CHAPTER NINE Personality Disorders Personality Disorders • What are Personality Disorders? • Classification of Personality Disorders Categorical vs. Dimensional models • Features of Axis II Implications for Assessment • Specific Disorders: Cluster A Cluster B Cluster C Personality • Most mental disorders are defined in terms of states: episodes of symptoms • Personality refers to enduring traits that are fairly stable over time or make a person who s/he is What are Personality Disorders? • Enduring patterns of perceiving, relating to & thinking about the environment and oneself – that are inflexible and pervasive – and cause either significant functional impairment or subjective distress Categorical Classification of PDs (DSM) • Advantages Familiar & convenient Ease in communication Consistent with clinical diagnoses Categorical Classification of PDs (DSM) • Disadvantages low inter-rater reliability very high comorbidity high overlap among symptom criteria not based on a theoretical model ambiguity occurs regarding the presence vs. absence of a PD most commonly diagnosed PD is PDNOS Dimensional Model of Personality • Looks at a continuum of normal to abnormal personality Personality Disorder – all individuals have some degree of these traits, but those with PDs have maladaptive levels trait • Various dimensional models exist – Five Factor Dimensional Model Normal Traits Five-Factor Model • Neuroticism: expression of negative emotions • Extraversion: interest in interacting with other people; positive emotions • Openness: willingness to consider and explore unfamiliar ideas, feelings, and activities • Agreeableness: willingness to cooperate and empathize with others • Conscientiousness: persistence in pursuit of goals; organization; dependability Dimensional Model • Advantages Theoretical basis Retention of information • Leads to less stereotyping • Adaptive traits are also highlighted Flexible Resolution of a variety of classification dilemmas • Avoids arbitrary assignment decisions • Addresses problems with comorbidity in the Categorical Model • Higher inter-rater reliability Dimensional Model Disadvantages Less familiar Lacks clinical application May be too complex Disagreement exists about preference of which dimensional model to use Features of Axis II • Different etiology than Axis I – not always true • More stable than Axis I disorders or more resistant to treatment – however, some Axis I disorders are very stable – some PDs are treatable Features of Axis II • Other disorders: ego-dystonic – personal distress, discomfort with one’s symptoms • Personality disorders: ego-syntonic – ideas and impulses do not bother the person Assessment of PDs • The ego-syntonic nature of personality disorders can make them difficult to assess using traditional measures • Others who have regular contact with an individual might be better judges of how that person’s behavior affects those around him/her Culture and Personality • Culture plays a large role in determining what is appropriate or acceptable at a given time and place • Cultures may differ in: Degree of emotional expression Individualism vs. collectivism Clusters of Personality Disorders • Cluster A Paranoid PD Schizoid PD Schizotypal PD • Cluster B Narcissistic PD Antisocial PD Histrionic PD Borderline PD • Cluster C Avoidant PD Dependent PD Obsessive-Compulsive PD Cluster A Personality Disorders Characterized by odd, eccentric, and/or socially isolated behavior Paranoid PD Schizoid PD Schizotypal PD Paranoid Personality Disorder • A pervasive distrust and suspiciousness of others such that their motives are interpreted as malevolent. – Reluctant to confide in others – Hold grudges – Finds threatening hidden meaning in benign comments – Doubt the loyalty and trustworthiness of others • Requires 4 of the 7 possible criteria. Paranoid Personality Disorder • Prevalence rates: 0.5 to 2.5 % • More common in men • Unlikely to seek treatment • Treatment – • Trusting atmosphere • Cognitive therapy to correct cognitive errors • Most therapists pessimistic Schizoid Personality Disorder • A pervasive pattern of detachment from social relationships and a restricted range of expression of emotions in interpersonal settings - Doesn’t desire or enjoy close relationships - Prefers solitary activities and takes pleasure in few things - Is indifferent to praise and criticism • Requires 4 of the 7 possible criteria Schizoid Personality Disorder • Prevalence: < 1% • More common in males • Unlikely to seek treatment • Many therapists think schizoid untreatable Schizotypal Personality Disorder • A pervasive pattern of interpersonal and social deficits marked by acute discomfort with, and reduced capacity for, close relationships as well as by cognitive or perceptual distortions and eccentricities of behavior – Ideas of reference, magical thinking, and