Students Flourish Social Venture Plan, NPLD 510 Danielle Bicknell Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Executive Summary: Social mission statement: In the United States credit scores are the only way borrowers are able to take out a loan in order to invest in their future, like a high quality college education. Lenders use a traditional credit score, called a FICO score to judge a borrowers risk. Students do not have a credit score since they are young and therefore lenders will not give them a loan. Therefore, funding options for students and therefore credit scores are broken for students. Students Flourish (SF) is an innovative new company that will financially empower students by giving them a credit score that captures their online behavior. Students flourish will equip students with a new type of credit score and financial education so that they can responsibly build their credit while in school which will give them more economic mobility after they graduate and become contributing consumers. Need for innovation: In the next school year, around 20 million students will enroll in post-secondary education. 75% of students get in to their first choice college.1 Unfortunately, more and more students are not attending their first choice school and this is largely due to cost. Traditional lending options for students often penalize students and put them into debt, therefore ruining their credit before they have a chance to build it. In order for students to get the highest return on their education, they need a credit score that accurately captures their risk and allows banks to use that information to make better lending decisions—thus expanding their loan products to a larger customer base. Social problem that needs to be addressed: The cost of attending post-secondary school is a major obstacle for youth in America. Regardless of achievement, the burden of paying for college prevents many students from going to school. Many students that are just starting to build their credit do not have the same options for loans as those who have a credit score. Plus, federal student loan options are inadequate and might disenfranchise high achieving students. Federal student loans do not segment customers; their loans are based on an equity model that gives everyone the same rate. Private student loans have complicated fees and are tied to a credit score and most students are not able to use their credit score to their advantage. The question must be asked, are the most deserving students getting the best deal to fund their education? 2 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Market Analysis/ Market Strategy Market Analysis: Postsecondary education in the United States includes academic, career and technical, and continuing professional education programs after high school. American colleges, universities, technical and vocational institutions offer a diverse array of postsecondary education experiences. Participation in postsecondary education in the U.S has expanded over the last decade, as well as the total financing for this growing sector of the U.S economy. 2 Students are increasingly relying on loans to funding their education. Between October 2000 and October 2009, the total outstanding amount of student loans owned by the federal government, in constant 2011 dollars, remained between approximately $100 and $150 billion.3 A combination of the federal student loan policy change and a growing demand for student loans resulted in a balance of over $500 billion by October of 2012.4 In addition to loans originated by the federal government, students can obtain private student loans from private financial institutions like banks, nonprofit lenders, and certain schools that elect to fund or guarantee loans. Student loan debt is the only form of consumer debt that has grown since the peak of consumer debt in 2008, and balances of student loans have eclipsed both auto loans and credit cards, making student loan debt the largest form of consumer debt.5 Market size: In fall 2014, some 21 million students were enrolled to attend American colleges and universities, constituting an increase of about 5.7 million since fall 2000.6 76% of freshman got accepted into their No. 1 college.7 3 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Problem Size •Students have thin or no credit, cannot receive competitive loans, or adequete financial aid from schools •20 million students expecting to attend US colleges in fall 2015 Consequences •Students receive inadequate financial assistance •Current fed. loan structure gives all students same rate •Students receieve negative return on education due to debt accumulated Current and Projected Market Share: Currently, a quarter of the 21 million students who will enroll in college in the next fall is need of some kind of additional funding in order to offset the costs of tuition and living expenses. That is 5,250,000 students that could benefit from Students Flourish. Target Market: Initial stage, learning period: Our target market will first be to entice college students to create a profile and link their accounts. We will do this to capture their data. From there, we will use the data to create our credit score criteria. This learning period will take time, about four years, which is the industry average, to build an algorithm that incorporates new metrics like online behavior. Second stage: Once we have a credit score model in place, our target market will be incoming college freshmen. We will partner with banks and other lending companies that share our mission to empower students and help the most promising students receive the most competitive interest rates on their loans. Competitive Analysis Customer Need: This year, fewer incoming students received grants or scholarships (69.5%) versus 73.4% in 2010. Only 26.8% received $10,000 or more in scholarships versus 29.2% in 2010.8 More than 28% said they frequently felt overwhelmed by all they