13-14 2.2 Legislative Branch and Committee Simulation

advertisement

TUESDAY 3/4/14

Please get out the following:

Unit 2.2 Packet

Pencil

Highlighter

Calendar

Packet Pg. 2-3 The United States Constitution: The Legislative Branch

Scavenger Hunt

For each question below, find the article and section within the Constitution that responds to the question. Write in the answer and then the constitutional provision with key words underlined. USE THE LANGUAGE FROM ORIGINAL TEXT.

Question Answer to Question Article Section Constitutional Provision

1. There is a 50-50 tie on a bill regarding gun control in the Senate.

Who will cast the tiebreaking vote?

The Vice President of the United States who is also the

President of the

Senate

2. Your uncle just celebrated his 30 th birthday. Can he run for the House of

Representatives?

1 3

The Vice President of the

United States shall be President of the Senate, but shall have no

Vote, unless they be equally divided.

3. The media are reporting a raise in federal income tax for the coming year. Where did the proposal for this new tax originate?

Question

1.

There is a 50-50 tie on a bill regarding gun control in the

Senate. Who will cast the tiebreaking vote?

Answer to Question

The Vice President of the United

States who is also the President of the Senate

2. Your uncle just celebrated his 30 th birthday. Can he run for the House of

Representatives?

Yes

3. The media are reporting a raise in federal income tax for the coming year.

Where did the proposal for this new tax originate?

The House of Representatives

6 years 4. A candidate you strongly support was just elected senator. How many years must pass until this candidate can be reelected?

Congress 5. Troops from a foreign country have invaded Oregon. Which branch of government has the power to declare war against this aggressor?

Article

1

1

1

1

1

Section

3

2

7

3

8

Constitutional Provision

The Vice President of the United States shall be

President of the Senate, but shall have no Vote, unless they be equally divided.

No Person shall be a Representative who shall not have attained the Age of twenty five years

All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the

House of Representatives

The Senate shall be composed of two senators from each State. . . for 6 years

To declare War

6. The president has appointed a new ambassador to Haiti. Who must approve this appointment?

The Senate 2 2 He shall appoint, by and with the Advice and

Consent of the Senate, Ambassadors

7. If a vice president were to commit a federal offense, who has the power to impeach him or her? Who has the power to put the impeached official on trial?

8. Who has the power to regulate trade

Impeachment - House of

Representatives

Trial - Senate

Congress

1

1

2

3

8

The House of Representatives shall have the sole

Power of Impeachment

The Senate shall have the sole Power to try all

Impeachments

To regulate Commerce among the several States

Constitutional Provision

1.

Article I, Section 9, Clause 2

Writ of Habeas Corpus

2. Article I, Section 7, Clause 2

The Veto

3. Article I, Section 2, Clause 1

Direct Election of the House of

Representatives

Principle or Principles Exemplified

Individual Rights

Separation of Powers

Checks and Balances

Explanation of How They are Exemplified

This clause does not allow the Writ of Habeas Corpus

(challenge of to be suspended ‘unless when in Cases of

Rebellion, or Invasion the public Safety may require it’. Habeas

Corpus is part of an individual’s right to due process of law and this clause protects that right from being abused or randomly denied.

The power of Congress to make laws is checked by the

President’s power to either approve or veto any proposed law.

In addition any bill must pass both houses of Congress so each chamber checks the other.

Finally, the president must veto a bill with reason that is in writing and returned to Congress. This checks his/her power to some extent by ensuring vetoes aren’t on a whim or for purely personal reasons.

Popular Sovereignty

Federalism

Members of the House of Representatives are elected by the people within their states every two years.

States will determine qualifications for voting.

4. Article I, Section 8, Clause 11

Declaration of War

Separation of powers and checks and balances

President is commander-in-chief but only the Congress can declare war thereby checking his power in that role.

Rule of Law The Congress can make laws that are deemed necessary and proper in order to help them exercise their delegated powers.