bodily illusions – Suspiciousness/paranoid thinking – Inappropriate affect – Lack of close friends/confidants – Social anxiety • Requires 5 of the 9 possible criteria Schizotypal Personality Disorder Prevalence: 3-5% More common in males Schizotypal PD and Schizophrenia • Individuals with schizotypal PD: – Sometimes have a history of psychological trauma, especially childhood maltreatment – Are at an increased risk of developing schizophrenia – Are commonly relatives of individuals with schizophrenia • BUT…the vast majority of individuals with Schizotypal PD still do NOT have relatives with schizophrenia Individuals with Schizotypal PD People with Schizophrenia Cluster B Personality Disorders Characterized by overly dramatic, flamboyant, emotional, and/or erratic behavior Narcissistic PD Antisocial PD Histrionic PD Borderline PD Narcissistic Personality Disorder • A pervasive pattern of grandiosity, need for admiration, and lack of empathy – Preoccupied with fantasies – Associates only with high-status others – Has a strong sense of entitlement – Is interpersonally exploitative – Is envious and thinks others are envious of him/her • Requires 5 of the 9 possible criteria Narcissistic Personality Disorder • Prevalence: 1% • Link with poor parenting • Treatment • Little research • Cognitive therapy to improve empathy & coping with criticism • Vulnerable to depressive episodes, may need treatment for depression Histrionic Personality Disorder • A pervasive pattern of excessive emotionality and attention seeking – Inappropriately seductive/provocative – Impressionistic style of speech – Suggestible, easily influenced by others and circumstances – Considers relationships more intimate than they really are • Requires 5 of the 8 possible criteria Histrionic Personality Disorder • Prevalence: 2-3% • More common in females • Link with Antisocial PD? • Treatment • Behavior therapy and focus on interpersonal relations • Generally poor prognosis Borderline Personality Disorder • A pervasive pattern of instability of interpersonal relationships, selfimage, and affects, and marked impulsivity – – – – Fears of abandonment Suicidal gestures or self-mutilation Chronic feelings of emptiness Stress-related paranoid ideation or severe dissociative symptoms • Requires 5 of the 9 possible criteria Borderline Personality Disorder • Prevalence: 2% • More common in females • Link to ASPD • Familial association w/ BPD & mood disorders • Poor/abusive parenting • Early trauma • Challenges in treatment Antisocial Personality Disorder • A pervasive pattern of disregard for and violation of the rights of others – – – – – Performing acts that are ground for arrest Deceitfulness Impulsivity Consistent irresponsibility Lack of remorse • Requires: – Age 18 or older – Evidence of Conduct Disorder by age 15 Antisocial Personality Disorder • Conduct Disorder Antisocial Prison • Often comorbid with substance abuse • Poor prognosis • Prevalence: 3% in males, 1% in females • May “burn out” after age 40 Psychopathy • Deceptiveness or duplicity • Absence of empathy, compassion or remorse toward the victims of the psychopath's exploitative selfinterest. • Can often be charming and appear socially well-adjusted. • May or may not engage in criminal behavior. Antisocial PD and Psychopathy • Earlier conceptualizations of ASPD had a greater overlap with psychopathy • However, due to DSM-IV’s focus on observable behaviors, ASPD is a distinct concept from psychopathy (there is still some overlap) • Psychopathy is a better predictor of recidivism than ASPD Overlap between ASPD, Psychopathy, & Criminality 20% of people with ASPD are Psychopaths ASPD Psychopaths Criminals 75-85% of criminals have ASPD 15-25% of criminals are Psychopaths Overlap between ASPD, Psychopathy, & Criminality ASPD Psychopaths Criminals Criminal Behavior among Male Adoptees 50 Had biological parents without ASPD 40 30 20 Had biological parents with ASPD 10 0 In adoptive family with no ASPD In adoptive family with ASPD Social Factors & the Etiology of ASPD • Inconsistent discipline (or complete lack of discipline) often seen in the prior family history of ASPD men • Kids with a “difficult temperament” are especially irritating to parents • Parents respond inappropriately by giving up or becoming severe in punishment • Person selects friends who share antisocial interests and problems (‘skinheads’, gangs) Continuity in Life-Course-Persistent ASPD • Person’s options become narrowed; locked into further antisocial behavior • Limited range of behavioral skills (can’t pursue more appropriate responses) • Ensnared by consequences of earlier behaviors • • • • drug addiction parenthood school dropout criminal record Psychological Factors: the Etiology of ASPD • Avoidance learning in the lab • Psychopaths unaffected by anticipation of punishment • Hypothesis 1: they