Research Paper Writing I have to write a what ? Vitoria Guarino 2000 Table of Contents • Overview (1-5) • Where to Begin: Necessary Items & Narrowing Your Topic (6-12) • Organizing Information: The Working Outline (13-20) • Gathering Information: Index Cards (24-29) • Where to Look: Finding Credible Sources (30-32) • Citation and the “Works Cited” Page (33-40) • Closing Remarks (41-43) First Things First • The worst thing you can do is panic. If you panic, you will delay, and the more you delay, the worse the quality of your work will be. • Anyway, if you already know the basic methods used to write shorter papers (essays), you already have most of the skills necessary to write a research paper. Remember This . . . • Every paragraph you write in an essay has a point – a main idea as expressed in a topic sentence. • So too, every paragraph is used in a slightly different way – some are intended to describe, and some to explain, while others are intended to prove a point by providing examples. The same is true of a research paper. Therefore . . . If your topic is WWII, and you wish to prove that the treatment of Germany at the close of the war was justified, you will probably devote a couple of paragraphs to the events leading up to the war. In each case you will emphasize Germany’s actions and its leaders’ biased perspectives. Then, you may want to devote a few paragraphs to atrocities committed by Germany during the war. Of course, you will also have to focus on the specifications of the treaties as well as reparations and you will prove, by way of specific examples, that each requirement was fair and just. Where to begin . . . You will need • • • • • • A package of large index cards Pencils and looseleaf A highlighter An MLA Handbook for citation formats A topic At least six reliable, informative sources that show you are able to find, select and understand a variety of formats including books, periodicals, an interview, and perhaps a film or documentary. • Access to a word processor Your first task Your first task requires four steps: 1. Find a topic in which you are interested. 2. Find and skim a variety of books and articles about it. 3. Find an “angle,” a point you want to make or prove about that topic. 4. Bring the topic (and the titles of your sources) to your teacher for several chats in order to narrow your topic and in order to make certain it meets your teacher’s standards. The best way to select and then narrow a topic is to read about a few of the topics provided by your teacher. If none are provided, you can visit the library (say “Hello!” to the librarian for Ms. Guarino) and view the Readers’ Guide to Periodicals (a fancy term for magazines, journals and newspapers). Once you have a general topic of interest, you can try to narrow your topic by asking yourself a few questions. Journalists’ Who? Questions What? Where? When? Why? How? Huh? (Just kidding) Some Questions Let us assume that you are interested in a broad topic such as child labor. In order to narrow the topic, first answer the five basic journalist’s questions: Who is involved in child labor? Who is most likely to be exploited? Who is doing the exploiting? Get some statistics! What motivates those who are involved? What industries are more likely to employ children? What are the authorities doing about it? What are the working conditions like? What groups are fighting against it? Where (in which countries) is it most prevalent? Where can people find help in addressing this problem? Where have the authorities dealt with the problem? When did child labor become popular? When did governments first address the issue? When was there a shift in the trend, if any? Why does child labor still exist? Why do governments ignore the issue? Why does the U.S. continue to trade with countries where it continues? How can it be curbed or stopped? How do those who have been child laborers feel about their experience? How do the parents feel? How well are policies working? How much time will it take to abolish it worldwide? How much money is made as a result of this practice? Once you have Asked these questions, and skimmed materials for answers, you should have a better sense of the aspects on which you would like to focus. For instance, perhaps you would like to focus on a connection between child labor and the United States, in which case you will need a working thesis or premise such as “Despite its staunch position against child labor, the United States continues to trade with countries in which children are exploited.” Once you have an “angle” from which to explore the topic, organizing your materials will be easier. Organizing Information Organization When you have discussed your ideas with your teacher, you should create a tentative (working) outline and then use that outline to guide your research. After all, you don’t want to devote too much research time to issues you don’t intend to include in your paper. Your outline will depend upon the topic of your paper and your writing style. However, there are a few basic models you can follow. Working Outline C LU U Remember that you may have to exclude E Be prepared to rearrange the sequence of S Find a nice balance between working chronologically and logically. se