Growing the North Country Economy from the Inside Out By Michael H. Shuman1 Overview The North Country represents a largely rural region in upstate New York. It comprises seven counties—Clinton, Essex, Franklin Hamilton, Jefferson, Lewis, and St. Lawrence—with a collective population of 433,000. Facing many of the challenges of rural communities and small towns across America – including depopulation, a “brain drain” of young adults, a steadily decline of natural-resource industries, and online shopping – the North Country has been working assiduously to find new, promising ways to grow its economy. One indicator suggests particular urgency in the North Country developing a new approach to economic development. According to the New York Department of Labor Statistics, the overall unemployment rate of the region (as of February 2015) was 8.1%, significantly higher than the rate for the nation as a whole. Approximately 14,500 residents are unemployed and looking for work. How might those jobs best be created? Chart 1 Employment in the North Country (February 2015) Clinton Essex Franklin Hamilton Jefferson Lewis St. Lawrence North Country Estimate Labor Force Employed Unemployed Unemployment Rate 35,500 33,100 2,400 6.8% 17,400 16,100 1,300 7.7% 20,300 18,700 1,600 7.9% 2,300 2,100 200 9.2% 45,200 41,300 3,900 8.7% 11,900 10,700 1,100 9.6% 47,200 43,300 4,000 8.4% 179,800 165,300 14,500 8.1% Since 2003, thanks in part to the pioneering work of the Burt Endowment at St. Lawrence University, the North Country has been pursuing an economic-development strategy rooted in LOIS businesses—that is, businesses that are locally owned and import substituting. This paper suggests that the potential for growing jobs through LOIS remains enormous. In fact, if the region were to become 100% self-reliant, just the direct 1 Michael H. Shuman is a Stanford-educated economist, attorney, and author. His latest books are The Local Economy Solution: How Innovative, Self-Financing ‘Pollinator’ Enterprises Can Grow Jobs and Prosperity (Chelsea Green, 2015) and Local Dollars, Local Sense: How to Shift Your Money from Wall Street to Main Street (Chelsea Green, 2012). For comments on this paper or to conduct similar analysis of another community or region, visit www.michaelhshuman.com or contact the author directly by phone (202-669-1220), e-mail (shuman@igc.org ), or mail (2203 Quinton Rd., Silver Spring, MD 20910). H 1 effects would be about 93,000 new jobs that paid as much as $5 billion in new wages.2 The indirect effects (through greater business spending) and induced effects (through greater spending by the newly employed), while not measured in this paper, would be greater still—perhaps 50-100% greater. The bottom line for the North Country is this: Unemployment can essentially be wiped out if even 15% of its potential for self-reliance were realized. To accomplish this, the North Country should prioritize growing local professional services, local financial services, local food production, local retail, local health services, local construction companies, local information services, local transportation assets, local manufacturing inputs, and local renewable energy and energy efficiency. These jobs can be grown by expanding local investment in promising businesses in these sectors and by creating new economic-development businesses called “pollinators.” The paper proceeds as follows: - First, it reviews the arguments for LOIS economic development. - Second, it explains the principal suite of tools used—the BALLE Leakage Calculators—used for analyzing import-replacement opportunities. - Third, it presents the raw results from the “Overview Calculator,” which suggests the ten biggest opportunities for import substitution. - Fourth, it looks at results from the “Food Calculator” and the “Finance Calculator.” - Finally, it summarizes how the North Country can plug these leaks through local investment and through business pollinators. The Arguments for LOIS Economic Development Modern economic development has increasingly focused on one overarching goal—to “attract and retain” business. And to accomplish this, regions throughout the world have taken both “high road” and “low road” approaches. The “high road” approach includes providing a highly skilled and productive workforce and extensive infrastructure (transportation nodes, high-speed internet, and so forth). The “low road” approach aims to lower business costs by breaking unions and rolling back environmental laws. Some regions also have added incentives to attract and retain business through special grants or tax breaks (in the United States these state and local incentives are estimates to exceed $80 billion per year). 2 The methodology used predicts wages based on national wage data, and does not take into account regional variations. Because the North Country has a relatively low cost of living and relatively low wages, these numbers could be somewhat smaller. 2 Many of the other popular concepts in economic development today – industrial parks, high-tech clusters, tax-increment financing (TIFs), business incubators, even many greenjob programs – turn out ultimately to rely on the paradigm of attraction and retention. Every region in the world is now bidding for the privilege of having an office, branch factory, or retail outlet from a powerful global corporation. What’s odd about the formulation of “attract and retain” is that it ignores locally owned business. You cannot attract a local business—that would be an oxymoron. And if the only way you can retain a local business is by paying it some kind of bribe, how deep are the local roots of that business anyway? A growing body of evidence suggests that this model of economic development is ineffectual at best and a huge waste of local resources and opportunities at worst. One of the sharpest analysts of corporate attraction policies has been Professor Ann Markusen, director of the Project on Regional and Industrial Economics at the Humphrey Institute of Public Affairs, based at the University of Minnesota. Several years ago, she assembled the best analysts in the field to explore the validity of these critiques and to offer reforms. Some of these analysts believed that these deals were ultimately beneficial, some didn’t, and some were unsure. The resulting