can ignore the effects of punishment (emotional poverty) • Hypothesis 2: they have trouble shifting their attention (impulsivity) Cluster C Personality Disorders Characterized by anxious or avoidant behaviors Avoidant PD Dependent PD Obsessive-Compulsive PD Avoidant Personality Disorder • A pervasive pattern of social inhibition, feelings of inadequacy, and hypersensitivity to negative evaluation - Avoids interpersonal job activities - Won’t get involved with others - Is preoccupied with criticism and rejection - Views self as socially inept, personally unappealing, or inferior to others - Won’t try new things in case they are embarrassing • Requires 4 of the 7 possible criteria Avoidant Personality Disorder • Prevalence: < 1% • May have biological predisposition combined with poor learning history of early relationships • Can be considered a severe version of social phobia, general type Dependent Personality Disorder • A pervasive and excessive need to be taken care of that leads to submissive and clinging behavior and fears of separation – Has difficulty making everyday and major decisions – Won’t express disagreement – Fails to initiate projects on own – Feels uncomfortable or helpless when alone – Urgently seeks another relationship when one ends • Requires 5 of the 8 possible criteria Dependent Personality Disorder • Prevalence: 2% (no gender difference) • May be linked to early neglect & disruptions in attachment patterns • Treatment -- little research, must make sure client does not become dependent on therapist! Obsessive-Compulsive PD • A pervasive pattern of preoccupation with orderliness, perfectionism, and mental and interpersonal control, at the expense of flexibility, openness, and efficiency – Preoccupied with rules, lists, details – Neglects family/friends because of devotion to work – Is overconscientious about rules, ethics, values – Cannot discard worthless objects – Hoards money in case of disaster – Refuses to delegate tasks to others • Requires 4 of the 8 possible criteria Obsessive-Compulsive PD • Prevalence: 1% • More common in males • Don’t confuse with OCD • Some behaviors look similar but OCD is ego-dystonic, OCPD is ego-syntonic • Treatment addresses • Fears underlying need for order & control • Distraction & relaxation techniques Prevalence & Course: PD Summary • PDs often originate in childhood & become ingrained by adulthood • Overall prevalence rate of 10-14% • Course & prognosis depend on disorder, but prognosis is generally poor Optional Slides Five-Factor Model • Neuroticism: expression of negative emotions • Extraversion: interest in interacting with other people; positive emotions • Openness: willingness to consider and explore unfamiliar ideas, feelings, and activities • Agreeableness: willingness to cooperate and empathize with others • Conscientiousness: persistence in pursuit of goals; organization; dependability Practice Example (kinda) O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Paranoid PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Paranoid PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Schizoid PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Schizoid PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Schizotypal PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Schizotypal PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Narcissistic PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Narcissistic PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Histrionic PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Histrionic PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Borderline PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Borderline PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Antisocial PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Antisocial PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Avoidant PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Avoidant PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Dependent PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Dependent PD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All OCPD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All OCPD: Five Factor Profile O A B C D E C A B C D E E A B C D E A A B C D E N A B C D E Extremely A B C D E Not at All Why care about PDs? • PDs are associated with significant impairment (e.g., social impairment) • Presence of pathological personality traits as an adolescent is associated with increased risk for the later development of other mental disorders • Sometimes, PDs represent the beginning stages of the onset of a more serious disorder How do we describe PDs? • Axis II — chronic and long term • Tend to irritate people around them • Difficult to maintain personal relationships Peer Nomination • Done with groups of individuals • Members