ASBESTOS INSPECTION REPORT
Conducted at:
FITERMAN HALL
30 WEST BROADWAY
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10007
Conducted for:
DORMITORY AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK
Prepared By:
PEI COBB FREED TEAM
AIRTEK ENVIRONMENTAL CORP.
39 WEST 38TH STREET – 12TH FLOOR
NEW YORK, NY 10018
AIRTEK PROJECT NUMBER
05-0867
Revised - 09/15/06
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
1.0
BACKGROUND..............................................................................................1
2.0
SCOPE OF WORK.........................................................................................2
3.0
SUMMARY OF FILE RESEARCH..................................................................2
4.0
SUMMARY OF AIRTEK’S INSPECTION RESULTS......................................3
5.0
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS...............................................3
6.0
ASBESTOS QUANTITY SCHEDULE.............................................................5
7.0
AREAS NOT ACCESSIBLE ...........................................................................8
8.0
REPORT CERTIFICATIONS..........................................................................8
APPENDICES
9.0
APPENDIX A: Analytical Results and Chain of Custody
10.0
APPENDIX B: File Search Data
11.0
APPENDIX C: Personnel Licenses
12.0
APPENDIX D: Laboratory Accreditations
13.0
APPENDIX E: ACM Location Drawings
1.0
BACKGROUND:
Airtek Environmental Corp. has conducted an asbestos survey for the presence of AsbestosContaining Materials (ACM) at the following building:
Site:
Borough:
Address:
Fiterman Hall
Manhattan
30 West Broadway, New York, NY, 10007
The Investigator and inspector responsible for this project were:
Damien Gordon Toylor
Hilton Sue
Moyna Ali
Enayat Nassry
Michael Porter
Site Visit(s):
Report Date:
Revision Date:
NYS Asbestos Inspector CERT #95-12324
NYS Asbestos Inspector CERT #91-02355
NYS Asbestos Inspector CERT #89-01641
NYC Asbestos Investigator CERT#99570
NYS Asbestos Inspector CERT #91-06440
Expires: 11/30/06
Expires: 05/31/06
Expires: 03/31/07
Expires: 07/04/07
Expires: 10/31/06
10/21/05 through 4/4/06
12/20/05
9/15/06
Field Procedures and Analysis Methodology:
Guidelines used for the inspection were established by the Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA) in the Guidance for Controlling Asbestos Containing Materials in Buildings, Office of
Pesticides and Toxic Substances, DOC #560/5-85-024 and 40 CFR Part 763, Asbestos Hazard
Emergency Response Act (AHERA).
Field information was organized as per the AHERA concept of Homogeneous Area (HA). A HA
is defined as a suspect material of similar age, appearance, function and texture. Each material
was grouped together as a specific HA, sampled and then assessed for condition.
Bulk samples of suspect ACM were analyzed by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM) with
dispersion staining, as described in 40 CFR Part 763 and the National Emissions Standard for
Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAPS).
The New York State Department of Health has recently revised the PLM Stratified Point
Counting Method. The new method, “Polarized Light Microscopy Methods for Identifying and
Quantitating Asbestos in Bulk Samples” can be found as item 198.1 in the ELAP Certification
manual.
The State of New York ELAP has determined that analysis of Non-friable, Organically Bound
Materials (NOB) are not reliably performed by PLM. Therefore, if PLM analysis of a NOB yields
a negative result, it must be further confirmed by Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM).
All samples were initially analyzed by PLM. Samples which produced a negative PLM result
and which are classified as a NOB were then re-analyzed utilizing the TEM methodology.
1
2.0
SCOPE OF WORK:
The whole building including interior and exterior, which may be affected by the
decontamination and deconstruction, was inspected for ACM:
The inspection was characterized by a close visual inspection of all accessible areas. Selective
demolition was also conducted to access interstitial spaces suspected of containing ACM.
