Strategic Public Relations Plan SK-II Damage Control In China Submitted by PR J453 Team 5 School of Journalism and Communication University of Oregon Niki Naboulsi – naboulsi@uoregon.edu Lindsey Lake – lake@uoreogn.edu Rachel Gehr -gehr@uoregon.edu Melodie Seble -- melodie@uoregon.ed Allie Hawes – hawes@uoregon.edu Background Industry and Environment Proctor & Gamble Co. (P&G) is a Fortune 500 American multinational corporation founded in 1837 that produces a wide range of consumer goods including cosmetic products, health care items, pet supplies and baby care items. P&G cosmetic brands include CoverGirl, Max Factor and Olay. P&G entered the mainland Chinese market in 1988. China is one of the most populous countries in the world, and is one of the fastest growing economies in the world. There are 1.3 billion Chinese citizens, which amount to approximately 560 million consumers. After the Maoist period ended in 1976, in which cosmetics were discouraged, the cosmetics industry in China grew rapidly, with annual growth rates of 10.2% between 1997 and 2005. By 2005, national sales of cosmetics in China reached US$8.6 billion. Additionally, by 2007, P&G sales amounted to 18 percent of China’s cosmetics and toiletries market. In 1991, P&G acquired the cosmetic brand Max Factor, which had developed a high-priced specialty product called SK-II. The brand had become popular in Japan since its launch there in 1980. SK-II products began to be distributed by P&G China in 1999. By 2006, SK-II had 97 sales counters in China, which accounted for seven percent of the brand’s global sales. In 2005, the SK-II brand suffered from an embarrassing lawsuit. A consumer purchased a facial product from the brand, then claimed to have an allergic reaction to the product. In addition, the consumer stated she purchased the product solely due to an endorsement of a well-known Hong Kong actress, who claimed the SK-II product reduced wrinkles. P&G was sued for false advertising, because the advertisement failed to mention the product “could” reduce wrinkles. The court case was ultimately dismissed, but P&G was issued a fine and was embarrassed. SK-II product crisis On September 14, 2006, P&G faced a crisis when the National Quality Inspection Department of the State General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine (AQSIQ), a state-run agency, released test results of SK-II products directly to Chinese state-controlled media. The agency announced that nine SK-II skin care products contained chromium and neodymium, chemical elements present in the earth’s crust that exist in some cosmetics, and which may cause skin allergies in larger concentrations. Chromium and neodymium are banned in Chinese products. One SK-II product, Whitening Source Pan-Cake, contained 5.20 and 4.20 mg/kg of chromium and neodymium, respectively, and the other eight products contained between .40 and .02 mg/kg of chromium. One product contained .02 mg/kg of neodymium. AQSIQ had not tested for these elements when it originally certified SK-II in 1998. P&G responded to the AQSIQ’s announcement by denying that SK-II was harmful to users. P&G stated that the levels of chromium and neodymium in the products were not high enough to cause health worries. However, the company declared that it would communicate with government departments to protect the interests of the customers and that the affected SK-II products could be returned. Stating that the AQSIQ’s findings were incorrect, P&G requested a retest of the products, despite warning that all P&G products would be barred from sale if more banned substances were found in SK-II products. This challenge of the Chinese government’s authority marks an important problem for P&G. Chinese media, state and military are strictly controlled by the government, the Communist Party of China. The government is the highest authority in China and has a great deal of power, and therefore is not often challenged by Chinese citizens or companies. The Chinese government is highly nationalistic and does not encourage challenges to state authority. Additionally, a major external factor that affected P&G was the relationship between the Chinese government and those of Japan in particular, as well as those of other countries such as the United States of America. Due to “historical grievances” in addition to a 2006 reduction of Chinese exports to Japan, Chinese authority was tense toward Japanese products. The day after P&G’s crisis began, on September 15, 2006, the company outlined the four conditions under which customers may receive funds for purchases of SK-II products, which were produced in Japan. The four conditions were that the product must be one of the nine, that the consumers had to have a history of skin allergies and produce proof from a doctor, that an original receipt of purchase was required, and that the product must contain more than two-thirds of the original amount. In addition, customers had to wait a month for a refund and had to sign what has been called the “King Clause,” which states that the SK-II products are not harmful to their health and are not faulty. P&G did not publicly announce a recall of SK-II in China. On September 21, three additional SK-II products were found to contain the banned substances. The next day, on September 22, P&G stopped all sales and operations at its Chinese