book of essays, Reining in the Competition for Capital (Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research, 2007), remains the best evaluations of the field. In the opening essay, Markusen and Katherine Ness of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign set out the problem by writing: “Incentive competition is on the rise. It is costly, generally inefficient, and often ineffective for the winning regions.”3 A more effective approach is to focus, laser-like, on locally owned, import-substituting (LOIS) businesses. Local ownership means that working control of a company is held within a small geographic area. Import-substituting means that the company is focused first and foremost (though not exclusively) on cost-effective production for local markets. While the vast majority of LOIS businesses are small, some actually grow to be quite large and powerful. Numerous studies in recent years suggest that local ownership –the LO in LOIS—enables businesses to contribute more to economic development than do global businesses attracted. Local ownership matters in at least five ways:4 Higher Multipliers – Locally owned businesses generally contribute more to the “economic multiplier.” More than two dozen studies over the past decade have compared the economic impacts of locally owned businesses with their nonlocal equivalents, and they have shown that local businesses generate two 3 Ann Markusen, ed., Reining in the Competition for Capital (Kalamazoo, MI: W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research, 2007). 4 Extensive documentation of these points can be found in Michael H. Shuman, The Small-Mart Revolution: How Local Businesses Are Beating the Global Competition (San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler, 2006), Chapter 2. 3 to four times the multiplier benefits.5 That means that every dollar that moves from a nonlocal to a local business in a community generates two to four times the extra income, two to four times the jobs, two to four times the local taxes, and two to four times the charitable contributions. More Reliable – While absentee-owned businesses increasingly consider moving to Mexico, China, or low-wage U.S. states, with only secondary concern for throwing the community into an economic tailspin, businesses anchored locally produce wealth more reliably for many years, often many generations. This means that economic-development investments in local business have greater payoffs. Higher Standards – Because local businesses tend to stay put, a community with primarily local businesses can raise labor and environmental standards with confidence that its businesses will adapt rather than flee. More Dynamic – A community made up of smaller, locally owned businesses is better equipped to promote smart growth and walkable communities, draw tourists through unique stores and attractions, retain talented young people who seek entrepreneurial opportunities and a distinct sense of place, and reduce the noise, fumes, and risks of unnecessary traffic. Better Social Impacts – Compared to economies dependent on absenteeowned enterprises, local-business economies tend to have more social stability, lower levels of welfare, and greater political participation. The case for promoting local ownership has been deepened by empirical evidence that regions with higher densities of local business have superior macroeconomic performance. For example: A 2010 study appeared in the Harvard Business Review under the headline “More Small Firms Means More Jobs.”6 The authors wrote, “Our research shows that regional economic growth is highly correlated with the presence of many small, entrepreneurial employers—not a few big ones.” The authors further argued that the major preoccupation of economic developers – how to attract global companies – is fundamentally wrong-headed. “Politicians enjoy announcing a big company’s arrival because people tend to think that will 5 See, for example, Michael H. Shuman, Local Dollars, Local Sense: How to Shift Your Money from Wall Street to Main Street and Achieve Real Prosperity (White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green, 2012), 17– 25. Also see Stacy Mitchell, The Big Box Swindle: The True Cost of Mega-Retailers and the Fight for America’s Independent Businesses (Boston: Beacon Press, 2006). 6 Edward L. Glaeser and William R. Kerr, “The Secret to Job Growth: Think Small,” Harvard Business Review, July-August 2010. 4 mean lots of job openings. But in a rapidly evolving economy, politicians are all too likely to guess wrong about which industries are worth attracting. What’s more, large corporations often generate little employment growth even if they are doing well.” Another study published shortly thereafter in the Economic Development Quarterly, a journal long supportive of business attraction practices, similarly finds: “Economic growth models that control for other relevant factors reveal a positive relationship between density of locally owned firms and per capita income growth, but only for small (10-99 employees) firms, whereas the density of large (more than 500 workers) firms not owned locally has a negative effect.”7 A paper published in 2013 by the Federal Reserve in Atlanta, which performed a regression analysis of counties across the United States, found statistically significant “evidence that local entrepreneurship matters for local economic performance . . . [T]he percent of employment provided by resident, or locally-owned, business establishments has a significant positive effect on county income and employment growth and a significant and negative effect on poverty….”8 Some see these results as paradoxical, because there’s also evidence that smaller businesses, which are likely to be locally owned, pay somewhat lower wages and offer fewer employee benefits than larger businesses (though the differential appears to be shrinking). How can it be that local businesses pay less, and yet local business communities prosper more? Conclusive research has yet to be done, but several theories might reconcile these results: Because successful small businesses often grow into larger businesses, an entrepreneurial community made up of many small businesses increases the probability of its ultimately enjoying larger businesses that pay better wages. Moreover, these larger businesses that grow indigenously remain locally owned and offer a more reliable basis for economic growth than briefly attracted outsiders. Even when local businesses contribute less to the local economy in wages than do nonlocal outsiders, they contribute more in other ways like local taxes, local supplier purchases, and local charitable contributions, which cascade through the economy through greater income, wealth, and jobs. The economic David A. Fleming and Stephan J. Goetz, “Does Local Firm Ownership Matter?,” Economic Development Quarterly, 2011. 