CEE 626 MASONRY DESIGN SLIDES Slide Set 3 Spring 2015 (Many slides modified from MSJC Seminar Presentation) 1 Objectives Introduce the Building code (BC) and Masonry Design Standard and Specification Describe relationship between BC, Design Standard and Load Standard. Give an over view of the masonry design Standard and how it is used – assembly material properties Apply standard to the design of unreinforced masonry walls Slide 2 Masonry Codes & Standards Almost the entire US now uses the IBC (Model Building Code), we will focus on the 2015 IBC. The IBC extensively references “Consensus” Design and Material Standards: ASTM Standards for Materials ASCE 7 for Loads ACI 318 for Concrete “MSJC” (TMS 402/602) for Masonry Slide 3 IBC Masonry Requirements In the past, some of the TMS 402/602 provisions were duplicated in the IBC. Differences between the TMS 402/602 and the IBC were hard to spot. Same was true of ASTM Standards. Most of these duplicate provisions were removed from the 2009 IBC, making differences much easier to spot. More duplicate provisions were deleted from the 2012 and additional duplications were removed in the 2015 IBC Slide 4 IBC Masonry Requirements – Section 2107, ASD For ASD, IBC Section 2107 requires compliance with TMS 402 Chapter 8, except for: Modifies splice & development lengths. Allows a simpler procedure, and in some cases is more conservative and in some cases less conservative than the TMS 402 Has additional requirements for mechanical and welded splices ASTM A706 steel required for welded lap splices. ACI 318 Type 1 or 2 mechanical splices required. Limits the maximum bar size to No. 9. Slide 5 The “MSJC” Code and Specification... Masonry Standards Joint Committee - MSJC ACI (ACI 530-13) (ACI 530.1-13) 2013 “MSJC” Code and Specification ASCE (ASCE 5-13) (ASCE 6-13) Lead sponsor TMS (TMS 402-13) (TMS 602-13) Future editions will be produced solely by TMS. As such, we’ll use TMS 402/602 Slide 6 The “MSJC” Code and Specification MSJC began in 1978 MSJC develops Code and Specification under ANSI consensus procedures, for reference by model codes such IBC, NFPA New edition of the Code and Specification typically every 3 years 2011 edition is referenced by 2012 IBC 2008 edition is referenced by 2009 IBC 2005 edition is referenced by 2006 IBC 2002 edition is referenced by 2003 IBC 1999 edition is referenced by 2000 IBC Slide 7 Back to TMS 402/602 - relation between Code and Specification... TMS 402 “Code” Design provisions are given in Chapters 1 - 14 and Appendices A, B and C Sections 1.2.4 and Chapter 3 require a QA program in accordance with the Specification Section 1.4 invokes the Specification by reference. TMS 602 “Specification” verify compliance with specified f m comply with required level of quality assurance comply with specified products and execution Slide 8 2011 TMS 402 Code... MSJC TMS 602 Ch. 1 - General Requirements Ch. 2 Allowable Stress Design Ch. 3 Strength Design Ch. 4 Prestressed Masonry 3.1 - General SD 3.2 - URM 3.3 - RM 2.1 - General ASD 2.2 - URM 2.3 - RM Ch. 5 Empirical Design Ch. 6 Veneer Ch. 7 Glass Block Ch. 8 AAC 6.1 - General 6.2 - Anchored 6.3 - Adhered 2011 TMS 402 also included a new Appendix for Design of Masonry Infill Slide 9 2013 TMS 402/602 Code Reorganized... Part 1: General Part 2: Design Requirements Part 3: Engineered Design Methods Part 4: Prescriptive Design Methods Part 5: Appendices & References Chapter 1 – General Requirements Chapter 4: General Analysis & Design Considerations Chapter 8: ASD Chapter 12: Veneer Appendix A – Empirical Design of Masonry Chapter 2 – Notations & Definitions Chapter 5: Structural Elements Chapter 9: SD Chapter 13: Glass Unit Masonry Appendix B: Design of Masonry infill Chapter 3 – Quality & Construction Chapter 6: Reinforcement, Metal Accessories & Anchor Bolts Chapter 10: Prestressed Chapter 14: Masonry Partition Walls Appendix C: Limit Design of Masonry Chapter 7: Seismic Design Requirements Chapter 11: AAC References Slide 10 2013 TMS 402/602 - Reorganization Part 1: General Part 3: Engineered Design Methods Chapter 8: ASD Chapter 9: SD Chapter 10: Prestressed Chapter 11: AAC Part 4: Prescriptive Design Methods Chapter 12: Veneer Chapter 13: Glass Unit Masonry Chapter 14: Masonry Partition Walls Part 5: Appendices & References Appendix A – Empirical Design of Masonry Appendix B: Design of Masonry infill Appendix C: Limit Design of Masonry References Specification Chapter 1 – General Requirements Chapter 2 – Notations & Definitions Chapter 3 – Quality & Construction Part 2: Design Requirements Chapter 4: General Analysis & Design Considerations Chapter 5: Structural Elements Chapter 6: Reinforcement, Metal Accessories & Anchor Bolts Chapter 7: Seismic Design Requirements User Friendly/Designer Input 5 Parts with smaller focused chapters 3 Appendices Slide 11 TMS 602 Specification – Format Consistent between editions TMS 402 Code TMS 602 Specification Part 1 General Part 2 Products Part 3 Execution 1.6 Quality assurance 2.1 - Mortar 2.2 - Grout 2.3 – Masonry Units 2.4 – Reinforcement 2.5 – Accessories 2.6 – Mixing 2.7 - Fabrication 3.1 - Inspection 3.2 - Preparation 3.3 – Masonry erection 3.4 – Reinforcement 3.5 – Grout placement 3.6 – Prestressing 3.7 – Field quality control 3.8 - Cleaning Slide 12 Loads and Load Combinations Vertical loads gravity dead ( D ) and live ( L ) load overturning forces from lateral Loads Lateral loads wind ( W ) earthquake ( E ) soil pressure ( H ) or fluid pressure ( F ) restrained movements due to temperature , shrinkage or creep ( T ) ASCE 7-10 ASD Load Combinations Note code references ASCE 7-10 or Bld. Code. IBC 2012 & 2015 same 14 IBC Loads & Combinations Design Almost all reinforced masonry is designed by: Allowable Stress Design per TMS 