your teacher’s expertise to help you shape your paper as you work. much of the info you find because it does not specifically relate to your topic. your outline as the paper develops. A Basic Model Keep your premise on hand and obvious at all times so you won’t forget it. Use roman numerals to indicate paragraphs, letters to indicate related topics, and numbers to indicate specific examples or subtopics. I. Introduction Premise (thesis or controlling idea): Despite its staunch position against child labor, the United States continues to trade with countries in which children are exploited. II. Current U.S. stand against child labor A. Current opinions of leaders 1. Clinton’s opinion (radio show) 2. Gore’s view (article) B. Current policies and the American tradition 1. Indictments /Court decisions 2. Laws 3. Bill of Rights?? III. Source of that view (brief historical perspective) A. Agricultural Society 1. Long hours, hard work, typical day 2. However, family’s best interest in mind, parental control and protection, etc. B. Influence of Industrial Revolution 1. Harsh conditions, long hours, mechanistic tasks 2. Children viewed as chattel 3. An issue of survival and greed C. Recognition of need for laws Have I missed Something here? 1. Statistics (injuries/deaths) 2. Quote which emphasizes need for laws/restrictions to protect the young IV. U.S. methods of dealing with the problem (laws) UH OH! Haven’t I written this already?? O.K. – I’ll revise my outline later! Decisions During outlining you will be asking yourself questions! This will require you to make careful decisions! V. Transitional paragraph A. Despite these policies, the U.S. continues to trade = hypocritical?? VI. U.S. dealings with countries where child labor exists A. Identify worst culprit and establish it as such 1. Statistics 2. Interview/1st person accounts B. Proof that U.S. still trades with worst culprit 1. 1998 Study 2. Times article/statistics I need to find more details/specific quotes and examples that will apply here! VII. Theories regarding reasons U.S. continues to trade A. Political 1. Power 2. Leverage 3. Business leaders and the polls I think I should ask my teacher for help figuring out the sequence of the first 4 paragraphs. Doubts During outlining you will be confused and doubtful. This will require you to ask your teacher for advice! A. Economic 1. Power 2. Leverage 3. Business leaders and the polls VIII. Arguments against U.S. continued trade A. Views of Politicians Will this need to be divided into two paragraphs because it is so important?? B. Views of child laborer (interview/documentary) C. My view I Will need to identify examples IX. Global and ethical implications as I complete index cards. A. World view B. Exploitation and Power (Psychology Today article) C. Recommendations for change X. Conclusion A. Sum it up B Close with quote from poem about child labor OR with Buddhist quote about humankind Should I combine these two paragraphs and create a powerful conclusion?? Please remember That a good writer begins writing promptly. She writes and then rewrites, reorganizes and edits her outline as she discovers new, relevant material. She is willing to change the sequence of her points in order to assist her reader. She confers with her teacher often so that she remains focused. She even reads what she has read aloud to herself and others in order to identify problem areas! Zzzzzzz... Now that you have Your working outline, you can devote even more time to focused research. You will need to make certain that your premise is correct and can be proven. You will need to gather a variety of evidence (quotes, examples, statistics) from a variety of sources. Gathering Info. . . Taking Notes You can take notes in any number of ways. However, certain methods seem to work better than others. Read the Table of Contents and the index of a text to find sections that may help you. Don’t attempt to read each book in its entirety. Make copies of articles and news clippings. Then, use that highlighter to identify important sections, facts, statistics, or quotes. Take notes every time you read an article. Keep that pen handy whenever you pick up an article or book. After all, you don’t want to read an article, find something useful, and then have to search for it again because you didn’t take notes. Always include bibliographical info. (Source data) with each bit of information You intend to quote OR paraphrase. The index card method is used most frequently. The index card Your index cards (note cards) should be set up as follows: (Perkins, 12) Statistics - China “In 1997, over six thousand children under the age of fourteen were employed in sweatshops throughout China. While manufacturers made millions of dollars, children were suffering.” Once you have your index cards You can rearrange your examples, statistics and quotes with ease. In fact, if you have provided accurate “key words” on each card, you can use the pile method. This involves placing the index cards in piles that correspond to your working outline topics. For instance, the sample card (Statistics – China) would most likely be included in which of the following sections? Quiz Show II. Current U.S. stand against child labor Statistics - China III. Source of that view (brief historical perspective) IV. U.S. methods of dealing with the problem (laws) VI. U.S. dealings with countries where child labor exists V. Transitional paragraph VII. Theories regarding reasons U.S. continues to trade VI. U.S. dealings with countries where child labor exists Statistics - China Where to Look The search is on Your first stop should be the library, where you can feel free to chat with the librarian. He or she will be more than happy to help, especially once you have a specific focus. • • • The main catalog in the library is a great place to start. If the catalog is computerized, the task may be even simpler. Look here for books and texts. The Reader’s Guide to Periodicals will help you find newspaper, magazine and journal articles that may be more current than the books you find. General encyclopedias can help during the first stage of the search (for general info.), but should be avoided as a research source. It is a good place to introduce yourself to a topic with which you are unfamiliar. Look for an encyclopedia that focuses on a particular subject such as the Encyclopedia of World Art. The search continues • • • The library also has newspaper indexes, the most useful of which is the New York Times Index. There are indexes that can help you find articles that deal specifically with different fields of interest. For instance, if you are writing about a particular law, you may want to look at the Legal Periodicals Index. So too, there is a General Science Index for those researching scientific subjects. Almost every subject has its own index! Like encyclopedias that are subject specific, many dictionaries focus on particular fields of interest. For instance, there is a Dictionary of American History. Again, these dictionaries may provide some useful background information you can use to improve your introduction or your conclusion. Citation and The “Works Cited” Page Parenthetical Citation Every time you include a quote OR paraphrase information that is NOT common knowledge, you MUST identify your source. Your note/index cards will make this process a breeze! The most common citation you will use will be for works or articles with one author. In this case, the author’s name and the page number are placed at the end of the sentence before the closing punctuation. An example In 1997, the issue of child labor in China could no longer be ignored because “over six thousand children under the age of fourteen were employed in sweatshops” where young men and women were required to work long hours for little pay (Perkins 12). Note that the author’s name and the page number appear at the end of the sentence, not after the quoted material. Variations However, if the author is mentioned within the sentence, the format changes slightly: According to Perkins, as of 1997, the issue of child labor in China could no longer be ignored because “over six thousand children under the age of fourteen were employed in sweatshops” where young men and women were required to work long hours for little pay (12). Also, if you include two or more books by the same author, you will include one important word from the title as well: work long hours for little pay (Perkins, Suffer 12). For more variations (books with two authors, poetry, etc.) ask your librarian for a copy of the MLA Handbook The Modern Language Association publishes an updated version of this handbook each year. The book provides detailed guidelines regarding every citation format including those used for internet sources. Ask the librarian! Works Cited Page Instead of a bibliography, you will include a “Works Cited” page at the end of your research paper. These works appear in alphabetical order according to the author’s last name. Once again, the MLA Handbook will list examples of formats necessary for a wide variety of sources. However, the most basic formats appear as follows: Perkins, Thomas. Suffer the Children: Child Labor Then and Now. New York: Norton Press, 1998. Cooke, Maya. “The Child Labor Dilemma.” Newsweek 6 Dec. 1997: 23-24. Cottlefisht, Myrtle. “Nike Ignores Child Labor Laws.” New York Times 14 March 1998, sec. 1: 4-5. More Citation Variations For journals, translations, works with more than one author,personal interviews, television shows, websites and reference works, consult the newest edition of the MLA Handbook. Remember that your “Works Cited” page should have the words “Works Cited” (without quotation marks) at the top of the page. It should be centered. The list itself should be double-spaced and the works should be in alphabetical order according to the last name of the author. Research Paper Writing Is not as difficult or overwhelming as it seems at first. However, the research process is a time consuming one, and you should never underestimate the amount of time the research, planning and organizing phases will take. So, our best advice is that you begin your work as soon as the paper is assigned, rely on your librarian for assistance, and meet with your teacher frequently to discuss your outline as well as your topic. Good Luck! Visit your librarian! Visit your Teacher! Work Hard! Vitoria Guarino 2000 Click once below in order to return to the first slide.