1 Tracking Student Progress to Meet the Bar for Every Student 2014 Leadership Institute Day 2 Please connect to the internet using the Leadership Institute network. Network ID: BCPS Password: baltimorecityschool$ If you have not already downloaded today’s materials, please go to the conference website and download the documents for the appropriate day and grade level. Website: 365.bcpss.org/leadership 2 Agenda 3 Session Outcome Activities We will develop a common understanding of how to effectively use available resources and apply a data inquiry process to increase the achievement of every student. Connecting Standards and Assessment Understanding and Analyzing Data to Prioritize Needs Identifying a Problem of Practice Developing an Action Plan to Address the Problem of Practice Group Norms 4 Understand that those who work, learn. Recognize that everyone has expertise. Phrase questions for the benefit of everyone. Challenge ideas, not people. Share talk time Recap of Day 1 5 Developing a common understanding of the urgency of raising the bar for every student through a deeper understanding of content and grade level expectations for the Maryland College and Career Ready Standards (MCCRS) through: • Examination of PARCC tasks for rigor in ELA and Mathematics • Deconstruct the MCCRS aligned to the task • Connections to the curriculum and Instructional Framework 6 Connecting Standards to Assessment Items PARCC Performance-Based Assessments 7 Literary Analysis Task Narrative Task Research Simulation Task • This task will ask students to carefully consider literature worthy of close study and compose an analytic essay. • In this task, students may be asked to write a story, detail a scientific process, write a historical account of important figures, or describe an account of events, scenes or objects, for example. • In this task, students will analyze an informational topic presented through several articles or multimedia stimuli. Students will answer a series of questions and synthesize information in order to write two analytic essays. 3 Types of Questions 8 When taking the PARCC assessment, students will encounter three question types: • Evidence-Based Selected Response (EBSR) items • Technology-Enhanced Constructed Response (TECR) items • Prose Constructed Response (PCR) items 5th Grade Literacy Module 3 Assessment 9 Independently complete this portion of the 5th grade assessment by reading both articles and completing questions Work with a partner to do the following: Identify the question type (EBSR, TECR, or PCR) for each of the assessment questions. Identify the cluster and the 5th grade standard for each question. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 10 Question 5 Part A Which fact is found in both articles about whales? c. Whales live together in pods. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.3 Explain the relationships or interactions between two or more individuals, events, ideas, or concepts in a historical, scientific, or technical text based on specific information in the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 11 Question 5 Part B Choose one detail from the article “Swimming with the Pod” and one detail from “Whale Songs” to support the answer to Part A. Supporting Detail from “Swimming with the Pod” Passage 1: Most orcas stay with the pod they are born into for their whole lives. Supporting detail from “Whale Songs” Passage 2: Both blue whales and humpback whales live in groups called pods. Type of Question: Technology Enhanced Constructed Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.1 Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 12 From Literacy Module 3 Assessment: 5A. Which fact is found in both articles about whales? (RI.5.3) 5B. Choose one detail from the article “Swimming with the Pod” and one detail from “Whale Songs” to support the answer for Part A. (RI.5.1) MCCRS for Mathematical Content (Grades 9-12) 13 A-REI.6 Solve systems of linear equations exactly and approximately (e.g., with graphs), focusing on pairs of linear equations in two variables. Question 7 14 The box office took in a total of $2905 in paid admissions for the high-school musical. Adult tickets cost $8 each, and student tickets cost $3 each. If 560 people attended the show, how many were students? Let s = the number of students attending, and let a = the number of adults attending. Which two equations can be used to solve this problem? Select the two that apply. A) 3a + 8s = 2905 B) a + s = 560 C) a + s = 2905 D) 8a + 3s = 2905 E) a = s − 560 Question 8 15 Use the table provided to solve the system of equations. (- 2, -2) (-5, 7) (3, -2) (0, -5) Question 9 16 Mark wants to open a snow cone booth in the neighborhood over the summer. He decides to sell the snow cones for $1.50 each. The initial supplies will cost $250 and each snow cone will cost him $0.25. Based on the graph of his costs and earnings, how many snow cones will Mark need to sell before he begins to make a profit ? 