402 Parts 1 & 2 and Chapter 8 Strength Design per TMS 402 Parts 1 & 2 and Chapter 9 Design is based on fm – Specified compressive strength of masonry Slide 16 Role of fm fm – Specified compressive strength of masonry. Synonymous to fc concrete Concrete designer states assumed value of fc compliance is verified by compression tests on cylinders cast in the field and cured under ideal conditions Masonry designer states assumed value of f’m compliance is verified by “Unit Strength Method” or by “Prism Test Method” Slide 17 To verify compliance with specified f’m Unit strength method (Specification 1.4 B 2) Estimates a conservative assemblage strength based on mortar type and unit strength (from manufacturer) Mortar must comply with ASTM C270 Grout must meet TMS 602 Specification Article 2.2 or a compressive strength of 2000 psi Prism test method (Specification 1.4 B 3) Pro: can permit optimization of materials Con: requires testing, qualified testing lab, and procedures in case of non - complying results Must comply with ASTM C1314 Slide 18 Unit Strength Method Applicability For clay masonry, 1. Units must conform to ASTM C62, ASTM C216, or ASTM C652 and are to be sampled and tested in accordance with ASTM C67. 2. Thickness of bed joints does not exceed 5/8 in. 3. For grouted masonry, the grout meets one of the following requirements: Grout conforms to ASTM C476. Minimum grout compressive strength (determined by ASTM C1019) equals f 'm but is not less than 2,000 psi*. Slide 19 Unit Strength Method Applicability For concrete masonry, 1. Units must conform to ASTM C55 or ASTM C90 and are sampled and tested in accordance with ASTM C140 2. Thickness of bed joints does not exceed 5/8 inch. 3. For grouted masonry, the grout meets one of the following requirements: Grout conforms to ASTM C476 Minimum grout compressive strength (determined by ASTM C1019) equals f 'm but is not less than 2,000 psi Slide 20 Masonry Compressive Strength Unit Strength Method Specified compressive strength of clay masonry, f’m Net area compressive strength of clay masonry, psi (MPa) 1,000 (6.90) 1,500 (10.34) 2,000 (13.79) 2,500 (17.24) 3,000 (20.69) 3,500 (24.13) 4,000 (27.58) Net area compressive strength of clay masonry units, psi (MPa) Type M or S mortar Type N mortar 1,700 (11.72) 2,100 (14.48) 3,350 (23.10) 4,150 (28.61) 4,950 (34.13) 6,200 (42.75) 6,600 (45.51) 8,250 (56.88) 8,250 (56.88) 10,300 (71.02) 9,900 (68.26) — 11,500 (79.29) — Slide 21 Unit Strength Method Specified compressive strength of concrete masonry, f’m Net area compressive strength of concrete masonry, psi (MPa) 1,700 (11.72) 1,900 (13.10) 2,000 (13.79) 2,250 (15.51) 2,500 (17.24) 2,750 (18.96) 3,000 (20.69) Net area compressive strength of concrete masonry units, psi (MPa) Type M or S mortar Type N mortar --1,900 (13.10) 1,900 (13.10) 2,350 (14.82) 2,000 (13.79) 2,650 (18.27) 2,600 (17.93) 3,400 (23.44) 3,250 (22.41) 4,350 (28.96) 3,900 (26.89) ----4,500 (31.03) ----- 1. Enter the table in these columns, knowing the masonry unit compressive strength and mortar type 2. Move across to the far left column to determine what f’m you should expect TMS 402 Part 1 General Requirements Ch. 1: Scope, Contract documents and calculations, Special Systems, Reference Standards Ch. 2: Notation, Definitions Ch. 3 Quality & Construction Slide 23 Quality Assurance: TMS 402 Chapter 3 Requires a quality assurance program in accordance with the Specification three levels of quality assurance (A, B, C) increasing levels of quality assurance require increasingly strict requirements for inspection, and for compliance with specified products and execution Slide 24 Article 1.6 – Quality assurance Quality assurance requirements address inspection tests and submittals The TMS TMS 402/602 addresses three levels of quality assurance (minimum requirements!) Increasingly severe levels of quality assurance: Level A – TMS 402 Table 3.1.1 & TMS 602 Table 3 Level B - TMS 402 Table 3.1.2 & TMS 602 Table 4 Level C - TMS 402 Table 3.1.3 & TMS 602 Table 5 Slide 25 Quality Assurance/Special Inspection Requirements depend on: Type of Structure Design/Detailing Method Formerly “Importance”, then Occupancy Category, now Risk Category Prescriptive or Engineered Criticalness of construction being considered Items having a bigger impact of structural capacity or where there is a bigger chance that something could go wrong may need continuous special inspection version other that may need only periodic special inspection Slide 26 Minimum Inspection/Testing: Types of Special Inspection Items having more of an impact of structural capacity or where there is a higher probability that something could go wrong may need more rigorous inspection: Continuous special inspection: full-time observation of work while in progress, by an approved special inspector who is present in the area where the work is being performed. Periodic special inspection: Part time or intermittent observation of work as specified, by an approved special inspector who is present in the area where the work is being performed and at the completion of the work. Note that on a job, both types of inspection may be required for different aspects of the project.