Project Completion Report Project title: Combating Violence against Women and Girls- Creating Awareness through Forum Theatre Name of organisation: Shilpee Theatre Group, Battisputali Project duration: May, 2013 – December, 2013 Report code: PCR Submission date: January, 2014 Contact person and designation: Yubaraj Ghimire Artistic Director Address: Shilpee Theatre Group Battisputali, Kathmandu Email:shilpeeetheatre@gmail.com Tel: 4469621 Abbreviations GBV Gender Based Violence Table of contents Summary of Results Project Context and Impact Results against Project Outcome Delivery of Project Outputs Unintended Consequences Progress against Planned Activities Deviation in Activities Implemented Synthesis of Monitoring and Evaluation Findings and their Follow-up Challenges and Successes Sustainability and Institutionalisation Key Lessons Learned Overview of Financial Performance Project Performance Self-reflection Self-assessment of Key Areas of Contribution and Organisational Capacity Annexes I. SUMMARY OF RESULTS The project which lasted for altogether eight months saw the performances of four different plays in the selected twenty eight districts of Nepal. The districts were selected on the basis of high prevalence of incidents of gender based violence cases. Three production based workshops were conducted for the preparation of the plays which included the issues related to GBV. A separate fifteen day production based forum theatre workshop was conducted for the artists of 'Jhorahat Theatre Group', Morang for their capacity building to work for reducing GBV in their area. Altogether forty seven artists took part in these four workshops. The number of female participants was twenty four and there were twenty three male participants of the workshop. The participants of the workshops came from diverse backgrounds and belonged to different communities like Brahmin, Dalit, Janajati from both hill and terai. Three forum theatre plays 'Dahitan Dhenki',['Naree' and 'Ke Lagyo Halkaa Le' were prepared for the performances during the project. All the plays had GBV as the main theme and these plays were performed for the spectators from five development regions of Nepal. There were one hundred ten performances altogether of the three plays during the project period which consisted of thirty performances of 'Dahitan Dhenki', forty performances of 'Naree' and forty performances of 'Ke Lagyo Halkaa Le'. The forum theatre workshop provided to 'Jhorahat Theatre Group' prepared the play 'Dhupen ke Dhuiya' which was performed in forty different venues of Biratnagar and its surroundings. More than 0.1 million spectators watched the performances. Out of 100000 viewers, 60% were male and 40% were females. II. PROJECT CONTEXT AND IMPACT GBV is one of the strongest manifestations of the deep-rooted discrimination against women. The incidents of GBV against women can happen in the family, outside the family such as in public places, public transport, workplaces etc. The forms of GBV range from mental torture to serious physical injuries to deaths. The discrimination and marginalization of women is so long seated that men and women have internalized and normalized it. To bring a remarkable reduction in the violence against women it is necessary to educate general public on GBV issues that are seen by them as normal events. Therefore, a need was felt for an interactive, contemplative and engaging medium to break the status quo and to make the women break their silence and raise their voices. However, GBV also exists because of the typical male psyche that considers this as something trivial. This patriarchal mentality needs to be changed as well. Therefore this project was planned to increase the awareness amongst the general public especially school and college students about GBV, to increase the accountability of the government service providers and develop collective responsibility among general public, community groups, women's network and civil society organisations including media to support women who experience and the report the cases of violence. The project followed the 'Awareness Campaigns on Zero Tolerance against GBV' strategy of the 'National Strategic Action Plan on GBV and Gender Empowerment 2012' implemented by the Government of Nepal. It was successful in creating awareness amongst the viewers of the twenty eight districts of the five development regions. Not only the men were sensitized about GBV but the forum discussions also created space for the women to break their silence and put their thoughts forward. The school and college level students who are the futures of the nation were also sensitized about GBV through the project which gives us hope that the future Nepalese society will see reduction in the number of GBV cases. III. RESULTS AGAINST PROJECT OUTCOME The project was carried out to eliminate the injustices faced by the Nepalese women. The society we live in is patriarchal and indifferent to the sufferings of women. May be because they are not the one suffering it is not possible for them to comprehend the problems of womenfolk. However, when the performances were carried out and the forum discussions were held they accepted that the issues included in the play can be found in their households and societies. After the performance they expressed their commitment to fight against such injustices. Earlier the women used to be kept in the sheds. It was part of our custom. Personally, I think that even though it is customary this system of keeping women in the animal sheds during menstruation is not good. I will try my best to remove this system from my village. Gopal Mijar, 30, Pakari V.D.C, Doti I know that it is difficult to react when a girl is travelling alone in the public transportation. She might not be sure how others will react and whether or not they will support her but she has to understand that everybody will help her if she speaks up. I will definitely speak up