CHAPTER 14: INTEREST RATE DERIVATIVES END-OF-CHAPTER QUESTIONS AND PROBLEMS 1. Fixed- for floating-rate swaps are like a series of FRAs (forward rate agreements) and like issuing a fixed- or floating-rate bond and using the proceeds to buy the other type of bond. For example, if you enter into a swap to pay fixed and receive floating, you have entered into a series of FRAs. On a series of future dates, you have committed to paying interest at a specific rate and receiving interest at a rate determined at the beginning of the interest payment period. This is exactly like a series of FRAs. Each FRA matches a swap payment. The first swap payment, however, is not an FRA as that payment value is known. It is more like taking out a short-term fixed rate loan and using the proceeds to lend at a different short-term rate. The remaining swap payments, however, are identical to those on a series of FRAs. Alternatively, the swap can be viewed as issuing a fixed-rate bond and using the proceeds to buy a floating-rate bond. The floating-rate bond interest payments would be set at the beginning of the interest payment period and the interest is paid at the end. 2. An interest rate option requires that you pay a premium up front. Take an interest rate call for example. When the option expires, you decide whether to exercise it. In effect, you have the right to receive a floating interest rate and pay a fixed interest rate. You would choose to do that if the floating interest rate were higher. The actual payment you receive occurs at a later date. With an FRA you pay nothing up front, but agree that on the expiration date you will make an interest payment at a predetermined fixed interest rate and receive an interest payment at a floating rate. A financial manager might want to buy an interest rate call or FRA to protect against a future interest rate increase. In the case of the interest rate call, the manager can still benefit if rates go down, but that comes at the expense of having to pay a premium up front. With an FRA, the manager will gain if rates go up and lose if rates go down but pays no up-front premium. So the manager saves the up-front premium by giving up the right to gain if rates fall. 3. There are several ways to terminate a swap and you might wish to build these features into the swap contract. One way is to allow you to have a third party take over your payments. Obviously your counterparty would need to agree and would put some restrictions on the credit quality of this third party. Another feature you might want is to allow you to terminate the swap by paying the counterparty the market value or having it pay you the market value. You might also want to buy an option to terminate the swap early. This would require an up-front premium. You can also terminate a swap by entering into an offsetting swap but this would not require the original counterparty's approval up-front or later because your original swap remains on the books. 4. Most interest rate derivatives, specifically swaps and options, pay off later than the expiration or settlement date. For example, at the expiration of an interest rate option, the underlying interest rate is compared to the exercise rate. If the option is in-the-money, it pays off but at a later date. If the underlying rate is, for example, the rate on a 90-day Eurodollar, the payoff will typically occur ninety days later. This is in keeping with the fact that on a given day, the 90-day Eurodollar rate as of that date implies an interest payment that will be made ninety days later. A similar procedure occurs on the settlement dates of a swap. On an FRA, however, the payoff typically occurs on the expiration date. This type of payoff is called in-arrears and can be done on a swap or option, though that is the exception. It is possible to set up an FRA to pay off with a delayed settlement but that is the exception. 5. A cap is nothing more than a series of interest rate call options. A cap is designed to protect against a series of floating rate resets, such as might be encountered when one makes periodic interest payments at a floating rate. A cap is a portfolio of interest rate options, with each option designed to protect against the interest adjustment on a specific date. The value of a cap is the sum of the values of the individual interest rate options that make up the cap, which are called caplets. An interest rate call that is not part of a cap protects only against a single rate increase. 