* Slide 27 Inspection & Testing Requirements Type of Facility Risk (Occupancy) Category Risk (Occupancy) Category I, II, III IV (Essential) Design method Prescriptive Engineered Prescriptive Engineered Inspection (IBC) Exempt Use TMS per 1705.4 402/602 Use TMS 402/602 Use TMS 402/602 Inspection (TMS 402/602) Level A* Level B Level C Level B * No site inspection is required for Level A Slide 28 Level B Special Inspection Requirements: TMS 402 Table 3.1.2 At start of construction, verify: On a Periodic basis: Mortar proportions Mortar joint construction Location of reinforcement and connectors Prestressing technique, materials Properties of thin-bed mortar for AAC Masonry Slide 29 Level B Special Inspection Requirements: TMS 402 Table 3.1.2 During construction, inspect: On a Periodic basis: Continuously Size, location of structural elements Type, size, location of anchors Size, grade, and type of reinforcement Hot and cold weather construction Application and measurement of prestress force Welding of reinforcing bars Placement of AAC masonry units & thinbed mortar (first 5000 ft2 continuous, and then periodic) Slide 30 Level B Special Inspection Requirements: TMS 402 Table 3.1.2 Prior to grouting, verify: On a Periodic basis: Grout space is clean Reinforcement and tendon placement Grout proportions (site prepared) Mortar joint construction Slide 31 Level B Special Inspection Requirements: TMS 402 Table 3.1.2 During construction, verify: Continuously Grout placement Grouting prestress tendons Preparation of grout, mortar, prism specimens Application of prestressing Slide 32 Level C Special Inspection Requirements: TMS 402 Table 3.1.3 On a Periodic basis: Proportions of mortar, grout & prestressing grout Placement of units and mortar joint construction Placement of reinforcement, connectors and prestressing tendons & anchorages Size and location of structural elements Size, grade, type of reinforcement, anchor bolts and prestressing tendons & anchorages Hot and cold weather protection Slide 33 Level C Quality Assurance: TMS 402 Table 3.1.3 Observe preparation of grout and mortar specimens and prisms (if required) Verify compliance with required inspection provisions and approved submittals Slide 34 Level C Special Inspection Requirements: TMS 402 Table 3.1.3 Continuously: Grout space prior to grouting Grout placement Prestress grout placement Type, size, and location of anchorages to structural members and frames. Welding of reinforcement Application & measurement of prestress force Placement of AAC masonry Preparation of grout, mortar, prism specimens Slide 35 TMS 402 (& IBC) QA Requirements Required Tests and Submittals Masonry material certificates Verify f ‘m & f ‘aac prior to construction** Level A* Level B Level C • • • • • Verify f ‘m & f ‘aac every 5,000 sq. ft. during construction** • Verify proportions of materials in premixed or preblended mortar & grout • Verify slump flow & VSI of SCG *Exempt from IBC • • Periodic Continuous ** For Engineered masonry and not for Veneer, Glass United Masonry or Empirically Designed Masonry Slide 36 General TMS 602 Special Inspection Requirements for “Traditional” Masonry* Minimum Special Inspection for Traditional Masonry* Level A Level B Level C Verify compliance with approved submittals PT PT PT Verify proportions of site-prepared mortars Construction of mortar joints Placement of masonry units Location of reinforcing, connectors and anchorages - PT PT PT PT PT PT FT Grout space (prior to grouting) Grade, type, and size of reinforcing, anchor bolts & anchorages - PT PT FT FT - PT PT FT FT - PT PT PT FT FT FT Verify proportions of site-prepared grout Size, type & location of attachments to other structural elements Size and location of structural elements Observe preparation of prisms and grout or mortar specimens Grout Placement * Does not include Prestressed masonry, Hot & Cold Weather requirements, etc. Refer to MSJC for specific Requirements •PT – Part Time or Periodic FT – Full Time or Continuous Slide 37 TMS 402 Parts 1 & 2 Part 1 Part 2 Ch. 1 General Ch. 2 Notation & Definitions Ch. 4 General Analysis & Design Considerations Ch. 5. Structural Elements Ch. 6 Reinforcement Metal Accessories & Anchor Bolts Ch. 7 Seismic design requirements Ch. 3 Quality & Construction Slide 38 Restricts pour height based on width/space minus horizontal reinforcement which restricts the space Grout Pour Grout space requirements in Table 3.2.1 are intended to provide adequate room for placement of grout. Grout Lift Grout Lift Construction: TMS 402 Section 3.2 Slide 39 TMS 402 Part 2 Design Requirements Ch. 4: General Analysis & Design Considerations 4.1 Loading 4.2 Material properties 4.3 Section properties 4.4 Connections to structural frames 4.5 Masonry not laid in running bond Ch. 6: Details of reinforcement, metal accessories & anchor bolts Ch. 7 Seismic design requirements Ch. 5: Structural Elements Slide 40 Loading: TMS 402 Section 4.1 must have continuous load path design loads from governing building code or ASCE 7 - 10 must have lateral force – resisting system must consider load transfer at horizontal connections must consider effects of differential movement lateral loads must be distributed according to member stiffnesses Slide 41 Most Masonry Buildings Shear Wall/Diaphragm Systems Walls parallel to lateral forces act as shear walls to resist in-plane loads; they may resist axial loads Bond beams transfer reactions from walls to horizontal diaphragms (floors and roof), and act as diaphragm chords Walls perpendicular to lateral forces resist moments from out-of-plane loads and transfer reactions to horizontal diaphragms; they may resist axial loads Slide 42 Material Properties: TMS 402 Section 4.2 Chord modulus of elasticity, shear modulus, thermal expansion coefficients, and creep coefficients for clay, concrete and AAC masonry Moisture expansion coefficient for clay masonry Shrinkage coefficients for concrete masonry and AAC masonry Slide 43 Section Properties for strength: TMS 402 Section 4.3 Use minimum (critical) net area for computing member stresses or capacities. Capacity is governed by the weakest section; for example, Minimum face shell thickness of hollow units if face shell bedded only (typical) Include area of grouted cores for grouted masonry for shear, axial compression and in–plane