Complete the following Chart Historian General Reason for Stalin’s Rise to Power Historian’s argument Robert C. Tucker/Robert Conquest Power Politics Stalin wanted to gain supreme power by gaining power over factions—and portraying himself as a revolutionary like Lenin Robert Daniels Structualist Explanations Stalin is a product of Russian history and the administration bureaucracy of the CP Shelia Fitzpatrick Socio-Cultural Explanations Many Russians became angry about Foreign intervention & peasants joined the party—these people didn’t know Marxism, allowing them to turn to Stalin E.H. Carr, Alexander Erlich and Moshe Lewin Ideological Explanations Stalin’s policies were a dramatic change from the chaos of the civil war years and the NEP Review of Stalin’s Rise to Power What role did ideology play in Stalin’s rise to power? • Stalin served in mostly administrative role – Editor – Fundraiser – General Secretary • Lenin death brought a power struggle Trotsky vs. Stalin: Ideology Trotsky Stalin • Permanent Revolution • Internationalism • Argued that Soviet Union was too economically and culturally behindneeded help from other nations • Socialism in one country • Other nations not needed • Focus on building up U.S.S.R economy and industry Review Source A, a source from Issac Deutscher • What was Lenin’s plan for permanent revolution? • Why did Stalin develop a policy of “Socialism in one country” Push back against Trotsky • Opponents of Trotsky argued that constant revolution would anger other capitalist nations – Lead to a risk of foreign intervention – Socialism in one nation provided more stability • New members of the party were peasants/workers with no knowledge of Marxism • Stalin created Marxism-Leninism orthodoxy (very anti-Trotsky) Marx • Internationalist Movement • Capitalism increased productivityled to global economy • Capitalism also leads to class struggle • Socialism then communism • Society could jump a stage—but ONLY with support of another nation Lenin Stalin • Argued that factions (or • Socialism in one country platforms) should exist— • Destroyed the “Old “democratic centralism” Guard” Bolsheviks • BUT b/c of Tsarist Russia’s • Aruged that Trotsky had lack of democracy the no faith in Russian people party had to be centralized • Revolutionary stages could occur very quickly • Believed that outside assistance was needed What is the nature of the Stalinist State? • How would you define the nature of the Stalinist state? • Was Stalin’s government a progress of society? Why or why not? • Looking at qualities of Totalitarianism, was Stalin’s state a totalitarian state? Totalitarianism