7 8 Anil Rupesingha, “Locally Owned: Do Local Business Ownership and Size Matter for Local Economic Well-Being?,” monograph, August 2013. 5 multiplier “benefits” of local businesses may turn out to be more important to community prosperity than the “costs” of lower wages. Many of the most talented people in a community, particularly younger millennials, increasingly gravitate to companies that offer great opportunities rather than great wages. They are willing to take less pay, at least for a while, for independence and ownership. These “creatives,” as urbanist Richard Florida calls them in The Rise of the Creative Class, are important guarantors of global competitiveness.9 Another critical determinant of local prosperity is the strength of civil society through volunteer organizations, civic groups, foundations, and political groups. The state of Kerala in India, for example, has been able to achieve life expectancy and literacy rates matching Western standards without high incomes, because of its dense network of social institutions.10 In Bowling Alone, Harvard’s Robert Putnam has made similar arguments about the importance of strong civil society in ensuring the prosperity of American communities.11 Local business communities, with rich intimate personal relationships, are more likely to foster this kind of social capital. The second part of LOIS, the IS, is import substitution—the consumption of goods and services produced in close proximity. Every time a community imports a good or service that it might have cost-effectively produced for itself, it “leaks” dollars and loses the critically important multipliers associated with them. Moreover, unnecessary imports – of petroleum, for example –subject a community to risks of price hikes and disruptions far beyond local control. They also deny a community a diversified base of businesses and skills needed to take advantage of unknown (and unknowable) future opportunities in the global economy. Three examples help to illustrate the potential benefits of import substitution: 9 A generation ago, Güssing was a dying rural community of 4,000 in Austria. Its old industries of logging and farming had been demolished by global competition. Many of today's economic developers would have given up and encouraged the residents to move elsewhere. But the mayor of Güssing decided that the key to prosperity was to plug energy "leaks." He built a small district heating system in 1990, fueled with local wood. The local money saved by importing less energy was then reinvested in expanding the district heating system in 1996 and in new energy businesses. Since then, 50 new Richard Florida, The Rise of the Creative Class (New York: Basic Books, 2002). 10 Amartya Sen, Development as Freedom (New York: Anchor Books, 1999). 11 Robert Putnam, Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community (New York: Touchstone, 2001). 6 firms have opened, creating 1,000 new jobs. And most remarkably, the town estimates that this economic expansion will reduce its carbon footprint by 90 percent. In autumn of 2008 Marian Burros of the New York Times wrote a piece about how the 3000-person community of Hardwick, Vermont, has prospered by creating a new "economic cluster" around local food. Cutting-edge restaurants, artisan cheese makers, and organic orchardists turning fruit into exquisite pies are just some of the new businesses that have added an estimated 75-100 jobs to the area in recent years. A new Vermont Food Venture Center hopes to accelerate the creation of food enterprises. Even a single, visionary business can lead a community-wide effort at import substitution. Take Zingerman’s in Ann Arbor, Michigan. On its first day of business in a college town known globally more for its radicalism than for its food, Zingerman's Deli sold about $100 worth of sandwiches. That was 1982. It has since grown into a community of ten businesses, each independent but linked through overlapping partnerships that collectively employ 650 people and achieve annual sales of over $50 million. Over that period the proprietors conscientiously built a food cluster from scratch. They carefully assessed the items going into the deli – bread, coffee, cheese – and captured profitable opportunities for creating a bakery, a coffee roaster, and a creamery. They looked at the products being sold at the deli – fabulous coffee cakes and highquality meats – and built new, value-adding businesses with these products, including a mail-order company and a restaurant called the Roadhouse. These three case examples cast doubt on one of the principal prescriptions for regions by economic developers – that they should focus on expanding existing clusters of exportoriented business. These examples suggest that a smarter approach, especially for rural regions, is to create new clusters based, initially at least, on local demand. Two further clarifications about LOIS are important. First, import substitution does not mean withdrawing from the global economy. To the contrary, as the late Jane Jacobs argued, an economic strategy promoting import-substituting businesses turns out to be the best way to develop exports. Suppose the North Country wished to replace imports of electricity with local wind-electricity generators. Once it built windmills, it would be self-reliant on electricity but dependent on outside supplies of windmills. If it set up its own windmill industry, it would then become dependent on outside supplies of machine parts and metal. This process of substitution never ends, but it would leave the North Country with several new industries – in electricity, windmills, machines parts, and metal fabrication – poised to meet not only local needs but also export markets. But instead of putting all of a community’s enterprise eggs in one export-oriented basket that leaves the local economy vulnerable to fluctuating global markets, import substitution develops myriad small businesses, grounded (initially at least) in diversified local markets, many of which then becoming exporters. 