and do something to help. Sujan, Phikkal, Ilam Taking dowry is like bribe; taking money for marrying their daughter. When I get married I will not take any dowry. I will convince my parents too. If I am self-reliant why should I take any dowry? Rajat Thapa, Mahendra Chowk, Jaleshwor, Sarlahi Even though there were fewer performances at government locations, the service providers like District Administration Offices and other organisations such as local NGOs working for improving the status of women, schools, and colleges were also were positive about working towards providing a better living situation for women. The forum discussions also made its female spectators realise that they themselves have to speak up against the injustices happening to them. They will have to be strong in intellectual, social and economical aspects then they will be able to create a better space for themselves in the society. It is hoped that the sensitivity and awareness brought by the play performances will play vital role in creating a better living conditions and opportunities in the society for Nepalese women. IV. DELIVERY OF PROJECT OUTPUTS The first output that the project had to deliver was 'three ready-to- be shown context specific plays based on GBV'. In order to prepare those plays three different 15 day forum theatre workshops were organised for the local theatre groups from five development regions of Nepal. First workshop prepared the play 'Dahitan Dhenki', second workshop gave 'Naree' and the third workshop came up with the play 'Ke Lagyo Halkaa le'. These three plays included the issues like dowry, domestic violence resulted by alcohol, discrimination between male and female child, Chaaupadi, women accused of being witches, child marriage etc. The project also had to sensitize 28,790 target audiences about GBV to promote individual and collective actions to combat violence against girls. Altogether one hundred and ten theatre performances were done during the project timeline and the number of spectators of those performances has exceeded the targeted number of audiences. The total number of viewers which included the members from our Primary, Secondary and Tertiary targeted beneficiaries group has reached over one lakhs out of which 60% were male and 40% were female. A booklet titled 'Gaau ma Rangamanch' (Theatre in the Village) has been published as a part of the project. This booklet includes the experiences of the artists about the workshop and the forum theatre tour. It also has the articles of those who were in the audience like local journalists, forum theatre artists and others describing their experience of the performances and its impacts. This booklet has been published in Nepali and English language with the pictures of the project. Total two thousand copies of booklet have been published in Nepali and English language. Similarly, an impact video of the same name i.e. 'Gaau ma Rangamanch' (Theatre in Villages) has been prepared as well. Besides the forum theatre discussions and the interaction that happened after the performance, this documentary follows the five selected spectators from the performances and documents the changes that occurred in their thoughts and lives. It is hoped that the booklet and the documentary will be helpful in inspiring and educating target groups, stakeholders and others to take necessary actions to address the problem of GBV. More than twenty thousand leaflets of three different designs were published in Nepali language for the three theatre performance tours. The leaflets contained the information about the legal provisions available in the cases of GBV and the places where an individual can go to report the cases of GBV if they come across one. V. UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES The project provided an excellent opportunity for the partners of ESP to work together. During the tour, ESP Nepal’s local partners like HUCODAN, HUSODAN, VCDC and others coordinated and helped Shilpee Theatre Group by selecting the performance venues and making other necessary arrangements. These different NGOs are ESP Nepal’s partners just like Shilpee but there had not been any exchange of information so far but because of this project Shilpee got to know about different areas in which the other NGOs are working and they got to know and watch how Shilpee has been working to fight GBV. The project is all about combating the GBV but it was also helpful in bringing together two different partners for a common purpose. One additional production based workshop was organized for the members of Jhorahat Theatre Group, Morang. This activity was not included in the original project proposal but realizing their potential and inclination to combat GBV it was decided to provide forum theatre training to them. There were altogether twelve participants of the workshop. This workshop trained six male and six female participants on the methods of forum theatre. The participants of were various cultural and ethnical backgrounds like Newari, Janajati (Terai), Brahmin etc. The workshop came up with the play 'Dhupen ke Dhuiya'. The play includes the GBV issues along with the problems invited by migration. The play was performed in forty different venues of Biratnagar and its surrounding area. Total 100 forum theatre shows were planned in the original project document but later from our experiences we realized that Far western region is more vulnerable to the GBV issues. Therefore, additional 10 shows were implemented in this region to cover bigger area. It proved to be effective to aware the people about GBV and make them committed to combat the issues. Also, we realised that besides creating the awareness about the GBV issues this project also provided a significant contribution towards the inclusion and promotion of the local languages in the theatre. Throughout the project Tharu, Awadhi, Maithili, Tamang and Doteli language were used in the three plays along