DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND CHILDREN’S SERVICES Unit plan Name C2 C English Year Level 8 Teacher Unit 1 Class Duration 5 weeks Teen representation in new media texts Unit Outline In this unit students listen to, read and view a variety of multimodal news media texts, including digital texts. They explore representations of teens in the texts to produce close readings of excerpts selected from them. Curriculum intent: Content descriptions Language/Cultural Considerations Teaching Strategies Language Literature Literacy Language for interaction Understand how rhetorical devices are used to persuade and how different layers of meaning are developed through the use of metaphor, irony and parody Responding to literature Understand and explain how combinations of words and images in texts are used to represent particular groups in society, and how texts position readers in relation to those groups These are areas where EAL/D students can be actively drawn into conversations, demonstrating varying values and viewpoints, and discussing country, identity and culture. Use students as a resource to deepen this discussion if they are happy to participate. Recognise, and explain differing viewpoints about the world, cultures, individual people and concerns represented in texts Intertextuality relies upon the audience sharing cultural capital with the author. EAL/D students may not have seen/read/heard many of the texts that teachers assume will be well known. If there are intertextual references, ensure that all students have seen the reference in its original form and Texts in context Analyse and explain how language has evolved over time and how technology and the media have influenced language use and forms of communication EAL/D students may not be able to show the depth of their understanding if they are required to respond in extended written or spoken text. Provide alternative methods of explaining this information, such as graphic organisers, a teacher interview, or creation of a multimedia response. Metaphor, irony and parody are all elements of language that are used once a firm grounding of language, its nuances and its manipulation can be understood. EAL/D students may not have had sufficient time in English culture to understand the English interpretations of these. Text structure and organisation Analyse how the text structures and language features of persuasive texts, including media texts, vary according to the medium and mode of communication The nuances inherent in certain words will not necessarily be understood by EAL/D students. Students in the Beginning and Emerging phases of English language learning will be developing a repertoire of C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 1 of 14 Interacting with others Interpret the stated and implied meanings in spoken texts, and use evidence to support or challenge different perspectives Many cultures do not expect students to challenge texts. The writer is seen as ‘expert’. In some cultures, challenging viewpoints is a dangerous activity. This means that some students may experience difficulty and/or reticence in both challenging perspectives and in justifying this opinion. www.det.nt.gov.au everyday vocabulary rather than investigating nuanced language. Use spoken activities to model such language choices and to allow students the opportunities to use these language structures before writing. Use vocabulary building exercises such as word clines to consider the emotional effect and strength of certain words against others. Use everyday vocabulary as headings under which students can write alternative words, accompanied by a symbol (such as a + or –) to show whether these carry positive or negative connotations. Enable students in the Beginning and Emerging phases of English language learning to use more simplistic vocabulary until they have mastered this. Understand how cohesion in texts is improved by strengthening the internal structure of paragraphs through the use of examples, quotations and substantiation of claims The appropriateness of quoting sources and the use of punctuation differ from culture to culture. Explicitly model the conventions around the use of examples, quotation and substantiation of claims. Understand how coherence is created in complex texts through devices like lexical cohesion, ellipsis, grammatical theme and text connectives Cohesive devices such as lexical chains and ellipsis require developed academic language. EAL/D students in the Beginning and Emerging phases of English language learning will be using simple cohesive devices until they have developed sufficient skills to use these. Allow opportunities for oral activities that develop these skills. Enlarge a section of text and highlight cohesive devices (using different colours). Note that lexical cohesion also works on subtle cultural levels. For example, some may find a clear relationship between ‘popcorn’ and ‘movie’, while others may not. Give students in the Beginning and Emerging phases of English language learning the opportunity to practice simple cohesive devices before requiring them to engage in more advanced activities. then explicitly show the links between texts. Interpreting, analysing, evaluating Analyse and evaluate the ways that text structures and language features vary according to the purpose of the text and the ways that referenced sources add authority to a text This is an opportunity for useful work around language, its structure and its meanings for EAL/D students. Explicitly address these structures, language features and purposes. Apply increasing knowledge of vocabulary, text structures and language features to understand the content of texts Use comprehension strategies to interpret and evaluate texts by reflecting on validity of content and the credibility of sources, including finding evidence in the text for the author’s point of view EAL/D students will be at different points on the EAL/D learning progression so comprehension Identify EAL/D students’ levels of reading comprehension and provide support as appropriate. Introduce new comprehension strategies, such as inferring, using explicit teaching around familiar texts.strategies should not be assumed. Explore and explain the