300 snow cones 350 snow cones 250 snow cones 200 snow cones School Team Activity 17 Within your ILT teams, begin analyzing data presented in the end of year ILT tool. Questions to consider while beginning the initial analysis of your data Looking across the data, what questions are raised? What patterns and trends do you see? What additional data might we need to look at? What inferences can we draw from the data? What are the strengths and needs ? Look at DataLink if possible to drill down to standards level data. Inquiry Questions 18 Teaching: • How effective were implemented strategies in raising achievement for all students? • What is the greatest area of strength for teachers? • Did teachers implement the strategies effectively? • What barriers got in the way of effective instruction? • What is the greatest area for growth for teachers? Student Learning: • How did students in each subgroup show achievement towards the goals? • What is the greatest area of strength for students? • What is the greatest area for growth for students? Leadership: • How were teachers supported to implement selected strategies? • What is the greatest area of strength of our school's leadership? • What is the greatest area in need of growth (actions of leadership)? Inquiry Questions 19 Teaching: · What strategies could be used to ensure student mastery of the standards? Student Learning: · How would students show achievement towards these standards? Leadership: · How do we support teachers in implementing effective strategies for teaching these standards? Connecting the Standards to an Evidenced-Based Inquiry Process 20 Evidence Inquiry Process Standards ILTs Step 1: Conduct a Treasure Hunt Assessing Student Learning Step 6: Monitor and Evaluate Results Step 2: Analyze Data to Prioritize Needs Step 5: Determine Results Indicators Step 3: Establish SMART Goals Strategies Instruction Teacher Teams Identifying and understanding data 21 Step 1: Conduct a Treasure Hunt Step 6: Monitor and Evaluate Results DecisionMaking for Results Process Step 5: Determine Results Indicators Step 2: Analyze Data to Prioritize Needs Step 3: Establish SMART Goals Step 4: Select Specific Strategies Purpose: • To g a t h e r a n d o r g a n i z e d a t a in order to gain insights about teaching, learning and leadership practices Considerations: • What are the data sources and where are they housed? • What assessments are in place to measure student learning? • What other data sources should be considered? • How can data be disaggregated? 22 Data Literacy What does it mean to be data literate? 23 Data Literacy is the ability to: • B e a w a r e o f t h e d i s t r i c t ’s t o o l s a n d s y s t e m s where data is housed • Understand the purpose and use of data to solve particular problems of practice • I n t e r p r e t m u l t i p l e d a t a s o u r c e s f r o m d i s t r i c t ’s tools and systems • Use the multiple data sources available to improve teaching and learning • E xa m i n e t h e e xp e c t a t i o n s ( s t a n d a r d s m a s t e r y ) and connecting with the assessment used to measure mastery Assessment Landscape 24 An assessment is a tool to measure student learning towards being college and career ready. Assessment Type Diagnostic Formative (Includes Interim and Unit) Summative Definition City Schools Example Assessments that occur prior to instruction; allow instruction to be planned according to each student's prior knowledge in a given subject. DIBELS, Agile Mind Unit Pre-tests Assessments that occur during instruction; allow instruction to be modified according to individual student needs. Literacy Module assessments, in-class “Checks for Understanding” Assessments that occur after instruction is complete; allow measurement of students mastery of a particular subject or skill set. HSAs, End of Course/Year exams Instructional Leadership Team Tool Overview 25 Integrated reporting tool that incorporates real time data on school demographics, climate and achievement. Designed to give Instructional Leadership Teams (ILTs) at each school periodic reports so that they can investigate the effect of actions made based on strategic decisions. Data Link Overview 26 Instructional Management Suite (IMS) Three Primary Functions: 1. Reporting & Analysis 2. Assessment Management 3. Curriculum & Instruction (pilot phase) Accessible through the web at: https://csdl.bcps.k12.md.us o Usernames and passwords are the same as network credentials for City Schools employees o Teachers and school staff are now able to access the system from their personal computers o All users see a version of the same site, depending on their role and location. 