with Nepali. The usage of those languages was particularly pleasing to the native speakers of those languages. They were pleased with the fact that their own language had been used in the play which created the feelings of ownership and increased the effectiveness of the play. It was not given much consideration before the start of the project but the project was really helpful in the preservation and the promotion of the local language. VI. PROGRESS AGAINST PLANNED ACTIVITIES SN Output-wise planned activities 1 15 days duration Forum theatre workshops to the local theatre groups of Kapilvastu, Bardiya, Doti, Janakpur, Sarlahi. Cumulative progress since the beginning of the project 2 Hundred theatre performances in five development regions of Nepal. Hundred and ten theatre performances were done in the five development regions of Nepal. Ten performances were added to the original hundred performances in the last quarter of the project. 3 Design and printing of leaflets More than twenty thousand leaflets in Nepali were printed and distributed amongst the spectators of the performances. The leaflets contained the information about the legal provisions and other help available to curb the GBV issues. 4 Film shooting by the videographer to document the changes on family, friends, neighbours and community after the performance. The videographer captured the performances and then selected few spectators whom he followed to their houses to know more about the impact of the play in their lives. It has been converted into a documentary which will act as the documentation of the project and can be useful as a learning tool in the future. Three workshops of fifteen days duration were organised for the theatre groups of Kapilvastu, Bardiya, Doti, Janakpur, Sarlahi along with the artists from Kavre and Dadeldhura. Besides these workshops, an additional forum theatre workshop was organised for the artists of Jhorahat Theatre Group, Morang for their capacity building. VII. DEVIATION IN ACTIVITIES IMPLEMENTED SN Major Activity Reason for Deviation 1 The 'Nepal Bandh' and transportation strike called by Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist) made us take a detour and hold the performances in Baitadi. Theatre performance in Baitadi district in the place of Baglung in the third quarter of the Level of hindrance (High/Medium/Low) High 2 3 project. Inclusion of Tamang language speaking artist in the second quarter of the project. Fewer performances in government locations. Makwanpur, Kavre, Panchthar and Ilam which are basically non-tharu and Maithili language speaking districts were added to the project towards the end by ESP. The inclusion of the Tamang language speaking artist who sometimes switched to Nepali language was necessary to connect more with the audiences who spoke or understood neither tharu nor Maithili language. Medium Difficulties in coordination. High VIII. SYNTHESIS OF MONITORING AND EVALUATION FINDINGS AND THEIR FOLLOW-UP We believe that monitoring and evaluation is very important to evaluate the success or the failure of any project. Shilpee takes the M&E part seriously and has been doing it for every task taken in hand. M& E was done for this project as well. A reporter was present during every performance to keep track of the discussions and the feedback of the spectators after the performance. This helped in keeping the records of the performances, venues and the number of the spectators present among others. Besides the reporter, a camera person also captured the forum discussions, the interactions that happened after the performances and followed some individuals from the spectators to evaluate the impact of the performance in their lives. Main purpose behind the M & E was documentation and the evaluation of the project. The reports that were prepared on the quarterly basis were helpful in keeping track of the progress made during that period and analyse the cumulative progress as well. They will also be the record of the accomplishments achieved during the project which could be helpful in the future if anybody wants to know about the effectiveness of forum theatre in creating awareness on different issues. M & E helped to measure the actual performance of the project against the initial standard set for the project. When the actual performance was matched with the set standard it helped in identifying our shortcomings. The realizations of our shortcomings led us to take corrective actions to overcome them. This way M & E helped us in maintaining the quality of the project . IX. CHALLENGES AND SUCCESSES The challenges that we had to come across during the implementation of the project are as follows: Women are naturally shyer than their male counterparts. It was a challenge for us to make them take part actively in the forum discussions. It was a challenge for them as well to speak and put their opinions in the mass. However, the plays had picked up issues so close to them that they actively took part in the discussion. Their sufferings gave them courage to overcome every kind of taboos inflicted upon them by the society. Culture shapes a person's mentality. The culture in which we all grew up is not women friendly at all. In that context, it was difficult to make the oppressors realize that their behaviour towards women is wrong. After the forum discussions some of them admitted that they had been wrong and that they will try to change their attitude towards women in the future. There are so many forms of violence based on gender which have to be brought forward for the general public’s notification but it is difficult to put them all in one play. If we try to include all of them in a single plot then there is risk of the play being too lengthy and not much effective. Therefore, only the pressing issues of the selected districts were incorporated in the play. This way the project managed to not only sensitize the local public and the concerned authorities