BASICS OF BIDDING DEFINITIONS: bid package = drawings (architectural, structural, mechanical & electrical plans and details) plus the project manual construction = assemblage of a variety of materials in order to bring about an architectural or engineering design. construction bid = an offer to perform specific work for a specified price. good bid = submitted by a reputable and dependable contractor no omitted items accurate quantities and price-outs realistic completion time allowances practical methods planned for any problem items appropriate markup properly executed bid forms with bond, insurance and alternative bids. price = amount of compensation for the contractor’s labor, material, equipment and profit. project manual= book consisting of: invitation to bid requirements instructions to bidders bid forms bond forms experience qualification forms contract form (the agreement) standard clauses labor law miscellaneous laws, rules & regulations taxes, permits, licenses & inspections general and special conditions environmental protection temporary facilities and utilities technical specs pertaining to trades and subcontractors take off = the activity of determining quantities from drawings and specifications GENERAL BIDDING STRATEGIES Everyone wants to produce the low bid, win the contract and take responsibility for construction. The goal is to do the work and make money in the process. There are two ways to look at bidding and bidding strategy. The “short view” or “get the contract first and worry about the details later” is for inexperienced bidders. Some details cannot be foreseen or planned and must rely on field decisions, but this should be the exception and not the rule when bidding. An expert bidder will try to use the long run strategy of incorporating longrange planning into the details of the bid as early in the process as possible. Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 1 IMPORTANT ITEMS IN A GOOD BIDDING STRATEGY Job Site Walk-Through Do not miss the opportunity to go on a walk-through. After the bid documents have been reviewed and you have a general idea of the nature of the project, you should arrange a visit to the site of construction. You may even want to do a preliminary take-off before the site visit. When you go for the job-site walk-through, be sure to make notes and ask follow up questions, submitting them to the architect, general contractor or owner of the project before you submit your bid. Your investigation of the site and its conditions can make a difference in your bid and whether you can make money at the price you quote. The walk-through gives you the opportunity to compare the bid documents to the actual site. Make note of any differences between the contract documents and the actual site conditions and get them clarified by the general contractor, architect or owner prior to submitting your bid You will acquire additional information you may need later. Your perspective on space and dimensions is heightened as you can develop a better feel for the work you are bidding on. . If you cannot get a sufficient answer, qualify what your bid is based upon. You should look at the following: distance from your company offices distance from suppliers and subcontractors working room – how congested will the site be? equipment availability source of water source of power environmental issues soil conditions safety issues – will you need flagmen, barricades, etc.? security issues ease in getting materials in and out of the jobsite availability of secure storage on site parking Make a check sheet so that you do not forget what you will be looking for on a job site. This check sheet should be inclusive enough so that you can use it over and over again on various projects. It is a good idea to photograph the site as you walk through it to jog your memory as to a certain condition. Not every item will be checked for every walk-through. See Example 1 Bid Package Careful review of the bid documents or bid package is essential in submitting a responsible, comprehensive bid. Each bidder should carefully examine these documents and do appropriate take-offs. Note the scale indicated on the drawings and the details. Care should be taken when measuring dimensions and counting material quantities. Yet, there are other considerations that when taken into account could affect the bid and whether you will make money when you perform the contract as you do the work. The Bid Package is made up of the drawings and the project manual. We will discuss the project manual next. Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 2 Project Manual The Project Manual is also known as the Specifications Book or “Spec Book”. In reviewing the spec book, another check list will help you cover all the important items that you should be looking for. Again, not all items will be checked for all projects. It is suggested that the specifications in the Project Manual be reviewed first. After the specs have been reviewed and notes taken, attention should then focus on the drawings. Studying the specs first can direct your attention in what to look for when you review the drawings. However, everyone has their own way of doing things and whatever way works best for you is the method you should use. Make note of any discrepancies between the Project Manual and the drawings and get them clarified before submitting your bid. Scope of Work: Everyone goes to the part of the spec book that covers their particular scope of work. This part is important, of course, but it is not the only section that will influence your bid. Carefully review the scope of work paying particular attention that you only bid on the work relative to your own scope of work. General Conditions: Careful attention should be paid to the General Conditions. There may be costs associated with conforming to the General Conditions in the spec book. Inattention to the costs related to the General Conditions will cut into, or possibly eliminate, your profit when you have to comply with them as part