Office of Procurement and Contract Services http://opcs.dhhs.state.nc.us DHHS Performance-based Contracting Where are the tracks taking us ? Training Agenda Center of Excellence and PBC Competitive Bid Process and Waiver of Competition Overview of Contract Administration General Contracting Requirements & Specific Contract Documents DHHS Compliance with Contracting Center of Excellence What is PBC all about? DHHS Departmental Center of Excellence What is the purpose? Who attends? What’s in it for me? Divisions, Offices, Schools and Facilities Division Center of Excellence What is the Center of Excellence? A process used to help managers make better, more informed decisions in managing the programs and services within their agencies. This tools helps to assure leaders that the agency is on course with the goals set for the agency by allowing them to know what was accomplished as well as guide them to improvement efforts. Division Center of Excellence MISSION STATEMENT To drive performance based contracting and process reform through best practices, information gathering and the sharing of ideas, networking and training for all DHHS divisions, offices, schools and facilities Division Center of Excellence What’s the purpose of having a center of excellence in your division? Identify and approve program needs; produce clear, meaningful data; identify and approve outcomes; train and assist division program staff; and reassess contract services. Division Center of Excellence What is managing for results? – It’s a system of management used to focus decisions and activities on clear and measurable results. – It’s purpose is to aid the division in maximizing the efficiency, quality, and effectiveness of services and programs. – It’s fact-based, results-oriented and accountable. Division Center of Excellence Who attends COE? A select group of people come together to assist in quality assurance of performance based Contracting. – Senior Management (director, section chief, budget – Subject Matter Experts (contracting, budgeting, programming, policymaking, technology, etc). Division Center of Excellence How often does your division meet? Do you attend? Do you have the right people with the right skills to make those important decisions about whether your contract objectives are meeting your division objectives? Do you perform contract analysis and outcome review on all new, renewals and amended contracts? Division Center of Excellence What structure will your division have in place to review contracts for state fiscal year 2008 and 2009? Understanding Performance-based Contracting S.M.A.R.T. Measures What are S.M.A.R.T. Measures? Specific Measurable Achievable Relevant Time-bound S.M.A.R.T. Measures Specific Your goals should be stated as simply, concisely and explicitly as possible. S.M.A.R.T. Measures Measurable Goals should be measurable and quantifiable. If you’re stating an increase, that increase must be measured. S.M.A.R.T. Measures Achievable An achievable goal has an outcome that is realistic given your current situation, resources and time available. Is your goal possible? S.M.A.R.T. Measures Relevant A relevant goal should help you on your mission or your “bigger” objectives. Is this important to the overall objective? S.M.A.R.T. Measures Time-bound A time-bound goal includes realistic timeframes. Whenever possible, time constraints must be defined. Summation All measures should be SMART: • • • • • Specific Measurable Achievable Relevant Time-Bound State and Contracting Agency need to work together to develop SMART measures. Research may be necessary to make the measures SMART. Work In Progress 5 Basic ELEMENTS of Performance-based Contracts Five Basic Elements of PBC 1. Needs Assessment 2. Project Goals & Objectives 3. Project Methods or Design 4. Project Evaluation 5. Reimbursement 1. Needs Assessment – The needs assessment is a key element of a contract. – It should be a clear, concise, well-supported statement of what the problem is and why the proposed solution is needed. – The needs assessment includes a narrative of factual data including statistical information to support what the need is and why the service is needed. 2. Project Goals & Objectives – The project objectives clearly describe the goals of the project. – Explain, in terms of results not outputs, the benefits of each objective. – The objectives are to identify the changes/effects the project will have on people’s lives (result) rather than the number of people served by this project (output). 3. Project Methods or Design – Project methods or design outline the activities (outputs) that will be accomplished with the available resources (inputs). – Structure the project methods or design as a time line and identify the target population (who receives/benefits from the service). – List the tasks and deliverables that must be completed to meet the objectives of the project. 4. Project Evaluation Develop evaluation criteria to evaluate the progress towards project objectives. – It is important to define carefully and exactly how success will be determined. – Describe performance measures that are specific, measurable, accountable, results-oriented and time-bound. Basic measures of time, dollars, units or stages of work can be supplied. To be useful, the project evaluation should identify: – – – – – – who (individual, agency)… is doing what (change in condition, behavior)… to whom (target population), and… why (bottom-line of the project)? when (change occurs by this specific date), and… how that change is measured (what data shows changed condition or behavior)? 5. Reimbursement Define the plan for reimbursement of services. – Expenses are to be outlined in the budget narrative. – The budget is to demonstrate consistency with project objectives. – When possible, link the payment with meeting the performance measures. Performance Measures What are Performance Measures? Performance measures are tools that provide a powerful means of focus within an agency by assuring that goals are on track. The previous 5 Mandated Elements include six performance measures. Six Performance Measures 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Demand Input Output Outcome Service Quality Efficiency 1. Demand Supports the need for the service – What is the problem? Includes statistical evidence on 3 levels: • National • State • Catchment Area Defines how many people in Catchment Area need the service Found in the Needs Assessment of the SOW Demand Measures - Example Found in the Needs Assessment section. Includes statistical evidence on 3 levels: National State Catchment Area Defines number of persons in catchment area who need service. Expressed as a number. US: Population approx 300 million 37 million people below the federal poverty line Rate of poverty 13% NC: Population approx 9 million 1.2 million people below federal poverty line Rate of poverty 15% Service Area: 23 counties = Poverty rates > 18% All rural and 19 located in Coastal Plain Region 10 small businesses 100 families meeting eligibility criteria Need Low Income North Carolinians (below the federal poverty level) lack the necessary resources to become Self Sufficient Demand: Statistical Resources http://www.census.gov/census2000/states/nc.html http://www.ncruralcenter.org/databank/index.html http://www.ncjustice.org http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/ocs/csbg/ http://www.roma1.org/about_roma.asp?pid=2 http://www.waptac.org/ http://www.nationalhomeless.org/publications/facts.html http://www.nccaa.net http://www.nccommerce.com/ Six Performance Measures 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Demand: Supports the need for the service Input Output Outcome Service Quality Efficiency 2. Input Defines the amount of resources being used to develop, maintain or deliver a product, activity or service Found in the Budget. It is the Contract Total. Expressed as a dollar amount. Input Measures - Example Found in the Budget. Total amount of the contract, including local match, if applicable. Expressed as a dollar amount. $500,000 Performance Measures 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Demand: Supports the need for the service Input: Defines the amount of resources invested Output Outcome Service Quality Efficiency 3. Output Show the quantity of work activity completed Expressed as a number or quantity Used to monitor how much was produced or provided the services provided under the contract – States the number of units of services that is expected to be delivered to customer in order to help solve the problem? Provide a