Residential property 2012 Year results Kiev Residential property Kiev Key Events The structure of the real estate market in Kiev, $ / sq.m. Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine adopted the Law on the implementation of social initiatives of the President of Ukraine concerning the reduction of the cost of hypothec loans. The law stipulates that the State Budget of Ukraine for 2013 and subsequent years, provides compensation of interest paid to banks and / or other financial institutions for loans obtained by citizens for construction (reconstruction) or purchase. primary market 39% secondary market 61% RC Boulevard Fontanov The President of Ukraine signed the Law under which notary offices starting from January 1, 2013 can perform state registration of property rights, other proprietary rights and their encumbrances for registered real estate objects with the entering of the relevant information into the National Register. The state mortgage institution launches a program of housing rent with the right of redemption by 3% per annum. The program is coordinated in all profile ministries. It is expected to be approved by the Cabinet of Ministers. A distinctive feature of the new proposals in 2012 is to reduce the flat area, so that the budget of buying an apartment in a new building could be comparable with the same purchase on the secondary market. High construction activity of the primary market of residential property in the course of 2012, the result of which was the putting into operation of a number of residential complexes in all segments of the market. Downward adjustment of the average price to 4% per year, caused by changes in the supply pattern in the primary market in connection with the release of new objects at the early stages of construction. Volume of the new housing in Kiev, thousands sq.m. 1501 1600 1201 1301 1401 1430 1300 948 1012 Reorientation of demand for primary segment combined with high construction activity of developers, provoked an increase in sales by 25%. Implementation by developers of their own credit programs and loans had a positive effect on the number of transactions. Start of sales of apartments in new facilities with 30% and higher of building readiness. Increased buyer’s interest to such projects was observed in case if a large company acted as a developer with a good showing in the market, and having active construction work at site. 800 400 0 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Ukrainian Trade Guild © 2013 The renewed interest of developers to the development of the residential facilities. In 2012, the developers launched a number of significant projects in all segments different from those already existing in the market with more rational planning and improved infrastructure. The development of large-scale projects, both by land area and quantity of apartments. 1200 From January 1, 2013 a new type of a local tax of the Ukrainian tax system shall come into force - tax on real estate property other than the land. The apartments which area exceeds 120 sq.m and houses over 250 sq.m. are subject to the taxation. Tendencies Residential property Kiev Proposal By December 2012 the amount of the primary real estate market in Kiev was about 13.5 thousand apartments. Secondary segment of residential real estate was about 8.5 thousand suggestions. Reduction in the volume of apartments' supply (2.3%) was caused by the increase of sales in the secondary and primary market segments, as well as traditional reduction of the volumes of the secondary segment at the end of the year. Significant objects entered the primary real estate market in 2012 Object Address Class Developer “H-Tower” 28-30, Shevchenko blrd. 47, Zverinetskaya str. 2, Dimitrova str. Elite 98 2012 Elite St.Sophia Homes Iton Group 78 1 quarter 2013 Elite Geos 88 2 quarter 2013 2-B, Heroes of Stalingrad av. 6/1, Lymymby str. Lomonosova str. Business Metal –Service 560 3 quarter 2013 Business UDP 811 2 quarter 2013* Business Liko-Holding 2-A, Dragomanova str. 5, Zadorojhny provylok 1, Degtyarenka str. 9-A, Otdykha str. Bajhana av. Business Ukraziabud 399 4 quarter 2013 Business Miskjhutlobyd 56 3 quarter 2013 Economy Intergalbyd 1675 3 quarter 2013* Economy Economy 1562 264 2 quarter 2013* 3 quarter 2013 92-B, Glyshkova av. Bogaturskaya str. Economy Stolitsa Group Kovalskaya Group KievGorstroy 855 2 quarter 2013 Economy Stolitsa group 288 4 quarter 2013 “Zverinetskyi” Chelsea Tower Park Stone Stabilization at the real estate market during 2011-2012 led to progressive renewal of interest in development of residential properties. Thus, at year-end of 2012 the