SK-II sales booths. However, Singapore’s Health Sciences Authority announced on September 23 that the products in question did not pose safety concerns because the banned substances were present only in trace amounts. Although this did not change the situation in China, it reinforces the theory that there were more issues involved than just the safety of the products. It is possible that the Chinese government used this matter to highlight its authority in political and business situations, though to allege so would be dangerous for P&G and would risk further sanctions against the brand. Customers, in general, were outraged as a result of the SK-II crisis. P&G repeatedly changed its product return policy, and as the days passed increasing numbers of consumers tried to return the products. SK-II sales booths were overwhelmed due to the large number of angry customers. The return centers were moved to hotel conference rooms to reduce security issues. On September 22, one week after the crisis began, P&G stopped accepting SK-II product returns altogether. Trends in Opinions and Attitudes As of the end of September 2006, P&G China was largely regarded as “arrogant” due to the SK-II crisis. This was due to the lack of decisive action from the company. Customers who had bought the affected products but who could not get refunds were furious. SK-II, which originated in Japan and was produced there, caused additional tension in the Chinese market due to historical strain between the two cultures. In addition, P&G was seen as rebellious when it denied the state-run AQSIQ’s results and requested a retest. Situation Analysis As of the end of September 2006, the SK-II brand of Proctor & Gamble Co. faced a crisis situation in the Chinese cosmetics market. Due to a recall of certain products that contained trace amounts of banned substances, as well as a poorly handled return policy, P&G was under fire from Chinese media, government and angry consumers. The company’s challenge is to regain the good will and trust of the Chinese state and consumers, and to clean up the SK-II products and rebuild the brand image. One potential difficulty lies in persuading the Chinese market that the expensive, highquality SK-II products are safe and worth buying. A larger difficulty is to regain the trust of the consumers, who, culturally, have a long memory of crises such as these. Additionally, P&G will have to work with the Chinese government to get the banned products certified for sale. Core Problem The core problem is the mistrust of SK-II and P&G by Chinese consumers and government, which if not resolved will result in permanent damage to the brand images and loss of revenue in the Chinese market. Goal Loyal and new Chinese customers are satisfied with SK-II products and value P&G’s customer service; P&G maintains a positive, healthy relationship with AQSIQ and other government organizations. Profiles of Primary Publics Current and Potential Consumers 1. Demographic and psychographic profile Urban, female, white collar workers with a disposable income who are able to afford luxury skin care products. These women represent between five percent and seven percent of the population, or approximately 65 to 90 million customers. Other consumer bases are nouveau riche business executives, spouses of white collar workers, and people who were educated abroad or have travelled outside of China. They are in their forties or younger and receive formal education that range from primary to post-graduate levels. 2. Motivating self-interests Current consumers want to know the truth about what ingredients are in the skin care products and they want the advertisements for the products to be accurate. They want the process of returning a product to be simple and consistent. 3. Status of current relationship with the organization and issue Current consumers are very upset with P&G. First, they believe that the P&G is falsely advertising the effects of SK-II. Then, AQSIQ announced that SK-II products contained substances that are banned in cosmetics under Chinese law. Also, when P&G allowed customers to return the product its conditions were extremely difficult to abide by and kept changing. Consumers are upset with how P&G interacted with them and feel the company didn’t do enough to make up for its mistakes. 4. Third party influentials and other opinion leaders Current consumers might start using other cosmetic lines if their trust in SK-II does not improve. Friends and the government could also be influencing people not to purchase SKII products. Additionally, the Chinese media frame P&G as arrogant. Key Messages Primary o A strong relationship between P&G, SK-II and customers is extremely important. o We are committed to being honest and producing the best skin care products we can. o We’re here to make your refund process simple. Secondary o P&G will do everything it can to make up for past mistakes. Monthly newsletters will keep current consumers updated, and gift certificates and extended counter time will strengthen the relationship with consumers. o Our products will include the best ingredients and our commercials will be accurate concluding with a warning of natural ingredients that might enter the product. o We’ll implement a new refund policy that will give consumers an easier and better experience at SK-II counters. We will give gift certificates to make the experience even better. Target Audience: Government Officials 1. Demographic and psychographic profile P&G’s denial of the accusations pertaining to the chromium and neodymium found in its products caused a major issue with the Chinese government, which is highly honored and holds most of the power in this communist society. Respect and hierarchy are major aspects of the Chinese government and culture; it is offensive to deny or disagree with its authority. 