number indicating how many items, referrals, action, products, etc. were involved Found in the Project Methods & Design section of the SOW Output Measures - Example Found in Project Methods and Design section. Defines the number of unique participants or clients in the program. States the services and quantity of the services provided. Technical assistance will be provided to 10 small businesses to obtain small business loans All or (10) small business will create and submit loan packages to financial institutions for approval At least 8 small business (out of 10) will have their loan packages approved At least 5 of the 8 businesses will be funded total amount requested for small business development 8 of the small businesses whose loans were approved will at least maintain 15 jobs for low income persons 5 small businesses who received full funding will expand or create 15 additional jobs for low income persons Expressed as a number. Output Measures - Example Found in Project Methods and Design section. Defines the number of unique participants or clients in the program. Minimize barriers to homeownership for 100 families through community and economic development services, service plan coordination, and agency/community collaboration All or 100 families will complete prehomeownership education and counseling States the services and quantity of the services provided. At least 75 families out of 100 will have their homeownership loan packages approved Expressed as a number. At least 50 families out of the 75 will become home owners Performance Measures 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Demand: Supports the need for the service Input: Defines how much money is needed Output: Defines the services provided Outcome Service Quality Efficiency 4. Outcome Defines the results achieved from the contract Must tie back to the service or activity of the contract and ultimately the main purpose of the program – How will the program effect the problem? Includes short-term, interim and long-term results Found in the Project Evaluation Section of SOW Expressed as a Percentage or Rate Outcome Measures - Example Loans for Small Businesses Found in the Project Evaluation Section. 100 % of small business (N=10) will create and submit loan packages for Approval Defines the results achieved from the contract. 80% of small business (N= 8) will have their loans approved 63% of small businesses (N=5) will be funded total amount of funding requested for small business development All or 80 % of small business whose loans were approved will at least maintain 15 jobs for low income persons 63% of small businesses (5) who received full funding for small business development will expand or create 15 additional jobs for low income persons Includes short-term, interim and long-term results Expressed as a % or rate. Outcome Measures - Example Found in the Performance Requirements section. Minimizing Barriers to Homeownership 100% of families (N=100) will complete pre home ownership education and counseling 75% of families (N=75) completing pre home ownership, education and counseling will have their homeowners loan packages approved 66% of families ( N=50) will become homeowners Defines the results achieved from the contract. Includes short-term, interim and long-term results Expressed as a % or rate. Long -Term The projected outputs, outcomes, goals and objectives will contribute to the increase of those moving above the federal poverty level and into self sufficiency in the catchment area by 50% in 3 years Performance Measures 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Demand: Supports the need for the service Input: Defines how much money is needed Output: Defines the services provided Outcome: Defines the results achieved Service Quality Efficiency 5. Service Quality Defined as how well the service was delivered, based on characteristics important to the recipient Used to determine if we are meeting the expectations of the recipient Takes the form of: • Timeliness • Accuracy • Meeting regulatory requirements • Courtesy Found in the Project Evaluation section of SOW Demonstrating Service Quality It’s not just delivering the service to the recipients… It’s HOW well it’s delivered! Service Quality Measures - Example Found in the Project Evaluation section. Defines how well the service was delivered, based on characteristics important to the recipient. Describe in the form of timeliness, accuracy, regulatory requirements, courtesy, and meeting recipient’s needs. 90% of the small businesses will say that the training and technical assistance they received was helpful 90% of small businesses will say that the trainers were knowledgeable For those loans not approved feedback from bank will show denial resulted from other than technical errors or things the trainer can not control such as type of project, financial projections, credit history or character. Performance Measures 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Demand: Supports the need for the service Input: Defines the resources invested Output: Defines the services provided Outcome: Defines the results achieved Service Quality: Defines how the services will be provided to the recipient’s satisfaction. 6. Efficiency 6. Efficiency Monitors the relationship between the amount produced and the resources used The cost per output or result (such as an evaluation or a study). Expressed as a dollar amount Found in the Reimbursement section of the SOW Efficiency Measures - Example Cost per participant or result. $200,000 (SB) ÷ 10 (SB) = $20,000 per small business Expressed as a dollar amount. 300,000 (home project) ÷100(families) = $3,000 per family Found in the reimbursement section Performance Measures 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Demand: Supports the need for the service Input: Defines how much money is needed Output: Defines the services provided Outcome: Defines the results achieved Service Quality: Defines how well the service was delivered 6. Efficiency: Cost per participant or result Benefits of Performance Measures Strengthens the program Contractor learns what is working and where improvement is needed Builds a strong case for future funding More people in need are served with the best possible programs Competitive Bid Process & Waiver of Competition What is the best way to find the appropriate Vendors? Competitive Bid Process RFP – A Request for Proposal (referred to as RFP) is an invitation for suppliers, often through a bidding process, to submit a proposal on a specific commodity or service. – A bidding process is one of the best methods for leveraging a company's negotiating ability and purchasing power with suppliers – The Request process brings structure to the procurement decision and allows the risks and benefits to be identified clearly upfront. – The Request purchase process is lengthier than others, so it is used only where its many advantages outweigh any disadvantages and delays caused. The added benefit of input from a broad spectrum of functional experts ensures that the solution chosen will suit the company's requirements. – Unlike an RFA, the applicants are not aware of the reward amount. Award is made to the offeror presenting the most advantageous overall proposal to the State. – These are posted by OPCS on the IPS site for all interested vendors to have access to the information. Competitive Bid Process RFA – Request for Application - A competitive process that usually results in the award of more than one contract. Unlike the RFP, applicants are knowledgeable of the award amount and are asked to submit an application that includes a description of services to be performed and a budget narrative of the potential award amount. – These are posted to the DHHS website for all vendors to be able to access the information. Competitive Bid Process So, what’s the difference in the RFA and RFP? – RFA’s are used when the funding source is acting as flow-through for grant funding. – RFA’s are used with non profit entities. Competitive Bid Process RFP or RFA? – Resource and Referral services using funds from Child Care and Development Block Grant to support or carry out a program. – Janitorial maintenance services from for the State – Evaluation Recommendation and Implementation of a new medical records system for the State. – Expand after school program services for at risk children using funds from Temporary Assistance for Needy Families Block Grant Competitive Bid Process What if I need information prior to issuing an RFP? RFI – Request for Information - An informal method of