primary real estate market was replenished by a number of significant projects in all segments. Released positive trend is the growing compliance with the requirements of buyers and their financial resources. Fountain Boulevard By December 2012 proposal in segment of real estate includes 16 residential objects (about 1750 apartments excluding absorption) that are in various stages of readiness. During 2012 proposal for luxury housing increased by 264 apartments owing to the sales in new housing estates – “H Tower”, “Zverinetskyi”, “Chelsea Tower”. The unique concept of “HTower” is to provide a better service to the future inhabitants of the world hotel operator “Hilton”. Yaskravy Venice Novopecherskiy yard Gelios Vіdpochinok Yuvіleyny residential complex on Glushkov Av. residential complex on Bogatyrskaya *startup of 1st stage Ukrainian Trade Guild © 2013 Apt., qty Startup 4 quarter 2013* Residential property Kiev At the end of 2012 club house in Michurin street (7 apartments),residential complex “ Dimond Hill” (131 apartments) and two buildings in residential area "Vozdvizhenka" (12 apartments) were put into operation in the luxury segment . Stable demand at primary real estate business class stipulates the launching of new projects in the segment. Key characteristics of opened objects during 2012 (Park Stone, Boulevard fountains, Novopecherskiy Dvor, Gelios) are the supply pattern shift to twobedroom apartments with small footage and effective planning solutions. Also in 2012, the sales of the 2nd stage of the residential complex Novopecherskie Lypky (419 apartments) started. By December 2012 the proposition in segment is formed by about 35 business class residential complexes. At the end of 2012 the segment was characterized by high construction activity, which led to the entering into operation of new stages of residential complexes, such as Novopecherskie Lipky (623 apartments), Perstizh Hall (151 apartment), Park Avenue (215 apartments), Parkove misto (490 apartments), River Stone (428 apartments), Elegant. The segment of the primary real estate economy class in 2012 showed high activity. Due to entrance of new residential complexes to the market, supply volume increased by more than 4.5 thousand flats. In addition economy class offer grew due to sales of the second stage housing complexes Comfort Town (600 apartments), Ministerial (850 apartments), Sonyachna Brama (311 apartments), Parkove misto (342 apartments). Ukrainian Trade Guild © 2013 Major economy class objects were entered into operation, 2012 Objects Developer Apartmen ts qty. Parkjvyi, 3rd section Ave. L. Kurbasa Residential complex on Perova blrd Ministerskiy, 1st stage, Kondratiuka str. Harkovye ozera, 1st stage, Voskresenskaya str. NBK 90 Keivgorstroy 168 Energopol Ukraine 540 InterGalbud 544 Residential complex on tymaniana str. Lipinka 1st stage, Zamkovetskaya str. Stolitsa Group 432 Stolitsa Group 254 Comfort Town 1st stage, Regeneratornaya str. K.A.N. Development 2500 Residential complex on Urlovskaya str. Residential complex on Akhmatovoy str. Residential complex on Grigorenko str. Kievgorstroy n/d Kievgorstroy n/d Kievgorstroy n/d The structure of the primary real estate market in Kiev,% from the total number of apartments 4% 36% elite business 60% economy The positive features of the new housing proposition at the economy segment are the reduction of square meters. Thus, the objects appeared on the market, where min. footage of 1-bedroom apartments starts from 34 sq. m. (residential complex on Bogatyrskaya str.). Besides, the proposition pattern changed significantly : among the objects the market share of 1 and 2-bedroom apartments reaches 90%. Activation in housing economy class segment was caused by the developer’s observance of terms of commissioning. Primary housing from the leading real estate companies became a virtually riskfree asset. Instability in the financial sector of Ukraine (waiting for the introduction of a tax on currency exchange and devaluation of hryvna, the risk of non-return of bank deposits) gradually return the buyers to the primary real estate market. New proposition in economy class creates the background for further development of the segment, which corresponds to the current demand. According to year results major objects of economy class segment entered into operation with a total of more than five thousand apartments. On December 2012, about 60 residential complexes were made the proposition in economy-class. Residential property Kiev Costs & Prices The cost of housing in the primary market in Kiev, $/sq.m. 3015 The average price of supply in the market of new buildings of