HUMAN EVOLUTION 1. (a) original concentration of the radioisotope must be established/estimated; rate of decay/half-life of the isotope must be known; in radiocarbon dating concentration of the surviving 14C in the fossil is measured; in potassium-argon dating ratio of 40K to 40Ar atoms are measured; (b) 10000 years (c) increased bipedalism; increased brain size/cranial capacity; reduction of sagittal crest; tooth size reduction; flattening of the facial bones; development of opposable thumb; 2 max 1 2 max [5] 2. few hominid fossils have been found/not often found/are very rare; most hominids/organisms not preserved/decompose; only teeth and bones remain / soft tissues do not fossilize; require certain conditions for preservation/dry/anaerobic/quickly covered/frozen; earlier cultures did not bury the dead / remains were scavenged/dispersed; acids break down/dissolve teeth/bones; many missing links/fossils of intermediate stages; difficult to get conclusive evidence / difficult to falsify theories; theories change radically with one/few discoveries; 6 max [6] 3. (a) most carbon is 12C but there is small amount of (radioactive) 14C; organisms absorb the same ratio of 12C:14C as in the environment; after death, no more atoms accumulate; 14 C steadily breaks down so amount decreases/12C:14C increases with age / half-life (approx 5730 years) expresses rate of decay of 14C; the less 14C in a sample the older the fossil / 14C useful for dating samples one thousand to one hundred thousand years old; HUMAN EVOLUTION 2 max 1 HUMAN EVOLUTION (b) Ardipithecus is an older genus (5.2–4.4 million years ago) than Australopithecus (4–2.5 million years ago); toe structure of Ardipithecus shows it was probably bipedal / early Australopithecus at least partially bipedal; tooth structure changed as diet changed from soft fruits/leaves/seeds/ nuts to omnivorous diet; large/primitive canines seen in Ardipithecus to smaller canines in Australopithecus; increasing height —Ardipithecus is smaller (the size of a chimpanzee); change in face from projecting to flat face / from tall to small lower jaw / development of high forehead / loss of brow ridges; 3 max [5] 4. (a) (b) Australopithecus afarensis/A. afarensis had a relatively small skull with a low forehead/moderate sized brow ridges; A. africanus/A. robustus evolved from A. afarensis with increases in cranial capacity/larger brow ridges/low forehead; Homo habilis/H. habilis had a small cranial capacity/small brow ridges/increased forehead; H. erectus/H. neanderthalensis/H. sapiens followed H. habilis and show increased cranial capacity; (as the Homo sp evolved) the forehead increased; (as the Homo sp evolved) the orbital ridges decreased; 3 max improved diet quality correlated (positively) with hominid skull development/size; improved diet quality provides energy to support a greater brain function; change of habitat (in Africa) 2.5 mya may have prompted emergence of Homo sp; change in diet to include meat increased brain size (of hominids); cooking food enabled hominids to eat a wider variety of food; 2 max [5] HUMAN EVOLUTION 2 HUMAN EVOLUTION 5. cultural evolution based on skills / information passed from one generation to another; new methods can be transmitted between different groups; cultural evolution is learned/taught/language dependent; large brains of Homo species allow more learning; cultural evolution allows more rapid evolution / most recent changes are cultural; genetic evolution is dependent on/controlled by genes; genetic evolution is limited by the genetic composition/genotypes of the populations; e.g. of human genetic evolution (such as increase in cranial capacity); e.g. of human cultural evolution (such as tool making/religion/art); 6 max [6] 6. (a) (b) time taken for the radioactivity/% parental isotope to fall to half of its original level/for half of the atoms in a given mass to decay; after 28 years there is 50% of previous reading of strontium-90 isotopes; 2 4 to 2.5 million years ago; in East Africa; most complete skeleton Lucy; Lucy dated to 3.2/3.6 million years ago; (accept any date within this range) other part-fossils found; 2 max [4] 7. fossils being formed is a rare event; (e.g. fewNeanderthals survived the example to illustrate why forming fossils is a rare event; cold, so few fossils) fossils being preserved is a rare event; fossils being found is a rare event; (e.g. due to geographical locations) chances of finding fossils is improved by searching in the right geological strata / OWTTE; poor data / fragmented remains / very small sample size; more prone to paradigm shifts/changes in theory when data is limited / discovery of a small amount of fossils can lead to a huge change in theories; paleoanthropology can still be considered a science e.g. Dmanisi, Georgia (falsification of earlier positions held); 6 max [6] HUMAN EVOLUTION 3 HUMAN EVOLUTION 8. (a) (b) forward facing eyes/binocular