of a group are asked to name individuals in the group who have high levels of a particular trait • Studies have found that informants are more willing to identify the negative aspects of personality than individuals are to self-report them Paranoid Personality Disorder • S stubborn, sarcastic, hostile • U unforgiving - bears grudges • S suspicious (of others) • P perceives attacks (reacts quickly) • E enemy in everyone (suspects all) • C confiding in others is feared • T threats seen in benign events Schizoid Personality Disorder • • • • • • S O L I T A shows emotional coldness omits close relationships lacks close friends or confidants involved in solitary activities takes pleasure in few activities appears indifferent to praise or criticism • R restricted interest in sexual experiences • Y yanks himself or herself from social relationships Schizotypal Personality Disorder • M magical thinking, superstitious, paranormal • E eccentric behavior or appearance • • • • • • • • P E C U L I A R paranoid ideation (suspicious) experiences unusual perceptions constricted affect unusual thinking & speech lacks friends ideas of reference anxiety (socially) rule out psychotic disorders & PDD Narcissistic Personality Disorder • • • • • • W O R S H I • P wants special treatment from others overestimates abilities, boastful requires excessive admiration strong sense of entitlement has grandiose sense of self-importance insists on only being affiliated with important people and institutions preoccupied with fantasies of brilliance, beauty or ideal love • M Machiavellian attitude • E envious of others Histrionic Personality Disorder • P provocative or seductive behavior • R relationships, considered more intimate than they are • A attention (must be the center of) • I influenced easily • S speech style – impressionistic • E emotional lability, shallowness • M make-up, draws attention to self • E exaggerated emotions, theatrical Borderline Personality Disorder • P paranoid ideas • R relationship instability • A angry outbursts, abandonment fears, affective instability • I impulsive behavior, identity disturbance • S suicidal behavior • E emptiness Antisocial Personality Disorder • C cannot follow law • O obligations ignored • R remorselessness • R recklessness • U underhandedness (deceitful) • P planning deficit • T temper Avoidant Personality Disorder • A avoids occupational activities • V views self as socially inept • O occupied with being criticized or rejected (insecure) • I inhibited in new interpersonal situations (afraid around others) • D denies involvement with people • E embarrassed by engaging in new activities • R reluctant to get involved in intimate relationships Dependent Personality Disorder • D difficulty making everyday decisions • E excessive lengths to obtain nurturance • P preoccupied with fears of being left to • E • N • D • E • N • T take care exaggerated fears of being unable to care for himself or herself needs others to assume responsibility difficulty expressing disagreement end of one relationship is the beginning of another relationship noticeable difficulties in initiating projects (low self-confidence) “take care of me” is his or her motto Obsessive-Compulsive PD • P preoccupation with details, rules, order, organization or schedules • E excessive devotion to work and productivity • R reluctance to work with others unless they give up complete control • F frugal (miserly spending style toward both self and others) • E excessive rigidity and stubbornness • C concentrate on details; completion of tasks is problematic • T time is poorly allocated Schizotypal PD and Schizophrenia • The vast majority of individuals with schizotypal PD do not have relatives with schizophrenia • Schizotypal PD associated with history of psychological trauma, especially childhood maltreatment (this is not true for schizophrenia) • There may be two distinct pathways to schizotypal PD – genes associated with schizophrenia – psychological trauma Individuals with Schizotypal PD People with Schizophrenia Continuity: Life-Course-Persistent AGE PRESCHOOL ADOLESCENCE (Loeber, 1990) Developmental Stacking Loeber, 1990 DELINQUENCY PEER PROBLEM POOR SOCIAL SKILLS AGGRESSIVE BEHAVIORS OPPOSITIONAL PROBLEMS HYPERACTIVITY BRAIN DAMAGE MOTHER’S DRUG USE TIME According to your book, the enduring deviant patterns of experience and behavior that mark PDs must be present in how many domains? • • • • • A. 1 B. 2 C. 3 D. 4 E. 5 Correct Answer = B What are some of these domains? In what area of functioning to do we often see the greatest impairment in PDs? What about PDs makes this impairment so important to consider? What is another name sometimes given to Cluster A PDs? • • • • • A. Dramatic, Emotionally Unstable Disorders B. Anxious, Avoidant Disorders C. Bizarre, Mistrusting Disorders D. Schizophrenia