Chapter 8: Cash Management and Forecasting Outline: Cash Management Process Considerations Liquidity Management Cash Concentration and Pooling Systems Cash Forecasting Projected Closing Cash Position Cash Management Risks and Controls v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 1 Discussion Question Which of the following is true of liquidity management? a) Inflows and outflows are generally well synchronized. b) Most large organizations will use the same accounts for collection and disbursement of funds. c) The primary objective of liquidity management is to meet daily obligations without incurring the opportunity costs that arise from excess or insufficient cash. Answer: c v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 2 Cash Flow Diagram With Investing and Borrowing Short-term investments $ Collections (cash inflows) $ Concentrated cash position $ Disbursements (cash outflows) $ Short-term borrowing v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 3 Why Liquidity Is Needed Transaction requirements Regulatory or covenant requirements Precautionary requirements Opportunistic requirements v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 4 Proper Level of Liquidity Insufficient liquidity Maintain adequate, but not excessive, liquidity. Excess liquidity Time needed to secure credit Losing interest earnings Credit availability Paying more interest than needed v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 5 Discussion Question What is the purpose of a stress test of a shortterm liquidity forecast, and how is one performed? Answer: The purpose is to forecast whether the firm has enough cost-effective remaining debt capacity to survive a serious, adverse event or multiple adverse events. The exercise assumes an adverse change to one or more of the firm’s funding sources, core business operations and projects, which could in turn affect credit ratings, defaults on covenants, etc. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 6 Using Short-Term Investments for Liquidity Management Precautionary and opportunistic requirements Earmarked funds Temporary surplus funds Ongoing operations Asset sales Securities issuance Seasonal performance Short- vs. long-term investments Price risk Yield pick-up v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 7 Discussion Question What is the primary objective of short-term investments? What is the trade-off a treasurer must make in choosing among alternative short-term investments? Answer: Preservation of principal is the primary objective in selecting among alternative short-term investments. The trade-off is risk vs. return; return is secondary. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 8 Using Short-Term Financing for Liquidity Management Spontaneous financing such as trade credit Sources of shortterm funds Borrowing arrangements or security issuance v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Sale or factoring of A/R Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 9 Discussion Question What are three steps that should be taken to properly manage short-term financing for an organization? Answer: 1. Careful planning of current and future credit needs 2. Determining the short-term financing objectives 3. Setting the overall strategic objectives relative to the organization’s general financing needs v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 10 Discussion Question What is the objective of short-term financing? Answer: To ensure adequate credit availability at minimum cost and risk and with maximum flexibility v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 11 Ratios Used by Lenders to Establish Covenants Liquidity Current ratio Quick ratio Cash flow to total debt ratio Indebtedness Total liabilities to total assets Long-term debt to capital Debt to tangible net worth v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Coverage Times interest earned Fixed-charge coverage Performance Cash conversion efficiency Return on sales Return on total assets Return on common equity Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 12 Discussion Question What is a MAC clause? Answer: A material adverse change (MAC) clause is a common provision creditors include in agreements. Also referred to as a discretionary clause, a MAC clause lets a lender refuse funding or declare a borrower to be in default even if all agreements are in full compliance if the lender believes a MAC has occurred in the borrower’s condition. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 13 Short-Term Financing: Strategic Objectives Strategic plan determines the need for and use of short-term funds. Management must determine and plan for: Level of debt Mix of debt among short-, intermediateand long-term sources Mix of debt and equity v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 14 Global Concentration of Funds Physical concentration of funds; referred to as “sweeping” outside U.S. Notional pooling: Company and all its subsidiaries must maintain accounts at the same bank. Positive and negative balances are aggregated each day to calculate interest earned or due; funds are not actually transferred but merely totaled. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Physical pooling: Most pooling is currently single-currency/one country. Must be justified by a careful cost/benefit analysis. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 15 Discussion Question What is an approach that combines sweeping and pooling, when is it used, and how does it function? Answer: Bank overlay structure Used when primary bank has branches in several countries that don’t provide full domestic banking in all countries. Local bank is used as needed for domestic transactions and to sweep surplus funds to primary bank. Primary bank (overlay bank) notionally pools balances on overlay accounts, providing a multi-country solution. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 16 Objectives of a Cash Concentration System Major objectives: Efficiently move funds from deposit banks to concentration bank Minimize excess balances Concentration enables: Investing a larger amount of funds, potentially increasing interest income Paying down debt faster, potentially reducing interest expense Taking advantage of discount terms, potentially reducing COGS or operating expenses v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 17 Discussion Question A retail organization’s over-the-counter/field deposit systems receive cash and/or checks drawn on local banks at each point of sale (POS). Which of the following provides cash/coin pickup/ delivery and immediate fund availability? a) Having a depository institution near each field location b) Virtual vault services c) Remote deposit capture (RDC) Answer: b v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 18 Retailers can get all check deposits in one centralized account. Banks may offer improved availability, reducing availability float. Banks produce IRD as needed. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Federal Reserve Reduce processing float by immediately transmitting for deposit. Depository Bank Scan and Image Remote Deposit Capture (RDC) Clear and settle electronically through Fed or other image exchange network. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 19 Cash Concentration System Configuration Considerations: Size and geographic distribution Transfer alternatives Branch footprint of banks EDTs and wire transfers are most frequent. Field offices, field banks, headquarters or concentration banks can originate EDTs. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Most large retail chains transmit information from POS terminals to headquarters. Wires are an alternative to ACH to expedite funds transfers. Establish value of funds acceleration. Drawdown wire. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 20 Break-Even Wire Transfer Amount Total ACH costs = $1.00 Total wire transfer costs = $10.00 Opportunity cost of funds = 3.5% Minimum Transfer = = Wire Cost ACH Cost Opportunity Cost Days Accelerated 365 Days $10.00 $1.00 0.035 1 Day 365 Days = $93,857 v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 21 Bank Services that Facilitate Deposit or Automatic Concentration Both require using multiple branches of single bank. Zero balance account (ZBA) • Separate units deposit in distinct depository accounts • Balances transferred automatically at end of day to master concentration account (balance is zero) Deposit reconciliation • Deposits from many locations credited to one corporate bank account • Auxiliary on-us field carries unique identifier for each company location for location-specific deposit reports v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 22 Excess Balances Average collected balance is greater than bank compensation needs or chosen target. Causes Deposit reporting delays by field units Clearing delays of one day when using ACH for cash concentration Transfer initiation delays if concentration entries are submitted to the originating bank late or contain reporting errors Receipts posted or received subsequent to investment cutoff times v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 23 Discussion Question What bank charges are involved in a concentration system, and what types of banks charge fees? Answer: Deposit and concentration banks may assess fees for each deposit, deposited items, inbound and outbound wires, ACH clearings, deposit reports, overdrafts, negative collected balances, and account maintenance. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 24 Discussion Question What administrative costs are typically involved in concentration systems? Answer: Managing deposit reporting—receiving and monitoring daily reports from local managers and concentration banks Scheduling cash transfers—deciding when and what amounts to transfer Preparing debit files Reconciling deposit reports Monitoring transfers to prevent internal fraud v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 25 Reducing Concentration System Costs Enhance concentration system efficiency. Improve transfer schedule timing. Reduce excess balances. Anticipate availability. Anticipate deposits. Use faster transfer mechanism. Reduce transfer costs. Use less expensive transfer mechanisms. Transfer funds less frequently. Threshold and target concentration. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 26 Objectives of Cash Forecasting Liquidity management Schedule investment decisions. Anticipate borrowing requirements. Financial control Meeting strategic objectives Capital budgeting Managing costs Managing currency exposure v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 27 Forecasting Horizons Short-term Daily, weekly or monthly basis Predict cash receipts and disbursements and the resulting balances. Mediumterm One to 12 months Project the inflows (collections from sales and other sources of funds) and outflows (expenses and other uses of funds) on a monthly basis. Long-term Any period beyond one year Consider projections of longterm sales, expenditures, and market factors; of strategic importance. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 28 Discussion Question Identify the following forecasting horizons. Answers: Shortterm 1. Used to establish and manage target balances for bank compensation purposes Mediumterm 2. Used to determine the company’s need for short-term credit or availability of funds for short-term investing Mediumterm 3. Used as a performance benchmark to compare actual cash flows to projected cash flows based on the cash budget Long-term 4. Used by financial institutions and rating agencies for credit analysis v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 29 Degrees of Certainty Certain Known in advance (e.g., interest, debt principal repayments, dividends, royalties, tax payments) Predictable Can be predicted with reasonable accuracy; prediction of future cash flows can be made based on past observations (e.g., cash collections from credit sales, payroll, clearing of vendor checks) Difficult to forecast; involves experience and judgment (e.g., new product sales, unexpected repairs, claims, strike