5. Article I, Section 8, Clause 18

Elastic Clause

PACKET PG. 4: LEGISLATE AND LEGISLATOR

KEY ELEMENTS:

SEPARATION OF POWERS

 Federalism is a type of separation of powers. Its known as ‘Vertical

Separation’.

 The separation of powers within the Federal government is known as

‘Horizontal Separation’.

KEY ELEMENTS:

SEPARATION OF POWERS

 Our system has:

Legislative Branch

(Congress) with specified powers in Article 1 of the

Constitution

 an Executive Branch (The

President) with specified powers in Article 2 of the

Constitution

 and a Judicial Branch with specified powers in Article 3 of the Constitution.

KEY ELEMENTS:

RULE OF LAW

 The idea is that no person is above the law and no one person or entity has too much power within our system – a direct connection to separation of powers.

 This is key to successful legislation.

LEGISLATIVE PROCESS

 Legislators are supposed to consider their constituents, or the people they represent, regardless of how many voted for them (popular

sovereignty).

House and Senate share responsibilities in creating laws that consider their constituents, their party affiliation and what is best for the nation.

 This is all allowed because of the

Necessary and Proper”/

“Elastic” Clause in the

Constitution

LEGISLATIVE PROCESS: PG. 215

LEGISLATORS:

DELEGATES VS. TRUSTEES

Delegate

When a congressperson acts and votes according to what their constituents want. The focus is on promoting their individual interests

(Common in the House).

Trustee

When a congressperson acts and votes according to their convictions and what is best for the country at large and in the long run.

(Common in the Senate)

Which do you think makes a more effective legislator, a delegate or a trustee ? Why?

What types of circumstances would be more appropriate for the delegate role?

What types of circumstances would be best for the trustee ?

PACKET PG. 4-6: JIGSAW

1.

Divide up the tables on pages 4-6 among your new table members.

2.

3.

Each person is responsible for 1-2 tables.

Time permitting: teach to the table your answers for each table.

HW: Read 12.1-12.3 and complete pages in the packet.

PACKET PG. 4: QUALIFICATIONS

FORMAL/CONSTITUTIONAL

QUALIFICATIONS

INFORMAL QUALIFICATIONS

PACKET PG. 4: QUALIFICATIONS

INFORMAL QUALIFICATIONS FORMAL/CONSTITUTIONAL

QUALIFICATIONS

House –

25 yrs

7 yrs citizen residency in district representing

Senate

30 yrs

9 yrs citizen

Residency in state representing

Race

Gender

Occupation

Education

1.

2.

6

TH

PERIOD SEATS:

Education and Labor Committee Chair: Drew

Mitchner

Energy and Commerce Committee Chair:

Hannah Katz

3.

Judiciary Committee Chair:

Parker Malachowsky

2.

1.

Everyone else:

Sit in the area of the room you normally are in.

Make sure you seat one extra person on the left side of the seating arrangement

3.

5

TH

PERIOD SEATS:

1.

Education and Labor Committee Chair:

2.

Kate Kesner

Energy and Commerce Committee Chair:

Randy Kenyon

4.

Judiciary Committee Chair:

Lexi Greenberg

2.

1.

Everyone else:

Sit in the area of the room you normally are in.

Make sure you seat one extra person on the left side of the seating arrangement

BLOCK 3/5-6/14

Please get out the following:

Unit 2.2 Packet

Pencil

Highlighter

Calendar

CHECK OUT

SEATS!

PACKET PG. 4-6: JIGSAW

1.

15 minutes:

Divide up the tables/charts on pages 4-

6 among your new table members – 5 total tables/charts.

2.

Teach/share tables to partners.

HW: Read 12.1-12.4 and complete pages in the packet.

1.

PACKET PG. 4:

CONSTITUENTS

Individual Constituents – help them with federal agencies, create jobs, answer complaints, and provide information.

2.

Business and Interest Groupsintroduce legislation that is beneficial to them, intervene with regulatory agencies, secure federal grants, and secure federal contracts.

3.

