Session 3: Entrepreneurship theories & Reasons for Growth Session plan Need for theories Classification of theories Entrepreneurship theories Reasons for growth in entrepreneurship Why so many theories? Growing emphasis on entrepreneurship development for achieving economic growth & tackling problems Demolition of the contention that entrepreneurs are born & cannot be made Identification & development of potential entrepreneurs require careful studies from different perspectives such as economic, psychological, cultural, etc. These theories provide a limited yet different view to understand the ‘entrepreneurial phenomenon’ Classification of entrepreneurship theories Entrepreneurship is an evolved process. With the advancement of science and technology it has undergone metamorphosis change and emerged as a critical input for socio-economic development. Various writers have developed various theories on entrepreneurship and popularized the concept among the common people. The theories propounded by them can be categorized as underEconomic theories Psychological theories Sociological theories Cultural theories/ Anthropological theories Integrated theories Economic theories Entrepreneurship and economic development are interdependent. Economic development takes place when a country' real rational income increases overall period of time wherein the role of entrepreneurs is an integral part Mark Casson – The demand for entrepreneurship stems from the need to adjust to the change. The supply of entrepreneurs is limited due to scarcity of requisite personal qualities. Identifying the potential entrepreneurs is crucial. Leibenstein – Role of an entrepreneur is A) input completion – improving the efficiency of available resources B) Gap filling – arbitrage function ECONOMIC THEORIES Schumpeter’s Theory of Innovation Schumpeter’s theory of entrepreneurship is a pioneering work of economic development. development in his sense, implies that carrying out of new combination of entrepreneurship is basically a creative activity. Entrepreneur is a catalyst that disrupts the stationery circular flow of the economy by innovations. 1- The introduction of new goods, that is the one with which consumers are not yet familiar, of a new quality. 2- The introduction of new method of production 3- The opening of new market 4- the conquest of new source of supply of raw material 5-The carrying out of new organization Schumpeterian theory cont.. 1- Distinction between invention and innovation Schumpeter makes a distinction between innovation and invention. Invention means creation of new things and innovation means applicable of new things onto practical use 2- emphasis on entrepreneurial function- Schumpeter has given emphasis on the role of entrepreneurial functions in economic development. in his views, development means basic transformation of the economy that is brought about by entrepreneurial functions. 3- presentation of disequilibrium situation through entrepreneurial activity-the entrepreneurial activity represents a disequilibrium situation, a dynamic phenomenon and a break from the routine or a circular flow or tendency towards equilibrium. 4- entrepreneurialism dream and the will to found a private kingdomthe motives of creating things and applying these things into practice inspire the entrepreneur to undertake innovation. Harvard School Theory Entrepreneurship is a purposeful activity that initiates, maintains or develops a profit oriented business in interaction with the internal situation of the business or with the economic, political & social circumstances surrounding the business. Two activities – 1. organizational or coordination 2. sensitivity to the environmental changes Psychological Theories Psychological theories centre's around the psychological characteristic so the individual in a society. Psychological characteristics affect the supply of entrepreneurs in the society. McClelland – N-Ach theory Theory of personal resourcefulness: Kanungo & Misra: The root of entrepreneurial process can be traced to the initiative taken by some individuals to go beyond the existing way of life. Supply of entrepreneurship depends on two factors Cognitive function: emotions, inner feelings, thoughts, motivations Human aspect: will to power, excel, achieve, change, innovate Psychological Theories cont.. Maslow & Alderfer: Maslow’s need hierarchy theory: Human beings have five basic levels of needs such as 1. Physiological – survival needs 2. Safety & security – security, stability, insurance, etc 3. Social – affiliation, belongingness 4. Esteem – egoistic needs- respect, recognition, etc 5. Self actualization – realizing one’s potential fully Psychological Theories cont.. Alderfer’s ERG theory: 1. existence needs – combination of physiological & safety needs 2. relatedness needs – social & esteem needs which are derived from other people 3. growth needs - self actualization needs For proper development of entrepreneurship, relatedness and growth needs are more important. Sociological theories Sociological Theories :Explain how sociological factors accelerate the growth of entrepreneurs. The forces of custom, values, the rigidity or flexibility of changing social status, acceptance of new ideas, freedom to exercise intellectual curiosity are determined by socio-cultural values which act as channels for economic action that gives birth to entrepreneurship Theory of religious beliefs Theory of social change Theory of religious beliefs Weber: Religious beliefs exogenously drive entrepreneurial spirit through encouraging or discouraging intensive occupational pursuit, accumulation of assets, etc. Few religions like hinduism, buddhism, Islam do not encourage entrepreneurship. He emphasized that entrepreneurial energies are exogenous supplied by means of religious beliefs Spirit of Capitalism is encouraged only when ‘Capitalism’ as an economic system in which economic freedom and private enterprise are glorified, so also the entrepreneurial culture. Adventurous Spirit- Weber also made a distinction between spirit of capitalism and adventurous spirit. According to him, the former is influenced by the strict discipline whereas the latter is affected by free force of impulse. Entrepreneurship culture is influenced by both these factors. Theory of Social Change Everett E. Hagen, in his theory of social change states how traditional society transforms into technical advanced society The theory states that the entrepreneur’s creativity as the key element of social transformation and economic growth. Interrelationship among physical environment, social structure, personality and culture plays an important part in transformation of society Economic Growth is a product of social change and political change : According to