Service Graduate Recruitment and Development Scheme. Graduate recruits must complete a ‘group learning task’ to demonstrate their development of skills in project management, team work, report writing and presentations. This project, ‘Creative Engagement: pursuing youth outcomes through the arts across the Victorian Government’ was produced by the Department of Premier and Cabinet graduate recruits and was sponsored by Arts Victoria. It has been produced under the guidance of Sue Doyle, David Everist and Warren Peart from Arts Victoria. We extend our thanks to representatives from the organisations profiled in this report who generously shared their time and resources with us. 2011 DPC Graduates Jessica Bartik, Karen Bird, Elizabeth Bott, Alex Kaiser, Felicity Rhodes, Daniel Smolich 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 2 Executive Summary Engaging young people through the arts has many benefits for both individuals and communities. This report examines seven Victorian art projects that have achieved positive outcomes for young people and their communities. The report highlights key characteristics of these projects for Victorian Government departments and agencies. The report profiles the following projects: ‘Who Owns me Today?’ by HighWater Theatre; ‘Northern Trax’ by the Anti Racism Action Band (A.R.A.B.); FReeZA Youth Committees; ‘We’re Afraid of the Daylight’ by Scum Pups; ‘Out of My Head’ by the Artful Dodgers Studio; ‘Kooriez in da Hood’ by the Koorie Heritage Trust; and the ‘Boon Wurrung Ngargee Sunset Ceremony’ by The Torch. The projects represent a diverse range of art forms, geographic locations and cultural and socioeconomic participants. Information for each project was gathered using face-to-face and phone interviews with project coordinators. Project coordinators also provided additional documentation such as acquittal reports and project evaluations. In addition to the intrinsic value of engagement in artistic activities for participants, these projects have led to a number of instrumental outcomes. This includes facilitating re-engagement in education, access to career pathways, improvements in health and wellbeing, reductions in antisocial behaviour, community engagement and exploration of personal and cultural identities. The projects profiled in this report highlight lessons for Victorian Government departments and agencies to consider when planning programs that use the arts to engage young people. Projects should draw upon the expertise and experience of professional artists, involve high quality art and public presentations and engage young people over the long term. Government departments and agencies should also explore opportunities to make connections with pre-existing community groups and networks. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 3 Contents Introduction .............................................................................................................................................. 5 Project Scope & Methodology ................................................................................................................ 5 Policy Context ........................................................................................................................................ 6 Case Study Profiles ................................................................................................................................. 7 HighWater Theatre – Who Owns me Today? ........................................................................................ 7 Antiracism Action Band (A.R.A.B.) – Northern Trax .............................................................................. 9 FReeZA - Youth Committees ............................................................................................................... 11 Scum Pups – We’re Afraid of the Daylight ........................................................................................... 12 Artful Dodgers Studio – Out of My Head.............................................................................................. 13 Koorie Heritage Trust – Kooriez in da Hood ........................................................................................ 15 The Torch – Boon Wurrung Ngargee Sunset Ceremony..................................................................... 16 Project Outcomes .................................................................................................................................. 17 Education ............................................................................................................................................. 17 Vocational Training & Career Pathways .............................................................................................. 18 Health, Wellbeing and Reductions in Anti-Social Behaviour ............................................................... 20 Community Engagement ..................................................................................................................... 22 Identity & Culture.................................................................................................................................. 23 Characteristics of successful projects ............................................................................................... 25 Involvement of Professional Artists ...................................................................................................... 25 High Quality Artistic Products/Performances ....................................................................................... 26 Long-term Engagement ....................................................................................................................... 26 Use of Existing Resources and Networks ............................................................................................ 27 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................. 29 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 4 Introduction This report examines seven Victorian projects that use creative activity as a way to connect with and generate positive outcomes for young people and their communities. The projects profiled in this report illustrate how arts projects have intrinsic value for participants, but also present avenues for advancing youth policy objectives across the Victorian Government in areas including education, employment and training, health and wellbeing, community engagement and cultural identity. Project Scope & Methodology Terms of Reference The aim of the project was to compile case studies of existing projects that use creative engagement to connect with young people. This is intended to assist Arts Victoria in promoting the value of creative engagement across the Victorian Government. Selection of Case Studies The projects were selected to represent a diverse range of art forms, geographic locations, and participant demographics. Most of these projects have had a previous association with Arts Victoria and were identified as examples of good practice in the field. Research Methods Information for the report was gathered through a combination of desktop research and interviews with project coordinators. A review of academic literature on the role of arts and cultural activity in youth policy was undertaken, and policy approaches in other Australian jurisdictions were considered. Pre-existing information on the selected projects was gathered from a range of sources, including external evaluations, media reports, internal evaluations and acquittal reports. This information was complemented by semi-structured interviews with program coordinators. These interviews were conducted throughout August and September 2011. Limitations The main constraint on this research was the limited time allocated for the project. Each team member was allocated 40 hours, or five working days, to complete the project. This limited the number of projects that could be profiled, as well as the depth of information that could be gathered, analysed and presented in the report. Representatives from HighWater Theatre were unavailable during the interviewing period, so the research on their project is based on previous evaluations and acquittal reports, which included first-hand accounts from participants and audience members. Definitions Key terms used in this report are: 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 5 Arts and cultural activity: these terms are used broadly and cover a variety