Diffusion Tensor Imaging: Is It Ready For The Clinic ? eEdE:14 Tushar Chandra, MD1 Mohit Agarwal, MD1 Ibrahim Tuna, MD1 Laura Kohl, MD1 Andrew Klein, MD1 Leighton Mark, MD1 Mohit Maheshwari, MD1 Suyash Mohan, MD2 Sumei Wang, MD2 John Ulmer, MD1 Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee1 Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania2 Disclosures Nothing to disclose Educational Educational Objectives Objectives Succinct overview of the fundamental principles and techniques of diffusion imaging, Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), fiber tractography and Diffusion kurtosis imaging (DKI) Simplified interpretation of DTI metrics Discuss clinical application of DTI in neuropathology Overview technical limitations and pitfalls Introduction Introduction Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) is a novel method which has various applications in clinical neuroimaging and research Within the central nervous system, water diffusion is more anisotropic in white matter and isotropic in gray matter and CSF This property can be exploited to highlight white matter changes in various pathological processes DTI is a powerful tool for assessment of microstructural integrity of the white matter qualitatively as well as quantitatively Diffusion imaging - Principle Water molecules in biological tissues are in constant movement, governed by two major principles: a. Fick`s Law: Random diffusion due to concentration differences b. Temperature and ion-ion interactions Random Brownian Motion Free Diffusion Diffusion of water molecules can be restricted in various pathological conditions Restricted Diffusion Diffusion imaging Free Diffusion Restricted Diffusion Diffusion imaging Diffusion imaging - Technique Detects the molecular motion of water and allows for quantitative assessement of the freedom of diffusion The addition of 2 strong, symmetric gradients to a EPI SE sequence helps in differentiation of stationary from mobile water molecules If there is net movement of spins (i.e. if diffusion occurs) between the 2 gradients, signal attenuation occurs Radiographics 2006;26: S205-223 Diffusion Signal Diffusion imaging Application of gradients Signal drop Gradients cause a drop in signal if diffusion is present No Diffusion Between Gradients More signal More Diffusion Between Gradients Less signal ‘b’ value Represents the strength of ‘diffusion sensitizing gradients’ Expressed in s/mm2 The larger the b value, the smaller magnitudes of water motion detected. b 0 image: No diffusion weighting Poor man’s gradient or T2 Apparent diffusion coefficient - ADC Measures area of water molecular diffusion in 1 second Expressed in mm2/s Reduced ADC - acute stroke, abscesses, cellular neoplasms, recurrent tumors Increased ADC – benign lesions, necrosis, post radiation changes Why Apparent? Since MRI cannot distinguish molecular motion arising from differences in concentration gradient from that resulting from temperature gradient or other reasons, the coefficient is apparent and not a true value Exponential Apparent diffusion coefficient -eADC Derived from dividing DWI by T2 images to remove effects of T2 shine through True restricted diffusion – dark on ADC, bright on eADC ADC or eADC maps can be used depending on whether we want contrast to match, or be opposite to, the diffusion weighted images Exponential Apparent diffusion coefficient -eADC DWI ADC eADC An area of increased diffusion signal on DWI image in the left parietal lobe in a 60 y/o male with treated astrocytoma is slightly dark on ADC but not increased in signal on eADC, suggesting that there is no ‘true’ restricted diffusion. There was no recurrent tumor on pathology Diffusion Tensor imaging ISOTROPIC- Equal diffusion in all directions ANISOTROPIC – Diffusion preferentially increased in some directions Diffusion Tensor imaging DTI requires obtaining data from diffusion acquisitions with gradients in different directions in each acquisition to provide directional information to the diffusion data The information is provided by 3 eigen values which represent the direction of 3 major axes of the ellipsoid and 3 eigen vectors that represent the magnitude in these directions Isotropic Diffusion In the white matter, diffusion is anisotropic and is related to cell density and integrity, axonal integrity, and myelination status Anisotropic Diffusion Physiological Principals of DTI White matter H2O H2O H2O H2O Diffusion Gradients Physiological Principals of DTI White matter Voxel H2O H2O Diffusion Ellipsoids Commentaries: Mark, Ulmer. AJNR 2002, 2004 Diffusion Tensor Diffusion Tensor imaging Tensor is a mathematical model of directional anisotropy of diffusion Diffusion tensor describes Gaussian diffusion distribution - a 3D ellipsoid with lengths and orientations of the 3 axes corresponding to the eigen vectors - λ1, λ2 and λ3 Acquisition in at least 6 directions is required, but clinically up to 30 directions are used From the tensor, we can calculate: a. Direction of greatest