3. Cold War - Indirect Conflicts & Canadian Foreign Policy Foreign Policy - definition a government’s policy governing international relations with other countries Foreign policies generally are designed to help protect a country's: • national interests (country's priorities & goals re: what’s best for the country), • national security, • ideological goals, and • economic prosperity This can occur as a result of peaceful cooperation with other nations (diplomacy), or through aggression, war, and exploitation Canada as Middle Power • The threat of nuclear annihilation kept superpowers (USA and USSR) from open war – both sides had allies in the developing world, where wars did occur • Canada emerged as a leading "middle power," assuming the role of peacekeeper and negotiator in international disputes • Prime ministers remained prominent in international affairs, taking part in visits from foreign heads of state, world tours, treaty negotiations, and other activities • Canada also became an active member of the UN, supporting and promoting peace Reflect & Discuss What is “Foreign Policy”? Why is it necessary? Why was Canada known as a “Middle Power” during the Cold War and why was this an important role? Cold War Indirect Conflicts a. The Korean War 1950-53 WWII left Korea divided into: • Communist North, supported by the USSR and China • Democratic South, supported by the U.S.A. In 1950 North Korea invaded South Korea a UN force under American command tried to force the invaders to retreat http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hh0hyALDW7Y&feature=related Korean War – cont’ Canada sent thousands of troops (27,000) to fight in Korea as part of the UN Canada’s Minister of External Affair Lester Pearson urged all sides to agree to a cease fire Canadian soldiers in Korea Korean war – con’t From July 1951-July, 1953 – a stalemate developed – no side made great advances *See animation - http://users.erols.com/mwhite28/korea.htm In July 1953 both sides agreed to an armistice / ceasefire Korea remained divided and tensions increased between the West and the communist nations. The Korean War demonstrated that the UN was willing to take action b. The Suez Crisis -1956 Suez canal in Egypt – links Mediterranean Sea with Red Sea provides shortest sea route from Europe to the Indian Ocean built in 1800s and privately owned by British and French investors 1956 – Egypt’s president, Nasser, & gov. took over canal and wanted to nationalize it (to be owned and run by the government) The other side of the Suez Crisis – Part 1 - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QnsBHL7PDv0&feature=related Suez Crisis – cont’ Israel frightened of Egyptian aggression – Egypt threatened to bar ships to and from Israel from using the canal Britain and France backed Israel; USSR backed Egypt Suez Crisis – cont’ •Lester Pearson – went to UN to try and work out solution • proposed a UN Emergency Force (UNEF) (later became peacekeeping forces) be sent to Suez Canal to separate and mediate Canadians at Suez Suez Crisis – cont’ 1957 - Pearson awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for his efforts in defusing the crisis Lester Pearson accepting Prize Reflect & Discuss What started the Korean War and in what years did it occur? How was Canada involved in the Korean War? Why was the Korean war an important event in the history of the UN? Why did the Suez Crisis occur, and in what year? Who suggested the use of an UN Emergency Force and what did he win as a result in 1957? How are both the Korean Conflict and the Suez Crisis examples of indirect conflicts between the USA and USSR? c. The Cuban Missile Crisis -1962 1959 - Cuban communist rebels under Fidel Castro overthrew Cuba’s pro-US leader in a revolution • US reacted angrily by imposing trade economic sanctions on Cuba • 1961 – US backed an invasion of Cuba by antiCastro Cubans – failed (Bay of Pigs) • this encouraged Cuba to turn to the USSR (Khrushchev) for support Castro & Khrushchev Cuban Missile Crisis – cont’ 1962 - US planes took photos showing that the USSR was installing offensive nuclear missile bases in Cuba – direct threat to US security Cuban Missile Crisis – cont’ President Kennedy announced a naval and air blockade of Cuba Cuban Missile Crisis – cont’ Soviet Premier Nikita Krushchev – at 1st refused to remove missiles world on brink of nuclear war Cuban Missile Crisis – cont’ at last minute, Krushchev agreed to remove missiles with US agreement that would not invade Cuba Canada & the Cuban Missile Crisis the U.S. expected full support from Canada (its NORAD partner) however PM Diefenbaker was reluctant to have Canada drawn into the conflict and at first refused to put Canadian NORAD forces on red alert and