soliciting general information to aid in later planning of specification writing. NO contract results from this process. To be used to obtain technical information NOT pricing. Competitive Bid Process RFQ – The Request for Quotation (RFQ) is used where discussions aren't required with bidders (mainly when the specifications of a product or service are already known), and price is the main or only factor in selecting the successful bidder. – RFQ may also be used as a step prior to going to a fullblown RFP to determine general price ranges. In this scenario, products, services or suppliers may be selected from the RFQ results to bring in to further research in order to write a more fully fleshed out RFP. Waiver of Competition Sole source and Government Contracts Contracts with public agencies (other state departments, UNC system, community colleges, local government agencies) do not justify a waiver of competition. • Sole source contracts with a for profit, non profit, or individual must justify a waiver of competition. • ALL contracts must justify how costs were determined as reasonable. Waiver of Competition Does this meet waiver of competition requirements? a) The contractor is in close proximity of clients and parents. b) The feds said to use this contractor. c) The division does not have the resources. Waiver of Competition Does this meet waiver of competition requirements? a) Discussions were held to ensure resources were allocated appropriately b) The division has contracted with this vendor since 1987 c) Performance has been satisfactory. d) The vendor home office is in NC e) Legislative mandate states that we must provide this service Waiver of Competition Does this meet a waiver of competition? a) A particular medical service is required. b) Competition was solicited, but no satisfactory offers were received. c) An emergency existed. Waiver of Competition Waivers of competition should be explained in detail and defended if challenged later. Overview of Contract Administration What should I be doing? Overview of Contract Administration WHEN IS A CONTRACT NEEDED? The use of a bi-lateral contract signed depends on the parties involved, whether the purchase is for goods or services, and sometimes even the type of services. BI-LATERAL CONTRACT REQUIRED A bi-lateral contract serves as a check and balance that monitors procurement activity for improper relationships, fraud, conflict of interest issues, regulatory requirements, etc. The contracting review and signature process provides for review by more than one individual which gives more opportunity to correct potential problems before a contract is executed. Overview of Contract Administration Contract Administration is any action by either party to the contract from the time of contract award until completion. Contract Administrators are responsible for the day to day management of the contract. Contract Manager serves as a resource for the division, oversee all contracts within the agency and provide technical knowledge, training, necessary information and logical methods to help the accuracy in the contracting process and increase efficiency. Overview of Contract Administration Main objectives are to: – ensure compliance to general contracting requirements; – ensure contractor’s progress and performance complies with the contract; – resolve issues that arise during the life of a contract; Overview of Contract Administration Main objectives continued: – ascertain contract amendments or revisions, negotiate fair adjustments, and determine which parties are responsible for approving cost increases; – keep accurate records and documentation pertaining to the contract; – prevent lapse in service. Overview of Contract Administration Components of Contract Administration Process 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Relationship Management Planning Pre Award Orientation Post Award Monitoring Payment Termination Close Out Overview of Contract Administration Relationship Management Creating a good working relationship, establishing mutual goals upfront, and partnering with all those involved in the contracting process helps prevent disputes and conflicts that may arise during the life cycle of the contract Overview of Contract Administration Planning Review start and end dates to make sure that there is no lapse in service. Review procurement file and identify those critical contract issues Read the Contract in full Establish a performance monitoring plan Identify team members and responsibilities Overview of Contract Administration Pre Award Orientation Pre-meeting with applicable program and contracting officials prior to the post award orientation conference so that there is a clear understanding of their specific responsibilities and restrictions in administering the contract. Items that should be discussed at the pre award meeting include such things as the responsibility of the personnel who will administer the contract, risks, quality control and testing, the specific contract deliverable requirements, special contract provisions, procedures for monitoring and measuring performance, contractor billing, voucher approval, and payment procedures Overview of Contract Administration Post Award Post award orientation, either by conference, letter or some other form of communication, should be the beginning of the actual process of good contract administration. This communication process can be a useful tool that helps government and contractor achieve a clear and mutual understanding of the contract requirements, helps the contractor understand the roles and responsibilities of the government officials who will administer the contract, and reduces future problems. Overview of Contract Administration Post Award continues However, it is not a substitute for the contractor’s fully understanding the work requirements at the time offers are submitted, nor is it to be used to alter the final agreement arrived at in any negotiations leading to contract award. Overview of Contract Administration Monitoring Monitoring plans should be implemented to monitor the contractors performance Examine potential risk to the agency Establish required level of monitoring Establish conformance to requirements set in the monitoring plan Overview of Contract Administration Monitoring continues Monitoring should be commensurate with the criticality of the service or task and the resources available to accomplish monitoring Overview of Contract Administration Payments Payment to a contractor implies work is progressing according to the contract; therefore the contract administrator must be assured that the government is getting what it paid for. Payments should only be made to contractors that perform according to contract terms and conditions. This can be determined by monitoring contractor’s performance through review of monthly reports, onsite visits, surveillance reviews, etc. Overview of Contract Administration Payment Continues Prior to certifying invoices for payment review invoices to evaluate accuracy and cost allow ability and reasonableness Measure submitted costs against funds available Ensure invoices/payments are consistent with contract payment schedule Overview of Contract Administration Termination Use this choice as a last resort High risk option Contractor or bonding agent may protest Negotiation/litigation may take months May be the only/best option Overview of Contract Administration Close Out Contract closeout begins when the contract has been physically completed, i.e., all services have been performed and products delivered. Closeout is complete when all administrative actions have been completed, all disputes settled, and final payments have been made. This process can be simple or complex depending on the contract type for cost-reimbursement contracts. Process requires close coordination between contract office, budget office, program office and the contractor. Overview of Contract Administration Close Out Process Continues Collect all required forms and reports Settle outstanding issues Conduct joint final inventory Make final payments Close out Contract file Conduct agency debriefing Recommend changes to next procurement contract Overview of Contract Administration Ethics Impartiality – it is the basic obligation of public service that employees shall act impartially and not give preferential treatment to any private organization or individual. Even the appearance of partiality or preferential treatment is a violation of the regulation on standards of conduct. Overview of Contract Administration Ethics – You are the