Trusted Advisor & Implementation Partner
Interoperability Case Study: Recipe for Success
Washington DC | June 24, 2010 | Tony Giroti
1
Copyright © 2010 Bridge Energy Group, Inc., All Rights Reserved
Agenda
• Intro to Interoperability
• Under the Hood
• Case Study / Client Example
– Interoperability & Standards used
– How we used them
• [Our] Recipe for Success
Copyright © 2010 BRIDGE ENERGY GROUP
2
Interoperability
“The capability of two or more networks, systems, devices,
applications, or components to exchange information
between them and to use the information so exchanged”
- Department of Energy’s GridWise® Architecture Council
Copyright © 2009, 2010 BRIDGE
3
Interoperability - Under the Hood
For Success besides Standards, you need Strategy, Business
Operating Model, Technology & Architecture
Standard
Vocabulary or
Shared meaning of
content
Registry
Technology & Architecture
Party
or
System
A
Communication & Transport
Interface
of A
Messages
Interface
of B
Party
or
System
B
Business Operating Model
Interoperation or
Collaboration
Agreement
4
Client Example:
Transmission & Distribution
5
Started with NIST’s recommendation
GridWise® Arch. Council’s Context-Setting Framework
To Provide the context for
identifying and debating
interoperability issues to
advance actions that make
integration within this
complex system easier.
Framework
Model / Architecture
Design
Solution
6
Open Smart Grid Reference Architecture
Remote Connect
/ Disconnect
Outage
Detection
Self Healing
Grid
Command & Control
SG & DR
Applications
Advance
Billing
OA&M
Others
Admin Interface
Reporting, Analytics
& BI
Portal
Reporting
Architecture
Business Architecture
Service / Process Orchestration
Enterprise
Services
Business Services
Workflow /
Human Tasks
Application Architecture
S
e
c
u
r
e
i
t
y
Development SDK
Transaction
Processing -OLTP
Common
Services
Real-Time
Architecture
Real-Time Integration Architecture
Cross Cutting
Modules
B2B Integration Modules
Application
Integ Modules
Customer /
HAN Modules
Reporting Tool
C
o
m
p
l
I
a
n
c
e
Service Oriented Architecture (SOA)
Domain Specific
Data Marts
Data
Mart
Data
Mart
Extraction
Transformation &
Load
Technical Services
A
r
c
h
i
t
e
c
t
u
r
e
Loosely Coupled
Architecture
Canonical Data
Model
Event Driven
Architecture
SOA Tool or Capability
Registry
CEP
Routing
Transformat
ion
ESB, Transport & Messaging
Real-Time Integration Architecture
Semantic Data
Model
Data Architecture
Master Data
Management
Meta Data
Database
Infrastructure Architecture
Hardware, OS, Virtualization
A
r
c
h
i
t
e
c
t
u
r
e
ETL Architecture
ETL Tool
Data Warehouse
Star/Snowflake
Data Warehouse
Source DBs
Tony Giroti
Data Warehouse
Infrastructure
7
Interoperability Standards
• IEC 61968/61970 & CIM: These families of
standards define information exchanged among control center systems
using common information models. They define application-level energy
management system interfaces and messaging for distribution grid
management in the utility space.
• IEC 61850: This standard defines communications within
transmission and distribution. substations for automation and protection.
It is being extended to cover communications beyond the substation to
integration of distributed resources and between substations.
• IEEE C37.118: This standard defines phasor measurement
unit (PMU) performance specifications and communications.
• MultiSpeak: App software integration within the utility
operations domain; a candidate for use in an Enterprise Service Bus.
8
Interoperability Standards (cont…)
• openADR: The specification defines messages exchanged between
utilities and commercial/industrial customers for price-responsive and direct load
control.
• eMIX: Exchange of price, characteristics, time, and related information for
markets, including market makers, market participants, quote streams, premises
automation, and devices
• Cyber Security:
–
Security Profile for Advanced Metering Infrastructure, v 1.0, Advanced Security Acceleration
Project – Smart Grid, December 10, 2009 : This document provides guidance and security controls to organizations
developing or implementing AMI solutions. This includes the meter data management system (MDMS) up to and including the HAN
interface of the smart meter.
–
NERC CIP 002-009:
Physical and cyber security standards for the bulk power system.
