The benefits of the Extended Project Qualification Higher education guide Date of publication September 2014 About this guide This guide has been produced by Dr Abigail Harrison Moore, Head of School, School of Fine Art, History of Art and Cultural Studies, at the University of Leeds. Russell Group universities are committed to the highest levels of academic excellence in both teaching and research. Leeds University is one of the UK’s top ten research institutions and is well recognised internationally as a centre of excellence. The guide is packed with useful insight, hints and tips and exemplifies what a leading university regards as important information to consider for A-level Art and Design students wishing to progress onto Art and Design/Art History degree courses. Why is the Extended Project Qualification valuable to students considering art and design/art history at university? The Extended Project Qualification (EPQ) has been growing in popularity amongst students, teachers and university admissions tutors for the last few years. It is at the heart of some of the changes being proposed by the UK Government to secondary education. Staff in universities, particularly the research universities, have identified it as a useful way of demonstrating important skills for transition to higher education, such as skills in writing, referencing, critical research, analysis, communication and presentation. It encourages you to become an independent researcher. We hope the guide will help you to bring out the best in your students. Please be aware: the particular requirements of each university, and each course, are different. the guide is relevant to both AS and A-level Art and Design, but does not contain mandatory teaching content. This is featured in the AQA qualification specification. This guide aims to help you understand what the EPQ is, will think about some of the ways you can meet the qualifications’ requirements and will indicate why it is useful for your university applications. There are many really helpful activities and courses offered by universities to help you through your EPQ, such as the ‘Skills at Library’ web resources (library.leeds.ac.uk/skills) that we encourage you to use. AQA Education (AQA) is a registered charity (number 1073334) and a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales (number 3644723). Our registered address is AQA, Devas Street, Manchester M15 6EX. University of Leeds Higher education guide: Extended Project Qualification The best way to access such resources is to go to the university web pages and follow the links, and they are often located on the university library pages or the education engagement/teacher’s resources pages. There are also some short films available, made by the University of Leeds with AQA, on different research skills, developed as a part of our EPQ project that you can find on You Tube and at www.leeds.ac.uk/info/125097/activities_for _schools_and_colleges/1939/teachers_re sources A closer look at the EPQ Students can opt to either complete a 56000 word piece of independent, research informed writing, or they can produce a ‘product’ plus a 1000 word analysis of the research process and the questions that the product helps to address. This product could be an art work or a series of art works, but also could be a film, a performance, a design object etc. All students need to complete a ‘production log’ which helps them demonstrate both their research process and them thinking critically about their research subject, and a ‘presentation’ which addresses the questions asked, the research undertaken and the lessons learnt. For Art and Design and Art History students, the EPQ offers an excellent way to test university study, in the fact that it demands that you use the same skills you need to demonstrate in your applications, interviews and portfolio inspections and as an undergraduate student. It demands that you develop an independent research question, review the literature on your subject, critically analyse your research and produce an extended piece of fully referenced writing. Whether you choose the product route or not, you will have a chance to experience what university study is like, and assess whether or not it is for you. What does a good EPQ look for? A good EPQ demands that you independently identify your project and produce an effective design and thorough plan. This starts with finding a subject that really engages you and one that you think will provide you with enough research sources but not so many that you cannot find your way through them. Remember 5-6000 words is actually quite a small word count, although it may be the longest piece of writing you have done so far, and so you have to find a subject that will enable you to show your ability to analyse in depth within the word count.. You will also be tested on your ability to carry out a project in a highly organised fashion, which is great practice for when you are writing essays at university. Throughout your EPQ you need to use a wide range of resources critically, analyse data effectively where appropriate and apply your findings to good effect. This means that you need to start by assessing the research field in which your topic is located, looking at both primary and secondary sources, and comparing your research materials to test and analyse them and to show clear links between your sources of information and AQA Education (AQA) is a registered charity (number 1073334) and a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales (number 3644723). Our registered address is AQA, Devas Street, Manchester M15 6EX. 2 of 6 University of Leeds Higher education guide: Extended Project Qualification the themes of your project. Ultimately you have to be able to fully explore the complexities of your topic, identify problems and/or issues, and address them. You will be able to do this in the extended essay, the production log and as part of your final presentation. While you are carrying out your full, indepth evaluations, you will need to demonstrate a high level of insight into how you conducted the project and the limitations of the resources at your disposal. By the time you have finished your EPQ, you will have a deep and extensive knowledge of your area of study, will be able to communicate this to a range of audiences and will be able to answer questions. Think about an exhibition you have visited, a film you have seen, or an article you have read, and try to develop a research question. technical skills, and a better way of communicating your ideas. You need, however, to think carefully about this decision and discuss it in detail with your supervisor and/or EPQ Centre Coordinator. DO NOT choose this route simply because it means you can write less! As our practice-led PhD students know, it is much harder to demonstrate the rigorousness of your research and the depth of your thought in a shorter word count. You have to meet the same expectations for research, referencing, criticality and an awareness of your process in the ‘product’ version. This route offers a really exciting and interesting way to do this but it will not be assessed simply on the finished product. The most amazing design in the world will not receive a high grade if the student has not demonstrated the research and thinking process that produced it. Think about projects that you have already completed either at school or at home. Do you find it easier to express yourself in words or through your creativity? Which version of the EPQ should students choose? What are the implications of doing the ‘product’ version? For creative students the ‘product’ version might offer a more effective way for you to demonstrate your independence of thought, research interests, criticality and What sort of research did you do before you developed the project? Did you enjoy the process of turning your research into an artwork, design, film, game performance, etc? If so, this version of the EPQ may be for you. AQA Education (AQA) is a registered charity (number 1073334) and a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales (number 3644723). Our registered address is AQA, Devas Street, Manchester M15 6EX. 3 of 6 University of Leeds Higher education guide: Extended Project Qualification How to do you develop an effective research question that demonstrates your independence of thought? While your EPQ should acknowledge and reference the work of others, it should not just duplicate or paraphrase what has been written in the field. You should aspire to present an original piece of work. This does not imply that you are expected to develop new terminologies, methodologies and theories – even though you are encouraged to critically and creatively engage with existing ones – but rather to show that you have a good grasp of your subject’s main concepts, theories and analytical criteria and can make use of them. There are various easy ways to strive for originality Avoid broad and generic subjects, for example, ‘Art and Propaganda’, ‘Women in Art’, ‘The work of Pablo Picasso’ etc. If you try to do too much, you will run the risk of writing a superficial EPQ and you are bound to include sweeping statements and too many paraphrases of existing literature. As a general rule you will be able to do less than you envisage when you start your project. Accept narrowing down your subject as an indication of striving for greater depth and specificity. Think instead about how you can focus in on your subject. For example ‘Art and Propaganda in Banksy’s Wall and Piece’, ‘Mary Cassat’s Images of Motherhood, 1870-80’, or ‘What influenced Picasso’s Demoiselles D’Avignon?’ Do not choose over-researched topics, such as ‘Palladio’s Villas’, or ‘Dali and Surrealism’. If you take on such a topic, you will face enormous quantities of secondary material, making it hard to work out your own thoughts. If you want to work with celebrated artists or works of art, choose an unused angle or new approach so that you can demonstrate your analytical creativity. For example, ‘The Use of Sculpture and Architectural Ornament in the Late Villas of Andrea Palladio’ or ‘The Influence of Dali’s ‘Arabic lineage’ on his early work’. Consider minor, unusual or nonmainstream resources, new exhibitions, films and texts as well as your own experiences and knowledge. Perhaps you have access to a particular archive (it could be a family or business archive or that of a community organisation) or to artists or experts, possibly you have insider knowledge in a certain area (as a member of a society); maybe you can draw on your ethnic origins, foreign language skills, etc. Remember, however, that activities such as browsing through archives, conducting ethnographic research or travelling can be time-consuming and expensive. AQA Education (AQA) is a registered charity (number 1073334) and a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales (number 3644723). Our registered address is AQA, Devas Street, Manchester M15 6EX. 4 of 6 University of Leeds Higher