Entire District/State – secure federal projects, create jobs through federal grants and contracts, support policies and legislation that is good for the entire district or state.

PACKET PG. 4: QUALIFICATIONS

FORMAL/CONSTITUTIONAL

QUALIFICATIONS

House –

25 yrs

7 yrs citizen residency in district representing

Senate

30 yrs

9 yrs citizen

Residency in state representing

INFORMAL QUALIFICATIONS

Race

Gender

Occupation

Education

PACKET, PG. 5:

INCUMBENTS

Current office holder who is running for reelection. 97% of the time they WIN!

They have the experience, funds and bragging rights (like money from the “pork barrel”, or treasury, they used for projects)

PACKET PG. 5: HOUSE (H.A.) VS. THE SENATE (S.A.)

HOUSE OF

REPRESENTATIVES

SIMILARITIES SENATE

Terms of Office

Election to Office

Qualifications for office

Deliberations and

Floor Debates

Leadership Roles

PACKET PG. 5: HOUSE (H.A.) VS. THE SENATE (S.A.)

SIMILARITIES SENATE

Terms of Office

HOUSE OF

REPRESENTATIVES

2 years 6 years

Election to Office

Qualifications for office directly

(435 total, based on state and district population size – Census Bureau stats every 10 years)

Popular Sovereignty

25 yrs old, US citizen, resident Residency and citizenship requirements

Directly

(100 total, 2 per state, 53

Dems., 45 Rep., 2 indep.)

30yrs old, US cit 9 yrs, resident

Deliberations and

Floor Debates

Leadership Roles Speaker,

Maj/Min leaders and whips

Debate can be open

Rules are same

Maj/Min leaders and whips

Senate Majority leader

A delegate to Congress is a non-voting member of the United States House of Representatives, who is elected from a U.S. territory or from Washington, D.C.

, to a two-year term. While unable to vote in the full House, a non-voting delegate may vote in a House committee of which the delegate is a member.

PACKET PG. 6: LEADERSHIP ROLES

LEADERSHIP ROLE POWERS & RESPONSIBILITIES WHO IS IN THAT POSITION

NOW?

Name and Party Affiliation

Speaker of the House

Majority and Minorities

Leaders

House

Senate Majority Leader

Senate Minority Leader

Majority and Minority

Whips

House & Senate

PACKET PG. 6: LEADERSHIP ROLES

LEADERSHIP ROLE

CHECK OUT PG. 209

POWERS & RESPONSIBILITIES WHO IS IN THAT POSITION

NOW?

Name and Party Affiliation

John Boehner (R) – Ohio

Speaker of the House

Majority and Minority

Leaders

House

Presides over the House, administrative duties, hands bills to committees, brings legislation to the floor for debate and vote, committee assignments.

Manage legislation on the house floor

(selected by the House – usually represents the majority party, in line for presidency after the VP)

Maj – Eric Cantor (R) – Virginia

Min – Nancy Pelosi (D) - California

(elected by their parties, majority is 2 nd in command and minority is 1 st in command)

Harry Reid (D) – Nevada

Senate Majority Leader

Senate Minority Leader

Selected by the Senate. Essentially same duties as the Speaker although will also help establish rules for debate since Senate doesn’t have

Rules Committee.

Leader of the opposition in the Senate – plays same role as House Minority leader. Organizes opposition and policy agenda and voting.

(under the Vice President, who is

President of the Senate and the

President Pro Tempore, who is the senior senator of the maj. Party)

Mitch McConnell (R) - Kentucky

Majority and Minority

Whips

House & Senate

Assistant floor leaders, responsible for informing and persuading party members.

Kevin McCarthy (R) – California

Steny Hoyer (D) – Maryland

Richard Durbin (D) – Illinois

John Cornyn (R) - Texas

PACKET PG. 6: COMMITTEES

TYPE OF COMMITTEE KEY FUNCTIONS CONCRETE EXAMPLE

Standing Committee

Subcommittees

Select/Special Committees

Joint Committees

Conference Committees

PACKET PG. 6: COMMITTEES

TYPE OF COMMITTEE

Standing Committee

Subcommittees

KEY FUNCTIONS

Always exist from Congress to

Congress. Responsible for reviewing bills that deal with specific policy.

