Writing High School Concept-Based Curriculum Units A Framework for Raising Achievement in Social Studies A project led by the High School Social Studies Section of the 6-12 Division of Curriculum & Instruction “A mental construct that frames a set of What examples sharing common attributes.” - H. Lynn Erickson is a concept? A Concept is: • • • • Timeless Universal Abstract and Broad Examples Share Common Attributes • Represented by 1-2 words What is concept-based curriculum and instruction? Concept-Based Instruction is teaching using “big idea” frameworks which share common attributes that integrate thinking so students can see patterns and connections between facts and related ideas that transfer through time and across many situations. Lynn Erickson, Ed.D. At the End of the Day…? http://www.gamespot.com/users/bloody1f 4knight/video_player?id=JSFnlDSs5bgM uTXf Too many social studies teachers and Let’s use students what we observed in where the video have too many days they feelalike pulling theirconnection. hair out to help make practical therefore, what we are recommending with the implementation of CBI is a paradigm shift. Conceptual teaching helps the student… To Teaching Teaching learned information integrate new & From previously Conceptually Topically make connections between facts transfer learning for deeper understanding Macro and Micro Concepts Macro Concepts provide BREADTH of understanding (interdisciplinary) Micro Concepts provide DEPTH of understanding (discipline specific) Micro Concepts Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Movement C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Manifest Destiny C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro American Civil War C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Civil War C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Great Depression C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Change C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Progressivism C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Supply and Demand C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Economic Systems C. Topic Identifying Concepts A. Macro B. Micro Systems C. Topic Unit Design Becoming familiar with CBI terminology • • • • • • • • Concept(s) Conceptual Lens Macro Concept(s) Micro Concept(s) Topic(s) Fact(s) Generalization(s) Enduring Understanding(s) • Essential Question(s) • Guiding Question(s) • • • • • • Unit Lesson Performance Task(s) Learning Experiences Critical Content Skills The Big Picture… Start with the big picture (big idea), the broad concepts, such as “change”, “system”, “conflict” or “movement”: But, then focus on the more specific facts and related ideas that connect and support such as “reconstruction,” “supply and demand,” “Civil War” or “trail of tears.” What are the components of concept-based instruction? – – – – – – – – Unit theme/title Conceptual Lens (Broad integrating “big ideas”) Concepts and subconcepts (macro/micro) Generalizations (Enduring Understandings) Guiding Questions (Essential Questions) Critical Content Skills Culminating Performance Assessment Tasks (what students must know, understand and be able to do in the Unit) – Learning experiences (the activities and performances supported by the lesson plans that prepare students for success with the performance tasks) The Three Non-Negotiable Unit Components 1. Students will know… (facts/terms/information) Factual knowledge, Memorized knowledge Critical factual knowledge for understanding the unit generalization(s). Critical factual knowledge for competency with the unit topics. Non-transferable—locked in time, place or situation CONCEPT CONCEPT 2. Students will understand … (lasting, transferable understanding) Transferable Generalizations/Enduring Understandings 3. Students will be able to do… (skills) TOPIC F F F F A A A A C C C C T T T T Taken (often verbatim) from the State Skill Standards Transfer across applications Not tied to a specific topic (attaching a skill to a specific topic makes it an activity or a performance.) F A C T 26 F F A A C C T T GENERALIZATIONS CONCEPT CONCEPT TOPIC F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T Steps involved in writing CBI units 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Determine unit topic/focus (Current Unit-Past Unit-Next Unit) Determine the “big picture”/conceptual lens for the entire experience Decide on the objectives that you want to use and place them under the correct strand. (History, Geography, Government, Culture, Politics, Economics) Objectives usually fit under several strands. Decide on the Make a list of the concepts that fit under these areas of study (History, Geography, Government, Culture, Politics, Economics). Determine