had to do and cited financial stress as a leading cause to their burden.9 4 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Business Need: In order to improve and innovate, the lending and banking sector is turning to big data. All the major banks work out how best to bring new unstructured data sets (such as social data and mobile data) along with transactional data in order to improve customer and client experience and become more competitive and increase growth.10 FICO Score: Lenders use the FICO score to determine who to lend to and at what rate. The FICO criteria negatively impacts students who have no established credit history. Lenders (Private, Federal and Financial Aid) need new data about students to segment the best potential student customers. Big data takes into account new metrics for behavior that is being used by other companies to assess risk (like Lenddo). In 2012, Philippine startup Lenddo became a loan company known for developing an algorithm that determines people’s credit worthiness based on their social media presence.11 They recognized a huge percentage of the middle-income market was not able to borrow from banks, and banks would not offer them loan products. This was because these individuals have no banking history on which to base how faithful they’d be in fulfilling their obligations. Creating a new credit score for students would help compete in the market, where FICO currently has 100% market share. Source: Fair Issac Corporation (2013) Risk Assessment Students Flourish did a risk assessment to understand where students are and where they want to be. Key factors in determining need is understating why students are not able to attend the college of their choice and the current funding options available to students. 5 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Students cannot attend their first choice school due to cost: Students and families who are hoping to pay less than the full tuition price will not know what they will actually have to pay to attend any of the schools to which they apply until after they are accepted and receive their financial aid packages.12 The average tuition discount rate exceeds 45% at private colleges and universities, the net price students have to pay is hard to predict.13 Students receive vastly different aid packages from the schools they applied to, which depend on the criteria the schools use to make their financial aid awards. There is a small group of highly selective colleges that award aid based only on financial need but their assessment of financial need varies depending on how they do the analysis and how desirable the student is to that school and that school’s policy on providing grant aid vs. self-help, like loans and work-study. Federal Student Loans The Federal government provides accepted incoming college students with a variety of subsidized and un-subsidized loans. These loans often require a parent to be a co-signer, and if the parent is an immigrant, and therefore does not have a credit score, this could impact the student’s ability to receive loans. In addition, the federal loan model is based on equity; therefore they offer everyone the same interest rate and fees. They do not segment students based on financial need or based on the school they decide to attend. Private Loans: Private lenders are another option for students who cannot receive enough funding from financial aid or government student loans. The main lenders in this category include, Sallie May, Wells Fargo, Discover, Chase and Citi-Bank. These loans come with complicated terms and several reports claim that they are predatory. The media recently reported complaints about private lenders making money off of students desperation. Students were quoted saying, “They are Satan!” and “I wouldn’t wish them (private lenders) on my worst enemy.”14 In addition, private lenders come with a particularly annoying set of issues that can seriously hinder a borrower’s ability to repay his or her debt. Top issues reported:15 1. Putting extra towards the principal, not the next month’s payment. 2. Correctly timing payment processing (no same day processing). 3. Getting lost in the shuffle (bad customer servicing issues). 4. Receiving the incorrect payoff balance. 5. Modifying the terms of an existing loan. 6 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Students are forced to settle for inadequate loans that put them into debt before they are able to build their credit. Source: Studentdebtcrisis.org What do students need? New credit score that more accurately captures their credit worthiness Credit score that takes new metrics into account to determine score Segments the best students and finds them the most competitive loans Economically empower students so they can add a higher return to their community Competitive Analysis: Ripe for innovation and Collaboration Competitive Analysis: Companies addressing innovation in financial services Lenddo: The Company developed an algorithm that pulls and analyzes data from people’s social media accounts – who their friends are, how often they interact, their activity – and puts the information into a rating or score. This score helps determine if a borrower is likely to pay back or default on their loans.16 Lenddo is not currently offered in the US and only targets middleincome borrowers. Collaborating with them to assess what metrics we should consider in our algorithm would be beneficial for Students Flourish. Lending Club: Lending Club demonstrated that there is an ability to make money lending without the traditional infrastructure of a bank or just the scores maintained by credit bureaus. Their peer-to-peer lending model offers loans to a segment of the market that cannot get approved for traditional loan products. Although the company has been successful, they have not opened up their market to students. Lending Club would be a key partner to have on the board or to collaborate with so they could use our algorithm to expand their products to students. 