2. Motivating self-interests The Chinese governmental officials work toward an equal playing field for businesses. It is the government’s duty to make sure everyone is following the rules and working within the same terms and regulations. The specific department - National Quality Inspection Department of the State General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine (AQSIQ) - is intended to make sure cosmetics, as well as other products, are safe for everyone and do not contain substances that are harmful to the people. Whenever a company or business fails to meet these standards, it is the AQSIQ’s duty to follow up and make sure any issues are taken care of. 3. Status of current relationship with the organization and issue P&G has unsuccessfully worked with the government officials from the AQSIQ due to its unwillingness to cooperate and make changes to SK-II products. The disrespect caused by P&G consequently created a hostile relationship between the two parties. 4. Third party influentials and other opinion leaders Other cosmetic businesses that compete with P&G need to be aware of the situation and make sure they do not run into similar situations. P&G can work with comparable companies who have faced equivalent cases in order to learn and improve from its mistakes. Along with that, medical doctors are the experts aware of the affects these products can have on one’s skin. The media play a large voice for this crisis, especially because the government controls them. Readers take the stories seriously and evaluate the situation. Other countries that sell SK-II products may or may not have similar standards as the Chinese set by the AQSIQ and will voice their opinions on the situation that may affect P&G’s businesses there as well. Key Messages Primary o Our new SK-II product line is AQSIQ approved! o Building a better business for a better future. o We provide the higher quality skin care that is safe and healthy for you. Secondary o P&G is making it a priority to have all its SK-II products be government-approved in order to provide safe products for its consumers. The new products will have AQSIQ stamps to prove they meet regulations. o Our company is working toward building better relationships with government officials - AQSIQ - in order to fix the recent mistakes and to move forward and make positive changes. Communication among different parties will help make sure we are on the right track and developing in the right direction. o P&G is making sure that all of our new products are approved by government, health regulations and more important, relaying that message to the government and our consumers. Through various events, promotions and marketing we are proving to the market that our products are worth the price. Objectives, Strategies and Tactics: Target Audience: Current Consumers Objective 1: To have 10 percent of consumers agree that P&G has improved communication with consumers by March 1, 2007. Strategy 1: Implement a program of clarification and education. Tactic 1: Hold a news conference on November 1, 2006. Location: Hotel ballroom Attendees: Any consumers of SK-II, President Michael Beauchamp, SK-II managers, and the media. Topics: Explanation of questioning the authority of the state, explanation of how products are going to be different, an apology, and future plans explained. Tactic 2: Monthly newsletter for one year. Sent to consumers of SK-II products who give their home address and want to keep in contact with the operations of SK-II. Format: letter to consumers, bullet points of accomplishments of the last month, future plans, and explanation of ingredients in all products. Tactic 3: Survey consumers now on their opinion of P&G and give the same survey six months later to measure satisfaction. First survey will be on the website the day before the news conference and stay up for a week for people to complete. Second survey will be given on March 1, 2007 and on the website for one week. o Surveys will be distributed through email from the addresses that consumers have provided. Evaluation: Clearing up confusion and explaining how products will be different will continue to keep the relationship between P&G and current consumers healthy and growing. The two surveys will measure if at least 10 percent of customers agree that P&G has improved. The newsletter and survey will both be sent out to at least 1,000 subscribers. The media coverage will be measured by how many times the conference is mentioned in the news, how many minutes of airtime it receives, and how many mentions there are on social media websites. The tone of coverage will be measured as well, whether it’s positive, negative, or neutral. Objective 2: To achieve 20 percent consumer satisfaction with the refund policy by January 1, 2007. Strategy 2: Implement a new refund policy on October 1, 2006 that is clearer