27 Analyzing Data to Prioritize Needs Analyze Data to Prioritize Needs 28 Step 1: Conduct a Treasure Hunt Step 6: Monitor and Evaluate Results Step 2: Analyze Data to Prioritize Needs Step 5: Determine Results Indicators Step 3: Establish SMART Goals Step 4: Select Specific Strategies Purpose: • To i d e n t i f y c a u s e s f o r celebration and to identify areas of concern Considerations: • Looking across the data, what questions are raised? • What inferences can we draw from the data? What are the strengths and needs? • What needs should be prioritized in order for immediate action to be taken? 29 Analyzing Data to Prioritize Needs K8 Example Analyzing Data Example– Grade 5 Module 3 30 Module 1 Module 2 Module 3 Data Link – Standards Mastery Grade 5 Module 3 31 2 1 3 Data Link – Standards Mastery Grade 5 Module 3 - RI.5.1 and RI.5.3 32 MCCRS for Reading Informational Text (Grade 5) 33 CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.5.3 Explain the relationships or interactions between two or more individuals, events, ideas, or concepts in a historical, scientific, or technical text based on specific information in the text. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.5.1 Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text. Standards Assessed Grade 5, ELA Module 3 34 5A. Which fact is found in both articles about whales? (RI.5.3) 5B. Choose one detail from the article “Swimming with the Pod” and one detail from “Whale Songs” to support the answer for Part A. (RI.5.1) School Team Activity 35 Within your ILT teams, begin analyzing data presented in the end of year ILT tool. Questions to consider while beginning the initial analysis of your data Looking across the data, what questions are raised? What patterns and trends do you see? What additional data might we need to look at? What inferences can we draw from the data? What are the strengths and needs ? Look at DataLink if possible to drill down to standards level data. Inquiry Questions 36 Teaching: • How effective were implemented strategies in raising achievement for all students? • What is the greatest area of strength for teachers? • Did teachers implement the strategies effectively? • What barriers got in the way of effective instruction? • What is the greatest area for growth for teachers? Student Learning: • How did students in each subgroup show achievement towards the goals? • What is the greatest area of strength for students? • What is the greatest area for growth for students? Leadership: • How were teachers supported to implement selected strategies? • What is the greatest area of strength of our school's leadership? • What is the greatest area in need of growth (actions of leadership)? 37 Analyzing Data to Prioritize Needs Secondary Example Analyzing Data Example– Intensified Algebra 1 Final 38 Data Link – Standards Mastery Intensified Algebra 1 Final 39 1 2 3 Data Link – Standards Mastery Intensified Algebra 1 Final – A-REI.6 40 MCCRS for Mathematical Content (Grades 9-12) 41 A-REI.6 Solve systems of linear equations exactly and approximately (e.g., with graphs), focusing on pairs of linear equations in two variables. Question 7 42 The box office took in a total of $2905 in paid admissions for the high-school musical. Adult tickets cost $8 each, and student tickets cost $3 each. If 560 people attended the show, how many were students? Let s = the number of students attending, and let a = the number of adults attending. Which two equations can be used to solve this problem? Select the two that apply. A) 3a + 8s = 2905 B) a + s = 560 C) a + s = 2905 D) 8a + 3s = 2905 E) a = s − 560 Question 8 43 Use the table provided to solve the system of equations. (- 2, -2) (-5, 7) (3, -2) (0, -5) Question 9 44 Mark wants to open a snow cone booth in the neighborhood over the summer. He decides to sell the snow cones for $1.50 each. The initial supplies will cost $250 and each snow cone will cost him $0.25. Based on the graph of his costs and earnings, how many snow cones will Mark need to sell before he begins to make a profit ? 