diffusion b. Degree of anisotropy c. Diffusion constant in any direction λ1 λ2 λ3 Diffusion Kurtosis imaging DTI Metrics and Tensor Diffusion Kurtosis imaging Diffusion Kurtosis imaging λ1 λ2 λ1 λ2 λ3 λ3 ISOTROPIC ANISOTROPIC Mean Diffusivity (MD) = (λ1+λ2+λ3)/3 Axial Diffusivity (Da) = λ1 Radial Diffusivity (Dr) = (λ2+λ3)/2 Fractional anisotropy - FA Measures the degree of anisotropic (unequal) diffusion in a voxel Ranges from 0 to 1 (no units) 0 – isotropic (sphere-like) 1 – Purely anisotropic (straight line) Color coded FA map (Red –Higher FA, Blue – Lower FA) Note thatWM tracts showing red color have a higher FA Can characterize demyelinating lesions, e.g., breakdown of myelin and axonal loss can reduce FA and remyelination can increase FA FA value of CSF is 0. Mean Diffusivity - MD Measure of directionally averaged magnitude of diffusion (λ1+λ2+λ3)/3 Higher MD values mean that the tissue is more isotropic MD is an inverse measure of membrane density and tumor cellularity Color coded MD map (Red –lower MD Purple – higher MD) Sensitive to cellularity, edema and necrosis Axial Diffusivity - Da Da is the apparent diffusion parallel to white matter tracts Da = Prinicipal Eigen value = λ1 Da is variable in white matter pathologies Color coded Da map (Red –Higher Da Blue – Lower Da) Da decreases in axonal degeneration Radial Diffusivity - Dr Apparent diffusion perpendicular to the white matter tracts Dr = (λ2+λ3)/2 Dr generally increases in white matter demyelination and dysmyelination Color coded Dr map (Red –Higher Dr Green – Lower FA) Change in axonal diameter and density also affect Dr Fiber DTITractography - Tractography Technique to assess direction of white matter tracts within the brain Directional information from neighboring voxels is combined to estimate 3D structure of major white-matter pathways Voxels are connected together taking into consideration both the direction of principle Eigen vector and FA value DTI - HARDI DTI ellipsoid not accurate for detecting white matter tracts as it assumes one direction of axons in each voxel (in truth, there are crossing fibers in each voxel) HARDI – can assess crossing tracts in the same voxel Diffusion Kurtosis imaging DKI is an extension of conventional DTI. DTI assumes Gaussian distribution (bell shaped curve) of diffusion (not accurate), as water diffusion in biological tissues is non-Gaussian. Due to the effects of cellular microstructure e.g., cell membranes, organelles & myelin in brain Diffusion kurtosis – studies non-Gaussian diffusion behavior. Leptokurtic- K>0 Mesokurtic –K=0 Platykurtic –K<0 Kurtosis measures the "peakedness" of the probability distribution. Qualitatively, a large diffusional kurtosis suggests a high degree of diffusional heterogeneity and microstructural complexity. Diffusion Kurtosis imaging From the diffusion and diffusional kurtosis tensors several rotationally invariant metrics such as the mean, axial, and radial kurtoses can be computed The extra information provided by DKI can also resolve intra-voxel fiber crossings and thus be used to improve fiber tractography of white matter DKI protocols require at least 3 b-values (as compared to 2 b-values for DTI) and at least 15 independent diffusion gradient directions (as compared to 6 for DTI) Typical protocols for brain have b-values of 0, 1000, 2000 s/mm2 with 30 diffusion directions Functional MRI BOLD – Blood Oxygen Level Dependent Rest: Normal flow Activity: High flow - Deoxyhemoglobin - Oxyhemoglobin As neural activity increases, blood flow increases Deoxyhemoglobin (paramagnetic) concentration decreases Magnetic field homogeneity increases And therefore gradient echo EPI signal increases, rather than loss of signal BOLD technique is used with DTI fiber tractography in pre-surgical mapping. Clinical Applications – Normal Brain Fiber tracking provides critical information about white matter anatomy and connections Regions with similar tractographic features tend to be functionally co-activated “neurons that fire together, wire together” IQ has been positively correlated with anisotropy in white matter association areas Reading ability has been correlated with anisotropy of left temporoparietal areas In the visual pathway, DTI has shown the retinotopic organization of fibers Clinical Applications - Tumors MD decreases as tumor cellularity increases, due to decreased ECF volume Atypical and malignant meningiomas - lower MD than typical meningiomas Flair hyperintense mass in Right frontotemporal region Primary CNS lymphoma and Medulloblastoma also have low MD MD increases with tumor response with treatment and can be used as a biomarker Relationship of FA with tumor cellularity and treatment response is unclear In the peritumoral zone, DTI metrics do not reliably differentiate edema from tumor infiltration Increased MD suggesting low cellularity Gr II glioma at biopsy Clinical Applications - Tumors Intact WM tracts displaced by tumor retain anisotropy and remain identifiable Edematous or tumor-infiltrated tracts lose