ways authors combine different modes and media in creating texts, and the impact of these choices on the viewer/listener Creating texts Experiment with text structures and language features to refine and clarify ideas to improve the effectiveness of students’ own texts In order to edit, students need to have the linguistic resources to identify mistakes. Errors are usually indicative of students’ positions on the EAL/D learning progression and reflect what they have yet to learn. Provide opportunities for peer editing or editing with the Expressing and developing ideas Analyse and examine how effective authors control and use a variety of clause structures, including clauses C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland Modal verbs tend to be acquired late in the EAL/D learning progression and are an important feature of effective academic writing. When introducing the task, explain that this is culturally acceptable in Australia and show public examples (such as editorials) where this occurs regularly. Provide models for how this response can be structured, including the language features required. Give extra support around modal verbs. 2 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au embedded within the structure of a noun group/phrase or clause Students in the Beginning and Emerging phases of English language learning still trying to master simple clause structures will find this task difficult. Punctuation differs from language to language, and some languages have no punctuation. Ensure that students have a firm understanding of simple clauses and sentences before attempting to explain complex sentences that contain embedded clauses. Explicitly model the punctuation required for an embedded clause, and explain that this is an easy way for students to identify such clauses. Understand the effect of nominalisation in the writing of informative and persuasive texts Nominalisation removes the person or thing responsible for the action and leaves information in an abstract form, for example, ‘evaporation’ refers to the process by which a liquid is turned into vapour. This may be confusing for some EAL/D students in the Beginning, Emerging and Developing phases of English language learning. Provide charts that show the process and the nominalised form side by side (for example the process of turning liquid into vapour – evaporation), and encourage students to translate these words into their first language where possible. Investigate how visual and multimodal texts allude to or draw on other texts or images to enhance and layer meaning Intertextuality relies upon the audience sharing cultural capital with the author. EAL/D students may not have seen/read/heard many of the texts that teachers assume will be well known. If there are intertextual references, ensure that all students have seen the reference in its original form and then explicitly show the links between texts. Recognise that vocabulary choices contribute to the specificity, abstraction and style of texts This is an area where teachers can give great insights into language choice for EAL/D students. Consider texts in English and across curriculum areas, and how language becomes more abstract as it becomes more academic. Unpack these abstractions, C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland teacher which can be informative activities for EAL/D students. Photocopy or print out their work, cut up the sentences and investigate together what effects can be created by manipulating the sentence or word order. 3 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au modelling thought processes to assist EAL/D students to understand how these can be understood. General Capabilities and Cross-curriculum priorities Literacy Students will develop skills in: Text knowledge: comprehend texts through listening, viewing and reading Text knowledge: compose texts through writing and creating Grammar knowledge: understand and create texts using text features and grammar Visual knowledge: understand and interpret visual knowledge. Information and Communication Technology (ICT) capability Students will develop skills in: Investigating with ICT to select appropriate and efficient sources of digital information in response to identified needs, inquiries and research questions. Critical and creative thinking Students will develop skills in: inquiring through identifying, exploring and clarifying information generating innovative ideas and possibilities analyse, evaluate and synthesise information reflecting on thinking, actions and processes Personal and social capability Students will develop skills in: social awareness: identify and understand others’ emotions and viewpoints social management: use listening skills, cooperate and communicate effectively with others cooperate and communicate effectively with others. Relevant prior curriculum Students require prior experience with: analysing how point of view is generated in visual texts by means of choices, for example gaze, angle and social distance comparing the ways that language and images are used to create characters, and to influence emotions and opinions in different types of texts analysing and explaining the ways text structures and language features shape meaning and vary according to audience and purpose using comprehension strategies to interpret, analyse and synthesise ideas and information, critiquing ideas and issues from a variety of textual sources comparing the text structures and language features of multimodal texts, explaining how they combine to influence audiences. C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 4 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Curriculum working towards The teaching and learning in this unit works towards the following in Year 9: comparing and evaluating a range of representations of individuals and groups in different historical, social and cultural contexts analysing and explaining how text structures, language features and visual features of texts and the context in which texts are experienced may influence audience response evaluating the social, moral and ethical positions represented in texts analysing and evaluating how people, cultures, places, events, objects and concepts are represented