300 snow cones 350 snow cones 250 snow cones 200 snow cones School Team Activity 45 Within your ILT teams, begin analyzing data presented in the end of year ILT tool. Questions to consider while beginning the initial analysis of your data Looking across the data, what questions are raised? What patterns and trends do you see? What additional data might we need to look at? What inferences can we draw from the data? What are the strengths and needs ? Look at DataLink if possible to drill down to standards level data. Inquiry Questions 46 Teaching: • How effective were implemented strategies in raising achievement for all students? • What is the greatest area of strength for teachers? • Did teachers implement the strategies effectively? • What barriers got in the way of effective instruction? • What is the greatest area for growth for teachers? Student Learning: • How did students in each subgroup show achievement towards the goals? • What is the greatest area of strength for students? • What is the greatest area for growth for students? Leadership: • How were teachers supported to implement selected strategies? • What is the greatest area of strength of our school's leadership? • What is the greatest area in need of growth (actions of leadership)? 47 Identifying a Problem of Practice Putting it into Practice 48 ILTs should know the teacher team level data inquiry process to inform the school level inquiry process ILTs analyze data through the ILT tool in order to identify a problem of practice ILTs complete cycle of inquiry and create action plans to improve problem of practice Inquiry Questions 49 Teaching: • How effective were implemented strategies in raising achievement for all students? • What is the greatest area of strength for teachers? • Did teachers implement the strategies effectively? • What barriers got in the way of effective instruction? • What is the greatest area for growth for teachers? Student Learning: • How did students in each subgroup show achievement towards the goals? • What is the greatest area of strength for students? • What is the greatest area for growth for students? Leadership: • How were teachers supported to implement selected strategies? • What is the greatest area of strength of our school's leadership? • What is the greatest area in need of growth (actions of leadership)? Conduct a Data Analysis 50 Examine & Discuss Data Assessments Achievement data Classroom observations, record reviews, and other data Conduct Data Analysis – View objectively Patterns Trends Variability Brainstorm - discussion Two Types of Data 51 Effect Data: Student achievement results from various measurements Cause Data: Information based on actions of the adults in the system Drilling Down with Effect Data What content area is our highest priority? Which sub-group of students are most in need of improvement? In what subcontent/skill area(s) do most students need to improve? What skill set needs additional support or intervention? Effect Data: % of 8th grade students scoring proficient or advanced on the state reading assessment Effect Data: % of ELL students Effect Data: % of ELL students who will likely be proficient in literary response Effect Data Source: % of students who will need extensive support in literary response 52 Activity: Drilling Down with Effect Data What content area is our highest priority? Which sub-group of students are most in need of improvement? In what subcontent/skill area(s) do most students need to improve? What skill set needs additional support or intervention? Effect Data: Effect Data: Effect Data: Effect Data Source: 53 Drilling Down with Cause Data What content area is our highest priority? Which sub-group of students are most in need of improvement? In what subcontent/skill area(s) do most students need to improve? What skill set needs additional support or intervention? Adult action: Percentage of instructional time focused on the high-priority content area. Adult action: Number of meetings held for the purpose of making student achievement decisions with relevant, timely data. Adult action: Frequency of team meetings focused on differentiated learning/instructional groups for specific concepts and skills. Adult action: Number of effective teaching strategies implemented to support specific concepts and skills. 54 Activity: Drilling Down with Cause Data What content area is our highest priority? Which sub-group of students are most in need of improvement? In what subcontent/skill area(s) do most students need to improve? What skill set needs additional support or intervention? Adult action: Adult action: Adult action: Adult action:. 55 IF you do the same thing over and over, and expect to get different results, . . . It might be time to try another approach. Let’s get to the Root Cause. 56 Why Use Root Cause Analysis (RCA)? 