contract administrator to specific program related service contracts and are working on an RFA to send to several non profits. – One of the non profits and potential subcontractor invites you to lunch. Should you go? Overview of Contract Administration Ethics Conflict of Interest with contracts: No DHHS employee will draft, negotiate, administer, accept or approve any contract or subcontract on behalf of the State if he/she or his/her immediate family has, directly or indirectly, any financial interest in such a contract or subcontract. Overview of Contract Administration Ethics A romantic relationship has developed between the contact administrator and a contractor employee. How should this be handled? Overview of Contract Administration Ethics Gifts – anything of value. No DHHS employee may request or receive any gift or favor from any contractor, subcontractor, supplier or other business entity or individual that has a present, past, or anticipated financial interest in any matter under the jurisdiction of DHHS. Overview of Contract Administration Ethics The contractor offers hockey tickets to the contract administrator for his birthday. Should he accept the tickets? Overview of Contract Administration Ethics Gifts received from a contractor, subcontractor or supplier doing business directly or indirectly with DHHS must be reported to the Secretary of DHHS. Overview of Contract Administration Ethics The company your contract is with offers you weekend use of a beach or mountain home... Should you accept the gift? Dealing with the Information Overview of Contract Administration Budget revisions : can change the contract line items, but cannot change the total contract amount. What’s the process for a budget revision? Overview of Contract Administration Budget revisions to contract in grant form “Wiggle Room” • The Controller’s Office allows a 10% adjustment in line items without having the contractor send through a formal budget revision -- as long as this does not affect the total dollar amount. • Be sure to keep track of what item has been modified, total line item adjustments cannot exceed 10%. Overview of Contract Administration Line item budget revision example: • • • • • Salaries = $ 50,000 Supplies = $ 8,000 Equipment Rental = $ 2,000 Travel = $ 10,000 Total contract amount = $ 70,000 The contractor has higher expenses in Supplies than first expected, and wants to shift money to compensate for this increase. The increase is $ 2,000. Where can this adjustment come from? Overview of Contract Administration Line item budget revision example: The amount for salaries can be adjusted: • • • • • Salaries = $ 48,000 Supplies = $ 10,000 Equipment Rental = $ 2,000 Travel = $ 10,000 Total contract amount = $ 70,000 The Total Contract Amount did not change. Overview of Contract Administration Line item title Original amount + or - New Salaries $50,000 - $2,000 $48,000 Supplies $8,000 + $2,000 $10,000 Equipment $2,000 $2,000 Travel $10,000 $10,000 Total $70,000 Overview of Contract Administration Using the same example: • • • • • Salaries = $ 50,000 Supplies = $ 8,000 Equipment Rental = $ 2,000 Travel = $ 10,000 Total contract amount = $ 70,000 The contractor wants to take the $ 2,000 from travel, and move it to supplies. Is the contractor able to do this? Overview of Contract Administration That will not work, 10% of travel is $1,000. The contractor would only be able to shift the 10% from this category, and would have to look at another category to shift the rest. • • • • • Salaries = $ 50,000 Supplies = $ 10,000 Equipment Rental = $ 1,000 Travel = $ 9,000 Total contract amount = $ 70,000 Leaving the Total Contract Amount unchanged. Overview Contract Administration Line item title Salaries Original amount $50,000 + or - New Supplies $8,000 + $2,000 $10,000 Equipment $2,000 - $1,000 $1,000 Travel $10,000 -$1,000 $9,000 $50,000 Overview of Contract Administration Budget Amendments Any change to the TOTAL CONTRACT AMOUNT must be completed through a contract amendment process. Overview of Contract Administration Budget items must match – CAF, Justification Memorandum, Contract Cover, SOW, Line Item Budget, DHHS Contract System Entry • Carefully review all budget entries and totals for the contract. They must match. • Review invoices for accuracy. Think about what we’re paying for? And how much? • Controller’s Office requests that the amount of invoice being approved for payment along with the account and center coding be circled. Overview of Contract Administration – The CAF details the funding and total amount to be: • $155,435. – The General Contract Cover specifies: • The contractor will be paid $155, 435. – The SOW specifies: • The amount allocated for this contract is $150,435. – The Line Item Budget Detail documents: • The total for the contract is $150,435. – The entry in the DHHS Contract System and NCAS mirrors the funding on the CAF • the total entered is: $155,435. How much is the contract really for? What should the contractor expect to get paid? You must track down where the difference is coming from and have all documents within the contract reflect the same amount. Overview of Contract Administration Invoice Accuracy – The Contract Administrator is responsible for making sure the invoices that come from the contractor are timely and accurate. Double check what is being billed for, and what is being paid. – It is essential that you keep accurate records and complete documentation to be able to efficiently monitor the contract. – If there are any discrepancies on an invoice, check with the contractor right away to get clarification and resolve and issues. – Insure that all mathematical computations are correct including year-to-date expenditures. Overview of Contract Administration “Playing catch up on invoices” If a batch comes in for July – December and it’s missing Sept. and Oct., then Nov. and Dec. can’t be paid without Sept. and Oct. invoices. Overview of Contract Administration Budgets If, for example, the state funded contract for administrative services is expending 10% less than projected budget... What should the administrator do? a) b) Wait until the end of the year and revert funds? Do a contract amendment prior to the end of the year and use the funds in other effective services? Overview of Contract Administration CONTRACT APPROVAL FORM – BUDGET INFORMATION Original A-1 Total or Amend. $300,000 $125,000 Amt Current Contact 0 $300,000 Total New Contract Total $300,000 $425,000 A-2 $(25,000) $425,000 $400,000 Overview of Contract Administration FISCAL YEAR FUNDING INFORMATION SFY Co# Acct Center Amount Federal State 2009 2B01 52399 1212 $200,000 $100,000 $100,00 0 2010 $100,000 $75,000 2B01 53299 1212 $ 300,000 Total Contract amount Other $25,000 Overview of Contract Administration Contract Funding Information Amount Percentage Fund Source CFDA # $100,000 50% MCHB XXXX $100,000 50% STATE $75,000 75% TANF $25,000 25% OTHER $300,000 Total Contract amount XXXX Overview of Contract Administration Program and Service Type Information by Fiscal Year Funding SFY Co# Acct Center Amount Program Name Service Type 2009 2B01 52399 1212 $ 200,000 Direct 2009 2B01 53299 1212 $100,000 Direct JOE's MEDICAL OUTREACH SERVICES Original Contract Budget Item Salaries Fringe Rent Supplies Travel Client Services Amount $100,000.00 $25,000.00 $25,000.00 $5,000.00 $10,000.00 $135,000.00 Total $300,000.00 JOE'S MEDICAL OUTREACH SERVICES Amendment I Budget Item Salaries Fringe Rent Supplies Travel Client Services Amount $ 100,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 10,000.00 $ 135,000.00 New A-1 Contract Budget $ 100,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 20,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 5,000.00 $ 15,000.00 $ 100,000.00 $ 235,000.00 Total $ 300,000.00 $ 125,000.00 $ 425,000.00 Amendment 2 Budget Item Salaries Fringe Rent Supplies Travel Client Services Total Current $ 100,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 15,000.00 $ 235,000.00 $ 425,000.00 New A-2 Contract Budget $ 100,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ 25,000.00 $ (15,000.00) $ 10,000.00 $ (10,000.00) $ 5,000.00 $ 235,000.00 $ (25,000.00) $ 400,000.00 Overview of Contract Administration Deliverables – Accurate records are necessary to keep track of the contract activities and deliverables. – Creating a timeline of activities, reports and deliverables will help you monitor what is expected from the contractor and resolve issues if expectations are not met. Overview of Contract Administration Should contracts have a final report due after the