Responsible for gathering information on bills throughout the hearing process.

CONCRETE EXAMPLE

See Page 210

Energy. Judicial. Labor. Homeland

Security

Subcommittee for Homeland

Security

Select/Special Committees

Joint Committees

Conference Committees

Responsible for creating legislation of investigating a specific issue as designated by

Congress.

Select Committee on Energy

Independence and Global

Warming.

Responsible for gathering information or investigating specific issues. Has members from both House and Senate.

Responsible for reconciling

(fixing the problems/differences) between two similar bills.

Joint Committee on Taxation.

Budget Resolution Conference

Committee

PACKET PG. 7:

POWER OF THE PURSE

The power to raise taxes and appropriate (assign) that tax money to programs. All appropriation bills must originate in the House.

Checks and Balances

Power of the Purse is on example of how Congress can direct the President and keep him “in check”. The Senate must also approve all Presidential appointments. Congress can also override a president’s veto with a 2/3rds vote in both houses.

Congress is also responsible for establishing lower federal courts and the number of federal judges.

PACKET PG. 7:

YOUR CURRENT REPRESENTATIVES

Who are CA’s US Senators?

What party do they belong to?

How long have they been in the

Senate?

When are they up for reelection?

Who is your member of the

House of Representatives?

What party do they belong to?

How long have they served in the House?

YOUR CURRENT REPRESENTATIVES

Who are your US Senators?

What party do they belong to?

How long have they been in the

Senate?

When are they up for reelection?

Barbara Boxer – democrat, since 1993,

2017

Diane Feinstein – democrat, since 1993,

2019

Who is your member of the

House of Representatives?

What party do they belong to?

How long have they served in the House?

Anna Eshoo –democrat, since 1993, 2014

(CA 18 th District)

Mike Honda – democrat, since 2001, 2014

(CA 17 th District)

YOUR CURRENT REPRESENTATIVES

Our district

T HE L EGISLATIVE P ROCESS

C OMMITTEE W ORK

Objective: Understand how committee work on bills in the Senate influences how individual members legislate.

C OMMITTEE W ORK IN THE L EGISLATIVE P ROCESS

 The committee chair is the member of the majority party who has served the longest in the Senate. The SENIORITY RULE usually refers to the longest serving member of the committee but for this task use Senate membership. The ranking member is the member of the minority party who has served longest.

 Directions: Use all the materials provided and follow the directions of your committee chair to help you through the process. Each committee should have a final version of a bill with amendments ready to hand in to the teacher.

 TIME – Each committee has 45 minutes (or until the end of the class period) to create a final version of their bill for reporting.

READ THE DIRECTIONS COMPLETELY AND CAREFULLY FIRST! REMEMBER

YOU ARE THE SENATOR YOU’VE BEEN GIVEN, NOT YOURSELF!!!!!

FRIDAY 3/7/14

Please get out the following:

Unit 2.2 Packet

Role card from simulation

Any other simulation work.

T HE L EGISLATIVE P ROCESS

C OMMITTEE W ORK

Objective: Understand how committee work on bills in the Senate influences how individual members legislate.

C OMMITTEE W ORK IN THE L EGISLATIVE P ROCESS

 The committee chair is the member of the majority party who has served the longest in the Senate. The SENIORITY RULE usually refers to the longest serving member of the committee but for this task use Senate membership. The ranking member is the member of the minority party who has served longest.

 Directions: Use all the materials provided and follow the directions of your committee chair to help you through the process. Each committee should have a final version of a bill with amendments ready to hand in to the teacher.

 TIME – Each committee has 45 minutes (or until the end of the class period) to create a final version of their bill for reporting.