in texts, including media texts, through language, structural and/or visual choices. Supportive learning environment Differentiation What do your learners already know, do and value? Where do the learners need and want to be? How do the learners best learn? Consider the individual needs and values of all students, including EAL/D, Gifted and Talented and Special Needs, and provide learning experiences that are accessible to and respectful of the diversity of students’ cultural backgrounds. Start from where your students are at and differentiate teaching and learning to support the learning needs of all students. Plan and document how you will cater for individual learning needs. The learning experiences within this unit can be differentiated by increasing the: frequency of exposure for some students intensity of teaching by adjusting the group size duration needed to complete tasks and assessment. For guided and/or independent practice tasks: student groupings will offer tasks with a range of complexities to cater for individual learning needs rotational groupings that allow for more or less scaffolding of student learning. Feedback How will I inform learners and others about the learner’s progress? Feedback is information and advice provided by a teacher, peer, parent or self about aspects of someone’s performance. The aim of feedback is to improve learning and is used to plan what to do next and how to teach it. Teachers and students use feedback to close the gap between where students are and where they aim to be. Teachers use self-feedback to guide and improve their teaching practice. Establish active feedback partnerships between students, teachers and parents to find out: what each student already knows and can do how each student is going where each student needs to go next. C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 5 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Ensure feedback is timely, ongoing, instructive and purposeful. Feedback may relate to reading, writing and speaking throughout the unit. In this unit this may include: students’ analysis and synthesis of how words and images are used and combined in news articles to position readers students’ use of specific vocabulary and complex sentences to construct paragraph responses students’ use of inferential comprehension strategies, including three level guide, main idea and inferring meaning, to gain an understanding of texts beyond literal meaning students’ ability to evaluate texts and reflect on the credibility of sources and validity of their content, particularly texts located on the internet students’ capacity to respond in full and to justify their responses to questions by incorporating quotes or evidence from texts. Use feedback to inform future teaching and learning. Reflection on the unit plan Identify what worked well during and at the end of the unit for future planning. Reflection may include: activities that worked well and why activities that could be improved and how monitoring and assessment that worked well and why monitoring and assessment that could be improved and how common errors that need, or needed, to be addressed (e.g. grammar, spelling, punctuation) differentiation and future student learning needs. Assessment How will I check the learners have made progress? Assessment is the purposeful, systematic and ongoing collection of information as evidence for use in making judgments about student learning. Principals, teachers and students use assessment information to support improving student learning. Feedback from evaluation of assessment data helps to determine strengths and weaknesses in students’ understanding. Students should contribute to an individual assessment folio that provides evidence of their learning and represents their achievements over the year. The folio should include a range and balance of assessments for teachers to make valid judgments about whether the student has met the achievement standard. Refer to Year level plan for more assessment information. Monitoring student learning Student learning should be monitored throughout the teaching and learning process to determine student progress and learning needs. Each lesson provides opportunities to present and gather feedback about how students are going and where they need to go to next. Specific monitoring opportunities in this unit include: Work samples Collect and check samples of student work to assess their ability to: interpret and analyse how combinations of words and images in news media texts are used to represent particular groups in society use comprehension strategies to interpret and evaluate texts use specific vocabulary and complex sentences that incorporate examples and quotations from texts. C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 6 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Assessing student learning Reading comprehension task — Close readings in response to unseen questions about news media texts Students write short responses to a reading comprehension task based on two news media articles. Note: The news media articles used in this task are about Jessica Watson and her solo circumnavigation voyage. As the task is unseen, it is important that articles relating to this topic are not explored in the body of the unit. This assessment provides opportunities to gather evidence of student learning in: Language Text structure and organisation Understand how cohesion in texts is improved by strengthening the internal structure of paragraphs through the use of examples, quotations and substantiation of claims Literature Responding to literature Understand and explain how combinations of words and images in texts are used to represent particular groups in society, and how texts position readers in relation to those groups Literacy Interpreting, analysing, evaluating Analyse and evaluate the ways that text structures and language features vary according to the purpose of the text and the ways that referenced sources add authority to a text Use comprehension strategies to interpret and evaluate texts by reflecting on the validity of content and the credibility of sources including finding evidence in the text for the author’s point of view Sequencing teaching and learning