14-1 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc 6. The two types of swaptions are payer swaptions and receiver swaptions. A swaption is an option to enter into a swap. A payer swaption is the right to enter into a swap as a fixed-rate payer and a receiver swaption is the right to enter into a swap as a fixed-rate receiver. The underlying is the rate on a specific type of swap. For example, consider a two-year payer swaption on a five-year swap on the 180-day LIBOR. It expires in two years. At expiration, the swaption will be in-the-money if the rate on a five-year swap based on 180-day LIBOR exceeds the exercise rate specified in the swaption. Because swap rates are directly related to interest rates, a payer swaption is similar to an interest rate call or cap. When an interest rate call or cap is exercised, however, it provides a payoff based on the difference between the interest rate and the exercise rate. When a payer swaption is exercised, its permits the holder to establish a swap, paying the exercise rate. Because swaps in the market can be established at the higher market rate, the value of the swaption when it is exercised is determined by the value of an annuity of length equal to the length of the underlying swap and where the annuity payments equal the difference between the market rate and the exercise rate. A receiver swaption works just the opposite and is more like an interest rate put or floor. 7. A forward swap is a type of forward contract and, as such, carries the obligation to enter into a swap. A swaption is an option and, as such, is the right to enter into a swap. A forward swap, like any forward contract, does not require an up-front payment whereas a swaption, like an option, does require an up-front payment. 8. A binomial term structure model has the same advantages of a binomial model for pricing options on stocks. It permits a specification of the evolution of the underlying variable, such as the one-period interest rate. Some instruments, such as American options, cannot typically be priced any other way. In fact some European-style instruments cannot be priced any other way. In addition it can be structured so as to guarantee that no arbitrage opportunities are possible across the entire term structure. It is, however, slower and should not be used when a formula such as Black-Scholes is available. 9. An interest rate cap provides protection against increases in the interest rate over the exercise rate at the expense of having to pay cash up front. By combining a short position in an interest rate floor, you obtain an interest rate collar, which will provide the same protection, but the firm can pay for it in a different way. When a party buys an interest rate floor, it obtains protection if rates fall below the floor exercise rate. By selling a floor, a firm receives a premium up front as compensation for the possibility that it will have to make payments to the floor holder if rates fall below the floor exercise rate. Thus, if the buyer of a cap sells a floor with a lower exercise rate, the payment received up front from the floor can partially or wholly offset the payment made for the cap. The disadvantage of a collar is that the gains from falling interest rates below the lower strike are forgone. 10. a. LIBOR = 14 % The FRA payoff will be $5,000,000(.14 - .12)(90/360) = $25,000, which will be paid to the firm. The loan interest will be $5,000,000(.14)(90/360) = $175,000. Thus, the net interest paid when the loan matures is $150,000. This is a rate of $5,150,000 $5,000,000 365/90 - 1 = .1274 14-2 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc b. LIBOR = 8 % The FRA payoff will be $5,000,000(.08 - .12)(90/360) = -$50,000, which means that the firm will have to pay $50,000. The loan interest will be $5,000,000(.08)(90/360) = $100,000. Thus, the net interest paid when the loan matures is $150,000. This is the same outcome as in a. 11. Date Now 90 days later 180 days later 270 days later 360 days later LIBOR 11.5 10.5 10.2 9.6 ---- Floating Payment -------575,000 525,000 510,000 480,000 Fixed Payment ------550,000 550,000 550,000 550,000 Net Payment to Fixed ---------25,000 -25,000 -40,000 -70,000 The first floating payment is determined as $20,000,000 (.115)(90/360) = $575,000. All remaining payments are similarly calculated based on LIBOR at the beginning of the period. The fixed payments are all $20,000,000 (.11)(90/360) = $550,000. 