of your contract. Instructions to Bidders: Ignore this section at your peril. Important detailed information is included in these instructions. If you are not bidding as the General Contractor, you will still be held to the definitions, interpretations, rules and procedures that are enumerated in this section of the project manual. Special attention should be given to the formalities of date, time and place of the bid opening. Note: If you are bidding as a sub-contractor, the contractor you are giving your quote or bid to needs enough time to incorporate your quote into his bid. Information Available to Bidders: This section has instructions on how to get extra information that you may need or find useful. Environmental research that you either could not obtain on your own or would be too expensive to obtain on your own is an example of the type of information that is available to bidders from the owner or architect. Reports on core sampling would have important information to anyone doing in-the-ground work. Wage Rate: If the project is funded by the government, note what wage rates you will need to pay your employees and what monthly paperwork might be required. Bid Forms: The organization accepting the bids will expect you to use the forms they put into the spec book. This makes the task of opening and recording bids easier and fairer to the owner as well as all those submitting bids. If you are a subcontractor, you should discuss with the general contractor how he might like to have a bid broken down. Don’t assume that they want to see information presented in the same way you want to present it. Addenda: Project Manuals are often written with corrections and additional information put into the addenda of the book. It may contain questions and answers from earlier meetings that were added at the last minute before printing. This information has been added for a reason and is important. It may have been too difficult to add it by rewriting the whole book Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 3 so it was added at the end. Instructions in the addenda will indicate where the information applies. Special Conditions: Take note of any special conditions noted in the project manual that may affect your working hours, the documentation you need to provide, and anything else that might affect your price. Many projects are being bid now that follow the USGBC LEED™ Guidelines. You need to understand how this might affect your scope of work such as the materials you might need to use, sequences you might need to follow and documentation you might need to provide. If you are unfamiliar with any of the terminology in the Project Manual, get it clarified prior to submitting your bid. Payment Terms: Understand what the payment terms are to the general contractor. If you are bidding as the general, understand what you need to submit to get payment and what the timeframe is between submitting your invoice and getting paid. Most projects pay monthly. You might need to carry 30-45 days between the time you submit your invoice and when you receive payment. Understand these terms prior to submitting your bid. Another form of Addenda is Bid Bulletins. This is also information that came to light after the Project Manual was compiled. Bid Bulletins also contain important, pertinent information. Questions: If you have any questions about any part of the bid documents or the pre-bid meeting you attended, ask a clarifying question and submit the question to the contact person in writing. If you think you will have several questions, make a Query List. The query list is a compilation of your questions and should be submitted all at one time. It will be more efficient for you and the person answering your questions. Be sure that you ask your questions well in advance of the deadline for asking questions. Questions and the answers are distributed to all the bidders so that everyone is on the same footing. In order to get the information out to everyone, a deadline for questions is established as part of the bidding process. Estimate Worksheet or Take-Off Sheet: Detailed information should be gathered first on a general spreadsheet and then a separate spreadsheet should be used to prepare a summary. This will help to organize the information and make preparing the bid easier. The detail sheet should be broken down by categories of work and material with space for the costs of each, leaving room for totals. The summary worksheet will have the totals only, labeled by categories in the scope of work. See Example 2 ALL OF THE DETAILS OF AN ESTIMATE ARE TOO NUMEROUS FOR THIS WORKSHOP AND ARE NOT INCLUDED HERE. Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 4 PACKAGING THE BID After you have reviewed all the bidding documents, the bid forms, bid bond (if required), the instructions regarding the formalities and have completed all your estimation figures including overhead and profit, you are ready to compile your bid. This is another time where a checklist could be helpful to the bidder in preparing the bid. The checklist should include all items that must be completed during the entire estimating process. This ensures that everything is accounted for and the bid can be submitted correctly and on time. This is an easy way to keep track of the details of bid submission as stipulated in the bid documents. Review your site notes, sketches and photographs one more time to see if anything jogs your memory. Bid Pricing The bid form supplied to the subcontractor with the plans and specifications may ask for one or more forms of bids: Lump Sum bid, a Unit Price bid or a Breakdown of Materials, Labor and Equipment bid. The general contractor will have similar requirements for his bid submission. The general contractor may also be required to submit a list of potential subcontractors that have tendered acceptable bids. Be sure to follow the instructions so that your bid is considered acceptable. Note how the general might want pricing broken out. Also, be sure to note what specific