on the burning issues of their area but also maintained the effectiveness of the play. The challenge of successfully including the government service holders persisted throughout the project. It is difficult to invite them to the performance venue because of their time schedule and other responsibilities and even if they come it is difficult to get the desired co operation from them. Therefore, the performances were done where possible. The number of performances throughout the project cannot be considered as the most satisfying ones but considering the difficulties that come across while bringing them; they will have to be given credit. X. SUSTAINABILITY AND INSTITUTIONALISATION Shilpee Theatre has been advocating about the equal rights for women and the end of all kinds of gender based violence faced by women even before the start of the project. This project will be a new feather added to its cap. This eight month long journey will be valuable to us in the future as well. The project has been such an eye opening one that the issue of violence against women and gender based violence will always be close to our hearts. Shilpee will continue working on it in the future too through its productions. Shilpee has always believed that the society can be reformed using theatre so through its proscenium plays, street plays and other forum theatre plays; it will give continuity to its fight against Gender based violence. XI. KEY LESSONS LEARNED The project was eye opening in many senses. The field visits gave us the actual picture of the problems which helped us realise the depth of the problems. The individuals who were involved in the project team have felt the change in their attitude and thoughts. Some of the valuable lessons learnt through this project are as follows: Forum theatre is a different but an effective tool to sensitize the general public on the issues like gender based violence. It is a platform where both the oppressor and the oppressed get to put their views and plan their actions if such kinds of situations occur in their life in reality. Most of these gender based violence incidences are happening because of the attitude of the men towards women. Because they are not the one suffering and because they are the actual oppressors in most of the cases, they are indifferently facing the problems faced by women. Therefore, it is necessary to change the male psyche so that they can be more open to the sufferings of the women and take measures to resolve the problems. It is important to make the members of the society realize the impact of their thoughts on the lives of the women around them rather than preaching them. Telling them that they should do this thing only might make them wanting not to do that thing at all and vice versa. Only when the realization comes from deep within them, they will follow those principles in real life. Therefore, our activities should focus on reaching to their thoughts and beliefs. XII. OVERVIEW OF FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE Budget Heading Planned Budget Actual Expenditure Budget Utilisation (%) Programme costs Nrs. 8653265.75 Nrs. 8661602 100.096% Overhead costs Nrs. 447848 Nrs. 433082 96.70% Total Nrs. 9101113.75 Nrs. 9094682 99.92% Comments on financial performance: Above given data show that 99.02 % of the total budget was utilized throughout the project period which clearly indicates the cost effectiveness of the project. Allocated budgets were spent in an effective way because of which it was possible to deliver all the proposed outputs of the project. This project has given the finance department of Shilpee an exposure to the mechanisms of Financial transactions with an INGO. The financial capacity building training provided to the project staffs has given insights into how the internal financial system can be made more systematic and effective which has been one of the major learning of the project. In order to strengthen the financial effectiveness in the future, Shilpee will be implementing the lessons learnt from this project about cost effectiveness. It will work on strengthening its internal finance system as well. XIII. PROJECT PERFORMANCE SELF-REFLECTION Effectiveness: The performances were successful in creating awareness about GBV amongst its spectators. They found the issues included in the play close to their lives and participated actively in the forum discussions. We encountered difficulties in reaching to the government authorities but there were plenty of performances in the schools and colleges so we could reach to our primary beneficiaries. We managed to reach to the spectators from all the five development regions. Their feedbacks have convinced us about the effectiveness of the project. Equity: The problems of Gender based violence were found in almost all the places where the performances were held even though the people did not admit it totally that those kinds of problems could be found in their areas. The primary beneficiaries of this project were adolescent boys and girls of schools and colleges as well as the government service providers. There were plenty of play performances in the schools and colleges of the selected 27 districts. However, there were only limited number of performances in the government locations mainly because of the lack of enough cooperation and coordination from their side. It can be said that the project was successful reaching to its targeted primary beneficiaries as well as other secondary and tertiary target groups such as community groups, general public, civil society organisations, media etc. Efficiency: Within the time span of eight months, many things were achieved: conducting four forum theatre workshops, three theatre tour covering the selected twenty seven districts from all five development regions, one hundred and one play performances with over 100000 viewers , a booklet and a documentary . Therefore, it can be said that the project was