LIFE PRICING FUNDAMENTALS Richard MacMinn Understand the law of large numbers as it relates to insurance. Describe insurers’ pricing objectives and explain why they are of relevance to the life insurer and consumer. Outline elements of life insurance rate making including the assumptions made in the absence of perfect information. Draw distinctions between participating and guaranteed cost, nonparticipating life insurance. Explain how asset share analysis is used to test the adequacy of life insurance rates. 28 June 2016 OBJECTIVES Copyright macminn.org 2 28 June 2016 LAW OF LARGE NUMBERS Copyright macminn.org The Weak Law of Large Numbers: For each n = 1, 2, . . ., suppose that R1, R2, . . . , Rn are independent random variables on a given probability space, each having finite mean and variance. Assume that the variances are uniformly bounded; that is, assume that there is 2i M for some finite positive number M such that n all i. Let Sn Ri Then, i 1 S E Sn P n 0 as n n 3 Adequacy Equity The payments generated by a block of policies plus any investment return on same must be sufficient to cover the current and future benefits and costs Copyright macminn.org 28 June 2016 PRICING OBJECTIVES This equity refers to setting premiums commensurate with the expected losses and expenses; it also suggests no cross subsidization. The equity notion sets a floor. Not excessive The excessive notion sets a ceiling Regulation Competition 4 Probability of insured event Mortality and morbidity tables Copyright macminn.org 28 June 2016 ELEMENTS OF RATE MAKING Time value of money Premiums paid now Interest on accumulated funds Promised benefit period of coverage level of coverage type of coverage Loading or expenses, taxes, contingencies and profit 5 LIFE INSURANCE RATE COMPUTATION Yearly renewable term life insurance 6 The YRT covers the life for one year at a set premium and is renewable The YRT premium for a 30 year old male would be $1.73 per $1,000 of coverage while it would be $1.38 for a female the same age. If investment income is included then the company would set the premium at $1.65 and $1.31 for males and females respectively Table 2-5 Illustrative Net Level Premium Calculation 1 2 3 Policy Year 1 2 3 4 5 4 5 Net Level Present Value Number Premium to be of Total Net Living at the Present Value Paid Annually Level Beginning of Factor at 5% by Each Premiums [(2) Each Year Survivor x (3) x (4)] 1 1 1 1 1 100,000 67,000 41,205 21,427 7,328 Richard: This is the level premium or premium per year. 1.0000 0.9524 0.9070 0.8638 0.8227 Total PV premium $100,000 $63,810 $37,374 $18,509 $6,029 $225,722 $395.40 The $225,722 is the present value per dollar in premiums paid each year of the policy. Hence, that times the premium per year must equal the present value of the claims, i.e., the $89,251,339. By altering the interest rate in table 2-3 cell C1 is possible to see how the level premium changes in table 2-5 cell E12 Single premium plan Level premium plan 28 June 2016 Copyright macminn.org Richard D. MacMinn: This allows us to calculate the present value of a one dollar premium flow per customer. SINGLE PREMIUM PLAN This plan provides multiyear coverage for a single premium now This eliminates the rising premiums associated with the YRT. This gives the insurer the ability to generate compound interest and reduce the rate for coverage 7 Table 2-2 Modified Version of 1980 CSO Mortality Table 1 2 3 4 Age Number Living (Beginning of Year) Probability of Death (During the Year) Number Dying (During the year) 95 100,000 0.330 33000 96 67,000 0.385 25795 97 41,205 0.480 19778 98 21,427 0.658 14099 99 7,328 1.000 7328 100 0 28 June 2016 Copyright macminn.org Table 2-5 Illustrative Net Level Premium Calculation 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 5 Net Level Present Value Number Premium to be of Total Net Living at the Present Value Paid Annually Level Beginning of Factor at 5% by Each Premiums [(2) Each Year Survivor x (3) x (4)] 1 1 1 1 1 100,000 67,000 41,205 21,427 7,328 Richard: This is the level premium or premium per year. The $225,722 is the present value per dollar in premiums paid each year of the policy. Hence, that times the premium per year must equal the present value of the claims, i.e., the $89,251,339. By altering the interest rate in table 2-3 cell C1 is possible to see how the level premium changes in table 2-5 cell E12 1.0000 0.9524 0.9070 0.8638 0.8227 Total PV premium Richard D. MacMinn: This allows us to calculate the present value of a one dollar premium flow per customer. Copyright macminn.org Policy Year 4 28 June 2016 MODIFIED VERSION OF 1980 CSO MORTALITY TABLE $100,000 $63,810 $37,374 $18,509 $6,029 $225,722 $395.40 8 Table 2-5 Illustrative Net Level Premium Calculation 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 5 Net Level Present Value Number Premium to be of Total Net Living at the Present Value Paid Annually Level Beginning of Factor at 5% by Each Premiums [(2) Each Year Survivor x (3) x (4)] 1 1 1 1 1 100,000 67,000 41,205 21,427 7,328 Richard: This is the level premium or premium per year. The $225,722 is the present value per dollar in premiums paid each year of the policy. Hence, that times the premium per year must equal the present value of the claims, i.e., the $89,251,339. By altering the interest rate in table 2-3 cell C1 is possible to see how the level premium changes in table 2-5 cell E12 1.0000 0.9524 0.9070 0.8638 0.8227 Total PV premium Richard D. MacMinn: This allows us to calculate the present value of a one dollar premium flow per customer. Copyright macminn.org Policy Year 4 28 June 2016 PRESENT VALUE OF CLAIMS FOR 95-YEAROLD MALES $100,000 $63,810 $37,374 $18,509 $6,029 $225,722 $395.40 9 Table 2-5 Illustrative Net Level Premium Calculation 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 5 Net Level Present Value Number Premium to be of Total Net Living at the Present Value Paid Annually Level Beginning of Factor at 5% by Each Premiums [(2) Each Year Survivor x (3) x (4)] 1 1 1 1 1 100,000 67,000 41,205 21,427 7,328 Richard: This is the level premium or premium per year. The $225,722 is the present value per dollar in premiums paid each year of the policy. Hence, that times the premium per year must equal the present value of the claims, i.e., the $89,251,339. By altering the interest rate in table 2-3 cell C1 is possible to see how the level premium changes in table 2-5 cell E12 1.0000 0.9524 0.9070 0.8638 0.8227 Total PV premium $100,000 $63,810 $37,374 $18,509 $6,029 $225,722 Richard D. MacMinn: This allows us to calculate the present value of a one dollar premium flow per customer. Copyright macminn.org Policy Year 4 28 June 2016 POLICY RESERVES FOR NET SINGLEPREMIUM WHOLE LIFE INSURANCE $395.40 10 LEVEL PREMIUM PLAN 11 If some of the 100,000 policyholders prefer to pay premiums on an annual basis then how much must be charged per year to make the insurer indifferent between the single premium and the annual level premium? Let pt be the proportion of the insured population alive at the beginning of policy year t. Let at be the annuity factor for the premium payment stream. Let x be the level premium. Then x must satisfy the last equation on the RHS. 28 June 2016 T pt t1 t 1 (1 r) aT p1 p2 p4 1 1 p3 2 1r 1 r 1 1 p 5 3 4 1 r 1 r aT x pv T (L) Copyright macminn.org Table 2-5 Illustrative Net Level Premium Calculation 1 2 3 1 2 3 4 5 5 Net Level Present Value Number Premium to be of Total Net Living at the Present Value Paid Annually Level Beginning of Factor at 5% by Each Premiums [(2) Each Year Survivor x (3) x (4)] 1 1 1 1 1 100,000 67,000 41,205 21,427 7,328 Richard: This is the level premium or premium per year. The $225,722 is the present value per dollar in premiums paid each year of the policy. Hence, that times the premium per year must equal the present value of the claims, i.e., the $89,251,339. By altering the interest rate in table 2-3 cell C1 is possible to see how the level premium changes in table 2-5 cell E12 1.0000 0.9524 0.9070 0.8638 0.8227 Total PV premium $100,000 $63,810 $37,374 $18,509 $6,029 $225,722 Richard D. MacMinn: This allows us to calculate the present value of a one dollar premium flow per customer. Copyright macminn.org Policy Year 4 28 June 2016 NET LEVEL PREMIUM CALCULATION $395.40 12 EXPERIENCE PARTICIPATION IN Guaranteed-cost, non-participating insurance (without profits policies) Policy elements fixed at inception They offer no way of passing changes in mortality (morbidity), interest or loading to policyholders Participating insurance (with profits policies) Policy gives its owner the right to share in surplus accumulated due to experience Surplus is distributed as dividends Copyright macminn.org 28 June 2016 INSURANCE Current assumption insurance Policy allows values to deviate from those at policy inception on the upside and downside Unlike participating policies that adjust ex post the current assumption policy adjusts ex ante; for example, if the insurer expects a 7% return on investments backing policy reserves then the policyholders may get a promised 6.5% credited to their cash values. 13 Copyright macminn.org The asset share calculation is a simulation of the anticipated operating experience of a block of policies An example 28 June 2016 ASSET SHARE CALCULATION 14