12. First convert the rates to discount factors: 1/(1 + .12(180/360)) = 0.9434 1/(1 + .1225(360/360)) = 0.8909 1/(1 + .1275(540/360)) = 0.8395 1/(1 + .1302(720/360)) = 0.7934 The swap rate is the coupon rate that will give a $25 million bond issue priced using the above discount factors a value of $25 million. Set this up first with a $1 notional principal. That is, coupon(0.9434) + coupon(0.8909) + coupon(0.8395) + (coupon + 1)(0.7934) = 1. The solution is found as 1 − 0.7934 = .0596 . 0.9434 + 0.8909 + 0.8395 + 0.7934 Thus, on the basis of $25 million, the swap payment would be .0596($25,000,000) = $1,490,000. Quoted on an annual basis, the swap rate would be .0592(2) = .1192. 13. First convert these rates to discount factors: 1/(1 + .0975(90/360)) = 0.9762 1/(1 + .09875(270/360)) = 0.9310 1/(1 + .10(450/360)) = 0.8889 First we find the present value of the fixed coupons as the present value of a fixed rate bond. The fixed coupon is $10,000,000(.12/2) = $600,000. The present value (including the principal) is 600,000(0.9762) + 600,000(0.9310) + 10,600,000(0.8889) = 10,566,660. 14-3 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc The upcoming floating payment is $10,000,000(.1025/2) = $512,500. We need the present value of this and the present value of the remaining floating payments. But on the next coupon date, we know that the present value of the remaining floating payments plus the final principal will be $10 million. Thus, we need calculate only 512,500(0.9762) + 10,000,000(0.9762) = 10,262,303. Thus, the value of the swap is 10,262,303 – 10,566,660 = -304,357. 14. First we must solve for the rate on a four-year swap at the swaption’s expiration. This is the solution to the following equation: c(1.10)-1 + c(1.105)-2 + c(1.109)-3 + (c + 1)(1.112)-4 = 1.000 Solving gives c = .1111. With a strike rate of 11.75 percent, the receiver swaption expires in-the-money. Then to determine the payoff value of the swaption, we must find the value of a four-year annuity of (.1175 .1111) = .0064, using the 1-, 2-, 3- and 4-year zero coupon rates. (.1175 - .1111)[(1.10)-1 + (1.105)-2 + (1.109)-3 + (1.112)-4] = .0199. Based on a $20 million notional principal, the value of the swaption at expiration is $398,000. In other words, this swaption allows the holder to enter into a four-year swap receiving 11.75 percent, while in the market, four-year swaps pay 11.11 percent. Thus, the holder can use the swaption to enter into the swap, receiving 11.75 percent, and simultaneously enter into a swap in the market paying 11.11 percent. Alternatively, the two parties to the swaption can settle by having the writer pay the holder of the swaption cash of $398,000. As another alternative, the holder of the swaption can simply enter into the swap receiving promised payments of 11.75 percent and hold the position. 15. LIBOR at 6 percent The option expires worthless. At the beginning of the loan the option premium has a future value of 32,000(1 + (.09+.025)(45/360)) = 32,460. The interest owed will be 10,000,000(.085)(180/360) = 425,000. Thus you effectively borrowed 10,000,000 - 32,460 = 9,967,540 and effectively paid back 10,000,000 + 425,000 = 10,425,000. The annualized rate is (10,425,000/9,967,540)365/180 - 1 = .0953. LIBOR at 12 percent The option is worth (.12 - .09)(180/360)(10,000,000) = 150,000. Again, the option premium has a future value of 32,460. The interest owed will be 10,000,000 (.145)(180/360) = 725,000. Again, you borrowed 9,967,540 and effectively paid back 10,000,000 + 725,000 - 150,000 = 10,575,000. The annualized rate is (10,575,000/9,967,540)365/180 - 1 = .1275. 