57 Root Cause Analysis: Helps identify the problem or challenge Helps resolve the Problem Eliminates Patching Conserves Resources Facilitates Discussion (leading to solutions) Provides Rationale for Strategy Selection Determining Root Cause 58 “Frequently, people in organizations persist in attacking symptoms rather than problem sources. Unfortunately, far too often, existing problem-solving methodologies barely probe beneath the surface…Thus the root causes of the problems persist, undisturbed, to feed the symptoms and grow.” Creative Root Cause Analysis: Team Problem Solving, Dr. Jack L. Oxenrider The Five Why’s 59 To get to a possible root cause, ask, “Why?” five times. Use brainstorming to hear team members’ ideas without judgment, then identify the group’s answer at each stage. At each stage, the group will move to a deeper understanding of the problem. Each new “problem” in the process should be an issue that the team can impact. Examples of Using the Five Why’s 60 Problem: On your way home from work, your car stops in the middle of the road. (1) Why did your car stop? Because it ran out of gas. (2) Why did it run out of gas? Because I didn’t buy any gas on my way to work. (3) Why didn’t you buy any gas this morning? Because I didn’t have any money. (4) Why didn’t you have any money? Because I spent my last $30 on dinner last night. (5) Why did you spend your last $30 on dinner? Because I don’t have a monthly budget. Examples of Using the Five Why’s 61 Problem – Average attendance is below 90% for all grade bands. (1) Why is attendance below 90%? Because students feel they are not learning and school feels like a waste of time. (2) Why don’t students feel they are learning and think school is a waste of time? Because teachers aren’t planning differentiated lessons. (3) Why aren’t teachers planning differentiated lessons? Because they don’t know how. (4) Why don’t teachers know how to differentiate? Because previous professional development (PD) has not included peer support. (5) Why doesn’t PD include peer support? Because there isn’t a collaborative structure or structures to ensure collaboration around implementing differentiated practices. Activity: Using the Five Why’s 62 Problem – No students of color have earned a score of 3 or higher on AP exams this spring. (1) Why have no students of color earned a score of 3 or higher on an AP exam? 63 Developing an Action Plan to Address the Problem of Practice Establishing SMART Goals 64 Step 1: Conduct a Treasure Hunt Step 6: Monitor and Evaluate Results Step 2: Analyze Data to Prioritize Needs Step 5: Determine Results Indicators Step 3: Establish SMART Goals Step 4: Select Specific Strategies Purpose: • To i d e n t i f y y o u r m o s t critical goals for student achievement based on the challenges and needs identified Criteria: • Specific • Measurable • Achievable • Relevant • Timely K-8 Example – Establishing a SMART Goal 65 Recall: Module 1 SMART Goal-Setting Template Proposed SMART Goal Module 2 Module 3 Percentage of (student group) scoring proficient or advanced in (content area) will increase from ___% to ___% by the end of the ___ school year as measured by (assessment tool) administered in (month,year). Percentage of 5th grade students scoring proficient or advanced in English Language Arts will increase from 57% to 60% by the end of the SY 14-15 school year as measured by Literacy Module 3 administered in April 2015. Secondary Example Establishing a SMART Goal 66 Recall: SMART Goal-Setting Template Percentage of (student group) scoring proficient or advanced in (content area) will increase from ___% to ___% by the end of the ___ school year as measured by (assessment tool) administered in (month,year). Proposed SMART Goal Percentage of 9th grade students scoring proficient or advanced in Algebra I will increase from 37% to 50% by the end of the SY 14-15 as measured by Intensified Algebra I Final administered in May 2015. Activity 67 Draft a S.M.A.R.T goal based on the inquiry process completed from the data in your ILT Tool. SMART Goal-Setting Template Percentage of (student group) scoring proficient or advanced in (content area) will increase from ___% to ___% by the end of the ___ school year as measured by (assessment tool) administered in (month,year). Mr. Holland’s Opus Selecting Strategies 69 Purpose: • Adult actions will impact student achievements Step 1: Conduct a Treasure Hunt Step 6: Monitor and Evaluate Results Step 2: Analyze Data to Prioritize Needs Step 5: Determine Results Indicators Step 3: Establish SMART Goals Step 4: Select Specific Strategies Considerations: • How are the strategies you’ve identified: • Action-oriented • Measurable/accountable • Specific • Research-based • Consider strategies that are instructional, organizational, programmatic, and focused on evolved