Iconic images

advertisement
LEARNING
ACTIVITY
Teacher material
Iconic images
Activity Plan
Part 1
What makes an iconic image?
Introduction to the topic: prepare a selection of fairly recent images that are
familiar to your students. These could be on laminated cards or online. Ideas for
iconic images include: a Coca-Cola advert, the 11 September 2001 attack on New
York, the opening of the Berlin Wall, the first man in space or the moon-landing.
Also include some images that might not be viewed as iconic. Discuss in small
groups of students, and then as a class, what makes an image iconic. Draw out:
 They are representative of something (and could therefore be used as
historical evidence)
 They are symbolic (their meaning extends beyond the subject matter they
represent)
 They encapsulate something of the essential characteristics of the time (the
zeitgeist) in a very succinct way that remains in the public memory long after
the events to which they relate.
And ask students to make a note of these criteria.
Main activity: Ask students to work in small groups to think of images that would
be iconic of the First World War (or the topic being studied). Write each of these
images on a post-it note and display all the post-it notes around the class.
Students silently study the post-it notes, moving any duplicates together, and
moving any images that are related close to each other. When all students have
viewed all the post-it notes, invite comment. Require students to justify the
comments they are making in support of, or against, an image being described as
iconic. Refer them back to the criteria to help them make judgements.
To conclude: introduce students to the next lesson.
Students will use criteria to select images from textbooks, Historiana and other
sites that they regard as iconic in order to present a museum exhibition on the
topic of World War 1 (or the topic being studied). The purpose of this exhibition
will be to present World War 1 (or other topic) to members of the public. The
images they select will need to be contextualised with captions. In order to write
these, students will need to apply the knowledge they have acquired about World
War 1 and to undertake further research where they find that they still have gaps
in their knowledge.
Students should work before the next lesson to find iconic images on Historiana
and other sites, using the ideas from the class discussions and new ideas that
emerge. They should also revise their learning of the topic they have been
studying so that they are ready to start setting the images in context.
(Alternatively this can be done as a second lesson.)
www.historiana.eu
Iconic images | Helen Snelson | Page 1 of 3
LEARNING
ACTIVITY
Part 2
What are the iconic images of the First World War? (or other topic studied)
Over the course of a single lesson, or more depending on what is desirable /
possible, students put together a museum display with the title: ‘What are the
iconic images of World War 1?’ (or topic being studied). This could be in the
classroom, in a public space, or online. Small groups of students present the
iconic images with captions. These captions should give the historical context to
each image and a short justification (referencing the criteria developed in the
previous lesson) as to why the image is iconic. Students should also prepare an
introductory panel to their exhibition, which explains what is meant by an iconic
image in the context of their topic.
Depending on time and the nature of the group, the teacher may want to give a
twist to the development of the exhibition part way through. For example, the
teacher, as museum curator, could make it clear that funders have changed. The
new funders are very keen to avoid any images which are iconic to just one
country; they require the images to be iconic across Europe. Such timely
intervention can be a good device to enable students to rethink and re-justify;
moving their thinking to a greater depth and breadth. It enables students to see
that any selection of sources as evidence is an interpretation that is defined by its
purpose and audience.
Assessment opportunities
This sort of activity lends itself to supportive and critical assessment by peers,
teachers and possibly the wider community. The students’ exhibitions should be
judged for:
 How well they demonstrate an understanding of what makes an iconic image.
 How clearly they present their chosen topic using iconic images. (Is there
sufficient depth and breadth for an interested and intelligent non-expert to
learn?)
 How clearly and accurately they have placed the images in their historical
context (and therefore how much they have learnt about the topic).
 How well they have designed and executed their exhibition. (Have they
worked well as a team and presented a piece of work in which they can take
pride?)
It would also be a good idea to invite groups to write personal reflections on the
activity. This would include their views on the working process they undertook and
also the final product. A key question for self-reflection would be: ‘What would we
not understand about World War 1 (or other topic) if we only viewed your
exhibition?’ This is not a punitive question, as of course the exhibition will be an
interpretation of the past. It is a question designed to make students explicitly
aware of just that. By the process of selection an interpretation is made. By the
process of selecting iconic images, there may be significant gaps in the story
presented. This should provide material for an excellent plenary discussion. For
example: to what extent do iconic images cause, or at least reinforce, the gap
between the knowledge of the public and the knowledge of the academic historian
about a topic? Does this matter?
Source:
www.historiana.eu
Iconic images | Helen Snelson | Page 2 of 3
LEARNING
ACTIVITY
1. IWM Collection Ref: Q11586: British 55th (West Lancashire) Division
troops blinded by tear gas await treatment at an Advanced Dressing
Station near Bethune during the Battle of Estaires, 10 April 1918, part of
the German offensive in Flanders.
www.historiana.eu
Iconic images | Helen Snelson | Page 3 of 3
Download