AY 2014-2015 ACADEMIC PROGRAM REVIEW SELF-STUDY TEMPLATE Reporting School/College: St. John’s College Program Reviewed: Photography BFA Q Date Submitted to Department/Division Chair: 12/5/2014; section 6D revised 6/22/15 Overview and Program Review Summary: Please summarize this program’s mission and its relationship to the vision and mission of St. John’s University, and the program’s School/College. Identify similar programs regionally and nationally and distinguish this program from them. In addition, summarize your findings as they relate to (1) program quality, (2) market growth potential, and (3) student learning. Also, summarize any significant changes, achievements (by faculty and students and the program itself), and plans for the future. Finally, based on the information gleaned from the data in the self-study, give an overall rating of the program’s Enrollment/Market Potential by categorizing it as one of the following: (1) Enhance; (2) Maintain; (3) Reduce support, Phase out, Consolidate, or Discontinue. (Suggested limit 1 page) (1) Program Quality St. John’s University’s BFA programs are the only programs within New York City that are part of a large comprehensive university, which is accredited by the National Association of Schools of Art and Design (NASAD). This fact positions us as a leader in offering a visual arts curriculum of the highest quality, within a university, while providing students access to a broad liberal arts education. Our Photography program’s affiliation with the International Center of Photography is also indicative of the high standards the program strives for since ours is the only undergraduate program ICP collaborates with. (The others being graduate programs from Bard, and New York University.) (2) Market Growth Potential Photography majors can seek employment opportunities in a variety of markets: Portrait, Commercial, Industrial, Scientific, Fine Arts, University/School Photography, Education, Image Editing, Web Design and Production, Video and Film. The BLS (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics) predicted that between 2010 and 2020, open positions in the photography industry would increase by 13%. Corporations will require a constant stream of new images, which could benefit commercial photographers in particular. The BLS showed that freelance photographers should also have a slightly higher potential for finding employment. Salary statistics from May 2012 BLS records show that the median salary for photographers was $28,490 per year. In comparison, during that same year photographers in the top 90th percentile earned an annual salary of $66,990. Accurate salary statistics are difficult to examine, since photographer rates are not universal, especially with freelance photographers. The median expected annual pay for a typical Photographer in the United States is $55,417 in December 2014 as per, http://www1.salary.com/-Salaries.html and in Payscale.com. In above source, the salary for a photographer who is skilled in Adobe Photoshop ranges from $36,895 - $122,162 nationally. Product photographer ranges from: $39,494 - $142,545 nationally. A Photographer with Product Photography skills in New York, New York earns an average salary of $67,500 per year. Self-Study Template 1 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Enrollment / Market Potential: From 2009 to 2010 the Photography program has seen a marked increase in the BFA program, from 19 majors in 2009 to 28 in 2010, a 49 % increase. The 2010 increase was marked by a large number of freshmen that year, the largest we have had to date. The program’s fluctuation in numbers is expected, and has maintained a count of majors between 21-28 from 2010 – 2014. The “marketing” aspect of the program suffers from a program title of “Creative Photography”, which is listed in all university marketing and recruiting material under “C”, which is not where potential students are looking under when seeking out photography programs. After years of attempts to correct this, the Department, Curriculum Committee and LAFC approved a change of name to “Photography” in 2014, but unfortunately, this name change has still not been filed by the Provost office for approval by NYS and thus it remains listed under “C”. Prospective students have commented countless times on their surprise to know that we have this major, only to become aware of it through the recruiting efforts and events that the Department of Art and Design engages and participates in via high school visits and NPD Events. (3) Student Learning Small studio classes, limited to 15, offer a competitive edge against other programs in the region, which usually average 25-30 students in studio classes. Students in our program benefit from much individualized attention both in class and through frequent communication with their departmental mentor or advisor. Faculty engagement outside the classroom, is an assumed responsibility of our faculty. During their senior year, students have the opportunity to transform the knowledge they have acquired in the classroom into valuable, sought after skills, either through the completion of a thesis project or an internship, depending on their selected profession within the field. They work closely with a faculty member of their choice, and receive feedback from the department as a whole. Our rigorous assessment methods, which are listed in section 2i, emphasize individual and group portfolio critiques that access the student’s progress in all areas of creative and personal development. These critiques allow students to get thoughtful and comprehensive feedback from the broad array of perspectives that our faculty embodies. Students have many opportunities to exhibit their creative work on the Queens campus. The most prestigious of these events is the end of the year student exhibition held in the Dr. M. T. Geoffrey Yeh Art Gallery and the Thesis/Senior exhibition held at the Dorsky Gallery in Long Island City. The Photography program’s pedagogical affiliation with the International Center for Photography, gives our students an additional professional edge and offers them the opportunity to study with a wide array of photography professionals, who are actively working in a diverse number of fields. During their Junior year, students attend classes at the International Center for Photography, usually applying for and selecting one of their certificate program tracks: General Studies in Photography, or Photojournalism. The rigor of both of these programs cannot be overstated. Students work along side prestigious faculty, photographers and graduate students, engaging in all aspects of the medium and taking advantage of both the ICP School’s extraordinary facilities and New York City’s resources. Our photography students can also take advantage of the University’s Global Studies Programs. Professors from the photography program often run special courses abroad such as “Photography In Paris”, or Self-Study Template 2 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q “Documentation of the Culture of Southern Italy”. In addition, our students have the opportunity to spend a semester abroad, expanding their visual resources and global opportunities. Being immersed in an entirely new culture and language gives the students the opportunity to learn and engage in an international setting where they encounter new challenges and opportunities for growth. Outside of the familiar walls of the classroom, the students are able to learn about art, culture and religion in its native and historical context. It is our sincere hope that we will continue to provide a model for the University to follow as it recommits to student engagement and Global learning. Additional educational components that give our programs a competitive edge include field trips to museums, galleries, and pertinent New York City locations. We tap the wealth of New York City’s diverse creative talents and invite numerous guest speakers to address our students in their classrooms and at the University Gallery. (4) Significant Changes and Achievements, Plans for the Future In 2012, the Agreement with the International Center for Photography was renewed and clarified to include two possible tracks for students who meet the requirements of ICP: the General Studies Certificate Program and the Photojournalism Program. The addition of the Photojournalism, Certificate Program track offers an important choice to our students who are interested in this career path. A course in Video Art was also introduced in 2013. Photography students can now benefit from this important elective that will better prepare them for documentary jobs that assume both stills and video. Our majors have made significant strides in the field as well as in the Vincentian Commitment of the University. In 2013, one of our senior photography majors was asked upon graduation to document the work of GLOBE with Professor Linda Sama in Nicaragua. One of our present seniors, Rachel King, spend her sophomore spring semester in Rome, as an Ozonam Scholar, documenting the challenges of the gypsy community in Italy. Alex and Rachel are just two specific examples, as most of our majors involve themselves in some type of social justice project during their years here. It is important to also note that Alexander Arpag received one of the most prestigious awards given to students in photography during his ICP studies, the Wall Street Journal Scholarship for Photojournalism, for his documentary work of the Amish Community aiding victims of Sandy in the Rockaways. Our students accomplish great strides during their years here. During the 2013-14 Academic year, our photography students, in addition to their academic responsibilities, also achieved the following: Kalen Roach, published in Specter Magazine, May 2014 issue http://www.spectermagazine.com/twenty-four/roach/ Photography BFA senior, Don O’Brien–Russell was accepted into the 9th juried all-media art exhibition at the Castel Gallery in the College of New Rochelle. The exhibition titled, The Ninth Westchester Biennial, runs from April 22 – June 22, 2014. (A series from Donald’s Independent Study work is featured in the biennial.) Kalen Roach, one of our senior BFA seniors had a solo exhibition at:Dougherty Gallery at Crescent Grill in Long Island City. The show will opened on April 3, 2014 and ran through May 11, 2014. In the future, we hope to offer more career-targeted course here in our Queens campus. An upper level course, the Visual Narrative, will be in introduced this spring as a Distance Learning course, and we are working on two other courses, Urban Documents, and the Alternative Darkroom, that will collaborate with other majors while introducing multi-disciplinary thoughts and collaboration within coursework. The course, Urban Documents, which is in the drafting stage, hopes to collaborate with the Department of English and the Department of Sociology and engage faculty and projects that bridge interdisciplinary learning. Self-Study Template 3 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q As mentioned in section (2), it is also pertinent to also note that the program has been listed under “C” as “Creative Photography”. This continues to be our “plague” as we await NYS approval of the program change to simply “Photography”, which has been requested for years, and finally approved in the spring of 2014. This simple correction of the proper listing will positively affect enrollment since prospective students will son be able to find this program under its proper heading. What is greatly needed in the photography program is centralized studio spaces, that include proper lighting studios and critique spaces. Centralized facilities is a need for all the BFA programs that are offered by the Department of Art and Design. It is our hope that the photography program be maintained and enhanced. STANDARD 1. The purpose of the program reflects and supports the strategic vision and mission of St. John’s University, and the program’s School/College. 1a. What evidence can you provide that demonstrates that the program embodies the Catholic, Vincentian, and metropolitan identity of St. John’s University? www.stjohns.edu/about/out-mission. (Suggested limit 1/3 page) The Department of Art and Design considers the deeply personal nature of the education our students receive as strong evidence of St. Vincent’s call to serve with deep empathy and humility. Two of our Department’s professors, Prof. Joseph Adolphe and Prof. Belenna Lauto, are Senior Fellows of the Vincentian Center for Church and Society. Each year exhibitions and events are planned by our faculty to enhance student community awareness regarding our Vincentian traditions and values. Founders Week lends itself to specifically focus on issues of social justice, and as such, our department has, over the years, been committed and involved with activities and exhibitions that bring awareness to our founding patrons. During the last 5 years, in cooperation with the University Gallery, which our department collaborates with, we have curated and/or worked with the Gallery Director, Parvez Mohsin on the following exhibitions that exemplify our commitment to the mission and values of the University: "Jeff Mermelstein: 9.11.01," Curated by Alex Morel September 1 - October 26, 2011 Muslim/American, American/Muslim: Portrait of a Brooklyn Masjid August 31 - October 28, 2011 Crafting the Bible: From Scriptoria to Printing House April 4 - May 2, 2011 "Unpacking the FSA" March 20 - May 2, 2012, (Curated and organized by Photography Majors under the guidance of Prof. Morel) Silent Beaches, Untold Stories: New York City’s Forgotten Waterfront September 13 - November 2, 2013 Sublime Porte: An Exhibition of Contemporary Turkish Art March 14 - May 2, 2013 Artist in Exile: Creativity, Activism, and the Diasporic Experience April 1 — May 3, 2014 In addition to the above, the following departmental initiatives provide evidence that our program supports the Catholic Identity of St. John’s University: The Development of Study Abroad Programs in Rome and Paris that are designed in part to provide students a deep connection to the rich cultural heritage of Christianity. All students in the Department of Art and Design summer program in Rome participated in service activities designed to allow them to interact with and serve the poor. Self-Study Template 4 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Department of Art and Design students’ involvement in grant funded programs targeted at social issues on campus. Students are always encouraged and mentored to use their skills to advance causes that affect those who are less fortunate. Students participate in Service Learning both voluntarily and as part of class requirements. Our two full-time photography professors: Prof. William Morel, and Belenna Lauto, are both engaged in on-going photographic research and documentary projects that serve to benefit social justice, develop awareness for the underprivileged, the poor, and those challenged by the circumstances of their life as a whole. In addition, Prof. Morel and Prof. Lauto encourage and inspire students to use their photographic work as a vehicle for positive, social change. As part of his professional documentary