1 GQ Magazines “Glee Gone Wild” Appropriate Advertising for Children Meaghan Jordan Professor A. Hoffman CCTP 625: Marketing, Advertising and Public Policy 22 December 2010 2 The Company The Fox Television Network introduced the hour long, musically themed show Glee on May 19, 2009. The show, based on a high school glee club, spends each episode combating average teenage dramas with the help of popular and iconic musical sequences. In the 18 months since the show premiered, it has become a pop culture phenomenon, captivating audiences ranging in ages from 9 to 90. The viewers, who have been dubbed “Gleeks,” faithfully tune it at 9pm EST on Tuesday nights. The show “…is produced by Ryan Murphy Television in association with 20th Century Fox Television. Ryan Murphy, Brad Falchuk and Ian Brennan are co-creators of the series. Murphy, Falchuk, Brennan and Dante Di Loreto serve as executive producers.”1 The co-creators of Glee, and the Fox network had not imagined the show would evolve into an industry frontrunner and ratings gold. The first season of Glee garnered a number of accolades and promotional engagements, including “two certified Gold albums, more than 10 million song downloads and an incredible 19 Emmy nominations,” as well as “…a Peabody Award; a Golden Globe for Best Television Series, Comedy or Musical; a Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series; and a People's Choice Award for Favorite New TV Comedy. The cast has performed for the President and First Lady at the White House, appeared on "The Oprah Winfrey Show," sang the national anthem at the World Series and graced the covers of Entertainment Weekly and Rolling Stone.”2 Along with several awards Glee has launched a full scale marketing campaign to capitalize on the current success of the show. A national concert tour, soundtracks, merchandising, promotional appearances, online and print ad campaigns and cast interviews are all outlets utilized by the Glee creators to effectively market their musical product. 1 "About the Show." FOX. FOX Broadcasting Company - FOX Television Shows. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.fox.com/glee/about/>. 2 "About the Show." FOX. FOX Broadcasting Company - FOX Television Shows. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.fox.com/glee/about/>. 3 The Controversy The sophomore season of Glee has gained a bigger following, especially after featuring music by Britney Spears and Lady Gaga, which has led to greater exposure for the shows cast. The November 2010 issue of GQ, featuring Glee’s three main characters, was released on newsstands October 25, 2010. The backlash from the cover photo and multi-page spread was immediate. The article and accompanying photos featured the shows biggest celebrities, Lea Michele, Dianna Agron, and Cory Monteith. However, the high school age characters they each play were swapped for sexy, scantily clad scenes and provocative poses. The cover of the magazine displayed the trio with Monteith in the center of the page flanked by Michele and Agron. His arms are draped around the women, who are wearing a short skirt, low cut sweaters with bras revealed and Michele opting for just a pair of pink underwear. If the clothing and facial expressions were not enough the hands of Monteith casually grabbing the backsides of the women put the picture over the edge. The photo’s individually showcasing the actors in the pages of the magazine pushed the envelope farther with the women stripping down even further, as well as using poses and gestures that stir up visions of a Playboy magazine spread. The popularity of the show amongst tweens and teenagers has these youngsters “Gleeking” out for anything published in relation to the show. The Parents Television Council issued a scathing press release condemning the GQ November issue for featuring the images. The PTC President Tim Winter stated, “It is disturbing that GQ, which is explicitly written for adult men, is sexualizing the actresses who play high school-aged characters on ‘Glee’ in this way. It borders on pedophilia. Sadly, this is just the latest example of the overt sexualization of young girls in entertainment.”3 Several media outlets reported this controversy, examining the pictorial from both the perspectives of the audience and PTC. Linda Holmes of the NPR “Monkey See” pop culture blog admitted that the photos were indeed sexy, which is typical content for GQ, 3 "PTC: Sexualized GQ Photo Shoot of Glee Cast Crosses the Line." Parents Television Council - Because Our Children Are Watching. Parents Television Council, 20 Oct. 2010. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.parentstv.org/PTC/news/release/2010/1020.asp>. 