Suspect materials were sampled and inventoried for quantity, condition and friability. Airtek
used previous survey results, which had been provided by the Applied Technology Services
Inc., in our determination of areas and materials to sample. Materials examined included:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
3.0
Tar materials on interior perimeter walls
Spandrel/Lintel/Relieving angle flashing and mastic
Paper materials on perimeter walls
Fiber glass materials on perimeter walls
Felt materials on perimeter walls
Flashing mastic on beams
Black cloth materials on beams
Roof materials/flashing
Roof tar/paper
Roof brick
Roof cloth
Roof insulation
Roof shingles
Coping caulk
Cap flashing
Window caulking
Window glazing
Roof screed
Brick wall mortar
Expansion joint caulking
Marble mortar & sealant
Window frame caulking
Column caulking
Floor covering materials
Cloth/rubber materials on beams
Black tar on concrete ceiling
Pipe insulation
Glue daub
SUMMARY OF FILE SEARCH:
All available Dormitory Authority of the State of New York (DASNY) files have been reviewed.
The following is a listing of our findings:
•
Previous files – Applied Technology Services Inc. initiated an asbestos investigation at
Fiterman Hall on July 12th, 1996 and found the following ACMs throughout the building:
Pipe Insulation
Mudded Joint Fitting
Floor Tile & Mastic
Exhaust Duct Insulation
Window Glazing
Metal Fire Doors
Vapor Barrier
2
•
Abatement Records –According to abatement records subsequent to the abovereferenced 1996 Survey Report, extensive abatement was conducted in support of the
gut rehabilitation.
Based on the currently recommended sampling and analytical procedures for ACM materials,
Airtek determined that additional sampling was necessary in order to determine the asbestos
content of additional suspect materials.
4.0
SUMMARY OF AIRTEK ENVIRONMENTAL’S INSPECTION RESULTS:
The asbestos inspection was conducted in several phases from October 21st, 2005 to April 4th,
2006 and involved a thorough visual examination of all areas and sampling of suspect materials
that would be impacted during the proposed work schedule.
Airtek Laboratory analysis confirmed the presence of asbestos in the amount greater than 1%
within the samples collected from the following material:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Tar and paper materials on interior of perimeter walls
Flashing mastic on exterior of spandrel beams
Roof membrane – 15th floor set back north roof
Window caulking (Bulkhead Windows)
Window frame caulking (Elevator Room Windows)
All flooring materials are assumed ACM
Roof shingles and tar (Parapet Wall – Chiller)
Airtek laboratory analysis determined the samples collected from the following materials to
contain less then one percent (<1%) asbestos.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
5.0
Felt and fiber glass backing materials on perimeter walls (Contaminated by ACM)
Cloth materials on spandrel beams (Contaminated by ACM)
Screed
Brick wall mortar
Expansion joint caulking
Marble mortar, sealant and caulking
Column caulking and mortar
Interior spandrel flashing mastic
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
Asbestos-containing materials, which may be affected by the scope of work, have been
positively identified at various locations throughout the building.
As the identified ACM is to be disturbed by the proposed renovation work, proper asbestos
abatement procedures shall be implemented prior to the commencement of such work. All
asbestos abatement work shall be performed in accordance with all applicable Federal, State
and Local rules and regulations. The abatement project shall be filed with all agencies having
jurisdiction over this project, such as USEPA, NYSDOL and NYCDEP.
A licensed abatement contractor must perform the removal of all friable and non-friable ACM.
Airtek believes that the implementation of these recommendations will serve to best protect
human health and the environment.
To assure that the removal of the aforementioned ACM is properly and effectively carried out,
the following recommendations are proposed by Airtek:
3
A. Develop and implement a schedule that outlines the time frame for removal of ACM.
B. Develop complete and concise specifications to effectively deal with removal of the ACM.
These specifications should be developed to comply with all applicable Federal, State and
Local regulations.
C. Retain the service of an independent testing laboratory to monitor the air for possible
asbestos contamination before, during and after the removal work.
Retain all
documentation and correspondence from the removal contractor, the testing laboratory and
related items in a permanent record.
