Business Studies Grade 12 Topic 3: Ethics and Professionalism INTRODUCTION: o Ethics refers to conduct we perceive as right and wrong. o Business ethics refers to accepted principles of right and wrong that direct the behaviour of business people, employers and employees. o Business ethics involve: • Corporate social responsibility. • Issues regarding the rights and duties of a company and its shareholders. • Issues concerning relations between different companies, e.g. takeovers and industrial espionage. • Leadership issues, e.g. corporate governance. • Political contributions made by business enterprises. • The misuse of corporate ethics policies as marketing instruments. ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR AND ETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: o Ethical behaviour goes beyond obeying laws, rules and o o o o regulations and involves doing the right thing. In simple terms, ethics means the moral principles that serve as a guide between right and wrong. Ethical business practices refer to honest when doing business, safety in the workplace and social and environmental issues, for example. It should also be borne in mind that what is ethically for one culture / population group it is unethical for another group. Ethical codes have been developed for industries, companies, managers and employees because the cost of white collar crime is high – both for businesses and society. ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR AND ETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: o A code of ethics is a document which explains a business’ values and principles. o Businesses should have a strict code of ethics for their employees and this code must be strictly enforced. o White collar crime refers to crimes such as fraud and money laundering. o The nature of ethical decisions and actions can be measured against the following questions: • Do the decision / action comply with the company’s code of ethics? • Are the decision / action within the framework of the law? • Are the decision / action fair to the company’s stakeholders? • Do I feel positive about my decision / action? ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR AND ETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: The King Code (King III) o Business entities should act as responsible corporate citizens. o But issues like ethics and corruption challenge responsible o o o o citizenship. The King Code of corporate governance provides a framework for dealing with issues such as corporate governance, ethics and corruption. Corporate governance refers to the way in which a company is governed and it explains the relationship between the company and its stakeholders (e.g. shareholders, customers, directors, managers) The Code was developed by Judge Mervyn King and the third version of the King Code (King III) was released early in 2009. Retired Judge Mervyn King was chairman of the first committee on Corporate Governance in July 1993. ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR AND ETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: The King Code (King III) o The Code applies to all entities. o The reason for the development and implementation of the Code was the occurrence of corruption in businesses. o King III focuses on: • • • • • • • • Responsibility Accountability Discipline Fairness Leadership Independence Transparency Social responsibility ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR AND ETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: The King Code (King III) o The Code provides detail on: • The boards and directors: role, composition, appointment process, director development, remuneration of directors. • Audit committees • Risk management • Managing stakeholder relationships. • Internal audits • Integrated sustainability reporting and disclosure • Compliance with laws, regulations, rules and standards. • Compliance and enforcement • Fundamental and affected transactions ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: Criteria of ethical and professional behaviour o Businesses are operating in an ethical and professional manner if the following criteria are met: The business must create benefits for society. The business must be sustainable. The business must not be harmful to society. Business operations must take place within the boundaries of the law. • Business operations must be carried out responsibly. • • • • ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: Unethical business practices o Unethical business practice does not comply with the above criteria. o Examples of unethical business practice includes: BUSINES PRACTICE: Advertising UNETHICAL: Unfair advertising refers to practices like exaggerating the abilities of a product, or marketing second-hand goods as new goods. It implies that consumers are being misled on purpose. ETHICAL: Fair advertising implies that a product is advertised for what it really is. ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: Unethical business practices o Examples of unethical business practice includes: BUSINES PRACTICE: Selecting, appointing and promoting employees UNETHICAL: Nepotism – appointing or promoting family members even if they are not best qualified for a job. ETHICAL: Selecting and appointing employees based on fair selection criteria such as qualifications, skills and experience ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: Unethical business practices o Examples of unethical business practice includes: BUSINES PRACTICE: Pricing UNETHICAL: Price fixing – competitors agree to sell their products at the same prices. Usually competitors agree on selling goods at a high price to secure maximum profit. ETHICAL: Determining prices of goods by taking into account market related factors like supply, demand and the state of the economy. ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: Unethical business practices o Examples of unethical business practice includes: BUSINES PRACTICE: UNETHICAL: ETHICAL: Applying for a tender Bribing officials to ensure a tender. Applying for a tender in the prescribed manner by meeting deadlines and tender requirements. Dealing with waste Dumping waste in places where it is not permitted, for example in a river. All companies generate waste in their operations. This waste should be dealt with and disposed of responsibly and legally. ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: More examples of ETHICAL and UNETHICAL behaviour Examples of ETHICAL behaviour: • Objective and impartial action. • • • • • • • Transparency Confidentiality of information. Caring for the environment. Avoid conflicts of interest. Stay within legal provisions. Committed and responsible. Take reasonable steps to ensure that employees behave correctly, etc. ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: More examples of ETHICAL and UNETHICAL behaviour Examples of UNETHICAL behaviour: • Dishonesty, fraud and lack of transparency: for example: the truth about the origin of the product is fabricated, forged products are marketed under a well-known brand, not honest when information is provided. • Maximum profit at the expense of customers: price of products continues to rise while the purchase price was reduced. • Falsification of documents: ‘creative accounting’ to keep shareholders happy or to evade income taxes. • Infringement on other people’s privacy: use of confidential information of stakeholders for personal benefits. ETHICAL AND UNETHICAL BUSINESS PRACTICE: More examples of ETHICAL and UNETHICAL behaviour Examples of UNETHICAL behaviour: • Sexual discrimination: favouring certain genders in the appointment of employees to fill vacant positions. • Business espionage: illegally obtain information about the business of a competitor or new products developed by competitors. • Emotional manipulation of people: encourage people to buy products now because a scarcity in the future will be encountered or that prices will be increased. • Tax evasion: do not declare all income that the business has earned, etc. • Bribery: e.g. pay someone or give the person an asset such as a vehicle to receive certain favours in return. THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ETHICS AND PROFESSIONALISM: ETHICS: • To do the right thing. PROFESSIONALISM: • Certain behaviour expected from a professional job. PROFESSIONAL AND UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICES: o A professional person is someone who is paid to perform specialised tasks, e.g. doctors, pharmacists. o Nowadays, the term is applicable to a broader career span to include highly qualified professions and skills e.g. professional artists, football and rugby players, etc. o Professional business practice describes appropriate behaviour for an occupation. o Doctors, accountants and teachers, for example, all have their own rules of professional conduct. o Professional behaviour involves doing what you are supposed to do while you are at work. PROFESSIONAL AND UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICES: o Criteria for professionals: • Exceptional and specialised knowledge in the professional field • Excellent skills in the profession • Good quality performance • High standards of professional ethics, behaviour and work activities • Good motivation and work moral • Master in his / her area o Any person can be professional in his / her work. It is no longer just about qualifications and university degrees, but also about hard work, honesty, attitude and values and social responsibility. o Work should be dealt with, with pride and dedication to maintain high standards of performance. PROFESSIONAL AND UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICES: o Examples of professional and unprofessional behaviour: BEHAVIOUR: Use of work time PROFESSIONAL: Appropriate use of work time involves working productively during the time an employee spends at work. UNPROFESSIONAL: Abusing work time for personal use, e.g. making personal telephone calls, wasting time, spending hours surfing the internet on the employer’s expense. PROFESSIONAL AND UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICES: o Examples of professional and unprofessional behaviour: BEHAVIOUR: PROFESSIONAL: UNPROFESSIONAL: Dealing with clients and customers Be honest and realistic. Refrain from saying only what a client or customer wants to her, but say things as they are. Overpromising – making promises you know you won’t be able to keep. Dress Dress appropriately, especially when dealing with clients or customers. Avoid inappropriate dress, e.g. clothes that are to casual for work – people won’t take you seriously Being on time Plan your time so that you are always on time. Arriving on time shows respect for other people’s time. Being late for appointments shows lack of respect for other people’s time. Conduct towards colleagues and employees Treat employees and colleagues with respect. Avoid gossiping at the office. PROFESSIONAL AND UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICES: o Examples of professional and unprofessional behaviour: BEHAVIOUR: Pursuing personal gain at the employer’s expense PROFESSIONAL: Everything in an employer’s office should be used for work purposes. UNPROFESSIONAL: For example, using and employer’s computer and internet service to trade shares while you are supposed to be working. PROFESSIONAL AND UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICES: o More examples of unprofessional behaviour: • Professional misconduct on social media / websites / blogs, etc. • Discuss work problems with other people in person or through on-line talks. • Hate speech. • Use of foul language. • Rudeness. • Poor telephone etiquette PROFESSIONAL AND UNPROFESSIONAL BUSINESS PRACTICES: o Principles for professional behaviour: PRINCIPLE: EXPLANATION: Respect Respect the rights of others and the image of the profession / business. Integrity Honest behaviour within the law and the norms of