of forms including audiovisual multimedia, contemporary music, theatre performances, sculpture, painting, photography and comedy. Intrinsic value of the arts: the personal and private benefits derived by an individual from experiencing art, including aesthetic pleasure, captivation and enjoyment. Instrumental value: the value of the arts as an instrument for achieving broad social and economic goals such as re-engagement with education or improved health and wellbeing. Young people: people aged between 12 and 25 years (based on definitions used by Arts Victoria’s Youth Arts Reference Group and the Youth Inter-Departmental Committee). Policy Context The contribution of the arts to policy areas across government is increasingly evident in Australian policy development (Craik 2007). The Queensland Government’s Creative Queensland policy established a framework for a whole of government perspective on the arts, arguing that the arts can contribute to improvements in educational outcomes, individual wellbeing, and community cohesion (Arts Queensland 2002). The Queensland Government also released the youth arts policy Arts, Culture + Me: Children and Young People in the Arts Action Plan, which set out a framework for supporting young people’s participation in the arts. This included a range of arts programs that provide young people with artistic skills and experiences while also offering education and training opportunities (Arts Queensland 2008). At the Commonwealth level, the National Cultural Policy Discussion Paper, released in 2011, included a discussion of the contributions the arts make to Australian society. It highlighted the important role that the arts can play in policies for young people, including educational engagement and social and cultural cohesion (Office for the Arts 2011). This focus on the broader value of arts and cultural activity has been a feature of Victorian Government policy in recent years. Arts Victoria is responsible for supporting and developing arts policy, programs, and cultural infrastructure in Victoria. In addition to its work within the arts and cultural sector, Arts Victoria advises on the ways that arts and cultural activity can contribute to broad government policy objectives. Arts Victoria supports several arts programs that make contributions to the policy outcomes of Victorian Government departments. Foremost among these are the schools partnership programs that are facilitated by Arts Victoria and the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development. These programs have provided young people with opportunities to develop their artistic skills and have helped teachers develop new approaches to teaching and learning (DEECD 2009). These current partnerships provide a sound base upon which the Victorian Government can build. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 6 Case Study Profiles HighWater Theatre – Who Owns me Today? A ‘creatively led partnership’ that is successful, both as an early intervention program to address anti-social behaviour and disengagement from formal education, and as a community education tool. The HighWater Theatre Rural Youth Program is an intensive, arts-based education program for teenagers in Albury/Wodonga who have fallen out of the formal education system. The collaboration between Somebody’s Daughter Theatre Company, Gateway Community Health (formally Upper Hume Community Health Service) and the Victorian Department of Education and Early Childhood Development has been running since 2001. Professional artists and post-release women (trainee artists) work with participants to produce high quality theatre that gives voice to their stories. Original plays are devised and performed to a range of schools, professional bodies and communities, in small rural towns as well as large cities. HighWater’s latest play Who Owns me Today? dealt with issues including foster-care, homelessness and bullying – key challenges in the lives of HighWater participants. In addition to the intensive drama, art and music workshops, HighWater supports participants through: individual education plans specialised sessions on health, wellbeing, nutrition and bullying assistance in preparing for job interviews social activities designed to develop practical independent living skills, and pathways to support services, including referrals to housing services, drug and alcohol counselling, doctors, dentists and sexual health clinics. The impact of HighWater Theatre is manifold. For the young participants involved, there has been a reduction in anti-social and offending behaviour, a reconnection with education and an improvement in their health and well-being. Often belonging to HighWater becomes the one strong, stable point in the lives of participants – the one secure thing they can rely on. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 7 For audiences, such as those who saw Who Owns me Today?, the experience of HighWater has been overwhelmingly positive. Many people commented that the play broadened their knowledge and motivated individual action, which HighWater regards as “the first steps towards broader systemic change to improve services for at risk young people” (HighWater Theatre 2011, p29). Significant outcomes – re-engagement with education reductions in anti-social behavior, and improved community understanding. Partner Organisations: Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, Gateway Health, Somebody's Daughter Theatre. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 8 Anti Racism Action Band (A.R.A.B.) – Northern Trax Uses theatre, dance, and music to develop the social and artistic skills of young people and promote cross-cultural understanding. Anti-Racism Action Band (A.R.A.B.) was established as a creative outlet for Arabic young people in Melbourne’s outer north. It aimed to challenge racial tensions and promote social inclusion while imparting performance, event management, social and life skills and crucial employment pathways for participants. A.R.A.B. quickly opened its door to youth from all cultural backgrounds as a proactive way to address racism. The area was lacking in opportunities for young people to engage with the performing arts and local young people were really enthusiastic to get involved. A.R.A.B. participants were given the opportunity to share positive representations of their culture and social lives. A.R.A.B.’s major production in 2010 was Northern Trax, a series of performance events in and around Melbourne’s Flinders Street Station. Northern Trax was staged as part of the 2010 Melbourne International Arts Festival. The centre-piece was an original theatre piece performed in Degraves St underpass that told the story of a contentious cross-cultural marriage. Northern Trax also included a series of seemingly spontaneous 'flash mob' dance and music performances around the northern train line platforms and concourses at Flinders Street Station. “They’ve given me the chance to go places I never thought I would go, I’ve performed places I never thought I’d perform. I was one of the trouble makers and now one of the stars of the show” (Northern Trax Participant)1 Northern Trax brought the stories of A.R.A.B. participants from the margins of Melbourne's ‘Zone 2’ into the heart of the CBD. The show involved public rehearsals with 150 teenagers, representing 50 different cultural groups and 40 different religious identities. The young performers were required to work together as a group, and the interaction between participants from a wide range of cultural backgrounds was an important outcome of the project. “We’re all different people but when we’re together we love the same thing, you know, like dance” (Northern Trax Participant)2 An earlier evaluation of the A.R.A.B program found that participants reported they had a better understanding of people from other cultures and backgrounds after being involved in A.R.A.B. 1 2 Northern Trax A Snapshot of Anti Racism Action Band, Available at http://vimeo.com/21630655 Northern Trax A Snapshot of Anti Racism Action Band, Available at http://vimeo.com/21630655 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 9 productions.3 One of the major successes of A.R.A.B initiative was found to be the noticeable difference in levels of self-esteem and confidence among the participants, along with a new understanding and tolerance of difference as reported by the staff at their schools, tutors, school partners and the students themselves. 