4 “But not all sexualized photos are created equal, and these, indeed, are in particularly and specifically poor taste.”4 This particular Glee scandal was covered by a number of media outlets, from CNN to TMZ, each adding their two cents but ultimately agreeing that the pictures were not acceptable. The Fox Network and creators of the show who at the time refused to comment on the situation did not address the public scrutiny. Instead they opted to remain silent and let the media frenzy subside, while benefiting from the additional publicity for the show. Yet, the Editor in Chief of GQ Magazine felt the need to take a firm position on the content published in the November edition. Jim Nelson responded to the PTC suggesting that the organization “…must not be watching much TV these days and should learn to divide reality from fantasy…As often happens in Hollywood, these ‘kids’ are in their twenties. Cory Monteith's almost 30! I think they're old enough to do what they want.” 5 Despite the magazine standing behind the photos, the public debate went on for weeks. The racy Glee GQ photos have brought up the question as to whether or not the publicity was appropriate based on the shows weekly demographics, television rating and appeal to the younger generations. Advertising and the Federal Trade Commission The Federal Trade Commission regulates the advertising and media industries. The guidelines for print and television advertising are clearly defined but are dealt with as separate entities. According to Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act they “…will find deception if there is a representation, omission or practice that is likely to mislead the consumer acting reasonably in the circumstances, to the consumer’s 4 Holmes, Linda. "GQ's Gross 'Glee' Photos: The Objections Are Right For The Wrong Reasons." Web log post. NPR : National Public Radio : News & Analysis, World, US, Music & Arts. PBS, 21 Oct. 2010. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2010/10/21/130719727/gq-s-gross-glee-photosthe-objections-are-right-for-the-wrong-reasons>. 5 "Parents Television Council Finds GQ 'Glee' Shoot 'disturbing'" Web log post. The Marquee Blog. CNN, 20 Oct. 2010. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://marquee.blogs.cnn.com/2010/10/20/parents-television-council-finds-gq-gleeshoot-disturbing/>. 5 detriment,”6 in any advertisement. The analysis of advertisements involves three components “…(1) the representation, omission, or practice must be likely to mislead the consumer; (2) the act or practice must be considered from the perspective of the reasonable consumer; and (3) the representation, omission, or practice must be material, that is, likely to affect a consumer’s choice or conduct, thereby leading to injury.”7 The FTC based on the generic makeup of the consuming group determines the perspective of the reasonable consumer. Specifically, in the cases involving children, “…advertisements directed to children are considered from the standpoint of an ordinary child.”8 The perspective of the consumer is key to determining if an add will intentionally harm or influence the customer in any way. When dealing with children and advertising the line between appropriate and inappropriate can be blurred. Although the GQ Glee photos were not direct advertisements for the show, the approval from the executive team inadvertently transformed the journalistic photos into advertisements. The placement of the advertisements in a magazine typically for men is 6 Beales III, J. Howard. "Advertising to Kids and the FTC: A Regulatory Retrospective That Advises the Present." Speech. George Mason Law Review 2004 Symposium on Antitrust and Consumer Protection Competition, Advertising, and Heath Claims: Legal and Practival Limits on Advertising Regulation. 2 Mar. 2004. Speeches/Articles by J. Howard Beales, III, Bureau of Consumer Protections. Federal Trade Commission, 25 Jan. 2007. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://www.ftc.gov/speeches/beales/040802adstokids.pdf>. 7 Beales III, J. Howard. "Advertising to Kids and the FTC: A Regulatory Retrospective That Advises the Present." Speech. George Mason Law Review 2004 Symposium on Antitrust and Consumer Protection Competition, Advertising, and Heath Claims: Legal and Practival Limits on Advertising Regulation. 2 Mar. 2004. Speeches/Articles by J. Howard Beales, III, Bureau of Consumer Protections. Federal Trade Commission, 25 Jan. 2007. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://www.ftc.gov/speeches/beales/040802adstokids.pdf>. 8 Beales III, J. Howard. "Advertising to Kids and the FTC: A Regulatory Retrospective That Advises the Present." Speech. George Mason Law Review 2004 Symposium on Antitrust and Consumer Protection Competition, Advertising, and Heath Claims: Legal and Practival Limits on Advertising Regulation. 