4
6.0
ASBESTOS QUANTITY SCHEDULE:
Approximate asbestos quantity schedules are presented on the following table:
TABLE 1
SUMMARY OF INSPECTION RESULTS FOR ASBESTOS
FITERMAN HALL 30 WEST BROADWAY, NEW YORK, NY 10007
PROPOSED
WORK
SUSPECT ACM THAT
MAY BE AFFECTED
LAB
RESULTS
Elbow drain insulation of
water tower
Roof shingle of water tower
Non ACM
APPROXIMATE
ACM
QUANTITY
0 SF
Non ACM
0 SF
Louvers of cooling tower
Non ACM
0 SF
Silicone caulk
Non ACM
0 SF
Glazing
Non ACM
0 SF
Gypsum wallboard
Non ACM
0 SF
Condenser gasket
Non ACM
0 SF
Radiator backing
Non ACM
0 SF
Hard wall plaster
Non ACM
0 SF
Pyrobar building block
Non ACM
0 SF
Deck patch on I-beam
above women’s bathroom
Cove moulding with glue
Non ACM
0 SF
Non ACM
0 SF
Wall joint compound
Non ACM
0 SF
Adhesive on duct-fiberglass
Non ACM
0 SF
Patch on duct insulation
Non ACM
0 SF
Trowelled on cement on
duct
Mastic/Glue paper
Non ACM
0 SF
Non ACM
0 SF
White speckled 9×9 VFT
Non ACM
0 SF
Grey speckled 9×9 VFT
Non ACM
0 SF
Blue speckled 9×9 VFT
Non ACM
0 SF
Pipe wrapping in cage
Non ACM
0 SF
Mudded joint fitting elbow
Non ACM
0 SF
White 12×12 VFT/mastic
Non ACM
0 SF
Beige 12×12 VFT/mastic
Non ACM
0 SF
5
NOTES/SPECIFIC LOCATION
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
TABLE 1
SUMMARY OF INSPECTION RESULTS FOR ASBESTOS
FITERMAN HALL 30 WEST BROADWAY, NEW YORK, NY 10007
PROPOSED
WORK
SUSPECT ACM THAT
MAY BE AFFECTED
LAB
RESULTS
Acoustical ceiling tile 4×2
and 2×2
Spray-on fireproofing
Non ACM
APPROXIMATE
ACM
QUANTITY
0 SF
Non ACM
0 SF
Blue 12×12 VFT/mastic
Non ACM
0 SF
Light grey 12×12
VFT/mastic
Tar materials on interior
perimeter walls
Spandrel/Lintel/Relieving
Angle flashing mastic
(Exterior Side)
Paper materials on
perimeter walls
Fiber glass materials on
perimeter walls
Felt materials on perimeter
walls
Flashing mastic on beams
Non ACM
0 SF
ACM
28,755 SF
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
Confirmed by Applied Technology
Services Inc. Aug. 1996
1st-15th Floor. Fair condition
ACM
28,755 SF
1st-15th Floor. Fair condition
ACM
26,793 SF
2nd -15th Floor. Fair condition
ACM
contaminated
ACM
contaminated
26,793 SF
2nd -15th Floor. Fair condition
1,962 SF
ACM
25 SF
Only exists on the 1st Floor. Fair
condition
Loading dock entrance. Fair
condition
Loading dock entrance. Fair
condition
Elevator machine room roof
Elevator machine room roof
Elevator machine room roof
Elevator machine room roof
Elevator machine room roof
Fan room roof
Bulkhead roof
Bulkhead roof
Bulkhead. Fair condition
Bulkhead. Fair condition
Bulkhead
Bulkhead roof
New elevator mechanical room roof
New elevator mechanical room roof
New elevator mechanical room roof
New elevator mechanical room roof.
Fair condition
New elevator mechanical room roof.