leadership actions Brainstorming The Four Types of Strategies 70 Four Types of Strategies Instructional Research-based strategies that are implemented in the classroom to activate the knowledge of students, engage the learner, and strengthen reading, writing, speaking, listening, and thinking. Organizational Strategies that will be used throughout the school, district, (organization). Strategies that will impact all stakeholders. Leadership Strategies that involve the principal/leader to take specific actions that impact implementation of recommended strategies. Programmatic Strategies that are based on the utilization of programs that lead to student improvement (academic and non-academic success) 71 K-8 Example – Selecting Specific Strategies Recall: Module 1 Module 2 Module 3 SMART GOAL Percentage of 5th grade students scoring proficient or advanced in English Language Arts will increase from 57% to 60% by the end of the SY 14-15 school year as measured by Literacy Module 3 administered in April 2015. Instructional • Explicit teaching • Small group instruction • Use of higher-order questioning Organizational • Investigating the amount of time spent on NonLinguistic representations Leadership Programmatic • Feedback to teachers on instructional strategies • Ensuring collaborative planning time focuses on standards 72 Secondary Example – Selecting Specific Strategies SMART GOAL Recall: Instructional • Explicit teaching • Small group instruction • Use of higher-order questioning Leadership • Feedback to teachers on instructional strategies Percentage of 9th grade students scoring proficient or advanced in Algebra I will increase from 37% to 50% by the end of the SY 14-15 as measured by Intensified Algebra I Final administered in May 2015. Organizational • Investigating the amount of time spent on Non-Linguistic representations Programmatic • Ensuring collaborative planning time focuses on standards 73 Activity: Numbered Heads Together 74 Four Types of Strategies Instructional Research-based strategies that are implemented in the classroom to activate the knowledge of students, engage the learner, and strengthen reading, writing, speaking, listening, and thinking. Organizational Strategies that will be used throughout the school, district, (organization). Strategies that will impact all stakeholders. Leadership Strategies that involve the principal/leader to take specific actions that impact implementation of recommended strategies. Programmatic Strategies that are based on the utilization of programs that lead to student improvement (academic and non-academic success) 75 Determine Results Indicator 76 Step 1: Conduct a Treasure Hunt Step 6: Monitor and Evaluate Results Step 2: Analyze Data to Prioritize Needs Step 5: Determine Results Indicators Step 3: Establish SMART Goals Step 4: Select Specific Strategies Purpose: • To m o n i t o r t h e d e g r e e o f implementation of strategies and evaluate the effectiveness of the strategies Considerations: • Are the strategies affecting student outcomes based on data from formative assessments? • Are mid-course corrections being made? K-8 Example – Determine Results Indicator 77 Recall: Instructional • Explicit teaching • Small group instruction • Use of higherorder questioning Strategies Adult Action: Teacher asks questions with multiple competencies ground in text Student Action: Independent reading of complex text. Students engaging in discussions about complex text Secondary Example – Determine Results Indicator 78 Recall: Strategies Instructional • Non –Linguistic representations • Small group instruction • Use of higherorder questioning Adult Action: Teacher will model creating a non-linguistic representation of the property and justify the representation used. Teacher will then model the abstract application of the property thinking aloud and looking back to the recorded visualization. Student Action: Student will create multiple visual representations of each property in their journals; they will then think aloud (in writing) as they apply those properties in solving problems (I know the transitive property means……) Results indicators 79 Writing your results indicators If we use the last block of the day for homework and intervention then we will see increased student attendance engagement and completion of work. (organizational) If we use questioning as a strategy to access prior knowledge then we will see students including inferences in their responses and teachers explicitly planning opening questions. (instructional) Results indicators 80 Writing your results indicators If the school purchases intervention materials aligned to student needs, then number of students scoring proficient or above on the literacy formative /summative assessment will increase. (programmatic) If there are structures and systems in place to monitor/adjust the SPP, then we will see the staff continuously reviewing and revising the plan. (leadership) Quick Write 81 I n d i v i d ua l l y R e f l e c t o n yo u r l e a r n i n g f r o m t h e p a s t t w o d a ys , w h a t a r e t h e k e y C o n n e c t i o n s t h a t s u p p o r t yo u r R e a d i n e s s t o L e a d ! Please take the next 10-15 minutes to complete the daily survey. Website: 365.bcpss.org/leadership Your responses are important for feedback not only about today, but also for future planning! 