7 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Upstart: P2P Platform for young borrowers. They have created a platform that brings together high-quality borrowers and investors who can choose to invest in those loans. Borrowers can get lower interest rates and investors can get an attractive yield, relative to other investment opportunities.17 Although the loans are anonymous, the investor can see a lot of information about the borrower—credit score, monthly income, existing debt obligations, schools attended, test scores, and more. In addition to all the information you’d see on a more traditional lending website, you get insight into the borrower’s education, which is critical to understanding his or her employability. This would be a key partnership to establish. Upstart does allow investors to look at different borrower criteria, but to save time and allow investors to make better lending decisions, it would be helpful to integrate the Students Flourish credit score into their lending criteria. Competitive Analysis Matrix Company: Lenddo Lending Club Upstart Students Flourish Trait: New credit score Yes (but n/a in US) No No Yes Markets to students No No Yes Yes Uses online consumer behavior to assess risk Yes Yes Yes Yes Product/Service: Students Flourish (SF) Mission Statement: Student lending is broken for millions of students in the United States and we at Students Flourish, are here to solve that problem. At Students Flourish, we use a new credit score to create the highest return on educational investments and encourage students to achieve their academic dreams without financial stress or obstacles. We believe that every student has a right to education and cost should not be an inhibiting factor. We want to create a high return on community by empowering students to attend their top-choice schools and use their advanced degrees to help revitalize the economy. We will rejuvenate the American economy, get students out of debt faster, and therefore increase their disposable income faster than being in traditional student debt. 8 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Features Students Flourish is a new credit score that empowers students and lenders Why it works • Transparency • Big data captures students behavior • Students voluntarily buy in • Lenders lend to best customers How it operates • Algorithm that captures students credit risk • Empowers most promising students to get the most competitive loan products What success looks like • Students get score that lenders can use to make better lending decisions • Lenders can expand services to serve a larger market How Students Flourish Works: 1. Download Students Flourish application: This can be done on a smart phone, computer or tablet. The company operates entirely online; therefore students can sign up and access their account 24/7. 2. Connect to your networks: Once a student downloads the application, they will voluntarily link their social media and other online accounts. All of this information will be encrypted through account creation and therefore be password protected—minimizing risk to external hackers. We will not sell our information to third parties who are not directly involved with the social mission of Students Flourish. Accounts that we will recommend a student links, includes, but is not limited to: Facebook* 9 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Twitter* LinkedIn* Online Bank Account* School records (if available online)* Accepted school information (if available online) FAFSA (student financial information) Cellphone usage Student feedback that they would like us to consider to integrate in our model *Criteria already used by other start-up financial service companies to assess credit worthiness. See Lenddo, Lending Club 3. Complete profile: Once a student links their accounts, they will complete their profile. This will include questions and the option to provide a biography that includes student qualities that we might want to factor into the credit score as we learn more about our student users. We will also include spaces for the student to be creative. They will be allowed to send SF feedback so we can continually iterate on how to build a better, more robust credit score. We will empower students through creating a profile and they have the ability to help us build a better credit score, which helps them receive better loan products. This is a win-win situation for students and for our company. New Credit Score: The our platform will gather information about all the products and services a customer interacts with online to help score the credit risk of students. It will lump customers into segments and then provide a "what-if-analysis" that lets the lender identify product, price modelfits, and revenue/profitability impacts for new product that they could offer a student. It will further incorporate payment behavior from bank accounts, and look at holistic characteristics of borrower (like grades, work experience, personal finance behavior). We will use metrics from scraping the API’s of LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook, and their bank accounts to analyze online student behavior. Then we incorporate factors like schools they were accepted into and the financial aid packages they received, or information from their FAFSA. We will combine this data to build a credit score algorithm and over a 4-year period study the effects of the model. As new information arises, we will iterate on our model and use elements of design thinking to find new metrics that can be added to the model to give the right students a higher score. 