work, Prof. Morel has been worked on documentaries that bring awareness to issues of poverty and prostitution in Haiti and the Dominican Republic. This semester, he is continuing photographic work on the border of DR and Haiti, documenting the extreme poverty and social and political divide that haunt these two countries. Prof. Lauto has been involved in documentary work that brings awareness to homeless mothers and their children, especially through the organization, MOMMAS House, recently documenting the plight of an 8 year old boy, who was born without legs. (Details on this work can be found in both respective faculty AFAR’s and websites.) Since the program’s inception our photography students/majors have embarked on a variety of projects that reflect the Catholic, Vincentian and Metropolitan identity of the University as a whole. The following exhibitions, documentary projects, missionary work, and presentations are a few of examples of the work a few of our photography students have involved themselves in during the last three years alone: Alex Arpag: missionary work, Sandy work by all majors, Rachel: Italy and here, also metropolitan…also list themed bodies of work: eg: Tatoinia, Kalen: liquor store ….etc., aging, etc.] Alexander Arpag spent a summer in Africa documenting orphanages for a missionary group druing his sophomore year. The resulting photographic work was featured in a department exhibition the following fall. Tatoina Mundy and Sharlotte Fondeur-Casas explored issues of intimacy and family relationships with their camera during their years here, resulting in two separate bodies of documentary work which were exhibited in and out of campus. Kalen Roach, during an Independent Study class, focused his documentary work on the strategic marketing of alcohol in under-privileged neighborhoods in Brooklyn. Rachel King, spend a semester in Rome documenting the plight of the gypsy community. She also volunteered in mentoring an tutoring the children. Alexander Arpag, BFA in Photography senior/alumni, was hired by St. John’s University to document the social work in Ecuador that Tobin graduate students were implementing under the direction and supervision of Dr. Linda Sama, May 19 – 30, 2014. Elizabeth Egan explored, through a series of photographs, issues of physical abuse women face in contemporary society. Self-Study Template 5 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q The photography program, by its very nature, depends greatly on the rich resources of New York City. Our juniors take 30 credits of their photography course work at the International Center for Photography, which is located on 43 rd Street and 6th Avenue. Every semester, individual classes design filed trips so that students are exposed to the rich artistic and cultural offerings of New York City. During the last year alone, our photo faculty has accompanied the students to view current work at a variety of Chelsea Galleries, ICP Galleries, the Museum of Modern Art, Metropolitan Museum of Art and a viewing of the documentary, Finding Vivian Maier, in the East Village. In addition, students are encouraged to explore photographically many diverse areas of New York City, documenting culturally rich neighborhoods such as: Flushing, Chinatown, Little Italy and Harlem. Our seniors are also honored by allowing them to exhibit their Thesis work at the prestigious Dorsky Gallery in Long Island City and those who choose to do an Internship as one of their Senior Capstone courses, also embark in the work place in New York City, taking advantage of career focused resources and networking opportunities they established while at St. John’s and ICP. 1b. What evidence can you provide that demonstrates that the program embodies the University’s vision. http://www.stjohns.edu/about/our-mission (Suggested limit 1/3 page) The B.F.A. program in Photography within the Department of Art and Design is commitment to studentcentered teaching to prepare young artists/photographers, to pursue careers in their chosen field upon graduation. This is achieved through small class size (15 student maximum) and six credit hours of contact in each studio class. Each of our BFA programs is committed to instruct young artists in the tools, techniques, vocabulary, traditions and history of their chosen profession, as well as to provide them with visual communication skills to address issues of poverty and social justice. Our BFA programs all strive to: “to preserve and enhance an atmosphere in which scholarly research, imaginative methodology, global awareness and an enthusiastic quest for truth serve as the basis of a vital teaching-learning process and the development of lifelong learning.” Photography has become an integral part of the world we live in. It is a universal language that we often take for granted. One only has to look around to be aware of the tremendous amount of images that we are confronted with each day. We have, in many ways, become dependent on photographic imagery for both educational and entertainment purposes. Photographs make the world more tangible, they allow an empathetic understanding of our humanity and can inspire social action and positive change. In our program we strive to help our students understand the positive potential of this powerful medium and align it with their responsibility as human beings and as benefactors of a Catholic, Vincentian University. 1c. What evidence can you provide that demonstrates that the program embodies the vision and mission of the program’s School/College? (Suggested limit 1/3 page) Specific to the Photography BFA program are five pedagogical goals that clearly reflect the Mission Statement of our College: 1. Mastery of technical skills. 2. Enhanced knowledge of visual history. 3. Develop critical thinking skills. 4. Develop Proficiency in a variety of photographic practices. 5. Demonstrate enhanced knowledge, skills and values consistent with the Core Curriculum. All courses, both required and electives, of the Photography Program engage students in an active learning environment. Weekly critiques and discussion sessions within the framework of the courses help students to Self-Study Template 6 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q develop advanced critical thinking skills as they are challenged to look, see, resolve, notice, analyze and compare their work within the context of assigned research topics, readings, gallery viewings, and course pedagogical content. Standard 1. Additional comments if needed. (Suggested limit 1 page) Beyond the above stated program goals, it is our hope that students from all of the Department of Art and Design BFA programs will create works of art and engage in creative activities that embody a level of poetic communication expressive of our shared humanity, and that the classroom environment cultivates and environment of individual responsibility. It is also fundamental to our programs that students understand that they are part of a global community and that art-making is a very powerful form of communication with the potential to effect positive change in the world. STANDARD 2. The program attracts, retains, and graduates high quality students. 2a. Undergraduate SAT and High School Average SAT 2005 2006 2007 High School Average 2008 2009 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Program 1130 1055 1152 1065 1045 92 82 91 85 86 School/ College 1104 1099 1085 1093 1093 88 88 88 88 89 University 1068 1075 1075 1087 1092 86 87 87 87 88 Freshmen SAT Scores Fall 2010 Fall 2011 Computed FNA2 CREATIVE PHOTO Fall 2012 Computed 1,086 Fall 2013 Computed 1,120 Computed 1,110 1,085 Freshmen High School Average Fall 2010 Fall 2011 High School FNA2 CREATIVE PHOTO Fall 2012 High School 87 Fall 2013 High School 89 High School 86 87 Self-Study Template 7 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q SAT Scores High School Average 2010 2011 2012 2013 2010 2011 2012 2013 School/ College - Q 1089 1077 1087 1098 88 88 88 88 Total University 1097 1087 1096 1104 87 87 88 89 SAT Test-Takers Intended College Major Mean Scores Number Percent (%) Critical Reading Visual and Performing Arts 10,424 7.7% Mathematics Total 481 969 488 *For further information, please visit http://www.ets.org/s/gre/pdf/gre_guide.pdf. Undergraduate 1st Year Retention Rate 2b. Fall 2003 2004* 2005 2006 2007 2008** # Fresh # Ret % Program 100% 33% 100% 100% 83% 4 4 100% School/ College 77% 79% 77% 77% 73% 1005 768 76% University 78% 78% 78% 79% 76% 3268 2557 78% Note*The % of students started in Fall 2004 and returned to the program in Fall 2005 **The % of students started in Fall 2008 and returned to the program in Fall 2009 2009 Total FNA2 4 2010 Returned DNR # % # % 2 50% 2 50% Total 8 2011 Returned DNR # % # % 7 88% 1 13% Total 4 2012 Returned DNR # % # % 3 75% 1 25% Total 2 Returned DNR # % # % 1 50% 1 50% Self-Study Template 8 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Fall 2009 2010 2011 2012* # Fresh # Ret % School/ College - Q 76% 74% 72% 905 683 76% Total University 78% 78% 76% 2757 2195 80% *The % of students started in Fall 2012 and returned to the program in Fall 2013 2c. Undergraduate 6 Year Graduation Rate Fall 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 Program 100% 67% 50% 100% 67% School/ College Average Rate 61% 59% 58% 60% 57% University 64% 59% 61% 61% 58% Fall 2004 cohort Total FNA2 3 Graduated 1 33% Fall 2005 cohort Total Graduated 1 1 100% Fall 2006 cohort Total 2 Graduated 2 100% Fall 2007 cohort Total 6 Graduated 5 83% Fall 2004 2005 2006 2007 School/College Average Rate - Q 57% 57% 57% 51% Total University 58% 58% 59% 55% 2d. Graduate Standardized Test Scores N/A Self-Study Template 9 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Comments: Refer to Charts 2a – 2d in your response. (Suggested limit 1/2 page) From 2005-2013, we have seen an increase in the photography program student SAT scores. Overall the program SAT scores and high school averages were in line with the College average, and higher than the national averages for students entering the visual and performing arts. In 2003, 2005, 2006,and 2008, the photography program had a retention rate of 100%. In 2007 and 2010, the program had a retention rate substantially higher than the college and university’s average for the same time period, at 83% and 88%. Unfortunately, the program’s retention rate fell to 50% in 2009 and 2012, but this is due to a small freshmen class, half (1) of who was not able to keep up with the curricular demands of the program and failed several of the major classes during the second semester, which caused them (in both cases) to lose their financial aid/scholarships. St. John’s University freshman retention rate 78.3 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. Graduation rate average from 2005 – 2007 for Photography major ranged from 83-100% %, which is substantially higher than the college and university’s average for the same time period, which was 51-57%. St. John’s University 6 year graduation rate 56.9 percent; source College Factual. 2e. Please describe how the program compares with peer and aspirational institutions. (Suggested limit 1/2 page) In 2011 the our freshman B.F.A. Photography retention rate was 75% percent compared to SVA’s (School of Visual Arts) over all First-Time in College (FTIC) rate of 80 percent. SVA is a peer NASAD accredited institution with a much larger enrollment within the New York metropolitan market and our 2011 freshmen class had only 4 students, of which 1 left due to financial and/or academic reasons. NASAD accredited institution retention rates: - Pratt Institute freshman retention rate 83 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Syracuse University freshman retention rate 91.8 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Skidmore College freshman retention rate 93.5 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Alfred University freshman retention rate 74 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Fashion Institute of Technology freshman retention rate 86 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. Non-NASAD accredited institution retention: - Adelphi University freshman retention rate 83 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Columbia University freshman retention rate 99 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - CUNY Queens College freshman retention rate 87 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Fordham University freshman retention rate 89 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Hofstra University freshman retention rate 78.3 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. 2f. If applicable, describe the program’s student performance over the past five years on licensure or professional certification exams relative to regional and national standards. (Suggested limit 1/4 page) N/A 2g. Number of majors and minors enrolled over the past five years. See table below. Self-Study Template 10 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Fall Number of Students 2006 2007 2008 2009 Majors 18 14 15 18 19 Minors 5 3 6 9 11 Total 23 17 21 27 30 MAJORS 2h. 2005 FNA2 Fall 2010 Fall 2011 Fall 2012 Fall 2013 Majors Majors Majors Majors BFA 28 26 23 21 Number of degrees granted during the past five years. See table below. Academic Year Degrees Granted 4/5 5/6 6/7 7/8 8/9 BFA 1 5 6 4 3 SJC -UG-Q FNA2 Creative Photography BFA 10/11 11/12 12/13 Degrees Conferred Degrees Conferred Degrees Conferred 4 5 5 Below is comparison degrees conferred data for local and national institutions based on data retrieved from the IPEDS website. This is based on the Classification of Instructional Program (CIP) Code of 50-Visual and Performing Arts. 20092010 20102011 20112012 Self-Study Template 11 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Local 1,938 1,974 2,017 National 95,797 91,802 93,956 1 Local institution include: Adelphi University, Columbia University, CUNY Queens College, Fordham University, Hofstra University, Iona College, C.W. Post University, Manhattan College, New York University, Pace University, Seton Hall University, Stony Brook University, and Wagner College. Comments : Based on the data in 2g and 2h, how do these trends compare to institutional, regional and national patterns? (Suggested limit 1/2 page) The BFA in Photography major has seen a moderate and steady growth since 2005. The program, however, suffers from a lack of marketing and a NYS name coding for the major, “Creative Photography”, which forces the university to list the major under “C” instead of under “P” so that prospective students might find it and apply. The name change has been requested over the years, and was finally approved by the LAFC in 2013. We are still waiting, however, for the paperwork to be filed by the Office of the Provost so that the State can approve the name change. In addition, since our facilities cannot accommodate many students, we cannot compare our numbers to other art schools which all have a “School for Art” with a building designed and used exclusively for visual arts programs. Our graduation rates are comparable to that of the university, though the data provided is not complete enough for us to make specific comparisons. It is important to note that the BFA in Photography