Fair condition
New elevator mechanical room roof
15th Floor roof
15th Floor roof
14th Floor roof
th
14 Floor roof. Fair condition
14th Floor roof
14th Floor roof
Black cloth material on
beams
Roof materials
Flashing
Coping caulk
Cap flashing
Screed
Flashing
Roof materials
Flashing
Side window caulking
Top window caulking
Window glazing
Screed
Roof materials
Flashing
Coping stone caulk
Side window caulking
Top window caulking
Screed
Roof materials
Flashing
Flashing
Roof membrane
Screed
Roof membrane under
screed
Flashing
Roof membrane
ACM
contaminated
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
ACM
ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
ACM
25 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 LF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
8 LF
4 LF
0 LF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 LF
8 LF
ACM
4 LF
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
ACM
Non ACM
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
6,950 SF
0 SF
Non ACM
0 SF
Non ACM
Non ACM
0 SF
0 SF
6
NOTES/SPECIFIC LOCATION
5th Floor roof
5th Floor roof
TABLE 1
SUMMARY OF INSPECTION RESULTS FOR ASBESTOS
FITERMAN HALL 30 WEST BROADWAY, NEW YORK, NY 10007
PROPOSED
WORK
SUSPECT ACM THAT
MAY BE AFFECTED
LAB
RESULTS
APPROXIMATE
ACM
QUANTITY
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
600 LF
Screed
Brick wall mortar
Expansion joint caulking
Marble mortar & sealant
Marble caulking
Window frame caulking
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
ACM
Column caulking
Column mortar
Floor Covering Materials
including
Adhesives/Mastics
Glue daub
Interior spandrel flashing
Black tar on concrete
Black tar
Black roof tar/paper
Non ACM
Non ACM
Assumed
ACM
0 SF
0 SF
288,000 SF
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
ACM
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
6,950 SF
Brown roof insulation
Black roof membrane
Brown roof paper
Red brick material
Brown roof cloth
Black roof insulation
Brown roof insulation
Black roof paper
White pipe insulation
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
Non ACM
ACM
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
0 SF
12 LF
ACM
ACM
80 SF
80 SF
415,168 SF
636 LF
Black roof shingle
Black roof tar
Total Approximate Quantity of ACM
7
NOTES/SPECIFIC LOCATION
5th Floor roof
6th & 15th Floor
6th & 15th Floor
st
1 Floor exterior of the building
1st Floor exterior of the building
st
1 Floor exterior of the building. Fair
condition
1st Floor exterior of the building
1st Floor exterior of the building
Throughout the building. Slightly
Damaged
NW entrance exterior ceiling
1st – 15th Floor
rd
3 floor south side ceiling
3rd floor south side ceiling
th
14 floor setback roof N. side. Fair
condition
14th floor setback roof N. side
14th floor setback roof N. side
14th floor setback roof N. side
14th floor setback roof N. side
14th floor setback roof N. side
14th floor setback roof N. side
14th floor setback roof N. side
16th floor water tank
th
5 floor column S. side (Riser Only).
Fair condition
Cooler roof walls. Fair condition
Cooler roof walls. Fair condition
7.0
AREAS NOT ACCESSIBLE:
Airtek inspected and sampled materials, which were observable and accessible to the survey
team. Any suspect ACM that have not been tested and/or found positive for asbestos, if any,
must be assumed ACM until and unless they are tested.
8.0
REPORT CERTIFICATIONS:
Airtek certifies that the information contained herein is based on the physical and visual
inspections conducted by Airtek and data collected during the inspection survey and file review.
Enayat Nassry
NYC Investigator
Michael Porter,
QA/QC
.
