Running head: ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder and its causal relationship with the SNAP 25 gene a systematic review study. By Jacqulyne Taylor BS, Concordia University, 2015 Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Master's Degree in Public Health Concordia University June, 2015 1 ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 2 Abstract Over the past fifty years Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) has been one of the most studied childhood neurodevelopmental disorders. Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) is growing in numbers every year and can cause many debilitating issues. A few of these symptoms are: having a hard time resisting temptation, having trouble taking turns, and have difficulty getting along with others. To this day there is still not any concrete ways to test for this condition other than subjective data. My research project delves into the possibility that there is a relationship between the SNAP-25 gene mutation and AttentionDeficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). The importance of this research project is that if science can find a cause for this condition then tests can be developed to diagnose children at a much earlier age. If a diagnosis can be made earlier, then non-pharmacological interventions can be created to help aid in adaptation. The primary research question is whether there is an association between the SNAP-25 gene. This study utilized a systematic review method to compare relevant studies. ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 3 Table of Contents Chapter Page 1. Introduction 5 Statement of the Problem 5 Purpose and Significance of the Study 6 Research Questions and Associated Hypothesis 7 2. Literature Review 7 Search Strategy 7 Theoretical Foundation 8 Literature Review Related to Key Variables or Concepts 8 Conclusion 10 3. Methods 10 Methods 10 Inclusion and Exclusion criteria 11 Data Analysis Plan 12 4. Results 12 Data Collection 13 Results 15 5. Conclusions 16 Interpretation of the Findings 16 Limitations of the Study 17 Recommendations 18 Implications for Social Change 18 ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) Conclusion References 4 18 19 ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 5 Introduction Over the past fifty years there has been an increased interest in research into the possibility of genetic causative factors in relation to Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). This continued interest has found some inconsistent findings in terms of what gene is associated, but studies have indicated definitely that genetic influences play a part in the etiology of ADHD. A study conducted looked into the genetic and environmental influence on the clinical diagnosis of ADHD (Larson, Chang, D'Onofrio, & Lichtenstein, 2014). The study found that ADHD had a high heritability with, and environmental effects were insignificant. Another study also examined the possibility of genetics and ADHD (Asherson et al, 2004). This study found that the SNAP-25 gene is associated with ADHD but the precise causal functional variant is still undecided. The next puzzle is to figure out what specific genes are the cause. Today’s society is plagued with a multitude of different psychiatric conditions, one of them is Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). ADHD was first described by Sir George Still in 1902 (ADHD history, n.d.). The condition never really received any notice until 1997 when there was the first formal survey on ADHD diagnoses in the U.S. (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], 1997). This survey’s results showed a much larger number than anticipated, thus research boomed. Since that year there has been a constant upward trend with ADHD diagnoses (CDC, 2015). ADHD is a brain disorder found in childhood that can persist into adolescence and adulthood. ADHD symptoms can include but are not limited to: hyperactive behavior, difficult controlling impulses, having difficulty concentrating, and trouble with peer relationships (Learning Disabilities, 2015). Another issue with ADHD is that often the diagnosis is accompanied by other issues, such as oppositional defiant disorder (Learning Disabilities, 2015). ADHD can have serious impacts on a child’s emotional and physical ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 6 wellbeing. Many times symptoms are present in young as infants. (National Institute of Mental Health, 2012).The current estimate for today is around 11 percent of our children in the United States have ADHD, and that is an alarming rate (CDC, 2015). If a particular cause of ADHD can be nailed down, then a diagnosis can be made much earlier and intervention programs can be formed. A study conducted by Rasmussen and colleagues (2004) found that twins who had inattentive and combined types of ADHD both had the same familial gene cluster, thus showing a direct correlation in ADHD and heredity. Medical professionals do not always consider heredity a cause of ADHD because no definitive genes have been labeled as such (Rasmussen, Neuman, Heath, Levy, Hay, & Todd, 2004). To this date it is believed ADHD may have many causes, but none have been solidified. In order to set up early best practice intervention programs we need to have more concrete causes. Purpose and Significance of the Study The purpose of this systematic review is to take a closer look at the different studies on familial causes for