requires 132 credits, 84 of which are studio related classes which each meet for 6 hours a week, while providing 3 credits of course work. Our students are required to take 18 credits for most of their semesters during their 4 years, and some simply opt to stay longer in order to better address their course work. NASAD accredited institution in the New York market 4-year Graduation rates: - Pratt Institute 4-year Graduation rate 42 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Syracuse University 4-year Graduation rate 69 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Skidmore College 4-year Graduation rate 83 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Alfred University 4-year Graduation rate 44 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Fashion Institute of Technology 4-year Graduation rate 70 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. NASAD accredited institution 4-year Graduation rates: - Adelphi University 4-year Graduation rate 53 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Columbia University 4-year Graduation rate 88 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - CUNY Queens College 4-year Graduation rate 25 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Fordham University 4-year Graduation rate 76 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. - Hofstra University 4-year Graduation rate 50 percent; source U.S. News & World Report. The National Association of Schools of Art and Design (NASAD) conducts bi-annual surveys of enrollment at their member institutions. The data included here was taken from NASAD surveys from 2009-2014 for peer institutions, which are defined as private universities with 100-200 majors. For the purposes of comparison, the data provided by NASAD is more accurate than what is in this document because the code used to gather the data for the charts above include both visual and performing arts and therefore over counts enrollment and Self-Study Template 12 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q degrees given compared with the more limited program offerings in the Department of Art and Design at St. John’s University. TABLE BELOW- NASAD Accredited Private Institutions: 100-200 majors offering Bachelor of Fine Arts or Equivalent : Number of Institutions with Majors Art/Design Major Enrollment Fall 2009-2010 13 1311 Number of Degrees Awarded July through June of the years given 274 2011-2012 22 2525 527 2013-2014 20 2058 476 When looking at program specific data the information given is more general because it includes all NASAD institutions and is not available with more specific size criteria. As the number of NASAD accredited degree granting institutions has increased so has the number of students who are awarded degrees each year. Overall the graduation rate for peer institutions has remained relative consistent and we see that trend mirrored within our own program. The NASAD data cited here can be found in the National Association of Schools of Art and Design (NASAD) Higher Education Data Services’ report on Art and Design Data Summaries from 2009-2014 (https://secure3.verisconsulting.com/HEADS/ ) 2i. What mechanisms are in place to monitor students’ progress toward degree? And, to what extent is there a collaborative effort to provide quality advising and support services to students? (Suggested limit 1/4 page) The Photography program participates in an assessment and implementation process shared by the Department of Art and Design. Photography students are subject to a rigorous portfolio review every semester. There is also a juried Student exhibition each year. Ongoing exhibitions are displayed on the fourth floor and on the “B” level display cases. Each student is personally reviewed during Professional Portfolio to assess preparedness for internships and future careers. Faculty members are always available by appointment for portfolio review and the annual report summarizes student accomplishments within our major. Types of Student Assessment: Student portfolio reviews: one per semester. Annual juried student show at the Dr. M. T. Geoffrey Yeh Art Gallery. Students are scheduled to meet each semester with an Art Department advisor to review their academic progress toward the completion of their degree program. At the end of each semester, most Faculty members hold individual student conferences and critiques in order to review the term's work and individual progress and effort. Exhibition Areas on the fourth floor and on the “B” level display class work and/or Senior Thesis work. Reviews are conducted each semester of the "Professional Portfolios" that seniors have produced in order to be considered for Internships. Self-Study Template 13 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Each student has individualized conferences with Chairperson/Internship Advisor concerning internship placement and or Thesis readiness. Faculty member is assigned to individualized supervision of interns. Two group meetings are scheduled each semester with the students who are on internship and an “on the job site” visit is planned with the intern, faculty and internship supervisor. Interns have recently been asked to put their internship work and personal Internship Logs on disks, which are gradually creating an “Internship Library” located in the Art Office. Students may request an individualized critique of their artwork by faculty. Annual report summarizes student accomplishments. Course evaluations are distributed to students at the end of each semester. Assessment sheets are provided to the University annually after spring portfolio reviews. Portfolios accepted for program as freshmen are now kept in student’s file in order to better assess the artistic growth of each student. Further opportunities for professional assessment of student work are provided through exhibition initiatives that have enabled students to exhibit their work in professional venues, and, since 2005, an after school open critique session. Since Outcome Assessments are quickly becoming an institutional priority, the Department has developed the following additional methods for determining current status and future strategies: a. Assessment forms were sent to approximately 340 alumni during 2008-09. A new assessment form has recently been finalized and is scheduled for distribution to BFA alumni in December 2014. b. Student-Faculty Forum was established in April 2001 and has become a valuable tool to foster direct communication with students. c. An alumni outreach plan is being further developed. Since 2002 we have had several alumni programs including a dinner and lecture with Milton Glaser in our Manhattan campus, three Alumni Art Exhibitions in the University Gallery, as well as a very successful 50 year BFA Alumni reunion/exhibition, which took place in December 2013. In the summer of 2014, we also hosted an alumni barbecue on campus. Our alumni often serve as mentors to our seniors and often come to visit and share their stories. 2j. If available, provide information on the success of graduates in this program as it relates to employment or attending graduate school. (Suggested limit 1/4 page) Specific to the BFA in Photography program, the following alumni have kept close communication with us and provided us with their career status: Courtney Brown, BFA 2007 Current: Photo Editor at Trip Advisor GENIUS. Previous: Editorial Assistant, Marie Clare Sean Hanratty, BFA 2007 Sean Hanratty is a photographer from New York City, currently based in Shanghai as a photojournalist. MFA in Photography from The School of Visual Arts. http://www.seanhanratty.com/ Self-Study Template 14 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Natalie Loizzo, BFA 2007 Portrait/wedding photographer, Long Beach, NY http://www.natalieloizzophotography.com/ Polina Nezvankina, BFA 2007 Professional photographer and owner of Laika Studio Specialty: Weddings, portraits and fine art photography. http://www.polinanezvankina.com NEW YORK CITY | MOSCOW www.laikastudio.com Michelle Zuccaro, BFA 2007 Photographer: portraits, editorial and family, Long Island based. http://www.michellezphotography.com/ Katharine Decker, BFA 2004 Owner of LightSplash Studios Portrait and Corporate Event Photographer for San Jose, Silicon Valley, Carmel, Monterey, Los Gatos, Santa Cruz, Palo Alto, Santa Clara and San Francisco Bay Area. www.lightsplash.com Norimichi Tsubouchi (Exchange International student - Photo major) Still Life Commercial photographer represented by: Wave in the USA, Schirke in Germany, Angela Woods in the UK, and D-Cord in Tokyo Partial client list: American Airlines, Avon, Bausch & Lomb, Bosch, Citibank, L’Oreal Paris, Louis Vuitton Moet, Henessy Group, Mastercard, Pierre Cardin, Samsung, Vanity Fair, Vogue http://norimichi.com/ Michael Marfione, BFA 2001 MFA, University of Pennsylvania From 2007-2012 he has worked for the artist Chuck Close and is currently also an adjunct of photography at St. John’s University and is a freelance documentary and fine art video artist and photographer. http://michaelmarfione.com/ Michael Pineiro, BFA 1999 Photographer, www.michaelpineiro.com John Holtschneider, BFA 1998 Present position: Art Director, Harry & David, Medford, Oregon past positions: Senior Graphic Designer, Sears Holdings Corp.; Senior Art Director, Roberft Brandt & Associates; Art Director, Leo Burnett, Chicago; Production Designer, JWT Alana Abel, BFA 2009 Present Position: Senior Coordinator at Capital One Jason Tinacci, BFA 1997 Jason Tinacci is an editorial and travel photographer based in California’s San Francisco Bay Area. Tinacci is also the founder and owner of TrellisCreative, a boutique stock photography agency that focuses on wine, food and lifestyle themed stock photography. http://www.tinacciphoto.com/ Self-Study Template 15 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Robert DeSantos, BFA 2008 Senior Photographer at PhotoOp and Venture Photography, http://www.photoopnyc.com William Morel, BFA 1996 MFA, Visual Arts, Rutgers University Alex is a documentary photographer and associate professor at St. John’s University. http://www.alexmorel.net/ Iris Cooley, BFA 2003 Marketing and Advertising Project Manager at Leo Burnett, Chicago, Illinois Hiroko Shono, BFA 2010 Portrait and Editorial photographer based in NYC. www.hirokoshono.com Kylie McMinn, BFA 2009 Artist/Photographer, www.kyliemcminn.com Brian Lentini, BFA 2001 Staff photographer and writer, Long Island Institute of Professional Studies; freelance photographer and writer for Juice Magazine. www.juicemagazine.com Katrin Bodyikoglu, BFA 1999 Photo Editor, Mother Earth News, Sussex Publications, NYC Andrea Coukoulis, BFA 2006 Marketing Analist at U-Haul International, Inc. Phoenix, Arizona past: Photo Assistant, Soap Opera Digiest, NYC Trudy Laltoo, BFA 1995 Picture Desk Editor and Product Owner, Getty Images Past jobs all as Photo Editor or Sports Photographer - Sports Ilustrated for Kids, ESPN, New York Times, NewSports, WireImage Sports (just to name a few) . Robert Raeihle, BFA 1993 Chair of Art Department at Commack High School MA, Studio Art, New York University, 1995 Georgina M Diaz, BFA 2014 Job status: currently working full time with benefits at B &H photo and video as a photo kiosk sales person. Kenneth Pizzo, BFA 2013 Photo retoucher for Box Services, and KiDS Creative. Clients: Alexander Wang, Balenciaga, Vera Wang, Prada K Jasmer Nelson, BFA 2004 Founder and President of MacLifestyle, Marina del Rey, California We will have more recent information once the results of our 2014 assessment are received in 2015. Self-Study Template 16 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q (We are in the process of distributing an alumni survey, which will gather more information regarding the success and graduate status of our alumni. The survey was drafted by the department and we are awaiting its completion and final approval.) 2k. Please comment on the students’ competencies in the program. Support your response using data provided below and any other data available. (Suggested limit 1/3 page) BFA in Photography students maintain a CUM GPA ranging from 3.2-3.4, which is consistent with the SJC average that ranges from 3.1-3.2. It is important to also note that our students are challenged with a major that requires 132 credits, 18 credits in most semesters. Standard 2. Additional comments if needed: (Suggested limit 1 page) STANDARD 3. The program engages in ongoing systematic planning that is aligned with the University and School/College planning, direction, and priorities. 3a. How does your program’s strategic goal/objectives link to your School/College plan and the University’s strategic plan? http://www.stjohns.edu/about/leadership/strategic-planning Student engagement within the photography program at St. John’s University is deeply committed to providing individualized attention to students in the classroom and to creating and planning activities outside of the class that expand on concepts being discussed with in the classroom while at the same time exposing students to the rich cultural offerings of the Greater New York area. Our record of engagement with students inside and outside of the Self-Study Template 17 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q classroom is exceptional and serves to support The Strategic Plan: 2011-2014, providing a quality education, student experience, career placement and furthering education. In the context of the university’s Catholic and Vincentian Mission while promoting diversity and global Awareness. Working with the student organization Art Club has allowed the Department of Art and Design to collaborate on off campus activities and guest lectures that engage students in learning and experiences beyond the confines of the classroom. Additionally, faculty who teach in the photography program have organized numerous events that provide off campus activities. These events provide informal venues that facilitate student-faculty interactions, they provide collaborate learning experiences, and allow students from different years to meet and interact with each other. Engagement also occurs among students both within and outside our program. In the B.F.A. Photography Program we recognize that one of the ways that service and learning can be most relevant and meaningful is when it is directly connected to and tailored to a student’s field of study. To that end we have developed service learning opportunities that are seamlessly integrated into classroom projects and curricula. We also realize that service can be defined in multiple ways. We have students who are engaged in projects that serve the university and the local community, such as the work photography students have done with organizations such as Mainchance, Briarwood, Mommas House, Chapin Home, Ozonam Home, and St. Mary’s Hospital, just to name a few. Photography students have also created work for exhibition based on each years Vincentian Theme for Founders Week. The documentation of social concerns is a focus within the photography curriculum and students are encouraged to use the camera as a vehicle for positive social change. Through the Global Studies Program professors from the photography Program have taught classes in Rome, southern Italy and Paris. Global Studies is an invaluable addition to the student’s college experience. Being immersed in an entirely new culture and language gives the students the opportunity to learn and engage in an international setting where they encounter new challenges and opportunities for growth. Outside of the familiar walls of the classroom the students are able to learn about art, culture and religion in its native and historical context. It is our sincere hope that we will continue to provide a model for the University to follow as it recommits to student engagement and Global learning. As stated in other sections of this report, the photography program at St. John’s University is deeply committed to providing individualized attention to students in the classroom and to engaging students in trips and activities outside of the class that expand concepts being explored in the classroom, while at the same time exposing students to the rich cultural offerings of the Greater New York area. Our record of engagement with students outside of the classroom is exceptional. The number of guest speakers, planned field trips and symposiums are too many to list, but a sampling of this year’s programming can be accesses via our internal department website: www.sjuartdesign.com, and clicking on the Calendar tab. The Department also keeps a record of each extracurricular planned activity in a collective binder in the Department office. It is our sincere hope that we will continue to provide a model for the University to follow as it recommits to student engagement, social justice and global learning. 