Scavenger Hunt Search Patterns Forensic Science Laboratory University College Chemistry 113 Introduction Investigating a crime scene requires a careful and trained eye coupled with a thorough knowledge and proper implementation of the techniques of evidence collection and preservation. The quality of an on-site investigation and evidence collection process often plays a pivotal role in the outcome of any legal proceedings that may follow. The goal of crime scene investigation should, therefore, be to obtain the maximum amount of information from the site in such a way that the quality and integrity of the information is essentially unimpeachable in a court room. The information gained at the site should ultimately lead to a rational and credible explanation of the events leading to the observed crime scene. It is through practice and careful consideration that skills of observation and interpretation are refined. Already sweating though it was just nine in the morning, Amelia Sachs pushed through a stand of tall grass. She was walking the strip search — what the crime scene people called it — an S-shaped pattern. Nothing. She bent her head to the speaker/mike pinned to her navy-blue uniform blouse. "Portable five eight eight five. Can't find anything, Central. You have a further-to?" Through crisp static the dispatcher replied, "Nothing more on location, 5885. But one thing. . . . the RP said he hoped the vic was dead. K." "Say again, Central." "The RP said he hoped the victim was dead. For his sake. K." "K." Hoped the vic was dead? Sachs struggled over a wilted chain-link and searched another empty lot. Nothing. The Bone Collector By, Jeffrey Deaver The manner in which a crime scene is investigated needs to follow well established procedures that have been developed over time to avoid the destruction or contamination of important information contained within the site and to provide for the safe transport of evidence to the laboratory for further analysis. At a crime scene, there is often a strong tendency in the excitement of the moment to rush in and begin the exploration of the site – searching for quick answers. Bystanders, initial police and rescue workers, officials, and others with very good intentions may severely compromise the integrity of a site within a remarkably small amount of time. Thus, one of the first requirements of crime scene investigation is to protect and preserve the site from destruction or contamination. Once this has been accomplished, the careful and methodical documentation of the site along with complete evidence collection can begin. If done properly, a crime scene investigation can often supply the missing “what”, “how” and “who” answers that are needed to solve the forensic mysteries encountered. Scavenger Hunt Inquiry Based Laboratory 1 Copyright James T. Spencer 2009 Objectives In this laboratory experiment, you will be developing what you perceive to be the most successful pattern for exploring a 12 ft x 12 ft crime scene. Scavenger Hunt Search Pattern Inquiry Based Lab You need to begin this project by designing a search pattern you believe will be the most successful. You want to include: 1. 2. 3. 4. a sketch of the search pattern to be followed, the number of people involved a written description of how the search will proceed. A sketch of the grid needs to be drawn including: measurements, and photos taken of each article of evidence before collection (this can be done on a phone). 5. All collected articles must be turned in for credit. The following thirteen items will be included in your provided 12 ft x 12 ft grid: Plastic heart shaped bead Plastic army man Bouncy ball Jack (from the game jacks) Eraser top Socket to a wrench set Birthday candle String of beads from a necklace Black and yellow cordage Cigarette butt Torn cloth Broken glass Blood stain Notes: Scavenger Hunt Inquiry Based Laboratory 2 Upon return to the classroom, you will be handed a crime scene dossier. You will need to look through the evidence collected and decide which items would be most applicable to your crime scene dossier. Your typed discussion must include applications of what you have learned to a variety of crime scenes. Your team must include: Exploration of different techniques you might employ if searching indoors versus outdoors Identify what changes you would make to your search if the crime scene is made larger or smaller Discuss how you would alter the plan for a ‘wet’ search instead of a ‘dry’ search (this could mean a water search rather than a land search OR trying to search in the rain instead of on a dry day) Reflect back on your experience, and determine if you would repeat the search the same way, or if you have discovered a ‘better’ solution to the problem. Explore what you felt your team did successfully and what alterations should be considered Depending on preference, each team may submit a single formal report, or individual reports. Regardless of the option you choose, everyone needs a copy of the completed lab for their portfolios The reports should include the search design, the formal and rough sketches, the photography log, with photos (electronically submitted), the analysis of assigned crime scene relevance, and a discussion of the application of this skill. During the outdoor work, utilization of a rubric will be performed by Mr. Donohue. A sample rubric is shown below. A peer evaluation rubric will also be completed by each group member. Scavenger Hunt Inquiry Based Laboratory 3 Scavenger Hunt Search Pattern Post-lab Assignment Name Instructor Laboratory Section Lab Period Dossier # ___________________________ List the collected items from the scavenger hunt that would be applicable to your dossier. With each included piece of evidence, record a detailed explanation listing how an investigator/lawyer can utilize that piece of evidence successfully. Scavenger Hunt Inquiry Based Laboratory 4 Scavenger Hunt Search Pattern Pre-lab Assignment Name Instructor Laboratory Section Lab Period 1) Designing a search pattern you believe will be the most successful. a. Sketch of the search pattern to be followed b. The number of people involved, with job descriptions c. Written description of how the search will proceed d. What job assignment do you have? Scavenger Hunt Inquiry Based Laboratory 5