the critical content. This can take the visual form of a unit map that provides a visual of the written unit overview. Develop a written overview of the unit and/or Come up with generalizations – 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 8-12 generalizations per unit – maybe repeat definition – based on concepts/subconcepts you have outlined on you unit web Develop guiding questions Confirm the critical content Identify the skills that should be used and reinforced Come up with performance tasks for the students Design rubrics that will assess how the student will be evaluated Create learning experiences and lessons that will help students complete the performance tasks 14. List unit resources and teacher notes Current Unit Previous Unit Next Unit (The Big Picture)/Conceptual Lens: Unit Map: Unit Overview: (Name of the current unit) is about (name the concept(s)). History Strand SCOS Objectives: Geography Strand SCOS Objectives: Political/ Government Strand SCOS Objectives: Economic Strand SCOS Objectives: Concepts Concepts Concepts Concepts Topics Topics Topics Topics Concept Social/ Culture Strand SCOS Objectives: Global Connections SCOS Objectives: Concepts Concepts Topics Topics Unit Plan Template History Generalizations: Essential Questions: Geography Generalizations: Essential Questions: Government/Politics Generalizations: Essential Questions: Economics Generalizations: Essential Questions: Social/Culture Generalizations: Essential Questions: Global Connections Generalizations: Essential Questions: Critical Content and Skills: Students will know… AC = Assessment Code: AC AC 1. the biological and cultural processes that shaped the earliest human communities. 2. the early physical and cultural development of humankind from the Paleolithic era to the agricultural revolution and the fact that knowledge of these societies is based on archaeological methods. 3. how early civilizations developed through interactions with their environment. Key skills... Q - Quizzes P - Prompts T - Tests O - Observations WS - Work Samples D - Dialogues SA - Student Self-Assessment 4. how the development of agriculture and trade changed the way ancient peoples lived. 5. that the earliest peoples banded together to provide for their basic needs, and created the first civilizations. AC AC 1. Read and translate maps into appropriate graphics to display geographic information. 4. Compare geographic information presented at different scales. 2. Examine and draw conclusions from artifacts. 5. Hypothesize about the influences of the past on present culture. 3. Answer geographic questions regarding major physical and human characteristics. Step 1: Task Planner What: Investigate prehistoric cultures Why: in order to understand that innovations and technology cause cultures to progress. How: (Engaging Scenario-Performance) You are an archaeologist preparing a presentation on the development of prehistoric cultures for an archaeology class. Chart the information you research on a map and create a colorful and appealing graphic organizer to display the development of prehistoric cultures. Present your information to the class stressing the innovations and technologies that caused the prehistoric societies to progress. Scoring Guide: (Rubric) Task: Presentation on the Development of Prehistoric Cultures Scoring Criteria Content: Thorough presentation of developing prehistoric cultures: * Includes at least 3 innovations that led to cultural change * Accurate representation of the development of prehistoric cultures. Accurate depiction of information related to developing cultures on map. Effective use of map symbols or icons. S t a Process: n Evidence of thorough research on prehistoric cultures. d - at least 3sources of information a r d Colorful and appealing presentation of data on graphic organizer. Scoring Key A= B= C= I= 100 Suggested Learning Experiences 1. Guide students to complete a KWL 2. 3. chart for the unit (Know/Want to Know/Learned). Encourage students to brainstorm what they “Want to Know” after presenting a brief and engaging summary of the ancient period. Locate prehistoric communities on maps of different scale and identify the geographical features that they had in common. Present archaeological evidence and theories related to ancient sea travel and trade between prehistoric communities. Create a fictional journal on an ancient trader making the sea journey from Harrapa to Upper Egypt, or the land trek across the Asian Steppes to Mesopotamia. Encourage students to generate their own theories about trade and interaction between ancient cultures using available archeological and geographical evidence. Construct a graphic organizer identifying factors leading to change from hunter/ gatherer to agricultural societies. 