3b. What is the evidence of monitoring the external and internal environments, specifically what are the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats facing the program? How were they identified? What actions have been taken in response to these findings? What characteristics of the program suggest a competitive edge against other programs regionally and nationally? Self-Study Template 18 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q The Department of Art and Design annually evaluates its mission, goals and outcomes during department meetings that are held each month throughout the academic year. In addition, the Department has earned accreditation by NASAD, The National Association of Schools of Art and Design, and has spent the last year generating an updated self-study Document as required by NASAD, and its Accreditation Team. Our last thorough self-Study for NASAD was completed in 2008. In addition, the Department of Art and Design, has prepared an Annual Report since 1988. From 2010 to 2013 the Department of Art and Design prepared annual reports as required by the National Association of Schools of Art and Design’s Commission on Accreditation in response to their Visitors Report of 2010. The NASAD Commission Action Report cited issues with our facilities and some programs had curriculum that needed to be addressed and upgraded to NASAD standards, to be eligible for full membership. Working closely with the support of the Dean’s Office of St. John’s College and the Department of Design and Construction, significant facilities issues were resolved, and curriculum revisions were made in the Fine Arts, Illustration and Photography programs in response to NASAD’s 2010 Visitors Report. The initial self-study Document prepared for NASAD was prepared and drafted by Belenna Lauto who served as department chair from 1998-2004. Information within the report, including goals, objectives and plans for improvement, were collectively gathered through various sources including the following: previously published university material, departmental annual reports, 1997 self-study initiated by then Chairperson, Prof. William B. Ronalds, as well as assessment information which was made available through various resources. The 2003-04 self-study was prepared by Prof. Belenna Lauto, with the help of full-time faculty. The completed draft was then distributed to the departmental full-time faculty for revision, additions, suggestions and discussion. The Dean, Dr. Jeffrey Fagen of St. John’s College was then provided with a copy for further analysis. From 2010 – 2013 the annual responses to NASAD’s Commission Action Repot, which required the department to document corrective action taken by the department and University in resolution of outstanding curriculum and facilities issues that were cited in NASAD’s “2010 Visitors Report” resulted in full accreditation were prepared by Ross Barbera who served as department chair from 2010 – 2013. The next full On-Site review by NASAD will be in March 2015. The Department of Art and Design is currently in the process of preparing for this upcoming visit by NADAD representatives. It is important to note that the University has always quickly responded to the concerns of external evaluators. The following table lists s areas of weakness that were identified in the NASAD 2010 Visitors Report and corrective actions taken by the Department of Art and Design: Areas of weakness that were identified in the NASAD 2010 Visitors Report Safety concerns, especially in the mezzanine level were cited the NASAD 2010 visitors report. Security cameras and controlled access systems were nonexistent in these areas. Some studios were accessible to anyone from the outside. Students complained about feeling unsafe when they are working alone in the SJH studios after hours. Corrective actions taken by the Department of Art and Design In December of 2010 the Department Chairperson, Ross Barbera together with the Dean of St. John’s College, and the Vice President of Public Safety, Mr. Thomas Lawrence, reviewed all department facilities for safety enhancements. This review resulted in security upgrades for most art studios located in SJH. The security enhancements involved the installation of strategically placed cameras and card swipe systems at designated entry and exit points to the art studios located on the mezzanine level and 3rd & 4th floor art studios of St. John’s Hall. As part of this security Self-Study Template 19 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q upgrade, new fire doors were installed on the mezzanine level doors during the spring of 2011. These doors only permit exit to the outside, and no inside entrance is possible through them. To insure our student's safety during off-hours, the Department of Art and Design, in conjunction with Public Safety, has a student monitoring procedure in place to control student access to studios. Public Safety requires that the Art Department maintains a list of students' who have been approved to use the studios during off hours. We provide Public Safety with an updated version of this list at the start of every semester, and security is notified whenever new students are added during the course of the semester. Only students on this list are permitted to access the art studios. The process requires that all students call Public Safety to be let in when they are actually at the studio door. At the time of entry, Public Safety physically checks the student ID before permitting studio access. In addition to this, security officers patrol on foot and check all art studios periodically during off-hours. All art department studios, classrooms and hallways are equipped with phones that directly connect to the central security office, and the security phone extension number is predominately displayed in a red sign above every phone. The NASAD Commission: The current physical environment used by the Department of Fine Arts presents a number of issues and concerns. Saint John's Hall houses the department offices and classrooms divided on a number of levels within the building. The distribution of teaching spaces in Saint John's Hall appears patch work as opposed to planned. Additionally, the department's course offerings are divided between Sullivan and Saint John's Hall &which seem to create a disconnect within the department. The need for a University community “Fine and Performing Arts Building (or designated space with integrated facilities),” which can serve as a hub for creativity for the entire the campus community is acute. Moving the Department of Art and Design to new space (in the old University Center) and creating integrated art and design-making facilities was included in the 2008 strategic plan. Unfortunately, the designated space was used for other purposes and when the revised strategic plan was unveiled moving our Department was no longer included. Until this goal is realized, the Department of Art and Design will continue to address the location and quality of the existing art and design facilities and will work to ensure that our students are safe and can productively work in the existing environment. 3c. What is the current and future market demand for the program? Support your response using the data provided below or any other internal or external sources to justify your response. Self-Study Template 20 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Photography majors can seek employment opportunities in a variety of markets: Portrait, Commercial, Industrial, Scientific, Fine Arts, University/School Photography, Education, Image Editing, Web Design and Production, Video and Film. The BLS (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics) predicted that between 2010 and 2020, open positions in the photography industry would increase by 13%. Corporations will require a constant stream of new images, which could benefit commercial photographers in particular. The BLS showed that freelance photographers should also have a slightly higher potential for finding employment. Salary statistics from May 2012 BLS records show that the median salary for photographers was $28,490 per year. In comparison, during that same year photographers in the top 90th percentile earned an annual salary of $66,990. Accurate salary statistics are difficult to examine, since photographer rates are not universal, especially with freelance photographers. The median expected annual pay for a typical Photographer in the United States is $55,417 in December 2014 as per, http://www1.salary.com/-Salaries.html and in Payscale.com. In above source, the salary for a photographer who is skilled in Adobe Photoshop ranges from $36,895 - $122,162 nationally. Product photographer ranges from: $39,494 - $142,545 nationally. A Photographer with Product Photography skills in New York, New York earns an average salary of $67,500 per year. In addition to the above data, the charts below provide a more positive outlook for the photographic market, estimating a growth of 17% between 2010-2020. Fastest growing occupations and occupations having the largest numerical increase in employment by level of education and training projected. Fastest Growing Occupations Photographers Change, 2010-20 Percent 17% Numeric Occupations having the largest numerical increase in employment Change, 2010-20 Percent Numeric 17,500 Projected Changes in Related Occupations (2010 – 2020) Changes, 2010-20 Grow faster than average - Increase 15 to 20.9% Photographers Percent Numeric 17% 17,500 *For more information please visit: http://www.bls.gov/news.release/ecopro.toc.htm Standard 3. Additional comments if needed: (Suggested limit 1 page) STANDARD 4. The program provides a high quality curriculum that emphasizes and assesses student learning and engagement. Self-Study Template 21 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q 4a. Please indicate how the program curriculum is in alignment with the following three items: (Suggested limit 1/2 page for each of the three categories below) 1. Standards within the discipline 2. Curriculum integrity, coherence, academic internships, teaching excellence, teaching vibrancy, and study abroad experiences. 3. The University Core competencies 1. Standards within the discipline: The BFA in Photography follows the standards set forth by the discipline and looks to the needs of the 21st century as well as to other programs to engage in the proper planning, changing and implementation of curriculum as demanded and expected by these changing times. Our collaboration with the International Center of Photography engages us with professionals in the photographic field who also direct and inform us of the changing demands as well as assess our the pedagogical needs of our students. The Department of Art and Design is accredited by National Association of Schools of Art and Design (NASAD) and meets NASAD’s standards of Art’s education. In order for a student to be eligible for admission to any of our BFA programs the following minimum criteria must be met: • 85 or above High School average and • a minimum score of 950 in the SAT • An accepted portfolio of original creative work. This portfolio is assessed personally by one of the full-time members of the Department of Art and Design For graduation, the BFA student must complete 132 semester hours with a cumulative quality point index of 2.0 for all courses taken, and a cumulative quality point index of 2.0 for all courses in the major. It should be noted that most of our students perform well above this minimum level. 