Hagen, most of the economic theories of underdevelopment are inadequate. He rejected the idea that the solution to economic development lies in imitating western technology. Hagen’s theory of social change According to Hagen entrepreneur is a creative personality who is interested in accelerating the change and is driven by achievement motivation Hagen tried to explain why this achievement motivation (explained by McClelland)varies between societies and their classes and strata. In traditional societies the status of individuals is fixed. Children learn to act according to established norms. If by external influences a new group gains power, the status of the old elite is challenged and weakened. The insecurity and frustration leads to changed behaviour which has consequences on the family structure. Children tend to become dissatisfied with the society and readily accept new values. In time, they become innovative personalities. These persons may become dominant groups causing economic development. Historic shift as a factor of initiating change Entrepreneurial growth has been very gradual and may or may not occur in the same generation but it is more likely to be an intergeneration change. Historic shift is the crucial force which has brought about social change which leads to the emergence of entrepreneurial class from different castes and communities. The forces of disruption against the stability of traditional society should be powerful to have creative personalities. Class relations change with different stages of development such as feudal society (landlords & tenants), capitalist society (capitalists & workers), etc. Disadvantaged or minority group is mostly the source of entrepreneurship. Withdrawal of status is the causal factor for emergence of creative personality. Hence, Hagen’s creative personality is the a mixture of Schumpeter’s innovation and McClelland's high need for achievement. CULTURAL THEORIES Advocates of cultural theories point out that entrepreneurship is the product of culture. Entrepreneurial talents come from cultural values and cultural system embedded into the cultural environment. Hoeselitz’s Theory :Hoeselitz explains that the supply of entrepreneurship is governed by cultural factors, and culturally minority groups are the spark-plugs of entrepreneurial and economic development. In many countries, entrepreneurs have emerged from a particular socio-economic class. He emphasized the role of culturally marginally groups like Jews and the Greeks in medieval Europe, the Chinese in South Africa and Indian in east Africa in promoting economic development. Cultural theories cont.. Thomas Cohram: Cultural values, role expectations & role sanctions play an imp role in process of entrepreneurship development. Entrepreneurs are seen as representing society’s ‘model’ personality rather than as deviant or super normal individuals. It is moulded by prevailing child rearing practices, educational practices & culture. Entrepreneurs own attitude towards his occupation and the role expectations held by sanctioning groups are determined by society’s values. DRUCKER ON ENTREPRENEURSHIP Peter F. Drucker: an entrepreneur is one who always searches for change, responds to it and exploits it as an opportunity.” He laid emphasis on two important factors – innovation and resource- that led to emergence of entrepreneurship. Innovation is the real hub of entrepreneurship which creates resource. A thing is regarded as resource when its economic value is recognized. Entrepreneurship is not confined to big businesses and economic institutions, it is equally important to small business and non-economic institutions. Entrepreneurship behavior rather than personality trait is more important to enhance entrepreneurship The foundation of entrepreneurship lies in concept and theory rather than in intuition. Drucker contd… Thus, Drucker has given his views that “an entrepreneur need not be a capitalist or an owner. A banker who mobilizes other’s money and allocates it in areas of higher yield is very much an entrepreneur though he is not the owner of the money. Integrated approach Udai Pareek and T.V.Rao: Few sequential propositions lead to entrepreneurship: 1. Need for motive – main thrust behind action 2. long term involvement & reinforcement in action 3. Resources – cognition, social & material inputs 4. Socio-political system which reinforces the individual needs to establish, develop, maintain or expand his business activity This approach tries to synthesize psychological & sociological theories. Summary of different theories Theories Content Casson (Economic) Need for bringing out change Leibenstein (economic) Gap filling Harvard (economic) Purposeful & profit oriented activity Schumpeter (economic) Innovations McClelland (psychological) Need for achievement Maslow & Alderfer(psychological) Need hierarchy Weber (social) Religion Hegen Social change & disadvantaged groups Cochran (cultural) Role expectations & social sanctions Hoselitz Cultural factors Drucker Innovations Pareek & Rao Integrated approach Reasons for the growth of entrepreneurship Change in industry structure: concentration on core competencies Lower entry barriers Technological development shifting towards bigger role to small firms Deregulation & privatization Formation of new business communities (eg alibaba.com) Increasing demand for variety, special needs Growth of service sector Increasing flow of information Reasons for the growth of entrepreneurship Easier access to resources Entrepreneurial education Strengthening of IPR Changing image of entrepreneur in society Rising dissatisfaction at job Recognition of small firms’ role in job creation Recognition that large organizations are not conducive to self-actualization Increase in media coverage The Future of Entrepreneurship Common aspects of entrepreneurship Risk Taking Creativity Independence Rewards Increased interest in entrepreneurship: The Future of Entrepreneurship Some Entrepreneurship courses have been started by universities Entrepreneurship cells to incubate new businesses are coming up Government support: Creating Infrastructure (roads, communication, power) Tax breaks (e.g. Small scale industry units) Motivation and public support through media and support groups Within large organizations Intrapreneurship is coming up as a way to retain talent and spur innovation as well as develop new businesses to deal with hyper-competition Promotion & Dev of Entre Stimulatory activities: Entrepreneurial education Planned publicity about b opportunities Identification of potential entrepreneurs Motivational training to new entre Help & guidance in selective products , etc. Provision of techno-economic information Creating entrepreneurial forums Recognition to entrepreneurs