and easier for consumers. Tactic 1: Send out a press release about the new policy. Send out one week before the policy begins. Send to at least 20 media outlets, 10 local, 5 national, and 5 online. Include that the refund policy will be implemented at all counters and that counters will stay open past normal hours to assist more customers. Tactic 2: For the new policy customers will bring back their SK-II bottle and they will be given a refund or replacement. Return policy applies to any SK-II product. No receipts are required. For six months after the policy is implemented, the costumers who return a product will be given a gift certificate of $50.00 for a future SK-II purchase. After three months of implementing the new policy, survey the consumers who have returned products. When customers return a product they will be asked to go to a website and complete a survey on how they rate the new policy. Tactic 3: When consumers purchase something with the $50.00 gift certificate, give a follow-up survey at the counter with 2 simple questions. Did the $50.00 gift certificate increase your satisfaction with SK-II? Are you currently satisfied with the way SK-II is performing? Evaluation: Customers will be satisfied with the new refund policy and consumer’s relationship with P&G will start to rebuild. The new policy will make it much easier on customers to return products, especially with more counter time and such an simple policy. The follow-up survey after the consumer’s future purchase with the $50.00 gift certificate will question consumer’s opinion of SK-II and will help measure improvement. Objective 3: For 40 percent of current customers to purchase SK-II products by December 1, 2006. Strategy 3: Implement a six month long program to prove P&G is working hard to improve the company and communicating with the current consumers to make sure they continue to purchase SK-II products. Tactic 1: One day a month for six months have a free trial day at all SK-II counters for all products. During this day hand out free mini samples of popular products. Hire more employees for this one day to assist. Have a video playing on a loop with factory and manufacturing information on SK-II products. Tactic 2: Get addresses of current consumers and send them a card that is personally signed from President Beauchamp. Letter will include changes P&G has made to their company and future plans. Tactic 3: On the P&G website make a “bulletin-board” feature where consumers can post anonymously about SK-II products, a problem they have, or questions. Response to any comment will take no longer than 48 hours. After three months insert a poll on the website with two questions. o Has P&G improved? o Will you continue to buy SK-II products? Evaluation: This will be measured by asking customers at the checkout counter if this is their first purchase or not. That way P&G will know if their current consumers are continuing to buy SK-II products. A letter and a free trial day will prove to current consumers P&G is doing everything they can to keep them as customers.P&G will monitor external bulletin boards, and with a comment section on the website consumers will be able to get their questions answered right away, and if there is a problem P&G will be able to fix it sooner. 1,000 consumers will be emailed with a poll. If at least 30 percent of people agree that P&G has improved then P&G will see the success. Target Audience: Potential Customers Objective 1: Create trust in SK-II products and the corporation. Strategy: Administer tactics to increase SK-II and P&G honesty and transparency. Tactic 1: Implement a monthly newsletter for a year and half. Hand out to everyone, not just customers, at SK-II counters. Send more detailed newsletters (than at counters) via email to potential customers who stop by counter for information. Include free product promotions within newsletter for interested customers who sign up for email newsletters. Tactic 2: Testimonials in newspaper from SK-II customers once every two months. In the monthly newsletter (tactic 1), explain how SK-II wants to hear “your” feedback Format: SK-II audiences send in their stories about resolved disappointments, loyalty to brand, or anything they wish to share. All op-eds considered. Evaluation: By giving constant information on SK-II products and the inner-workings of the company, P&G wishes to create strong relationships with a wide range of audiences and increase number of customers by 35%. We will measure this increase by a survey at the end of four months in the newsletter to see the newsletter’s impact on the customers. The op-eds give current customers a chance to explain their experiences, no matter negative or positive, with SK-II and why they are still with the company through all of the troubles. By doing this, potential customers realize the transparency of the company and understand the loyalty of current customers. Objective 2: Increase sales by 40% by February 1, 2007. Strategy: Engage in promotions and events to create positivity of SK-II products. Tactic 1: Promotional give-aways During the Chinese New Year and holidays in December, create excitement about brand by giving out promotional goods and services. Buy one, get one free for SK-II products when you are a new customer. Tactic 2: Three ballroom formal dinner events over one year. Held in