8
Efren Martinez,
Lab Manager
APPENDIX A
9.0 Analytical Results and Chain of Custody
Certificates of Analysis
9
LABORATORY RESULTS
HA #
Sample #
Location
Material
1
DT01-04
West side 15th floor
Black tar material
2
DT05-07
South side 14th floor
Black tar material
3
DT08-10
East side 13th floor
Black tar material
4
DT11-13
North side 12th floor
Black tar material
5
DT14-20
West side 11th floor
Black tar material
6
DT21-23
South side 10th floor
Black tar material
7
DT24-26
East side 9th floor
Black tar material
8
DT27-29
North side 8th floor
Black tar material
9
DT30-36
West side 7th floor
Black tar material
10
DT37-39
South side 6th floor
Black tar material
11
DT40-42
East side 5th floor
Black tar material
12
DT43-45
North side 4th floor
Black tar material
13
DT46-52
West side 3rd floor
PLM
Results
PLM-NOB
16
DT59
Northeast corner 1 floor
Black felt material
5.1%
Chrysotile
3.6%
Chrysotile
3.5%
Chrysotile
4.8%
Chrysotile
3.9%
Chrysotile
3.6%
Chrysotile
4.3%
Chrysotile
3.2%
Chrysotile
3.6%
Chrysotile
3.6%
Chrysotile
4.2%
Chrysotile
5.1%
Chrysotile
3.1%
Chrysotile
4.6%
Chrysotile
2.8%
Chrysotile
Inconclusive
16
DT60
Northeast corner 1st floor
Black felt material
Inconclusive
17
DT61-64
West side 15th floor
18
DT65-67
South side 14th floor
19
DT68-69
North side 13th floor
20
DT70-73
North side 12th floor
21
DT74-80
South side 11th floor
22
DT81-83
South side 10th floor
23
DT84-86
East side 9th floor
24
DT87-89
North side 8th floor
25
DT90-96
West side 7th floor
26
DT97-99
South side 6th floor
27
DT100102
East side 5th floor
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
Black tar material
nd
14
DT53-55
Southeast corner 2
floor
Black tar material
15
DT56-58
Northeast corner 1st floor
Black tar material
st
10
TEM-NOB
NAD*
Trace
Chrysotile
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
1.9%
Chrysotile
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
Inconclusive
Inconclusive
1.8%
Chrysotile
Trace
Chrysotile
NAD
1.9%
Chrysotile
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
HA #
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
Sample #
DT103105
DT106112
DT113115
DT116120
DT121123
DT124125
DT126129
DT130136
DT137139
DT140142
DT143145
DT146152
DT153155
DT156158
DT159161
DT162168
DT169171
45
HS01
45
HS02
45
HS03
46
HS04
46
HS05
46
HS06
47
MA01-03
48
MA04-06
49
MA07-09
50
MA10-12
51
MA13-15
52
MA16-18
Location
Material
PLM
Results
West side 3rd floor
TEM-NOB
1.5%
Chrysotile
Black paper
material
Black paper
material
North side 4th floor
PLM-NOB
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
Trace
Chrysotile
Inconclusive
NAD
nd
Southeast corner 2
floor
West side 15th floor
South side 14th floor
North side 13th floor
North side 12th floor
West side 11th floor
South side 10th floor
East side 9th floor
North side 8th floor
West side 7th floor
South side 6th floor
East side 5th floor
North side 4th floor
West side 3rd floor
nd
Southeast corner 2
floor
On beam at loading
dock entrance
On beam at loading
dock entrance
On beam at loading
dock entrance
On beam at loading
dock entrance
On beam at loading
dock entrance
On beam at loading
dock entrance
Elevator machine room
roof
Elevator machine room
roof
Elevator machine room
roof
Elevator machine room
roof
Elevator machine room
roof
Fan room roof
Black tar material
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black fiber glass
backing
Black cloth
material
Black cloth
material
Black cloth
material
Black cloth
material
Black cloth
material
Black cloth
material
3.6%
Chrysotile
NA
NA
Roof material
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Coping caulk
Inconclusive
NAD
Cap flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Screed
Flashing
11
NAD
HA #
Sample #
Location
53
54
MA19-21
MA22-24
Stair roof
Stair roof
Roof material
Flashing
55
MA25
Stair roof
Side window
caulking
55
MA26
Stair roof
55
MA27
Stair roof
56
MA28
Stair roof
56
MA29
Stair roof
56
MA30
Stair roof
57
58
MA31-33
MA34-36
59
MA37-39
60
MA40-42
61
Stair roof
Stair roof
New mechanical
equipment room roof
New mechanical
equipment room roof
MA43-45
62
MA46
62
MA47
62
MA48
63
MA49
63
MA50
63
MA51
64
