Social Science Survey: GRIT Scale Office of Institutional Research and Assessment Fall 2012 MCC-Blue River, MCC-Longview, MCC-BTC MCC History This assessment began in Spring of 2012, when the 1st Social Science Survey was developed. It was administered at MCC-Blue River as a pilot project. The instrument included several demographic questions; along with the Ambition Inventory and GRIT Scale. After reviewing results, several revisions were made. The Ambition Scale was determined to be less robust and was deleted. Additional questions were added to look at students’ perception of control and its relationship to GRIT. Implementation was attempted throughout the district. The following campus locations participated: Blue River, Longview, and the Business and Technology Center. The survey was created in our ClassClimate survey system for a more professional look and data collection efficiency. Retention data from Spring 2012 There were 428 students who took the GRIT in spring 2012 and provided accurate Student ID’s. Of those students, 54 (13%) earned a degree or certificate and another 222 (52%) re-enrolled in the fall semester of 2012. The overall retention rate of this group is 59%. T-tests were performed to analyze differences between students GRIT score and their persistence. There was no significant GRIT score difference found between students who graduated or reenrolled and those who did not persist to Fall 2012. For this student group, “Grittiness” did not predict retention. Fall 2012 The survey was administered to 879 students at MCC. Blue River had 577 respondents (66%), Longview had 287 respondents (33%), and BTC had 15 respondents (2%). Of the 879 students who completed the survey, 822 (94%) were matched with student ID. Having the student ID allowed us to look at various educational factors for the student and their responses to the survey items. Figure 1 shows the percentage of students and the GRIT score. 1 Figure 1 GRIT score group by percentage Additionally, the following variables were analyzed for relationship with the GRIT score; Age, Fall 2012 Hours Attempted, Fall 2012 Hours Earned, Fall 2012 GPA, Cumulative GPA, MCC GPA, MCC Hours Attended prior, MCC Hours Earned prior, Total MCC Hours Attended, Total MCC Hours Earned, COMPASS Read scores, COMPASS English scores, MATH COMPASS scores, ACT comp scores, Grades for Course Completers, Q1-Expected grade, Q2-deserved grade, Q3-Time spent studying, Q4-Extent like studying. Table 1 (pg. 3) shows the variables that were significant with the GRIT scales. As you can see some correlations were positive and others were negative. This is because some of the questions were reverse keyed. A positive correlation means that as one variable increases, the other variables increases with it. 2 Table 1 Significance with the GRIT scale Fall 2012 Results GRIT Score # of Students Age Sig .257** 822 Term GPA Sig .183** 819 Cumulative GPA Sig .186** 813 MCC GPA Sig .189** 821 MCC Hours Attempted Prior Sig .063 822 MCC Hours Earned Prior Sig .078* 822 Tot MCC Hours Attempted Sig .080* 822 Tot MCC Hours Earned Sig .120** 822 **. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level. *. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level. ANOVAS Campus There was a significant difference by campus by GRIT Score. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum BR 577 3.496822648 .6081561444 .0253178716 3.447096044 3.546549253 .0000000 5.0000000 LV 287 3.413763064 .6599613908 .0389562892 3.337085663 3.490440466 .0000000 5.0000000 BTC 15 3.916666667 .4692953152 .1211715293 3.656779584 4.176553750 2.9166667 4.5833335 Total 879 3.476867654 .6268119070 .0211418409 3.435373206 3.518362101 .0000000 5.0000000 3 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 4.274 2 2.137 Within Groups 340.686 876 .389 Total 344.960 878 F Sig. 5.495 .004 1. What is the grade you expect to receive in this class? Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum A 321 3.643302183 .6303721657 .0351839433 3.574081118 3.712523248 .0000000 5.0000000 B 397 3.451721243 .5768754890 .0289525509 3.394801321 3.508641164 .0000000 5.0000000 C 149 3.193512305 .6313319278 .0517207268 3.091305814 3.295718797 .0000000 4.8333335 D 12 3.374999992 .7260485039 .2095921496 2.913690781 3.836309203 2.2500000 4.4166665 879 3.476867654 .6268119070 .0211418409 3.435373206 3.518362101 .0000000 5.0000000 Total ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 21.231 3 7.077 Within Groups 323.730 875 .370 Total 344.960 878 F Sig. 19.128 .000 2. What grade do you think you deserve in this course? Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum A 313 3.650159747 .6175791474 .0349076373 3.581475602 3.718843892 .0000000 5.0000000 B 403 3.451819686 .5817362628 .0289783473 3.394851656 3.508787717 .0000000 5.0000000 C 144 3.211805556 .6505836111 .0542153009 3.104638594 3.318972519 .0000000 4.8333335 D 17 3.161764694 .6900021357 .1673500993 2.806998332 3.516531056 2.0833333 4.4166665 F 2 3.166666700 .3535533906 .2500000000 -.009884484 6.343217884 2.9166667 3.4166667 879 3.476867654 .6268119070 .0211418409 3.435373206 3.518362101 .0000000 5.0000000 Total 4 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square F 21.650 4 5.412 Within Groups 323.310 874 .370 Total 344.960 878 Sig. 14.631 .000 3. How much do you study for this class each week?: Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N None Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 43 3.193798447 .6633650875 .1011622274 2.989644806 3.397952087 1.4166666 4.5000000 1 hr or less 205 3.335772355 .5533808872 .0386497977 3.259568061 3.411976650 1.7500000 4.9166665 Bet 2-3 Hrs 406 3.451970445 .6245592835 .0309963568 3.391036607 3.512904282 .0000000 5.0000000 Bet 4-5 Hrs 169 3.630670615 .6171955636 .0474765818 3.536943051 3.724398180 .0000000 4.7500000 6 Hrs or more Total 56 3.927083339 .5862616019 .0783425019 3.770081457 4.084085222 2.0833333 4.8333335 879 3.476867654 .6268119070 .0211418409 3.435373206 3.518362101 .0000000 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 23.127 4 5.782 Within Groups 321.833 874 .368 Total 344.960 878 F 15.701 Sig. .000 5 4. Which most accurately describes how you study? Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Didn’t Answer I have no difficulty Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 3 3.916666667 .1443375673 .0833333333 3.558112273 4.275221061 3.7500000 4.0000000 392 3.692389459 .6327089338 .0319566270 3.629561143 3.755217775 .0000000 5.0000000 studying I don't know how I don't need to 158 3.362869196 .5842861390 .0464833094 3.271055867 3.454682525 1.7500000 4.9166665 24 3.399305529 .4688220857 .0956979075 3.201339325 3.597271734 2.5833333 4.4166665 study I don't like to study I don't study Total 286 3.274475526 .5494399261 .0324890639 3.210526567 3.338424485 .0000000 4.8333335 16 2.973958350 .6809027296 .1702256824 2.611130897 3.336785803 1.4166666 4.0833335 879 3.476867654 .6268119070 .0211418409 3.435373206 3.518362101 .0000000 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 36.748 5 7.350 Within Groups 308.212 873 .353 Total 344.960 878 F 20.818 Sig. .000 6 5. What is the biggest challenge you face in terms of your ability to study? Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N No challenges Reading and Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 42 3.874999962 .6132706652 .0946297181 3.683891369 4.066108555 2.4166667 4.7500000 116 3.545258622 .6048707590 .0561608401 3.434014807 3.656502438 2.2500000 5.0000000 comprehending the material Focusing on the 142 3.327464786 .6532823032 .0548222331 3.219084987 3.435844585 .0000000 4.6666665 Managing Time 309 3.612189867 .6560977153 .0373240950 3.538747395 3.685632340 .0000000 4.9166665 Staying Motivated 270 3.309259260 .5140896556 .0312865001 3.247661711 3.370856809 1.4166666 5.0000000 Total 879 3.476867654 .6268119070 .0211418409 3.435373206 3.518362101 material .0000000 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 23.613 4 5.903 Within Groups 321.347 874 .368 Total 344.960 878 F 16.056 Sig. .000 7 6. Do you study about the same amount of time in all of your classes? Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for N Mean Std. Mean Std. Error Deviation Lower Yes 2 3.416666650 .8249579350 .5833333500 Maximum Upper Bound Bound 0 Minimum 3.995286325 10.828619625 2.8333333 4.0000000 379 3.554529469 .6724523089 .0345415549 3.486611804 3.622447134 .0000000 5.0000000 No, I spend a different amount of time for 130 3.392948715 .5931923006 .0520264064 3.290013196 3.495884235 1.8333334 4.7500000 Reading/English classes No, I spend a different amount of time for Math 171 3.410818708 .5783102272 .0442244884 3.323518829 3.498118587 2.0000000 4.8333335 classes No, I spend a different amount of time for Science 169 3.471893492 .5756931327 .0442840871 3.384468503 3.559318481 .0000000 4.7500000 classes I do not spend any time studying 28 3.252976189 .6104719623 .1153683568 3.016259874 3.489692504 1.4166666 4.1666665 outside of class Total 879 3.476867654 .6268119070 .0211418409 3.435373206 3.518362101 .0000000 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 5.362 5 1.072 Within Groups 339.598 873 .389 Total 344.960 878 F 2.757 Sig. .018 8 7. Do you think your study habits will change if you get a grade that is not what you desire? Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum 66 3.714646464 .6653931069 .0819042296 3.551072422 3.878220505 2.1666667 5.0000000 2 65 3.441025645 .5952508707 .0738317838 3.293529701 3.588521588 1.4166666 4.5833335 3 142 3.319248830 .6077685180 .0510028010 3.218419787 3.420077874 .0000000 4.7500000 4 243 3.408093276 .5924714144 .0380070590 3.333226396 3.482960156 .0000000 4.6666665 Very 338 3.560897438 .6343311099 .0345030638 3.493028936 3.628765941 .0000000 5.0000000 854 3.479996098 .6266426297 .0214432693 3.437908343 3.522083852 .0000000 5.0000000 Very Unlikely Likely Total ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 10.870 4 2.718 Within Groups 324.086 849 .382 Total 334.957 853 F 7.119 Sig. .000 9 8. I like to study. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Very much like Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 28 3.970238086 .5538001330 .1046583877 3.755496812 4.184979359 2.7500000 4.7500000 me Mostly like me 121 3.793388437 .5884792063 .0534981097 3.687465903 3.899310971 1.8333334 4.8333335 Somewhat like 267 3.564918854 .5195118025 .0317936060 3.502319713 3.627517994 2.0833333 4.8333335 me Not much like 296 3.411599101 .5352214461 .0311091147 3.350375177 3.472823024 1.8333334 5.0000000 me Not like me at 162 3.221193410 .5932185840 .0466076537 3.129152239 3.313234582 1.4166666 5.0000000 all Total 874 3.493897789 .5816967843 .0196761872 3.455279630 3.532515948 1.4166666 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 32.605 4 8.151 Within Groups 262.793 869 .302 Total 295.398 873 F 26.955 Sig. .000 10 9. I know how my current education will help me obtain my goal(s) for the future. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Very much like Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 489 3.651670077 .5657247141 .0255829559 3.601403737 3.701936417 1.8333334 5.0000000 me Mostly like me 263 3.344740176 .5321779051 .0328154954 3.280124506 3.409355846 1.7500000 4.8333335 Somewhat like 77 3.194805195 .5091649850 .0580247352 3.079238919 3.310371471 2.0000000 4.7500000 me Not much like 22 3.113636368 .4983739983 .1062536934 2.892669716 3.334603020 2.0833333 4.0833335 me Not like me at 11 3.068181818 .7672264335 .2313274736 2.552752087 3.583611550 1.4166666 4.2500000 all Total 862 3.496036351 .5816305152 .0198104140 3.457153995 3.534918707 1.4166666 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 30.082 4 7.521 Within Groups 261.189 857 .305 Total 291.271 861 F 24.676 Sig. .000 11 10. I feel overwhelmed with how much I need to do in a week. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Very much like Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 215 3.348837207 .5803371558 .0395786655 3.270823254 3.426851160 1.7500000 4.9166665 me Mostly like me 235 3.453191489 .5568322738 .0363237324 3.381628155 3.524754823 1.8333334 4.7500000 Somewhat like 247 3.497975713 .5768086194 .0367014536 3.425686542 3.570264884 2.0000000 5.0000000 me Not much like 139 3.678057555 .5408253799 .0458722100 3.587354271 3.768760838 1.4166666 4.8333335 me Not like me at all Total 33 3.876262636 .6535563933 .1137695650 3.644521616 4.108003657 2.5000000 5.0000000 869 3.492136557 .5829372611 .0197747922 3.453324557 3.530948556 1.4166666 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 14.454 4 3.613 Within Groups 280.506 864 .325 Total 294.960 868 F 11.130 Sig. .000 12 11. I have difficulty balancing school and my personal life. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Very much like Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 127 3.225721787 .6055947197 .0537378417 3.119376178 3.332067395 1.4166666 4.6666665 me Mostly like me 183 3.346994536 .5620489607 .0415478547 3.265017125 3.428971946 1.8333334 4.7500000 Somewhat like 249 3.508701476 .5260700541 .0333383351 3.443039103 3.574363849 1.7500000 4.9166665 me Not much like 226 3.615781704 .5250436278 .0349253826 3.546959023 3.684604384 2.0000000 4.8333335 me Not like me at 84 3.828373036 .6354845253 .0693370462 3.690464440 3.966281632 2.3333333 5.0000000 all Total 869 3.492040661 .5817613289 .0197349014 3.453306955 3.530774367 1.4166666 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 25.889 4 6.472 Within Groups 267.882 864 .310 Total 293.771 868 F 20.875 Sig. .000 13 12. I have someone who supports my success in school. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Very much like Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 509 3.580222660 .5774010707 .0255928525 3.529941797 3.630503524 1.7500000 5.0000000 me Mostly like me 176 3.332859853 .5034403234 .0379482422 3.257964730 3.407754977 1.4166666 4.5833335 Somewhat like 89 3.347378273 .6407406552 .0679183736 3.212404778 3.482351769 1.8333334 4.9166665 me Not much like 56 3.431547616 .5937611463 .0793446707 3.272537343 3.590557889 2.4166667 4.7500000 me Not like me at 37 3.391891886 .6176621310 .1015430288 3.185953079 3.597830694 2.0833333 4.7500000 all Total 867 3.488465976 .5824762164 .0197819294 3.449639842 3.527292109 1.4166666 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 10.845 4 2.711 Within Groups 282.970 862 .328 Total 293.815 866 F 8.259 Sig. .000 14 13. I have many stressful things going on in my life. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Very much like Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 290 3.445114939 .6188752827 .0363416079 3.373587153 3.516642726 1.4166666 4.8333335 me Mostly like me 185 3.462612616 .5227956601 .0384367014 3.386779290 3.538445943 2.1666667 5.0000000 Somewhat like 220 3.531439399 .6218193231 .0419230502 3.448815130 3.614063667 1.7500000 4.9166665 me Not much like 135 3.503086415 .4994199938 .0429832293 3.418073077 3.588099753 2.0000000 4.7500000 me Not like me at 44 3.695075770 .5702982173 .0859756912 3.521689265 3.868462276 2.6666667 5.0000000 all Total 874 3.492086195 .5823241570 .0196974084 3.453426385 3.530746004 1.4166666 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 