2. Curriculum integrity, coherence, academic internships, teaching excellence, teaching vibrancy, and study abroad experiences: In order to provide our students with the best possible education in the arts and fulfill our aspirations for pedagogical excellence, the Department of Art and Design faculty meets regularly to discuss and evaluate all programs and identify areas for improvement. Syllabi are evaluated and updated every three years. Two annual portfolio reviews, along with the annual student exhibition, offer concrete assessment opportunities whereby faculty may continually evaluate the educational programs offered. In addition our faculty are closely connected with the changing demands of the field and we adjust our curriculum accordingly. Since 2009 all of our BFA programs have undergone revisions. These revisions include the creation of upper level courses, the creation of courses such as Motion Graphics, Advanced Web, Junior and Senior Design, Studio Seminar I and II, Introduction to Video, Contemporary Photographic History and Practices, and several others, which were created to keep our programs up-to-date and competitive. All of our syllabi now follow an updated format, which includes the specific goals of our majors that the course addresses and references the curriculum map for each of our majors. The BFA in Photography has a capstone internship or thesis experience which provides the students with an opportunity to engage in research projects and/or experience career possibilities first hand. Our photography professors have been cited for teaching excellence many times throughout their tenure with the following awards and recognition: Student Government Faculty of the Year, Teaching Excellence Awards, Learning Communities, Professor of the Year, and several others. In addition classroom evaluations rate the photography Self-Study Template 22 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q professors higher than the University average. Our professors are also involved in global programming. From the creation and participation in program specific study abroad courses such as: Southern Italy: A Visual Culture, and Photography in Paris, to projects and exhibitions that involve students in social justice around the world such as have been mentioned in previous sections of this report. The BFA program curriculum in Photography is under constant review and evaluation in an effort to provide students with a relevant curriculum that effectively encompasses the technical, artistic and conceptual skills needed by today’s contemporary, professional photographers. Retention is addressed by establishing clear communication among student, faculty, advisors and the Department overall. Students are offered opportunities for developing their potential as well as to discover the resources available to them on a consistent basis. Each year, aside from the University's freshmen orientation events, the Department of Art and Design offers incoming freshmen an “art student orientation day” which all freshmen are invited to attend. All full-time Faculty are present during this busy day which includes an introduction to the Department by the Chairperson, an introduction to the department internal website, useful information regarding the art/museum resources in NYC, lunch with the art faculty, a tour of the Department, studios and library art resources, and an introduction to the satellite labs in order to familiarize students with the systems and Departmental procedures. The University has also implemented a Learning Communities Program in which all freshmen art majors are encouraged to participate. Several of the Department Faculty are actively involved with these Communities and some of the freshmen studio classes are linked with Core classes in order to encourage collaboration between disciplines. The Grade Point Average required for retention is: 2.0. Students maintaining at least a 2.0 cumulative quality point index are considered to be in non-probationary academic standing. When the cumulative quality point index is below 2.0, but in the judgment of the Dean, the student is considered to be making acceptable progress toward a 2.0, the student is placed under academic probation, but is permitted to continue on a matriculated basis with a limited program of 12 credits (or 4 courses) until he/she attains satisfactory academic standing. For graduation, the BFA student must complete 132 semester hours with a cumulative quality point index of 2.0 for all courses taken, and a cumulative quality point index of 2.0 for all courses in the major. It should be noted that most of our students perform well above this minimum level. Advisement procedures established by the university are as follows: The Freshmen Center advises all incoming freshmen with loose collaboration with the Art Department Chair and advisors. Upon the completion of freshmen year, students are assigned a Departmental Faculty Advisor, whom they are encouraged to keep throughout their next three years. Students are expected to meet with their advisor at least once a semester. Departmental advisors are guided and trained by the Chairperson and University personnel and administrators through various workshops and meetings. The University has adopted the philosophy of “Developmental Advisement” and as such students are encouraged to meet with their advisors to discuss their career goals, strengths and weaknesses, as well as their class choices. The Department keeps a secure file system, holding academic files of each art major as well as advisors' evaluations, initial portfolio review evaluations, thesis and internship evaluations, and any other relevant information pertaining to the student regarding individual progress and pedagogical issues. Self-Study Template 23 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Photography students have the option of doing an internship or a thesis project during their final semester in the program. All BFA students are expected to have a professional portfolio by their senior year. Besides the creation of both physical and online portfolios, students also make a business card, write a cover letters and contact employers for potential internship opportunities. Each student has individualized conferences with the faculty member assigned to supervise interns. Two group meetings are scheduled each semester with the students who are on internship and their faculty advisor. The Department of Art and Design maintains a internship placement database which is located in the Art & Design Department Office and available to any student who wishes to research possible locations/companies for internship or employment. 3. The University Core competencies: Photographers must obtain combination of critical thinking, information literacy, skillful writing, oral and visual presentation and communication skills in order to succeed in the 21st century. Our program aims to target each of these competencies both in the major and core curriculum. The following list of departmental goals has been specifically developed in order to critically assess the quality of student learning. Included in these measurable goals is an assessment of the degree to which students' attitudes, social values, ethical values, commitment to scholarship and lifelong learning develop as a result of their education. a. Student artistic/creative progress. b. Student professional skills: academic progress toward the completion of their chosen degree and career goals. c. Student professional skills: technological skills d. Student overall visual literacy: intellectual, historical, technical e. Critical thinking f. Community service/ Student involvement g. Program satisfaction h. Achievement of personal goals. 4b. The syllabi for the courses within this program incorporate the suggested elements of a syllabus – an example of which can be found at the following St. John’s University Center for Teaching and Learning link. (Suggested limit 1/3 page) http://stjohns.campusguides.com/content.php?pid=71651&sid=984766 In 2014 The Department of Art and Design updated the syllabi for each of the courses offered in the four major programs as well as the Music minor. Updated syllabi are available to all faculty for review and comparison. A list of the courses offered by the Department and links to the 2014 updated syllabi can be found at: http://sjuartdesignfaculty.weebly.com/department-syllabi.html In order to provide our students with the best possible education in the arts and fulfill our aspirations for pedagogical excellence, the Department of Art and Design faculty also meets regularly in order to discuss and evaluate all programs and identify areas for improvement. Syllabi are evaluated and updated every three years. Self-Study Template 24 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q 4c. Describe the assessment model currently in place for the program and indicate the extent to which disciplinary and core knowledge, competence, and values are met, as well as findings and action plans for improvement. For reference, visit WeaveOnline – https://app.weaveonline.com//login.aspx; Digication – https://stjohns.digication.com (Suggested limit 1/2 page) The program goals and outcomes of each of the programs offered by the Department of Art and Design have been designed so that students can develop their creative, critical, formal and technical skills, and become versed in the visual and verbal language of design. Students are expected to gain an understanding and awareness of contemporary design practices, contemporary designers and the history of design. The individual program goals and outcomes emphasize the University Core Competencies, especially critical thinking, writing/communication skills, information, presentation and literacy skills. The program goals and outcomes of the BFA in Photography are provided below. 1. Mastery of technical skills. Demonstrate mastery of the technical aspects of the medium of photography including the camera, film, digital, lighting, darkroom and digital printing. 2. Enhanced knowledge of visual history. Demonstrate knowledge of the history of the visual arts, including photography, and its impact on social and visual culture. 3. Develop critical thinking skills. Demonstrate field-specific critical thinking skills so as to analyze, discuss and critique photographic images considering technical, aesthetic ethical and conceptual applications and values. 4. Develop Proficiency in a variety of photographic practices. Demonstrate the ability to engage in various photographic practices, including, but not limited to: portrait photography, studio / product illustration, documentary photography journalism, digital photography, and fine art photography 5. Demonstrate enhanced knowledge, skills and values consistent with the Core Curriculum. Demonstrate effective communication skills and values consistent with the Core Curriculum in areas of: information literacy, writing skills, and self-reflection. All BFA Students are required to participate in a fall and spring portfolio review. In the fall students meet as a group according to major and year with faculty of that major and group critique and evaluate the students work based on the program goals and learning outcomes. In the spring, students meet individually with three faculty members to review their portfolios. Thesis student’s work is reviewed twice a semester by all full-time faculty. Students are expected to demonstrate mastery of technical skills. Students in the Photography BFA program learn both analog and digital skills with all types of cameras and digital imaging in order to achieve mastery of their chosen profession. Students are expected to demonstrate knowledge of visual history. A well-rounded education in art/photography includes gaining knowledge of the history of the visual communication arts, recognizing and naming historical figures in photography and making connections between the historical and contemporary concerns within the medium. Self-Study Template 25 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Students are expected to master formal skills and apply them accordingly. Foundation classes focus on working with formal elements and introduce photographic techniques and practices. Upper-level classes challenge students how to define and demonstrate their technical knowledge and develop their own artistic “voice”. Students are expected to demonstrate field-specific critical thinking skills. Throughout all of their coursework students are encouraged to apply critical thinking skills to the application of techniques learned and to demonstrate the ability to solve visual problems with clearly articulated processes, including problem identification, research and information gathering, generating and editing alternate solutions, implementing final solutions and evaluating a project against the original goals and expectations. There is a consistent focus on design fluency in verbal and visual vocabulary and the ability to analyze, discuss and critique visual problems and solutions, considering technical, aesthetic and conceptual applications. Writing and the articulation of ideas is also an addressed and expected competency in all of the BFA programs offered in the Department of Art and Design. Students are expected to apply values and ethics to their photographic practice. Students in the Photography Program are trained to consider ethical, social and environmental responsibility in the making, publishing and production of images. They spend time examining individual situations and reflect upon the consequences of images and the power of photography in society at large. Students are expected to demonstrate enhanced knowledge, skills and values consistent with the Core Curriculum. The breadth of coursework covered in the Photography B.F.A. addresses the University’s Core Competencies. Students demonstrate information literacy and the ability to use computers and other technology for a variety of purposes. They demonstrate effective communication skills in a variety of formats and proficiency in visual, verbal and written vocabularies. Students are expected to illustrate realistic ideas to implement knowledge, skills, and values in occupational pursuits in a variety of settings. Students formulate portfolios, which establish direction toward specific career goals or towards the pursuit of a graduate degree in the visual arts. They demonstrate understanding of basic business practices in the discipline, including the expectations of a professional artist, in varied job settings that a artists/photographers might be employed in, proper interpersonal relations within an office, an understanding of both subordinate and leadership roles within a professional structure, appropriate attire for business, client’s expectation of freelancers and pricing/payment structures. 4d. What, if any, external validations, e.g. specialized accreditations, external awards, other validations of quality has the program received? (Suggested limit 1/3 page) The program has received NASAD, (National Association for Schools of Art and Design), accreditation, which is the highest accreditation given to schools of art and design and is rarely given to art programs under the umbrella of a larger university curriculum. Our affiliation and agreement with the International Center for Photography, (ICP), also validates the quality of our programs. ICP’s historical associations have always been with graduate programs, namely from New York University and Bard. We are currently the only undergraduate program that has an educational partnership/agreement with ICP. Standard 4. Additional comments if needed. (Suggested limit 1 page) We will be publishing our assessment methodologies on Weave and Digication in 2015. We are also collecting freshmen entry portfolios in order to better assess what students have accomplished during their 4 years here. We hope to publish these findings, along with student portfolios during the next year or so. Self-Study Template 26 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q In an effort better to assess our programs, we continue to collect data from our alumni and hope to improve networking and mentoring between current students and alumni. STANDARD 5. The program has the faculty resources required to meet its mission and goals. 5a. Below you will find the number of students enrolled as majors and minors in the program. Please complete the table by adding the number of full-time faculty assigned to the program. Then calculate the student to full-time faculty ratio. Fall 2005 Fall 2006 Fall 2007 # Majors/ FT Faculty FT PT Total FT PT Total FT Majors 18 0 Minors 5 Majors & Minors Combined 23 # of FTE Students (Majors & Minors) 23 0.00 # of FTE Faculty assigned to the program FTE Student/ FTE Faculty Ratio 18 13 0 PT Total 6 17 20 18 6 9 21 27 0 PT Total 9 10 1 11 27 29 1 30 23 16 0.33 16.33 20 0.33 20.33 27.00 0.00 27.00 29.00 0.33 29.33 1 15 FT 19 1 3 1 Total 0 23 16 14 PT 19 3 14 FT Fall 2009 18 5 1 Fall 2008 0 2* 2* 2* 2* 2* 2 to 23 2 to 17 2 to 21 2 to 27 2 to 30 Self-Study Template 27 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Fall 2010 Fall 2011 Fall 2013 F Total F Total F Total F Total Majors Majors Majors Majors Majors Majors Majors Majors MAJORS 28 28 26 26 Fall 2010 Total Fall 2012 FTE MAJORS FTE Student/FTE Faculty Ratio 23 Fall 2011 21 21 Fall 2012 Fall 2013 F Total F Total F Total F Total FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE FTE 28 28 26 26 23 23 21 21 Fall 2010 # of FTE faculty assigned to the program 23 2 2:28 Fall 2011 Fall 2012 2 Fall 2013 2 2:26 2 2:23 2:21 Important Notes: FTE Students = Number of FT Students + (number of PT Students/3) FTE Faculty = Number of FT Faculty + (number of PT Faculty/3) * The full-time faculty indicated above is the full-time faculty from the Department of Art and Design. This number does not reflect the faculty resources at the International Center for Photography. This methodology is used by STJ for all external reporting. The figure for majors includes first and any second majors. 