2 Mar. 2004. Speeches/Articles by J. Howard Beales, III, Bureau of Consumer Protections. Federal Trade Commission, 25 Jan. 2007. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://www.ftc.gov/speeches/beales/040802adstokids.pdf>. 6 irrelevant, since the pictures were available online through various media outlets reporting on their scandalous nature. The accidental advertisements promoting the explicit nature of Glee were easily accessible and influential to the shows younger fan base. Advertising and alternative mediums in which it is achieved has evolved with the inception of the Internet and social media platforms. The Association of National Advertisers explains that “Advertising. It’s linked with our domestic heritage. It’s aligned with forces that are dramatically transforming our society.”9 Children are a large part of society and are easily influenced. Looking at the Glee photos from an advertising standpoint of a child, it can be argued that the images are deceitful, as well as potentially harmful. The picture of Lea Michele sitting on a bench in the high school gym locker room with her legs spread wide while straddling a bench do not exactly convey an innocent message. A number of Agron’s pictures have her dressed as a cheerleader, holding pom-poms with a mega phone strategically placed between her legs. The high school locale and childish props are suggestive. The vast majority of the images promote a sexual lifestyle with undertones of female degradation through Michele and Agron’s poses and infantile attire. The sexual idolization taken away from the photos by an impressionable, Glee obsessed tween is not healthy. The pictures are not promoting the characters of a pop culture infused, musical show but rather three young actors who coincidentally are photographed in a setting similar to the television show they appear in. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) states, "Children are influenced by media– they learn by observing, imitating, and making behaviors their own."10 Evaluating the advertisement by FTC standards and from a medical standpoint clearly indicate the GQ photos are in direct violation of federal law. 9 "The Role of Advertising in America." ANA. Web. 8 Dec. 2010. <http://www.ana.net/advocacy2/content/advamerica>. 10 Blackwell Clark, Laura. "Influence on Children Media - History of Media for Children, General Considerations, Studies of Media Influence, Domains of Influence, Recommendations." Web log post. StateUniversity.com. Net Industries and Its Licensors. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/2212/Media-Influenceon-Children.html>. 7 Television Rating Systems The Federal Communications Commission adopted the current television ratings system in 1998. The system was designed to meet the requirements mandated by Section 551 of the 1996 Telecommunications Act. The need for such a system was presented by Congress after “…made extensive findings with respect to the influence that television has on children and the need to provide parents with useful tools to block programming they believe harmful to their children.”11 The “1996 Act,” the abbreviated name given to the act, “…required the Commission to determine whether video programming distributors (1) have established acceptable voluntary rules for rating video programming that contains sexual, violent or other indecent material about which parents should be informed before it is displayed to children and; (2) have agreed voluntarily to broadcast signals that contain such ratings.”12 In order to fulfill the legal requirements, The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB), the National Cable Television Association (NCTA) and the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) produced the first model of the TV Parental Guidelines in 1997. Following consultations with advocacy groups and industry representatives the FCC ruled the revised version of the TV Parental Guidelines fulfilled the described need as it was stated in Section 551. The voluntary system was adopted by all of the major players in the industry. The TV Parental Guidelines consist of a ratings system with six levels of labels that can be applied to television programming. While the ratings are displayed on network and cable channels, news, sports and MPAA rated movies on premium cable channels, like HBO or Starz, are excluded from the ratings system. When considering what rating is applicable for programming towards children factors such as “…age and/or maturity; content indicators concerning sexual situations, violence, language or 11 Federal Communications Commission. Commission Finds Industry Video Programming Rating System Acceptable; Adopts Technical Requirements to Enable Blocking of Video Programming (The "V-Chip") (CS Docket No. 97-55, CS Docket No. 97-321, ET Docket 97-206). Washington: FCC, 1998. Print. 