7 Second, this perspective does not carry negative moral judgments about non-LOIS businesses. It just underscores that economic development, a concerted intervention in the economy by public or private authorities, always has limited resources, and it’s smart to invest those resources, whether money or time, in only those businesses most likely to boost the economic prospects of the region. Prioritization is critical to success. The BALLE Leakage Calculators To understand the North Country economy, a helpful tool is the Leakage Calculators designed by the author while he was research director of the Business Alliance for Local Living Economies (BALLE). The main function of the BALLE “Overview Calculator” is to estimate for a given county, region, or state the degree to which it is self-reliant now and the potential jobs and wages were the region to become self-reliant. It estimates the specific opportunities for import substitution in each of the 1,100 sectors in the North American Industrial Classification System (NAICS). Several other models exist that do this as well, including: RIMS II, which is sold by the US Department of Commerce; and IMPLAN, which comes from a private company called MIG. Both models provide comprehensive profiles of community economies throughout the United States, and show how a proposed change—a new stadium or a wage hike—can ripple through the local economy. The main problem with using these models is cost—the data for the seven counties of the North Country would have required several thousand dollars. The BALLE Leakage Calculator is substantially cheaper, and still provides the user with a reasonably good picture of job opportunities. The way the BALLE Overview Calculator works is that it constructs a model of a selfreliant United States for all 1,100 NAICS sectors. It then compares per-capita jobs for a given sector in a region with that of a self-reliant United States. If a region is above 100% self-reliance, it is probably exporting. If it is below 100%, it is probably importing. Compared to RIMS II and IMPLAN, the BALLE Leakage Calculator underestimates the potential for new jobs and wages.12 This means that the estimates that follow in this paper are overly conservative. Like a ruler, the BALLE Leakage Calculator only generates measurements, and it’s up to the user to apply intelligence in interpreting them. The calculators show how many jobs are possible through self-reliance, not how many jobs are plausible. And there are many reasons why a possible job might not be plausible: You can’t have oil-drilling jobs, for example, if you don’t have oil. You can’t have theater jobs if you don’t have theaters. Every region has competitive advantages, and that’s why leakage analysis must proceed alongside a sober assessment of assets and business designs. 12 The reason is two-fold. First, RIMS II and IMPLAN contain estimates of the amount of local production consumed locally. The BALLE Leakage Calculator, lacking these estimates, assumes that all local production is consumed locally. Second, RIMS II and IMPLAN also estimate the multiplier impacts of changes in demand, which amplify the direct effects. The BALLE Leakage Calculator only looks at the direct effects. 8 NAICS also has some quirks that US government statisticians promise to fix over time, and one of the most important is that it excludes farming. So another tool within the BALLE Leakage Calculators, called the “Food Calculator,” estimates leakages of fresh food. It is based on data from the U.S. Department of Agriculture. A third tool, the “Finance Calculator,” estimates how much money residents have squirreled away in savings. RIMS II and IMPLAN focus primarily on flows of purchasing dollars, not investment dollars, so this calculator is especially useful at estimating, based on national data from the Federal Reserve, what the level of local savings are. One final note: The BALLE Leakage Calculators are based on various data bases prepared by the U.S. government between 2008 and 2010. The results therefore are several years out of date (which is almost always the case with economic models). Estimated Leakage in the North Country The results from the Overview Calculator are shown in Chart 2. It shows eight “runs” of the Calculator—one for each of the seven counties in the North Country, and one for the region. Totaling all seven counties suggests a potential for 100,106 new jobs paying $5.3 billion. But when constructing a region, the Overview Calculator zeroes out new job opportunities for sectors that are above 100% self-reliant regionally as a conservatism.13 The better regional estimate is therefore 92,545 jobs paying about $5 billion. Chart 2 Overview of North Country Leakage Clinton Essex Franklin Hamilton Jefferson Lewis St. Lawrence Total New Jobs From New Wages From Self-Reliance Self-Reliance 15,895 $841,669,559 9,304 $534,761,899 13,227 $721,165,201 1,612 $92,605,992 26,033 $1,296,541,980 7,667 $415,515,688 26,368 $1,381,984,480 100,106 $5,284,244,799 Adjusted Estimate 92,545 13 $4,965,508,259 The North Country economy has a number of NAICS sectors where just one of its seven counties has a strong industry (with a self-reliance number greater than 100%) and the other six counties have nothing. In principle, each of these six counties still could grow jobs in this sector. The BALLE Calculator assumes, however, that if that one exporting county also can meet regional demand, then no new jobs should be considered possible. Hence, the adjusted estimate of new jobs is lower than the sum of all the counties individual jobs potential. 