compression Out of plane flexural compression typically stays in Slide 44 face shell Section Properties for stiffness: TMS 402 Sections 4.3.2 and 4.3.3 Radius of gyration and member slenderness are better represented by the average section; for example the net area of units (face shells and webs) even if the units are only face shell bedded For partially grouted and solid grouted masonry, also include grout area Slide 45 Bearing Area: TMS 402 Section 4.3.4 Direct bearing area A1 Modified bearing area A2 based on the intersection of a 45 – degree truncated pyramid with the edge of the element. See TMS 402 Section 4.3.4 and Commentary Fig. CC-4.3-2 for definitions of A1 and A2. Bearing Area A1 A2 2 A1 A1 Slide 46 TMS 402 Part 2 Design Requirements Ch. 4: General Analysis & Design Considerations Ch. 5: Structural Elements 5.1 Masonry assemblies 5,2 Beams 5.3 Columns 5.4 Pilasters 5.5 Corbels Ch. 6: Details of reinforcement, metal accessories & anchor bolts Ch. 7 Seismic design requirements Slide 47 Wall intersections: TMS 402 Section 5.1.1 nominal flange thickness, t 50% interlocking units L = 6 t for compression or unreinforced masonry in tension L = 3/4 floor - to - floor wall effective flange height for reinforced length, L masonry in tension wall to the right of movement joint not part of flange of web wall movement joint Slide 48 Effective compression width per bar: TMS 402 Section 5.1.2 For running - bond masonry, or masonry with bond beams spaced no more than 48 in. center – to – center, the width of compression area per bar for stress calculations shall not exceed the least of: Center - to - center bar spacing Six times the wall thickness (nominal) 72 in. Slide 49 Distribution of concentrated loads, running bond: TMS 402 Section 5.1.3.1 The critical area for walls laid in running bond shall not exceed the wall thickness times the smaller of: Length of bearing area plus a length determined by a dispersion of 2 vertical: 1 horizontal. That dispersion is limited by the smallest of one - half the wall height, a movement joint, the end of the wall, or an opening. Center – to – center distance between concentrated loads Slide 50 Distribution of concentrated loads, running bond: TMS 402 Section 5.1.3.1 Load Load Load 1 2 h 2 h/2 1 Effective Length Effective Effective Length Length Slide 51 Distribution of concentrated loads, running bond: TMS 402 Section 5.1.3.1 Load 1 Load 1 2 Effective Length 2 Effective Length Slide 52 Distribution of concentrated loads, other than running bond It is assumed that loads are not transferred across vertical head joints Compression stresses are calculated using a smaller critical area of masonry TMS 402 Section does not specify, but Code Commentary continues to use a 2: 1 dispersion. Slide 53 Distribution of concentrated loads under bond beams TMS 402 Section does not specify, but Code Commentary continues to use a 2: 1 dispersion. It is assumed that loads are not transferred across vertical head joints. Slide 54 Distribution of conc. loads under bond beams: TMS 402 Section 5.1.3 Bearing Plate Check bearing on hollow wall Load Load Bond Beam Bearing Plate Bond Beam Load is dispersed at a 2:1 slope Running bond Load dispersion terminates at head joint in stack bond Stack bond Slide 55 Composite versus noncomposite construction: TMS 402 Section 5.1.4 Multiwythe walls have more than one wythe of masonry Multiwythe walls may be designed for: composite action, or noncomposite action Composite action requires that collar joints be: crossed by connecting headers, or filled with mortar or grout and connected by ties Slide 56 Composite action TMS 402 Section 5.1.4.2 Composite action permits use of composite section properties in analysis and design Composite action is assumed to transfer loads and provide continuity of deformations, without slip, across collar joints TMS 402 Section limits shear stresses on collar joints or headers Slide 57 Stresses with composite action, Code Commentary - Fig. CC – 5.1-7 collar joint filled lateral load Tens. Comp. lateral load Assumed stress distribution in multiwythe walls of composite masonry Vertical Bending Horizontal Bending tension normal to bed joints tension parallel to bed joints Slide 58 Noncomposite action: TMS 402 Section 5.1.4.3 Collar joints may not contain headers, grout, or mortar Horizontal in-plane loads and gravity loads applied to one wythe are to be resisted by that wythe only Weak–axis bending moments, however, are distributed to each wythe in proportion to its flexural stiffness Slide 59 Stresses with noncomposite action, Code Commentary - Fig. 5.1-8 collar joint open lateral load Comp. Tens. Comp. Tens. lateral load Assumed stress distribution in multiwythe noncomposite walls Vertical Bending Horizontal Bending tension normal to bed joints tension parallel to bed joints Slide 60 Max. 1¼ in. (31.8 mm) Required spacing of Adjustable Ties for Non-Composite Masonry 16 in. (406 mm) Max. Vert. Spacing 1.77 Sq. Ft. (0.16 m2) Maximum Wall Surface Area Per Tie Max. Clear. 