MA52-54
65
66
67
MA55-57
MA58-60
EN01
67
EN02
67
EN03
68
EN04
68
EN05
68
EN06
Material
PLM
Results
Side window
caulking
Side window
caulking
TEM-NOB
Inconclusive
Inconclusive
2.6%
Anthophyllite
and 1.6%
Chrysotile
NAD
NAD
NA**
NA
2.6%
Anthophyllite
and 1.1%
Chrysotile
Top window
caulking
Top window
caulking
Top window
caulking
Window glazing
Screed
PLM-NOB
NA
NA
Inconclusive
NAD
Roof material
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
New mechanical
equipment room roof
Coping stone
caulk (Alumina
covers)
Inconclusive
NAD
New mechanical
equipment room roof
Side window
caulking
3.5%
Anthophyllite
and 1.6%
Chrysotile
New mechanical
equipment room roof
New mechanical
equipment room roof
Side window
caulking
Side window
caulking
New mechanical
equipment room roof
Top window
caulking
New mechanical
equipment room roof
New mechanical
equipment room roof
New mechanical
equipment room roof
15th floor roof
15th floor roof
14th-floor roof west side
14th-floor roof adjacent
to entrance
14th-floor roof park place
side
14th-floor roof west side
14th-floor roof adjacent
to entrance
14th-floor roof park place
side
Top window
caulking
Top window
caulking
Screed
NAD
NA
NA
3.4%
Anthophyllite
and 2.2%
Chrysotile
NA
NA
NAD
Roof material
Flashing
Flashing
Inconclusive
Inconclusive
Inconclusive
NAD
NAD
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Roof membrane
Inconclusive
Roof membrane
Inconclusive
Roof membrane
2.8%
Chrysotile
12
HA #
Sample #
Location
Material
PLM
Results
PLM-NOB
TEM-NOB
Inconclusive
NAD
Screed
Inconclusive
NAD
Roof membrane
under screed
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Roof membrane
Inconclusive
Inconclusive
NAD
NAD
Roof membrane
Inconclusive
NAD
Roof membrane
Screed
Inconclusive
Inconclusive
NAD
NAD
Screed
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
th
14 -floor roof park place
side
14th-floor roof park place
side
14th-floor roof park place
side
14th-floor roof W
Broadway side
5th floor roof east side
adjacent to entrance
5th floor roof southwest
corner
5th floor roof north side
5th floor roof east side
5th floor roof adjacent to
AC exhaust system
5th floor roof north side
5th floor roof east side
5th floor roof adjacent to
AC exhaust system
5th floor roof north side
15th Floor north side wall
15th Floor north side wall
adjacent to the Exit
15th Floor west side wall
15th Floor southwest
Section
15th Floor southeast
section
15th Floor East Side Wall
15th Floor Northeast
Section
69
EN07
69
EN08
69
EN09
70
EN10-12
71
EN13
71
EN14
71
72
EN15
EN16
72
EN17
72
73
EN18
EN19
73
EN20
73
74
EN21
EN22
74
EN23
74
EN24
74
EN25
74
EN26
74
EN27
74
EN28
75
EN29
15th Floor North Side
75
EN30
15th Floor Northwest
Side
75
EN31
15th Floor West Side
Screed
Screed
NAD
Screed
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Expansion joint
caulking
Expansion joint
caulking
Expansion joint
caulking
th
74
EN32
74
EN33
74
EN34
74
EN35
74
EN36
74
EN37
74
EN38
75
EN39
75
EN40
75
EN41
6 Floor North Side SetBack Roof
6th Floor Northwest Side
Set-Back Roof
6th Floor Southwest Side
Set-Back Roof
6th Floor Southeast Side
Roof
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
6th Floor East Side
Brick wall mortar
NAD
6th Floor Northeast Roof
6th Floor Northeast
Section Park Place Side
6th Floor North Side
Above the Window
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Brick wall mortar
NAD
Expansion joint
caulking
Expansion joint
6th Floor Northwest Side caulking
Expansion joint
caulking
6th Floor West Side
13
HA #
Sample #
Location
st
76
EN42-44
77
EN45
77
EN46-48
78
EN49-51
79
EN52-54
80
EN55
80
EN56
81
EN57-59
82
EN60-62
83
84
84
84
85
86
86
86
86
MP1-3
MP4
MP5
MP6
MP7-10
MP11
MP12
MP13
MP14
87
MP15-17
88
MP01-03
89
MP04-06
90
MP07-09
91
DT01-03
92
DT04-06
93
DT01
93
DT02-03
94
DT04-06
Material
PLM
Results
PLM-NOB
TEM-NOB
Inconclusive
NAD
Marble caulking
gray
Inconclusive
NAD
NAD
1 Floor Exterior of the
building Greenwich Side
Marble
mortar/sealant
1st Floor exterior
Greenwich side adjacent
to the steps
1st Floor exterior
adjacent to the main
entrance W Broadway
side
1st Floor exterior left side
of Main entrance W.