• Meter Upgradability - PAP 00
9
Transmission Operator’s View
Generation
Generation
ISO / Market
Distribution Utilities
Distribution
Utilities
Distribution
Utilities
eMIX
IEC 61850
Data Integrator
Substation
Devices
C37.118
IED
Synchrophasors
Energy Delivery and Power Accounting
Services (CIM Services, IEC 61968)
Scheduling
Settlement
Billing
Data Integrator
CIM DB
IEC 61968 / SOA /MultiSpeak/ CIM
Enterprise Integration
MV90
Revenue
Revenue
Meters
Meters
TCP/IP
Grid, Substations
SCADA
Operations
Reporting
Asset Mgmt
System
Reconciliati
on
IT
10
Distribution Utility’s View
Transmission Operator
eMIX
Smart Grid Services
•PAP00: Meter Upgradability
•Cyber Security
openADR
CIM
CIS/Billing
System
1
Meter Data
Management
GIS System
Distribution
Operations
2
CIM DB
IEC 61968 / SOA/MultiSpeak/CIM
Enterprise Integration
MDM DB
3
OMS
Asset Mgmt
System
IVR
11
The How Part of Using Standards
Meter
data
1
MDM
√
√
OMS
New
TMWA
CIS
DBM
ARCS
Enterprise
Systems Diagram
Rates Data
Mart
ITRON
Meter
Reading
MV90
Lodestar
Billing
Expert TASC
OMS
(Outage
Management
System)
· Reno (Mail pymts (SP)
· EDS (SP)
· Bill Matrix (NP)
· Ready Pay (NP)
· FEDS (SP)
· STORES (SP)
· Collection Agency (NP)
· LIHEA Pymts (NP)
PI
(Substation
Reads)
Banner CIS
(Customer Information System)
2
Paybase
Check Print
INDUS Passport
· Purchasing
· Inventory
· Work Mngmnt
· Tag Out
Remittances
(Docutran)
Deposit/
Refund
Checks
Lodestar
Client/
Server
ERP
· CIS INQ
· SCIS INQ
· Call-in
Priviledge
· Equifax
TEA (Time
Entry
Application)
Pension
Calc. Sys.
CheckFree
PowerPlant
(Generation
Fixed Asset
Accounting)
Oracle
Historical
Data Tables
Loadstar
ORCOM
CIS
4
Outage
√
AS-IS
5
Human Capital
Managment
Energy
Accounting Sys
&
Gas
Managment Sys
ERP
Peoplesoft
Supply Chain
Mobility
Financials
3
IVR / VRU
Bill Print
(Opencsf)
OMS - ABB
(Outage
Management
System)
CQence
Mail
Processor
IVR / VRU
Load Mgmt
Mobile
Dispatch
AMS Meter
Inventory
Cascade
ECAS
EMS - ESCA
(Energy
Management
System)
Microsoft
Exchange/
Outlook
STS
(Services
Tracking
System)
Shareholder
System
Fleet
Anywhere
Primavera
Paris
eTrak
MapGuide
(iConnect)
AS-IS
IVR
Oracle
Spatial
Adele
Mapping
System
CMS
(Construction
Management
System)
ERP
WMS
(Work
Management
System)
Risk /
Credit
BookRunner
Henwood
Capital
Budget
Sys.
Service I/F
Service I/F
Service I/F
SLA
Exceptions
Management
Canonical Data
Model
UDDI
Service
Registry
Legend
Landbase
Processing
UDS
(Utilty Design
System)
Compatible
Units
Description
Now (Job
Desciption)
Career
Architect
Auto
Affirmative
Action
Planning
HR Logix
Open
Systems
Enterprise
System
SPPC
System
NPC System
Out
Sourced
Billing 5
Determinants
New
AS-IS
Mainframe
Service I/F
Service I/F
Service I/F
OA & M
BAM
Process
Orchestration
XML
Transformation
(Formatting)
CIS
ESB Value Proposition: Develop a Loosely Coupled Architecture
SOA Value Proposition: Build Services and then orchestrate them into a business
process. Develop Technical (LDAP service); Business Services (Billing Determinant);
Copyright © 2009, 2010 Tony Giroti
12
Smart Grid Services (Connect/Disconnect, Outage Detection). PLUS Reusability
4/6/2010
Recipe for Interoperability Success
Ingredients:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Start with a pot full of Strategy & Roadmap
Add 1 to 2 lbs of Standards depending upon appetite
Add 1 Tsp of Business Operating Model
Add 2 Tsp of Technology
Sprinkle gently with Enterprise Architecture
Mix vigorously with a Holistic Approach
Bake it Collaboratively
Let it Simmer
Serve piecemeal to your organization and partners
Copyright © 2010 BRIDGE ENERGY GROUP
13
Q&A. Thank You
Tony Giroti
508.624.8932
BRIDGE Energy Group
TGiroti@BridgeEnergyGroup.com
14