Spectrum Disorders E. Bizarre Spectrum Disorders Correct Answer = D Why is this alternative name reasonable for Cluster A PDs? In what ways are each of the Cluster A PDs similar to Schizophrenia? In what ways are they distinct from each other? One of these things is not like the others… Which of the following would not be seen in Paranoid PD? • • • • • A. pervasive mistrust of others B. strong desire for autonomy C. finding pleasure in few activities D. an inability to forgive others E. hostility Correct Answer = C Which Cluster A PD is characterized by finding little pleasure in activities? One of these things is not like the others… Which of the following would not be seen in Narcissistic PD? • • • • • A. dramatic attention-seeking behaviors B. presenting a grandiose self-concept C. lack of empathy D. upward comparisons to famous people E. disappointment in response to a lack of praise Correct Answer = A In which Cluster B PD do we usually see dramatic attention-seeking behaviors? Why is it important that, in option B, I wrote “presenting a grandiose self-concept? One of these things is not like the others… Which of the following would not be found in Borderline PD? • • • • • A. identity disturbance/unstable self-concept B. fears of abandonment C. lack of remorse D. parasuicidal behaviors E. short-lived dissociative symptoms Correct Answer = C What are parasuicidal behaviors? How are these behaviors hypothesized to be connected to dissociative symptoms in BPD? Which of the following is not a benefit of the dimensional approach to classifying PDs? • A. it enables us to be more strengths-focused in our treatment • B. it makes it easier to discuss personality issues with clients • C. it has a better theoretical and empirical basis than the current categories • D. it has higher inter-rater reliability • E. it is very familiar to most practicing clinicians Correct Answer = E What are some of the other disadvantages of the dimensional approach? What are the advantages and disadvantages of the categorical approach? Is APD redundant with Generalized Social Phobia? • Social Phobia Generalized Social Phobia APD • Who tends to suggest that APD is unnecessary? • What do they suggest should be done with the APD category? – Are these fair or reasonable suggestions? • What is it that most psychologists don’t know? – Why aren’t they aware of this information? The dimensions of DPD • Previous research suggests that DPD is actually bidimensional – Dependence/Incompetence – Dysfunctional or Insecure Attachment • Different relationships to other PDs • Implications – Necessity of different treatment approaches – More evidence of comorbidity and symptom overlap problems Do Cluster C PDs belong together? • The research and clinical opinions are a bit mixed. – OCPD is sometimes separate – DPD is bidimensional – There is evidence of a common latent trait • Seems to center around issues with criticism • Research on how these disorders both do and do not overlap is still sorely needed Special Topic Understanding Psychopathy Psychopaths vs. Sociopaths Paranoid Personality Disorder Pervasive, extreme mistrust Often hostile Suspicious and perceive others’ motives as malevolent Familial association with Delusional Disorder Schizoid Personality Disorder Aloof, cold Detached from social relations Restricted experience or range of emotion Not distressed by lack of social contact Schiztypal Personality Disorder Behavioral eccentricities Cognitive or perceptual distortions Ideas of reference Magical thinking Illusions Discomfort with close relationships Narcissistic Personality Disorder Grandiose Self-absorbed Lack empathy Need admiration Exploit others Envious, arrogant Sensitive to criticism Histrionic Personality Disorder • Excessive emotionality • Need to be center of attention • Provocative • Dramatic Borderline Personality Disorder • Fear of abandonment • Unstable interpersonal relations • Unstable self-image or identity • Chronic feelings of emptiness • Affective instability or reactivity of mood Borderline Personality Disorder • Impulsive • Inappropriate and intense anger • Transient, stress-related dissociative symptoms • Self-mutilation and suicidal gestures Antisocial Personality Disorder Persistent violation of others’ rights Impulsive Deceitful Lack of remorse Difficulty learning lessons Must be 18 Avoidant Personality Disorder Fear of negative evaluation Feelings of inadequacy Social inhibition and interpersonal avoidance Want contact with others but are afraid of criticism Dependent Personality Disorder Excessive need to be cared for Submissive Clinging Fears of separation Overly eager to please (responds to criticism by clinging) Obsessive-Compulsive PD Preoccupied with: • • • • Details Orderliness Perfectionism Control Excessively devoted to work Inflexible • Often interferes with task completion