1/ 16 in. (1.6 mm) Vertical Section /16 in. (4.8 mm) Wire 3 Tie Location 16 in. (406 mm) Max. Horiz. Spacing Spacing of Adjustable Ties Eye Unit Pintle Unit Plan View Slide 61 Prescriptive Requirements for Beams: TMS 402 Section 5.2 Lintel Block or Cut Unit Shore Slide 62 Prescriptive Requirements for Beams: TMS 402 Section 5.2 Span length equals clear span plus depth, but not more than distance between support centers Moments for continuous beams based on center to - center spans Minimum bearing distance = 4 in. Lateral support on compression face required at a maximum spacing of 32 times the beam thickness (nominal) but no more than 120b2/d Must meet deflection limits of TMS 402 Section 5.2.1.4 Slide 63 Deep Beams Beam depth Alternative beam depth 00 leff leff Slide 64 Prescriptive Requirements for Columns: TMS 402 Section 5.3 Old requirements changes in 2013 TMS 402 aspect ratio of cross – section 3 height > 4 times smaller cross – sectional dimension Columns are defined in TMS 402 Section 5.3 ISOLATED member that primarily resists compressive loads h / r 99 Minimum side dimension: 8 in. Slide 65 TMS 402 Section 5.3 – Prescriptive Requirements for Columns Columns are not: wall segments between openings (these are not “isolated”) pilasters (these are not “isolated”) piers (these are defined for strength design as isolated elements that meet certain dimensional limitations ) Slide 66 Distinction between Columns and Pilasters Pilasters are thickened sections of masonry walls, are not isolated members, and are not columns Pilasters need not be reinforced If pilaster capacity includes the effect of compression reinforcement, that reinforcement must be tied laterally Slide 67 TMS 402 Section 5.3 – Prescriptive Requirements for Columns Cross – sectional dimension 8 in. h / r 99 Minimum design eccentricity = 0.1 x t 0.25% g 4.0% At least 4 longitudinal bars, laterally tied, except for the strange case of lightly loaded columns (for example, columns in a “car port” that primarily resist tension) Slide 68 Column Ties 16 times the vertical bar diameter Tie spacing Tie spacing may not exceed: 48 times the tie diameter The least dimension of the column First tie at ½ tie spacing from footing or slab Last tie at ½ spacing from support Slide 69 TMS 402 Part 2 Design Requirements Ch. 4: General Analysis & Design Considerations Ch. 5: Structural Elements Ch. 6: Details of reinforcement, metal accessories & anchor bolts Ch. 7 Seismic design requirements Slide 70 Details of Reinforcement: TMS 402 Section 6.1 reinforcing bars must be embedded in grout; joint reinforcement can be embedded in mortar placement of reinforcement protection for reinforcement standard hooks Slide 71 Anchor Bolts: TMS 402 Section 6.2 Headed bolts, J - bolts or L - bolts Must be embedded in grout Slide 72 Anchor Bolts: TMS 402 Section 6.2 Tensile capacity governed by tensile breakout tensile pullout yield of anchor in tension Shear capacity governed by shear breakout masonry crushing shear pryout yield of anchor in shear For combined tension and shear, use linear interaction Slide 73 TMS 402 Section Commentary - Fig. CC-6.2-1 Tensile breakout failure of masonry Tension Force lb assumed cone for calculation of Apt, Equation 6-1 lb 45° conical failure surface Apt Tension Force 45° conical failure surface 2 b Slide 74 Effective embedment length, lb TMS 402 Section 6.2.4 and 6.2.5 Plate and headed bolts embedment measured perpendicular from the masonry surface to bearing surface of plate or head of bolt Bent anchors embedment measured perpendicular from masonry surface to bearing surface of bent end, minus one anchor bolt diameter Slide 75 TMS 402 Section Commentary Fig. CC-6.2-7 Shear breakout failure of masonry Shear Force Apv 2 2be 45 Apv lbe Slide 76 TMS 402 Part 2 Design Requirements Ch. 4: General Analysis & Design Considerations Ch. 5: Structural Elements Ch. 6: Details of reinforcement, metal accessories & anchor bolts Ch. 7 Seismic design requirements Slide 77 Seismic Design: TMS 402 Chapter 7 Applies to all masonry except Walls must either be isolated from the seismic force - resisting system classified as shear walls Objective is to improve performance of masonry structures in earthquakes glass unit masonry and veneer improves ductility of masonry members improves connectivity among masonry members Requirements for AAC masonry differ slightly Slide 78 Seismic Design: TMS 402 Chapter 7 Assign a structure’s Seismic Design Category (SDC) according to ASCE 7 - 10 SDC depends on seismic risk (geographic location), risk category (importance), underlying soil SDC determines required types of shear walls (prescriptive reinforcement) prescriptive reinforcement for other masonry elements permitted design approaches for LFRS Slide 79 Seismic Design: TMS 402 Chapter 7 Seismic design requirements are based on ASCE 7 - 10 Seismic Design Categories (from A up to F) Requirements are cumulative; requirements in each “higher” category are added to requirements in the previous category Slide 80 Minimum Reinforcement, Shear Wall (SW) Types SW Type Minimum Reinforcement SDC Empirically Designed none A Ordinary Plain none A, B Detailed Plain Vertical reinforcement = 0.2 in.2 at corners, within 16 in. of openings, within 8 in. of movement joints, maximum spacing 10 ft; horizontal reinforcement W1.7 @ 16 in. or #4 in bond beams @ 10 ft A, B Ordinary Reinforced same as above A, B, C Intermediate Reinforced same as above, but vertical reinforcement @ 4 ft A, B, C Special Reinforced same as above, but horizontal reinforcement @ 4 ft, and = 0.002 any Slide 81 Seismic Design: TMS 402 Chapter 7 Seismic Design Category A drift limit of 0.007 from ASCE 7 - 10 (Section 12.12.1) for typical masonry structures minimum design connection force for wall - to roof and wall - to - floor connections from ASCE 7 - 10 (Section 12.11.2) Seismic Design Category B lateral force – resisting system cannot be designed empirically Slide 82 Seismic Design: TMS 402 Chapter 7 Seismic Design Category C Shear walls must meet minimum prescriptive requirements for reinforcement and connections (ordinary reinforced, intermediate reinforced, or special reinforced) Other walls must meet minimum prescriptive requirements for horizontal or vertical reinforcement Slide 83 Requirements for Detailed Plain SWs and SDC C: TMS 402 Section 7.3.2.3 roof connectors @ 48 in. max oc roof diaphragm #4 bar (min) within 16 in. of top of parapet Top of Parapet #4 bars around openings #4 bar (min) within 8 in. of