convention center ballroom Anybody on distribution list can attend, email invitation and rsvp sent via email newsletters Formal, three-course dinner with executive staff of SK-II at cost of $20 per person. The profits from the dinner will be a fundraiser for Chinese NGO. Partner with Chinese fashion designers, who will have clothing to rent (profits for Chinese NGO) Format of Event: o Introductions of P&G and staffing of local SK-II counters o Presentations of upcoming events and new products o Overall goal: create excitement about forthcoming advancements within the company and an inside look into the future of SK-II and P&G Tactic 3: Customer rewards program When a customer spends 200 US dollars, the customer receives a free package of newly released SK-II products Tiered- system of rewards: the more you spend to SK-II, the more you receive. Simple as a discount to customer birthday rewards to new customer promotions Evaluation: Incising a customer is more than gaining revenue; it gains loyalty and strong relationships. By showing commitment to the customers and understanding their needs, SK-II may find new audiences and create a new base never thought of. The main tool to evaluate this tactic will also be a survey. These customers will already receive the newsletter so it will be distributed that way. Personal contact is key in finding new customers, so positive interaction at the SK-II counters is crucial to the success of this objective. Fun, energetic and appealing events create excitement around the brand; thus, leading to an unwavering customer base. Objective 3: Expand knowledge and create excitement about brand by 40 percent by March 1, 2007 Strategy: Encourage brand excitement and provide inside information to customers by opening communication from company to customers. Tactic 1: SK-II promotional event This is a fun, day-long event for all ages, even kid-friendly, to come and see what is new for SK-II April 13, 2007 It will be held in a hotel ballroom in downtown Beijing, China. Hands-on activities, testers, facials for cost and new products available. Informational booths about ingredients in products and videos on how it is made. o Various other fashion designers, cosmetic booths, home decor and food will also be available. All of the events will be put on by SK-II staff and executive board to show inside of what the company does. Tactic 2: Launch Bulletin Board online This bulletin board is created by SK-II and creates conversation weekly with a post about the inside of the company. Some topics: New and upcoming for SK-II (products) New management positions Code of Ethics clearly stated Anyone can view the bulletin board, but only those with registered emails can post. o o o Tactic 3: Product launch event February 16, 2007 This event will be based off of the new cream customers have been discussing on op-eds and bulletin boards. o Completely based of customer feedback and launch of new products All people may come to this event and first 120 will get a free sample of the cream. Brochures and other informational packets will be distributed to all Clients, vendors, shareholders, and employees welcome Format of the Event o This is not an extremely formal event o Speakers from P&G will introduce new product and explain changes within the SK-II products o Celebrity spokespeople will give testimonials Evaluation: Potential customers are drawn to events that cause excitement and market the brand in a positive way. By showing involvement in the community and making sure all audiences are noticed, SK-II plans to increase knowledge and excitement by 40 percent. A survey will be handed out at the door that includes a gift card give-away for completing and returning. This measurement will give insight to the changes in P&G and SK-II products. Giving customers an exclusive look into SK-II and lets the audiences know that we wish to be transparent and understand their feedback is greatly appreciated. Target Audience: Government Officials Objective 1: To have the AQSIQ and other government departments approve our new products and have a positive and supportive relationship by the December 15, 2007. Strategy 1: Host a large banquet for the AQSIQ government executives, members of the Ministry of Health, as well as the Chinese, administrative P&G employees to present the new SK-II product line on November 16, 2006 at the Hilton hotel ballroom in Guangzhou. Tactic 1: Present each attendee with a package of samples from the new SK-II product line these will meet all the standards set by AQSIQ. Tactic 2: Prepare a slide show presentation on what P&G has done since the recalls on its products. Explain what the new products are with details describing everything they contain. This is to be clear that they are following all of China’s regulations. Tactic 3: Have President Michael Beauchamp express a formal apology to the entire audience. Address the following: Admitting to their mistakes. What they should have done instead. Why they are apologizing. What they are going to do for the future. Thank everyone for his or her cooperation and patience. Tactic 4: Mr. Beauchamp and other P&G executives will individually bow formally to all the attendees briefly thanking them for their presence and apologizing for the inconvenience their company has created. Evaluation: We will review the number of attendees at the