12 Federal Communications Commission. Commission Finds Industry Video Programming Rating System Acceptable; Adopts Technical Requirements to Enable Blocking of Video Programming (The "V-Chip") (CS Docket No. 97-55, CS Docket No. 97-321, ET Docket 97-206). Washington: FCC, 1998. Print. 8 dialogue…”13 are all taken into account. A particular shows designated time slot during the day may also have an impact on the level of rating the show is give. For example, shows broadcasted during later primetime hours have a tendency to be rated for mature audiences, since the viewers are generally of the older demographic. Once the program has been evaluated the show can be given the following ratings, TV-Y, TV-Y7, TV-G, TV-PG, TV-14 or TV-MA. The square shaped ratings appear on the screen as a show is beginning for approximately 15 seconds. Some ratings appear at the bottom of the screen, while others pop up in the bottom corner. The placement and design of the rating is determined by the individual broadcast stations, but is always clearly visible to the viewer. Fox Television Network uses a blue and white ratings icon that appears on the screen after each commercial break for those viewers who are just tuning in. On Tuesday nights at 9pm Glee begins on Fox with a TV-14 rating appearing on the screen. By applying the rating to the show, the TV Parental Guidelines determined that, “This program contains some material that many parents would find unsuitable for children under 14 years of age. Parents are strongly urged to exercise greater care in monitoring this program and are cautioned against letting children under the age of 14 watch unattended. This program may contain one or more of the following: intensely suggestive dialogue (D), strong coarse language (L), intense sexual situations (S), or intense violence (V).”14 This higher rating makes it clear that the issues dealt with in Glee’s storylines are not appropriate for a younger audience. The TV Parental Guidelines dictate which rating appears on screen at the time of the particular broadcast. The rating on the screen in evaluated based on specific terms, so as to be applicable to every show reviewed. However, often parents do not agree with the rating or the coinciding appropriateness of the topics featured in shows. To further awareness and aid parents trying to decide if a child can view a certain show, The Parents 13Federal Communications Commission. Commission Finds Industry Video Programming Rating System Acceptable; Adopts Technical Requirements to Enable Blocking of Video Programming (The "V-Chip") (CS Docket No. 97-55, CS Docket No. 97-321, ET Docket 97-206). Washington: FCC, 1998. Print. 14 "UNDERSTANDING THE TV RATINGS." The TV Parental Guidelines. TV Parental Guidelines. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://www.tvguidelines.org/ratings.htm>. 9 Television Council offers a second rating system on their website. The reviews of specific programs are deconstructed to include what questionable topics are addressed in the show, the offensive language used and an overall synopsis of the program. At the end of the explanation an appropriate age rage is recommended to the parent. Going one step further, a traffic light rating is also included, with red meaning a “Show may include gratuitous sex, explicit dialogue, violent content, or obscene language, and is unsuitable for children,” yellow being “The show contains adult-oriented themes and dialogue that may be inappropriate for youngsters,” and green being “Family-friendly show promoting responsible themes and traditional values.”15 The stop light colors illustrate the suitable viewership for categories involving sex, language violence and overall content. In the specific case of Glee, the Parents Television Council disagrees with the rating given by the TV Parental Guidelines. The PTC suggests that Glee is unsuitable for children under the age of 16, due to sexual innuendo and more mature topics dealt with in each week’s plotlines. The website rating firmly asserts, “Parents should be aware that this is an edgy teen show filled with adult themes. Simulated sex scenes are usually left to the adults on the show, but sexual situations between the teens are dealt in frank and explicit ways.”16 The two trusted television ratings systems may disagree on a suitable age for young viewers to begin watching the show. In spite of this fact, it is unanimous that the sexual and adult content of Glee is a troubling point that is overlooked because of the popular music and high school setting. The Analysis The marketing and advertising of any product toward children is heavily monitored and regulated by the Federal Trade Commission. The Glee GQ photo’s were not direct advertisements from the network for the show but publicity for the three actors featured in the show. However, the show’s executive staff approved the photo shoot for 15 "GLEE - Parents Television Council Family TV Guide Show Page." Parents Television Council - Because Our Children Are Watching. Parents Television Council, 2010. Web. 18 Dec. 2010. <http://www.parentstv.org/ptc/shows/main.asp?shwid=2943>. 