ENGINEERING
PROJECT ECONOMICS
Lecture 9
Incremental Analysis
Sherif H. El-Gohary , Phd
shamdy@zewailcity.edu.eg
LEARNING OUTCOMES
1. Why incremental analysis is required in ROR
2. Incremental cash flow (CF) calculation
3. Interpretation of ROR on incremental CF
4. Select alternative by ROR based on PW relation
5. Select alternative by ROR based on AW relation
6. Select best from several alternatives using ROR
method
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Who Got More Pay Raise?
Bill
10%
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Hillary
5%
Can’t Compare without Knowing
Their Base Salaries
Bill
Hillary
Base Salary
$50,000
$200,000
Pay Raise (%)
10%
5%
Pay Raise ($)
$5,000
$10,000
For the same reason, we can’t compare mutually exclusive projects based on
the magnitude of its IRR. We need to know the size of investment and its timing
of when to occur.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Comparing Mutually Exclusive
Alternatives Based on IRR
• Issue: Can we rank the mutually exclusive projects by
the magnitude of its IRR?
n
A1
A2
0
-$1,000
-$5,000
1
$2,000
$7,000
IRR
100%
>
40%
PW (10%)
$818
<
$1,364
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Why Incremental Analysis is Necessary
Selecting the alternative with highest ROR may not
yield highest return on available capital
Must consider weighted average of total capital available
Capital not invested in a project is assumed to earn at MARR
Example: Assume $90,000 is available for investment and MARR = 16%
per year. If alternative A would earn 35% per year on investment of $50,000, and
B would earn 29% per year on investment of $85,000, the weighted averages are:
Overall RORA = [50,000(0.35) + 40,000(0.16)]/90,000 = 26.6%
Overall RORB = [85,000(0.29) + 5,000(0.16)]/90,000 = 28.3%
Which investment is better, economically?
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Why Incremental Analysis is Necessary
If selection basis is higher ROR:
Select alternative A
(wrong answer)
If selection basis is higher overall ROR:
Select alternative B
Conclusion: Must use an incremental ROR analysis to make a
consistently correct selection
Unlike PW, AW, and FW values, if not analyzed correctly, ROR values
can lead to an incorrect alternative selection. This is called the
ranking inconsistency problem .
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Calculation of Incremental CF
Incremental cash flow = cash flowB – cash flowA
where larger initial investment is Alternative B
Example: Either of the cost alternatives shown below can be used in
a grinding process. Tabulate the incremental cash flows.
A
B
B-A
First cost, $
-40,000
- 60,000
-20,000
Annual cost, $/year
-25,000
-19,000
+6000
Salvage value, $
8,000
10,000
+2000
The incremental CF is shown in the (B-A) column
The ROR on the extra $20,000 investment in B determines which alternative
to select (as discussed later)
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Example 2
• A sole-source vendor can supply a new industrial park with large
transformers suitable for underground utilities and vault-type installation.
• Type A has an initial cost of $70,000 and a life of 8 years.
• Type B has an initial cost of $95,000 and a life expectancy of 12 years.
• The annual operating cost for type A is expected to be $9000, while the
AOC for type B is expected to be $7000.
• If the salvage values are $5000 and $10,000 for type A and type B,
respectively, tabulate the incremental cash flow using their LCM for hand
solutions.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Solution
• The LCM of 8 and 12 is 24 years. In the incremental cash flow tabulation for 24
years
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Interpretation of ROR on Extra
Investment
Based on concept that any avoidable investment that does not
yield at least the MARR should not be made.
Once a lower-cost alternative has been economically justified, the ROR on the
extra investment (i.e., additional amount of money associated with a
higher first-cost alternative) must also yield a ROR ≥ MARR (because the
extra investment is avoidable by selecting the economically-justified
lower-cost alternative).
This incremental ROR is identified as ∆i*
For independent projects, select all that have ROR ≥
MARR (no incremental analysis is necessary)
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
ROR Evaluation for Two ME
Alternatives
(1) Order alternatives by increasing initial investment cost
(2) Develop incremental CF series using LCM of years
(3) Draw incremental cash flow diagram, if needed
(4) Count sign changes to see if multiple ∆i* values exist
(5) Set up PW, AW, or FW = 0 relation and find ∆i*B-A
Note: Incremental ROR analysis requires equal-service comparison.
