3/9/18 The community in the giver is good, because it is peaceful. That is, there is no crime, no war, no fighting, and no breaking rules, also they are forgiveness. For Example, Jonas, Fiona, and Ashur are respectful and Jonas is shocked when he sees war in his dream. Furthermore, in the graduation the chief Elder said “I apologies” and everyone said “we accept your apology”. Clearly, the community in the giver is good, because it is peaceful. The community in the giver is bad, because it is loveless. That is, there is no family love, no romantic love, and there is no emotion. For Example, Jonas can’t even touch Fiona. Also, they have family, but burt they can’t say love you to them. Furthermore, after good dream to Jonas, he asked the giver “what is it” and the giver said “it is called love”. Thus, the community is bad because it is bad. The community in the giver is bad, because it is controlled. That is, the government controlled everything and there is many rules. This is shown, they controlled feeling, weather, and even job for the future.as well, when Fiona is about to release. The chief elder said “when people have the freedom to choose, they choose wrong, every single time”. Therefore, the community in the giver is bad because it is controlled.