What will constitute the learning journey and what are the contexts for learning? Who does what? What do my students already know and can do? What do my students need to learn? How do I teach it? The relationship between what is taught and how it is taught is critical in maximising student learning. Start with what your students already know and set goals for the next steps for learning. Decide how to provide multiple opportunities for all students to explore and consolidate ideas, skills and concepts by considering how students learn best and by using a variety of teaching strategies. Teaching strategies and learning experiences A suggested teaching and learning sequence is outlined below. For further information about learning focuses and teaching strategies, refer to the lesson overview and lesson plans. C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 7 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Exploring news media Conceptualising news media Portraying teenagers in news media texts Positioning the reader Understanding news media texts Reading visual texts Reviewing, revising and extending Layers of meaning in news media texts Interpreting stated and implied meanings Finding main idea in written and spoken texts Text and language features The language features of news media texts Modelled and independent paragraph construction Examples, quotations and substantiation of claims Applying knowledge of news media texts Reading comprehension assessment Making judgements How do I know how well my students have learned? Teachers and students use standards to judge the quality of learning based on the available evidence. The process of judging and evaluating the quality of performance and depth of learning is important to promoting learning. Teachers identify the task-specific assessable elements to make judgements against specified standards on evidence. Achievement standard In this unit, monitoring and assessment of student learning aligns to the following components of the Achievement standard. Receptive modes (listening, reading and viewing) By the end of Year 8, students understand how the selection of text structures is influenced by the selection of language mode and how this varies for different purposes and audiences. Students explain how language features, images and vocabulary are used to represent different ideas and issues in texts. Students interpret texts, questioning the reliability of sources of ideas and information. They select evidence from the text to show how events, situations and people can be represented from different viewpoints. They listen for and identify different emphases in texts, using that understanding to elaborate upon discussions. Productive modes (speaking, writing and creating) Students understand how the selection of language features can be used for particular purposes and effects. They explain the effectiveness of language choices they use to influence the audience. Through combining ideas, images and language features from other texts, students show how ideas can be expressed in new ways. Students create texts for different purposes, selecting language to influence audience response. They make presentations and contribute actively to class and group discussions, using language patterns for effect. When creating and editing texts to create specific effects, they take into account intended purposes and the needs and C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 8 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au interests of audiences. They demonstrate understanding of grammar, select vocabulary for effect and use accurate spelling and punctuation. Lesson overviews Exploring news media Conceptualising news media (1 of 3) Portraying teenagers in news media texts (2 of 3) Positioning the reader (3 of 3) Share knowledge of communication mediums for news media texts Identify and make distinctions between breaking news (news reports) and feature articles (opinion/intent) Identify and explore a range of multi-model media texts, including digital and print texts (e.g. newspaper and magazine); television news media, online news media (including ‘real time’ news streaming) and social networking texts Skim media texts to interpret how words and images are used to represent teenagers, and how texts position readers in relation to teens Define key terms — for example teenager, adolescent, youth (word sets; collocation/close association words) Sort source articles according to level of perceived bias by skimming and scanning (gender, cultural, social/socioeconomic, race, age) Identify the language of appraisal (negative, positive or neutral) Skim titles and subheadings, images, captions, topic sentences Compare and contrast sample news media texts to work on key identifiers (gender differences; age differences; socio-economic factors) Scan language features (e.g. loaded adjectives, subjective descriptions, themes) Distinguish between ‘hard’ news (breaking news; current affairs) and ‘soft’ or social/entertainment news (e.g. celebrity) Define relevant terms including portmanteau (blended) words Differentiation Resources Article — Hoodies, louts, scum: how media demonises teenagers C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 9 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Concept map — Inspiration software or Web 2.0 concept mapping tool (e.g. bubble.us) Website ― English for students: Portmanteau words Sheet — PMI chart Websites BBC skillwise — Skimming factsheet, quiz and worksheet BBC news school report: Glossary of common media terms BBC skillwise — Scanning factsheet, quiz, game and worksheet Media awareness network: How to detect bias in the news Exploring news media: Source, and create multiple sets of a variety of current news media examples, of interest to students, from a range of print and electronic media. Sources may include: Courier Mail, and The Australian newspaper ABC, SBS and Channel 9 news and Channel 10 news Behind the News Sky news, Wot news and Yahoo! news Headline spot: Top stories Time for kids Blogs — National Geographic (Scroll down near the bottom of the page to locate blogs) Source a range of news articles that include positive and negative stories about teenagers. Articles selected should allow students to identify the ways in which authors use words and images to position readers. Articles (from current and historical sources that include a range of topics and perspectives (e.g. gender bias, Indigenous perspective)) should be selected. These may be sourced from: Website — Aboriginal Australia resources — Newspapers (includes links to news articles that provide an Indigenous perspective) Website — South-East Advertiser (includes links to local and regional news articles) Website — BBC news school report: Useful links Source articles with headlines that: use puns and play on words. For example, Monday morning sports pages show evidence of metaphor and irony in information texts. 