16. LIBOR at 6.5 percent The option is worth (.095 - .065)(90/360)(25,000,000) = 187,500. The option premium has a future value of 60,000(1 + (.095+.01)(30/360)) = 60,525. The interest received will be 25,000,000(.075)(90/360) = 468,750. Thus you effectively lent 25,000,000 + 60,525 = 25,060,525 and effectively received 25,000,000 + 468,750 + 187,500 = 25,656,250 for an annualized rate of (25,656,250/25,060,525)365/90 - 1 = .10. 14-4 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc LIBOR at 12.5 percent The option expires worthless. Again, the option premium has a future value of 60,525. The interest received will be 25,000,000(.135(90/360)) = 843,750. Thus you lent (25,000,000+60,525) = 25,060,525 and effectively received 25,000,000 + 843,750 = 25,843,750 for an annualized return of (25,843,750/25,060,525)365/90 - 1 = .1329. 17. Date 6/28 9/28 12/31 3/31 6/29 Days -92 94 90 90 LIBOR 10.00 11.00 11.65 12.04 ---- Interest Due -----511,111 574,444 582,500 602,000 Cap Principal Payment Repayment (70,000) 0 0 0 52,222 0 82,500 0 102,000 20,000,000 Net Cash Flow 19,930,000 (511,111) (522,222) (500,000) (20,500,000) Without Cap Net Cash Flow 20,000,000 (511,111) (574,444) (582,500) (20,602,000) Interest Due: On 9/28 you owe 20,000,000(.10)(92/360) = 511,111 based on LIBOR on 6/28. All remaining figures are calculated similarly based on the number of days during the period. Cap Payment: 70,000 paid for cap on 6/28. Cap pays off 20,000,000(.11 - .10)(94/360) = 52,222 on 12/31 based on LIBOR on 9/28. Remaining figures are calculated similarly. Principal Repayment: 20,000,000 paid on 6/29 to pay off loan. Net Cash Flow: -Interest Due + Cap Payment - Principal Repayment. Figure on 6/28 also reflects receipt of 20,000,000. Without Cap Net Cash Flow: -Interest Due - Principal Repayment. The internal rate of return with the cap is 19,930,000 = 511,111 522,222 500,000 20,500,000 + + + 2 3 (1 + y) (1 + y ) (1 + y ) (1 + y )4 y = .026, annualized to (1.026)4 - 1 = .108 18. Date 4/15 7/16 10/15 1/16 4/16 Days --92 91 93 90 LIBOR 8.00 7.90 7.70 8.10 ---- Interest Received ------715,556 698,931 696,208 708,750 Floor Payment (60,000) 0 8,847 27,125 0 Principal Repayment 0 0 0 0 35,000,000 Net Cash Flow (35,060,000) 715,556 707,778 723,333 35,708,750 Without Floor Net Cash Flow (35,000,000) 715,556 698,931 696,208 35,708,750 Interest Received: On 7/16, 35,000,000(.08)(92/360) = 715,556. All remaining figures calculated similarly based on LIBOR at beginning of period and number of days in period. Floor Payment: 60,000 paid for floor on 4/15. On 10/15 floor pays off (.08 - .079)(91/360)(35,000,000) = 8,847. All remaining figures calculated similarly. Floor does not pay off on 4/16 because LIBOR on 1/16 is above 8. Principal Repayment: 35,000,000 principal is paid off on 4/16. Net Cash Flow: Interest Received + Floor Payment + Principal Repayment. On 4/15 also reflects payment of 35,000,000. 14-5 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc Without Floor Net Cash Flow: Interest Received + Principal Repayment. The internal rate of return with the floor is 35,060,000 = 715,556 707,778 723,333 35,708,750 + + + (1 + y) (1 + y ) 2 (1 + y )3 (1 + y ) 4 y = .0199, annualized to (1.0199)4 - 1 = .0821. 19. a. A collar. Selling the floor reduces the effective cost of the cap. The firm gives up the chance to gain if interest rates fall. b. Date 1/15 4/16 7/15 10/14 1/15 Days --91 90 91 93 Interest Paid ------758,333 851,250 773,500 686,650 LIBOR 10.00 11.35 10.20 8.86 -- Cap Payment (150,000) 0 101,250 15,167 0 Floor Payment 115,000 0 0 0 (10,850) Principal Repayment 0 0 0 0 30,000,000 With Collar Net Cash Flow 29,965,000 (758,333) (750,000) (758,333) (30,697,500) All calculations are done the same way as in problems 17 and 18 with one exception. In problem 18 the firm bought the floor. Here the firm sells the floor so it receives cash up front and pays out cash whenever LIBOR is less than 9. Thus on 1/15 (at maturity) the floor pays 30,000,000(.09 .0886)(93/360) = 10,850. The internal rate of return is 29,965,000 = 758,333 750,000 758,333 30,697,500 + + + (1 + y) (1 + y ) 2 (1 + y )3 (1 + y ) 4 y = .0249, annualized to (1.0249)4 - 1 = .1034. c. The firm needs to adjust the strike on the floor such that its premium offsets the $150,000 premium on the cap. The floor premium is $115,000 when the strike is 9 percent. To raise the premium, it would have to raise the floor, meaning that the firm would have to give up the benefits of falling rates starting at a rate higher than 9 percent. This would then be a zero cost collar. 