9 By providing detailed data for all 1,100 NAICS sectors, the BALLE Leakage Calculator can reveal interesting information about the North County. Chart 3a-3c, for example, shows all the NAICS sectors that are more than 100% self-reliant—that is, sectors that are exporting. Some of the “exporting” sectors – say, car dealerships –are best understood as providing goods and services to people in neighboring counties on the periphery of the North Country (or in Canada) who enter briefly to go shopping. Others—like marinas—are providing tourist services to outside visitors temporarily coming into the North Country. The pattern of strengths in the North Country is very similar to other rural regions of the United States. One can see some strengths rooted in traditional industries closely tied to natural resources, such as agriculture, forestry, mining, hydropower, and tourism. Some of these industries have led directly to certain kinds of manufacturing. The raising of dairy cows, for example, begat milk and cheese manufacturing; forestry begat wood and paper manufacturing; mining begat stone-related industries. Some manufacturing strengths just reflect the North Country’s unique history. Hence, the presence of several prominent universities in the region shows up as education “exports.” Appendix I presents similar charts for each of the seven counties. They reveal the contribution each county makes to the region’s strengths. Note, again, that these charts reflect NAICS data from 2008-2010, and some of these data are obsolete. For example, a cursory review by the North Country Symposium Committee of Appendix I(g), which lays out the strengths of St. Lawrence County, noted that the companies that accounted strengths in the manufacturing of fluid milk, cheese, mobile homes, and concrete blocks had recently moved their plants elsewhere or otherwise were no longer operating. 10 Chart 3a Top Sectors of Export Strength in the North County NAICS Code 113310 212312 212399 221111 221119 236115 236118 236220 311119 311511 311513 311991 315299 321992 322121 322130 322212 322222 323118 323119 323121 324121 325412 325612 326112 326150 326160 326199 327113 327331 327332 332111 332911 334412 336510 337122 339112 339113 339991 339994 339999 Regional Self-Reliance Logging 291% Crushed and Broken Limestone Mining and Quarrying 125% All Other Nonmetallic Mineral Mining 2189% Hydroelectric Power Generation 523% Other Electric Power Generation 412% New Single-Family Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) 185% Residential Remodelers 103% Commercial and Institutional Building Construction 109% Other Animal Food Manufacturing 256% Fluid Milk Manufacturing 376% Cheese Manufacturing 563% Perishable Prepared Food Manufacturing 136% All Other Cut and Sew Apparel Manufacturing 141% Prefabricated Wood Building Manufacturing 102% Paper (except Newsprint) Mills 522% Paperboard Mills 380% Folding Paperboard Box Manufacturing 284% Coated and Laminated Paper Manufacturing 445% Blankbook, Looseleaf Binders, and Devices Manufacturing 760% Other Commercial Printing 242% Tradebinding and Related Work 100% Asphalt Paving Mixture and Block Manufacturing 434% Pharmaceutical Preparation Manufacturing 252% Polish and Other Sanitation Good Manufacturing 687% Plastics Packaging Film and Sheet (including Laminated) Manufacturing 429% Urethane and Other Foam Product (except Polystyrene) Manufacturing 377% Plastics Bottle Manufacturing 141% All Other Plastics Product Manufacturing 126% Porcelain Electrical Supply Manufacturing 629% Concrete Block and Brick Manufacturing 140% Concrete Pipe Manufacturing 262% Iron and Steel Forging 226% Industrial Valve Manufacturing 103% Bare Printed Circuit Board Manufacturing 122% Railroad Rolling Stock Manufacturing 220% Nonupholstered Wood Household Furniture Manufacturing 131% Surgical and Medical Instrument Manufacturing 244% Surgical Appliance and Supplies Manufacturing 125% Gasket, Packing, and Sealing Device Manufacturing 197% Broom, Brush, and Mop Manufacturing 164% All Other Miscellaneous Manufacturing 105% Industry Name 11 Chart 3b Top Sectors of Export Strength in the North County NAICS Code 423220 423460 423820 424330 424410 424810 424940 441110 441120 441210 441221 441222 441310 444130 444190 444210 445210 445310 446110 446130 446199 447110 448140 452990 453110 453930 454311 454312 454319 483114 484220 485410 485991 488190 488510 511110 515111 515120 519120 Regional Industry Name Self-Reliance Home Furnishing Merchant Wholesalers 113% Ophthalmic Goods Merchant Wholesalers 108% Farm and Garden Machinery and Equipment Merchant Wholesalers 128% Women's, Children's, and Infants' Clothing and Accessories Merchant Wholesalers 108% General Line Grocery Merchant Wholesalers 132% Beer and Ale Merchant Wholesalers 167% Tobacco and Tobacco Product Merchant Wholesalers 101% New Car Dealers 113% Used Car Dealers 131% Recreational Vehicle Dealers 128% Motorcycle Dealers 111% Boat Dealers 177% Automotive Parts and Accessories Stores 103% Hardware Stores 211% Other Building Material Dealers 154% Outdoor Power Equipment Stores 237% Meat Markets 109% Beer, Wine, and Liquor Stores 128% Pharmacies and Drug Stores 121% Optical Goods Stores 124% All Other Health and Personal Care Stores 118% Gasoline Stations with Convenience Stores 182% Family Clothing Stores 107% All Other General Merchandise Stores 143% Florists 118% Manufactured (Mobile) Home Dealers 426% Heating Oil Dealers 747% Liquefied Petroleum Gas (Bottled Gas) Dealers 150% Other Fuel Dealers 202% Coastal and Great Lakes Passenger Transportation 544% Specialized Freight (except Used Goods) Trucking, Local 101% School and Employee Bus Transportation 154% Special Needs Transportation 196% Other Support Activities for Air Transportation 306% Freight Transportation Arrangement 138% Newspaper Publishers 133% Radio Networks 273% Television Broadcasting 132% Libraries and Archives 562% 12 Chart 3c Top Sectors of Export Strength in the North County NAICS Code 532310 541370 561492 611310 611430 621410 621420 621910 622110 622210 623110 623210 623220 623990 624120 624190 624210 624229 712110 712120 713920 713930 721191 721199 721211 721214 721310 722310 811490 812210 812220 813312 813410 Industry Name General Rental Centers Surveying and Mapping (except Geophysical) Services Court Reporting and Stenotype Services Colleges, Universities, and Professional Schools Professional and Management Development Training Family Planning Centers Outpatient Mental Health and Substance Abuse Centers Ambulance Services General Medical and Surgical Hospitals Psychiatric and Substance Abuse Hospitals Nursing Care Facilities Residential Mental Retardation Facilities Residential Mental Health and Substance Abuse Facilities