8–10 sets of sample news media texts for group work. (Include two common articles in each set and pre-determine how the reader is positioned in each.) Source radio and television news audio clips, video and transcripts. Sources may include: ABC radio national (search ‘teenagers’) Helpful information — Access to computers is required Instructions for how to use Inspiration software C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 10 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Writing studio: Close reading/reading to write Stewart and Kowaltzke 2008, Media new ways and meanings (3rd edition), John Wiley & Sons, Australia. Understanding news media texts Reading visual texts Make inferences about what is on the page Read and analyse photographs Use strategies to interpret and make connections with visual texts Consolidate concepts from week one and two, including the following: positioning the reader reading visual texts. language of appraisal. Differentiation Resources Understanding news media texts Sets of photographs from news media texts (4 sets of 6–7 photographs) Photocopy a class set of: Reading a photograph or picture — 10 elements to consider taken from A Visual Literacy Unit for Students in Years 7 and 8 by Annette Moult Sheet — Think, pair share Helpful information — Websites MyRead: Three level guide C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 11 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Instructional strategies online: What is think, pair, share? TeacherVision: Question-Answer Relationships Layers of meaning in news media texts Interpreting stated and implied meanings (1 and 2 of 3) Finding the main idea in spoken and written texts (3 of 3) Interpret and evaluate texts using the comprehension strategies: Summarise and synthesise main ideas from sample news media texts making connections — text to self, text to world and text to text Identify and explain the use of past, present and future tense in news media texts three level guide — to improve students’ literal, inferential and applied comprehension with print and images. Examine how modality is used in persuasive texts to ‘soften’ and ‘strengthen’ language for different purposes Make three level guides from a variety of news media texts. Differentiation Resources Poster — Using connections Film clip — Science student wears unwashed jeans for 15 months Photocopy a class set of a current story, published in two mediums — a digital form and a traditional print form — onto A3 paper Sheet — Venn diagram Article ― A sporting star is born by Zane Bojack (ABC Grandstand) Organise two sets of two different news media texts — short online or print articles containing a photo. Choose a front page of an online news media website and create a print screen or digital copy. Create a three level guide ‘model’ for the page. Access to a computer lab or a digital projector and screen required. (If using computers, upload sheets and links resources to a class project room.) Helpful information http://www.qsa.qld.edu.au/ Comprehension strategies and activities for Years 1–9 (September 2010), Queensland Studies Authority TeacherVision: Question-Answer Relationships Reading Quest: Question-Answer Relationships MyRead: Strategies for teaching reading in the middle years ― How to get them there http://www.qsa.qld.edu.au/: Comprehension strategies and activities for Years 1–9 (September 2010), Queensland Studies Authority — Locating the main idea in texts — p. C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 12 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au 10–18 Text and language features The language features of news media texts (1 of 4) Modelled and independent paragraph construction (2 and 3 of 4) Examples, quotations and substantiation of claims (4 of 4) Use the 321:RIQ process to reflect on learning o nominalisation Apply the TEEing process to structure paragraphs — using: Revise the use of quotation marks and reference quoted text Consider the role of quotations in news media texts o noun groups o text cohesion (including examples, quotations and substantiations of claims) Write written responses using evidence from the text (e.g. providing examples and quotations) o embedded clauses o nominalisation Identify and compare the language features and structures of written and spoken news media texts, specifically: o active and passive voice Practise grammar, sentence structure, spelling and punctuation skills Differentiation Resources Source 2–3 examples of print news media texts in which the layout and language features are persuasive. Source examples of written and spoken news media texts. Source may be located from, or include: Website — Happy News Website — YouTube C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 13 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au Helpful information ― Sheet — Quotation marks Applying knowledge of news media texts Assessment: Reading comprehension (1 and 2 of 2) Complete assessment task Reflect on learning as a result of completing the unit Differentiation Resources Display Before, during and after reading’ prompts in the classroom Helpful information Complete the assessment prior to the lesson to develop an understanding of the task requirements. References http://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/ Australian Curriculum Version 3.0 dated 23 January 2012 https://portal.ntschools.net/SITES/LEARNINGLINKS/default.aspx http://www.scootle.edu.au/ec/p/home C2C adapted with permission by NT DET © The State of Queensland 14 of 14 www.det.nt.gov.au