ending date? If the contract has a report due after the ending date of the contract, is final payment made without a report? Overview of Contract Administration Deliverables – SOW lists: • progress report due 12/31/07 and • annual report due 06/30/08. So, what should the report include? Overview of Contract Administration How do you use this information? – If the Contractor is not meeting objectives, review objectives to see if it’s reasonable for adjustment or issue a Corrective Action Plan – But, don’t wait until the end of the year to find out how the contractor is doing or what’s going on with the program. – Present this to your COE for discussion. Overview of Contract Administration My contract ended 6/30/08. – Can I amend it on 7/03/08? My contact was effective on 10/01/06 and ends on 09/30/08. – Can I amend the contract to extend the period of time? My contact was effective on 7/01/05 and ends on 06/30/08. – Can I amend the contract to extend the period of time? Overview of Contract Administration What happens when work begins before the contract is fully effective? – The contractor is acting at their own risk when working without a contract. – Any assurances by the division to the contractor are outside of their legal authority and therefore not binding. – If a dispute arises between the start of performance and the signing of the contract, there is nothing to use to resolve it. – A contract contains protections for both parties – the division and contractor. If there’s work and no fully executed contract, neither one of them has those protections. – Also, by statute, anyone spending money for a purpose other than for which it was appropriated may be held personally liable for the sum so spent. Overview of Contract Administration Why revise the scope of work when its a no cost extension? – If the original scope of work specifically covers the contract period, then technically no work is required during the no cost extension. For example, timelines in the original scope of work. Overview of Contract Administration Previous Audit Findings – Program manager had a personal service contract with a non profit agency while simultaneously acting as contract administrator for a division contract. – Failure to determine that a secondary employment situation did exist and thereby permitting the conflict of interest to exist. Overview of Contract Administration Previous Audit Findings – An 80,000 contract with another state agency was not handled in accordance with the State rules and regulations. – Invoices were paid without adequate supporting documentation, and the contract was incorrectly classified as a personal service contract. Overview of Contract Administration Previous Audit Findings The division failed to adequately identify the federal awarding agency or Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance (CFDA) number in the sub recipient contracts. General Contracting Requirements & Specific Contract Documents Contract Approval Flow General Contracting Requirements Contract Approval Flow Use the Contract Approval Flow chart to determine the correct approvals for your contract. Know the following to determine contract approval flow: • • • • service type dollar amount options (how procured) contractor agency type General Contracting Requirements Contract Approval Flow – All Contracts must go through an internal approval process. – The Contract Approval Form (CAF) walks you through the necessary approvals. General Contracting Requirements Internal Approvals ◊ Contract Administrator ◊ Section Chief Signature ◊ Division Contract Office ◊ Division Budget Office ◊ Division Personnel Manager (if Personal Service) ◊ COE Chair ◊ Division Director General Contracting Requirements Contract Approval Flow – Some contracts will need External approval. – The requirements for external approvals will depend upon the service type, dollar amount, options (how the contract was secured), and type of contractor. General Contracting Requirements External Approvals ◊ DIRM – containing any IT related service ◊ Public Affairs – containing any Media related service ◊ DHHS B&A – depending upon the service, contract amount, how the contract was selected, and the type of contract. ◊ DHHS Personnel – Personal Service, $10,000 ◊ OPCS – depending upon the service, contract amount, how the contract was selected, and the type of contract. ◊ The Secretary – any Other State Agency ◊ AG’s Office - RFP over $25,000 ◊ Other General Contracting Requirements Examples You have a Contract that focuses on specialized training of staff. The contract includes items such as: – – – – Travel Supplies Computer Equipment purchase ($6,000) Maintenance of computer equipment and software. At a Glance… will this need External approval? General Contracting Requirements The Computer items should raise a flag. – This contract deals with IT purchase and maintenance – and needs DIRM approval. – The IT Checklist is to be completed for every contract, and will guide you through determining whether the contract needs to go through DIRM for approval. General Contracting Requirements Examples You have a Contract that focuses on educating consumers about birth defects and the importance of prenatal care. The contract includes items such as: – – – – Salaries Supplies Office Equipment Design and Publishing of promotional materials At a Glance… will this need External approval? General Contracting Requirements The Media item should raise a flag. – This contract deals with Design and Publishing of promotional materials – and needs Public Affairs approval. – The Publication Approval Form can be found on the Public Affairs web site. The web site also contains useful information about required elements in all publications, etc. General Contracting Requirements Examples using the Flow Chart: – You have an education contract that was awarded from an RFP. – The contract is with a Non-Profit agency for $ 50,000. What approvals are required? General Contracting Requirements – – – – This is a Program Related Service = Education Value = $50,000 The Option = RFP Type of Contractor = Non-Profit Approval levels required for this contract – All internal (except HR) – External approvals required for this contract • • • • DHHS B&A OPCS AG State P&C General Contracting Requirements Examples using the Flow Chart: – A training contract in the amount of $230,000 with the Department of Administration. What approvals are required? General Contracting Requirements – – – – This is a Program Related Service = Training Value = $230,000 The Option = Government Type of Contractor = Other State Department Approval levels required for this contract – All internal (except HR) – External approvals required for this contract • OPCS • Secretary General Contracting Requirements Examples using the Flow Chart: – You have an maintenance contract that was awarded from an RFQ. – The contract is with a For-Profit agency for $ 9,000. What approvals are required? General Contracting Requirements – – – – This is an Operation = Maintenance Value = $9,000 The Option = RFQ Type of Contractor = For-Profit Approval levels required for this contract – All internal (except HR) – No external approvals required for this contract General Contracting Requirements Examples using the Flow Chart: – You have a sole source direct medical service contract. – The contract is with a For-Profit agency for $ 190,000. What approvals are required? General Contracting Requirements – – – – This is an Program Related Service = Direct Medical Services Value = $190,000 The Option = Sole source Type of Contractor = For-Profit Approval levels required for this contract – All internal (except HR) – No external approvals required for this contract General Contracting Requirements If the value of that contract was over $200,000, then the contract would require approval from the Office of Procurement & Contract Services. General Contracting Requirements Examples using the Flow Chart: – Providing staff training to DHHS – This is a sole source contract with a for profit for $20,000. What approvals are required? General Contracting Requirements – – – – This is an Operations Related Service = Staff Training Value = $20,000 The Option = sole source Type of Contractor = For-Profit Approval levels required for this contract – All internal (except HR) – B&A – OPCS General Contracting Requirements Examples using the Flow Chart: – A personal services contract (with an individual) providing IT related services for $9,000 at a rate of $80 per hour. What approvals are required? General Contracting Requirements – – – – This