CHAPTER 3 LAND USE The Land Use Element for Harlingen's Vision 2020 Comprehensive Plan addresses the interrelated goals, objectives and policies that guide the future physical development of the city. This chapter documents the results of data collection, analysis, findings and recommendations relating to land use in the City and its extraterritorial jurisdiction (ETJ). The Land Use Chapter includes the Existing and Future Land Use Plans. The Existing Land Use Plan is the map indicating current land usage and the Future Land Use Plan is the general plan for guiding future land use and development. The development of the Land Use Chapter involved the compilation of an extensive amount of data including previous plans and studies, analyses of existing conditions, and development of projections and forecasts for future development within the city and the planning area. Land use analyses were coordinated with other elements of the Comprehensive Plan, recognizing the important interrelationships of land use with transportation, public utilities, recreation, and other elements. Comprehensive Planning Study Area The City Limits and Study Area boundary are shown in Figure 1-1 in Chapter 1 Introduction. The City of Harlingen encompasses a total area amounting to approximately 24,957 acres or 39.0 square miles. This is an increase of 3,197 acres in five years or approximately 14.7% land area. The area outside the City's corporate limits that is included in the study area is approximately 191.8 square miles of unincorporated Cameron County. The study area excludes the corporate limits and ETJ of other municipalities located within the Harlingen area. These other cities are identified on Figure 1-1. For purposes of the subdivision controls, the ETJ of the City of Harlingen extends 5 miles beyond the city limits, except where another ETJ boundary has been mutually agreed upon by the City of Harlingen and another municipality. For annexation purposes, the ETJ of Harlingen increased from two miles to three and one half when the 2000 Census figures indicated population exceeding 50,000. Previously Prepared Land Use Plans Lon C. Hill Plan Harlingen's original townsite was developed by Lon C. Hill, Sr. in 1911. This early plan for Harlingen established a uniform grid pattern of 300 foot square blocks separated by 80 foot wide avenues running east-west and 60-foot streets running north-south. The intersection of the St. Louis, Brownsville & Mexico Railroad lines dominated the townsite with the 200 foot wide rail right-of-way transecting the town from northwest to southeast. Harland Bartholomew Plan In 1968-69, the City of Harlingen retained the planning consulting firm of Harland Bartholomew and Associates to develop a Comprehensive Plan for Harlingen, Texas. The major goals of the plan were to reduce out-migration of population, attract new industries, and stimulate growth of tourism and recreation. The land use plan envisioned a compact and efficient urban area and called for new technical education facilities, highways, major streets, and community facilities. In the downtown area, the plan proposed a new lake expanding the existing water storage reservoir, auto and pedestrian oriented shopping areas, new parks, and a major tourism convention complex. Many of the proposals made in the Harland Bartholomew plan have become reality in the last 30 years. Wayne W. Snyder Plan More recently, Wayne W. Snyder Associates prepared a Comprehensive Plan Update for the City of Harlingen in 1982. The land use plan reflected established and emerging development patterns of intensive commercial uses concentrated downtown and in the Valley Vista and Sun Valley mall areas, and industrial uses located along the railroad and northwest areas. Existing Land Use Inventory An updated inventory of the generalized existing land uses in the City of Harlingen and its extraterritorial jurisdiction (ETJ) was conducted in JulyNovember, 2000. The land use inventory was performed by driving and reviewing areas known to have changed significantly in the last five years. The current zoning map was also reviewed extensively for compatibility with the future land use map. The land use inventory was revised on the previously adopted land use map to show a generalized map of existing land use for the study area. The level of detail and accuracy is appropriate for the purpose of determining the generalized pattern and location of existing land uses within the city and ETJ. The existing land use map for the City of Harlingen is shown in Figure 3-1. The categories of land use are identified according to the following classification system: Low Density Residential - Primarily single family residential dwellings and associated uses built no denser than eight (8) units per acre; Medium Density Residential - Multifamily dwellings such as duplexes, apartments, townhomes and condominiums built no denser than eighteen (18) units per acre; High Density Residential - Multifamily dwellings such as apartments, rooming and boarding houses, dormitories, residence halls, mobile home parks and group quarters built denser than 18 units per acre; Retail- Wholesale and retail trade, services, office uses, hotels and motels, and other general business uses; Industrial - Light manufacturing, warehousing uses, heavy manufacturing and other intensive industrial uses; Recreational and Public Facilities - Public and private parks, water areas, outdoor recreation areas, public and semipublic areas including, community facilities, and governmental uses; Institutional - Airport, educational facilities and churches; Vacant Area - Areas that are developed or reserved for transportation corridors or not yet developed for urban uses. The estimated total area of existing land uses within the corporate limits of the City of Harlingen for each category of land use is summarized in Figure 3-2. The acres for each type of use were estimated using a query method on the land use inventory map and summing up the estimated acreage for different uses. Each figure represents the estimated amount of built-up area for each type of use. The