The LCM of lives must be used in the relation
(6) If ∆i*B-A < MARR, select A; otherwise, select B
If multiple ∆i* values exist, find EROR using either
MIRR or ROIC approach.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Example: Incremental ROR
Evaluation
Either of the cost alternatives shown below can be used in a
chemical refining process. If the company’s MARR is 15% per year,
determine which should be selected on the basis of ROR analysis?
A
B
First cost ,$
Annual cost, $/year
-40,000
-25,000
-60,000
-19,000
Salvage value, $
Life, years
8,000
5
10,000
5
Initial observations: ME, cost alternatives with equal life estimates
and no multiple ROR values indicated
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Example: ROR Evaluation of Two
Alternatives
Solution, using procedure:
A
B
B-A
First cost , $
Annual cost, $/year
-40,000
-25,000
-60,000
-19,000
Salvage value, $
Life, years
8,000
5
10,000
5
-20,000
+6000
+2000
Order by first cost and find incremental cash flow B - A
Write ROR equation (in terms of PW, AW, or FW) on incremental CF
0 = -20,000 + 6000(P/A,∆i*,5) + 2000(P/F,∆i*,5)
Solve for ∆i* and compare to MARR
∆i*B-A = 17.2% > MARR of 15%
ROR on $20,000 extra investment is acceptable: Select B
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Example
n
0
1
2
3
IRR
B1
B2
-$3,000 -$12,000
1,350
4,200
1,800
6,225
1,500
6,330
25%
17.43%
Given MARR = 10%, which project is a better choice?
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Example
n
0
1
2
3
IRR
B1
B2
B2 - B1
-$3,000 -$12,000
1,350
4,200
1,800
6,225
1,500
6,330
-$9,000
2,850
4,425
4,830
25%
15%
17.43%
Given MARR = 10%, which project is a better choice?
Since IRRB2-B1=15% > 10%, and also IRRB2 > 10%, select B2.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Breakeven ROR Value
An ROR at which the PW,
AW or FW values:
Of cash flows for two
alternatives are exactly
equal. This is the i* value
Of incremental cash flows
between two alternatives are
exactly equal.
This is the ∆i* value
If MARR > breakeven ROR,
select lower-investment
alternative
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Example
• As Ford Motor Company retools an old truck assembly plant in Michigan to
produce a fuel- efficient economy model, the Ford Focus. Ford and its
suppliers are seeking additional sources for light, long-life transmissions.
Automatic transmission component manufacturers use highly finished dies
for precision forming of internal gears and other moving parts. Two United
States– based vendors make the required dies. Use the per unit estimates
below and a MARR of 12% per year to select the more economical vendor
bid. Show both hand and spreadsheet solutions.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
• These are cost alternatives, since all cash flows are
costs. Use the procedure described above to
determine ∆ i *B–A
1. Alternatives A and B are correctly ordered with the
higher first-cost alternative in column 2 of Table
2. The cash flows for the LCM of 10 years are tabulated.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Example - using an AW-based
incremental ROR method
• Compare the alternatives of vendors A and B for
Ford in previous example, using an AW-based
incremental ROR method and the same MARR of
12% per year.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Solution
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
• the ROR is found using the actual cash
flows and the respective lives of 10
years for A and 5 years for B.
ROR Analysis – Multiple
Alternatives
Six-Step Procedure for Mutually Exclusive Alternatives
(1) Order alternatives from smallest to largest initial investment
(2) For revenue alts, calculate i* (vs. DN) and eliminate all with i* < MARR; remaining
alternative with lowest cost is defender. For cost alternatives, go to step (3)
(3) Determine incremental CF between defender and next lowest-cost alternative
(known as the challenger). Set up ROR relation
(4) Calculate ∆i* on incremental CF between two alternatives from step (3)
(5) If ∆i* ≥ MARR, eliminate defender and challenger becomes new defender
against next alternative on list
(6) Repeat steps (3) through (5) until only one alternative remains. Select it.