allow U.S. planes with atomic weapons to land in Canada Canada & the Cuban Missile Crisis Canadian troops were eventually put on alert; however CanadaU.S. relations were already damaged Fog of War Lesson One – Empathize with your Enemy http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOoOcIFhaoA&feature=related Reflect & Discuss How did the Cuban Missile Crisis start? How was this crisis a defining moment in the Cold War? What was Canada’s involvement? Was the USA happy with how Diefenbaker reacted? Why or why not? d. The Vietnam War 1954-1975 a) The U.S. in Vietnam: major conflict in Cold War North – communistcontrolled – backed by USSR South – although more dictatorship than democracy – was supported by USA Vietnam Vietnam & Domino Theory USA feared that if south fell to communism – all Asian countries could fall – by 1960’s USA sent troops first war recorded by television cameras Americans watched Vietnamese villages being bombed, own young men returning home disabled or in body bags – some began questioning involvement Billy Joel – Goodnight Saigon http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j6gZefW4yEA&feature=related Vietnam – cont’ 1968 – learned that US soldiers had massacred women and children in the village of My Lai ended in 1973 under President Richard Nixon – lost war – BADLY Term “Vietnam” has negative connotations to this day Canada, especially Lester Pearson, critical of US involvement in Vietnam Vietnam – cont’ b) Canada’s reaction to the Vietnam War: PM Pearson did not support American involvement in the war – Canadian government officially NOT INVOLVED Canada welcomed American “Draft Dodgers” Some Canadian citizens enlisted in American military and fought in war (approx 40,000 between 1959-1975) e. Cyprus - 1964 Civil war broke out on the Mediterranean island of Cyprus Between Greek majority & Turkish minority Canadian UN troops initially sent in 1964 Last of troops not withdrawn until 1993 Now Cyprus is in relative harmony CBC Archives – Cyprus Pullout http://archives.cbc.ca/IDCC-1-71-1290-7540/conflict_war/blue_berets/ Détente -1960-1979 Literally means relaxation of tensions In terms of Cold War, refers to the period between 1960-1979 when there was a relaxation of tensions between the USA and USSR SALT Treaties attempt to limit nuclear proliferation during this time Reflect & Discuss How was the Vietnam War an example of an indirect conflict between the USA and USSR? What was Canada’s involvement officially and unofficially? What was Canada’s involvement in Cyprus? Trudeau’s Foreign Policy 1. Canada-U.S. Relations In 1968 the Liberals, lead by Pierre Elliot Trudeau were elected Trudeau wanted to steer foreign policy away from dependence on the U.S. Trudeau realized Canada should consider the U.S. government to some extent when it came to foreign affairs, as he explained in a famous speech: “Living next to you is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant. No matter how friendly and even tempered is the beast, one is affected by every twitch and grunt.” (March, 1969) Trudeau & USA Trudeau wanted to ease Cold War tensions and scale back Canada’s participation in the nuclear arms race Nuclear missiles were removed from Canadian NATO forces in Europe (1970-1972) • Bomarc missile sites were dismantled • The last nuclear warheads were removed from Canada by 1984. • Trudeau cut the national defence budget Recognizing Communist China In 1970, Canada officially recognized the communist government of the People’s Republic of China (even though the U.S. was pressuring to withhold the recognition) Canada & China – History In 1949 – communists led by Mao Zedong took over the government of China The UN, under pressure of the USA, refused to recognize the communist government • Instead recognized the former government, now located in Taiwan, which held one of the 5 permanent seats on the Security Council 1971 – USA finally allowed “Red China” to replace Taiwan on the Security Council Mao Zedong & Trudeau Cuba When Cuba became communist in 1959 – the USA: • established an embargo (A government order imposing trade barriers) on Cuba in October 1960 • Broke diplomatic ties following January • Tensions peaked during the Bay of Pigs invasion (1961) and the Cuban Missile Crisis (1962) Trudeau (and PMs after him) did not cut diplomatic ties, and ignored the embargo Trudeau – Nuclear Weapons In early 1970’s – tensions between US and USSR eased – agreed to reduce # of nuclear weapons •signed SALT I (Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty) in 1972 Trudeau Era SALT II was delayed due to several events led to each side accusing the other of provoking war: 1. 