1,3,6 2 3 5,7 1,3,4,5 1,2,3,4 4 4,5 1 Unit Resources Cradle of civilization Series. (1997). Millbrook Press. Dickinson, P. (1995). A bone from dry sea. Laurel Leaf. (Fiction) Journey into civilization Series. (1994). Chelsea House. Lindsay, W. (1994). Eyewitness: Prehistoric Life. Knopf pub. McCord, A. (1995). Eyewitness visual dictionary: Prehistoric life. Dorling Kindersley. Teacher Notes Let’s look at identifying and pulling out concepts. Tools we need to begin? SCOS Identifying Concepts Unit Title/Focus: NCSCOS Objectives: Geography History Government Economics Culture History Government Economics Culture Concepts: Geography Charting the Process of Identifying Concepts Unit Title/Focus: Great Depression and World War II NCSCOS: NC History - Goal 6 The learner will analyze the immediate and long-term effects of the Great Depression and World War II on North Carolina. 6.01 Identify the causes and effects of the Great Depression and analyze the impact of New Deal policies on Depression Era life in North Carolina. 6.02 Describe the significance of major events and military engagements associated with World War II and evaluate the impact of the war on North Carolina. 6.03 Examine the significance of key ideas and individuals associated with World War II. 6.04 Assess the impact of World War II on the economic, political, social, and military roles of different groups in North Carolina including women and minorities. Geography Region Rural Urban Geographical locations Natural Processes History Conflict Cooperation Change and continuity Invasion Conquest Government Communism Socialism Imperialism War Censorship Domestic Policy Foreign Policy Economics Scarcity Market economy Culture Adaptation Voluntarism Conflict Cooperation Concepts: Change and Survival Geography 6.02, 6.04 History 6.01, 6.02, 6.03, 6.04 Government 6.01, 6.03, 6.04 Economics 6.01, 6.04 Culture 6.01, 6.04 Now let’s look at coming up with generalizations. War Resources GENERALIZATION= Enduring Understanding Two or more concepts in a relationship... Concept Concept • CONCEPTUAL IDEAS THAT TRANSFER • DEVELOP “DEEP UNDERSTANDING’ Generalizations* Full sentence statements, describing what, specifically, students should understand about the critical concepts in the lesson Generalization Guidelines: 1. No proper or personal nouns or pronouns 2. Use a present tense verb 3. Show a relationship between at least two concepts 4. Transferable idea that is supported by the factual content 5. Uses a qualifier (often, can, may) * Referred to as “Enduring Understandings” in Understanding by Design (Wiggins and McTighe) Sample Generalizations Social Studies • Culture exhibits both change and continuity through time. • Social, economic and political systems structure a society. • Changes in laws and rules reflect changes in power relationships. Sample Generalizations Social Studies • Culture exhibits both change and continuity through time. • Social, economic and political systems structure a society. • Changes in laws and rules reflect changes in power relationships. Sample Generalizations Social Studies • Culture exhibits both change and continuity through time. • Social, economic and political systems structure a society. • Changes in laws and rules reflect changes in power relationships. Sample Generalizations Social Studies • Culture exhibits both change and continuity through time. • Social, economic and political systems structure a society. • Changes in laws and rules reflect changes in power relationships. Two or more concepts in a relationship... War Resources War decreases availability of resources. Two or more concepts in a relationship... Economic Systems Government Government decisions influence a nation’s economy. Two or more concepts in a relationship... Human Environment/ Interaction Geographic conditions Movement Geographic conditions may lead to movement of people, goods, and ideas and cultural diffusion. Two or more concepts in a relationship… Environment Nationalism Nationalism may cause a change in physical and political boundaries. Two or more concepts in a relationship... Change Culture Continuity Culture exhibits both change and continuity through time. Two or more concepts in a relationship… Market Economy An unequal distribution of wealth may lead to economic recession. Wealth Are these two or more concepts in a relationship? Market Economy Supply & Demand To Be or NoT To Be… In the following slides, select whether each statement is a generalization or not. If the statement is a generalization, select “A;” but if not, select “B” Concepts: change, environment, scarcity, movement, conflict 1. How does the environment change over time and what are the reasons for this change? A. Generalization