For Independent Projects
Compare each alternative vs. DN and select all with ROR ≥ MARR
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
IRR on Increment Investment:
Three Alternatives
n
0
D1
D2
D3
-$2,000 -$1,000 -$3,000
1
1,500
800
1,500
2
1,000
500
2,000
3
800
500
1,000
IRR
34.37% 40.76% 24.81%
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Step 1: Examine the IRR for each
project to eliminate any project
that fails to meet the MARR.
Step 2: Compare D1 and D2 in pairs.
IRRD1-D2=27.61% > 15%,
so select D1. D1 becomes the
current best.
Step 3: Compare D1 and D3.
IRRD3-D1= 8.8% < 15%,
so select D1 again.
Here, we conclude that D1 is
the best Alternative.
n
D2
D1
D3
0
-$1,000
-$2,000
-$3,000
1
800
1,500
1,500
2
500
1,000
2,000
3
500
800
1,000
IRR
40.76%
34.37%
24.81%
When you have more than two
mutually exclusive alternatives,
they can be compared in pairs
by successive examination
Step 1:
Examine the IRR for each project to eliminate any project that fails to meet MARR (15%).
Step 2:
Compare lowest investment cost D2 and the second lowest investment cost D1 in
pairs. Compute the incremental analysis IRRD1-D2. If IRRD1-D2 > MARR select D1
otherwise choose D2.
Step 3:
Compare the result from step 2 with the highest investment cost D3. Compute the
incremental analysis IRRD3-D1 and chose D3 if IRRD3-D1 > MARR otherwise choose D1.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
IRR on Increment Investment: Three Alternatives
n
D2
D1
D1 - D2
0
-$1,000
-$2,000
-$1,000
1
800
1,500
700
2
500
1,000
500
3
500
800
300
IRR
40.76%
34.37%
?
Step 2: Compare D1 and D2 in pairs.
PW( i ) = -$1,000+$700(P/F, i, 1)+ $500(P/F, i, 2)+ $300(P/F, i, 3) = 0
PW( 25% ) = -$1,000+$700(0.8)+ $500(0.64)+ $300(0.512) = $33.6
PW( 30% ) = -$1,000+$700(0.7692)+ $500(0.5917)+ $300(0.4552) = -$29.15
i* D1-D2= 25% +(30% - 25%) [33.6 /33.6 + 29.2] = 25 + 5(0.535) = 25 + 2.675 = 27.67 %
IRRD1-D2=27.67% > 15%, so select D1. D1 becomes the current best.
IRR on Increment Investment: Three Alternatives
n
D1
D3
D3 – D1
0
-$2,000
-$3,000
-$1,000
1
1,500
1,500
0
2
1,000
2,000
1,000
3
800
1,000
200
IRR
34.37%
24.81%
?
Step 3: Compare D1 and D3.
PW( i ) = -$1,000+$0(P/F, i, 1)+ $1,000(P/F, i, 2)+ $200(P/F, i, 3) = 0
PW( 6% ) = -$1,000+$0(0.9434)+ $500(0.89)+ $300(0.8396) = $57.92
PW( 10% ) = -$1,000+$0(0.9091)+ $500(0.8264)+ $300(0.7513) = $-23.34
i* D3-D1 = 6% +(10% - 6%) [57.92 /57.92 + 23.34] = 6 + 4(0.7127) = 6 + 2.851 = 8.85 %
IRRD3-D1= 8.8% < 15%, so select D1 again. We conclude that D1 is the best Alternative.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Summary of Important Points
Must consider incremental cash flows for mutually exclusive alternatives
Incremental cash flow = cash flowB – cash flowA
where alternative with larger initial investment is Alternative B
Eliminate B if incremental ROR ∆i* < MARR; otherwise, eliminate A
Breakeven ROR is i* between project cash flows of two alternatives,
or ∆i* between incremental cash flows of two alternatives
For multiple mutually exclusive alternatives, compare two at a time
and eliminate alternatives until only one remains
For independent alternatives, compare each against DN and select
all that have ROR ≥ MARR
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.
Sherif ElGohary, Ph.D.