1979 – USSR invaded Afghanistan & moved medium-range missiles into Eastern Europe – so NATO announced that it would move similar missiles into Western Europe – SALT talks called off 2. 1983 (Sept.) – Soviet jets shot down a Korean passenger jet that had strayed into Soviet airspace 3. 1983 - USA –invaded Grenada (in Caribbean) and deposed a Soviet government 4. USA carried out a covert (secret) war against left-wing Sandinista regime in Nicaragua Trudeau – appealed to both sides to show more restraint – conducted “peace tour” to enlist support of countries around the world • However - 1984 – Trudeau decided to leave politics Foreign Aid - CIDA While the Cold War politically split the world between the East and West, an economic gap separated the rich North from the poor South. The Trudeau government aimed to promote world peace, he believed the North should be helping countries struck with poverty in the South to develop their economies and improve living conditions. This became known as a policy of “Trade and Aid” of Trudeau’s foreign policy. In 1968 the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) was formed to boost foreign aid to less industrialized countries (countries receiving aid would agree to buy products from Canada, which is called “tied aid”) Commonwealth & Francophonie The Commonwealth was made of countries of the former British Empire la Francophonie was an organization of French-speaking states (many were former colonies of France) Canada is a member of both organizations, which discusses solutions for the North-South gap. 1950 the Commonwealth countries created the Colombo Plan to provide money and aid to less developed countries in the organization in SE Asia (most of the Canadian aid went to India, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan) Reflect & Discuss What was Trudeau’s Foreign Policy towards the USA? What was Trudeau’s Foreign Policy towards China? Cuba? How did these policies go against the USA’s? Why was Foreign Aid a part of Trudeau’s Foreign Policy? Why did he feel it was important? How were the Commonwealth and Francophonie connected to his Foreign Policy? Group of Eight (G8) Formerly Group of 7 (G7) – Canada joined in 1976 Member countries: Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States an international forum for the member governments to meet annually to discuss political and economic issues of mutual concern G8 con’t Together, these countries represent about: • 65% of the world economy • only about 14% of the world population, • the majority of global military power (7 of the top 8 positions for military expenditure, and almost all of the world's active nuclear weapons) G8 – cont’ The group's activities include year-round conferences and policy research, culminating with an annual summit meeting attended by the heads of government of the member states. The European Commission is also represented at the meetings. The ministerial meetings bring together ministers responsible for various portfolios to discuss issues of mutual or global concern. G8 cont’ The range of topics include health, law enforcement, labour, economic and social development, energy, environment, foreign affairs, justice and interior, terrorism and trade. Many people are critical of the G8 because they feel their policies negatively affect developed countries common criticism: they only look out for their own interests rather that what is best for the http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X9IwOEeEQj8 world as a whole Reflect & Discuss What is the G8? What countries are involved? What is its purpose? Why is it criticized in the world community? Middle East Ongoing conflicts in Middle East between Israel (est. 1949) and Arab states 1973 – Yom Kippur War took place Few years later - Anwar Sadat – leader of Egypt – initiated peace talks with Israelis USA – tends to back Israel, USSR backs Arab nations Middle East – cont’ Camp David accords – signed in 1979 Egyptians agreed to recognize Israeli’s right to exist In turn – Israelis agreed to negotiate the occupied territories (i.e. Gaza Strip) By late 1990s –agreement seemed close, but Intifadas (Palestinian uprisings) started in 2001 – no resolution Afghanistan – 1979-1988 Cold war “heated up” again when: USSR placed 350 missiles in Eastern Europe USSR invaded Afghanistan • • • Installed a new dictator, Karmal, as President The West, China, and India were alarmed because the Soviets appeared to be attempting to take control of the Persian Gulf Result – USA boycotted the 1980 Moscow Olympics • From 1980-1988 – viscous war in Afghanistan - created enormous refugee problem for neighbouring states like Pakistan • 1988 – Soviets agreed to withdraw USA invaded Grenada - 1983 US justification for invasion – to depose a Soviet government that had assassinated the Prime Minister •Grenada was part of the Commonwealth of Nations • invasion was opposed by the United Kingdom, Trinidad & Tobago and Canada, among others. •British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher personally opposed the U.S. invasion Grenada – cont’ • Ronald Reagan, President of the United States, assured her that an invasion was not contemplated. Reagan later said, "She was very adamant and continued to insist that we cancel our landings on Grenada. I couldn't tell her that it had already begun."