banquet understanding that if all invited show up then we were successful; however if there is a small turn out then we will need to reevaluate our plan. At the end of the event, the response from the attendees will give us an idea of how they feel about our restructured business and products. Objective 2: To have all P&G SK-II products meet the AQSIQ requirements and standards for China by November 15, 2006. Strategy 2: Communicate with the government to make sure P&G has an updated list of the prerequisites for product ingredients. In addition, turn in all necessary forms, reports, etc. so the government departments know everything going on with our products. Tactic 1: Plan quarterly meetings with the head of the AQSIQ department to make sure that SK-II products are continually following all the guidelines. Meetings will cover: Conversation about current SK-II products about if they have made any current changes and if so, do they meet requirements. Discussion on potential new products P&G wants to come out with. Review, together, the AQSIQ standards and requirements. Tactic 2: Add “AQSIQ Approved” stamps on all SK-II products. This will assure consumers that their products are abiding by all governmental criteria. Tactic 3: Send product updates through quarterly newsletters sent to the AQSIQ department and distributors. Included in the newsletters will be current news on P&G’s business in China, as well as other locations, philanthropic events and success, etc. Evaluation: All SK-II products will be either approved or disapproved by the AQSIQ department by November 15, 2006. Objective 3: To have a clear message understood by the Chinese government on P&G’s progress and how it is making changes to better the company by November 15, 2006, that will continue for the next year. Strategy 3: Provide several public meetings in the beginning of November and plan events in order to show the advancements P&G has made over the past year. Tactic 1: Write personalized letters to all the specific government members involved in this case informing them why P&G is penitent and explaining its intention and what it is doing to plan for a better future. Included with the letter will be a signed document, from all P&G executives, promising to take responsibility and action any time an instance like this occurs again. Tactic 2: Hold a press conference on November, 5, 2006 at the Guangzhou city hall conference room and have President Beauchamp display a public announcement to the all the parties affected by the issues involving SK-II products. Admitting to their mistakes. What they should have done instead. Details as to what actually happened. What they are going to do for the future. Outline the new, permanent return policy. Thank everyone for his or her cooperation and patience. Tactic 3: Host an event on November 25, 2006 at all SK-II sales counters to promote their new SK-II product line - similar to a re-opening - and invite government officials to attend the events that are at our larger distributor locations. Free samples of the new products, as well as food and beverages provided. Evaluation: Communicate with government officials, at the end of the year - December 30, 2006 and continue on for the following year, on their opinions on how they believe P&G has improved and what they can continue to focus on and enhance. Go straight to the officials in charge to make sure there has been progress made. Calendar Public: Current Consumers Sept. 2006 Strategy: Implement education/clarification strategy Tactic: News conference (Nov. 1) Tactic: Monthly newsletter to consumers (for one year) Tactic: Survey to consumers (entrance and exit) Strategy: Improve refund policy Tactic: New policy implemented (initial news release) Tactic: Increased availability in stores Tactic: Gift certificates to customers Tactic: Survey consumers Strategy: Brand improvement, apology Tactic: Free trial day at counters Oct. 2006 Nov. 2006 Dec. 2006 Jan. 2007 Feb. 2007 March 2007 + (once monthly) Tactic: Note from President to customers Tactic: Bulletin board on company website (implement immediately; monitor every day) Public: Potential Consumers Sept. 2006 Strategy: Honesty program Tactic: Monthly newsletter (through March 2008) Tactic: Op-eds every two months Strategy: Engage in conversations Tactic: Promotional giveaways (Dec.) Tactic: Formal banquets Tactic: Customer rewards program Strategy: Brand management strategy Tactic: Promotional event (April 2007) Tactic: Bulletin board (implement immediately, monitor daily) Tactic: Product launch event (Feb.16, 2007) (Includes Oct. 2006 Nov. 2006 Dec. 2006 Jan. 2007 Feb. 2007 March 2007 + planning, collateral material production) Public: Government Officials Sept. 2006 Strategy: Product launch banquet (Nov. 16) Tactic: Samples of product line for attendees Tactic: Informative presentation Tactic: Formal apology by President at banquet Tactic: Personal greetings by President Strategy: Ensure products meet gov’t standards Tactic: Quarterly meetings with AQSIQ Tactic: Add approval sticker to products (Begin immediately) Tactic: Product updates via quarterly newsletter Strategy: Public apologies/events Tactic: Personal letters to gov’t officials Tactic: Press conference, apology (Nov. 5) Tactic: Event at SK-II stands (Nov. 25) Oct. 2006 Nov. 2006 Dec. 2006 Jan. 2007 Dec. 2007 Budget Current