16 "GLEE - Parents Television Council Family TV Guide Show Page." Parents Television Council - Because Our Children Are Watching. Parents Television Council, 2010. Web. 18 Dec. 2010. <http://www.parentstv.org/ptc/shows/main.asp?shwid=2943>. 10 Agron, Michelle and Monteith, which meant the content of the spread was condoned as appropriate. In the current pop culture climate, it is fair to say that publicity, whether it be magazine articles or interviews, are considered an advertisement for the actors, as well as the shows they represent. Using this logic the GQ spread would then be considered an advertisement and liable to the laws regarding deceitful advertising toward children. The popularity of Glee amongst tweens and teenagers was unexpected. The shows creator Ryan Murphy told GQ "I didn't want to do a family show," says Murphy. "I wanted to do my version of a family show. But we try to be as responsible as we can, because we know some young people watch. Some of the humor goes over their head, hopefully."17 The sensitive issues dealt with during the hour long musical is rated TV-14 for reason, but that has not stopped younger audiences from tuning in on Tuesday evenings. The corporate acknowledgement that the show addresses adult subjects coupled with the ratings are helping parents make an educated decision about whether or not a child can watch the show. The young audiences that are allowed to watch have become engrossed with the musical nature of the show, “Gleeking” out and going fan crazy for any material mentioning the show. Based on the young demographic, shows like Glee should not be participating in photo shoots like the one featured in the November issue of GQ. The advertisements and publicity for any show or the actors should coincide with the age of the audience. The rating of a television show should also be a factor in the type of advertisements released to promote a single episode or an entire season. Glee, being rated TV-14 could have material geared toward a slightly older crowd, but should also consider that a large part of their audience is young. A similar advertising issue occurred in 2008 with the popular CW show Gossip Girl. The launch of the “OMFG” campaign for the shows midseason premiere were not received well by many people. The response from network clearly explained, “We wanted to create a provocative campaign that stands out from the competition and reminds viewers of some of the 'OMG' moments that have made 17 Pappademas, Alex. "Glee Gone Wild." GQ Nov. 2010. GQ.com. Conde Nast Digital. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.gq.com/entertainment/movies-and-tv/201011/gleegleeks-rachel-finn-quinn-cory-monteith-lea-michele-diana-agron?currentPage=1>. 11 Gossip Girl one of the most buzzed-about new shows on television," the CW said in a statement. "This sexy, sophisticated campaign speaks directly to our adult 1834 viewers using expressions that are part of their lexicon.”18 These particular print and television ads were for an intended demographic, but like Glee, Gossip Girl has a young fan base because of the books, which the show is based off of. The CW then chose to also feature ads that just said “OMG.” The network was able to cater to their projected audience while still taking into consideration the younger audiences who they did not initially anticipate would be watching the show. Glee should consider a marketing strategy comparable to Gossip Girl to avoid future controversy. The advertisements, particularly for children, should reflect the standards set forth by the FTC to ensure that the contents of the ads are not deceiving but truthfully representing the show. The advertising and/or promotional materials should find a happy medium to appease all demographics. In the December/January issue of Teen Vogue Glee once again takes center stage. Monteith and Michele are featured on the front cover with an accompanying interview and pictures. This publicity for the show is age appropriate, showing the on screen couple fully clothed and in proper poses. This advertisement, unlike