Group & Teams: From Conflict to Cooperation Topics for discussion 1. What is “conflict”? Is it good for organization? 2. Causes of conflict 3. Why “teamwork” matters for organization? 4. “Group” & “team”, are they the same? 5. How can you as a manager build an effective team? CONFLICT Conflict • A process in which one party perceives that its interests are being opposed or negatively affected by another party. • Nature of conflict: disagreement is normal Types of Conflict • Negative conflict--bad for organizations – Conflict that hinders the organization’s performance or threatens its interests. – Sometimes called dysfunctional conflict • Constructive conflict--good for organizations – Conflict benefits the main purposes of the organization and serves its interests. – Sometimes called functional conflict or cooperative conflict CAN TOO LITTLE OR TOO MUCH CONFLICT AFFECT PERFORMANCE? Too Little v.s. Too Much ? • Too little conflict—indolence Apathy, lack of creativity, indecision, and missed deadlines • Too much—warfare Political infighting, dissatisfaction, lack of teamwork, turnover, workplace aggression and violence • Moderate Level—creativity and initiation 7 Causes of Conflicts 1. Competition of Scarce Resources: When 2 parties need the same things 2. Time Pressure: When people believe there aren’t enough hours to do the work 3. Inconsistent Goals or Reward Systems: when people pursue different objectives 7 Causes of Conflicts (con’t) 4. Ambiguous Jurisdictions: when job boundaries are unclear 5. Status Differences: when there are inconsistencies in power & influence 6. Personality Clashes: when individual differences can’t be resolved 7. Communication Failures: when people misperceive & misunderstand How to Stimulate Constructive Conflict 1. Spur competition among employee Example: offering salespeople bonuses and awards for achievement 2. Change the organization’s culture & procedures Example: announcing to employees that the org. is now going to be more innovative and reward original thinking and unorthodox ideas How to Stimulate Constructive Conflict (Con’t) 3. Bring in outsiders for new perspectives Example: people from a different unit of org., new hires from competing companies, or consultants 4. Use programmed conflict: advocacy & the dialectic method Devil’s advocacy—role-playing criticism to test whether a proposal is workable: assigning someone to play the role of critic to voice possible objections to a proposal Dialectic method—role-playing 2 sides of a proposal to test whether it is workable: having 2 people or groups play opposing roles in a debate in order to better understand a proposal TEAMWORK Why Teamwork Matters Results from companies, teamwork can achieve: • Increased productivity • Increased speed • Reduced costs • Improved quality • Reduced destructive internal competition • Improved workplace cohesiveness GROUP VS. TEAM Groups & Teams: How Do They Differ? • Group: Collections of people performing as individuals two or more freely interacting individuals who share collective norms, share collective goals, and have a common identity i.e. group of passengers on a flight • Team: Collections of people with common commitment a small group of people with complementary skills who are committed to a common purpose, performance goals, and approach for which they hold themselves mutually accountable Formal v.s. Informal Group • Formal Group—created to do productive work – A group that established to do something productive for the organization headed by a leader • Informal Group—created for friendship – A group formed by people seeking friendship and has no officially appointed leader, although a leader may emerge from the membership 4 Purposes of Work Teams 1. Advice Teams They are created to broaden the info. base for managerial decisions i.e. committees, advisory councils, and review panels. 2. Production Teams They are responsible for performing day-to-day operations i.e. mining teams, flight attendant crews, and manufacturing crews. 4 Purposes of Work Teams (con’t) 3. Project Teams They work to do creative problem solving, often by applying the specialized knowledge of members of a cross-functional team i.e. research groups, planning teams, and development teams. 4. Action Teams They work to accomplish tasks that require people with specialized training and a high degree of coordination i.e. hospital surgery teams, airline cockpit crews, and police SWAT teams. Various Types of Teams Team Description Cross-functional team Members composed of people from different departments, such as sales and production, pursuing a common objective Problem-solving team Knowledgeable workers who meet as a temporary team to solve a specific problem and then disband Quality circle Volunteers of workers and supervisors who meet irregularly to discuss workplace and quality related problems Self-managed team Workers are trained to do all or most of the jobs in a work unit, have no direct supervisor, and do their own day-to-day supervision Various Types of Teams Team Description Top-management team Members consist of the CEO, president, and top department heads and work to help the organization achieve its mission and goals Virtual team Members interact by computer network to collaborate on projects Work team Members engage in collective work requiring coordinated effort; purpose of team is advice, production, project, or action Group and Team Development: 5 Stages Forming Storming Getting oriented & getting acquainted Individual personalities & roles emerge Norming Performing Conflicts resolved, relationships develop, unity emerges Solving problems & completing the assigned task Adjourning Preparing for disbandment Considerations in Building a Group into an Effective Team 1. 2. 3. 4. Performance goals & feedback Motivation through mutual accountability Size: small teams or large teams? Roles: how team members are expected to behave 5. Norm: unwritten rules for team members 6. Cohesiveness: the importance of togetherness 7. Groupthink: when peer pressure discourages “thinking outside the box”