5b. Below you will find the credit hours the department has delivered by full-time faculty and part-time faculty (including administrators) and the total credit hours consumed by non-majors. Credit Hours Taught Fall 2005 Fall 2006 Fall 2007 Fall 2008 Fall 2009 # # # # # % % % % % Self-Study Template 28 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q 1644 31% 1680 33% 1911 39% 1992 40% 2001 37% FT Faculty PT Faculty 3638 69% 3470 67% 3016 61% 2978 60% 3371 63% Total 5282 100% 5150 100% 4927 100% 4970 100% 5372 100% % consumed by Non-Majors Credit Hrs Taught 82% Fall 2010 Number F-T Faculty P-T Faculty (inc Admin) 3,353 Number 5,252 Percent 36.2% 1,908 34.1% 63.8% 3,688 65.9% % Consumed by Non-Majors 100% 4,205 80.1% Number 1,392 3,778 0.0% 5,596 4,513 81% Fall 2012 0.0% Total 81% Fall 2011 Percent 1,899 83% Fall 2013 Percent Number Percent 26.9% 1,398 27.5% 73.1% 3,682 72.5% 0.0% 100% 80.6% 81% 5,170 100% 4,195 81.1% 0.0% 5,080 4,048 100% 79.7% 5c. Below you will find the number of courses the department has delivered by full-time faculty and part-time faculty (including administrators). Courses Fall 2005 Fall 2006 Fall 2007 Fall 2008 Fall 2009 Taught # # % # % # % # % 27 34% 32 40% 38 46% 32 39% % FT Faculty 31 35% PT Faculty 57 65% 53 66% 48 60% 45 54% 51 61% Total 88 100% 80 100% 80 100% 83 100% 83 100% Self-Study Template 29 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Courses Taught Fall 2010 Number Fall 2011 Percent Number Fall 2012 Percent Number Fall 2013 Percent Number Percent F-T Faculty 36 40.0% 37 47.4% 30 30.3% 28 27.2% P-T Faculty (inc Admin) 54 60.0% 41 52.6% 69 69.7% 75 72.8% 0.0% Total 90 100% 0.0% 78 100% 0.0% 99 100% 0.0% 103 100% 5d. What is the representative nature of faculty in terms of demographics, tenure and diversity? (See departmental information on next page). How well does this support the program? (Suggested limit 1/2 page) Since 2004 the Department of Art and Design has striven to seek the best candidates to aid the university in its mission, serve the needs of each program, and to serve our students overall. One goal of the department is to engender diversity when hiring by maintaining a 50/50 ratio male and female. Since 2004, 5 of our last 8 hires were women. Of our 12 fulltime faculty members, 6 are women (50%). Of our entire adjunct faculty, including adjuncts in Staten Island and abroad, 21 of 42 are women (50%). The Department Personnel and Budget committee reviews all junior faculty for reappointment and tenure as stipulated by University procedures and guidelines. Another goal of the Department of Art and Design is to hire persons of color and ethnically underrepresented backgrounds. In the last 4 years the department has hired individuals who identify themselves as: Hispanic, S/Central America; Arab, N. African Middle East & Black Caribbean; Asian, Pacific Rim; and Asian, Hispanic, S/Central America. Moving forward the Department of Art and Design, strives to maintain the standard of hiring the best candidates to aid the university in its mission to serve our students, and maintain diversity that reflects our global community. Our photography faculty is diverse in gender, ethnicity and photographic style. As professionals, the photography faculty cover specialties in the fine art photography, documentary photography, commercial and editorial work, and video. Fulltime faculty represent both genders, and both are from Latin American origin. Two of our adjunct faculty are African American, and the other two from northern and southern European backgrounds. The ICP faculty are also extremely divers and because of ICP, our photography students are privileged to study with the widest range of faculty as compared to all of our other programs. Self-Study Template 30 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Departmental Plan 2005 FT 2006 PT Total # % # % Male 6 60% 12 46% Female 4 40% 14 Total 10 100% Black 0 Hispanic FT 2007 PT Total # % # % 18 6 50% 11 44% 54% 18 6 50% 14 26 100% 36 12 100% 0% 1 4% 1 0 0 0% 1 4% 1 Asian 0 0% 3 12% White 10 100% 20 Unknown 0 0% Total 10 100% Tenured 6 TenureTrack FT 2008 PT Total # % # % 17 8 57% 13 52% 56% 20 6 43% 12 25 100% 37 14 100% 0% 1 4% 1 1 0 0% 1 4% 1 3 0 0% 2 8% 77% 30 12 100% 20 1 4% 1 0 0% 26 100% 36 12 100% 60% 6 8 3 30% 3 Not Applicable 1 10% Total 10 100% FT 2009 PT Total # % # % 21 8 57% 14 54% 48% 18 6 43% 12 25 100% 39 14 100% 7% 0 0% 1 1 1 7% 1 4% 2 2 0 0% 3 12% 80% 32 12 86% 20 1 4% 1 0 0% 25 100% 37 14 100% 67% 8 8 4 33% 4 1 0 0% 10 12 100% FT PT Total # % # % 22 8 57% 11 50% 19 46% 18 6 43% 11 50% 17 26 100% 40 14 100% 22 100% 36 7% 0 0% 1 1 7% 0 0% 1 1 7% 1 4% 2 1 7% 0 0% 1 3 0 0% 3 12% 3 0 0% 2 9% 2 80% 32 12 86% 21 81% 33 12 86% 20 91% 32 1 4% 1 0 0% 1 4% 1 0 0% 0 0% 0 25 100% 39 14 100% 26 100% 40 14 100% 22 100% 36 57% 8 8 57% 8 9 64% 9 6 43% 6 6 43% 6 5 36% 5 0 0 0% 0 0 0% 0 0 0% 0 12 14 100% 14 14 100% 14 14 100% 14 Gender Ethnicity Tenure Status Self-Study Template 31 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q 2010 FT 2011 PT Total # % # % Male 8 62% 10 48% Female 5 38% 11 52% Total 13 FT 2012 PT Total # % # % 18 8 62% 13 48% 16 5 38% 14 52% 34 13 0% 1 1 8% 1 4% 2 1 8% 2 7% 3 1 4% FT 2013 PT Total # % # % 21 7 58% 12 48% 19 5 42% 13 52% 40 12 FT PT Total # % # % 19 7 54% 14 45% 21 18 6 46% 17 55% 23 37 13 Gender 21 27 25 31 44 Ethnicity Black 1 8% Hispanic 1 8% 1 5% 2 Asian 0% 1 5% 1 0% American Indian/Alaskan Native 0% 0% 0 0% 17 81% 28 2 10% White 11 85% 2 or More Races 11 85% 0% 1 4% 1 8% 2 8% 3 1 0% 1 4% 0% 0 0% 21 78% 32 2 7% 1 11 92% 0% 2 6% 2 15% 2 6% 4 1 0% 1 3% 1 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 19 76% 30 85% 24 77% 35 2 8% 2 6% 2 0 0% 0 0 0% 0 2 11 Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander Unknown Total 0% 13 0% 21 0 0% 34 13 0% 27 0 0% 40 12 0% 25 0 0% 37 13 31 44 Tenure Status Tenured 8 62% 8 8 62% 8 11 92% 11 12 92% 12 Tenure-Track 5 38% 5 5 38% 5 1 8% 1 1 8% 1 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 0% 0 Not Applicable Total 13 13 13 13 12 12 13 13 Self-Study Template 32 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q 5e. What evidence exists that the program’s faculty have engaged in research and scholarship on teaching and/or learning in the program’s field of study? (Suggested limit 1/2 page) The entire full-time and part-time faculty actively participates in research and scholarship that includes professional practice, exhibitions, presentations and publications. Through assessment and planning activities faculty share and discuss syllabi, relevant improvements in technology, media and advancements in pedagogical theory. Creative output whether in the form of written research and scholarship or gallery exhibitions informs teaching, supports the University’s mission and goals and creates a vital bridge between the academy and the professional world. Art and Design faculty remains committed to continued research, scholarship, and professional practice as a vital component of a successful program. Faculty submits an Annual Faculty Activity Report (AFAR) and yearly department report to the chair. During the last academic year, our faculty has engaged in the following projects: Prof. Morel: Myth and Realities of Contemporary Caribbean” (a working title). This is an on going project where images from my other bodies of works about the region (mainly in Hispaniola) have started to shape this idea. This series of photographic images references myths/legends, folklore, and the cultural, socio-economic, and political reality of the region today. During the research leave I am hoping to make my way to other areas of the Antilles and/or the northern cost of South America, create new work, and consolidate the project. On Books & Reading”. For some time now, perhaps a few years, I have been creating images of books and people reading. It wasn’t until this past spring 2012 that I started to concentrate on this curious interest, looking back at images in my archive and consciously and intensely photographing during the past several months. It wasn’t until recently also that I became aware of a book, “On Reading” (1971), a book of photographs by one of my preferred and greatly influential photographers of the XX century, Andre Kertesz. I have to admit that after seeing this book and images, I felt an immediate discouragement towards my own interest; after all, the great Kertesz had already visited this idea with a lifetime of amazing photographs. So, what could I possibly contribute…? I managed to finally convinced myself of how wonderful it was to share this interest with one of my most admired artist, and of the relevance of the subject almost half a century later when books as objects and concepts are being reevaluated, transformed, and hold on to. This work is on going; I am still photographing and editing past work. Untitled New Work. This project is closely related to my previous work “Relations & Tales” about family and relationships. I want to examine the idea of home (a place or idea that identify us and to which we want to return) specifically from the perspective of those in advance age. At this point, I have reached an age where I’m starting to look much like the “mental-image” I have of my youngest uncle. My grandparents’ children are looking more the way I remember my grandparents when I was a child. This realization came suddenly and unexpectedly, and with it the urgency to photographs the elders of my family as well as the places they associate with permanency and belonging (places that might no longer exist). The children of my grandparents on both side of the family are 19 plus their spouses, and they are scatter through out the United States and the Dominican Republic. New Work & Collaborations. During the summer of 2012 I was invited to a research trip to Istanbul and other areas of Turkey along with other faculty members including Prof. Parvez Mohsin and Prof. Paul Fabozzi. This experience resulted in the highly successful exhibition and symposium “Sublime Porte: Art & Contemporary Self-Study Template 33 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Turkey”, spring 2013. With this exhibition we created an exciting dialogue between local and international artists, about regional issues that have overarching global repercussions, in a geographic area of international confluence. Now, the exhibition has been invited to travel and expand its concept to Brasil, where several museums (Museu de Arte Contemporânea de Niterói - Rio de Janeiro, and Museu de Arte Moderna da Bahia Salvador do Bahia) would like to show it as soon as late 2014 or 2015. As part of the project, we are creating new works in collaboration with the local communities, and/or about the region, aside from works related to Turkey. Concurrently, we (Prof. Mohsin, Prof. Fabozzi, and I) are also extending the “Sublime Porte” concept to Bangladesh and India. These locations will serve as a platform for research, the creation of new works, and potential exhibitions in the region as soon as mid 2014. In India Sunaparanta Goa Center for the Arts and Goa College of Art have extended their invitations to an artist's panel discussion and an exhibition of selected works created in Turkey. Prof. Lauto: Working on a manuscript for possible book on the visual language and aesthetics of photographs, which now has emerged more as a “conversation” on styles within the history of photography. Expanding work on Marionette series, creating a series of limited edition artist books and most recently, mixed media pieces that incorporate both analog and digital processes. Since October 28th, 2013, working on a documentary project of Isaiah, a 5 year old boy, currently residing with his mother, Burnadette, and baby brother, Elijah, at MOMMAS House in Glen Cove, LI. Isaiah was born without legs, and due to the challenging circumstances of Burnadette’s personal life, which is now being addressed by MOMMAS House, she had not been able to find doctors that would take on Isaiah’s case until now. This long-term project will document Isaiah’s journey towards obtaining and learning to use prosthetic legs. In addition, both professors collectively applied to six grants in 2013-14. 5f. What initiatives have been taken in the past five years to promote faculty development in support of the program? (Suggested limit 1/2 page) The University provides summer support grants and "seed" grants to all full-time faculty members. Innovative Teaching Grants are also provided by the Center for Teaching and Learning. The latter provide faculty with the opportunity to experiment and develop new ideas for cohesive, innovative classroom strategies. The center also provides faculty with a multitude of workshops, resources and information. In the past both the Departmental P&B and the Office of the Dean allow adequate funds for faculty development and travel. The Dean's Office, through its development fund, often pays for art faculty to attend workshops on any topic related to teaching and or student engagement. In addition, travel and conference funds are available to faculty who want to attend and/or are presenting in professional conferences. On occasion, the Office of the Dean even provided aid to Art and Design faculty for exhibition and research expenses. Since 2013, the Department, with the support of the Office of the Dean has helped to fund three research leaves and travel expenses to approximately 20 conferences for our department full-time faculty. The Office of Grants and Research also assists the art faculty when approached. Since 2012, our faculty has more actively pursued the assistance of the Grants Office in order to comply with university procedures and benefit from the services rendered by this office. Self-Study Template 34 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q 5g. The table below shows the amount of external funding received by the department. If available, please provide the dollar amount of externally funded research for full-time faculty supporting the program under review. (Program dollar amounts are available through departmental records.) N/A External Funding Fiscal Year 4/5 5/6 6/7 7/8 8/9 $ Amount Program $ Amount Department External Funding 4500 Fiscal Year 09/10 10/11 11/12 12/13 $ Amount Program $ Amount Department - - - - 5h. Please comment on the table below that shows trends in overall course evaluation and instructional vibrancy for your program (if available), your college and the university. (Suggested limit ½ page) Photography (Q) Saint John’s College Total Undergraduate Overall Evaluation (Spring) 2011 2012 2013 Instructional Vibrancy (Spring) 2011 2012 2013 4.15 4.20 4.24 4.40 4.43 4.46 3.95 4.01 4.00 4.28 4.33 4.33 4.01 3.21 4.07 4.27 4.29 4.35 Note: Institutional Vibrancy is the average of the first 14 questions on the course evaluation, with questions pertaining to course organization, communication, faculty-student interaction, and assignments/grading. All course evaluation questions range from 1 (Strongly Disagree) to 5 (Strongly Agree). Self-Study Template 35 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q The Photography Program course evaluations score higher than both college and university averages. We are please with the resulting evaluations of the program and will continue to work towards providing our students with challenging pedagogical goals and that have substantial programmatic and faculty engagement and support. 