relative amount of each type of existing land use within the City of Harlingen is graphically illustrated by the pie chart in Figure 3-3. The largest category of developed land use is single family residential, which occupies approximately 3,069 acres. All types of residential use including single family, multi-family and mobile home, amount to a total of approximately 4,249 acres or 17.0 percent of the incorporated area of the city. Medium density residential and high density residential areas represent approximately 468 acres and 712 acres, respectively. The airport area accounts for the relatively large area of public institutional use. Other institutional uses such as schools, churches and the TSTC campus are included in the 2,215 acres, or 8.9 percent of the city's corporate area. Table 3-2 2000 EXISTING LAND USE FOR HARLINGEN, TEXAS Harlingen's Vision 2020 Comprehensive Plan EXISTING LAND USE ESTIMATED ACRES PRECENT 3,069 12.3 Medium Density 468 1.9 High Density 712 2.8 TYPE OF USE Residential: Low Density Subtotal - Residential 4,249 17.0 Retail 1,492 6.0 Industrial 418 1.7 Recreation and Public Facilities 573 2.3 Institutional 2,215 8.9 Vacant Land 9,776 39.2 Other (Streets and Water) 6,234 24.9 Total 24,957 100.0 SOURCE: Land use inventory performed by city staff in July - Novermber, 2000. Figure 3-3 Existing Land Use Percentage Pie Chart Commercial uses account for approximately 1,492 acres or 6.0 percent. These include retail, wholesale, services and office uses. Recreation areas and public facilities occupy approximately 573 acres or 2.3 percent of land area. Industrial land uses include approximately 615 acres or 2.5 percent area. The Harlingen Industrial Parks are located outside the City Limits and are not included in the acreage shown in the table and figure, but comprise just over 300 acres of industrial land with all but 60 acres currently developed. Future Land Use Plan The Future Land Use Plan for the City of Harlingen is shown in Figure 3-4. This is the general plan for future development of the city based upon forecast growth and known infrastructure improvements planned to the year 2020. It shows the generalized pattern of planned future land use, taking into consideration the City's land use goals and objectives. The Future Land Use Plan is not a zoning map, nor should it be used as such. A comprehensive plan shall not constitute zoning regulations or establish zoning district boundaries. The detailed pattern and location of land uses on a parcelspecific basis cannot be accurately predicted 20 years into the future. Small area land use decisions should appropriately be made at the scale of neighborhood, subarea, and development project planning, which are to be considered in subsequent zoning and rezoning actions by the City. These decisions should be based upon consideration of the Future Land Use Plan and should take into contemplation significant changes in infrastructure and land use patterns since the adoption of the Plan and should ultimately be consistent with the generalized land uses shown. The Future Land Use Plan was developed based on the following policy considerations: Compatibility with existing uses should be maintained; Transportation access and circulation should be provided for uses that generate large numbers of trips; Flood plain areas should not be encroached upon by future development unless stringent flood plain management practices are complied with; Airport land use compatibility requires that noise sensitive uses and height obstructions be avoided in the airport environs, especially within the 65 dBa noise contour; Environmentally sensitive areas should be protected, including important wildlife habitat areas and topographically constrained areas within the floodplain along the Arroyo Colorado and elsewhere; and Certificated services areas for water and wastewater services will affect the rate of urbanization for the city. In addition, four public hearings were held to solicit public input. They were held March 29, 2000 at the public library, April 26, 2000 at Austin Elementary, at the public library on November 14, 2000, at Harlingen South High School on November 15, 2000. Finally, on December 15, 2000, a land use charrette was held by the Planning Department. A charrette is an intense problem solving session. In this case, the charrette was held in a limited time frame, 2 ½ hours. While everyone in the public was invited and the event was advertised several times, a number of participants were particularly sought. These participants were carefully chosen to represent a broad range of community interests in six categories: homeowners who have demonstrated neighborhood leadership ability, social service representatives, engineers, real estate agents, large landowner/developers and public representatives like chamber of commerce, schools, waterworks, and Planning & Zoning officials. The actual attendance was a good representative mixture of those groups. The group was welcomed and the procedure and ground rules were explained to them before breaking them into six groups. Each group received several large maps illustrating existing land use, city limits and significant water features. They were also given a set of markers and asked to show what they believed would be the future use of the vacant land in and around the existing city limits. It sounds simple, but given the divergent interests and backgrounds present in each group, proved challenging for all. City staff members participated minimally, serving only as moderators for the groups, to answer technical questions and give a little push if the groups got stuck. At the end of the session, each group was asked to present their results to the overall group. While there were variations between the group's maps, there were amazing similarities among the six final products. These maps, along with the justifications provided by the presenters as to why certain land uses were allocated to certain spaces provided valuable input into the final product provided here. Many thanks are owed to the participants in this session representing the