10 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Benefits: Cross-Sector Win-Win-Win Students: Students become financially empowered through a credit score that works to help them achieve their academic dreams without the burden and stress of money issues getting in the way of their education. Businesses: Lenders, like banks and other innovative financial service companies can target students with our credit score and expand their products and services to better fit their needs. In addition, when they buy the credit score, they have more data to assess student behavior and innovate their current products. Schools: Schools can benefit from higher student retention. When students feel more financially empowered, they will perform better in school and not drop out due to stress or financial concerns. Government: Student lending reform has been a topic of concern for the government, although it has not been addressed. Senator Elizabeth Warren (Senator, Massachusetts) has called on banks and the government to reform student lending.18 With the Students Flourish credit score, this is a tool the government and private sector can use to reform student lending and decrease student debt, therefor revitalizing the economy. Funding Sources/Financials Incorporating Business Type: Although we will try to hold off as long as we can to incorporate, we will most likely incorporate as a For-Profit Company with a social mission. SF sees key advantages to this approach. Advantages: • Product/service triggers social change through transparency, and offering a high-impact low cost service to help students get the best financial products • Easy to collaborate and partner with banks, businesses, and government • Easier to scale • Attracts high-quality investors and employees Business Model: • Incorporate as a B-corporation19 • Show commitment by meeting comprehensive and transparent social and environmental standards 11 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan • • • Institutionalize stakeholder interests Build collective voice through the power of the brand Open 24/7: Online service and account allows convenience for students Funding Sources Students Flourish will have medium reliability and high autonomy in terms of organizational structure.20 It will most likely receive its funds from the fees from the service, which will be selling the credit score to lending institutions in exchange for data. In terms of investment, I would entertain government contracts, like social impact bonds and individual and corporate contributions, either from investors or banks that might want to partner. Additional funding sources include but are not limited to: Advertising: SF we will have a large user base of students, financial service companies and products that cater to students could advertise on the website. Investors: SF will need a lot of capital to establish itself as a financial services company, I will most likely need to attract impact investors, angel investors and consider other traditional investors like Google Ventures and Andreessen-Horowitz. Foundation Grant: I would in part be an advocacy organization as well as a start-up, and hopefully pool the resources of the community I am based in, so this seems like it would be a good option to explore. Banks: Since banks make most of their money off of fees, there is potential to partner with them in order to receive initial funding. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has fined many banks for illegal loan practices, and many banks have had to discontinue certain services due to new financial regulations. By partnering with my organization, which will be a social impact with a social mission, they could reconsider these products and receive good publicity for doing something that will benefit others and make them money as well. Revenue Channels: Banks/Lending institutions: buy score/customer data Partnerships: Mutually beneficial partnerships with like-minded financial service companies Advertising: Credit card companies, colleges and financial service companies can advertise on the website. 12 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Big Data is a lucrative industry to go into. There is tremendous growth “big data” is expected to experience in the near future. The “big data” market is expected to cross $50 billion by 2017.21 Source: Wikibon (2014) Location and Operations Location: Students Flourish is an innovative financial services company that will benefit from locating its initial headquarters near other like-minded companies. Since San Francisco and Silicon Valley currently houses the majority of these companies and the investors that fund them, it would be beneficial to be located in the Bay Area. HUB is a collaborative workspace that allows budding businesses to rent space and brings people and companies together to host events that allow businesses to scale effectively. They are located near the Financial District in San Francisco, and close to public transportation that would enable employees, investors and collaborators from Silicon Valley and the Bay Area to easily travel to our office. Rent Estimate: $375/month. Includes: Dedicated office space, reduced rate for conference/event space, dedicated mailbox and150 printed pages/month22 13 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Technology: Algorithm Design: One of the most important aspects of algorithm design is creating an algorithm that has an efficient run time. There are key steps to approaching algorithm design type:23 1. Problem definition 2. Development of a model 3. Specification of Algorithm 4. Designing an Algorithm 5. Checking the correctness of Algorithm 6. Analysis of Algorithm 7. Implementation of Algorithm 8. Program testing 9. Documentation Preparation One option for design: Minimum Spanning Tree Key Assumptions Students Flourish requires an applicant to become a students flourish member, link to their profiles from sites like Twitter and Facebook, and get a reference from another member. This works on the assumption that social media and other online behavior are reputable and the student can see the benefit of providing it. Differentiating Criteria Internal Criteria: ● Organizational mission: By wielding the tools of transparency and trust, Students Flourish provides incoming undergraduate and graduate students with financial services and uses a new credit model that bases eligibility on factors that customers with a thin or no credit history can benefit from. We will disrupt the broken student lending system so that every student has the ability to attend their first choice college without financial obstacles that could inhibit their academic performance, thus giving students a high return on their educational investment and generating a high return on the community where the next generation of leaders will serve. We segment the best customers and with a new credit score, a better loan, and flexible and clear terms and conditions, helps them attend their first choice college without financial stress or impediments. 