is an IT related service = Programming Value = $8,000 The Option = Personal Services Type of Contractor = Individual Approval levels required for this contract – – – – All internal (including HR) DIRM DHHS HR B&A General Contracting Requirements Personal Service Contracts Specific Documents Required Contract Documents Contract Documents (depending upon the Type of contract) – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – Contract Approval Flow Chart Contract Approval Form (CAF) Contract Determination Questionnaire Indirect Cost Rate Cash Advance Documentation Contract Justification IT Checklist HIPAA Checklist/BA Addendum General Contract Cover (a. UNC b. General) Terms and Conditions (a. Private b. Local Gov. c. State Dept. d. Health Care) SOW (including elements and measures) Line Item Budget and Budget Narrative Conflict of Interest Policy/Acknowledgement Federal Certifications (a. Tobacco b. Debarment c. Lobbying d. Drug-Free Workplace e. Lobbying Activities) No Overdue Tax Certification ITS Tax Exempt Letter/Verification Required Contract Documents Contract Approval Form Requires specific information about the contract along with appropriate routing and signature approval. The contracting review and signature process provides for review by more than one individual which gives more opportunity to correct potential problems before a contract is executed Required Contract Documents Audit Determination Questionnaire – States, local governments, and non-profit organizations that receive federal and/or state funds must comply with the audit requirement in OMB Circular A-133 – Contractors that meet the definition of “sub recipient” are subject to the audit requirement, but contractors that meet the definition of “Vendor” are not. – The audit determination form is a guide used to help determine whether payments constitute a federal award or a payment for goods or services Required Contract Documents Audit Determination Questionnaire (Cont.) – Unless otherwise required, for-profit/commercial entities are not subject to these requirements – To distinguish between the two types of contracts, refer to OMB Circular A-133 and NCAC T10 C1 S/B.0400. There is a list of question to assist in distinguishing between a purchase of service or financial assistance arrangement Required Contract Documents Subrecipient Characteristics: Determines who is eligible to receive financial assistance; Has it performance measured against whether the objectives of the programs are met; Is responsible for adherence to applicable state program compliance requirements; and Uses funds to carry out a program of the organization as compared to providing goods or services for a program of the pass-through entity. Required Contract Documents Vendor Characteristics: Provides the goods and services within normal business operations; Provides similar goods or services to many different purchasers Operates in a competitive environment Provides goods or services that are ancillary to the operations of the state program; and Is subject to the compliance requirement of the state program. Required Contract Documents At a Glance, what is your determination of the following (FA or POS): – Contract award to evaluate a new program – Contract award to administer NC Food Stamp program – Contract award to provide psychiatrist to Cherry Hospital – Provide HIV services to low income citizens Required Contract Documents Congratulations if you made the following determinations. – Contract award to evaluate a new program (POS) – Contract award to administer NC Food Stamp program (FA) – Contract award to provide psychiatrist to Cherry Hospital (POS) – Provide HIV services to low income citizens (FA) Required Contract Documents Indirect Cost Any cost that is incurred for common objectives and therefore cannot be directly Charged or traced to a specific activity or any single cost objective. If a contractor budget include indirect (or administrative) cost : Contractor may include indirect cost in the contract budget for reimbursement if they have have a predetermined indirect cost rate, fixed rate or provisional rate Review contract funding source to determine possible limitations regarding administrative cost Official documentation of indirect cost include either an official document for the cognizant federal agency or an independent source (not the contractor) Verify indirect cost computation to ensure that indirect cost is not computed on excluded line items or those with dollar limitations A copy of the official indirect cost documentation must be attached to the executed contract Required Contract Documents Cash Advance Request Requirements Advances may be allowed if they meet the Dept criteria and “Advance of Financial Assistance Funds Policy” – Approved only when the lack of an advance would create an economic hardship for the contractor – Not allowed for procurement of goods and services and Purchase of Services contracts – Advance should not exceed the cash requirement for up to sixty days – Requesting agency must document the need via the DHHS Certification of Cash Need and submit to the DHHS Controllers Office Required Contract Documents Cash Advance – Signature required by Entity’s director, board chair person and entire board – If contractor is funded with federal funds, the division must identify and budget state funds to support the advance; however, federal funds may be used to support the advance if allowed by the federal regulations – Must include “advance request” payment for service language in the contract – All advances must be settled before June 30 the fiscal year end Required Contract Documents LET’S TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE.... 1. What types of contracts may be eligible for cash advance? (A) Financial Assistance or (B) Purchase of Service 2. Cash advances typically should not exceed what time period (A) 60 days or (B) 90 days 3. Contract must be signed and in place prior to cash advance (A) True or (B) False Required Contract Documents 4. State or Federal funds must be budgeted to support the advance pay (A) True or (B) False 5. DHHS Certification of Cash Need form must be completed and submitted to: (A) Division Budget Office or (B) DHHS Controllers Officer 6. Contract document must include the “advance request” payment for service language” (A) True or (B) False Required Contract Documents Contract Justification Memorandum Serves a stand alone contract and substantiate the reason for entering into the contract. Key Components include: • • • • Purpose and expectation of the contract Contractor Selection Method Selection Justification Contract and Program Funding Required Contract Documents IT Determination Letter DIRM must review and approve all contracts containing an Information Technology component. Refer to DIRM website for additional information. http://dirm.state.nc.us/dirmhome Required Contract Documents HIPPA The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191) Individually Identifiable Health Information Information that is a subset of health information, including demographic information collected from an individual, and: (1) Is created or received by a health care provider, health plan, employer, or health care clearinghouse; and Required Contract Documents (2) Relates to the past, present, or future physical or mental health or condition of an individual; the provision of health care to an individual; or the past, present, or future payment for the provision of health care to an individual; and (i) That identifies the individual; or (ii) With respect to which there is a reasonable basis to believe the information can be used to identify the individual. Required Contract Documents Business Associate A business associate relationship may arise when a person or organization performs a function or activity on behalf of a covered entity or provides certain legal, financial or management services to the covered entity and the function, activity or services involved in the use or disclosure of individually identifiable health information. Required Contract Documents HIPAA forms, instructions and other materials can be located on the HIPAA web site: http://hipaa.dhhs.state.nc.us/index.html Documentation needed for contracts may include: External Business Associate Assessment Tool (Instructions) Internal Business Associate Assessment Tool (Instructions) HIPAA Business Associate Addendum for Contract HIPAA Business Associate Addendum for Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) HIPAA MOA (stand alone) Required Contract Documents Indirect Cost