corners & ends of walls 24 in. or 40 db past opening #4 bar (min) @ diaphragms continuous through control joint #4 bar (min) within 8 in. of all control joints control joint #4 bars @ 10 ft oc #4 bars @ 10 ft oc or W1.7 joint reinforcement @ 16 in. oc Slide 84 Seismic Design: TMS 402 Chapter 7 Seismic Design Category D Masonry that is part of the lateral force – resisting system must be reinforced so that v + h 0.002, and v and h 0.0007 Type N mortar and masonry cement mortars are prohibited in the seismic force – resisting system Shear walls must meet minimum prescriptive requirements for reinforcement and connections (special reinforced) Other walls must meet minimum prescriptive requirements for horizontal and vertical reinforcement Slide 85 Requirements for Special Reinforced Shear Walls: TMS 402 Section 7.3.2.6 roof connectors @ 48 in. max oc roof diaphragm #4 bar (min) within 16 in. of top of parapet Top of Parapet #4 bars around 24 in. or 40 db openings past opening #4 bar (min) within 8 in. of corners & ends of walls #4 bar (min) @ diaphragms continuous through control joint #4 bar (min) within 8 in. of all control joints control joint #4 bars @ 4 ft oc #4 bars @ 4 ft oc Slide 86 Seismic Design Categories E and F: TMS 402 Section 7.4.5 Additional reinforcement requirements for masonry not laid in running bond and used in nonparticipating elements Horizontal Reinforcement of at least 0.0015 Ag Horizontal Reinforcement must be no more than 24 in. oc. Must be fully grouted and constructed of hollow open-end units or two wythes of solid units Slide 87 Limit Design – Appendix C New to 2013 TMS 402 Alternative Design Method for Special Reinforced Shear Walls Useful for design of complex, perforated wall configurations Good for traditional methods Where direct design can help Slide 88 Limit Design: Seismic Design of Reinforced Masonry Structures Combines… Linear-Elastic Analysis (conventional) to identify potential yield mechanisms. Using Force - based design (ASCE 7 - 10) Emphasizes strength Displacement based design in considering component deformation capacity Slide 89 Force-based Seismic Design Limitations uncoupled cantilever walls are easy to design coupled cantilever walls are more difficult to design walls with arbitrary openings may be impossible to design rationally Slide 90 Limit Design: Seismic Design of Reinforced Masonry Structures Design Methodology Seismic Analysis > Yield Mechanism > Verify Strength and Displacement vs. Full Structure Hinging Base Hinging Slide 91 Limit Design: Seismic Design of Reinforced Masonry Structures Design Considerations Yielding and non-yielding components are detailed to achieve desired ductility or strength, respectively Joints are detailed to develop adequate moment capacity for yielding wall components Use of shear reinforcement in both direction Locating lap splices of flexural steel outside of plastic hinge zones, otherwise design for overstrength Slide 92 Limit Design: Seismic Design of Reinforced Masonry Structures Impact on Design Reduced flexural reinforcement Relevant ductility checks Compared against traditional design methodology Focus on expected yield zones over prescriptive code ductility requirements Simple Approach Based off of conventional seismic load Direct Calculation of control mechanism (no iteration) Slide 93 Allowable – Stress Design: TMS 402 Chapter 8 fundamental basis Anchor bolts Shear stress limits on multi-wythe walls development and splices of reinforcement unreinforced masonry reinforced masonry Slide 94 Allowable – Stress Design: TMS 402 Chapter 8 fundamental basis Anchor bolts Shear stress limits on multi-wythe walls development and splices of reinforcement unreinforced masonry reinforced masonry Slide 95 Allowable Tensile capacities for Anchor Bolts: TMS 402 Sec. 8.1.3.3 tensile breakout Headed Bolts and Bent Bar Bab 1.25 Apt f m' (8 - 1) and (8 - 3) tensile pullout Bent bar Bap 0.6 f ed d b 120 lb ed d b d b ' m (8 - 4) steel yield Headed Bolts and Bent Bar Bas 0.6 Ab f y (8 - 2) and (8 - 5) Slide 96 Allowable Shear capacities for anchor bolts: TMS 402 Sec. 8.1.3.3.2 Same for Bent Bars and for Headed Bolts shear breakout Bvb 1.25 Apv (8 - 6) f Ab (8 - 7) masonry crushing Bvc 350 f m' 4 ' m shear pryout Bvpry 2.0 Bab 2.5 Apt f m' (8 - 8) steel yield Bvs 0.36 Ab f y (8 - 9) Slide 97 Allowable – Stress Design: TMS 402 Chapter 8 fundamental basis Anchor bolts Shear stress limits on multi-wythe walls development and splices of reinforcement unreinforced masonry reinforced masonry Slide 98 Stresses with composite action 8.1.4.2 Shear stresses developed at the interfaces between wythes and collar joints or within headers shall not exceed the following: (a) mortared collar joints, 7 psi (48.3 kPa). (b) grouted collar joints, 13 psi (89.6 kPa). (c) headers,1.3 (specified unit compressive strength of header Psi)1/2 (MPa) (over net area of header). Slide 99 Development of reinforcement embedded in grout: TMS 402 Sec. 8.1.6 Required embedment length in tension addresses splitting from bar to surface and bar to bar ld 0.13 d b2 f y K f m' 12 in. (bars) , 6 in. (wires) (8 - 12) For epoxy – coated bars or wires, increase the above values by 50% Slide 100 Development of reinforcement embedded in grout: TMS 402 Sec. 8.1.6 Other requirements for flexural reinforcement Equation (8-12) used for lap splices Can decrease lap splice using confining steel. 