Harlingen citizenry. They include the following: Judy Adams, homeowner Wayne Beneke, Harlingen Industrial Foundation, Inc. chair Jack Brown, enginee Michael Browning, Valley International Airport Director Kevin Campbell, developer Teri Carmona, real estate agent Arnie Clark, developer J.R. Cocke, developer Carlos Cortez, homeowner Bill DeBrooke, commercial property owner Armando Elizarde, Planning & Zoning Commission member Ernestina Espinoza, homeowner Mike Fennegan, developer Lupita Garza, real estate agent Gloria Golden, real estate agent Tip Johnston, Zoning Board of Adjustments chair, real estate agent B.J. Joseph, Planning & Zoning Commission chair Cheryl LaBerge, Chamber of Commerce Tom Mason, Planning & Zoning Commission member Pastor Ralph Morales, homeless shelter/church representative Tony Ramirez, HISSO Dennis Raymond, Harlingen Waterworks Dan Reyna, Zoning Board of Adjustments member Rosalyn Robinson, citizen advocate Judy Sparks, homeowner Susan Steffner, homeowner Jarvis Thormahlen, church representative Nazario Villarreal, developer Henry Willms, engineer Eric Ziehe, real estate agent Staff moderators included: Roy Rodriguez, City Manager Tom Wilson, Parks Director Julio Cerda, Engineering Assistant Michelle McCoy, Planning Director Curtis Hill, Senior Planner Gloria Berlanga, Planning Coordinator Joel Olivo, Planning Technician Valarie Germany, GIS Technician Maria Valencia, Code Enforcement Technician Goals and Objectives Goal 3.1 Improve and Maintain the High Quality of Life for Harlingen's residents. Obj. 3.1.a. Encourage new development to locate in accordance with land suitability (the usability and adaptability of land) recognizing the need for both concentration of facilities and activities, and the preservation of open space. Obj. 3.1.b. In zoning recommendations avoid mixtures of incompatible uses in close proximity to each other. Encourage use of buffers and transitions of land uses with intermediate intensity to separate higher intensity uses from lower intensity uses. Obj. 3.1.c. Review subdivision and development of land uses for provision of efficient traffic access and circulation for local access and through traffic movement, including extension and improvement of thoroughfares and continuity of local streets consistent with the City's Major Thoroughfare Plan. Obj. 3.1.d. Relate the intensity of land use to sustainable development, especially the capability of providing adequate public facilities and services, and utility systems for water, wastewater and drainage. Obj. 3.1.e. Provide adequate public services to efficiently serve existing and planned future development. Obj. 3.1.f. Promote, develop and maintain public and private open spaces within the urbanized area to provide scenic amenities and green spaces in appropriate relation to built-up areas. Obj. 3.1.g. Protect the airport environs surrounding Rio Grande Valley International Airport from incompatible land uses and height hazard obstructions to aviation activity that would limit or tend to limit air operations and air transport service, especially those areas within the 65 dBa sound level contour for airport related noise. Obj. 3.1.h. Promote and encourage development of lodging (hotels, motels, and bed and breakfast inns), entertainment and cultural activities, sports and recreation, and other similar facilities and uses to serve tourism and visitation in Harlingen and the Valley. Obj. 3.1.i. Consider regional roles and responsibilities to strengthen the relationship of Harlingen and other communities within the Lower Rio Grande Valley in land use and development decisions. Minimize Urban Sprawl Goal 3.2 Promote development and redevelopment within Harlingen's existing urbanized area. Obj. 3.2.a. Provide adequate resources and services to promote and support the Heart of Harlingen Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy efforts. Obj. 3.2.b. Provide the basic resources, services and amenities to preserve and enhance Jackson Street and La Placita Districts as the business, services and cultural center of the city, providing jobs, access, mobility, parking, arts and entertainment, community facilities, open space, and pedestrian focus. Obj. 3.2.c. Encourage development of vacant land and redevelopment of underutilized land within the existing urbanized area, consistent with available infrastructure and compatible land uses. Obj. 3.2.d. Encourage redevelopment and infill development of inner city areas, which may include higher intensity uses that are compatible with other existing uses and located in appropriate areas. Obj. 3.2.e. Manage subdivisions within the Extraterritorial Jurisdiction in accordance with the City's goals, objectives and policies. Obj. 3.2.f. Annex urbanizing areas within the Extraterritorial Jurisdiction in a timely and orderly manner to enhance and preserve community integrity and economic viability. Utilize Existing Infrastructure to Maximize Efficiency and CostEffectiveness of Future Growth Goal 3.3 Promote fiscally responsible growth that can be efficiently and economically served by existing and planned public infrastructure. Obj. 3.3.a. Encourage development in areas that will take maximum advantage of existing water, sewer and street systems, and plans for expansion and improvement of these systems should recognize and be coordinated with the City's comprehensive land use and development plan. Obj. 3.3.b. Development should pay its fair share of costs for extension of public utilities serving its site, with the City paying the cost of any oversizing or added capacity needed to serve other future uses, which should be recovered from impact fees paid by development as it occurs. Obj. 3.3.c. Coordinate land use planning and development with school plans prepared by the Harlingen Consolidated Independent School District. Obj. 3.3.d. Sound floodplain management principles should be applied in regulating the use of identified flood hazard areas, including elevation of the lowest habitable floor of structures above the 100 year flood level and maintaining the flood carrying capacity of the regulatory floodway.