READ THE DIRECTIONS COMPLETELY AND CAREFULLY FIRST! REMEMBER

YOU ARE THE SENATOR YOU’VE BEEN GIVEN, NOT YOURSELF!!!!!

MONDAY 3/10/14

Please get out the following:

Unit 2.2 Packet

Pencil

Highlighter

Calendar

Text book

LEADERSHIP ROLES

CHECK OUT PG. 209

A delegate to Congress is a non-voting member of the United States House of Representatives, who is elected from a U.S. territory or from Washington, D.C.

, to a two-year term. While unable to vote in the full House, a non-voting delegate may vote in a House committee of which the delegate is a member.

YOUR CURRENT REPRESENTATIVES

Our district

1.

2.

3.

TECHNICALLY, HOW A BILL BECOMES A LAW

Member of Congress Introduces

B ILL

Bill is referred to a Committee by

S PEAKER OF THE H OUSE and/or

S ENATE M AJORITY L EADER *

Bill is referred to C OMMITTEE * –

Committee Chair can:

Kill the bill

P IGEONHOLE THE B ILL ( PUT AT

THE BOTTOM OF THE

AGENDA / EXTENDS DISCUSSION )

C ONSIDER THE B ILL

WHAT HAPPENS AGAIN IN COMMITTEE?

1.

2.

3.

Committee refers bill to SUBCOMMITTEE *

Subcommittee holds hearings and investigates

Subcommittee reports bill back to Committee

4.

Committee decides on the bill* – options:

Pigeonhole the bill

Kill the bill

Vote on the bill as is

Revise bill in M ARK UP S ESSION (T HIS IS WHAT YOU DID )

AND THEN?

1.

Committee reports the bill to R ULES C OMMITTEE *:

Places bill on calendar

Determines type of debate – OPEN or CLOSED

2.

Bill reaches the floor of the House*

A MENDMENTS are proposed and voted on the floor of the House

G ERMAINE (must be same issue as the bill)

3.

4.

F LOOR V OTES on the amendments and Bill

 Different type of votes determined as process goes along

Entire House votes on the final bill

1.

2.

GOODNESS! I’M STILL NOT A LAW?!

Speaker signs the Bill and sends it to the Senate

Bill repeats the entire process in the Senate Chamber*

(usually Senate has been crafting own version of the bill at

3.

the same time)

No rules committee in the Senate

Open debate always with occasional restrictions

F ILIBUSTER (tactics used to delay passage of a bill, like lengthy speeches) is permitted

Senate votes on passage of the Bill

Bill is referred to C ONFERENCE C OMMITTEE *– if it is different version from the House version

THIS IS GETTING RIDICULOUS?!?

2.

3.

1.

House and Senate vote on the reconciled version of the Bill

Bill is printed in final form

Bill is sent to the President

Presidential action*:

1.

Signs bill- Bill becomes a Law

2.

3.

1.

Does not sign- 10 Day Rule- Pocket Veto

(If Congress is out of session within 10 days of sending the Bill- Bill is Dead

Veto the Bill – Bill is returned to Congress

1.

2.

Veto is overridden in the house

Veto is overridden in the Senate

1.

Bill becomes a Law

(YAY FINALLY!)

LEGISLATIVE PROCESS: PG. 215

POLITICALLY, HOW A BILL BECOMES A LAW:

 Read Politics, Power and You pg. 220-221

 What factors influenced YOU during the committee simulation?

 In a floor debate, how might the following affect your decision.

 filibuster

 your party affiliation

 your status as an incumbent

 (lets say we’re about to have an election)

EUQ: REFLECTING ON THE LEGISLATIVE

PROCESS

Summative Reflection – Civic Participation

Please respond to our second essential question in paragraph form in the space provided. Draw on the various assignments, activities and readings we have done over the last week including:

Proficient:

Your 2.2 guided reading packet and any additional notes you took during class

The Constitution

The Senate committee simulation – see your notes on the front

Power, Politics and You pg. 220-221

Advanced

Federalist # 10

Federalist #51

What factors influence how individual members of Congress legislate?

Download