vision; large brains; flexible shoulder joints / shoulder blades on the dorsal side of the thorax; manual dexterity / power grip / opposable thumb / grasping limbs; finger pads / nails not claws; skull adapted for upright posture; pronation / rotating hand; 2 max fossilization is an exceptionally rare occurrence; most components of formerly living things tend to decompose relatively quickly following death; fossilization tends to favour hard body parts; fossilization favours species that were widespread/lived for a long time; paleoanthropology is an inductive/data-poor science (a relatively small amount of data is used to draw conclusions); many of the conclusions that have been drawn on limited data have not stood for long; exposed fossils are soon destroyed/weathered, reducing the chance of them being found; new discoveries regularly come to light, leading scientists to re-interpret previous assumptions in the light of the new data; examples e.g. the Dmansi site, Georgia, discoveries have led to a re-evaluation of previous theories of human evolution; 3 max [5] 9. (a) all the genes in an (interbreeding) population (b) both involve the formation of new species; by the isolation of its genetic pool (in both cases); both provide conditions for natural selection; sympatric in same geographical area, allopatric in different; sympatric could be reproductive/behavioural isolation while allopatric physical isolation; example of each; (e.g. allopatric speciation of Galapagos finches and sympatric speciation due to polyploidy) Award mark only where comparison is clear. 4 max growth in brain requires more protein; increased brain correlates with change of diet from plants/leaves to fruit/meat (higher quality diet); eating meat provides more protein; larger brain implies more evolution as learning capacities increase; 2 max (c) 1 [7] HUMAN EVOLUTION 4 HUMAN EVOLUTION 10. (a) (b) cultural evolution involves passing of technology/language/customs from one generation to the next / does not affect the gene pool/change the genetic makeup while genetic evolution involves passing of genes/genetic mutations from one generation to another / OWTTE; cultural evolution allows for faster changes than genetic evolution; Accept any other valid difference. 1 max long stable periods / little change; short periods of sudden/rapid evolution; e.g. volcanic evolution/meteor impact causing sudden climatic/ environmental changes / other valid examples; 2 max [3] 11. (a) (b) (c) (d) both involve reproductive isolation / separation of gene pools; sympatric is speciation due to isolation of populations living in the same geographic area whereas allopatric is speciation due to geographic isolation; 2 analogous structure similar in appearance/function but with different evolutionary history e.g. wing of bat and wing of bird; 1 smaller/70S ribosomes in mitochondria/chloroplasts (as in prokaryotes); circular DNA in mitochondria/chloroplasts (as in prokaryotes); mitochondria/chloroplasts have double membrane; similar size/shape of mitochondria/chloroplasts to prokaryotes; 2 max opposable thumb; large range of shoulder movement; good vision / stereoscopic vision / overlapping field view; large brain relative to body size; tailless primate; Y-5 cusps of molars; 2 max [7] 12. (a) time for radiation material to decay to half its original amount / activity / mass HUMAN EVOLUTION 1 5 HUMAN EVOLUTION (b) gradualism: slow, continuous change over a long period of time; gradual accumulation of (neutral) mutations / variations; punctuated equilibrium: long periods of stability followed by sudden changes; fossil record supports this; natural selection can be intense and can cause rapid change / evolution; rapid evolution due to major environmental changes / volcanic eruptions / meteor impact / other example; only advantageous alleles ultimately survive; some mutations had no morphological effects so not visible in the fossil record; rate of evolution could have fluctuated over time; 6 max Award [4 max] if only one idea is discussed. [7] 13. (a) tool making first associated with H. habilis; requires larger brain; brain requires vast amounts of energy / consumes 40% of energy intake; so larger brain size had an effect on diet requirements / created a demand for changes in diet; food scarcity may lead to decrease in brain size; change to higher calorific diet may allow increase in brain size; more complex tool making / human society / language development required larger brain size; larger brain / better cognitive skills allowed for better hunting and gathering; led to greater calorific intake; about 2.5 MYBP (million years before present) animal foods began to occupy an increasingly prominent place in diet; animal tissues can provide the necessary structural lipid for human brain expansion; changes in the dental fossil record are indirect evidence for such a change in diet; [5] HUMAN EVOLUTION 6