Other Residential Care Facilities Services for the Elderly and Persons with Disabilities Other Individual and Family Services Community Food Services Other Community Housing Services Museums Historical Sites Skiing Facilities Marinas Bed-and-Breakfast Inns All Other Traveler Accommodation RV (Recreational Vehicle) Parks and Campgrounds Recreational and Vacation Camps (except Campgrounds) Rooming and Boarding Houses Food Service Contractors Other Personal and Household Goods Repair and Maintenance Funeral Homes and Funeral Services Cemeteries and Crematories Environment, Conservation and Wildlife Organizations Civic and Social Organizations 13 Regional Self-Reliance 114% 103% 178% 299% 305% 290% 107% 103% 142% 123% 115% 242% 142% 113% 171% 166% 201% 109% 137% 145% 238% 321% 154% 184% 117% 501% 138% 161% 101% 116% 145% 126% 126% But what’s perhaps most striking about the list of regional strengths is how few of them there are. Chart 4 shows how “leaky” the entire region is. Chart 3a-c presented the 113 sectors in the region with greater than 100% self-reliance. But nearly 1,000 NAICS sectors are leaking. Put another way, in nine out of ten sectors, there are opportunities to grow jobs in the North Country through greater regional self-reliance. In more than half the potential business sectors in the region, there’s no business activity whatsoever. Chart 4 Number of NAICS Sectors at Differing Levels of Self-Reliance >100% 76-100% 51-75% 26-50% 1-25% 0% Clinton 137 33 52 62 75 734 Essex Franklin Hamilton Jefferson 94 63 43 118 18 18 9 33 31 34 8 52 48 56 9 66 44 66 7 97 858 856 1017 727 Lewis St. Lawrence Region 57 72 113 6 27 48 14 38 75 33 77 104 32 110 173 951 769 580 From the perspective of each given county, the opportunities for import substitution are even greater. In St. Lawrence County, for example, three quarters of the NAICS sectors have zero activity. In Hamilton, more than 90% have zero activity. This means that it’s highly probable that any entrepreneur with a promising business idea in the North Country ought to be able to grow it, initially, through local demand. But which leaks, if plugged, offer the greatest opportunities for creating new jobs? Chart 5 presents a summary of where the jobs are. (Appendix II presents a detailed version of these numbers.) The data in this chart suggest that economic development efforts would be wise to focus on eight priorities: Local Professional Services (9,101 jobs) – Professional services offer perhaps the best source of new jobs in the region. The category includes scientists, engineers, lawyers, accountants, and architects. What’s so important about this category is that, unlike many service jobs, these jobs tend to command high salaries. They also require relatively low overheads (many just need offices and computers). Some of this can be done by attracting professionals to the region (perhaps alumni of universities who moved away). Some require residents to purchase more of their professional services locally. Local Finance, Insurance, and Real Estate (8,138 jobs) – The North County has a huge deficit in financial services jobs. Most residents are doing their banking at nonlocal banks and their long-term investment in Wall Street securities. Fixing this gap has a double payoff—more jobs from the FIRE sector, and more investment capital for potential jobs in new and expanding local businesses. 14 Chart 5 Summary of Potential New Jobs in North Country from Import Substitution NAICS Sector (2-Digit Level) Agriculture Mining, Oil, & Gas Utilities Construction Manufacturing * Food & Beverage * Fiber, Textiles, & Clothing * Wood & Paper * Printing * Chemicals & Plastics * Rubber, Stone & Glass * Metals & Fixtures * Machinery * Electronics & Computers * Autos, Trucks, & Transport * Furniture & Household Goods * Miscellaneous Wholesale Retail Transportation Delivery, Warehouse, & Storage Publishing, Movies, & Information Services Finance, Insurance, & Real Estate Rental & Leasing Professional Services Holding Companies & Subsidiaries Administrative, Support, & Waste Management Education Health Care & Social Services Entertainment Food & Accommodations Household Services Personal Services Civic Organizations Total 15 Potential New Jobs 147 828 408 5,070 Potential New Wages $4,691,063 $47,561,136 $37,262,570 $280,154,565 1,914 689 883 670 1,233 679 2,990 1,600 1,965 2,109 602 277 6,100 5,775 2,376 1,072 3,813 8,138 448 9,101 3,333 11,915 1,409 5,563 2,065 5,500 895 1,157 1,821 92,545 $87,819,030 $32,009,754 $38,697,036 $29,719,323 $58,639,258 $32,152,407 $138,670,431 $75,861,226 $95,284,228 $99,764,241 $27,337,966 $12,116,882 $368,637,845 $141,109,630 $89,711,812 $41,801,166 $304,207,683 $1,066,439,425 $20,915,761 $597,512,383 $291,650,180 $438,989,424 $39,386,590 $212,456,797 $73,474,924 $81,235,304 $28,296,733 $27,530,210 $44,411,275 $4,965,508,259 Local Food (7,561 jobs) – Local food includes new jobs from agriculture services, food manufacturing, and food & accommodation services. The North Country already has an energized local food movement that simply needs to be expanded. Note, moreover, that these jobs do not include new food retail jobs (covered in retail below) nor new farming jobs (which, again, are not in the NAICS data). Local Retail (5,775 jobs) – The more that North Country residents, businesses, and institutions buy local, the more retail jobs that are possible. In fact, the number is probably higher than 5,775, because many of the 6,100 jobs associated with wholesale distribution can be captured with more retail purchasing. Local Health Services (5,563 jobs) – Health care is already an area of strength for the region, and health services—most of which are inherently local—tend to pay well. As more people in the North Country get insurance coverage from the Affordable Care Act, they will naturally grow this sector. So a key challenge is for the local educational institutions to train and graduate people to fill these positions. Local Construction (5,070 jobs) – A remarkable number of construction services are being purchased outside the North Country. These gaps can be filled by better targeting the courses of local vocational schools. And developers should themselves become better educated about the virtues of using local tradespeople. Local Information Services (3,813 jobs) – More