settlements) Less predictable v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 30 Discussion Question An organization gathers both internal and external information sources for cash flow forecasting. A variety of historical data is available for predicting the amount and timing of cash inflows and outflows. Which of the following validation methods should be used? a) In-sample validation b) Out-of-sample validation Answer: b v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 31 Forecasting Methods A/R balance pattern Receipts and disbursements forecast Receipts schedule Disbursements schedule Completed forecast v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Distribution forecast Simple average Regression analysis Pro forma financial statements Statistical forecasting Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 32 Forecasting Methods: Forecasting Using the Distribution Method Company used regression analysis to estimate proportion of dollars that will clear on a given business day. It has determined the proportion depends on the number of days since distribution. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 33 Discussion Question What are the three steps in percentage-ofsales pro forma statement forecasting? Answer: ■ Forecast income statement and balance sheet. ■ Calculate projected ending cash balance by determining how forecasted income statement and balance sheet values impact cash. ■ Compare projected ending cash balance with target cash balance and adjust pro forma statement to show funding source for cash shortfall or investment of cash surplus. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 34 Current Income Statement and Balance Sheet (Percentage-of-Sales) To generate percentage-of-sales forecast, following assumptions are made (numbers in thousands): Sales will increase by 10% to $2,200 in 2011. COGS, selling and administrative expenses, current assets (cash, receivables, inventory), and payables are constant percentage of sales. Cash balance is derived from cash flow statement. Additional fixed assets of $100 will be purchased. Depreciation will be $50. Notes will be reduced to $100 at beginning of year. Dividends will be $24. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 35 Pro-Forma Income Statement and Balance Sheet (Percentage-of-Sales) All projected account balances except cash are calculated based upon given assumptions. Ending cash balance is determined by evaluating impact on cash of income statement activity and balance sheet changes and adjusting beginning cash balance accordingly. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 36 Discussion Question Given the following two pro forma statements, what is the projected ending cash balance? Answer: v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 37 Statistical Forecasting Extrapolation Identifies past trends to predict pattern of future cash flows. Time series Identifies repetitive patterns in a historical series to predict future values of the series. ■Simple moving average bases a forecast on a rolling average of past values. ■Exponential smoothing produces a forecasted value based on the most recent actual value, the most recent forecasted value, and a number between zero and one that is used to weight these two values. Correlation Statistically identifies degree of association between a cash flow and another variable. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 38 Simple Moving Average Forecast v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 39 Exponential Smoothing Forecast Ft+1 = X t + 1 Ft Where: t = Time period subscript (t = current period, t+1 = next period, etc.) Ft+1 = Cash flow forecast for the next period (t+1) Ft = Cash flow forecast for the current period (t) α = Smoothing constant (0 < α < 1) Xt = Actual cash flow for the current period (t) v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 40 Discussion Question How does a cash manager arrive at the projected closing cash position? Answer: A cash manager adjusts opening bank available balance by: Adding the expected settlements in collection and concentration accounts Deducting the projected disbursement totals v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 41 Cash Management Risks and Controls: Internal Control Issues System of checks and balances Monitoring of transactions, cash flows and information Controls Matching for errors, invoices, deposit amounts Verification against bank reports Segregation of duties at each step of a transaction or outsourcing for smaller companies v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 42 External Fraud Disbursement fraud ACH fraud Wire fraud Technology: color copiers, printers, scanners Non-recurring transaction frequency Highly automated system Fraudulent endorsements and alterations Payroll fraud and ACH kiting Target small or medium firms < $10,000 Positive pay and payee verification Debit blocks and filters, controlled disbursement v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 43 Discussion Question The Great Recession of 2007 to 2009 caused almost 150 banks to fail in the U.S., highlighting the need to reduce bank failure risks for companies. What are the risks and what can be done to reduce them? Answer: Field deposit systems typically involve many banks, and a company may be at risk if one fails. To reduce this risk, treasury professionals need to monitor the creditworthiness of each bank in the concentration process. Timely concentration limits this risk. A greater risk is presented if the company’s main concentration bank fails. v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 44 End of Session 5 Assignment: Complete the following tasks for Module Four, Chapters 9 and 10: Review each chapter. Complete the test-your-understanding questions at the end of each chapter. Complete the online module-specific test. Complete the Exam Practice (Describe and Differentiate) questions (located at the end of the module). v3.0 © 2011 Association for Financial Professionals. All rights reserved. Session 5: Module 4, Chapter 8 - 45