5i. What percentage of full time faculty assigned to this program have terminal degrees or industry certifications renewed within the past 2 years? Comment. (Suggested limit 1/3 page) 100% - Both full-time faculty assigned to this program have terminal degrees in the field of Photography. Standard 5. Comments: Indicate to what extent the program has the faculty resources required to meet its mission and goals. Include references from 5a – 5i. (Suggested limit 1 page) The photography program greatly benefits from its affiliation with the International Center for Photography, especially in the area of faculty resources. Since students take 30 credits of their photography course work at ICP, they have the privilege of studying with faculty who are in the cutting edge of the field in both the Queens campus and at ICP. The two full time faculty in our program at St. John’s greatly compliment one another in that one specializes in social documentary work and the other in mixed media and fine art work. Both are genuinely involved in many aspects of their field and use their research and work as vehicles for student engagement, pedagogical ideas and student learning. Our adjunct photography faculty also offer our students a great deal of professional experience and bring to the program specialties in digital imaging video and fine art specialties that enhance the program. For some time now we have been wanting to bridge the ICP faculty with our adjunct faculty, and this year, we were able to hire Andreas Rentsch, who now adjuncts at both our Queens campus and at ICP, and will be working with our freshmen photo majors this spring. The program would benefit from an additional full-time faculty that could share the coursework that the program provides to the St. John’s community. Since we offer 2-3 sections of non-major photography classes each semester, which always fill, an additional full-time faculty can better serve the university community and engage with our nonmajor students more effectively. The department, however, has more pressing faculty needs in other areas, such as in graphic design. Standard 5. N/A Additional comments if needed. (Suggested limit 1 page) STANDARD 6. The program has adequate resources to meet its goals and objectives. And, it is cost-effective. 6a. Narrative/Supportive Technological Environment - Comment on classrooms and labs meeting industry-standards for quality and availability of hardware, software, and peripherals; library space, holdings and services; science laboratories, TV studios, art/computer graphic labs; etc. (Suggested limit 1 page) The Department of Art and Design is located in St. John’s Hall with the exception of the Graphic Design labs which are located in Sullivan Hall, a building that was built for the purpose of housing technologically advanced classrooms. Fine Art studios in St. John’s Hall include rooms: 404, 405, 303, and 316, all which are general arts studios with multiple uses. Room 404 and 405, however, are used primarily for painting and drawing. They are both equipped Self-Study Template 36 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q with easels. Room 500, also in St. John’s Hall, is a printmaking studio; and room 403 is a darkroom facility for the purpose of analog processes in photography. Rooms 316 and 406A also act as satellite graphic design/ digital photography labs for student use. Labs are equipped with Mac desktops, the Adobe CS6 Creative Suite and both labs have access to free ink jet printing. In addition to these, the Mezzanine area of St. John Hall is divided into three larger studio sections, two of which are used for studio classes in design, drawing, illustration, jewelry design, and 3D design, and one of which is a designated Thesis studio for our BFA seniors and those working on Independent projects. The Mezzanine area also houses lockers for BFA students and two small rooms, one which functions as a small lighting studio for student use, and the other is set up as a resource room for BFA students. Sullivan Hall houses two state-of-the-art computer labs, rooms 222 and 207, which are used for graphic design classes, some photography and illustration classes, and the intro to video class. These labs have been updated every year for software and are included in a rotation schedule with the rest of the university for hardware updates every 2-3 years. However, since Adobe changed their updates to the Cloud, the labs are still using 2-year old software, Adobe CS6. Currently equipped with the newest Macs and the necessary software for graphic design, photography and video, our labs are our most sophisticated facility, but are now challenged with the Adobe cloud updates, which IT is looking into. It is imperative that the Adobe programs be updated for the next academic year in order for the program to stay abreast of the industry standards. The University provides classrooms throughout the campus in order to meet the needs of art history courses. Classrooms assigned to art history courses all have inter-net and digital projection accessibility. The Department also avails professors of laptops and projectors for use in studios, which are not permanently equipped with projectors and computer podiums, though at this time, only the Mezzanine area lacks permanent podium and projection equipment. An issue that we often face is that the projectors do not work well in some of the classrooms and this impacts the proper teaching of art history since it is necessary for the work to be projected accurately in order to accurately discuss elements of color, etc. within the work. The most important long-term goal of the Department of Art and Design move into a space in which studios, labs and lecture halls are centralized and built to meet the needs required by each discipline. The Department has instituted several recruitment initiatives to help bolster our numbers but the condition of the art making studios and the lack of integrated art and design space continues to be a challenge to both recruitment and retention. Until such time, we have been putting our efforts into making the space that we do have as workable as possible and have received support from the administration towards the functional realization of the existing space. Undeniably, the Mezzanine area presents the most challenges. Issues of air quality, ventilation and heat in this area have been of great concern to the Faculty, students and administration. During the last few years, however, much has been accomplished to improve the environmental quality of these studios, and the administration has eagerly supported our suggestions and efforts to improve these existing spaces as best as possible. As a result, the air duct system of the Mezzanine is regularly cleaned, and appropriate safety supplies such as eye wash stations are maintained. The darkroom, located in Room 403, serves the needs of majors by providing black and white analog facilities for learning traditional photographic methods. The exhaust system in the darkroom is checked regularly and two new air-conditioning units were installed this summer (2014). The darkroom is continually monitored for environmentally sound procedures. The facility is equipped with fifteen Beseler enlargers and one fully automated Beseler 45 that is available only to photo majors and Faculty. Since the photography program has an affiliation with the International Center for Photography in Manhattan (ICP), photography majors spend their junior year at the ICP school facilities, which are located at 43rd Street and 6th Avenue. The facilities at ICP offer our students state-of -the-art darkrooms, lecture rooms, digital labs and finishing Self-Study Template 37 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q rooms. The ICP digital facilities also benefit from the “rental” of the Adobe Cloud and as such our students have access their to the newest upgrades of Adobe Photoshop and Lightroom. The ICP School meets and exceeds all of the needs and safety requirements mandated by NASAD, our external accrediting unit, and of our program. Since our last Program Review in 2008, many enhancements have been made within the existing space to avail students of adequate studio space and equipment in which to produce challenging work. A small lighting studio was set up in one of the smaller rooms in the Mezzanine area. This studio is equipped with a variety of professional lighting equipment, seamless papers and backdrops, strobes, soft-lights, and a Calumet 4x5 camera. In addition 3 new Epson 3880 photo ink jet printers were purchased and added to the existing 9800 printers in the 3rd and 4th floor of SJH. Room 316 in SJH, which is now used for photography classes and as a satellite working studio for BFA majors, is equipped with 5 Macs 2 scanners and 4 ink jet printers. Room 406A is now equipped with 1 Epson 3880 and 2 Epson 9800, 44” wide printers and 2 scanners. Since all of our majors are now provided with a Mac laptop in freshman year, and Adobe now rents their latest software from the “Cloud”, the need for more digital labs has greatly ceased since just about any classroom, especially in the newly built DeAngelo Hall can adequately be used for teaching with digital media. As the Department grows, however, more photography and illustration facilities will be needed, especially in the area of printing labs. Library and Learning Resources offered to the Photography Program The Library's collections in support of the Department of Art and Design include the following: 17,322 volumes of books (monographs) The Art Department subscribes to Art in America, Art News, Art Forum, Print, and other relevant magazines as well. These magazines are available in the Art Office for students and faculty. In addition, the library finances and supports the following on-line resources for the Department: Databases: Art Index (Wilson); Covers international articles on art from 1984 to present. Also indexes images. Art Retrospective (Wilson) ; Art journal indexing from 1929 to 1984. ARTstor; Repository of digital images of art, associated data, and user-friendly tools. Design & Applied Arts Index; The leading index for articles published in design and applied arts periodicals from 1973 onwards, covers new designers and the development of design and the applied arts since the mid-19th century. ProQuest Research Library; Includes full text of art and music journals such as Art in America, Afterimage, American Music, Music & Letters, and more. E-Reference Sources: Credo Reference: Art; Includes A Biographical Dictionary of Artists, Dictionary of 20th Century Design & Designers, and more. Oxford Art Online; Includes Grove Art Online, The Oxford Companion to Western Art, the Encyclopedia of Aesthetics, and The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Art Terms as well as nearly 6000 images of art and architecture. Oxford Reference Premium: Art; Includes The Dictionary of Modern Design, Dictionary of 20th Century Art, and more. Faculty work together with the Director of Collections, Mr. Andrew Sankowski and with Cynthia Chambers, in order to update the collection on a continual basis. Our art history faculty work closely with the library in order to maintain and evaluate resources. Self-Study Template 38 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q An exceptionally rare collection of the Library is one of exhibition catalogs dating back to 1949. This collection, which consists of approximately 9,000 holdings, has been set up this past year in the Reserve section so students and Faculty have access to its "treasures" for research purposes. The Department itself archives a slide/image collection that was in use through the 1990’s. Consisting of 10,607 slides, and over 20,000 images on electronic media, the collection, though rarely used in recent years, is archived in the department office. The newly organized Resource Room in the Mezz provides a small library of art and photography books for student use. Texts and books of interest are provided for students to do research and additional readings. Students may reserve access to the Resource Room during regular studio hours. The single greatest challenge faced by all the programs housed in the Department of Art and Design is the difficulty we have recruiting high achieving high school students because of the scattered nature of our facilities. A number of improvements have been requested and funded (as detailed elsewhere in this document) over the last five years and while necessary, these upgrades have simply served to patch and make workable a less than ideal situation. Our incoming freshman class benefits from top notch curricula and from working with professional New York based artists and designer educators but most of these students arrive to a campus where their classrooms are below the grade they experienced in high school. To be blunt, our facilities are undeniably lacking when compared to peer institutions and even to many community colleges in the New York metro area. What is missing is not simply specialized equipment, which we have been fairly successful in acquiring through funding from the Dean of St. John’s College, Capital Requests and even from donations, but the integrated art making spaces found at Art Schools and at other liberal arts universities housing art and design departments. We are fortunate that so many students and their parents have been able to overlook this deficiency and still choose to attend our program, but it is unlikely that we will be able to maintain strong numbers or continue to dramatically increase the number of incoming freshman without a substantial investment in infrastructure and facilities. The Department of Art and Design has made similar requests and the past and as stated elsewhere in this document we were slated to be moved to new space (in the old University Center) as part of the 2008 strategic plan. Unfortunately, the proposals outlined in the 2008 strategic plan failed to materialize and the designated space was used for administrative purposes. 