GQ, promotes the show in an acceptable manner towards children. The wholesome Teen Vogue spread is an example as to how the show should be marketed towards its young audience. The pictures in this article are not deceiving and properly illustrate how Michele and Monteith would act during a typical episode of Glee. Conclusion The regulation of advertising, especially when involving television shows, needs to be monitored closely. Glee being a pop culture phenomenon has attracted an audience comprised of all ages. The advertising of the show and its actors has to take into consideration that children are devouring all things related to the show, even if they do not appear in kid friendly environments, like GQ. What the Glee GQ controversy brought 18 "'Gossip Girl' Ad Campaign Features Sex and Foul Slang Term." FoxNews.com Breaking News | Latest News | Current News. Fox News Networks, 11 Apr. 2008. Web. 5 Dec. 2010. <http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,350368,00.html>. 12 to light was the fact that producers/networks have to be proactive about subsequent ad campaigns. The mass understanding and technologically savvy youth in contemporary society are able to view anything about Glee by simply typing the shows title into a search engine. Keeping publicity in check will prevent controversies and deceitful advertising towards impressionable youth. 13 Works Cited "About the Show." FOX. FOX Broadcasting Company - FOX Television Shows. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.fox.com/glee/about/>. Beales III, J. Howard. "Advertising to Kids and the FTC: A Regulatory Retrospective That Advises the Present." Speech. George Mason Law Review 2004 Symposium on Antitrust and Consumer Protection Competition, Advertising, and Heath Claims: Legal and Practival Limits on Advertising Regulation. 2 Mar. 2004. Speeches/Articles by J. Howard Beales, III, Bureau of Consumer Protections. Federal Trade Commission, 25 Jan. 2007. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://www.ftc.gov/speeches/beales/040802adstokids.pdf>. Blackwell Clark, Laura. "Influence on Children Media - History of Media for Children, General Considerations, Studies of Media Influence, Domains of Influence, Recommendations." Web log post. StateUniversity.com. Net Industries and Its Licensors. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/2212/Media-Influence-onChildren.html>. Federal Communications Commission. Commission Finds Industry Video Programming Rating System Acceptable; Adopts Technical Requirements to Enable Blocking of Video Programming (The "V-Chip") (CS Docket No. 97-55, CS Docket No. 97321, ET Docket 97-206). Washington: FCC, 1998. Print. "GLEE - Parents Television Council Family TV Guide Show Page." Parents Television Council - Because Our Children Are Watching. Parents Television Council, 2010. Web. 18 Dec. 2010. <http://www.parentstv.org/ptc/shows/main.asp?shwid=2943>. "'Gossip Girl' Ad Campaign Features Sex and Foul Slang Term." FoxNews.com Breaking News | Latest News | Current News. Fox News Networks, 11 Apr. 2008. Web. 5 Dec. 2010. <http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,350368,00.html>. Holmes, Linda. "GQ's Gross 'Glee' Photos: The Objections Are Right For The Wrong Reasons." Web log post. NPR : National Public Radio : News & Analysis, World, US, Music & Arts. PBS, 21 Oct. 2010. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.npr.org/blogs/monkeysee/2010/10/21/130719727/gq-s-gross-gleephotos-the-objections-are-right-for-the-wrong-reasons>. Pappademas, Alex. "Glee Gone Wild." GQ Nov. 2010. GQ.com. Conde Nast Digital. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.gq.com/entertainment/movies-andtv/201011/glee-gleeks-rachel-finn-quinn-cory-monteith-lea-michele-dianaagron?currentPage=1>. 14 "Parents Television Council Finds GQ 'Glee' Shoot 'disturbing'" Web log post. The Marquee Blog. CNN, 20 Oct. 2010. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://marquee.blogs.cnn.com/2010/10/20/parents-television-council-finds-gqglee-shoot-disturbing/>. "PTC: Sexualized GQ Photo Shoot of Glee Cast Crosses the Line." Parents Television Council - Because Our Children Are Watching. Parents Television Council, 20 Oct. 2010. Web. 27 Nov. 2010. <http://www.parentstv.org/PTC/news/release/2010/1020.asp>. "The Role of Advertising in America." ANA. Web. 8 Dec. 2010. <http://www.ana.net/advocacy2/content/advamerica>. "UNDERSTANDING THE TV RATINGS." The TV Parental Guidelines. TV Parental Guidelines. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. <http://www.tvguidelines.org/ratings.htm>. 15 Appendix A: GQ Photo Spread for “Glee Gone Wild” 16 17 Appendix B: Teen Vogue “O-M-Glee!” 18 Appendix C: 2008 Gossip Girl “OMFG” Advertising Campaign