than any other sector, information services, which includes software, gaming, and publishing, attracts young people. Targeting entrepreneurship programs on talented high school and college graduates in the region to enter this field would help plug this leak. Local Transportation (2,376) – The vast majority of transportation jobs fall into two categories. First, there’s a huge opportunity for growing the region with stronger regional airports. Second, the region is currently dependent on trucking that originates from elsewhere. Growing an indigenous trucking industry could plug this leak. There are two other leaks worth mentioning, even though the exact jobs from each are harder to estimate. One concerns manufacturing. Note that outside of local food, manufacturing does not appear at all on the list of eight top job producers above. The reason is that most successful manufacturing businesses naturally export to national or global markets, and the jobs that they can create based just on local demand are quite modest. That said, it would be worthwhile for the North Country to survey existing manufacturers and ask them each to list the top ten inputs (by value) they are purchasing 16 from outside the North Country. This list would help to reveal which new manufacturers could provide the best “input substitution” for the region. The other leak concerns energy. While the North Country is blessed with huge hydropower resources, it’s clear that many residents and businesses also depend on sources of electricity outside of New York State, natural gas and propane for heating, and oil and gasoline for vehicles. Substantial work has already been done to introduce renewable energy technologies to the region, including wind, photovoltaics, geothermal, and cellulosic ethanol. Given the likelihood that over time fossil fuel prices will rise, further work to spread these technologies and develop their parent industries will have significant long-term job payoffs. Similarly, energy efficiency, which also shrinks local dependence on outside energy imports, can continue to be an important job creator. Other Leakage Opportunities As noted earlier, the BALLE Leakage Calculators comprise three tools. The Food Calculator provides further insight into the opportunities from food localization. Chart 6 shows that, comparing local food production with local food consumption, the region has the potential for planting 9,146 more acres for fruit production and 7,197 more acres for vegetable production. Additionally, the region could produce 202,704 more pigs each year and 12,089,157 more chickens. Chart 6 Local Fresh Food Business Opportunities to Achieve Self-Reliance14 Clinton Essex Franklin Hamilton Jefferson Beef (Head of Cattle) 6,152 2,228 0 377 0 Pork (Hogs) 38,973 17,866 23,240 2,401 56,067 Poultry and Eggs (Chickens) 2,330,004 1,061,671 1,398,718 142,763 3,357,238 All Dairy Products (Milk Cows) 0 162 0 224 0 Fresh Fruits (Acres) 1,794 830 1,049 110 2,585 Fresh Vegetables (Acres) 1,792 829 216 74 2,386 Lewis 0 11,595 739,549 0 567 171 St. Lawrence Region 0 0 51,561 201,704 3,059,214 12,089,157 0 0 2,211 9,146 1,729 7,197 How easy would it be to find 16,000 more acres to become self-reliance in fruits and vegetables? Chart 7 summarizes several characteristics of farms in the North Country. Currently, about 4,300 farms cultivate 1.1 million acres. Reassigning about 1-2 percent of farmland to local production is all that’s needed to achieve self-reliance in local produce (the region also needs some of this production to be in greenhouses, however, to maintain variety in the winter). 14 The Food Calculator shows how many additional animals would be needed to raise or how many additional acres to grow to achieve self-reliance in a county or in the North Country Region overall. 17 Chart 7 Farming in the North Country Number of Farms Land in Farms (Acres) Average Sales per Farm ($) Average Farm Size (Acres) Clinton 590 149219 $210,508 253 Essex Franklin Hamilton Jefferson Lewis St. Lawrence Region 243 604 20 885 616 1,330 4,288 50,226 130,852 450 262,331 167,249 347,246 1,107,573 $47,156 $112,743 $18,116 $157,335 $182,839 $105,377 $834,074 207 217 23 296 272 261 258 Chart 8 estimates that North Country residents have almost $50 billion in savings—about $11 billion in banks, and $39 billion in stocks, bonds, pension funds, mutual funds, and insurance funds. Some of the banking capital is in local banks and credit unions, which are listed in Chart 9. The ownership of these institutions matters, because a dollar deposited in a local bank or credit union is three times more likely to be lent to a local business than a dollar deposited in a nonlocal bank. Virtually all of the $39 billion in securities capital held by residents is invested non-locally. Chart 8 Capital in the North Country Checking Accounts & Currency Savings Deposits Money Market Deposits Stocks Bonds Mutual Funds Pension Funds Insurance Funds Clinton Essex $79,525,074 $36,773,972 $1,659,712,733 $767,484,092 $356,370,044 $164,792,577 $2,025,853,776 $936,794,974 $596,573,767 $275,867,544 $1,126,921,875 $521,111,030 $3,243,157,392 $1,499,700,314 $337,099,462 $155,881,478 $9,425,214,123 $4,358,405,981 Franklin $49,039,086 $1,023,460,797 $219,755,360 $1,249,241,438 $367,876,832 $694,915,655 $1,999,890,936 $207,872,168 $5,812,052,272 Hamilton $4,872,629 $101,693,264 $21,835,364 $124,127,313 $36,553,032 $69,048,312 $198,713,460 $20,654,625 $577,497,999 Jefferson Lewis $114,585,466 $25,569,645 $2,391,433,884 $533,646,351 $513,483,677 $114,583,427 $2,918,996,322 $651,371,442 $859,586,537 $191,815,973 $1,623,750,365 $362,338,454 $4,672,975,221 $1,042,770,278 $485,717,233 $108,387,370 $13,580,528,705 $3,030,482,940 St. Lawrence Region $106,461,503 $416,827,377 $2,221,884,289 $8,699,315,413 $477,078,343 $1,867,898,795 $2,712,043,227 $10,618,428,494 $798,642,954 $3,126,916,643 $1,508,628,547 $5,906,714,242 $4,341,667,272 $16,998,874,876 $451,280,504 $1,766,892,844 $12,617,686,639 $49,401,868,684 One way to think about securities capital is that every 1% of capital that residents shift from Wall Street to Main Street would make $390 million more available to new or expanded local business. 