4 Significant outcomes – educational partnerships positive interactions between young people from diverse cultures, and positive representations of young people. Partner organisations: Arts Victoria, Department of Immigration and Citizenship, Moreland City Council, City of Whittlesea, City of Darebin, City of Melbourne, Hume City Council, Platform Youth Theatre, The Social Studio, Wick Studios, Jungle City Dancers, Melbourne International Arts Festival and various Victorian Secondary Colleges. 3 Hallifax & Rodriguez (2006) A.R.A.B. Evaluation Research and Report, Available at: http://arab-vass.com/wpcontent/blogs.dir/18/files/2010/07/EvaluationDocument.pdf 4 Ibid, p 33 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 10 FReeZA - Youth Committees FReeZA is a non-profit organisation that works with young Victorians to provide safe and affordable, drug, alcohol and smoke free, all-ages music events. FReeZA Youth Committees plan, organise and manage live music events, giving young people the opportunity to develop transferable practical skills, while doing something that appeals to them. Seventy-eight FReeZA Youth Committees operate across metropolitan, regional and rural Victoria with events attracting over 140,000 young people annually. In coordinating the events, members of FReeZA Youth Committees work with a local community youth worker, professional artists and their managers. Key activities include booking bands and performance spaces, managing a budget, event promotion and the operation of technical equipment. As Shane Wickens, Artistic Director of The Push (the peak body that supports the FReeZA program) explained, “FReeZA events create a ‘buzz’ of excitement for committee members as participants can see the results of their work, develop improved self confidence and skills that are highly valued by the competitive music industry”. FReeZA taps into young people’s understanding of what will appeal to other young people. FReeZA Youth Committees aim to achieve a cross section of interests and skills, which, in turn, promotes new social networks for participants and greater connection with the community. Many exFReeZA participants have maintained contact with their local FReeZA Committee. One participant now mentors young people on Shepparton FReeZA Youth Committee, while another former participant has started his own business managing young artists and bands and continues to mentor his former Youth Committee in Bendigo. The young people on FReeZA Committees are also given the opportunity to participate in the annual Push FReeZA Summits, which in 2011 were held in Bendigo and Brunswick. The annual event brings together young people from across Victoria. The participants have the opportunity to meet other young people with similar interests, discuss their local music scenes and their experiences of running live music events, and hear from influential Australians in the music industry. Significant outcomes – vocational training promotion of healthy lifestyles, and community connections. Partner organisations: The Push, Department of Human Services (Office for Youth), many local councils and community groups. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 11 Scum Pups – We’re Afraid of the Daylight An opportunity for young people to express their opinions and experiences about daily life in their community through art. Scum Pups uses photography, digital media and public art projects to engage young people in the Upwey community. Under the guidance of Tiffaney Bishop, a local professional artist, the group runs projects that deal with social and cultural issues in the local community. In 2008, Scum Pups ran a project called We’re Afraid of the Daylight, which set out to challenge local perceptions about local young people and safety within the community. For twelve months the five young people engaged in the We’re Afraid of the Daylight project were involved in weekly workshops held at Upwey train station. This was supplemented with weekend workshops and time in the studio developing photographs and learning about the art form. By engaging artistically with their surroundings and having their art professionally recognised, participants found they connected in different ways with their peers and adults within the community. The project helped participants to develop conceptual thinking and to communicate their feelings in a constructive manner while inspiring a self-motivation, independence and commitment. The previously shy participants now give presentations on the project to other communities with the aim of encouraging young people like themselves to speak up and get involved. Through this project participants came to see that their opinions and concerns matter and that they, as young individuals, are important. This project served to build trust between teenagers and the local police. Local police supported the project financially and attended the weekly art workshops, fostering positive relationships and mutual understanding between the young people and local members of Victoria Police. According to Leading Senior Constable Craig Lane of the Belgrave police; A lot of the time, when police deal with kids or youth, it’s mainly because the young people have got into trouble. We want to break those barriers down and this is the perfect way to do it. They can use me as a source if they need to ask me about policing, or anything for that matter. They appreciate me coming and I appreciate them being truthful and honest. That’s the best thing about it. Leading Senior Constable Craig Lane Partner Organisations: Victoria Police, Metro Trains, Burrinja (local art gallery), Shire of Yarra Ranges, Bendigo Bank, Bell Real Estate and Foodworks. Significant outcomes – negative community perceptions challenged reductions in anti-social behavior, and positive relationships between young people and the police. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 12 Artful Dodgers Studio – Out of My Head The Artful Dodgers Studio provides innovative and creative spaces for young people whose lives have been affected by difficult circumstances. Artful Dodgers Studios (Dodgers) is an innovative program established in 1996 by Jesuit Social Services for young people aged 15-27. Participants work alongside professional artists and musicians in a safe and vibrant arts space that encourages the development of artistic skills and offers holistic support. The Dodgers vision is to engage, transform, and strengthen young people through involvement in the arts. This is facilitated through increasing social connection, self-esteem, positive mental health as well as foundation and vocational skills. The creative program helps to validate them as important cultural contributors and the studios help them to explore artistic skills and identity beyond the risk factors in their lives. Many participants face barriers to education and employment. The Dodgers is all about art and music. Participants can choose how they will engage and this is integral to their sense of empowerment as they maintain control over their own stories, artistic output and solutions. Dodgers artists work with young people to encourage them to strive for artistic excellence and participate in exhibitions and performances. “We’re here to unlock the arts for young people who would not ordinarily be given access. It’s about stimulating people through art, not placating them. The greatest thing we can offer is the opportunity to locate their unique voice, validate their creative choices and share it with others.” (Forest Keegel, Community Cultural Development Artist ) In 2013 the Dodgers music studio helped foster a collaboration between young participants and exchild soldiers turned hip hop artists 'FLYBZ' and legendary Australian song writer Paul Kelly. Producing, managing and releasing the track 'Child Soldier' the Dodgers were able to help the newly arrived Fablice and Floreni fulfil their musical ambitions. This resulted in national media exposure, airplay and paid performance opportunities for FLYBZ. They now use music to tell their stories to school and community groups and have won an African Australian Award, a National Youth awards and a Victorian Refugee award. Rudder Exchange Visual Arts Mentoring Partnerships (REVAMP) is for young artists with experience at the Dodgers and who wish to further their art practice. REVAMP matches established visual artists with young people to exhibit together. Alumni of REVAMP have transitioned into tertiary study and exhibiting their work professionally. For example, a recent graduate won a scholarship of $8000 for one year’s tuition at the Tom Bass Sculpture Studio School in NSW. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 13 “Participating in REVAMP and working alongside my mentor and the other artists has made me realise that I am just as able and just as entitled to express myself creatively as anybody else. I’ve expanded my appreciation of the art world and feel freer to express myself without harsh selfcriticism. My confidence has grown phenomenally. You can see it in the way I carry myself and interact with people. I feel so well. This is a wellness that the hospitals can’t give you. This is a wellness that you can only get by being included back into society.” (REVAMP Participant) Significant outcomes – mentoring for ‘at-risk’ young people building confidence and self-esteem, and exploration of personal identity. Major partner organisations: Victorian Departments of Human Services and Health, the City of Melbourne, Jesuit Social Services. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 14 Koorie Heritage Trust – Kooriez in da Hood Kooriez in da Hood engaged young Indigenous people in an exploration of personal and cultural identity. Kooriez in da Hood was run by Koorie Heritage Trust in 2010. Fifteen Koorie youth from Melbourne collaborated with leading Indigenous artists and mentors, Brook Andrew, Bindi Cole and Nikki Ashby, to design and showcase a range of hoodies that represented Koorie culture, family and life. Weekly workshops were run over three months to develop artistic concepts and stencil techniques. The project culminated in a hip hop fashion parade, during which the young artists paraded their wearable art in an eye-catching show choreographed by Kaurna/Narrunga woman, Nikki Ashby. Following the fashion parade, the artwork was exhibited at the Koorie Heritage Trust, with some of the limited edition hoodies available for sale. Kooriez in da Hood developed the artistic and technical skills of participants through a project that had relevance to their daily experiences. The connections with Koorie culture were a major aspect of this project. Kooriez in da Hood participant Grant Balcombe, a young Tjapukai/Western Yallangi man, commented: Our Indigenous forefathers wore kangaroo and possum skin cloaks to represent their origins and tribal affiliations, but recently the Koorie Heritage Trust have encouraged young people…to get back in touch culturally by allowing us to create our own hoodies with our own personal designs that represent us and our culture through our eyes. Subsequent Kooriez in da Hood programs are currently being planned, with the next one to be held in Shepparton. The long term vision for the project includes a second stage where participants will undertake product development and marketing workshops to assist them in marketing their artwork. Significant outcomes – exploration of cultural identity opportunities for self-expression, and positive role models for participants. Lead Organisation: Koorie Heritage Trust. Project led by three Indigenous artists: Brook Andrew, Bindi Cole and Nikki Ashby. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 15 The Torch – Boon Wurrung Ngargee Sunset Ceremony Dance was used to engage young Indigenous people to learn about local Indigenous history, culture and law. The Boon Wurrung Ngargee Sunset Ceremony Dance Revitalisation Project (the Sunset Ceremony) was coordinated by the Torch, a cross-cultural arts organisation. It involved collaboration between Indigenous artists, Indigenous elders and over 30 young Indigenous people. The project drew on the guidance of Boon Wurrung Elder Aunty Carolyn Briggs and a collaborative team of Indigenous artists led by Artistic Director Jacob Boehme. Participants conducted research into traditional ceremonial practices such as body painting and participated in a week of intensive studio-based creative development projects. This process resulted in the creation of eight new dances and six new songs that drew upon the Boon Wurrung language. The participants and mentors then honed the songs and dances through a series of workshops and rehearsals. The ceremonial celebration of the project occurred in February 2011 before a crowd of more than 1000 people. The Ceremony allowed Indigenous people to connect to their cultural heritage and increased awareness of Indigenous culture amongst non-Indigenous participants. The Sunset Ceremony celebrated the diversity of Melbourne’s Indigenous community by using the traditional Boon Wurrung language in a contemporary manner. This led to the creation of ‘contemporary reinterpretations of important Boon Wurrung stories’, which added to Victoria’s knowledge of Boon Wurrung culture and Indigenous dance. One of the participants explained, “being a part of Boon Wurrung Ngargee made us feel we were connecting to our culture and bringing this clan’s stories back to life” (The Torch 2011, p4). The Sunset Ceremony was positively reviewed in the Autumn 2011 issue of Arts Yarn Up and on the Melbourne Museum website. Significant outcomes – exploration of Indigenous history, culture and law Increased social cohesion and partnerships between different communities and Indigenous tribes , and Connecting with and celebrating Indigenous identity. Partner organizations: Arts Victoria, Baluk Arts, Frankston Arts Centre, Victorian Aboriginal Child Care Agency (VACCA), the VACCA Choir, Songlines, Melbourne Aboriginal Youth Services and Recreation (MAYSAR), Footscray Community Arts Centre, Idja Dance Theatre, The Boon Wurrung Foundation, City of Port Phillip Yalukit Willam Ngargee and the St Kilda Festival Team, Chunky Move and the Brotherhood of St Lawrence. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 16 Project Outcomes The projects profiled in this report provided participants with artistic skills and experiences that had great intrinsic value. Many of these projects also had significant positive instrumental outcomes. The social impact of the arts has been studied extensively over the past two decades (White & Rentschler 2005). Many studies have shown that creative activity can have positive outcomes for young people, particularly those who have disengaged from formal education or suffer from socioeconomic disadvantage (Gibson & Anderson 2008). The outcomes of the profiled projects are outlined below, grouped under the following headings: education; vocational training and career pathways; health, wellbeing and reductions in anti-social behaviour; community engagement, and identity and culture. Education Earlier research There has been a large amount of research on the arts and education over the past decade, particularly in the US and UK. This literature points to a wide range of positive educational outcomes for students who participate in arts programs (Deasy 2002). Outcomes include increased educational engagement, increased school attendance and retention, improved social skills, and the development of cognitive skills that can be applied in other learning areas (Bamford 2006; Gibson & Anderson 2008). Arts education programs can provide flexible frameworks for learning which increase the chances of successfully re-engaging young people in education (Hogan 2008). Arts programs can be particularly beneficial for young people who have experienced difficulties with learning, as activities such as dancing, singing and acting provide a starting point that does not require the use of reading and writing skills (Bryce, et al 2004). The arts are an effective outreach tool to engage young people. In particular, arts programs can provide motivation to engage in school activities (Brice Heath 1999; Broadbent 2003). This was reflected in an evaluation of government-funded artist residencies in Victorian schools, which found positive effects including improved student engagement in education and development of interpersonal and teamwork skills (DEECD 2009). An evaluation of four school-based arts education programs across Australia similarly found that involvement in arts programs had a positive impact on students’ engagement with learning, improved their self-esteem and teamwork and led to improved attendance at school for students from Indigenous Australian communities (Bryce, et al, 2004). The programs provided positive learning opportunities for students who do not fit the conventional mould of institutional learning. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 17 The findings of these evaluations indicate that students gained skills from the arts programs that may be transferable to other areas of learning. Case study observations HighWater Theatre provides a strong example of the use of the arts as an effective method of engaging young people in education. HighWater Theatre grew out of concern in the Albury/Wodonga region for the increasing numbers of young people who were not attending school. 19.8 per cent of 15-19 year olds across the Hume Region, the region in which HighWater is based, are currently not engaged in full time study, training or work (Osmotherly 2011, p4). However, the establishment of youth art projects such as HighWater has generated positive educational outcomes for those involved. A report produced by Osfield Consultants in 2011 found that 82 per cent of HighWater participants had re-engaged in education, employment or training. In addition to re-engaging with education, HighWater participants have come to recognise the value of education and stated that the positive reinforcement they received through HighWater gave them the confidence to continue their studies. As one 16 year old female participant described, "I never thought you needed [an education] - I just thought I'd cruise along but now I realise how important getting an education is. That's why I'm going back to school" (Osmotherly 2007, p72). The Anti Racism Action Band (A.R.A.B.) has had positive educational outcomes in Melbourne's northern suburbs. A.R.A.B.'s work is based in an economically disadvantaged area of Victoria, where there is significant cultural diversity and a high proportion of recent arrivals to Australia, including refugees. Partner schools have stated that cultural conflicts sometimes arise in this environment, and that A.R.A.B. plays a valuable role by providing opportunities for positive interactions between young people. Creative Producer Kate Gillick said that some participants described A.R.A.B. programs as a major motivation to come to school, as these programs give them something to look forward to and help them build relationships with classmates. In a previous evaluation of A.R.A.B., participants also reported that they had a better understanding of people from other cultures and backgrounds after being involved in A.R.A.B. productions (Hallifax & Rodriguez 2006). Vocational Training & Career Pathways Earlier research Research on youth arts programs has found that they can provide opportunities for young people to develop leadership skills (Brice Heath 1999). Arts programs that include a structured professional mentoring component can also provide young people with job skills and career pathways (Wright, et al 2004). 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 18 Case study observations The development pathways that A.R.A.B. provides for participants are a key feature of their work. A.R.A.B. provides coaching and mentoring for program participants. These pathways have supported participants who often become involved in A.R.A.B. programs through their school, to develop skills to become senior performers, and then ‘graduate’ to work as coordinators and mentors for newer participants. Maysa Abozeid’s experience at A.R.A.B. provides a strong example of this. Maysa, a self-described ‘blind, Italian, Egyptian, Muslim female comedian’, became involved in A.R.A.B. through a school program in 2005 as a shy and disconnected teenager. After getting to know Maysa through this program, A.R.A.B. Creative Producer Kate Gillick suggested that Maysa could try spoken word performances based around her life. It became clear that Maysa had a natural talent for comedy, so Kate worked with her to develop a stand-up comedy routine. Maysa was soon performing on Melbourne’s comedy circuit, with assistance from A.R.A.B.’s Tawasal program. She travelled to New York to perform at the ArabAmerican Comedy Festival and her story was featured in an article in The Age in 2007. Maysa has continued her involvement in A.R.A.B. programs, and was a senior solo performer in Northern Trax in 2010. While discussing her role in this production, Maysa told the Northern Weekly newspaper that A.R.A.B. had changed her life, commenting, “I was 16 when I joined, and it made me a completely different person.” Tawasal, which means ‘to connect’ in Arabic, is a program that assists young performers who have developed advanced performance or technical skills to obtain paid work alongside professional artists. In 2010, approximately 180 A.R.A.B. participants accessed paid work through Tawasal with music, dance and comedy performances. Participants performed at events including festivals, workshops and conferences for government, schools, community organisations and businesses. Tawasal has now been operating for several years. A.R.A.B. Program Manager David Ralph sees potential for its further development as a social enterprise that could sustain itself and support the ongoing growth of the program. Through expansion of the program, more young people could access the valuable career development opportunities that A.R.A.B. provides. The annual Push FReeZA Summit connects FReeZA Youth Committee members with professionals from the music industry who provide advice and mentor FReeZA participants. During these full day summits a range of industry professionals run workshops on setting up technical equipment, moving into a career in the music industry, social networking and online marketing tools. The summits also feature live music performances from popular artists. This presents a rare opportunity for young people to receive direct advice from professionals and to develop mentor relationships with accomplished musicians. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 19 The Artful Dodgers Studio also provides a mentoring program called Rudder, through which established artists mentor young people who wish to develop their artistic skills. Four participants in the Out of my Head exhibition now participate as mentees in Rudder. The mentees have displayed their art at other exhibitions and have applied for residencies in various arts programs. Health, Wellbeing and Reductions in Anti-Social Behaviour Earlier research Young people who participate in structured arts programs have demonstrated improvements in mental health and self-confidence (VicHealth 2009), while also developing interpersonal and conflict resolution skills (Wright, et al 2004). Arts programs that target young people who have had difficult life experiences aim to provide positive reinforcement though the process of creative activity and demonstrate that artistic activity can be a valuable way to reach ‘at risk’ young people, who may have already fallen out of formal mentoring or treatment programs (Brown 2008). Research conducted in Victorian youth justice facilities found that participants in theatre programs had improved interpersonal skills and self-esteem (Coulter 2008). Similarly, an evaluation of a youth theatre program in regional Australia found that participation provided the young people with the opportunity to explore and analyse some of the difficult aspects of their lives (Kelman 2008). Case study observations Health and Wellbeing For the young participants involved in HighWater, there were noticeable improvements in health and wellbeing. The program provides an environment where young people feel free to share their experiences, confident that other participants will be able to empathise and relate to the challenges they face. A 2007 Osfield Consultants report found that 'all [participants] report that their use of drugs and alcohol has either stopped or has substantially reduced’ (p15). Participants also report improved self esteem and confidence, greater will to live, stronger commitment to school work, and a greater sense of connection to others and belief that people care about them. One 15 year old male participant explained, “I haven't been drinking as much and getting into fights. I guess you could say I feel cared about. I actually want to get up in the morning and be on time for HighWater. I have something to look forward to” (Osmotherly 2007, p19). FReeZA has promoted their events for many years as drug, alcohol and smoke-free. The program delivers positive messages about responsibilities and expectations around alcohol and drug use, while providing opportunities for young people to experience live music in a safe environment. The promotion of these health messages aims to influence young people's lives beyond the actual events, by guarding against binge drinking and drug use becoming normalised in the context of young people's entertainment. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 20 Reductions in Anti-Social Behaviour HighWater projects have reduced crime and anti-social behaviour among participants through developing participants’ life skills, positive relationships and knowledge of support services. HighWater also aims to improve the quality of agency and community responsiveness to the needs of at-risk young people. The Wodonga area has one of the highest instances of youth substance abuse in Victoria, is equal highest in terms of anti-social behaviour, and has one of the highest instances of reported suicidal behaviour in Australia. Nearly 80 per cent of participants enrolled in the HighWater Active Pilot project had prior contact with the police as offenders and 85 per cent were known victims of physical, sexual or emotional abuse (Osmotherly 2011, p27). Throughout their time in the program, only two of the young people re-offended (Osmotherly 2011, p27). Even those who did re-offend returned to HighWater after their release from juvenile detention, with one going on to complete Year 12 and become an apprentice welder and the other maintaining a 100 per cent attendance at HighWater (Osmotherly 2011, p27). The ‘We’re Afraid of the Daylight’ Scum Pups exhibition challenged community misconceptions about disruptive youth, while also discouraging anti-social behaviour among young people. The long-standing reputation for youth violence and anti-social behaviour in Upwey had led to local youths being referred to as “Upwey Scum”, a tag which created a negative identity and led to stigmatisation. The project’s name, Scum Pups, was an attempt to reverse this stigma, to reclaim a sense of dignity and respect by using the word Scum in a positive and empowering way. Scum Pups challenged local perceptions about the level of safety within the community and enabled participants to connect in meaningful ways with both their peers and adults. The stories the participants told through their art resonated with other local young people, who congratulated Scum Pups participants on speaking out. The participants are now positively engaged with the local community and are less fearful of experiencing the type of bullying and violence that they once had, believing they are more confident, empowered, supported, and equipped with new relationships of understanding with their peers. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 21 Community Engagement Earlier Research Studies in the US, UK, and Australia have found that arts programs can help to create stronger social and cultural bonds within communities (Bamford 2006). The arts encourage intercultural exchange and respect for differences and can provide a positive forum for understanding and friendship between people from diverse backgrounds (Smyth & Stevenson 2005; Matarasso 1997). An evaluation of two community arts programs in Victoria found that these programs improved cultural awareness and understanding between community members. It found these programs were effective tools for engaging hard to reach populations, particularly young people and socioeconomically disadvantaged groups (Pope & Doyle 2006). Another evaluation of community arts projects in Victoria found that the projects helped to increase social connectedness by bringing people together around a common purpose and helped to develop positive relationships between a diverse range of community members (VicHealth 2003). Case study observations A.R.A.B. projects provide participants with the opportunity to share positive representations of their cultural and social lives. Northern Trax brought the stories of participants from Melbourne’s northern suburbs into the CBD, allowing them to challenge the perceptions of an audience that may not otherwise have heard their stories. One audience member who witnessed a ‘flash mob’ performance at Flinders Street Station said “I saw all these teenagers hanging around en masse and I was like “what are they all doing here?”…then this music started and they were all dancing in the street. It was great” (Anti Racism Action Band 2010). Who Owns me Today? was performed at several different locations, including as part of Mental Health Week. According to HighWater program partners, the impact of the play on audience members, which included high school students, carers, teachers, and local community members, was as significant as the personal outcomes for the HighWater participants. It served as a vehicle for young people to share their stories with the broader community. The performances of Who Owns me Today? changed community perceptions about the young people involved and significantly increased understanding and awareness of the complex issues that lead to offending youth behaviour and school disengagement (HighWater Theatre 2011). HighWater’s work has also had a direct impact on the public servants who work with young people. At the request of the Department of Human Services, Who Owns me Today? was performed to the Department’s senior management and policy advisors in Melbourne, many of whom were profoundly moved by the performance. One Senior Policy Advisor explained “I feel sad but motivated and inspired. It gives me the reality and the personal stories to carry with me in my policy work. A total reality check” (Osmotherly 2011, p27). Another Senior Program Advisor reflected that 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 22 the play was “a confronting but timely reminder of who we work for in our Collins Street offices” (Osmotherly 2011, p27). Identity & Culture Earlier Research The arts are a positive medium for the exploration and representation of culture and personal identity. For instance, arts projects for young Indigenous Australians have provided a vehicle for young people to connect with aspects of their cultural heritage (Donelan & O’Brien 2008). Similarly, custodial programs for Maori offenders in New Zealand prisons have used arts and cultural activities including carving, ceremonial dance and body tattoos as a way to teach inmates about their culture and identity and create connections while they are imprisoned (Eames 2008). Case Study Observations The Sunset Ceremony project used dance to engage young Indigenous people in learning about local Indigenous history, culture and law. It celebrated the diversity of Melbourne’s Indigenous community by using the traditional Boon Wurrung language in a contemporary manner. It allowed Indigenous youth to reclaim their language though new songs, rhythms and dances, and created a connection with, and increased awareness of, their cultural background and heritage, in particular the interconnections between land, law, culture, flora and fauna. The art created in the Sunset Ceremony project was a ‘safe entry point’ that led to conversations and discussions about social issues affecting Indigenous people, and particularly Indigenous youth. As artistic coordinator Alison Brash explained, this project strengthened intergenerational bonds between Indigenous elders and Indigenous youth and led to greater cultural connections between parents, or foster parents, and the participants. The participation of approximately 200 people (both Indigenous and non-Indigenous) in the final dance of the Sunset Ceremony promoted reconciliation between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people, and enriched Victoria’s knowledge of Boon Wurrung culture and Indigenous dance. Like the Sunset Ceremony, Kooriez in da Hood engaged young Indigenous people in an exploration and celebration of personal and cultural identity. As Andrea James, former Koorie Heritage Trust community worker explained, “Hoodies are often associated with crime and hiding yourself - we wanted to bust that open” (Stephens 2010). Through the project, participants were given the opportunity and skills to create hoodies that depicted images and messages important to them. The hoodies became an avenue for the exploration and expression of identity. The Out of my Head exhibition similarly gave participants the opportunity to construct identities through the creation of art. The artists at Artful Dodgers Studio assisted young people to create 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 23 positive identities, rather than being defined by issues they were experiencing such as mental illness or drug and alcohol misuse. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 24 Characteristics of successful projects Based on these case studies, there are a number of key characteristics for Victorian Government departments and agencies to consider when contemplating creative projects targeted at young people. These relate to the involvement of professional artists, the use of high quality artistic projects and performances, long-term engagement, and use of existing community resources and networks. Involvement of Professional Artists The engagement of professional artists in youth art projects has several benefits, ranging from skills transfer to ensuring a high standard of artistic output from the project. The projects that engaged professional artists found that the artists’ professionalism and creative skills were a means to educate and attract the interest of the young participants. The Out of my Head exhibition by the Artful Dodgers Studio used professional artists prior to the creative phase of the project, engaging them to run workshops with participants to determine which artistic medium most inspired and best suited them. This engagement gave participants an opportunity to learn about various forms of art from experts respected for their knowledge in these areas. The involvement of professional artists also improved the quality of the art produced by each program and in turn often inspired an interest and passion for the art form among participants. This was demonstrated by Kooriez in da Hood where participants proudly wore the hoodies they produced, as they were high quality products for which they often received complements. Similarly, We’re Afraid of the Daylight participants reported feeling more inspired and passionate due to the mentoring they received from the professional artist. For projects such as HighWater and FReeZA, their reputation and local community attitude to the programs has been enhanced as a result of the involvement of professional artists. The high quality performances staged by HighWater have contributed to the significant community interest in the plays and ongoing community goodwill towards the program. Without such outputs, the local community may have been less receptive to such a program targeted towards ‘at-risk’ youth, as it was during the initial conception of HighWater. FReeZA participants’ experiences in dealing with and learning from well-respected music artists, is often useful in job applications, given the esteem in which the program is held by industry and broader community. Each of the projects profiled allowed participants to learn from an adult outside of the traditional education system and provided an alternative role model from whom they could learn practical and relevant skills. Tiffaney Bishop from Scum Pups commented that high quality fine arts and professional artists brought a level of sophistication to the project. This sophistication gave 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 25 participants an entry point into a world beyond their own, a world in which they could engage with adults through intelligent conversations about art. High Quality Artistic Products and Performances The production of tangible artistic creations such as a performance or an exhibition allows participants to see themselves as artists, rather than participants in an intervention program (O’Brien & Donelan 2008). An evaluation of school-based arts education programs found that the most successful programs provided positive reinforcement, worked toward a public presentation or performance, and provided a safe environment where creative risk taking was encouraged (Bryce, et al 2004). These findings were echoed by program coordinators from the projects profiled in this report, all of which culminated in the public performance or exhibition of art. A public display allows the community to recognise youth art and provides personal rewards and affirmation for its creators. The Scum Pups We’re Afraid of the Daylight project found the importance of professional and community recognition highly rewarding for its participants. A public display of art also helped to challenge the community perceptions of the participants. The youth who inhabit Upwey train station each afternoon have a local reputation for being destructive, but the thought-provoking, intelligent, high quality artwork presented the participants in a positive light. The creative director from A.R.A.B. emphasised that participants are informed from the outset that they are at rehearsals that will lead to a performance, not simply a one-off workshop. This ensures that participants know that they are expected to commit to the process and that there will be a tangible result at the end. Kate Gillick believes that “there can be nothing more vague than developing skills that have no airing to an audience ...the performer/audience relationship can be electric and transformative for the individual.” One participant in an A.R.A.B. performance said that “the artists treat us like adults, like they see our potential and our limits but the expectation is high” (Hallifax & Rodriguez 2004). Similarly, the partners of the HighWater collaboration acknowledge that if HighWater was not producing high quality plays such as Who Owns me Today?, and if participants were not regularly engaged in the highly structured and disciplined workshops necessary to produce such performances, the program would not succeed. Long-term Engagement Projects that involve long-term engagement with young people are likely to achieve better outcomes. It can take several months for trusting and productive working relationships to develop between adult facilitators and teenage participants (Jarrett, Sullivan & Watkins 2005). The young 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 26 participants in the projects profiled did not typically have positive relationships with adults, so it took time to overcome their suspicion of authority figures. The projects profiled in this report demonstrate that long-term engagement is important for a variety of reasons. HighWater interviewed participants and concluded that, if an ‘at-risk’ young person has a positive experience in a program and then the program ceased, the young people would likely feel as though they have once again been let down. HighWater therefore commits to long-term engagement with participants, ensuring that throughout their time in the program they develop life skills and the confidence to continue with their education. HighWater has found that this type of engagement leads to enduring impacts and attitude changes for participants and the community more broadly (Osmotherly 2011, p51). While an on-going program is important, an essential component of this long-term commitment is staffing consistency and commitment. The We’re Afraid of the Daylight project also found that their long-term engagement with participants projected a positive model of commitment and stability from respected adults, which many of the young people had not previously experienced. Similarly, The Torch found that their on-going commitment to participants provided them with the confidence required to take on further education and training such as the Certificate IV in Community Development run in partnership with RMIT which has been specifically targeted at participants wanting to engage with formal education, who would not otherwise have the opportunity. Use of Existing Resources and Networks Many of these projects drew upon and strengthened existing community networks and resources and recognised the value of engaging community arts organisations. Often these projects also worked with community organisations that did not have a specific arts focus such as local schools and councils, who were still able to offer resources. In some instances, projects found that existing groups could provide them with material resources. For example, the second phase of Kooriez in da Hood will use a printing press and other technical equipment sourced from the local community. Ongoing engagement with community networks has allowed organisations such as A.R.A.B. to develop multi-year funding agreements with its philanthropic partners, providing certainty and the ability to plan well into the future. Kate Gillick and David Ralph from A.R.A.B. stated that it took them years to build up the necessary level of trust with teachers so that they would support A.R.A.B.’s schools programs. Similarly, FReeZA has found that its community networks and links to the music industry have allowed it to attract high profile bands and musicians, thus improving the quality of the program. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 27 Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the use of existing resources and networks demonstrates a desire to work with the local community, rather than forcing a project on the local community. This is likely to strengthen community support and ownership of a project. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 28 Conclusion The projects presented throughout this report exemplify the potential for arts projects to improve the lives of young people, across a variety of areas including education, employment and training, health and wellbeing, and engagement with community and culture. Highlights for participants include provision of safe spaces to express themselves, greater connections to support services, the formation of positive relationships with the community and government agencies, greater access to pathways and new opportunities, skill development and personal growth. While the case studies cover a range of locations, diversity of participants, art forms and methods for engagement, there are shared characteristics that have contributed to these successful projects. Each of the projects involved professional artists, aimed for high quality artistic products and performances, and most were also long term and drew on existing resources and networks. These are relevant considerations for government departments and agencies when planning and implementing future projects. This report highlights the continued importance of delivering high quality arts projects targeted at young Victorians. It showcases recent examples that Arts Victoria can use when working with other areas of Government to identify similar opportunities that will advance the goal of ensuring the potential contribution of arts and culture is realised. Given the policy synergies between the outcomes of these projects and the objectives of Victorian Government departments, these projects have the potential to be 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project used as models for future government ventures. 29 Reference List Antiracism Action Band 2010, Northern Trax Acquittal Report, Arts Victoria, Melbourne, Victoria. Artful Dodgers Studio 2010, Out of My Head 2009, Artful Dodgers Studio, Collingwood, Victoria. Arts Queensland 2002, Creative Queensland: The Queensland Government Cultural Policy, Arts Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland. Arts Queensland 2008, Arts Culture + Me: Children and Young People in the Arts Action Plan, Arts Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland. Bamford, A 2006, The Wow Factor: Global research compendium on the impact of the arts in education, Waxmann, Münster, Germany. Brice Heath, S 1999, ‘Imaginative Actuality: Learning in the arts during the non-school hours’, in Fiske, EB (ed) Champions of Change: The impact of the arts on learning, Arts Educational Partnership, Washington, DC, pp.19-34. Broadbent, C 2003, ‘The Arts as a catalyst for improved learning outcomes for youth in detention’, in Communities of learning: Communities of practice: proceedings of 43rd Annual National Conference of Adult Learning Australia, Adult Learning Australia, University of Technology, Sydney, NSW. Brown, M 2008, ‘The Road Less Travelled: Arts-based Programs in Youth Corrections’, in O’Brien, A & Donelan, K (eds) The Arts and Youth at Risk: Global and Local Challenges, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK p.51-69. Bryce, J, Mendelovits, J, Beavis, A, McQueen, J & Adams, I 2004, Evaluation of School-Based Arts Education Programmes in Australian Schools, Australian Council for Educational Research, Canberra, ACT. Coulter, K 2008, ‘”Through the Maze, Finding the Hook, Walking a Tightrope”: The Art of Positive Work with Young Offenders in Custody’, in O’Brien, A & Donelan, K (eds) The Arts and Youth at Risk: Global and Local Challenges, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, pp. 70-92. Craik, J 2007, Re-Visioning Arts and Cultural Policy: Current Impasses and Future Directions, ANU E Press, Canberra, ACT. Cultural Ministers’ Council 2005, Stage Two Report, Social impacts of participation in the arts and cultural activities: Evidence, issues and recommendations, Department of Communications, Technology and the Arts, Canberra, ACT. Deasy, R (ed) 2002, Critical Links: Learning in the Arts and Student Academic and Social Development, Arts Education Partnership, Washington, DC. DEECD 2009, Partnerships between schools and the professional arts sector, Paper No. 19, Department of Education and Early Childhood Development, Melbourne, Victoria. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 30 Donelan, K & O’Brien, A 2008 Creative Interventions for Marginalised Youth: The Risky Business Project, Drama Australia Monograph Number Six, Drama Australia, Queensland. Eames, P 2008 ‘Doing Justice: How Arts in Prison Can Heal’, in Lewis, A and Doyle, D (eds) Proving the Practice: Evidencing the effects of community arts programs on mental health, DADAA Publishing, Fremantle, Western Australia, pp. 84-91. FReeZA 2011, viewed August 2011 http://www.freeza.vic.gov.au/ViewPage.action?siteNodeId=1479&repositoryName=Freeza Gibson, R & Anderson, M 2008, ‘Touching the Void: arts education research in Australia’ in Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 28(1), pp. 103-112. Hallifax, J & Rodriguez, F 2006, Anti-Racism Action Band Stage 1 Research and Evaluation Report, Victorian Arabic Social Services, Broadmeadows, Victoria. HighWater Theatre 2000, ‘HighWater Theatre: The Project’, viewed August 2011, http://www.somebodysdaughtertheatre.com/highwater.html HighWater Theatre 2011, HighWater Theatre Acquittal Report , Arts Victoria, Melbourne, Victoria. Hogan, S 2008, ‘Arts Pathways: Building Bridges’, in O’Brien, A & Donelan, K (eds) The Arts and Youth at Risk: Global and Local Challenges, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, pp. 123-138. Jarrett, R, Sullivan, P & Watkins, N 2005 ‘Developing Social Capital Through Participation in Organised Youth Programs: Qualitative insights from three programs’ Journal of Community Psychology, 33(1), pp. 41-55. Kelman, D 2008, ‘Narrative, Dialogue and Resistance: Making Meaning through Drama with Young People “At Risk”’, in O’Brien, A & Donelan, K (eds) The Arts and Youth at Risk: Global and Local Challenges, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK, pp. 93-107. Koorie Heritage, ‘Trust Projects: Kooriez in da Hood’, viewed August 2011, http://www.koorieheritagetrust.com/?CategoryID=171&ArticleID=123 Matarasso, F 1997, Use or ornament: The social impact of participation in the arts, Comedia, Stroud, UK. Neil, C 2009, ‘Scum Rises to the Top’ in Ferntree Gully Belgrave Mail, 25 August. Neil, C 2010, ‘Police and Pups’ in Ferntree Gully Belgrave Mail, 9 March. O’Brien, A & Donelan, K (eds) 2008, The Arts and Youth at Risk: Global and Local Challenges, Cambridge Scholars Publishing, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK. Office for the Arts 2011, National Cultural Policy Discussion Paper, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, Canberra, ACT. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 31 Osmotherly, J 2011, HighWater Theatre Active Pilot: Evaluation Report, Osfield Consultants, Wangaratta South, Victoria. Osmotherly, J 2007, HighWater Theatre: The Partnership, Osfield Consultants, Wangaratta South, Victoria. Pope, J & Doyle, S 2006, Strengthening Local Communities: Arts in Community Settings – The Evaluation of Two Community Support Funded Arts Programs, Department for Victorian Communities, Melbourne, Victoria. Smyth, L & Stevenson, L 2005, ‘You want to be part of everything’: The arts, community & learning, Arts Education Partnership, Washington, DC. Stephens, A 2010, ‘Hoodies in pride of race and place’, The Age Online, February 15, available at http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2010/02/14/1266082214679.html The Torch 2011, Boon Wurrung Ngargee - Acquittal Report, The Torch, Melbourne Victoria. VicHealth 2003, Creative Connections: Promoting Mental Health and Wellbeing through Community Arts Participation, VicHealth, Melbourne, Victoria. VicHealth 2009, Evaluation of the Community Arts Development Scheme, VicHealth, Melbourne, Victoria. White, T & Rentschler, R 2005, ‘Toward a New Understanding of the Social Impact of the Arts’, proceedings of the 8th International Conference on Arts and Cultural Management, Montreal, Québec. Wright, R, John, L, Offord, D & Rowe, W 2004, National Arts and Youth Demonstration Project, symposium held in Montréal, Québec. 2011 DPC Graduate Learning Team Project 32