packages you might be bidding. The general might want to see separate pricing for drywall, framing, doors, ceilings and hardware. Understand this before you present your bid. Understand what the general wants you to include and what he might want excluded from each package. If you include too much, you might not get the project. Too little, and you might find yourself financially responsible for it during the project. Lump Sum Pricing: This is the most common request for a bid. The bidder estimates the costs for labor, material, equipment, overhead, profit, bonds, permits, insurance, fees and taxes and totals them into a lump sum figure and submits it as a price for doing the work. If you have developed a good working relationship with a general contractor, you can offer cost savings suggestions to him to help you get an edge. These are known as alternates and must be stated as such. Always price your work “per plans and specifications”. Alternates can be a way to help you get the project and develop a good working relationship with a general contractor. Everyone is always looking for the idea that helps them get the job. This is where your experience really helps. Unit Pricing: The quoted estimation of the price of units that will go into construction of the scope of work is unit pricing. Usually the unit price is added to the lump sum bid for reference purposes. The owner may request that the unit cost be added so that, should any additions or deletions to the work occur, the price can already be noted and a price be put on work order, change order or addendum. The process of applying these unit prices varies from contract to contract, but details about how the unit prices are to be used on the project will usually be found in the supplementary conditions of the contract documents. Another reason for a unit price estimate is that the general contractor can use it to compare accuracy between subcontractor quotes. If the lump sum prices are similar, but the unit prices are different, then one of the subcontractors may have made an error in his quote. Any questions about a bid or quote must be answered before a bid is accepted. Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 5 Bid Cover Sheet The bid cover sheet does not have the breakdown of costs on it but does have all the basic general information required on the bid form. The example offered in this workshop is similar to the bid forms issued in many local bid document sets. See Example 3 The Bid Form The bid which is often called the tender is sometimes submitted on a form of the contractor’s or the owner’s choosing. In any case, it usually contains the following information: 1. The name and address of the project 2. The identity of the owner 3. The identity of the bidding contractor 4. A description of the work to be done 5. A list of the bid documents 6. A list of the addenda 7. The bid price 8. The duration or completion date of the project 9. Signatures of the bidders or corporate officer if the company is incorporated 10. The time, date and place of the bid. 11. Alternates or unit prices required by the bid documents Either on the bid form or in a letter, the bidding contractor must declare that the bidder agrees to hold the bid open for acceptance by the owner at the price specified for a period of time (usually 60 days) and that the bidder will comply with all other bid requirements. NOTE: Compiling a bid can be a complicated task, but if you do your homework and take care to review all the documents, gather all the information you may need and pay attention to details, it can be a successful process. This information contained in these pages is only an overview of the information you will ultimately need. Suggested Reading: These books may be available at your local library. You may want to purchase any or all of these books. Basic Estimating for Construction by James A. S. Fatzinger; published by Prentice Hall ISBN 0-13-518267-0 Fundamentals of Construction Estimating by David Pratt; published by Delmar Publishers ISBN 0-8273-6135-1 Bidding for Contractors: How to Make Bids that Make Money by Paul J. Cook; published by RS Means; ISBN-10: 0876292708 Means Estimating Handbook published by RS Means CMD Group ISBN 0-87629-177-9 Plan Reading & Material Takeoff by Wayne J. DelPico; published by RS Means CMD Group ISBN 0-87629-348-8 Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 6 Example 1 SITE VISIT CHECK LIST Project Date of visit: Address Distance from business General weather conditions Access roads Site conditions Adjacent Structures Obstructions Soil data Soils report available? From: Water available Electric available Telephone service Sewage/Portajohns Garbage/Dumpsters Gas Parking and Storage Soil disposal: Contamination Site History Other Comments: Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 7 ESTIMATING WORKSHEET Example 2 Job Date Page # Estimated by Description Qty Unit Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved Materials Unit Price Labor Total 8 Example 3 ACME CONSTRUCTION Date _________________________________ Bid # ____________________________ Project _________________________________________________________________ Project Address __________________________________________________________ Owner __________________________________________________________________ Contact Person_________________________ Phone # __________________________ Owner Address ___________________________________________________________ BIDDING Division(s) ___________________________ Sections ____________________________ Summary of Work _________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Addendum noted __________________________________________________________ Base Bid ________________________ Special Information: ALTERNATE #1 ________________________ ALTERNATE #2 ________________________ ALTERNATE #3 ________________________ ALTERNATE #4 ________________________ ALTERNATE #5 ________________________ Bid Bond Included Taxes Included Elizabeth Bowers All Rights Reserved 9