ADHD, specifically genomes. The systematic review will help to look for a common trend in the studies completed to help add to the research on ADHD specific genes. The studies out there have found some conflicting results and this would be a good way to look for a trend. Studies have shown that children who are diagnosed early in their youth with ADHD learn to cope more effectively with the symptoms (Voeller, 2004). When there is a way to clinically diagnose a young child with ADHD, other than a rating scale, individualized programs can be created to help today’s youth cope with this issue. ADHD is here to stay no matter what the cause is and it is prudent for us to start looking into the exact cause in order to move forward. The public health implications for early diagnosis and treatment are important. Childhood self- ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 7 esteem, productivity, and learning all would benefit with any new findings. Children with undiagnosed ADHD often have low self-esteem due to always being in trouble and the outcast. Children with low self-esteem do not focus on growth but just on not making mistakes (Simply Psychology, 2012). Research Questions and Associated Hypothesis In regards to my research topic I have one main question: Is the SNAP -25 gene associated with the etiology of Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD)? My hope is that if a gene can be associated with a diagnosis then much earlier detection can be made for this condition. Early detection would mean the creating of evidence based programs to help facilitate the teaching of coping mechanisms with associated symptoms and help reduce the use of medications. Null hypothesis: There is not an association between SNAP 25 gene and ADHD. Research hypothesis: There is an association between SNAP 25 gene and ADHD. Background Literature Review Search strategy In terms of my search strategy my inclusion criteria included: Search Engines: Academic Search Premier and CINAHL PLUS with TEXT. The search terms utilized were: ADHD and Familial, ADHD studies, ADHD and causes, Molecular Psychiatry and ADHD, American Journal of Pharmaco Genomics and ADHD. The exclusion criteria was: Non peer reviewed articles, older than 1998, phenomenological studies, and non-relevant studies. ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 8 Theoretical Foundation The Organizational Change Theory (OCT) theory is based on the processes and strategies can help increase the chances that health programs and policies will be adapted (Riverside, n.d.). The origin for this theory is hard to place but most likely is an adaptation from Kirkpatrick’s ‘Four Levels of Learning Evaluation Model’ (Theories of Change, n.d.). Organizational Change Theory has been utilized to help guide implementation in many different health programs. If one major cause of ADHD can be proven to be inherited then early intervention programs can be tailored to families who are expecting and have history with ADHD. Many parents see the signs early on but ignore them and blame it on teachers, situations, or others. According to a study, at least 40% of children who have ADHD showed symptoms before the age of four; this shows that there is a lot of room for intervention programs to make a difference (Krieger, 2012). The theoretical foundation works by laying out future goals then working back to see what needs to happen in order for those goals to be met. Many studies have adapted this model because of its easy to use step process in terms of results. The steps for this theory are: awareness of the problem, decision to adopt the innovation, implementation, and then making the implementation a part of the culture (University of Pennsylvania, n.d.). This theory is a good fit because in terms of ADHD we need to work backwards in order to find a cause. Once a cause is identified then earlier diagnosis and programs can be created and incorporated into medical practice. Literature Review Related to Key Variables or Concepts Today’s society is plagued with a multitude of different psychiatric conditions, one of them is Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). ADHD can affect people at all age ranges and can be mild to very debilitating. A few symptoms of ADHD are: ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 9 •daydream a lot; •forget or lose things a lot; •squirm or fidget; •talk too much; •make careless mistakes or take unnecessary risks; •have a hard time resisting temptation; and •have trouble taking turns (CDC, 2015). According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 11 percent of children under the age of 18 suffer from this condition and the number is growing. ADHD is one of the most common neurodevelopmental disorders of childhood (CDC, 2015). Medical professionals still do not consistently relate heredity to a concrete causes in terms of ADHD and primary diagnostic tool is a questionnaire (Rasmussen, et al., 2004). The studies completed on ADHD specific type of genomes to date, have some inconsistent findings but all studies agree that some type of genome is the cause. This systematic review will help to look for a common trend in the studies completed to solidify ADHD and heredity genes/causes. To this date it is believed ADHD may have many causes, but none have been solidified. In order to set up early best practice intervention programs we need to have more concrete causes. One study looking into the SNAP-25 gene association with ADHD did not find any concrete relationship between the two and felt further studies are warranted (Laurin, Feng, Ickowicz, Pathare, Malone, Tannock, Schachar, Kennedy& Barr, 2007). Another study conducted also looked into the relationship between the SNAP-25 gene and ADHD and found a correlation, which shows the inconsistent results (Brophy, Hawi, Kirley, Fitzgerald & Gill, 2002). ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 10 This study examines the conflicting research on the SNAP-25 gene looking for any positive or negative trends. The rationale for this study is that there is a desperate need for an accurate earlier diagnosis of this condition so behavioral therapies and programs can be implemented earlier in life. There has been many genes studied with this condition but the SNAP-25 gene appears to be the most common theme with varying results. Conclusion As this condition and its association with gene mutation is a fairly new studied area the literature review definitely shows the gaps for inconsistent findings. Hopefully a systematic review can combine the relevant studies looking for that common thread. A commonly agreed upon theme among medical professionals is that there is genetic cause, but the uncertainty is which one. ADHD affect more and more children every day, and while stimulant medication is the current go to treatment, medication does not teach coping skills and lifelong changes, this comes from early intervention. Early identification and treatment need to occur such as blood tests and pre-natal testing. If early treatment happens high probability child will not need medication, or for only brief periods in their life. With early identification schools can also have evidence based programs to help facilitate normal development. Methods I applied a systematic review design to explore the possible relationship between Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder (ADHD) and the Synaptosomal-associated protein 25 (SNAP 25) gene. The systematic review supported me in addressing my research question on the relationship between ADHD and the SNAP 25 gene. This design type combined sample sizes and effects to help clarify the relationship to determine whether there is a correlation or not. ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 11 At the beginning of this year I searched for electronic articles and studies on Google Scholar, PubMed, CINAHL Plus, and MEDLINE. The keywords used in the search included ADHD and familial associations, genes, possible causes, and twins. I went through the reference lists from the compiled articles to also help identify articles for inclusion. After excluding articles that did not correspond with the criteria, the remaining articles were organized into a chart. I searched for original research articles that included gene association that focused on the SNAP 25 gene. Studies that researched other gene associations were only included if they contained the SNAP 25 gene in it. Inclusion and Exclusion criteria In this study the first priority was to include studies that scanned the gene association with ADHD. The studies were also scanned to be primarily in English to assure material is not lost in translation. The included studies must contain the SNAP 25 gene with no age restrictions on its participants. All included studies were less than 15 years old to ensure relevant data are used. For the inclusion and exclusion criteria and studies/articles screened please refer to Table 1 and Figure 1. Table 1 Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria Inclusion Criteria -Published after year 2000 -Contained the SNAP 25 gene -Peer reviewed articles -ADHD causes - Quantitative studies Exclusion Criteria -Older than year 2000. -Does not study SNAP 25 gene -None peer reviewed - No ADHD causes - Phenomenological studies ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 12 After using the inclusion and exclusion criteria, I determined there were three peer-reviewed studies I would include in this systematic review. The number of findings is from the process of elimination presented in figure 1. Studies included (28) Studies excluded (20) Final (3) Figure 1: Results of Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria Data analysis plan I used a systematic review method to combine and analyze results from individual studies. In this analysis I combined the effects from the included studies. The analysis included sample sizes, and tests associated with genetic disease markers. A few of these tests are: the extended transmission disequilibrium test (ETDT), and the haplotype-based haplotype relative risk test (HHRR) (Mill, Richards, Knight, Curran, & Asherson, 2004). Table 2 Effects and Exposures to be measured Type of Variable (Effect or Exposure) Description Level of Measurement ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) Effect- ETDT screening study Effect-HHRR screening study SNAP 25 allele mutation Quantitative SNAP 25 allele mutation Quantitative Results Data Collection A flow chart representing the sequence of the selection process of studies for this systematic review are in Figure 1. 48 studies identified in the initial survey 20 excluded 20 low quality studies excluded 28 met inclusion criteria 3 with methodology score of 2 included in final analysis. 