Kiev as of December 2012, amounted to $1939/sq. meters. Decline in average prices by 4% at the year-end is due to changes in the structure of supply of the primary market. By the class of primary real estate average prices in December 2012 were as follows: in economy class $ 1316/ sq. m., in business class - $ 2191/ sq. m., in elites - $ 7429/ sq. m. Decreasing in average prices to index in December 2011, correspondingly was 1.3%, (economy class), -9.5% (business class), 2.2% (elites). Primary market of residential real estate at economy class segment was characterized as stable during 2012. A little decrease of an average price was caused by the sales in the new complexes at a price below the market price. But, there was a planned price increase of some already built objects with a higher level of readiness. Changes in prices depend on the level of readiness, so it reaches 15-30%. 2324 2048 2020 1939 1959 970 2004 2006 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 The cost of housing in the primary market in Kiev by classes, $/sq.m. 8000 7603 7462 7429 6000 4000 2463 2421 2191 1316 1334 1274 2000 0 Also in the sector, there is a huge difference in the price offer of the leading real estate developers and construction companies with weaker positions. The gap goes up to $ 300 / sq.m. at a comparable quality characteristics of the object. Average market price of the primary real estate at business class showed the largest decline of the year. 2010 elite 2011 business 2012 economy The cost of housing in the secondary market in Kiev, $/sq.m. 3480 2850 2046 2023 2120 1977 In spite of 9% fall, direct reduction in price has not been fixed. Descending price dynamics is caused by structural changes: in 2012, the market slowly left those apartments which were in finished objects or were at the final stages of construction. Thus, the main volume of demand is concentrated in the segment of flats to 5070% readiness, and their costs are 1020% lower than of those put into operation. Price reduction at elite class, by the results of the year, occurred under the influence of new objects, released at the early stages of construction. Thus, start of sales in Chelsea Tower happened at the stage of foundation. Also, because of unsaturation of primary real estate market, the main effect on cost and prices render an overstated price expectations of developers. As a result, prices for luxury apartments are within a rather wide range from $ 3200 to $ 15000. Negative price dynamics of primary residential property, fixed in December in all segments of the housing market was caused by discounts provided by the developers in the New Year holiday’s period. The volume of discounts was 310%, but the least liquid apartments it reached 17%. 1040 2004 Ukrainian Trade Guild © 2013 2006 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Generally, during 2012, the total state of the primary market in Kiev remained fairly stable. Residential property Kiev Demand Distinctive feature of 2012 was the gradual increase in the share of primary residence in the pattern of demand. This situation became possible due to creation of the product, comparable to its consumer characteristics at the secondary market. This is a small area apartments, situated in a newly created infrastructure and being on locations available to transport. The cost of housing in the primary market in Kiev by classes, $/sq.m., 2012 The main volume of demand in the primary segment was concentrated in the field of residential complexes that meet the above parameters. These objects showed good sales figures: in the period of seasonal activity in the market the number of transactions were 20 apartments per month, meanwhile average market index was 5.51 apartments per month. The main volume of demand in the primary segment was concentrated in the segment of economy class (up to 80% from the total number of transactions). In this case, the smallest apartments were sold foremost. Thus, in many objects under construction 1-room apartments up to 40 sq.m. are fully realized, meanwhile , the apartments up to 4547 sq.m. were less interesting to the buyers. Performing more efficient planning has provoked a significant increase in demand for two-bedroom apartments in the segments of the economy and business class of primary real estate, because of area reduction of apartment. But the main demand for primary housing still remains for one-bedroom apartments. Ukrainian Trade Guild © 2013 Source: UTG Residential property Kiev Residential cost on primary market in Kiev by classes, on January – February, 2012, $/sq.m. The maximum buyers’ activity was observed in