Information Technology Checklist NCAS DHHS Contract System Tax Exempt Status – IRS Federal Tax Exempt Letter – Verification of IRS Federal Tax Exempt Letter Required Contract Documents General Cover – UNC - Use only for UNC System-modified version due to Master Agreement – Other-Use for all other Contractors – Delete attachments that do not apply and label attachments according to order of precedence as applicable – Delete all instructions in blue italics Required Contract Documents General Cover “must” include the following: – This Contract – General Terms and Conditions or Master Agreement for UNC – Scope of Work – Budget (Line Item) – Budget Narrative (descriptive) – All other attachments are “If Applicable” Required Contract Documents General Terms and Conditions – – – – – – Private Sector Private Universities Duke Medical Public Agencies (local governments) State Departments Health Care Providers Required Contract Documents Financial Assistance Requirements – No Overdue Tax Debts – Notice of Certain Reporting Requirements – Grants Information Center (GIC) General Contract Cover – UNC – All Other General Terms and Conditions – – – – – – Private Sector Private Universities Duke Medical Public Agencies (local governments) State Departments Health Care Providers Required Contract Documents Federal Assurances – Federal Disclosure of Lobbying Activities – Federal Certification Regarding Lobbying Form – Federal Certification Regarding Debarment, Suspension, Ineligibility, and Voluntary Exclusion-Lower Tier Covered Transaction – Federal Certification Regarding Drug-Free Workplace Requirements – Federal Certification Regarding Environment Tobacco Smoke Required Contract Documents Federal Certifications – The Federal Government requires individuals and organizations to sign certain certifications depending on the amount for federal citations. – Use the following guidelines to determine when these certifications are required Required Contract Documents Federal Certifications CERTIFICATION REGARDING LOBBYING (Referred to as the Hatch Act) – Include in sub awards for all tiers (Federal award > $25,000 or more) – The main provision is to prohibit federal employees (applies by extension to state and local government from engaging in partisan political activity and to prevent pernicious political activities which advocates the over throw of our constitution from of government. It forbids officials paid with federal funds from using promises of jobs, promotion, financial assistance, contracts, or any other benefit to coerce (influence) campaign contribution or political support. Required Contract Documents Federal Certifications CERTIFICATION REGARDING DEBARMENT, SUSPENSION, INELIGIBILITY AND VOLUNTARY EXCLUSION-LOWER TIERCOVERED TRANSACTIONS – Include in sub awards for all tiers (Federal award > $25,000 or more) – This executive order called for the creation of a government wide debarment and suspension system in connection with all transactions with federal agencies. – To curb fraud, waste, theft, embezzlement, falsification or destruction of records, and abuse in Federal programs, increase agency accountability and ensure consistency among agency regulations concerning debarment and suspension of participants in Federal programs – Applicants for federal funds are required to certify that neither they, their principals, nor their researchers are presently debarred, suspended, proposed for debarment, declared ineligible, or voluntarily excluded from covered transactions by any federal department or agency or have a civil judgement or criminal offense in connection with fraud, etc Required Contract Documents Federal Certifications CERTIFICATION OF DRUG FREE WORKPLACE REQUIREMENTS – Must provide with any federal participation – To inform about the dangers of drugs in the workplace – Contractor certifies that he will provide a drug free workplace by: Publishing a statement notifying employees that the unlawful manufacture, distribution dispensing, possession or use of a controlled substance is prohibited in the contractors workplace and specifying the actions that will be taken against employees for violation of such prohibition Required Contract Documents Federal Certifications Public Law 103-227, Part C-Environmental Tobacco Smoke, also known as the Pro Children Act of 1994 (Act) Required if there is any federal participation and the contractor provides health, child care, education, or library services to children under the age of 18 in indoor facilities) Required Contract Documents FEDERAL CERTIFICATION GUIDELINE REVIEW If the federal participation value of the contract is $25,000 or more, the Contractor must sign: – – The Certification Regarding Lobbying The Certification Regarding Debarment, Suspension, Ineligibility and Voluntary Exclusion If there is any federal participation, the Contractor must sign: – The Certification Regarding Drug-Free Workplace Requirements If there is any federal participation and the Contractor provides health, child care, education, or library services to children under the age of 18 in indoor facilities, the Contractor must sign: – The Certification Regarding Environmental Tobacco Smoke Include the appropriate attachments in the contract for any required certifications, if any. Required Contract Documents Example You have a contract providing health services to children. The contract amount consist of $250,000 in Federal Funding, Individual with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), CFDA # 81.181. At a Glance - are certifications required? If certifications are required, state the appropriate forms to attach. Required Contract Documents Example You have a contract providing training to social workers. The contract amount consist of $22,000 in federal funds, social services block grant and 200,000 in state funds At a Glance - are certifications required? If certifications are required, state the appropriate forms to attach. Required Contract Documents Conflict of Interest Policy What is a Conflict of Interest (COI): An actual or perceived interest by a member of an organization or group in an action that results in, or has the appearance of resulting in personal, organization, or professional gain. The conflict of interest occurs when the member or group has a direct fudiciary interest in another relationship Conflict of Interest Acknowledgement form Accompanies the Conflict of Interest Policy and must be notarized COI Verification needed on a yearly basis Required Contract Documents Conflict of Interest – Contracts extending more than one state fiscal year must include documentation in the file that the conflict of interest policy has not changed from the previous year. If the policy has changed a new conflict of interest policy is required – Conflict of Interest Policy is required with all private, non profit entities – Contract document (General Cover) must include COI language – Conflict of Interest not required for UNC system, local government and public authority agencies Required Contract Documents 1. At a Glance – who are required to have a COI? (A) Governmental Agencies (B) Private Entities (for-profit) (C) Private Entities( non-profit) 2. COI verification is needed every three years (A) True or (B) False 3. The contractor signed a three year contract but their COI policy changed from when the contract was initially awarded. Thus, the contractor should: (A) Submit a new COI or (B) Do nothing Required Contract Documents Is the following a Conflict of Interest (yes or no) 1. A contract has been awarded to a contractor to review insulin drug claims, but the contractor also serves on the board for Eli Lilly & Company 2. A contract has been awarded to a church to carry out youth services, whereby the contract administrator belongs to the church and is also over the youth services Required Contract Documents Financial Assistance Contract Requirements Certification of No Overdue Tax Debts – Certifies that the contractor does not any overdue tax debts – Not required for UNC system, local government and public authority agencies – Contract document (General Cover) must include “statement of no overdue tax debt language Required Contract Documents Financial Assistance Contract Requirements Notice of Certain Reporting Requirements – Grantees, local governments, public authorities, and subgrantees shall comply with all rules and reporting requirements established by stature or administrative rules. – G.S 143C-6-23 required every grantee that receives a State or Federal pass-through funds directly from state agency to file annual reports on how