[8] After the invasion, Prime Minister Thatcher wrote to President Reagan: This action will be seen as intervention by a Western country in the internal affairs of a small independent nation, however unattractive its regime. I ask you to consider this in the context of our wider East-West relations and of the fact that we will be having in the next few days to present to our Parliament and people the siting of Cruise missiles in this country...I cannot conceal that I am deeply disturbed by your latest communication.[9] Nicaragua 4. USA carried out a covert (secret) war against leftwing Sandinista regime in Nicaragua Trudeau – appealed to both sides to show more restraint – conducted “peace tour” to enlist support of countries around the world • However - 1984 – Trudeau decided to leave politics Reflect & Discuss Explain these conflicts and their importance to the Cold War: • • • • Middle East Afghanistan Grenada Nicaragua Mulroney’s Foreign Policy September 1984 – Conservative leader Brian Mulroney became new PM His approach to international relations in many ways opposite of Trudeau: 1.worked to forge stronger links with USA developed close personal relationship with President Reagan 2. US’s Strategic Defense Initiative – “Star Wars” defense shield plan – part of which would orbit the earth Canadians didn’t want it, but Mulroney personally did – however he said “no” to Canada’s participation 3. Economically – Canada “open for business” Mulroney dismantled FIRA (Foreign Investment Review Agency) that Trudeau set up in 1973 to block any foreign investment that seemed not to be in Canada’s interest 4. 1987 – Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with USA – removed tariffs on goods crossing the border very controversial NAFTA 5. 1992 – North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) with USA and Mexico very controversial came into effect in 1994 under Chrétien Reflect & Discuss What characterized Mulroney’s Foreign Policy? What were the names and dates of the two Free Trade Agreements negotiated by Mulroney? End of the Cold War 1985 - Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev – realized that USSR could no longer afford costly arms race with the U.S., he proposed massive cuts in arsenal for both powers. To help communist countries run more effectively Gorbachev began a series of social, economic and political reforms. New policies: 1. perestroika – reconstruction (of economic and political systems) - a policy supporting reform. 2. glasnost – openness (freedom of speech, no censorship, etc.) encouraging open debate about issues facing the country. End of Cold War November 1989 – Berlin Wall came down dissolution of USSR in 1991 – division between East and West officially gone broke into 15 smaller states (including Poland, Hungary, East Germany (now part of Germany), Czechoslovakia, Romania, and Yugoslavia) New World Order End of Cold War did not bring peace to the world numerous regional conflicts and ethnic rivalries, such as: • Gulf War – Iraqi invasion of Kuwait (1991) Former Yugoslavia (1991-1999) • Somalia (1992) • Rwanda (1994) • Afghanistan (2001-present) • US invasion of Iraq (2003present) Post-Cold War Foreign Relations Bi-lateral relations Bi-lateral relations – between Canada and one other country – some important relationships include: • Canadian-American Relations • Canadian-British Relations • Canada-Japan Relations Post-Cold War Foreign Relations Multilateral relations Multilateral relations – contacts with many other nations, usually within one association or organization Some International organizations of which Canada is a part: • • • • • • • • The United Nations (UN) The Commonwealth La Francophonie North Atlantic Treaty Organization Organization of American States (OAS) World Trade Organization (WTO) Group of Eight (G8) Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) • Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) • North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) Reflect & Discuss Define “bilateral” and “multilateral” relations. What are some of the more important bilateral relations that Canada has? What are some of the more improtant multilateral relations that Canada has?