1 .0 2 2.3 Asc fy db 2 .5 (8 - 13) Slide 101 ASD Unreinforced Masonry: TMS 402 Section 8.2 8.2.1 Scope 8.2.2 Design Criteria 8.2.3 Design Assumptions 8.2.4 Axial compression and flexure 8.2.5 Axial Tension 8.2.6 Shear Slide 102 Ratio of Wall Strength to Compressive Strength of Masonry Code Commentary Fig. CC - 8.2-1 1.2 (test results) 1.0 0.8 2 70r h 2 h l 140r 0.6 Slenderness affects axial compressive strength 0.4 fit to test data stability failure 0.2 0 h/t 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 h/r 0 25 50 75 99 125 150 Slide 103 Allowable axial compressive stress: TMS 402 Section 8.2.4 Depends on slenderness (h / r) 2 h h 1 ' for 99 Fa f m 1 r 4 140 r 1 70 r Fa f m' 4 h 2 for h 99 r (8 - 16) (8 - 17) Also requires a stability check P (1 / 4) Pe Pe (8 - 15) Em I 2 h 2 e 1 0.577 r 3 (8 - 19) Slide 104 Allowable Flexural Stresses of URM: TMS 402 Section 8.2.4 Flexural compression 1 ' Fb f m 3 Flexural tension (Table 8.2.4.2) out - of - plane bending (traditional values) lower values for masonry cement and air - entrained portland cement - lime mortar higher values for grouted masonry Factors of safety around 2.5 Values for in – plane and out - of - plane flexural tension are equal Slide 105 Linear interaction for combined loads: TMS 402 Section 8.2.4.1 Members subjected to combined flexure and axial compression shall satisfy TMS 402 Equation (8-14) fa fb 1 Fa Fb (8 - 14) Slide 106 Shear for unreinforced masonry: TMS 402 Section 8.2.6 Calculated shear stress VQ fv In b (8 - 20) Allowable stress is lowest of 1 .5 f m' 120 psi Nv 0.45 An Where = 37 psi running bond or not running bond and fully grouted, = 60 psi for running bond and grouted , and = 15 psi otherwise Slide 107 Shear for unreinforced masonry: TMS 402 Section 8.2.6.3 Normalized web area on concrete masonry units (ASTM C140) must not be less than 27 in2/ft2 or you must check shear stresses in the web do not exceed 1.5 f m' Slide 108 Rational Design of Load – Bearing Walls – Also must account for holes in wall and span direction gravity and out – of – plane loads are resisted by combinations of horizontal and vertical strips vertical strips roof diaphragm horizontal strips ALLOWABLE STRESS (ASD) DESIGN URM WALLS – OUT OF PLANE AND IN- PLANE VERTICAL LOADS If Load bearing there is a vertical load May be eccentrically Applied Roof/floor Diaphragm Supports Wall ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls Out-of-Plane Ex1a – MDG TMS 14 111 On Board ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls Out-of-Plane Ex1b – MDG TMS 14 113 On Board ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls Out-of-Plane Similar to Ex MDG TMS 115 On Board ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls Out-of-Plane Ex1 – MDG TMS Revised from text – Strength level wind loads – Higher Allowables f’m = 1500 psi Wind load = 23. psf Strength Level (ASCE 7-10) Mortar Type TBD Design Walls 20’ Note that actual max moment is slightly lower than mid-span – But code allows you to look at mid-span 16.67’ ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls Out-of-Plane Ex1 – ASSUME THE AXIAL LOAD IS 650 lb/ft DEAD LOAD and the rest LIVE LOAD Converted joist reaction to per ft load And assume Strength level Wind load is 23 psf e found by assuming the bearing conditions shown Mwind= 23. plf x (3.33)2/2 x 12in/ft = 1530.3 lb.in Mwind = (- 1530.3 lb.in/2 + (23 plf x (16.67)2/8) x 12in/ft) = 8057 lb.in M at top due to axial load 1530.3 lb.in M DL = 650 x 2.48” = 1612 lb.in, M LL = 400 x 2.48” = 992 lb.in at mid-height ½ these values M= ½ Pe 8057 lb.in +? Check Shear! Critical Locations Top of wall Mid-height Bottom of wall (rarely) Look at all load combinations but D+(L or S or Lr) OR D + .75(L or S or Lr) +.75 (.6W or .7E) OR 0.6 D + (.6W or .7E) usually critical Check bearing under load (D+L) - assume a 4” x 6” bearing plate fbr= P/A1 = 1050 / (4 x 6) = 43.5 psi (average) < ¼ (1500) = 375 psi Most people will assume code implies this is an average stress even though it’s inconsistent with e calculation Check axial Stress under load (D+L) top of wall just under parapet and load since it may be critical - it must be less than Fa. Parapet weight Or use Tek note 14-01B 39.4 psi is less than 280 psi therefore fa ≤ Fa OK note that D+L load combo is critical at this level for this check - no other combos needs to be addressed Check top of wall (D+L) For net flexural tension fbt= -fa+fb ? fb (D+L) = (MDL + MLL)/S = (1612+992)/81 = 31.2 psi fbt= -39.4+31.2 = -7.9 psi (still in compression therefore OK) Check D + .75 L + .75 (0.6W) at the top (this produces more tension stress-most times) fa= -(650+400 x 0.75)/30 = - 31.7 psi fb= (1612+0.75 x 992+ 0.75 x 0.6 x1530.3)/81 = 37.6 psi fbt= -fa+fb = -31.7 + 37.6 psi = 6.1 psi Ft = ? Lowest allow. for Type N masonry cement normal to bed joints hollow = 12 psi Any mortar will work – OK So far ft ≤ Ft (See Table 8.2.4.2) Should also check fb ≤ Fb = 1/3 f’m = 1500/3 = 500 psi (all are well below this value) Bending OK at this level Check Stability at Top - D+L always governs since it is always determined using the eccentricity (e) associated with the axial loads only Check Stability at Top - D+L P ≤ ¼ Pe based on 1 ft design width again P = 1050 lb Check Stability at Top - D+L Pe = π2 (900 x 1500) (334)/(16.67 x 12)2 x [1-0.577 (2.48/2.84)]3 = 13582 lb ¼ Pe = 3395 lb > 1050 lb therefore OK Note we could reduce the applied e by accounting for the concentric axial weight of the parapet – e effective at top = M/P = (1612+992)/(1050 + 3.33 x 40) = 2.20 in. Check Combined Compression Stresses D +.75 L + 0.75 (0.6)W or D + L critical ? Too close check both fa/Fa + fb/Fb ≤ 1 = 39.4/280 + 31.2/500 = 0.202 (D+L) less than 1 OK fa/Fa + fb/Fb ≤ 1 = 31.7/280 + 37.6/500 = 0.19 (D+.75L+.75(0.6W)) less than 1 OK Check Mid-height of the Wall Again we should check stability but the top is more critical and there is no bearing check Check axial stress at wall base (more critical - later) Here just check bending and combined stresses. Bending (normally check 0.6D+0.6W & D + 0.75L+ 0.750(0.6W) – the first load case governs for tension fb(wind) = (0.6 x 