82 References 83 Barr, R., & Parrett, W.H. (2007). The kids left behind. Bloomington, IN: Solution Tree. Delpit, L. (1995). Other People’s Children: Cultural Conflict in the Classroom Learning 24/7 Observation Study (2005). What’s happening in schools? Or not? Marzano, R. (2007). The art & science of teaching. Alexandria, VA: ASCD. Marzano, R., Waters, T., & McNulty, B. (2005). School leadership that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD. Perry, T., Steele, C. & Hilliard III, A. (2003). Young Gifted and Black: Promoting High Achievement Among African-American Students Reeves, D.B. (2003). 90/90/90 schools. Retrieved from www.LeadandLearn.com Reeves, D.B. (2006). Ten things high schools can do right now to improve student achievement. www.LeadandLearn.com Reeves, D.B. (2010). Data Teams, 3rd Edition. www.LeadandLearn.com Reeves, D.B. (2010). Decision Making for Results: Data-Driven Decision Making 2nd Edition. www.LeadandLearn.com Singleton, G. & Linton, C. (2006). Courageous Conversations About Race: A Field Guide for Achieving Equity in Schools Zemelman, S., Daniels, H., & Hyde, A. (2005). Best practice. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann. Appendix 84 EXTRA K8 QUESTIONS Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 85 Question 1 Part A What is the meaning of the word breach as it is used in paragraph 4? c. Break through Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Craft and Structure Standard: RI 5.4 Interpret words and phrases as they are used in a text, including determining technical, connotative, and figurative meanings, and analyze how specific word choices shape meaning or tone. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 86 Question 1 Part B Which sentence from the passage best supports the answer from Part A? b. He punches his head and upper body above the water and looks around. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.1 Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 87 Question 2 Part A What is the purpose of “beach rubbing” as described in paragraph 5? a. It is an enjoyable way to clean the skin of the whale. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.3 Explain the relationships or interactions between two or more individuals, events, ideas, or concepts in a historical, scientific, or technical text based on specific information in the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 88 Question 2 Part B Which detail from the article helps support the answer to Part A? d. Scientists think this feels good to orcas and may help keep their skin clean. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.1 Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 89 Question 3 Part A What is the author’s main purpose in the article “Swimming in the Pod”? b. To discuss how whales live and play together. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.2 Determine two or more main ideas of a text and explain how they are supported by key details; summarize the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 90 Question 3 Part B Which sentence from “Swimming in the Pod” best supports the answer in Part A? b. When orcas are not searching for food they like to “talk” and socialize – even play. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.1 Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 91 Question 4 Part A What is the main idea of paragraph 1? b. The “who, what, where, when, and why” of the blue whale. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.2 Determine two or more main ideas of a text and explain how they are supported by key details; summarize the text. Connecting Standards to Assessment Items 92 Question 4 Part B Which detail from the passage best supports the answer for Part A? a. Blue whales are the largest of all animals to ever live on earth. Type of Question: Evidence Based Selected Response Cluster: Key Ideas and Details Standard: RI 5.1 Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text.