some anisotropy but remain identifiable Destroyed WM tracts lose directional organization and diffusion anisotropy is lost completely Jellinson et al. AJNR 2004 Diffusion-weighted imaging: Diffusion Image, Apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC), eADC – tumor cellularity Diffusion tensor imaging: Fractional anisotropy, diffusivity (mean, axial and radial) – tumor biology Diffusion and Functional Imaging For Tumors Tractography: Accurate localization of white matter tracts in relationship to the tumor margins Functional MR Imaging: Depiction of eloquent cortical areas in relationship to tumor margins Clinical Applications - Presurgical Brain Mapping Progression free survival is directly related to the extent of resection Motor Area However, benefits of cytoreduction must be weighed against risk of damage to eloquent structures and white matter tracts Pre-surgical mapping with DTI and fMRI results in more informed presurgical planning and decreases the risk of post operative neurological deficits White Matter Tracts Tumor Fused image with functional motor areas and white matter tracts superimposed on FLAIR depict relationship of tumor to eloquent cortex and white matter tracts Fiber Tractography - Presurgical Brain Mapping 34-year-old, right-handed woman with a posterior parasylvian low-grade glioma. SPGR gadolinium-enhanced underlays with 50% faded Colorcoded fractional anisotropy (CC-FA) diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) map Track-ball filtering of whole brain fiber tracking DTI data reveals better detail of spatial relationships between tumor and SLF HB, SLF IV, IFOF, ILF, and OR IFOF = Inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus, ILF = Inferior longitudinal fasciculus, SLF HB = Superior longitudinal fasciculus horizontal bundle, SLF IV = Superior longitudinal fasciculus IV, OR = Optic radiation, UF = Uncinate fasciculus Ulmer et al Neuroradiology Clinics of North America 2014 Tumors - Which functional systems are at risk ? Motor (Corticospinal Tract) Vision (ILF, IFOF Optic Radiations) Language (SLF,ILF,IFOF) Vision (Optic Radiation) Clinical Applications - Demyelination MS lesions have higher ADC and lower FA values than Normal Appearing White Matter (NAWM) Significantly increased ADC and lower FA values are seen in acute (enhancing) MS lesions than chronic (non enhancing) lesions FLAIR : MS plaque MD image: High MD Color FA Map : low FA Tractography: Decreased WM fibers Non enhancing TI hypointense lesions have higher ADC and lower FA values than T1 isointense lesions Clinical Applications - Epilepsy Increased MD and lower FA values are seen in hippocampi of patients with mesial temporal sclerosis Gray Matter Heterotopia In patients with malformations of cortical development, increased MD and lower FA values are seen in abnormal areas within MCD and also in the normal appearing areas on MR Increased MD and low FA can be used to localize lesions in MR negative cases of epilepsy Displaced WM Tracts Decreased Radial Diffusivity Clinical Applications – Congenital Anomalies White matter abnormalities in congenital brain malformations can be assessed with DTI Pertinent applications include callosal agenesis, cortical dysplasia, holoprosencephaly, schizencephaly, Chiari II malformation etc Schizencephaly DTI Disrupted WM Tracts Improved understanding of white matter abnormalities in developmental lesions fMRI – Motor Cortex Along the cleft Clinical Applications – Traumatic Brain Injury DTI is a useful technique to evaluate microstructural injury to the white matter fiber tracts in patients with TBI Decreased FA and increased MD are seen in areas afflicted by TBI, that are occult on conventional MRI Studies suggest some correlation between findings on DTI with EEG and neuropsychological testing In the future, DTI may serve as a surrogate marker for closed head injury Cingulum Temporal White Matter Interpretative Challenges of Clinical DTI Tumor, edema and radiation-induced decrease in anisotropy. Tumor-induced geometric distortions of fiber tracts. Anatomic constraints • Distinguishing functionally different pathways in the same white matter bundle. • Acute angulations and blending of white matter pathways. DTI data are imperfect! Conclusion DTI is a powerful tool to investigate microstructural white matter changes and brain connectivity DTI is currently being clinically used in conjunction with functional MRI for presurgical brain mapping and is gradually becoming the standard of care For indications such as demyelination, trauma, epilepsy and congenital anomalies, DTI provides useful information that is clinically helpful and often helps in diagnostic interpretation and clinical decision making As the technique becomes more robust, it will be increasingly applied in clinical practice for other indications Thank You Author: Tushar Chandra Clinical Instructor, Radiology Medical College of Wisconsin 9200 W Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee WI 53226 Email: drtusharchandra@gmail.com