8057) /81.0 = 59.7 psi, fb(dead)= 650(2.48/2)(0.6)/81.0 = 5.97 psi fa(dead) = (650 + 11.67 x 40)/30 = 37.2 psi x 0.6 = 22.32 Ft = -22.32+ 59.7 +5.97 = 43.3 psi >> than 33 psi allowable I could get for PCL Type S What do we do? 1. Put more concentric axial load on the wall 2. Make the wall thicker 3. Grout the wall 4. Reinforce the wall Lets try 3 Check Mid-height of the Wall - solid grouted 8” wall Again we should check the top again but it worked hollow, it will work solid. Bending (normally check .6D+0.6W & D + 0.75L+ 0.75(0.6W) – first load case governs for tension S= 116.3 in3 fb(wind) = (8057)/116.3 = 69.8 psi , fb(dead)= 650(2.48/2)(0.6)/116.3 = 4.16 psi fa(dead) = (650 + 11.67 x 78)/(12 x 7.625) = 17.1 psi Ft = -17.1 (0.6) + 0.6 x 69.8 +4.16 = 35.8 psi < than 77 psi allowable (Type N Masonry cement) OK Check combined bending and axial compression D+.75L+.75 (0.6W) Fb = 500 psi h/r = (16.67 x 12)/2.2 = 90.9 Fa = .25 (1500) [1- 16.67(12)/(140 x2.2)]2= 329 psi (17.1 + .75 (400)/(12x7.625) )/329 + [69.8 x 0.75 x0.6+ (650+.75 x 400) x 2.48/2/116.3]/500 = 0.063 + 0.083 = 0.15 <<<1.0 therefore OK You should check the base of the wall for fa < Fa - (maximum value for fa) however the critical load combination is D + L and increasing the axial stress by 1 psi for each foot of height (~17 psi) results in fa ~ 60 psi <<< Fa= 329 psi. Check Top of Wall for Shear- solid grouted 8” wall (normally check .6D+0.6W & D + 0.75L+ 0.75(0.6W) – V wind = 23 x (20 x 10)/16.67 = 275.9 lb V dead = 1612 lb.in/ (16.67(12)) = 8.06lb V (.6D+0.6W) = 165.5 lb fv = VQ/Ib at max (solid rectangle) = 3/2 (165.5)/(7.626 x 12) = 2.71 psi This is much smaller than the critical allowable Fv = v + .45 Nv/An = 37 psi + .45 Nv/An OK USE A SOLID GROUTED 8in CMU WALL with TYPE N MASONRY CEMENT MORTAR IT WOULD MOST LIKELY BETTER TO REINFORCE OF THE WALL MORE LATER!!!! ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls loaded laterally In-Plane – Shear Any vertical loads are going to cause the Wall to bend outof-plane so check wall as described previously for OOP Lateral Load for roof or floor Length of wall = L Applied parallel to wall length h Base Shear Over turning moment Just look at in-plane bending and shear ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls loaded In-Plane 1) Check Bending (flexural stresses) Flexural Tension almost always governs ft = My/I ft max = M/S = Flexural tensile stresses usually govern design ≤ Ft flexural compression fb= My/I , fb max = M/S Note that the depth of section is now , d= L and width, b, is t (for solid) or t faceshell Remember that for out-of-plane t = depth of section and b = effective length of wall. Note Ft in-plane ignores flashing. May not be conservative. May want to use Ft = 0. Also check fb ≤ Fb = (1/3) fm’ ASD - Shear for Unreinforced Masonry In-Plane 2) Check Shear fv = VQ/Ib ≤ Fv (As before for out-of-plane plane) Fv = Allowable In plane stress (Can also be used for outof-plane - conservative) and is lowest of : ' 1.5 fm 120 psi Nv 0.45 An ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls In-Plane • • Do examples of Unreinforced Wall Design Leave room for notes on the following examples done on board 131 ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls loaded laterally In-Plane Lateral Load for roof or floor Length of wall = L Applied parallel to wall length h Base Shear Over turning moment 132 ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls In-Plane 20 ft 16.67 ft Wind 17 psf 30 ft 30 ft 133 ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls In-Plane Reaction to shear wall = 204 x 30/2 1 ft Design Width = 3060 lb Uniform Load at Roof diaphragm Produced by wall spanning to roof = Load = 17 lb/ft x 20’ x 20’/2 (1/16.67’) 20 ft 16.67 ft = 204 lb/ft Wind 30 ft 17 psf 30 ft 134 ASD Design of Unreinforced Walls In-Plane Lateral Load for roof or floor Length of wall = L= 30 ft Reaction to shear wall = 3060 lb 16.67 f t Over turning moment = 3060 x 16.67 ft = 51,010 lb.ft 135 On Board Assume 8” Hollow block (CMU) wall with a weight of 37 psf Check base of wall for flexure - Assume Face shell bedded Bending (normally check .6D+0.6W & D + 0.75L+ 0.75(0.6W) – first load case governs for tension Section modulus - you have two strips 1.25” wide going the full length of the wall. So S = 2 x1.25 (30 x 12)2/6 = 54000 in3 fb(wind) = (0.6) x51,010 x 12/54000 = 0.6 x11.33 = 6.8 psi fa(dead) = 20 x37x30/(30 x 12x(1.25+1.25)) = 24.67 psi ft= = -24.67( (0.6) +6.8 = -8.0 psi Still in compression so any mortar would be OK. Check combined bending and axial compression D+.75L+.75 (06W) Fb = 500 psi h/r = (16.67 x 12)/2.84 = 70.5 (same as before – for Out-of-plane) Fa = .25 (1500) [1- 16.67(12)/(140 x2.84)]2= 280 psi fa = 24.67 psi since all dead load and only wind produces flexure so fb = 0.75 (6.8) Thus fa/Fa+fb/Fb = 24.67/280+.75(6.8)/500 = = 0.088 + 0.010 = 0.098 <<<1.0 therefore OK . No applied load at top of wall so no stability check needed Check shear Shear is constant over the height of the shear wall and we want to check the greatest shear load under the lowest axial load (gives lowest capacities) By inspection 0.6D+0.6W will give the above conditions at the top of the wall Two rectangular strips go the full length of the wall and are essentially two thin rectangular sections 1.25 in wide. So we can say the maximum shear stress= fs(max wind) =VQ/Ib = 3/2 (V)/An = 3/2 (3060) / (2.5)(30 x12) = 5.1 psi x 0.6 = 3.06 psi Allowable Shear = Fv = ? = The smallest of the following 1.5 f m' 120 psi 1.5 1500 58.1 psi 120 0.45 Nv 37 0.45(0) 37 psi governs 7.5 psi An OK in Shear Use a 8" Hollow CMU Face shell bedded Any mortar is likely wor k but the assumption s for the compressio n stress check assumed Type S masonry Cement for Determinat ion of f' m