Program Design Roger A. Rennekamp, Ph.D. Extension Professor and Specialist in Program and Staff Development Department of Community and Leadership Development University of Kentucky Development of Linkages with the Public Evaluation and Accountability Situation Analysis Program Implementation Priority Setting Program Design Program A program is a sequence of intentional actions and events organized in a manner that they result in valued outcomes for a clearly defined audience. How does a program work? We do stuff. Good things happen. If A If Then B Then C Logic Model (logic modeling, program planning, program design, outcome engineering) What is a logic model? A graphic representation of a program, supported by a program theory, depicted as a logical chain of “if-then” relationships, and guides program program implementation and evaluation. Three Major Components of Logic Models Inputs Outputs Outcomes resources actions results Defining Outputs Inputs Outputs Outcomes resources actions results Activities Audience Three Types of Outcomes Inputs Outputs Outcomes resources actions results Initial Outcomes Intermediate Outcomes Long-Term Outcomes A Simple Linear Model Inputs Activities Audience Resources committed to the program Learning experiences supported by the resources invested Individuals who participate, their characteristics, and reactions Initial Outcomes Intermediate Outcomes Long-term Outcomes Learning that results from participation (KOSA) Actions that result from learning (Practices and Behaviors) Conditions which change as a result of actions (SEEC) Generic Program Logic Model Inputs Outputs Activities Audience Outcomes Initial Resources deployed to address situation Activities supported by resources invested Individuals or groups who participate in the activities Learning that results from participation Staff Volunteers Time Money Materials Equipment Technology Partners Workshops Meetings Field Days Demonstration Camps Trainings Web Sites Home Visits Number Awareness Characteristics Knowledge Reactions Opinions Skills Aspirations Contextual Factors Intermediate Long-Term Actions that results from learning Conditions which change as a result of action Practices Behaviors Policies Social Action Choices Social Economic Environmental Program Planning Worksheet Inputs Resources deployed to address situation Outputs Activities Activities supported by resources invested Audience Individuals or groups who participate in the activities Outcomes Initial Learning that results from participation Contextual Factors Intermediate Actions that results from learning Long-Term Conditions which change as a result of action Let’s look at some logic models for specific programs. Cumberland County 21st CCLC Logic Model Inputs Cooperative Extension, School, Community Partnership Department of Education Grant Site Director and Staff, Principal, Teachers, Volunteers, School Staff, Extension Staff, and Evaluator 21st Century Community Learning Center Advisory Activities Homework Help, Tutoring, Field Trips, Academic Enrichment, Cultural and Performing Arts Events Reality Store, AfterSchool Classes, Red Ribbon Week, STOP, Junior Guard, Leadership Team, Nutritious Snacks Family Events, Science Fair, Parenting Classes, Adult Computer Classes, Community/School Collaboration, GED Referrals Primary Audience Initial Outcomes Intermediate Outcomes Long Term Outcomes 21st Century Community Learning Center Participants Students Complete Homework, Experiential Learning Approaches Increase Student Comprehension Academic Index Increases by 3.7%, Arts and Humanities Scores Increase 2.5% Capable and Competent Information Age Workforce (Academic Outcomes) All Cumberland County Middle School Students Participating Youth Become More Engaged with School, Gain Resistance, Coping, and Leadership Skills Targeted Assets Increase 5%, Attendance Increases 2%, Disciplinary Referrals and Dropout Rate Decrease 10% Healthy, Responsible, Caring Citizens (Youth Development Outcomes) Parents Participate in Learning Opportunities, Community Members Volunteer at School Parents Increase Computer Literacy, Gain Parenting Skills, Community Members Have Renwed Commitment to Youth Lifelong Learners and Engaged Community Leaders (Family and Community Outcomes) Parents and Community Members Logic Model for the Value-Added Microprocessor Project T argeted Audiences Learning Outcomes Behavioral Outcomes Long Term Outcomes Inputs Activities SARE Professional Development Program Grant Develop Microprocessor Certification Manual Project Leadership Team (Farmers, Processors, UK Faculty, Collaborators) Conduct Train-theTrainer Sessions for individuals who will teach local HBM Workshops Extension Agents, Health Inspectors, and Food Manufacturing Inspectors are trained. Agency Professionals have knowledge and skills needed to provide training and technical asssistance. Agency Professionals provide accurate and reliable technical assistance to processors. Food sold by ValueAdded Entrepreurs is safe for consumption. Collaborators (KY Department of Agriculture, Health Departments, UK and KSU) Trainers conduct local HBM certification workshops for farmers and food processors. Home-Based Microprocessors participate in certification workshops. Home-Based Microprossessors have knowledge and skills necessary to produce safe homeprocessed products. Home-Based Microprocessors use safe processing practices. Consumer confidence in products produced by microprocessors increases. Commercial Food Manufacturers use safe commercial processing practices. Revenues from microprocessed foods increases. Stakeholders (Farmers, Microprocessors, Food Manufacturers, Farmers Markets, Roadside Stands, Consumers, Inspectors, Other Agency Staff) UK Value-Added Small Processing Incubator conducts Better Process Control Schools. Commercial Food Manufacturers Production Supervisors have knowedge and skills necessary to oversee production of safe manufactured products. Why Use Logic Models? Planning Tool Blueprint for Implementation Guides Evaluation Strengthens Case for Investment Simple Image of a Complex Phenomenon Reflect Shared Understanding Diagnose Program Flaws Who Uses Logic Models? W.K. Kellogg Foundation Centers for Disease Control United Way of America Harvard Family Research Project Cooperative Extension Service Steps in Logic Modeling Convene a planning group Large room and lots of paper Template or free form Create a model beginning with outcomes Get feedback from outside Revise Plan evaluation and select indicators Logic Modeling Resources This Powerpoint Presentation http://www.ca.uky.edu/AgPSD/programdesign.ppt Program Design Publication http://www.ca.uky.edu/AgPSD/programdesign.pdf Logic Modeling Course on the Web www1.uwex.edu/ces/lmcourse/ W.K. Kellogg Foundation Logic Modeling Guide www.wkkf.org/Pubs/Tools/Evaluation/Pub3669.pdf MAPS and Program Plans MAP Program Plan Program Program Plan Plan MAPS and Program Plans MAP 1 Program Plan 1 MAP 3 MAP 2 Program Plan 2 Program Plan 3 Program Plan 4 Program Plan 5 MAP 4 Program Plan 6 Program Plan 7 Program Plan 8 Entering the Plan of Work in CATPAWS A C-MAP can have more than one Program Plan associated with it Improved CATPAWS template No longer select PAC codes for each plan Evaluation is topic for March staff meetings Template available in April Final Submitted by July 1