Broadway side
1st Floor exterior
adjacent to the main
entrance btwn. Wall &
sidewalk W Broadway
side
Marble mortar
gray
NAD
Marble mortar
gray
NAD
Marble caulking
black
Inconclusive
1st Floor exterior window
frame & marble wall
Window frame
caulking gray
3.5%
Anthophyllite
and 1.3%
Chrysotile
1st Floor exterior window
frame & marble wall
1st Floor exterior building
column
1st Floor exterior building
column W. Broadway
side
6th Floor Exterior North
6th Floor Exterior North
6th Floor Exterior West
6th Floor Exterior West
15th Floor Exterior North
15th Floor Exterior North
15th Floor Exterior East
15th Floor Exterior South
15th Floor Exterior West
Exterior Ceiling – NW
Entrance
3rd Floor Interior
Spandrel
6th Floor Interior
Spandrel
14th Floor Interior
Spandrel
3rd Floor South Side
Ceiling
3rd Floor South Side
Ceiling
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
Window frame
caulking gray
Column caulking
dark gray
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
NA
Inconclusive
NAD
Spandrel Flashing
Spandrel Mastic
Spandrel Mastic
Spandrel Mastic
Spandrel Flashing
Spandrel Mastic
Spandrel Mastic
Spandrel Mastic
Spandrel Mastic
Inconclusive
6.4% Chrys.
7% Chrys.
6.1% Chrys.
Inconclusive
5.5% Chrys.
6.2% Chrys.
6.7% Chrys.
6.1% Chrys.
NAD
NAD
Glue Daub
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Flashing
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
Column mortar
dark black
Black tar on
concrete
NAD
NAD
Black tar
Black roof
tar/paper
Black roof
tar/paper
Brown roof
insulation
14
6.4% Chrys.
NA
NAD
HA #
Sample #
Location
th
95
DT07-09
96
DT11-13
97
DT14-16
98
DT17-19
99
DT20-22
100
DT23-25
101
DT01-03
102
DT04
102
DT05-06
103
103
104
105
DT01
DT02-03
DT04
DT05-06
14 Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
14th Floor Setback Roof
N. Side
16th Floor Water Tank
5th Floor Column South
Side
5th Floor Column South
Side
Cooler Roof Walls
Cooler Roof Walls
Cooler Roof Walls
Cooler Roof Walls
Material
PLM
Results
Black roof
membrane
Brown roof paper
NAD
Red brick material
NAD
Brown roof cloth
NAD
Black roof
insulation
Brown roof
insulation
Black roof paper
White Pipe
Insulation
White Pipe
Insulation
Black roof shingle
Black roof shingle
Black roof tar
Black roof tar
NAD*=No Asbestos Detected
NA**=Not Analyzed
15
PLM-NOB
TEM-NOB
Inconclusive
NAD
Inconclusive
NAD
NAD
NAD
31%
Chrys.
NA
2.7% Chrys.
NA
5.8% Chrys.
NA
APPENDIX B
10.0 File Search Data
(Previous report reviewed: ATS, Inc. 06/97)
APPENDIX C
11.0
Personnel Licenses
APPENDIX D
12.0
Laboratory Accreditations
APPENDIX E
13.0 ACM Location Drawings