13 ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 14 Figure 1: Process to select studies for inclusion in the systematic review. The figure above represents the process results when completing the literature review. There is the possibility for data discrepancies as the utilized studies did conduct different types of genomic testing and different genetic markers. Table 1 Characteristics of Included Studies Study (Authors name) Brophy et al, 2002 Setting Study Design n Population Interventio n Clinics and Schools Observatio nal study 93 Ages 4-14 ethnically Irish with ADHD or UADD DNA amplificati on and WenderUtah rating scale for parents Barr et al, 2007 Toronto based Observatio nal study 266 Primary Outcomes Score Found 2 increased preferential transmissio n of SNAP25/DdeI allele to ADHD cases. Nuclear Transmissi No clear 2 families in on/disequili pattern of the Toronto brium transmissio area test (TDT) n of risk analysis, alleles dependent on the sex of the transmittin g parent was observed across the markers tested in our sample ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) Nelson at al, 2003 UCLA School of Medicine Observatio nal study 202 Families with children who have ADHD and who does not have ADHD. Genomic DNA was isolated using the Puregene Kit and Using the transmissio n Disequilibr ium test (TDT). 15 We provide 2 additional evidence of linkage disequilibri um of haplotypes in SNAP25 and ADHD with new evidence supporting a paternal, rather than maternal, haplotype transmissio n bias Table 1 provides a short description of each study included in my systematic review. Due to the wide variety of tools used to measure SNAP 25 allele relationship to ADHD, a systematic review was an appropriate design for synthesizing and analyzing relevant literature for the presence of relationships between the SNAP-25 gene allele and ADHD. The variables analyzed included HHRR analysis of SNAP-25, HHRR analysis of parental transmission of SNAP-25, TDT analysis of SNAP-25, and TDT analysis of parental transmission of SNAP-25. Results Data analysis included study sample size, outcome variables, and statistical significance after analyzing the included studies in the systematic review. The reported outcome was there SNAP 25 allele association with ADHD. Table 2 ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 16 Additional characteristics of studies to include statistical significance Author Score Brophy et al, 2002 2 Barr et al, 2007 Nelson at 2 2 Control (if applicable) DSM-IV ADHD criteria n/a n/a al, 2003 Intervention Measures Results Interview, Genotyping P=0.671 IBD allele sharing between affected sib pairs. Transmission P=0.05of the TC maternal) haplotype P= 0.027paterna Genotyping SNAP25 P=1.0 (MnlII) SNAP25 P=0.004 (9806) Genotyping Transmission P=0.011of the 30 paternal UTR SNAP- P= 0.05 25 maternal Stat. Significant? No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes The study conducted by Brophy et al, 2002 concluded that there was found increased preferential transmission of SNAP-25/DdeI allele to ADHD cases. The actual statistical results do not show significance which is surprising. The second study by Barr et al, 2007 concluded that there is a possible neurodevelopmental etiology responsible for ADHD, but feel it is premature to state if there is preferential transmission. The third study conducted by Nelson et al, 2003 found a statistical significance in “additional evidence of linkage disequilibrium of haplotypes in SNAP-25 and ADHD with new evidence supporting a paternal, rather than maternal, haplotype transmission bias”, pg. 312. Conclusions Interpretation of the Findings ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 17 This study was a systematic review on ADHD and its’ association with the SNAP-25 gene. Previous studies results are conflicting, thus I wanted to try and fill in those gaps. My findings confirm that there is an association between the SNAP-25 gene and ADHD to include a link with paternal transmission. The conceptual framework used in this study was Organizational Change Theory (OCT) , this theory is often the basis of newly implemented testing or teaching programs which would be a perfect fit for the SNAP-25 gene testing and program start-up. The findings will be analyzed with the change theory’s foundation that it is more about the change versus the new process. Limitations of the Study The first limitation of this study is the number of studies utilized for the systematic review. There are not many published studies testing the allele of the SNAP-25 gene. This is a limitation because the results are a small snapshot of the ADHD community. This also raises the possible issue of publication bias. It’s possible that there have been studies that tested the SNAP25 gene, but were not published. All three studies utilized genome testing that was validated through program such as Mathematica (Wolfram Research Inc., IL, and USA). Another limitation is that the studies utilized did not all use the same testing on the allele. This is a limitation because the results are a small snapshot of the ADHD community and may not be entirely representative of all testing of ADHD and the SNAP-25 gene, which would reduce the generalizability of my results. My conclusion definitely supports the need for more research to be done. The only way to have avoided this limitation would have been to broaden the research topic. The fact that there were three studies included may have had a small impact on my results and conclusions. ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 18 Recommendations ADHD is a growing concern every day and needs to be addressed with more passion. As evidenced by this systematic review, there is a potential for a genetic cause of ADHD that is linked with paternal transmission. Existing research is not robust enough to demonstrate a cause an effect relationship, so further research is warranted. Some of these issues include: not enough studies conducted on the association of the SNAP-25 gene and ADHD; the small sample sizes used in research; and the future studies need to test the gene by replicating the research techniques used. I recommend further research be conducted on testing the allele of the SNAP-25 gene by replicating the tests used in these studies such as haplotype-based haplotype relative risk (HHRR) and transmission disequilibrium test (TDT) . There is a strong connection between these studies, but the limitations of this study mean that further research is needed to validate these findings. Implications for Social Change If researchers can find a definitive link between the SNAP-25 gene and ADHD this opens a window for non-subjective tests to confirm a diagnosis. Once a test is created then this will lead to age appropriate programs and interventions starting at birth to aid with this issue. ADHD is a growing concern with over 6% of our kids with ADHD taking medication some as early as four years of age (CDC, 2015). The current treatment recommendation for those under age five is behavioral therapy and most do not receive it. (CDC, 2015). Conclusion ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 19 Like it or not ADHD is here to stay and is affecting around 11% of today’s youth (CDC, 2015). There is no single way to “test” a child for ADHD and a diagnosis depends on subjective data. Children with ADHD have an uphill struggle most of their youth which can include: difficulty with learning, making friends, controlling impulse, and hyperactivity (NIH, 2012). As these children grow into teens and adults many are prone to depression, drug use, and suicide (Voeller, 2004). The need is there to pursue a definitive cause so we can move forward helping our children. References ADHD History. (n.d.). Retrieved from: http://adhdhistory.com/sir-george-f-still/ Brophy, Hawi, Fitzgerald Gill, & Kirley. (2002). Synaptosomal-associated protein 25 (SNAP- ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 20 25) and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): evidence of linkage and association in the Irish population. Molecular Psychiatry, 7, 913–917. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (March 18, 2015). ADHD Timeline, to include ADHD national survey. Retrieved from: http://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/adhd/timeline.html Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (May15, 2015). ADHD Data & Statistics. Retrieved from: http://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/adhd/data.html. Center for Theory of Change. (n.d.). Theories of Change Origins. Retrieved from: http://www.theoryofchange.org/what-is-theory-of-change/toc-background/toc-origins/ Kustanovich, V., Merriman, B., McGough, J., McCracken, J. T., Smalley, S. L., & Nelson, S. F. (2003).Biased paternal transmission of SNAP-25 risk alleles in attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder. Molecular Psychiatry, 8(3), 309 Krieger, K. (June 28, 2012). Is it ADHD or Typical Toddler Behavior? Ten Early Signs of ADHD Risk in Preschool Age Children. Retrieved from: http://www.kennedykrieger.org/overview/news/it-adhd-or-typical-toddler-behavior-tenearly-signs-adhd-risk-preschool-age-children Larsson, H., Chang, Z., D'Onofrio, B. M., & Lichtenstein, P. (2014). The heritability of clinically diagnosed attention deficit hyperactivity disorder across the lifespan. Psychological Medicine, 44(10), 2223-2229. doi:10.1017/S0033291713002493 Laurin, N., Feng, Y., Ickowicz, A., Pathare, T., Malone, M., Tannock, R., & ... Barr, C. L. (2007). No preferential transmission of paternal alleles at risk genes in attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder. Molecular Psychiatry, 12(3), 226-229. doi:10.1038/sj.mp.4001936 Learning Disabilities. (2015). Other Disorders That Sometimes Accompany ADHD. Retrieved ATTENTION DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER (ADHD) 21 from: http://www.ldonline.org/adhdbasics/other Mill, J., Richards, S., Knight, J., Curran, S., Taylor, E., & Asherson, P. (2004). Haplotype analysis of SNAP-25 suggests a role in the etiology of ADHD. Molecular Psychiatry, 9(8), 801-810. doi:10.1038/sj.mp.4001482 National Institute Health. (2012).What is attention deficit hyperactivity disorder? Retrieved from: http://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/attention-deficit-hyperactivitydisorder/index.shtml?rf=71264 Rasmussen, E., Neuman, R., Heath, A., Levy, F., Hay, D., & Todd, R. (2004). Familial clustering of latent class and DSM-IV defined attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) subtypes. Journal Of Child Psychology & Psychiatry, 45(3), 589-598. Riverside Community Health Foundation. (n.d.). Theories and models frequently used in health promotion. Retrieved March 26, 2015 from http://www.rchf.org/news/pdf/theories-andmodels-frequently-used-in-health-promotion.pdf University of Pennsylvania. (n.d.). Stage Theory of Organizational Change. Retrieved from: http://www.med.upenn.edu/hbhe4/part4-ch15-stage-theory-of-organizationalchange.shtml Voeller, K. S. (2004). Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Journal Of Child Neurology, 19(10), 798-814.