education guide: Extended Project Qualification What is the role of the supervisor in your independent EPQ? Although you will be allocated a supervisor in school or college, you need to be able to demonstrate excellent independent working skills in your EPQ while showing clear evidence of responding very effectively to guidance given. Supervisors will guide your process and let you know if they think you are going in the wrong direction or plan to do too much. By the time of your final submission, however, you will have accumulated a great deal of in-depth knowledge about your subject, and your readers (and markers) are going to be genuinely interested in learning from you and will appreciate it greatly if you offer them your own ideas and research results. It is important therefore to have a good understanding of the student-supervisor relationship. Supervisors are not necessarily experts in your specific field of inquiry. You will meet with your supervisor several times before you submit your EPQ. Your first task is to convince your supervisor of the viability of your research idea and agree with her or him on a clearly specified topic. Supervisors monitor the running and academic content of the project. They provide general advice, will be available for discussion, and give you some general feedback on your draft submission. They do not propose or develop your topic, structure your project, or supply you with books and bibliographies. They will comment on your progress and offer assistance, but they do not ‘fix’ or proofread your final paper before submission. On the whole, you can gain the most from your supervisor if you consider him or her as an informed and curious person with whom you can enter into a subject-centred debate. Your supervisor’s job is not to take the initiative or do the research for you. Think about a time when you discussed a subject you were interested in with your friends, teachers, or parents? How did you convince them about your knowledge of the subject? What was the value of listening to their opinions and how did this modify your ideas? Referencing, writing and thinking skills Please refer to the Higher education guides on Research practice in Fine Art and Critical thinking and contexts. Select a research resource and think about how and why it might be useful for your EPQ. Select a second research resource on the subject and compare and contrast this with the first. What do you learn from this? Try using our ‘Evaluating Information Checklist’ at library.leeds.ac.uk/skillsfinding-and-evaluating information#activateevaluating_the_information_you_find. AQA Education (AQA) is a registered charity (number 1073334) and a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales (number 3644723). Our registered address is AQA, Devas Street, Manchester M15 6EX. 5 of 6 University of Leeds Higher education guide: Extended Project Qualification How the EPQ can help you to select a degree course. Both the process of completing the EPQ and the subject you choose to focus on will help you make some important decisions about life after school or college. If you find the process too challenging or simply rather dull, it might be that university study is not for you? If you really enjoyed the process of producing a product, researching it, testing it and demonstrating how it might improve/enhance the world, then maybe you should be thinking about a career that allows you to do this, an apprentiship scheme or even setting up on your own and becoming an entrepreneur. If you think you are ready and wanting to go onto higher education, then the EPQ might help you both decide on your subject and demonstrate to the admissions tutors why you are the perfect recruit. Remember that universities offer a much wider range of subjects than you can study at school or college and each course will be different, even if the title is the same! So do your research carefully, think about what you enjoy and whether you have a particular career in mind. Your EPQ is really useful for your UCAS application, as you will be able to demonstrate in an original way your motivation to study your subject, will be able to include your EPQ subject in your personal statement and will be able to speak knowledgably about a subject close to your heart, in a research-informed way, at interview and portfolio inspection. If you are applying for a different subject to your EPQ, simply think about the transferrable skills it has helped you develop that are useful for university study. Conclusion The EPQ offers students a chance to experience university level study, or to test an idea that they would like to build a career around. It will give you the chance to think deeply and research widely about a subject that you have been curious about for a while and helps you show the world what you have to offer in terms of your skills and independence of thought. It will probably be one of the most challenging things you do at school or college, but try to embrace and enjoy the challenge and use it to help you make some decisions about your future. To view other guides produced by University of Leeds go to: inset hyperlink below Research practice in Fine Art Critical thinking and contexts Thisinsert guide has weblinks been produced by the University of Leeds in association with AQA. AQA Education (AQA) is a registered charity (number 1073334) and a company limited by guarantee registered in England and Wales (number 3644723). Our registered address is AQA, Devas Street, Manchester M15 6EX. 6 of 6