14 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan ● Primary product or service: Determine student eligibility based on new metrics that help lenders make better decisions about lending money to students, with metrics that are relevant for young consumers with little or no credit history. ● Product or service delivery: (bundling, distribution channel) ○ Bundling: Using a new credit score to determine best customers, and provide a low, fixed interest loan that is more competitive than other private or government lenders. ○ Distribution channel: Work with students to spread the word (word of mouth). Target universities and partner with them to spread the message of the company. Use social media to reach out and create awareness. Use government resources and team up with politicians (like Senator Elizabeth Warren) to advocate for student lending reform. ● Price or cost: $5 verification fee to run an innovative credit check and determine eligibility (non-eligible customers can ask for refund upon request). No origination fee for applying, fixed interest rate, ability to pay-as-you-go and flexible repayment options after school is over. ● Target customer: Students who get into their first choice college, demonstrate trustworthiness and have financial issues that inhibit them from attending school. ● Organizational type: Private enterprise with a social mission. Students Flourish is a direct lender, which means we will not sell your information to third parties and all personal information will be encrypted and easy to access through online account creation. ● Key assets: New innovative credit score that segments the best student borrowers, transparent loan that has a fixed interest rate. Collaborate with other companies to build more robust credit score and use intelligence to scale with other companies. ● Growth potential: Growth and customer retention is promising, but acquiring a customer base will be the first major challenge. External Criteria: ● Geography: United States ● Access to limited resources (key partnerships): ○ Partnership with nonprofits that focus on student debt consolidation, credit building and financial education ○ Partnership with government to bring awareness about student debt reform, and also apply for social impact bonds through a government/private partnership ○ Partner with schools and their financial aid offices to advertise and get feedback from customers to iterate the product depending on the schools tuition, fee structure and financial aid ● Reputation: Through partnerships and marketing channel, our mission and products will speak highly of the mission we enact 15 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Marketing: In the first phase, we will mainly focus on online marketing strategies. In order to bootstrap our service while we build it, we will utilize free and low cost marketing services like: Register SF with Google Places and Bing in order to increase search results Embrace social media to gain exposure. Creating SF accounts to spread the message and attract customers. Start a blog: Detailing our mission and our progress. We will advertise this blog on our social media pages to gain followers. Use multimedia on YouTube and Tumblr: We can make informational videos about what we do, our social mission and a call to action for others to get involved. Use SEO (search engine optimization) to make sure the website is primed for performance on search engines. Engage with the press: Write press releases to help generate publicity Arrange speaking opportunities with schools and organizations. Organization and Management: Organization Timeline: Steps for scalability and growth 1.Preparation for launch 2. Establish Start-up 3. Retention and growth 4. Sustainable revenue model 4. Track/ manage continued growth 5. Scale nationally 16 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Phase 1: Establishment I am currently searching for a Co-founder that shares the same vision as me and has complimentary strengths so that we can effectively build and scale Students Flourish. Management Key First Hires: CEO: Danielle Bicknell CTO: Co-founder position Data Scientist: Co-founder position Phase 2: Establish Start-Up. Key Next phase hires include, but are not limited to: COO/ Head of Operations: To oversee management and hiring Head of Marketing: To optimize the website and gain users Social Innovation Officer: To ensure the social mission is aligned with the business goals Customer Service: To oversee quality assurance of users and deal with any issues they may have using the service. Report website issues to engineers to fix. CFO: To manage financials internally and externally Frontend/Backend Engineers: To build and maintain the function of the website Board Members: Potential members to reach out to o Business: Jeff Stewart Lenddo CEO and Dave Girouard Upstart Founder. o Nonprofit: Robert Cordray, Head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau o Government: Senator Elizabeth Warren (Massehusetts) 17 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Appendix 1: Logic Model: Students Flourish Inputs Activities Outputs Outcomes