Teaching tips Advice for the classroom © 2014 Commonwealth of Australia through the Australian Government Department of Education. This material may be used, reproduced in material form and communicated free of charge for non-commercial educational purposes until 31 December 2018, provided all copyright notices and acknowledgements are retained. How to build executive functions in the classroom If you are a classroom teacher, how can you strategically approach the development of executive function in your students? While there are a number of books and programmes that you can investigate, you can go a long way just by tweaking the kinds of things you already do in the classroom. Valuing the executive functions The first thing you can do with a group of students is introduce the executive functions and begin a discussion about what they mean and how they affect everyone's lives. This is a quick way to demonstrate that you value these concepts and want to apply them in a classroom context. You can extend this by referring to the executive functions throughout your teaching: pointing out the situations in which students or other people need to inhibit their impulses, discussing task demands in terms of working memory and looking at difficulties through the lens of mental flexibility. Executive function is so fundamental to human endeavour that you once you know about it, you see it everywhere. As a teacher you will have no trouble finding links between executive function and school work. Making students stop and think Impulse inhibition is essential for directed focus and sustained action. You can help students with these forms of impulse inhibition in any context. Maintaining focus Acknowledge that we all have wandering minds, especially when working on something difficult or boring. Rather than blaming students for having poor willpower, help them take a strategic approach to managing their attention. This includes helping students notice that their attention has wandered, encouraging them to remove distractions in the environment, and finding ways to make the task easier or more interesting. Sustaining action Nobody really likes to struggle, so when the going gets tough, most people do something else. It’s a lot easier for a struggling student to give up than it is for them to engage with their tasks and continue the long slog to mastery. You can help students reflect on the moments when they want to quit, find ways in which they might persist, and find alternative paths to a solution. © 2014 Commonwealth of Australia through the Australian Government Department of Education. This material may be used, reproduced in material form and communicated free of charge for non-commercial educational purposes until 31 December 2018, provided all copyright notices and acknowledgements are retained. 2 Prompting second thoughts In Daniel Kahneman's book Thinking, fast and slow he highlighted two thought systems: the first system is fast, which is based on human instinct and emotion. The second system is slow, which is based on a considered, logical response. When you ask students to put their hands up to answer a question (especially an open question), you might ask for their first thoughts. Once you have collected those responses, you might ask for their second thoughts, which is their slow, more considered response. After you have done this you could ask the students to explain how they came to their first and second thoughts. Problem-based learning Students need direct instruction and repeated practice in order to cement basic skills. There is no doubt that direct instruction and repeated practice are critical teaching tools that are more or less engaging. But direct instruction tends to focus on situations with one right answer and ignores open-ended problems. Open-ended problems are a powerful way to put students in a situation where they have to stop and think, pay close attention, weigh multiple factors and consider alternative perspectives and options in order to formulate a response. They also provide a rich context in which students can think about their own thinking. Resources for developing problem-based learning experiences Into the classroom is part of the Government of South Australia's Leading learning resource and links to some great videos about problem-based learning. Dan Meyer is an American maths teacher who has developed a deep expertise in problem-based learning. His blog is full of examples and discussion. Ambiguity and risk While schools are often very good at encouraging students to be conservative, both in terms of managing their behaviour and of producing work that meets set criteria, we are often not as good at teaching students how to calculate risk and take action in an ambiguous environment. Students should be encouraged to look at many things in terms of risk and reward, to predict positive and negative outcomes, and to develop ways of managing those risks. This doesn't just apply to physically dangerous activities like climbing a tree, but also to social, intellectual and emotional situations. People intuitively calculate risk all the time – if this process is brought to our attention then we have the opportunity to intervene or improve it. Gever Tulley's book 50 dangerous things (you should let your children do) is an excellent discussion on the topic of teaching children active risk management. © 2014 Commonwealth of Australia through the Australian Government Department of Education. This material may be used, reproduced in material form and communicated free of charge for non-commercial educational purposes until 31 December 2018, provided all copyright notices and acknowledgements are retained. 3 Increasing the challenge To increase a challenge for a student, we often respond by providing more advanced work, such as more advanced maths problems or more difficult texts. But neurologically this runs the risk of being 'more of the same but different'. An alternative approach is to ask questions or provide tasks which help students explore deeper or broader aspects of the problem, for instance asking them to find patterns, establish cause and effect relationships or make comparisons with unrelated problems or topics. Asking the right questions Bringing it to life is part of the Government of South Australia's Leading learning resource and has a good framework for asking the kinds of questions that lead to higher levels of cognitive demand. Not just for the smart kids It's important that all students spend time grappling with open-ended problems, ambiguity and other challenges. This is irrespective of academic ability. Executive function precedes academic achievement, which makes it even more important to give struggling students the opportunity to stretch their thinking. A key step as a teacher is to realise that even the simplest pieces of content can be rich grounds for exploration. You don't need complicated or high-level subject matter to challenge your students. All you need is a willingness to look closely, ask fundamental questions and encourage students to explore and share their thinking with you. Resources Related support guides on the myfuture website Support strategies Serious play Supporting worksheets available on the myfuture website Developing good controls Breaking bad habits My assignment game plan My assignment timetable Problem solving planner Websites 'Into the classroom' Leading learning, Department for Education and Child Development (SA) http://www.acleadersresource.sa.edu.au/index.php?page=into_the_classroom © 2014 Commonwealth of Australia through the Australian Government Department of Education. This material may be used, reproduced in material form and communicated free of charge for non-commercial educational purposes until 31 December 2018, provided all copyright notices and acknowledgements are retained. 4 'Bringing it to life' Leading learning, Department for Education and Child Development (SA) http://www.acleadersresource.sa.edu.au/index.php?page=bringing_it_to_life Dan Meyer's blog, http://blog.mrmeyer.com Books Daniel Kahneman's 2011 book, Thinking, fast and slow Gever Tulley's book, 50 dangerous things (you should let your children do) http://www.fiftydangerousthings.com Sources of information Department for Education and Child Development, 2013, Leading learning, Government of South Australia, http://www.acleadersresource.sa.edu.au Alloway, TP 2010, Improving working memory: supporting students' learning, Sage Publications, California Bodrova, E & Leong, DJ 2007, Tools of the mind (2nd edn), Pearson/Merrill Prentice Hall, NJ Dawson, P & Guare, R 2010, Executive skills in children and adolescents: a practical guide to assessment and intervention, The Guilford Press, New York Diamond, A & Lee, K 2011, 'Interventions shown to aid executive function development in children 4 to 12 years old', Science, 333(6045), 959–964 Gathercole, S & Alloway, TP 2008, Working memory and learning: a practical guide for teachers, Sage Publications, California Kahneman, D 2012, Thinking, fast and slow, Penguin books, United Kingdom Kaufman, C 2010, Executive function in the classroom: practical strategies for improving performance and enhancing skills for all students, Brookes Publishing Company, Baltimore Meltzer, L 2010, Promoting executive function in the classroom, The Guilford Press, New York © 2014 Commonwealth of Australia through the Australian Government Department of Education. This material may be used, reproduced in material form and communicated free of charge for non-commercial educational purposes until 31 December 2018, provided all copyright notices and acknowledgements are retained. 5