B. Not a Generalization 2. Wartime bombing decreases resource availability. A. Generalization B. Not a Generalization 3. Great Britain’s implementation of naval and aeronautic technology changed the course of World War Two in favor of the Allies. A. Generalization B. Not a Generalization 4. The physical environment of a region may be altered due to limited resources and human environment interaction. A. Generalization B. Not a Generalization Writing Generalizations Begin with Level 1: Combine two or more concepts in a sentence to establish a relationship using the following verbs: Level 1 Verbs affects impacts influence is/are/have. GENERALIZATIONS CONCEPT CONCEPT TOPIC F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T F A C T The Structure of Knowledge The student understands that .... the availability of natural resources affects the development of a region’s economy and its settlement. Economy Natural Resources F A C T S F A C T S F A C T S F F F F F A A A A A C C C C C T T T T T S S S S S Physical Environment Settlement Patterns Environmental impact on the US Economy 3 2 1 The student understands that … 3 2 F A C T S F A C T S F A C T S F F F F F A A A A A C C C C C T T T T T S S S S S 1 Use one of the following verbs: affects, impacts, influences, is/are/have The Structure of Knowledge The student understands that … 3 2 F A C T S F A C T S F A C T S F A C T S F A C T S F A C T S F A C T S 1 F A C T S Use one of the following verbs: affects, impacts, influences, is/are/have Writing Generalizations Unit Title/Focus: Concepts: Geography History Government Economics Generalizations & Essential Questions Geography History Government Economics Culture Culture Level II Generalizations To scaffold a Level 1 generalization to Level 2 as “how?” or “why?” • Level 1 – Government policies are influenced by societal norms. • Why do governmental policies reflect societal norms? • Level 2 – Governmental policies differ based on time, place, values, and beliefs. Three Non-Negotiable Unit Components 1. Students will understand that… Transferable Generalizations/Enduring Understandings Examples: “Systems are interdependent.” (macro-level) “Organisms adapt to changing environments.” (micro-level) “Rational numbers, including whole numbers, fractions and decimals can be expressed in equivalent forms of standard notation or scientific notation.” (micro-level) 73 2. Students will know… Factual knowledge, Memorized knowledge Critical factual knowledge for understanding the unit generalization(s). Critical factual knowledge for competency with the unit topics. Non-transferable—locked in time, place or situation 3. Students will be able to do…(skills) Taken (often verbatim) from the State Skill Standards Transfer across applications Not tied to a specific topic (attaching a skill to a specific topic makes it an activity or a performance.) Critical Content/Concept Web Draft 2/28/03 Prehistoric Society: Survival Unit Title:______________________ Change Conceptual Lens:__________________ 6.4A1-2 Culture Artifacts Paleolithic (Old Stone Age) Neolithic (New Stone Age) 6.4A2 Unit Title History History before written language (prehistory) Pictographs (drawn) Petroglyphs (chiseled) Timeline Prehistoric Society: Survival 6.4A3 Geography 6.l7B1 Economics 6.8E6 Human-environmental Division of labor interaction – available Revolution of resources; uses 6.2B1 Government agriculture Movement of people Tribes (hunter-gatherers Clans follow the food supply) Family unit Small farms Designer(s):________________________________ Unit Overview How would you have liked living in prehistoric times? Imagine what it would have been like to rely on your inventiveness just to survive! In this unit we will see how prehistoric people discovered and used fire to meet their needs; how they developed language to communicate; and how they used the environment to create tools. We will learn how prehistoric people advanced from food gatherers to food producers; and how specialization, government and religion shaped early societies. Grade Level: _______ Essential Understandings Guiding Questions (generalizations) Culture: 1. Societies develop technologies to meet their needs. 1. 2. Advancing technologies change cultures. 2. 3. Artifacts reflect cultural and technological changes. 3. a. What is “culture?” b. What kinds of tools were developed in prehistoric societies? How were these tools/artifacts used? a. How did the development of early tools/artifacts change prehistoric societies? Is change always beneficial? Is change inevitable? a. How do artifacts reflect time, pl.ace and the human condition? Describe an artifact that has changed over time. Economics 4. A change from a food gathering society to an agricultural society leads to a division of labor. 