Cold Bending Steel Beams: a State-of The-Art Engineering Solution that
Meets Industry Challenges
By: Antoine N. Gergess, PhD, PE, F.ASCE
Professor, University of Balamand, Lebanon
www.balamand.edu.lb
World Congress and Exhibition on Steel Structure, Dubai
November 15 - 17, 2015
Horizontal Curves
Heat Curving
Continuous heat
V heat (R > 300m)
Drawbacks
Procedure is complex
Numerical computations have to account for material and
geometric non-linearity
Temperature distribution along the flange width are not
exactly uniform
Analysis has to account for the girder behavior during heating
and during cooling (natural cooling).
During heating, heated zone elongates to form a larger outer
radius
During cooling, the heated portion shortens to form a reverse
curvature
Material Properties
1.0
Yield Stress
Modulus of Elasticity
0.8
Ratio
E/E
0.6
Fy/Fy
0.4
0.2
0
135
270
405
Temperature, C
540
675
Cut-Curving
Flange
Flange
Flange
Scrap
Pressure Applied
During Fit-up
Web
Flange
Flange
Fitting Jig
Draw-Backs
Too costly because of excessive waste
Too much scrap for sharp curvatures
Used for mild curvatures (R 300m)
Fit-up operation too complicated
3-ROLLERS BENDING
Mainly used in buildings
Fit-up difficult for larger
size bridge girders
Perfect curve
OTHER IDEAS?
118
COLD BENDING
Analysis
= a’/L; = x2/a’
Pflange 3.75t f Fy (limit state of flange local buckling)
2
P
Fy t f b f
3χL
2
L p 0.255b f
E
(lateral bracing limit)
Fy
Stress-strain curve
Idealization
0.125
res (m)
0.1
0.075
0.05
0.025
0
0.0
1.0
2.0
a' = 0.333L
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
Distance x (m)
a' = 0.25L
Circular
7.0
8.0
9.0
10.0
a' = 0.1L
a
Residual Stresses
Flexural stiffness is reduced by the presence of cold
bending residual stresses.
ROLLED BEAMS
WELDED SHAPES
Influence of Residual Stress on Average Stress-Strain Curve
Tampa Steel Concept
Apply smaller loads at uniform intervals to achieve
desired curvature
Idealization of Curve
L
1
2
3
3
4
5
max = 4
6
7
5
2
6
x
δ δmax R R x
2
2
L2
δmax
8R
S
S
Load P
Li
OFFSETS ii, ij
Load: 2
Load: 3
1
2
3
4
6
5
22
23
33
24
34
44
35
45
Load: 4
Load: 5
25
Load: 6
55
max
26
36
46
56
66
7
Test Girder
Loading Details
Test Girder after Curving
Idealized Stress-Strain Curve
Fy
2.27y
1.89y
max 10 y
STRESS
R = 255 m
r 0.39y
r 0.77y
R = 115 m
y
residual 8.5 y
STRAIN
1.5 y
FORMULATION
PARAMETERS:
Load Frame Spacing S
Bending Loads Ptf, Pbf
Deflection within span S
S
Segment Length Li
Number of Segments n
Offsets
Ptf
Li
LOAD FRAME SPACING (S)
Based on lateral bracing limit:
S 1.76r t
S = 14.4c for Grade 250 steel
S = 12.2c for Grade 345 steel
For unsymmetrical sections use ctf
Flange
Width 2c
Load P
Comp. side
Flange
S = Lp
E
Fy
BENDING LOADS (Ptf, Pbf )
From simple beam plastic load analysis:
P
4Fy t f c
Top Flange: Ptf based on ttf, ctf
Bot. Flange: Pbf based on tbf, cbf
2
S
Constant
P
Mp
Fytfc
PS
4
Fytfc
S
c
c
Mp = Fytfc2
DEFLECTION
Δ
13Fy S
ctf cbf
2
Ptf Pbf
216Ec
Load P
tf bf
set = cte = tf
bf
bf ???
Plastic
Hinge
tf
S
Set P = Pbf,
P Pbf
Load in cycles
(on-going research)
m=tf/bf
SEGMENT LENGTH Li
tf
4RΔ
Li
S
S
[m]
Constant
[m-1]
2
2Li/S
2Li
l
8R
[m+1]
2Li
Radius R
2Li
S
NUMBER OF SEGMENTS
Length L
nLi
a
1
2
3
4
a
n
5
n+1
Line of symmetry
Round-down to
the nearest
even integer
L-S
n
Li
adjust
(L - S)
Li
n
Challenges ?
Cracking, Fracture
Flange Upsets
Dimples
Web Crippling
Challenges ?
- Effects on Steel mainly fracture characteristics
- Does it lead to a permanent reduction
in the ductility and fracture resistance of steel?
- Effects if steel is loaded beyond plastic limits
- ANSWERS ? Specific need for full-scale
testing.
How could it be assessed - 1?
• Perform visual
inspection using
NDT techniques
• Instrument to
measure loads,
offsets, strains and
web movement
How could it be assessed - 2?
Perform in-depth
material testing of
the bent zone, e.g.
Charpy V-notch test
Fracture sensitivity
Tensile strength
Brinell hardness
How could it be assessed – 3?
Check for compliance with AASHTO Requirements
ASTM A709
ASTM A709
Grade 345
HPS 485W
Plate Thickness
up to 5 cm (2 in.)
up to 10 cm (4 in.)
Yield Strength
345 MPa (50 ksi)
485 MPa (70 ksi)
min. 404 MPa
620 – 758 MPa
(min. 58 ksi)
(90 – 110 ksi)
21%
19%
Toughness: CVN
35 m-N @ -12C
47 m-N @ -23C
Fracture Critical
(25 ft-lbf @ 10F)
(35 ft-lbf @ -10F)
Property
Tensile Strength
Min. Elongation
5 cm (2 in.)
Zone 3
6.35 cm (to 2.5 in.)
6.35 cm (to 4in.)
HPS 485W
Results of FHWA Tensile Tests on HPS 485W Specimens.
Wright W, Candra H, Albrecht P. “Fracture Toughness of A709 Grade HPD
-485W Steel”. Draft FHWA Report, Washington, D.C, 2005.
How could it be assessed – 4?
3D Finite
Element
Modeling
Specifications
Develop criteria and specifications for
consideration by AASHTO
Limits on strain
Limits on applied load
Limits on minimum radius
Guidelines for localized damage repair
Guidelines for inspection
Fabrication aids
Acknowledgment
Dr. Rajan Sen, PhD, PE, F.ASCE, Samuel and Julia Flom Professor,
University of South Florida, Tampa
Tampa Steel Erecting Company, Tampa, Florida
Thank You!
www.balamand.edu.lb