those grants funds were used – 3 reporting levels (1) Less than $25,000, (2) At Less than $500,000 and, (3) $500,000 or more – Contract document (General Cover) must include “reporting requirements” language Required Contract Documents Financial Assistance Contract Requirements Grants Information Center (GIC) – All Annual grantee reports required by G.S.143C-6-23 must be entered on line in the Grants Information Center – A 15 digit GIC # is established for both Purchase of services and Financial Assistance contracts – Enter the GIC # in NCAS for FA and POS contracts paid under “specified” account codes – Enter new grantee information and update FA Grant award data and GIC # into the GIC – Controller will not process payment without a valid GIC Required Contract Documents Financial Assistance Contract Requirements Purchase of Service (POS) contracts are exempt from the statement of no overdue tax debts and reporting requirements Testing your knowledge: Which contract requires “no overdue tax debt” and “reporting requirements” forms? (a) Purchase of Service contract with a non profit (b) Financial Assistance contract with a non profit Required Contract Documents TAX EXEMPT IRS federal tax exempt letter applies when a Contractor qualifies for a non-profit tax exempt status. – If your agency has a copy of the IRS federal tax exempt letter on file, send the verification form to the contractor. (Delete instructions) Required Contract Documents Tax Exempt - 501(c)(3) designation When the agency becomes a state private non profit corporation, it can then apply for 501(c)(3) designation through the IRS. Once the IRS grants 501(c)(3) status, the organization is exempt from certain taxes and any donations to the charitable organization are tax deductible. Many individuals and organizations prefer to make donations to 501(c)(3) private non profits. Any organization or group can apply for 501(c)(3) status, provided their charter or mission focuses on the non profit’s objective DHHS Contract Compliance How can we show the good work that we are doing? DHHS Compliance with Contracting DHHS Compliance Review sheet – This worksheet is helpful in preparing and monitoring contracts. – Use this as a checklist to make sure to include all requirements and monitoring guide for the contract period. DHHS Compliance with Contracting OPCS Tracking Log – Tracks number of contracts that need OPCS approval – Tracks contract approval time, internal and external (+30, 30, <30) – Contract Compliance – Average Number of Days for approval, internal and external DHHS Compliance with Contracting Contract Approval Time-Frames SFY 2007 - 2008 Other - Including Legislative increase amendments 5% Contracts or amendments rec'd for approval more than 30 days prior to the effective date 18% Contracts or amendments rec'd for approval on or after effective date 15% Contracts or amendments rec'd for approval less than 30 days prior to the effective date 62% Timely Approvals Trend Analysis SFY 2006 – SFY 2008 SFY 2006 - 2008 Approval Time Frame Comparison 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% M ore than 30 days SFY 2006 Less than 30 days On or After effective date SFY 2007 Other - Including legislative increase SFY 2008 SFY 2006 - 2008 Compliance Comparison 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% DCD DM H DM H Fa ci l i ti es SFY 2006 DPH DSS DVR SFY 2007 ExecM gt SFY 2008 SFY 2006 - 2008 Compliance Comparison 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% DHSR SFY 2006 DIRM DM A DAAS DSB&HH SFY 2007 OES Rur a l Hl th EconOpp SFY 2008 Compliance Rating at the time of Approvals 2008 (SFY Totals) Results include only Contracts and Amendments that are approved through OPCS. Does not include RFPs that are sent to DOA or State P&C for approval 1 1 0 0 2 0 0 3 2% 2% 0% 0% 6% 0% 0% 2% 15 4 0 2 8 2 0 3 31% 9% 0% 15% 24% 3% 0% 2% 1 17 3 2 2 38 0 19 2% 40% 75% 15% 6% 52% 0% 15% 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 2% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 5% 4 0 0 0 0 5% 0% 0% 0% 0% 14 0 1 1 5 16% 0% 14% 14% 8% 7 0 1 1 3 8% 0% 14% 14% 5% 1 0 0 0 1 0 0% 2 11% 1 5% 11 2% 57 9% 95 15% Documents P5 COE Review # Non Compliant Performance P2 Required # Non Compliant P3 Timely Approval # Non Compliant problem in this area: P1 Approval Process # Non Compliant Division DCD 48 DHSR 43 DIRM 4 DMA 13 DMH 33 DMH -Facilities 73 DAAS 2 DPH 130 DPH-MinH DSB&HH DSS 88 DVR 88 OES 7 Rural Hlth 7 EconOpp 61 HR Prop & Constr ExecMgt 19 More@4 Controller DD Council MMIS Overall: 616 a % of ALL contracts that have # Non Compliant # of Contracts or Amendments Reviewed by OPCS # Non Compliant Areas of Contracts or Amendments NOT in Compliance OPCS Reviews (Edits, NCAS header, etc.) 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 1% 9 1 0 3 4 34 0 21 19% 2% 0% 23% 12% 47% 0% 16% 1% 0% 0% 0% 2% 0 0 0 0 0 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 28 0 6 3 10 32% 0% 86% 43% 16% 0 0% 0 0% 3 16% 10 2% 2 0% 122 20% P4 Measures Other Possible # of points per Row Possible # of points per Column # of contracts reviewed SFY 2008 - PBC Quality Rates Demand Input Output Outcome Service Quality Efficiency Total # DAAS 33% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 89% 1 3 18 DCD 73% 98% 98% 98% 98% 92% 93% 17 51 306 DHSR 52% 100% 100% 36% 9% 21% 53% 11 33 198 DIRM X X X X X X X 0 0 0 DMA 33% 100% 100% 67% 33% 33% 61% 1 3 18 DMH 83% 100% 100% 96% 88% 96% 94% 8 24 144 DMH -Facilities 90% 100% 100% 62% 71% 71% 83% 7 21 126 DPH 90% 100% 100% 81% 81% 86% 90% 43 129 774 DSS 80% 100% 99% 94% 93% 92% 93% 28 84 504 DVR 69% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 95% 16 48 288 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 19 57 342 Exec Mgmt X X X X X X X 0 0 0 OES X X X X X X X 0 0 0 Rural H 33% 100% 100% 100% 0% 100% 72% 2 6 36 Department Totals 81% 100% 100% 87% 83% 86% 89% 153 459 2754 Division EconOpp Areas of Compliance Trend Analysis SFY 2006 – 2008 SFY 2006 - 2008 Areas of Non-Compliance 250 200 150 100 50 0 P1 Approval Process P2 Required Documents SFY 2006 P3 Timely Approval SFY 2007 P4 Performance Measures P5 COE Review SFY 2008 P6 Other (Edits, NCAS header, etc.) DHHS Compliance with Contracting System Integration Advantages of Merging Systems: – Consistency: combined structure fosters better information management and reporting – Accountability: demonstrate successes and sound management – Facilitate auditing: reduce the potential for non-compliance penalties – Monitoring: enhance performance component of monitoring and contracting – Contracts/Subrecipient: enhance sub recipient and contracts component of program management – Time Savings: anticipated savings of time, less burdensome than three databases DHHS Performance Management Database Program Management Database DHHS Contract Numbers/Dollar Values/% Reviewed/Compliance Rate SFY 2008 Contract Data Divisions DCD Contracts in system (as of 7/08) sfy 2008 Approx. $ Value of Contracts as of 7/08 sfy 2008 funding % of Contracts Reviewed by OPCS Compliance Rate SFY 2008 48 $ 166,068,711 40% 52% DHSR 115 $ 10,759,660 19% 47% DIRM DMA DMH DMH - Facilities DAAS DPH DPH-MinH DSB&HH DSS DVR OES Rural Hlth EconOpp HR Prop & Constr ExecMgt B&A DD Council MMIS 73 89 73 317 12 619 0 31 488 139 31 529 121 0 5 34 5 41 0 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ 12,612,885 440,473,392 31,164,531 37,952,820 1,753,138 83,272,609 23,442,866 71,978,940 20,493,869 1,128,341 33,728,057 30,066,834 454,936 5,788,291 1,300,000 1,461,259 - 0% 7% 19% 18% 17% 9% 11% 29% 3% 1% 45% 44% - 25% 69% 55% 30% 100% 64% 49% 99% 14% 43% 82% 74% Government Accountability Efficient and Effective Management of State Resources Center of Excellence Merge Example: NC Rural Fund Program Goal: Help low income person in NC attain economic self sufficiency The primary purpose of this Contract is to: (1) Assist low income families to attain homeownership (2) Assist small businesses to start, maintain and or expand small businesses development resulting in jobs for low income citizens How? Provide technical assistance to small businesses which will result in the creation/maintenance of job opportunities for low-income citizens Increase awareness about local, state & federally sponsored initiatives that focus on minimizing barriers to employment, education and housing opportunities Scope of Work Types of Vendors What’s a non profit? Organization incorporated under State law and whose purpose is not to make a profit, but rather to further a charitable, civic, religious, scientific, or other lawful purpose. Q&A Thank You for your Participation