Chapter 8: E-Business Strategy For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 1 LEARNING OBJECTIVES(1): • Outline the steps involved in strategy development. • Explain the major drivers of e-business strategy and their impact. • Explain the importance of an e-business value chain. • Discuss the roles of alliances and acquisitions to strategy development. • Identify the major strategies e-businesses are using to differentiate themselves. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 2 LEARNING OBJECTIVES(2): • List the advantages that a pioneering firm can gain. • Explain the importance of brand names for ebusinesses. • Describe the strategic role of portals. • Identify the alternative competitive arenas where ebusinesses can find opportunities. • Describe the measures that businesses can use to judge e-business success. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 3 Vignette: Microsoft vs. The World (1) • Thinking Strategically – Determine what environmental factors are influencing Microsoft. – Contrast Microsoft’s strengths and weaknesses. Decide which of Microsoft’s strengths allow it to gain an advantage over its competitors. – List environmental threats that Microsoft faces currently and could face in the future. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 4 Microsoft's Internet Strategic Actions: Purchases/License/Alliances • 1994 License Spyglass browser • • • • • • • technology. 1995 MS invests UUNet. 1995 AOL. 1996 Purchase Vermeer Technology. 1996 Purchase Colusa Software Inc. 1996 Purchases eShop, Inc. 1996 Purchases Electric Gravity, Inc. 1996 Sun Microsystems License. • 1996 AT&T, Netcom, • • • • • MCI, CompuServe alliances. 1997 Invests in Realnetworks. 1997 Purchases HotMail for $400 million. 1997 Purchases WebTV for $425 million. 1999 Invests in Nextel. 1999 Invests in AT&T. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 5 Vignette: Microsoft vs. The World (3) • Thinking Strategically – Determine what steps Microsoft could take to lower those threats. – Speculate on the future opportunities that Microsoft may have. – List the different competitive arenas in which Microsoft is competing. – Determine what steps Microsoft would need to take to take to pursue those opportunities. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 6 What Is Strategy • A strategy consists of a pattern of decisions that set the goals and objectives that lead to long run competitive advantages for a firm. – Undertake a SWOT analysis. – Determining distinctive competencies. Determining the competitive arena. – Develop a plan to reach the business goals. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 7 Steps for Strategy Development (1) • Undertake a SWOT analysis. – Evaluate the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats facing a business. • Determining distinctive competencies. – Analyze a business’s value chain to help identify internal strengths and weaknesses that can help determine how a business can compete. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 8 Definitions: • A value chain is a way of envisioning the collection of activities that a business undertakes to design, produce, market, deliver, and support products or services. • The Competitive Arena is the competitive environment in which a business competes. • Distinctive Competencies are unique areas of advantage where a firm can differentiate itself from competitors. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 9 Steps for Strategy Development (2) • Determining the competitive arena. – Determine the competitive environment in which a business competes • Helps set the mission • Indicates the windows of opportunity to be pursued • Identifies the competitive environment. • Develop a plan to reach the business goals. – Outline the strategic actions and tactics a business must undertake to move from where and how it currently competes to where and how it needs to compete given its distinctive competencies. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 10 Model of Strategy Development Strategy Environmental Forces For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Competitive Threats Strategic Drivers Value Chain (Strengths & Weaknesses) Chapter 8 Slide: 11 Table 8.1: Drivers of Environmental Turbulence Environmental Drivers Technological change Changing customers Description Moore's law more power and lower costs is allowing technology to be applied across a broader spectrum of products and uses. Customers around the globe accepting Internet use and on-line purchasing. Individuals are facing time compression and technology is being used as an enabler to accomplish more. Customers have increased power due. Product life cycles are growing shorter due to the rapid development Shorter of new technology, aggressive marketing, and a willingness of buyers product life to try new products. cycles Distance between competitors is vanishing. causing an increase in the Number of intensity of competition. competitors Need for speed Instant connectivity is becoming the norm in business-to-business applications as well as in the way that consumers shop. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 12 E-Business Value Chain (1) E-business value chains view information technology as part of a business’ overall value chain adding to the competitive advantages of a business Inbound Logistics Extranets: Lowers costs increase speed Production ERP Software: Lowers costs Customized Production: Differential Advantage Management Leadership: Management Intranets: Lower costs, better communication. Innovativeness: Speed, flexibility, new product ideas Marketing/Sales E-commerce: Lower costs, new market entry. Databases: Meet market needs better, make better decisions. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Customer Support Internet: Lower costs, speeds service. Competitive Advantage Through Stronger Customer Relationships Chapter 8 Slide: 13 E-Business Value Chain (2) Inbound Logistics Extranets: Lowers costs increase speed Inbound Logistics Extranets: Lowers costs increase speed Production ERP Software: Lowers costs Customized Production: Differential Advantage Management Leadership: Management Intranets: Lower costs, better communication. Innovativeness: Speed, flexibility, new product ideas Marketing/Sales E-commerce: Lower costs, new market entry. Databases: Meet market needs better, make better decisions. Production ERP Software: Lowers costs Customized Production: Differential Advantage Customer Support Internet: Lower costs, speeds service. Competitive Advantage Through Stronger Customer Relationships Management Leadership: Intranets: Lower costs, better communication. Innovativeness: Speed, flexibility, new product ideas For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 14 E-Business Value Chain (2) Inbound Logistics Extranets: Lowers costs increase speed Production ERP Software: Lowers costs Customized Production: Differential Advantage Marketing/Sales E-commerce: Lower costs, new market entry. Databases: Meet market needs better, make better decisions. Management Leadership: Management Intranets: Lower costs, better communication. Innovativeness: Speed, flexibility, new product ideas Marketing/Sales E-commerce: Lower costs, new market entry. Databases: Meet market needs better, make better decisions. Customer Support Internet: Lower costs, speeds service. Customer Support Internet: Lower costs, speeds service. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Competitive Advantage Through Stronger Customer Relationships Competitive Advantage Through Stronger Customer Relationships Chapter 8 Slide: 15 Figure 8.3: Coca-Cola E-Business Value Chain(1) Inbound Logistics Extranets: Lowers costs increase speed Inbound Logistics Extranets: Links Coke with bottling partners and suppliers. Production ERP Software: Lowers costs Customized Production: Differential Advantage Management Leadership: Management Intranets: Lower costs, better communication. Innovativeness: Speed, flexibility, new product ideas Production ERP Software: Links Coke with its bottling partners. Provides interconnected management system. Marketing/Sales E-commerce: Lower costs, new market entry. Databases: Meet market needs better, make better decisions. Customer Support Internet: Lower costs, speeds service. Competitive Advantage Through Stronger Customer Relationships Management Leadership: Intranets: Management willing to change and sell ideas. Intranets: Worldwide systems improves communication. Innovativeness: New approach in the soft-drink industry. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 16 Figure 8.3: Coca-Cola E-Business Value Chain(2) Inbound Logistics Extranets: Lowers costs increase speed Production ERP Software: Lowers costs Customized Production: Differential Advantage Marketing/Sales E-commerce: Cellular linked vending machines. Databases: Used with decision support systems. Can determine the effectiveness of marketing efforts. Management Leadership: Management Intranets: Lower costs, better communication. Innovativeness: Speed, flexibility, new product ideas Marketing/Sales E-commerce: Lower costs, new market entry. Databases: Meet market needs better, make better decisions. Customer Support Internet: Lower costs, speeds service. Customer Support Internet: Provide more timely delivery to trade customers. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Competitive Advantage Through Stronger Customer Relationships Competitive Advantage Through Stronger Customer Relationships Chapter 8 Slide: 17 Alliances & Acquisitions • The creation of an e-business value chain may come from forming alliances or through the acquisition. – Alliances are formal or informal relationships between independent companies that work together for a common purpose. – An acquisition exists when one corporation purchases all or a controlling part of another company. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 18 Portals • A portal is an entranceway onto the Internet. • They are often the preferred starting point for: – Searches – Entertainment – Information, – Email, – Or any other Internet based product. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 19 E-BUSINESS STRATEGY • Low cost and therefore low price competitor. – A "frictionless" Internet market implies that customers have almost perfect information and can compare prices around the world (by using intelligence agents to search out the best prices enhances this process). • Differentiation strategy by finding a unique market position against competitors. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 20 Table 8.2: Methods of Differentiation Differentiation Advantages Strategy Gain Speed & This provides a number of first mover First Mover advantages including Advantages costs, meeting needs, lowering risk, and lower prices. Gives buyers Build Brand assurance when Name interacting with a site. Allows for easy name recognition. Disadvantages Firms need to be flexible to be fast. Being first increases risks and may require large amounts of capital to maintain advantages. Requires a large amount of capital to obtain and maintain a brand name. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 21 Table 8.2: Methods of Differentiation Differentiation Advantages Strategy Allows for economies of Portal Development scale and builds barriers to entry. Pursue Niche Very good strategy for smaller or weaker Strategies businesses. Allows a business to focus and become an expert in one competitive arena. Allows businesses to build Enhanced barrier to entry. By staying Customer Relationships close to customers business can meet needs better. Disadvantages Requires large amount of capital, pushing off profitability. Having only one niche can be risky because all of the "eggs" could be in one basket or with one customer. Could result in a loss of power by the business supplying the product or service. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 22 Case 8.1: CDNOW: Here for Now • Thinking Strategically – Consider how a business that sells CDs could differentiate itself from other CD selling businesses. – Determine what components of the e-business value chain could be used to create value. – Visit the CDNOW web site (www.cdnow.com). Determine how this site is differentiated from other CD selling sites. – List a number of competitive threats that could impact CDNOW’s competitive position. – Suggest strategic actions that CDNOW can take to remain competitive into the future. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 23 Speed and First Mover Advantages • A pioneering firm has differentiated itself from competition because it is the first to enter a competitive arena or it is able help define the competitive arena. – Advantages: • Lower Costs • Meeting Current Needs • Lower Consumer Risk Perception • Charge Higher Prices For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 24 Costs Advantages • May increase the business’ or product's time in a life cycle, spreading development costs over time and the number of products produced. Firms that follow have less time in the life cycle to recover all costs • An early entry firm can gain cost advantages through experience curves and when greater market shares are obtained they obtain greater economies of scale. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 25 Meeting Current Needs • The faster a business can respond to the market, the more likely that information from areas such as marketing research will be valid resulting in actions that could lead to higher market share. • First, movers have been shown to have a substantially higher market share than later entrants. A product that is six months late to market may miss out on one third of the potential profit over the product's lifetime. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 26 Consumer Risk Perceptions • First mover may become the comparison standard for all rival products by setting the standard for performance. • Consumers may lower the risk involved in purchasing by choosing a product with an established image or brand. • Innovators and early adopters may try first mover products first and influence others through the diffusion process. • Advertising and publicity aids in consumer search, but given the lack of alternative products in many innovative markets, advertising may have the effect of setting relevant product attributes the consumer uses in the evaluation process. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 27 Comparison Standard and Switching Cost • A comparison standard is what the customer uses to judge a product. – For example, if a customer had first gained their online search experience with Yahoo!, they will evaluate all other search engines against Yahoo. • A switching cost is the additional "costs" involved in learning something new. – The costs involved in adopting a new software package would include the software expense, support, training costs, and slowed productivity costs. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 28 Prices • Higher introductory prices can be charged for innovative buyers who is often more risk tolerant and may have higher disposable income. • With greater amounts of information available to the later adopting consumer, backed by possible word of mouth about benefits, a higher price can be maintained. • Later entering firms are seen as higher risk because of lack of information on their products, forcing them to charge lower prices. Remaining customers may be those who are more risk adverse driving the later entrants price even lower. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 29 Case 8.2: EToys: First on the Block • Thinking Strategically – Speculate on the importance of the first mover advantage for EToys. – List some of the advantages that EToys may have gained because they beat Toys R’Us to the market. – Consider if the order of entry was reversed, would EToys have been able to gain market share? Recommend a strategy that EToys could follow to maintain its competitive advantage. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 30 First and Second Movers • Being the first entrant into a market does not guarantee a long term competitive advantage. firm must have: A – Expertise, resources, and creativity necessary to exploit first mover opportunities. • Pioneers must find ways to forestall or neutralize the efforts of later entrants or they will not gain first mover advantages. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 31 Building Barriers • Entry Into an Industry Can Be Limited by: – Gaining Economies of Scale – Cost Advantages – Developing High Switching Cost – Brand Names – Strong Customer Relationships • Development of Portals For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 32 Brand Names • A brand is a sign, symbol, design, term, name or combination that allows for easy recognition of a product or company. – Brand names often give assurance to the purchaser because they believe that the risk of using a brand name is lower. • Build online brand names by: – Online and offline advertising – Ease of navigation and overall experience that a user has with the Web Site. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 33 Portals Portals are the sites that users depend on to access other Internet services. http://www.mediametrix.com/TopRankings/TopRankings.html 1 Table 8.3: Top Web Domains* From Homes % From Businesses AOL.com 46.0 Yahoo.com Yahoo.com 40.5 Netscape.com Microsoft.com 27.3 Aol.com Geocities.com 25.9 Microsoft.com Netscape.com 25.4 Excite.com Excite.com 23.2 Infoseek.com Infoseek.com 15.6 Geocities.com Angelfire.com 15.1 Altavista.digital.com Lycos.com 14.5 Lycos.com Msn.com 1 % 49.0 40.0 34.1 33.0 30.3 22.8 22.1 19.9 19.7 14.3 Data from July 1998, source: Jim Kerstetter, “Will Portals Pay Off?” PC Week, August 31, 1998, pp. 1+14-15. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 34 Case: AOL: Nobody’s Laughing Now • Thinking Strategically – Speculate on the reasons for AOL’s portal success. – Determine why AOL was able to grow to dominate Internet access. – List some advantages that AOL’s size gives it in the competitive portal arena. – Compare and contrast AOL (www.aol.com) against other portal sites. Determine how differentiated these sites are from each other. – Justify AOL’s use of strategic alliances to maintain its advantages. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 35 Niche Portals • Niche portals target specific markets – The number one sport site targeted toward males 1834 is ESPN (www.espn.com). – IVillage is a site targeted toward women (www.ivillage.com). – E*Trade (www.etrade.com) targets individuals interested in receiving financial information. – Snap (www.snap.com) offers "rich-media”. • International portals target international markets For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 36 International Portals • International portals target national or ethnic markets – Yahoo have services for European, Asian, and other country specific markets. – StarMedia (www.starmedia.com) is a portal site specifically designed to serve the Spanish speaking markets of Central and South America as well as in the United States. – SurfChina.com (www.surfchina.com) is a search engine for Chinese Web sites. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 37 Vertical Portals • Vertical Portals are designed to serve narrow niches within specific industries. – Allow business users a one-stop site for all information and purchase needs, allowing businesses access to industry or trade information and to buy and sell online. • VerticalNet (www.verticalnet.com) hosts vertical sites for technology, communications, food service, healthcare, and other firms. • Asay Publishing (www.asaypub.com) serves the used office equipment after-market. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 38 Competitive Strategies Small and Meduim Sized Enterprise Strategies*i Strategy % of Advantages Respondents Over 80% Online systems allow channel members and consumers Customer to gain access to product and inventory information. service Over 60% This allows SMEs access to larger markets without the Electronic cost of setting up new distribution systems and target commerce narrow markets faster. Lower overhead costs can be carried over to lower prices to customers. Over 50% Online connections between the SME and its customers Customerincrease the speed of response and allow for close to relationship instant communication. Linked Extranets allow SMEs to management act as virtual partners with other businesses. applications Over 40% SMEs can act as a virtual marketing intermediary linking B-to-B larger businesses with very small suppliers. Online connections access to inventory and supplies helps control costs. (extranets) i Natalie Engler, “Small But Nimble,” Information Week, January 18, 1999, pp. 57-62. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 39 Low Resource High Resource Strategies for Existing Businesses Table 8.5: E-Business Strategy Matrix Characterized by: High brand name recognition. Large portals and general e-commerce sites Keys to success: Heavy brand name advertising. Examples: Yahoo, Amazon.com, Disney, WalMart, Schwab.com. Characterized by: Low brand name recognition. Keys to success: First mover advantages. Enhance customer relationships. Examples: CDNow, E-Toys, SMEs with Web site support. Low Differentiation Characterized by: High brand name recognition with niche markets. Keys to success: Develop vertical portals. Serve niche community. Examples: iVillage, VerticalNet, ESPN.com. Characterized by: Low brand name recognition outside of niche market. Keys to success: First mover advantages. Serve niche markets. Enhance customer relationships. Examples: Asay Publishing, High Differentiation For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 40 ALE 8.1: Evaluating An E-Business Value Chain • Develop a value chain model for an industry or business. – Identify the key e-business technologies needed to compete in the chosen industry. – Identify which of the value chain components would give a business in that industry a distinctive advantage. – Determine if it is possible to hold that advantage over time. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 41 ALE 8.2: SWOT Box exercise • Use the following matrix to undertake a SWOT analysis by identifying the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats faced by a business or industry. Strengths: Weaknesses: Opportunities: Threats: • Recommend an e-business strategy that could be pursued to reach the opportunity and limit future threats. For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 42 Exercise 8.3: Evaluating Differential Advantages For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Free Home Pages Other Finance Weather Personalization Shopping Chat Games Sports Free Email News Major Portal Sites Search • Use the table below to indicate the types of services offered by portal sites. • Determine what allows each to differentiate themselves from others. • If you can not find any differences, determine what that means for the long-term survival for some of these portal sites. Chapter 8 Slide: 43 ALE 8.4: Strategy Analysis Matrix • Identify strategic positions of a number of ebusinesses. (Try to find at least one business for each cell in the matrix.) • Identify the strategies these businesses are pursuing and the keys to their long-term success. Table 8.5: E-Business Strategy Analysis Matrix High Characterized by: Characterized by: Resource Keys to success: Keys to success: Low Characterized by: Resource Keys to success: Low differentiation Characterized by: Keys to success: High differentiation For use with Strategic Electronic Marketing: Managing E-Business Copyright 2000 South-Western College Publishing Chapter 8 Slide: 44