carried out in an efficient way. Economy: All the expenses were done following the guidelines provided by ESP. The products and services were bought or hired from the correct sources and if the expenses for them exceeded Nrs. 25000/-, then they were bought or hired after comparing three different quotations from different suppliers. With 99.92 % of the total budget utilization and all the proposed outputs delievered it can be said that the project was cost effective. XIV. SELF-ASSESSMENT OF KEY AREAS OF CONTRIBUTION AND ORGANISATIONAL CAPACITY SN Area Self-assessment 1. Contribution to state policies and programmes (including implementation) a. Contribution of project to effective, Significant accountable state policies and programmes b. Contribution of the organisation to the Exceptional project (in terms of financial and human resources, technical support, overall level of effort etc) Brief justification: Shilpee prepared three different plays on GBV issues. The issues included in the play were selected according to the regions because of which the plays became even more effective. The spectators who witnessed the performances became aware about the GBV issues which we believe in will help in strengthening the status of Nepalese women. 2. Assessment of dialogues (interactions, workshops, formal delegations, conferences, etc) Total number of dialogues in the quarter: N/A How many events with a. Behaviour of state institutions and political parties 1. Presence: x 2. Participation: x 3. Contribution: x 4. Commitment: x How many events with b. Preparation of the above dialogues by the organisation 1. Unplanned: x 2. Some planning: x 3. Informed positions: x 4. Strategic positions: x Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): x 3. Organisation and engagement capacity of beneficiaries (groups, networks, clubs etc formed by the project) Total number of groups/networks/clubs formed or mobilised in the quarter: N/A How many groups with a. Engagement with duty bearers by groups/networks/clubs formed (if not, by 1. Not at all: x the organisation itself) 2. Limited: x 3. Occasional/On demand: x 4. Structured/Regular: x How many groups with b. Responsiveness to rights of citizens by duty bearers 1. No acknowledgement: x 2. Acknowledgement: x 3. Partial response: x 4. Full response to demand: x Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): x 4. Space for dialogue (between civil society, political parties and state institutions): a. b. 5. a. b. 6. a. b. c. 7. a. b. 8. a. b. N/A Select a category Consideration of diversity reflected in design, implementation and governance 1. None/ 2. Some/ 3. Reasonable/ 4. of the project Exceptional Select a category Availability of space created for or by target groups to dialogue with state 1. None/ 2. Occasional/ 3. Regular/ 4. institutions and political parties Strategic Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): x Strategic areas of engagement with the state institutions (analysis, identification and support): N/A Select a category Identification of areas of strategic engagement with the state institutions 1. Absent/ 2. Limited/ 3. Good/ 4. Exceptional Select a category Support for strategic engagement with the state institutions 1. Absent/ 2. Limited/ 3. Good/ 4. Exceptional Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): x Working with state institutions to strengthen gender equality and social inclusion (GESI) in policy making, implementation and statistical analysis: N/A Select a category Support for policy making - Extent to which the project helped the state 1. Absent/ 2. Limited/ 3. Good/ 4. develop good GESI policies Exceptional Select a category Support for implementation - Extent to which the project helped state put GESI 1. Absent/ 2. Limited/ 3. Good/ 4. policies into practice Exceptional Select a category Support for statistical analysis - Extent to which the project helped the state 1. Absent/ 2. Limited/ 3. Good/ 4. analyse progress in GESI Exceptional Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): x Quality of information products and effective dissemination (information products include research reports, IEC materials, radio/TV programmes, manuals, review/learning documents and video documentary) Type & number of information produced in the quarter: : N/A Select a category Extent to which project’s information products meet quality standards 1. Low/ 2. Medium/ 3. High/ 4. Exceptional Select a category Extent to which project’s information products reach the right audiences 1. Missed target/ 2. Reached some of target/ 3. Met target/ 4. Exceptional Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): x Organisational capacity in mainstreaming gender equality and social inclusion Policies and mandates – Awareness Some and motivation to respond to consequences of inequality and exclusion Analysis drives action – Understanding Awareness of power relations and actions to address them c. Monitoring system – Observation of Awareness change from equality/inclusion perspectives & sharing lessons d. Structures and human resources – Awareness Inclusive behaviour Brief justification: Shilpee believes in providing equal opportunity to everyone regardless of their caste, ethnicity, gender etc. This project has strengthened its belief further. This project has brought positive changes in the mentality of its members so it will try to be even more inclusive in the future. 9. Organisational capacity in applying value for resources approach: N/A Select a category a. Grants, finance and admin management, including systems and 1. Limited/ 2. Under development/ 3. procedures Developed/ 4. Exemplary Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): x 10. Organisational capacity in M&E and lessons learning: N/A a. Frameworks and systems – Understanding b. Use of information – Action and reflection practices c. Capacity improvements – Approach and plan Brief justification (max 2-3 sentences): XV. ANNEXES