4. . Competition for resources and land can lead to 5 conflict and movement of peoples. 6. People may form groups to provide for basic needs or for protection. Geography 7. The resources of a region determine the types of food, clothing, shelter and tools. 8. The search for resources to meet basic needs influences migration patterns. Government/Civics 9. Political systems organize society to maintain order and achieve goals. 10. Civilizations progress socially, economically and politically. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. a. Why did prehistoric societies change from food gatherers to food producers? Why did agriculture require a division of labor? b. How did farming impact the lives of prehistoric peoples? c. Why was the domestication of animals significant to early peoples? a. Why does competition for natural resources lead to conflict? b. How does conflict over natural resources lead to the alteration of land boundaries? a. Why did people form groups in prehistoric times? b. How do groups organize to meet their basic needs? a. What natural resources were available to prehistoric societies? b. How was the first farming done? What tools were used? a. Why do groups of people move from one place to another? How does geography affect migration patterns a. Why do societies create political systems and why do these systems differ across cultures and through time? 10. a. What is the difference between Paleolithic and Neolithic man? How did the Neolithic society develop? Critical Content/Concept Web Draft 2/28/03 Prehistoric Society: Survival Unit Title:______________________ Change Conceptual Lens:__________________ 6.4A1-2 Culture Artifacts Paleolithic (Old Stone Age) Neolithic (New Stone Age) 6.4A2 Unit Title History History before written language (prehistory) Pictographs (drawn) Petroglyphs (chiseled) Timeline Prehistoric Society: Survival 6.4A3 Geography 6.l7B1 Economics 6.8E6 Human-environmental Division of labor interaction – available Revolution of resources; uses 6.2B1 Government agriculture Movement of people Tribes (hunter-gatherers Clans follow the food supply) Family unit Small farms Designer(s):________________________________ Unit Overview How would you have liked living in prehistoric times? Imagine what it would have been like to rely on your inventiveness just to survive! In this unit we will see how prehistoric people discovered and used fire to meet their needs; how they developed language to communicate; and how they used the environment to create tools. We will learn how prehistoric people advanced from food gatherers to food producers; and how specialization, government and religion shaped early societies. Grade Level: _______ Essential Understandings Guiding Questions (generalizations) Culture: 1. Societies develop technologies to meet their needs. 1. 2. Advancing technologies change cultures. 2. 3. Artifacts reflect cultural and technological changes. 3. a. What is “culture?” b. What kinds of tools were developed in prehistoric societies? How were these tools/artifacts used? a. How did the development of early tools/artifacts change prehistoric societies? Is change always beneficial? Is change inevitable? a. How do artifacts reflect time, pl.ace and the human condition? Describe an artifact that has changed over time. Economics 4. A change from a food gathering society to an agricultural society leads to a division of labor. 4. . Competition for resources and land can lead to 5 conflict and movement of peoples. 6. People may form groups to provide for basic needs or for protection. Geography 7. The resources of a region determine the types of food, clothing, shelter and tools. 8. The search for resources to meet basic needs influences migration patterns. Government/Civics 9. Political systems organize society to maintain order and achieve goals. 10. Civilizations progress socially, economically and politically. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. a. Why did prehistoric societies change from food gatherers to food producers? Why did agriculture require a division of labor? b. How did farming impact the lives of prehistoric peoples? c. Why was the domestication of animals significant to early peoples? a. Why does competition for natural resources lead to conflict? b. How does conflict over natural resources lead to the alteration of land boundaries? a. Why did people form groups in prehistoric times? b. How do groups organize to meet their basic needs? a. What natural resources were available to prehistoric societies? b. How was the first farming done? What tools were used? a. Why do groups of people move from one place to another? How does geography affect migration patterns a. Why do societies create political systems and why do these systems differ across cultures and through time? 10. a. What is the difference between Paleolithic and Neolithic man? How did the Neolithic society develop? Critical Content and Skills: Students will know… AC = Assessment Code: AC AC 1. the biological and cultural processes that shaped the earliest human communities. 