spring (March-April) and New Year (NovemberDecember) periods. The structure of transactions financing on primary real estate market in Kiev 9000 8000 7000 6000 Providing the credit lines by the developers has also the positive effect on the number of transactions. Thus, if in 2010-2011 term of loans was limited by the date of commissioning, so, in 2012 the developers met customers’ needs, prolonging granting term on the average for a year. This trend entailed changes in the structure of financing transactions: the number of sales with use of payment by installments made up 37%. However, the main source (60%) of apartments purchase was own funds of the buyers, mostly got from the previous sold apartment. The structure of transactions according the buyers purposes on the primary real estate market, 2012 0.1 3% 5000 4000 3000 37% 2000 with loan 1000 without the loan 0 with credit line 60% elite business economy Average apartment’s sales volume per month in one residential complex 5.84 5.14 4.98 5.04 5.26 5.43 5.52 3.54 2.99 3.34 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011 2012 2012 2012 2012 The pattern of demand on primary market depending on rooms’ quantity 10% 3% 1-room 0.9 2-room 52% 35% 3-room other improving housing conditions Ukrainian Trade Guild © 2013 In most cases (90%) the purpose to buy an apartment in 2012 was to improve own living conditions. The share of investment transactions, circulated before the crisis, did not exceed 10%. In view of substantial increase of the cost of resources, attracted by the banks, the mortgage in 2012 did not develop. Average interest rates for hypothecs loans are in the range of 22-25% per year (growth in 2012 was 2.3%). Lack of opportunities to attract long hryvna resources makes it impossible to activate mortgage lending in the short term. Residential property Kiev Contact information UTG LLC 2-a Mechnikova str., (Business centre “Parus”) 01601, Kyiv, Ukraine Tel./fax: (380 44) 537 23 64 www.utgcompany.com Vadim Neposedov President vvn@utg.kiev.ua Vitaliy Boyko Managing partner boyko@utg.kiev.ua Eugenia Loktionova Director Loktionova@utg.kiev.ua Victor Oborskiy Head of strategy consulting department v.oborsky@utg.kiev.ua Victoria Pogasiy Market research specialist pv@utg.kiev.ua This and other company’s review can be found on our website www.utg.kiev.ua This presentation is the publication of the generalized character. Ukrainian Trade Guild is not legally liable for the information, the analytics and the forecasts published in this overview of Ukrainian Trade Guild in terms of possible third person losses as the result of this report usage. Any publication of news stories from the report given, whether as a whole or in parts, is possible only with the company’s reference as the data source. Photo on front page – RC Komfort Town, by author Oleg Stelmah Ukrainian Trade Guild © 2013 Forecast In condition of macro-economic stability, prices on the primary and secondary residential market will not be subject to significant changes. In 2013, we shall expect stable development activity. The market will be filled with new projects different from those already existing, with more rational layout and upgraded infrastructure. New projects will be run mainly by major developers, who are able to attract substantial capital for a long period, as the demand is formed on housing in new buildings with a high degree of readiness. Reorientation of consumer demand for primary housing that started in 2012 will be continued in 2013. There is growth of trust to new buildings due to the qualitative changes in the market development of residential real estate. Particularly, in 2012, real estate developers started to declare the real term and observe initially announced date of commissioning. The trend of increasing competition among key players in all the segments of the primary market will continue in 2013. Fighting for the buyer will be tightened, which will result an extensive use of marketing mechanisms to promote sales and significant improvement of quality of service, including after sales service. Trends in the residential market in 2012 showed that the "price bottom" is past the point; however, nevertheless, it is too early to forecast the active growth. In prospect, the long term price dynamics will depend on the development of mortgage and growth of effective demand, which is a consequence of development of the Ukrainian economy in a whole. Given that the primary market has significant potential to increase supply due to the frozen projects; in the medium term we should expect growth in the number of new buildings in Kiev. RC Green island