2.971 4 .743 Within Groups 293.065 869 .337 Total 296.036 873 F 2.202 Sig. .067 15 14. I have difficulty balancing school and other responsibilities (including work, home, and family matters) Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Very much like Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Upper Bound Bound Minimum Maximum 165 3.219696968 .5881833009 .0457900079 3.129283015 3.310110922 1.4166666 4.6666665 me Mostly like me 177 3.365819210 .5253253891 .0394858742 3.287892480 3.443745941 1.8333334 4.7500000 Somewhat like 256 3.519205727 .5554101711 .0347131357 3.450844782 3.587566672 1.7500000 4.7500000 me Not much like 208 3.639423078 .5249980575 .0364020657 3.567656755 3.711189401 1.8333334 4.8333335 me Not like me at 64 3.968750019 .5751504827 .0718938103 3.825081703 4.112418335 2.6666667 5.0000000 all Total 870 3.493007664 .5837980714 .0197926083 3.454160759 3.531854569 1.4166666 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 34.308 4 8.577 Within Groups 261.864 865 .303 Total 296.173 869 F 28.332 Sig. .000 16 Ethnicity There was no difference in means by ethnicity. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum White 618 3.468716291 .6137576720 .0246889543 3.420231722 3.517200861 Black 67 3.613184078 .5695894442 .0695864259 3.474250296 3.752117860 2.0833333 4.7500000 Hispanic 45 3.518518516 .5819488166 .0867518076 3.343681736 3.693355296 2.0833333 4.5000000 Asian 14 3.482142843 .6802922858 .1818157612 3.089353771 3.874931915 2.2500000 4.5000000 Am Indian 4 3.583333350 .2256677417 .1128338708 3.224245615 3.942421085 3.4166667 3.9166667 Unspecified 7 3.511904771 .3348181199 .1265493542 3.202249657 3.821559886 3.1666667 4.0000000 Pac Islander 8 3.822916713 .5222006436 .1846258081 3.386346049 4.259487376 3.0000000 4.5833335 Multi Racial 59 3.484463281 .7689923801 .1001142805 3.284062776 3.684863787 .0000000 5.0000000 822 3.488949718 .6184786091 .0215719187 3.446607112 3.531292324 .0000000 5.0000000 Total .0000000 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 2.260 7 .323 Within Groups 311.786 814 .383 Total 314.045 821 F Sig. .843 .552 Age There was a significant difference in means by Age. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Std. N Mean Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum 16 - 20 488 3.344945358 .5701743138 .0258105784 3.294231518 3.395659198 .0000000 4.5833335 21-25 187 3.583778969 .6492170504 .0474754526 3.490119391 3.677438547 .0000000 4.9166665 26-30 65 3.866666655 .5996237188 .0743741688 3.718087173 4.015246138 2.5833333 5.0000000 31-35 29 3.775862066 .4410167295 .0818947507 3.608108273 3.943615858 2.7500000 4.4166665 36-40 26 3.878205150 .5779421476 .1133437803 3.644769265 4.111641035 2.5833333 4.5833335 41 and over 27 3.842592596 .6120815974 .1177951583 3.600461181 4.084724012 2.6666667 4.8333335 822 3.488949718 .6184786091 .0215719187 3.446607112 3.531292324 Total .0000000 5.0000000 17 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 30.778 5 6.156 Within Groups 283.267 816 .347 Total 314.045 821 F Sig. 17.733 .000 Admit Type There was a significant difference of means by admit type. Descriptives GRIT Score 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum TRN 73 3.549086753 .7137369607 .0835365927 3.382559599 3.715613907 .0000000 5.0000000 REG 404 3.510932344 .6374389066 .0317137709 3.448587259 3.573277429 .0000000 4.9166665 FTF 311 3.424705258 .5723447805 .0324546950 3.360845909 3.488564606 .0000000 5.0000000 DEG 13 3.916666685 .3154948964 .0875025405 3.726015027 4.107318342 3.4166667 4.4166665 Total 801 3.487515608 .6197699438 .0218984942 3.444530315 3.530500901 .0000000 5.0000000 ANOVA GRIT Score Sum of Squares Between Groups df Mean Square 4.119 3 1.373 Within Groups 303.172 797 .380 Total 307.292 800 F 3.610 Sig. .013 18