14-6 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc 20. f0 = .1322 X = .12 rc = .1128 d1 = σ = .17 ln(.1322/. 12) + (.17 ) 2 /2(.1233) T = 45/365 = .1233 = 1.65 .17 .1233 N(1.65) = .9505 d 2 = 1.65 - .17 .1233 = 1.59 N(1.59) = .9441 C = (e -.1128(.1233) [.1322(.95 05) - .12(.9441) ]) e-.1322(180/365) = .0114 For every $1,000,000 of calls sold, this will amount to $1,000,000(.0114)(180/360) = $5,700. 21. For the first caplet: f0 = .08 X = .07 rc = .071 d1 = σ = .166 ln(.08/.07 ) + (.166 ) 2 /2(.2493) T = 91/365 = .2493 = 1.65 .166 .2493 N(1.65) = .9505 d 2 = 1.65 - .166 .2493 = 1.57 N(1.57) = .9418 C = (e -.071(.249 3) [.08(.9505 ) - .07(.9418) ]) e -.08(90/365) = .0097 For $10,000,000 notional principal, this will amount to $10,000,000(.0097)(90/360) = $24,250. For the second caplet: f0 = .082 X = .07 rc = .073 d1 = σ = .166 ln(.082/.0 7) + (.166 ) 2 /2(.4986) T = 182/365 = .4986 = 1.41 .166 .4986 N(1.41) = .9207 d 2 = 1.41 - .166 .4986 = 1.29 N(1.29) = .9015 C = ( e-.073(.4986) [.082(.920 7) - .07(.9015) ]) e-.082(90/365) = .0117 For $10,000,000 notional principal, this will amount to $10,000,000(.0117)(90/360) = $29,250. The total cost of the cap is, thus, $24,250 + $29,250 = $53,500. 14-7 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc 22. a. The binomial tree is as follows, with the probabilities in parentheses: Time 0 Time 1 Time 2 Time 3 Time 4 16.86 % (.0915) 15.68 % (.1664) 12.41 % (.3025) 9.47 % (.55) 6% 13.46 % (.2995) 12.31 % (.4084) 9.13 % (.4950) 6.28 % (.45) 10.16 % (.3675) 9.04 % (.3341) 5.95% (.2025) 6.95 % (.2005) 5.86 % (.0911) 3.83 % (.0410) In each node of the tree, the probability is calculated by raising .55 to the power of the number of times the rate went up to reach that node, times .45 to the power of the number of times the rate went down to reach that node, times the number of ways the rate could get to that node. The number of ways the rate could get to each cell is discussed in the book. b. The solution for the in-arrears FRA is the rate FRA 2 in the following equation: .3025(.1241 - FRA 2) + .4950(.0913 - FRA 2) + .2025(.0595 - FRA 2) = 0 Solving gives FRA 2 = .0948. The solution for the delayed settlement FRA is the rate FRA 2 in the following equation: .3025(.1241 - FRA 2)(1.1241)-1 + .4950(.0913 - FRA 2)(1.0913)-1 + .2025(.0595 - FRA 2)(1.0595)-1 = 0 Solving gives FRA 2 = .0943. c. Swap pricing is easily done using only the time 0 zero coupon discount rates. It is the solution c to the following: c(1.06)-1 + c(1.07)-2 + (c + 1.00)(1.078)-3 = 1.00 Solving gives c = .0771. 14-8 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc d. The payoffs of the put in the five states at time 4 are Max(0,.10 - .1686) /1.1686= 0 Max(0,.10 - .1346) /1.1346= 0 Max(0,.10 - .1016) /1.1016= 0 Max(0,.10 - .0695) /1.0695= .0285 Max(0,.10 - .0383) /1.0383= .0594 The prices in the four states at time 3 are [.55(0) + .45(0)]/1.1568 = 0 [.55(0) + .45(0)]/1.1231 = 0 [.55(0) + .45(.0285)]/1.0904 = .0118 [.55(.0285) + .45(.0594)]/1.0586 = .0401 The prices in the three states at time 2 are [.55(0) + .45(0)]/1.1241 = 0 [.55(0) + .45(.0118)]/1.0913 = .0049 [.55(.0118) + .45(.0401)]/1.0595 = .0232 The prices in the two states at time 1 are [.55(0) + .45(.0049)]/1.0947) = .0020 [.55(.0049) + .45(.0232)]/1.0628 = .0124 The price at time 0 is, therefore, [.55(.0020) + .45(.0124)]/1.06 = .0063 e. To price a three-period cap, we must price 1-, 2- and 3-period interest rate calls or caplets. For the three-period caplet, we have the following: The payoffs at time 3 are as follows: Max(0,.1568 - .09)/1.1568 = .0577 Max(0,.1231 - .09)/1.1231 = .0295 Max(0,.0904 - .09)/1.0904 = .0004 Max(0,.0586 - .09)/1.0586 = 0 The prices at time 2 are as follows: [.55(.0577) + .45(.0295)]/1.1241 = .0400 [.55(.0295) + .45(.0004)]/1.0913 = .0150 [.55(.0004) + .45(.0)]/1.0595 = .0002 14-9 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc The prices at time 1 are as