2. the early physical and cultural development of humankind from the Paleolithic era to the agricultural revolution and the fact that knowledge of these societies is based on archaeological methods. 3. how early civilizations developed through interactions with their environment. Key skills... Q - Quizzes P - Prompts T - Tests O - Observations WS - Work Samples D - Dialogues SA - Student Self-Assessment 4. how the development of agriculture and trade changed the way ancient peoples lived. 5. that the earliest peoples banded together to provide for their basic needs, and created the first civilizations. AC AC 1. Read and translate maps into appropriate graphics to display geographic information. 4. Compare geographic information presented at different scales. 2. Examine and draw conclusions from artifacts. 5. Hypothesize about the influences of the past on present culture. 3. Answer geographic questions regarding major physical and human characteristics. Step 1: Task Planner What: Investigate prehistoric cultures Why: in order to understand that innovations and technology cause cultures to progress. How: (Engaging Scenario-Performance) You are an archaeologist preparing a presentation on the development of prehistoric cultures for an archaeology class. Chart the information you research on a map and create a colorful and appealing graphic organizer to display the development of prehistoric cultures. Present your information to the class stressing the innovations and technologies that caused the prehistoric societies to progress. Scoring Guide: (Rubric) Task: Presentation on the Development of Prehistoric Cultures Scoring Criteria Content: Thorough presentation of developing prehistoric cultures: * Includes at least 3 innovations that led to cultural change * Accurate representation of the development of prehistoric cultures. Accurate depiction of information related to developing cultures on map. Effective use of map symbols or icons. S t a Process: n Evidence of thorough research on prehistoric cultures. d - at least 3sources of information a r d Colorful and appealing presentation of data on graphic organizer. Scoring Key A= B= C= I= 100 Suggested Learning Experiences 1. Guide students to complete a KWL 2. 3. chart for the unit (Know/Want to Know/Learned). Encourage students to brainstorm what they “Want to Know” after presenting a brief and engaging summary of the ancient period. Locate prehistoric communities on maps of different scale and identify the geographical features that they had in common. Present archaeological evidence and theories related to ancient sea travel and trade between prehistoric communities. Create a fictional journal on an ancient trader making the sea journey from Harrapa to Upper Egypt, or the land trek across the Asian Steppes to Mesopotamia. Encourage students to generate their own theories about trade and interaction between ancient cultures using available archeological and geographical evidence. Construct a graphic organizer identifying factors leading to change from hunter/ gatherer to agricultural societies. 1,3,6 2 3 5,7 1,3,4,5 1,2,3,4 4 4,5 1 Unit Resources Cradle of civilization Series. (1997). Millbrook Press. Dickinson, P. (1995). A bone from dry sea. Laurel Leaf. (Fiction) Journey into civilization Series. (1994). Chelsea House. Lindsay, W. (1994). Eyewitness: Prehistoric Life. Knopf pub. McCord, A. (1995). Eyewitness visual dictionary: Prehistoric life. Dorling Kindersley. Teacher Notes 2. Students will know… Factual knowledge, Memorized knowledge Critical factual knowledge for understanding the unit generalization(s). Critical factual knowledge for competency with the unit topics. Non-transferable—locked in time, place or situation Examples: …Newton’s Laws …Key Vocabulary …the causes of the American Revolution …the names and contributions of historical figures in our community …the formulas for finding the area of quadrilaterals 3. Students will be able to do…(skills) Taken (often verbatim) from the State Skill Standards Transfer across applications Not tied to a specific topic (attaching a skill to a specific topic makes it an activity or a performance.) Examples: display Create tables, graphs and charts to scientific data. Analyze primary and secondary source documents to evaluate historical information. Analyze the use of connotative and denotative language in text. Use context clues in reading to determine meaning.