Customers Objective Improve the relationship between current consumers by 10 percent by March 1, 2007. Tactic Cost Hold a news conference at the hotel ballroom. $875.00 Monthly newsletter for one year sent to consumers. Survey consumers now on their opinion of P&G and give the same survey six months later to measure satisfaction through our website. Total: Have 20 percent of current consumers be satisfied with the refund policy by January 1, 2007. Send out a press release about the new policy. For the new policy customers will bring back their SK-II bottle and they will automatically be given a replacement. $1,500 $0.00 $2,375.00 $350.00 $50,000.00 There will be extra counter time at SKII. The counter will stay open a little later than others or open earlier. $9,000.00 After a return, the customers will be given a gift certificate of $50.00 for a future SK-II purchase. $10,000.00 After three months of implementing the new policy, survey the consumers who have returned products. $0.00 Total: $69,350.00 Have 30 percent of current customers agree that P&G has improved and made up for its mistakes and that they will continue to purchase SK-II products by December 1, 2006. One day a month for six months have a free trial day at all SK-II counters for all products. · During this day hand out free mini samples of popular products. · Hire more employees for this one-day to assist. Get addresses of current consumers and send them a card that is personally signed from President Beauchamp. On the P&G website make a “bulletinboard” feature where consumers can post anonymously about SK-II products, a problem they have, or questions. Total: Total Cost for Objectives: $2,000.00 $500.00 $0.00 $2,500.00 $74,225.00 Future Customers Objective Create trust in SK-II products and corporation by March 1, 2007 Tactic Cost Monthly newsletter for a year and half Hand out at SK-II counters publicly · Sent via email to potential customers who stop by counter for information · Include free product promotions within newsletter for interested customers who sign up for email newsletters $3,000.00 Op-eds in newspaper from SK-II customers once every two months. $100.00 Total: $3,100.00 Increase customers by 60% by February 1, 2007. Promotional giveaways during launch of new products in December · During the new year, create excitement about brand by giving out promotional goods and services. · Buy one, get one free for SK-II products when you are a new customer Ballroom formal dinner events · Held in convention center ballroom · Anybody can attend, email initiation and RSVP sent via email newsletters · Formal, 3 course dinner with executive staff of SK-II $6,700.00 Customer rewards program · When a customer spends up to $200, the customer receives a free package full of newly released products $800.00 Total: Expand knowledge and excitement about brand by 40% by March 1, 2007 $5,000.00 $19,500.00 SK-II promotional event · It will be held in a hotel ballroom · Hands on activities, testers, facials for cost and new products available. · Informational booths about ingredients in products and videos on how it is made. $5,000.00 Bulletin Board online · This bulletin board is created by SK-II and creates conversation weekly with a post about the inside of the company. $0.00 Product launch event · All people may come to this event and first 120 will get a free sample of the cream · Brochures and other informational packets will be distributed to all · Clients, vendors, shareholders, and employees welcome Total: Total Cost for Objectives: $800.00 $5,800.00 $21,400.00 Government Officials Objective Improve relationship with government officials by the end of the 2006-year. Tactic Cost Present each attendee with a package of samples of the new SK-II product line. $500.00 Prepare a slide show presentation on what P&G has done since the recalls on its products. $0.00 President Beauchamp will express a formal apology to audience. $0.00 Overall costs for catering, renting the room, chairs, tables, tablecloths and flowers. $9,000.00 Mr. Beauchamp and other P&G executives will individually bow to all the attendees briefly thanking them for their presence and apologizing for the inconvenience their company has created. $0.00 Total: $9,500.00 Have all P&G SK-II products meet the AQSIQ requirements and standards for China by November 15, 2006. Plan quarterly meetings with the head of the AQSIQ department. $50.00 Add “AQSIQ Approved” stamps on all SK-II products. $15,000.00 Send product updates through quarterly newsletters sent to the AQSIQ department and distributors. $700.00 Total: Have a clear message understood by the Chinese government on P&G’s progress and how it is making changes to better the company by November 15, 2006 that will continue for the next year. $15,750.00 Write personalized letters to all the specific government members involved in this case. Included with the letter will be a signed document, from all P&G executives, promising to take responsibility and action any time an instance like this occurs again. $1,300.00 Hold a press conference at the Hilton hotel ballroom. $900.00 Host an event at all P&G stands to promote their new SK-II product line. Free samples of the new products, as well as food and beverages provided. $18,000.00 Total: $20,200.00 Total Cost for Objectives: $45, 450.00 GRAND Total of all Objectives: $141,075.00