follows: [.55(.0400) + .45(.0150)]/1.0947 = .0263 [.55(.0150) + .45(.0002)]/1.0628 = .0078 The price at time 0 is, therefore, [.55(.0263) + .45(.0078)]/1.06 = .0170 For the two-period caplet, we have the following: The payoffs at time 2 are as follows: Max(0,.1241 - .09)/1.1241 = .0303 Max(0,.0913 - .09)/1.0913 = .0012 Max(0,.0595 - .09)/1.0595 = 0 The prices at time 1 are as follows: [.55(.0303) + .45(.0012)] 1.0947= .0157 [.55(.0012) + .45(.0)]/1.0628 = .0006 The price at time 0 is, therefore, [.55(.0157) + .45(.0006)]/1.06 = .0084 For the one-period caplet, we have the following: The payoffs at time 1 are as follows: Max(0,.0947 - .09)/1.0947 = .0043 Max(0,.0628 - .09)/1.0628 = 0 The price at time 0 is, therefore, [.55(.0043) + .45(0)]/1.06 = .0022 The three-period cap is worth the sum of the prices of the three component caplets, .0170 + .0084 + .0022 = .0276 f. We must find the rate on a two-period swap in each of the three states at time 2. In the upper state c(1.1241)-1 + (c + 1.00)(1.1233)-2 = 1.00 Solving for c gives .1233. In the middle state, c(1.0913)-1 + (c + 1.00)(1.0908)-2 = 1.00 14-10 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc Solving for c gives .0908. In the lower state, c(1.0595)-1 + (c + 1.00)(1.0579)-2 = 1.00 Solving for c gives .0579. The payoffs of the swaption at time 2 are as follows: Max(0,.1233 - .09)[(1.1241)-1 + (1.1233)-2] = .0560 Max(0,.0908 - .09)[(1.0913)-1 + (1.0908)-2] = .0014 Max(0,.0579 - .09)[(1.0595)-1 + (1.0579)-2] = 0 Note that the swaption payoff is a two-period annuity. The values of the swaption at time 1 are [.55(.0560) + .45(.0014)]/1.0947 = .0287 [.55(.0014) + .45(0)]/1.0628 = .0007 The price of the swaption is, therefore, [.55(.0287) + .45(.0007)]/1.06 = .0152 g. At time 2, we see that the rates for the underlying swap are .1233, .0908 and .0579. The rate on the forward swap will be the probability-weighted average of these rates where the probabilities are those given in the tree in a. for the respective states at time 2. Thus, the forward swap rate is .3025(.1233) + .4950(.0908) + .2025(.0579) = .0940 23. f0 = .0979 X = .10 rc = .0838 d1 = σ = .1465 T = 74/365 = .2027 ln(.0979/. 10) + (.1465 ) 2 /2(.2027) = - 0.29 .1465 .2027 N(-0.29) = .3859 d 2 = - 0.29 - .1465 .2027 = - 0.36 N(-0.36) = .3594 P = (e -.0838(.2027) [ .10(1 - .3594) - .0979(1 - .3859]) e-.0979(90/365) = .0038 For $22,000,000 of calls sold, this will amount to $22,000,000(.0038)(90/360) = $20,900. 24. The payoffs at time 4 are as follows: Max(0,.11 - .1686)/1.1686 = 0 Max(0,.11 - .1346)/1.1346 = 0 Max(0,.11 - .1016)/1.1016 = .0076 Max(0,.11 - .0695)/1.0695 = .0379 Max(0,.11 - .0383)/1.0383 = .0691 The values of the put at time 3 are as follows: [.55(0) + .45(0)]/1.1568 = 0 14-11 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc [.55(0) + .45(.0076)]/1.1231 = .0030 [.55(.0076) + .45(.0379)]/1.0904 = .0195 [.55(.0379) + .45(.0691)]/1.0586 = .0491 We must check to determine if the put is worth more exercised at each of these nodes. At the top two nodes, the put is out-of-the-money. At the second-from-bottom and bottom nodes, we have Max(0,.11 - .0904)/1.0904 = .0180, which is less than .0195 so do not exercise Max(0,.11 - .0586)/1.0586 = .0486, which is less than .0491 so do not exercise At time 2, the values of the put are as follows: [.55(0) + .45(.0030)]/1.1241 = .0012 [.55(.0030) + .45(.0195)]/1.0913 = .0096 [.55(.0195) + .45(.0491)]/1.0595 = .0310 We must check for early exercise. In the middle and bottom nodes, we have Max(0,.11 - .0913)/1.0913 = .0171 so replace .0096 with .0171 Max(0,.11 - .0595)/1.0595 = .0477 so replace .0310 with .0477 At time 1, the values of the put are as follows: [.55(.0012) + .45(.0171)]/1.0947 = .0076 [.55(.0171) + .45(.0477)]/1.0628 = .0290 We must check each node for early exercise. We have Max(0,.11 - .0947)/1.0947 = .0140 so replace .0076 with .0140 Max(0,.11 - .0628)/1.0628 = .0444 so replace .0290 with .0444 At time 0, the price of the put is [.55(.0140) + .45(.0444)]/1.06 = .0261 If exercised now, the put would be worth Max(0,.11 - .06)/1.06 = .0472 So the current value of the put is .0472, which would be obtained by exercising it immediately. 14-12 Copyright © 2001 by Harcourt, Inc