6b. Narrative/ Supportive Physical Environment - Comment on level of faculty and student satisfaction with HVAC; faculty and student satisfaction with classroom lighting, crowdedness, and acoustics; flexible teaching environments, and faculty offices, etc.. (Suggested limit 1 page) The physical environment of all of our studios and offices suffer form being in the oldest building on campus, which often presents environmental and maintenance issues that are monumental to repair. The Department makes every effort, despite of the daily challenges of maintenance, to made sure that safety procedures are installed throughout the studios. Material Safety Data Sheets are kept in the Department office, each relevant studio, and posted on the web by the environmental safety unit of the university. Both the Department of Art and Design and the Operations Department of the University adhere to regular maintenance and cleaning schedules for studios and facilities. Studio assistants and Faculty are responsible for reporting broken equipment and/or situations that may require both immediate and long-term attention. SDS binders are now placed in each of the following studios: painting, printmaking and darkroom. SDS binders that provide information on Epson inks are kept in the Art and Design office and posted on the web. This summer, with the help of new Building manager, the studios were cleaned and ceiling pipe leaks for toilets in the Basement level, that presented health hazards to our students when they worked in the Mezzanine studios, Self-Study Template 39 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q were finally addressed and repaired. During the summer, the Mezzanine was also flooded by an air-conditioning compressor. This is one of many issues we face on a daily basis in St. John Hall. The Faculty offices have been greatly improved since 2002, but due to the lack of space, they are scattered throughout the Basement level of St. John Hall. Though we still often face issues of inadequate storage space for art supplies and student projects in progress, we have recently purchased flat file drawers for every faculty and strategically placed them in each studio where they are needed. The Department office has physically undergone some aesthetic improvements since 2012-13: several walls have been painted and student work now hangs appropriately throughout the art office. As previously mentioned, we have been working hard towards improving what we have and making the spaces as functional as possible. In an ideal world, however, our art Faculty, because of our University environment, should be assigned offices that allow for studio space. The Photography program uses two classrooms in Sullivan Hall (SUL 222) and (SUL 207) to teach software intensive classes. These classrooms are maintained by Information Technology. Hardware and software purchases as well as overall maintenance is overseen by IT. Ken Mahlmeister and his team have been extremely supportive and work to procure hardware and software necessary for teaching Graphic Design Photography classes. Recent hardware acquisitions have included new projectors in rooms 207 and 222, several new scanners in each room, one new duplexing 11X17 Laser printer (installed 2014) and one additional printer has been ordered and is will be installed later this semester. For the most part, the hardware needs of the program are currently being met under this system, however we are currently working with software (primarily the Adobe Creative Suite) that is 2.5 years out of date. Older software presents several challenges. First, students are unable to work with what is industry standard and what they are likely to find when they leave school and become employed as photographers, especially in the areas of retouching and video. Second most students have a subscription to the Creative Cloud (on their laptops) and going back and forth between current versions of the software and the outdated software in the Sullivan labs presents some issues because not all software is easily backwards compatible. The Department of Art and Design requested that Sullivan 222, 207 and the 1st Floor Macintosh labs be updated with Adobe’s Creative Cloud in 2013 and again in 2014. We are still in discussions with Information Technology regarding our request and hope installation of the Creative Cloud can be implemented in time for classes to begin in Fall 2015. Until this “upgrade” and access is achieved, we can no longer tell prospective students and their parents that St. John’s offers instruction in industry standard software, which is used at peer institutions as well as the SUNY and CUNY schools. While we are fortunate to have use of the Sullivan classrooms, having classes offered in two different locations on campus presents some challenges. Ideally the Macintosh labs/classrooms would be relocated to a centralized location either in St. John’s Hall or elsewhere so students could take all their classes in one building and would have access to integrated art and design making facilities comparable to those found at peer institutions. 6c. To what extent has the University funded major capital projects, e.g., renovations, which are linked directly to the program during the past five years? (Bulleted list) • Partially funded: Podium Technology in all Art Studio Classrooms During the summer of 2012 the art studios on the 3rd and 4th floors of SJH were upgraded to “Podium Classrooms,” making Internet access and digital technology available. The upgraded rooms include painting and drawing studios 404 and 405, the Illustration and Design studio located in room 303, and the digital printing room located in room 316. No podium technology was incorporated into the mezzanine art studios located in SJH or room 500 in SJH. Self-Study Template 40 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q • 100% funded: Security Upgrade Major security upgrade in the art studios located in SJH with the installation of security cameras and controlled access systems at all entrances to these studio areas. (see item 3b) • 100% funded: Furniture Upgrade and Replacement – Fine Arts Capital request for new painting easels, painting tables and a Rack System for Storing Paintings Vertically, Submitted in October 2012, funded June 2013. In 2014 tables and chairs in Rooms 303 and 316 were replaced with new, rolling tables which are better fit for studio use and greatly enhance these two rooms. • 100% funded: Mezzanine Renovations for Thesis Studio During the summer of 2014 the art studios located in the mezzanine level of SJH were renovated to include a dedicated studio workspace for students enrolled Art 4125 Creative Thesis. • Exhaust work totaling $200,000 has been approved, but it is yet to be determined what has been done and what still needs to be accomplished. Construction and Building Department have not yet communicated to us what these improvements entail nor have they provided us with a detailed plan of the exhaust and air-quality problems that they hope to resolve. 6d. If external data that describes the cost effectiveness of the program has been provided by your School/College Dean, please comment on the program’s cost-effectiveness. (Suggested limit 1 page) The chart below positively illustrates the cost effectiveness of the program: The photography program had a contribution margin/profit of $ 154,634 for the FY 2014. The direct expenses of this program are primarily the ICP tuition and the digital lab maintenance, which is shared by all four BFA programs. Standard 6. Additional comments if needed. (Suggested limit 1 page) In recent years the University has had a policy of enhancing programs that have a proven track record of attracting students. Majors and departments with strong enrollment have certainly benefited from this strategy, but in a time of systemic enrollment challenges, more innovative and forward thinking measures are called for. Enhancing programs (such as ours) with well-documented and fixable challenges would be advantageous and this strategy would provide additional revenue streams in a time overall lower enrollment. New York City has the greatest concentration of college students studying art, design and music found anywhere in the country. With its lack of integrated Art, Design and Music making facilities, St. John’s University takes itself out of the running for many of Self-Study Template 41 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q these students. In most cases high school students choose another school in the New York metro area and we loose the opportunity to share the collective knowledge of the Art and Design faculty and to engage student with the laudable goals of the University mission. The Department of Art and Design respectfully requests that the capital expenditure and space allocation outlined in the 2008 strategic plan be reinstated and that we move forward with a plan of increased recruitment bolstered by development of state of the art facilities similar to those found in other programs in the University. This year we also face a challenging problem in the area of facilities as we have a BFA major who is confined to a wheelchair. As we are making every effort possible to provide a comfortable and productive learning environment for this brilliant, young artist, several of our studios, such as Room 500, our Printmaking room, are not wheelchair accessible and the scattered nature of the studios overall makes it very difficult to navigate with a wheelchair or any other type of physical challenge. This alone, makes a valid case for the consideration of updated art facilities. STANDARD 7. Effective actions have been taken based on the findings of the last program review and plans have been initiated for the future. Comments: (Suggested limit 1page) As a result of the program review of 2009, effective action has been taken by the Department of Art and Design to upgrade the quality of the department’s facilities, curriculum and overall student engagement. The safety concerns in the mezzanine level and the 4th floor studios located in St. John’s Hall were addressed. The University funded the Department of Art and Design’s request for the installation of security cameras and controlled access systems at all entrances to the art studios located in these areas. (see item 3b) As part of the security systems enhancement, new fire doors were installed on the mezzanine level “Exit” doors that lead directly to the outside. These new doors only permit outside egress and prevent entrance. New fire doors were also installed on the 4th floor of St. John’s Hall replacing old doors that did not close properly. The Department of Art and Design in conjunction with Public Safety established a new protocol to control student access to the art studios during off-hours. (see item 3b) During the summer of 2014 the art studios located in the mezzanine level of SJH were renovated to include a dedicated studio workspace for students enrolled Art 4125 Creative Thesis. Typically only a few graphic design students choose the Thesis rather than the Internship class but for these students designated workspace will be a significant improvement. A new dedicated student exhibition space was established in the St. John’s College Office, Room 145 for the continuous display of art created by Department of Art and Design students. In our commitment to improve student engagement, and effort to maximize the senior thesis experience, in 2011 we extended the senior thesis course to include an exhibition in a professional New York City art gallery, the Dorsky Gallery. The senior thesis exhibition in an off campus NYC gallery has evolved into an annual event, and the experience engages students in every aspect of professional exhibition planning and participation, and has transformed the thesis course from a theoretical to a real world lesson. The department continues to aggressively explore ways to improve both its internship and thesis programs. Self-Study Template 42 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Initiated plans for future improvements The Department of Art and Design continues to explore ways to provide juniors and seniors with private, individual workstations, where they can work on advanced projects. This is an acute need that has also been cited in the “2010 NASAD Visitors Report.” To further enhance student engagement, the Department of Art and Design plans to increase its efforts in hosting student forums throughout the year that extend beyond the classroom. The University Gallery could be used as the setting for these student discussions and reading events, and other departments could also be invited to participate. The photography program faculty will work with to continue to develop new courses which are relevant to student learning and career options as well as continue to update relevant syllabi and curricula to more effectively address future career options. The Department of Art and Design continues to explore ways to create meaningful connections between program alumni and current students. To date, Department has adopted several measures aimed at this goal. A LinkedIn group which was developed in 2014 allows faculty and alumni to open post job and internship positions. Alumni also come back several times a semester to critique upper level student work. In the future we plan to expand these initiatives and offer networking events where current students can meet alumni working in the field and hopefully make connections, which will survive post graduation. We also plan to work with career services to and the LinkedIn group to more effectively connect students and recent alumni to job openings in their field of study. The Department of Art and Design is committed to serving transfer students and minors as well as the majority of students who enter our undergraduate programs as freshman. To this end, the Department has worked with the Office of Transfer Student Services to create advising procedures for incoming transfer students and has revised the list of courses eligible for transfer credit in some programs. In the future the Department of Art and Design will continue to monitor transfer student progress and make adjustments to our requirements and advising practices as needed. The curriculum for all minors offered by the Department were updated so they now require 18 (rather than 21) credits. Several programs have made significant revisions to the minor structure to better serve students who come from different areas of study within the University. The updates have been completed but many students are not aware of the changes. In the future, the Department will work to publicize the five minors offered and will continue to monitor how students progress through the new sequences of course offerings. Inadequate facilities remain our biggest challenge when it comes to recruiting and retaining high quality art and design students. Moving forward, the Department of Art and Design will continue to make request for integrated art and design making spaces. In the absence of large-scale capital improvements, each program in the Department will work to make the best use of existing space and to implement small scale updates of technology and equipment that will improve the student experience and maintain high quality instruction. Relevant to the Photography program are integrated analog and digital studio with critique rooms, lighting studios, and printing labs with capacity for 15 students to print simultaneously, such as available in peer institutions. Self-Study Template 43 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q Self-Study Template 44 LAS_FA_PHOTO_BFA_Q