Impact • • • • • • Staff/Employees Investors (funding) Algorithm for new credit score SF website with student databse Student Data Student customers • • • • • Marketing/ outreach to students, schools and lenders Encourage students to complete SF profile online Provide students with credit score Provide banks with credit score Maintain website • Students receive new credit score • Banks receive new credit score and offer certain students lower interest loans • • • • Increase of students receive more competitive options for loans Decrease in student debt Increase in banks ability to expand services to students Increase in awareness about student borrowing behavior • Students are finanically empowered to attend college without financial burderns 18 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan Appendix 2: SWOT Analysis: Students Flourish Strengths Weaknesses • Students get better loans • Banks can expand lending to larger customer base • Students have less debt • Students can afford to go to first choice college • Students have more options for college funding • Banks have more accurate data about student creditworthiness • Needs government/business recognition to hold weight in the industry • Hard to market without buy in from stakeholders • Needs large user base to work • Needs time (3+ years) to test and reports results to iterate on algorithim • Major competitor (FICO) has 100% of market share and has been established for ~20 years Opportunities Threats • Can partner with banks to strengthen reach and message • Can collaborate with other innovative fin. tech. companies • Lots of opportunity for press (innovative financial services is hot topic) • Word of mouth marketing potential • Collaborate/partner with colleges • No users, no ability to build/operate Students Flourish (SF) • Government could inhibit performance • Businesses could back out and weaken the brand • SF could measure the wrong metrics and put students in a worse position • Poor collaboration with other companies could threaten SF • No business recognizes score and company fails 19 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan References 1 Lapovsky, Lucie. "Many Students Can't Afford Their First Choice College." Forbes. April 3, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.forbes.com/sites/lucielapovsky/2014/04/03/manystudents-cant-afford-their-first-choice-college/. 2 "Financing Postsecondary Education in the United States." National Center for Education Statistics. May 1, 2013. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_tua.asp. 3 Ibid. 4 Ibid. 5 "QUARTERLY REPORT ON HOUSEHOLD DEBT AND CREDIT." Federal Reserve Bank of New York. November 1, 2012. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.newyorkfed.org/research/national_economy/householdcredit/DistrictReport_Q32012 .pdf. 6 "Fast Facts: Back to School Statistics." National Center for Education Statistics. August, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=372. 7 O'Shaughnessy, Lynn. "20 Facts You Didn't Know about College Freshmen." CBSNews. February 7, 2012. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.cbsnews.com/news/20-facts-you-didntknow-about-college-freshmen/. 8 Ibid. 9 Ibid. 10 http://www.freshminds.net/2013/02/big-data-in-retail-banking-the-opportunities-andchallenges/ 11 Balea, Judith. "Lenddo Stops Lending, Now Helps Clients Determine Customer Trustworthiness." Tech in Asia RSS. January 26, 2015. Accessed May 1, 2015. https://www.techinasia.com/lenddo-customer-trustworthiness/. 12 Lapovsky, Lucie. "Many Students Can't Afford Their First Choice College." Forbes. April 3, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.forbes.com/sites/lucielapovsky/2014/04/03/manystudents-cant-afford-their-first-choice-college/. 13 Porter, Margot Vanover. "National Association of College and Business Officers." Tuition Upsets. July 1, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.nacubo.org/Business_Officer_Magazine/Magazine_Archives/JulyAugust_2014/Tuiti on_Upsets.html. 14 Woodruff, Mandi. "9 Students Reveal Their Unbelievable Loan Horror Stories." Business Insider. December 8, 2011. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.businessinsider.com/x-studentloan-horror-stories-2011-12. 15 "Submit a Complaint Consumer Financial Protection Bureau." Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. January 1, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.consumerfinance.gov/complaint/#student-loan. 16 Balea, Judith. "Lenddo Stops Lending, Now Helps Clients Determine Customer Trustworthiness." Tech in Asia RSS. January 26, 2015. Accessed May 1, 2015. https://www.techinasia.com/lenddo-customer-trustworthiness/. 20 Danielle Bicknell NPLD 510 Social Venture Plan 17 Ludwig, Adam. "Upstart's P2P Lending Platform Aims At Young Borrowers." Forbes. August 8, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.forbes.com/sites/techonomy/2014/08/18/upstartsp2p-lending-platform-aims-at-young-borrowers/. 18 Grasgreen, Allie. "Elizabeth Warren Will 'keep Hitting' at Student Loans." POLITICO. September 17, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://www.politico.com/story/2014/09/elizabethwarren-student-loans-suze-orman-111046.html. 19 "B Corporation." What Are B Corps? Accessed May 1, 2015. https://www.bcorporation.net/what-are-b-corps. 20 Pratt, Jon. "Analyzing the dynamics of funding: Reliability and autonomy."Strange Accounts: Understanding Nonprofit Finance, Compiled articles from The Nonprofit Quarterly (2005): 1925. 21 Shields, Anne. "Must-know: An Overview of "big Data"" Why Traditional Database Systems Fail to Support "big Data" July 25, 2014. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://marketrealist.com/2014/07/traditional-database-systems-fail-support-big-data/. 22 "Impact HUB: San Francisco." Impact HUB. Accessed May 1, 2015. http://sanfrancisco.impacthub.net/become-a-member/. 23 Beigi, Homayoon. Fundamentals of speaker recognition. Springer Science & Business Media, 2011. 21