the profession / business. Competence Apply skills to the benefit of the business, community and environment. Confidentiality Do not submit customer information to anyone else or use it for own gain. Objectivity Act objectively without bias and prejudice but fair towards others. Development Try to continuously improve their own skills and encourage others to do the same. THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: o Personal ethics refers to an individual’s conscience, while professional ethics refers to the adherence to a professional code. o The two roles can sometimes be in conflict with each other: An auditor audited his friend’s books. It is found that the accounting was irregular and there was tax evasion over a period of time. His personal ethics will be loyalty to his friend but professional ethics require him to report the irregularity. o The difference between ethical and professional behaviour is based on cultural, religious and community norms. THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR: PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: • Refers to a set of values that are morally acceptable in society. • A set of desired practices, e.g. treating people with respect. • Businesses develop their own codes of ethics for best practice. • Specific occupational groups have developed their own codes of professionalism. THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: ETHICAL BEHAVIOUR: • Ethical conduct is a pre-requisite for being professional. PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: • Being professional means: Demonstrating appropriate behaviour towards colleagues and clients or customers. Performing tasks to the best of one’s abilities. Not pursuing personal agendas as the company’s expense. Representing your employer with dignity. Keeping work-related promises. THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: o The link between ethical behaviour and professionalism is clear. o Unethical behaviour almost certainly also constitutes unprofessional behaviour. o However, being unprofessional doesn’t always involve unethical behaviour, for example: BEHAVIOUR: UNETHICAL: UNPROFESSIONAL: Stealing money from an employer. √ √ Arriving late for an appointment. x √ WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: o Although the main purpose of business is to make profits for the owner(s) / shareholders, there is increasing pressure on businesses to provide professional, ethical and responsible business practices. o It requires that businesses always have to find ways to strike a balance between profit and the application of ethical and professional business practices. o The provisions of the King Code should be applied. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Not starting a venture at the expense of someone else o An enterprise should not exist at the detriment of employees, the community or the environment. o The enterprise should make a positive contribution towards alleviating poverty, creating employment and uplifting society. o The management team may not take unnecessary risks with investors’ money. E.g. directors of companies should use the capital invested by shareholders in the company, wisely and transparently. o Examples of this unprofessional business practice were Master Bond in the nineties and Fidentia in the 2000s. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Not starting a venture at the expense of someone else o Master Bond, as a business, stole over R600 million of pensioners’ savings and retirement money invested in the business. This business pretended that they were a registered bank, whose deposits from pensioners are protected by the SA Reserve Bank. • They received deposits as investment, especially from pensioners and these deposits would be used to buy real estate on which dwellings and shops would be built. • Most of these developments had never existed and some of the land Master Bond indicated they have bought was in the sea and not on land. • Documents were falsified to indicate that it seems that the deposits (investments) were used to develop property. • While the investors lost their money, the owners and managers of Master Bond lived in luxury WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Not starting a venture at the expense of someone else o In the Fidentia scandal, the owner and executive management of Fidentia took R694 million form the pension fund of the “Living Hands – trust” for widows and orphans to reinvest it. • While the vulnerable persons (widows and orphans) were waiting for monthly payments (interest) on the investment, the executive management of Fidentia never reinvested the money, but it was used to pay themselves huge salaries. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Payment of fair wages o Employees must be compensated for their contribution towards the enterprise. o The efforts of employees contribute to the enterprise’s profit and employees o o o o o o should be compensated accordingly. The salaries of executives and employees should be in proportion to the position the employee held. In some businesses (such as Master Bond and Fidentia) the executives received exorbitant salaries while employees received meagre salaries. Employees may not be exploited by giving them minimum salaries just because jobs are scarce and that they feel that they need to work for a wage / salary that the employer offer. Compensation and working conditions may not be weaker than the BCEA specified for the specific industry. Provision must be made for fair performance appraisal and promotion possibilities. This appraisal should be agreed between the employer and employee. The evaluation of ethical behaviour should be part of the performance appraisal system. Nepotism should be avoided. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Regular payment of tax o Legislation compels businesses and individuals that generate o o o o o income, to pay tax. “Creative accounting” where some income is not recorded, may not e applied as business practice “. If people or businesses evade tax, it is unfair to all people and business enterprises that regularly pay tax. Tax returns should be submitted in time (before the annual deadline) at the South African Revenue Service (SARS). These returns must have a fair statement of revenue and expenditure. Information technology may not be used to manipulate income or to make transactions’ data to occur complex in order to make inspection difficult. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Regular payment of tax o Tax officers should under no circumstances be bribed to accept incorrect information. o In cases where the tax officer suggests that a bribe will be accepted for incorrect tax information, that officer must be reported to SARS. o Tax money is used to the advantage of everybody. o Tax money is applied for the benefit of all and to keep society functioning, e.g. • • • • • Funding the police service Building and maintaining prisons Building public hospitals Maintaining and building new roads Education WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Use reliable / honest accountants / auditors with good reputation o No business can afford to make use of accountants / auditors who are known for their unethical and unprofessional practices. o The bookkeepers of Master Bond and Fidentia has been guilty of “creative accounting” by covering large personal loans to executives because it is actually a way of stealing the money. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Openness and transparency o All transactions and negotiations of the business must be open and transparent. This means no information may be withheld and there may not be hidden agendas. o The business must make the employees aware of the different policies in the business, as well as legislation applicable to specific employees and ensure that employees adhere to these policies and laws. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Social responsibility o The community should be involved in the decision making and implementation of plans and programs relating to social responsibility. o These programs should work towards the lifting of the community in which the business operates and must be sustainable. WAYS IN WHICH RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND EFFECTIVE BUSINESS PRACTICES SHOULD BE CONDUCTED?: Adequate internal control o Control over the business’ ethical code and codes of conduct should be applied consistently. o Corrective measures must be implemented when employees deviate, before it is too late and the company’s image is harmed. o Recognition for compliance with these codes should also be given. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Taxation EXPLANATION: • The government needs revenue from taxation to provide essential services such as housing, education, and medical care. • Professional behaviour in this regard would be to pay due tax to SARS. • There are businesses and individuals that do not declare all income to the Receiver of Revenue. • This attempt to escape tax is called tax evasion – tax evasion is a criminal act. STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: • The best way to reduce tax evasion is to reduce tax rates. • As tax rates are reduced, more people will choose to pay taxes instead of risking the penalties imposed on offenders. • Businesses should pa their taxes to avoid penalties and interest and even imprisonment. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Sexual harassment EXPLANATION: • SH in the workplace involves unwanted attention of a sexual nature from someone at work, that causes discomfort, humiliation, offence or job interference. • Sexual harassment includes: Unwelcome sexual advances. Requests for sexual favours in return for employment benefits. Pressure for sexual favours to clinch sales deals. • It is immoral, wrong and unethical to abuse your position to take advantage of another person. STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: • Formulating a clear policy regarding sexual harassment. • Making others aware of the problem, of their rights and of the rights of others. • Implementing complaints and disciplinary procedures. • Formulate an employment equity programme that ensures well-planned career paths, based on merit, for all employees. • Cultivating a positive corporate culture, in which the rights and dignity of all employees are respected. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Sexual harassment EXPLANATION: • Employers should be proactive and prevent the problem, rather than having to address it after the damage has been inflicted. STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: . ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Pricing of goods in rural areas EXPLANATION: STRATEGY/ RECOMMENDATION: • Goods in rural stores are often more expensive than goods • Attention must be in urban stores. given to improve the • The Consumer Price Food Index for rural areas is infrastructure in rural considerably higher than the index for metropolitan areas. areas to address this • Most of the stores in rural areas are located far away from problem. major towns; store-owners buy stock from wholesalers and • Rural store-owners pay a high price for delivery to the rural store. can try to negotiate • The lack of infrastructure in rural areas results in rural better prices form store-owners often not having any competition – this wholesalers. means that they are the only, or one of very few, suppliers • Gaining the goodwill of of necessities in the area. customers by building • Some rural store-owners abuse their monopolistic position long-term by charging excessive prices to these mostly very poor relationships with communities. customers. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Price-fixing EXPLANATION: STRATEGY/RECOMMENDATION • The Consumer Protection Act prohibits this business • Adhere to the regulations of practice. Yet there are still businesses that are guilty the law. of this. • Do not use price-fixing to • It involves an agreement between different gain unfairly high profit. businesses (cartels) which ask the same price for a • Adhere to ethical business particular stock item. practices. • The consumer is exploited and businesses make a lot more profit than usual. Such practices can be reported to the Commission for Competitiveness. • If businesses are found guilty, they can be heavily fined. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Unfair advertising EXPLANATION: • The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) is a selfregulating body that was set up to regulate advertising. • The National Consumer Commission (NCC) investigates deceptive advertising and has legal powers to stop deceptive advertising. • Three categories of misleading advertisement practices are misleading prices; misleading promotion and misleading packaging. STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: • All advertisers must adhere to the Code of Advertising Practice as determined by ASA. • According to this Code, all advertising should be legal, decent, honest and truthful. • The following points summarise some of the principles of the Code: Advertisements should not show anything which may encourage acts of violence. Advertisements should not show anything which may encourage or support criminal or illegal activity. Advertisements should not use fear tactics without justifiable reason. Advertisements addressed to, or likely to influence children should not contain anything which may cause them mental, moral, physical or emotional harm. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Unfair advertising EXPLANATION: • Unethical/unfair advertising practices include: Giving goods deceptive names. Using false/deceptive advertising. Selling second hand goods as new goods. Discouraging or criticising a competitor’s goods. Exploitation of children’s lack of understanding of a product. Misuse of people with disabilities in advertisements. STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: • Anyone can lodge a complaint over unfair advertising with the ASA. • The ASA deals with all complaints, free of charge. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Unfair advertising Examples: o Prices are manipulated by “free gifts” that accompanies the product when the consumers purchase it. o Businesses advertise a particular item at a very low price to attract consumers, but when consumers visit the store, the item is not available at the advertised price. o Buy one and get one free, but there are hidden costs included that the consumers had to pay. o Advertise e.g. a living room set with accessories such as reading lamps, etc. as shown in the illustration, without specifying that the reading lamp are not included in the advertised price. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Unfair advertising Examples: o Advertising of refurbished second hand goods as new goods is o o o o misleading and unfair. The use of a competitor’s name or trademark of a competitor in an advertisement when different products are compared. The allocation of misleading characteristics to a product, e.g. a vacuum cleaner is advertised an described as if it has excellent suction action, but the product does not have that feature. Presentation and/or wording in the advertisement amount to concealment where certain information is purposely omitted, e.g. advertising a used car, without stating the year of manufacturing or mileage. Ambiguity and exaggeration in an advertising may mislead the consumer. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Unauthorised use of funds EXPLANATION: STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: • Unauthorised means: “without permission” and involves theft or fraud. • Some employees have access to funds of the enterprise, putting them in a position to use these funds. • Unauthorised use of funds involves using the business’ money for personal gain, e.g. Using the business’ petrol card to fill up your car to go on a personal trip. A partner who earned money on behalf of the partnership without telling the other partners about the earnings. An employee who takes business supplies such as stationary, paper, or cartridges for personal use. • Fraud cases have been highlighted in the media. • Limit. to the absolute minimum, the number of employees who have access to funds. • Formulate a fraud prevention strategy. • Identify vulnerable areas. • Combat fraud through internal auditing. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Abusing work time EXPLANATION: STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: • Employees get paid for the time they spend at work. • It is unethical to use work time for personal matters. • Examples of abusing work time (and money) include: Personal telephone calls during working hours. Downloading information for personal use from the internet during working hours. Wasting time, e.g. going out to meet a client for “half an hour”, returning to the office hours later. • Structure working hours in such a way that employees have free time for personal matters. • Many businesses are allowing their employees to work flexible working hours – e.g. an employee works from 7:00 – 16:00 or 9:00 – 18:00 instead of working from 8:00 – 17:00. • An employer can allow its employees a particular number of phone calls, copies or data – once an employee has used up his / her benefits they are required to pay for further use of facilities. • Employers should monitor phone calls, the number of copies made and the time employees spend on the internet. ISSUES THAT COULD CHALLENGE RESPONSIBLE, ETHICAL AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOUR: Abusing work time EXPLANATION: STRATEGY / RECOMMENDATION: • Employers should remind employees that profit will increase if expenses (such as telephone and paper) decreases, thus leaving more money to pay out in bonuses.