18 Chart 9 Local Financial Institutions in the North Country Local Banks Carthage Federal Savings and Loan Association Citizens Bank of Cape Vincent Citizens National Bank of Hammond Gouverneur Savings and Loan Association Massena Savings and Loan North Country Savings Bank Watertown Savings Bank WSB Municipal Bank Local Credit Unions Adirondack Regional Americu Champlain CVPH Employees Dannemora Ed-Med GP Community Northern North Franklin Plattsburgh City School District Peru Central School St. Lawrence Sea Comm State CS Employees Ticonderoga Tri-Lakes Twin Rivers U First United Neighbors Watertown Postal Leak Plugging Economic Development Tools How, then, can the North Country take full advantage of all the leak-plugging and jobcreating opportunities above? Broadly speaking, a local economic development agenda requires answers to six questions. Each question corresponds to one of six economic-development objectives beginning with the letter P: planning, purchasing, people, partners, purse, and public policy. Planning—What are the most plausible opportunities for new or expanded local businesses to meet local needs? (Planning here means both the “spacial” planning undertaken by urban planners and the “business” planning undertaken by consultants.) Purchasing—How can the community help these businesses, once established, flourish with concerted buy-local efforts by nearby consumers, businesses, and government agencies? 19 People—How can a new generation of entrepreneurs and employees be trained for these new local business opportunities? Partnership—How can local businesses improve their competitiveness by working together as a team? Purse—How can local capital be mobilized to finance these new or expanding local businesses? Public Policy—How can laws, regulations, and practices at all levels of government—local, state, national, and global—be recalibrated to eliminate the current advantages nonlocal businesses enjoy? Detailed answers to all these questions have been laid out in the author’s books, as well as in a handbook entitled Growing Local Economies: A Grassroots Approach to Local Economic Development. These publications are all available on the author’s web site. Perhaps the most critical of these questions is “purse.” Without local finance, local businesses have almost no ability to be formed or grow. With local finance, the full potential of import substitution can be realized. Below are 22 tools that the North Country can begin to deploy to grow the local financial sector. To make them easier to digest, these tools are divided into three categories: easy, somewhat challenging, and very challenging. Here are eleven tools that can be deployed by North Country residents at a low cost right now: - Move Your Money – Residents of the North Country should be encouraged to move all their day-to-day financial activities, including checking, loans, credit cards, and mortgage, to a local bank or credit union. These are the institutions that recycle their capital locally—so much so that even though local and regional banks account for only 20% of the assets of all banks in the United States, they provide more than half of all the loans to small business. - Pre-Purchase Local Goods and Services – In most U.S. states, preselling is not regarded as a security, so North Country businesses can raise capital without attorneys by convincing their most loyal customers to make purchases in advance. And even in those states where it may be a security, wellestablished businesses still can use this technique. Hence, Awaken Café in Oakland raised most of the $100,000 it needed to open a new store by preselling coffee. Credibles is a pre-selling web site for small food businesses seeking to expand. North Country small businesses should be taught how to take advantage of this technique. - Sponsor Local Businesses – North Country businesses should take full advantage of web sites like Kickstarter and IndieGogo, which last year raised nearly $1 billion for small businesses and projects. Even though all you get for your money is a t-shirt or token of appreciation, you know that thousands 20 of small contributors like yourself are helping to get a big idea off the ground. A new generation of web sites, such as Lucky Ant and Community Funded, which specifically facilitate local sponsorships, would be especially valuable for the North Country. - Tap Internet Lending Sites – Kiva and KivaZip facilitate peer-to-peer lending to micro-entrepreneurs, mostly in the global South but increasingly in U.S. inner cities, though as a dot-org it only pays back principal. Prosper and the Lending Club, both dot-coms, also pay interest (now averaging close to 10% per year). The North Country might encourage its local businesses to use these sites for loans and its local investors to scour them for local business investment opportunities. - Weave Investor Networks – The Local Investment Opportunities Network (LION) of Pt. Townsend, Washington, brings together local investors and businesses each month to establish “preexisting relationships” that facilitate the circulation of business plans. New LIONs are spreading around the country, and should be set up in the North Country. Unlike traditional angelinvestor networks, where entrepreneurs present their business plans at periodic dinners, LIONs often involve unaccredited (non-wealthy) investors. - Lobby Your Pension Fund – In the absence of local pension funds, North Country residents can lobby their workplace pension funds to put some money in local stocks and bonds. Most managers of these funds will claim – incorrectly – that local investment is illegal under the federal Employee Retirement Investment Security Act (ERISA). They need to understand that many of the local investments outlined here outperform the U.S. stock market, and therefore are completely legitimate investors for fiduciaries managing these funds. - Form a Local Investment Club – North County residents can form their own investment funds on the cheap in the form of investment clubs. The legal key is that all decisions have to be made together, as a group. A great example is No Small Potatoes, a project of Slow Money Maine. - Prepare a Community List – Knowledge is power. Imagine a local craigslist of all the local investment opportunities in the North Country. A list like this is easy to create and invaluable for potential local investors. To the extent that state securities law might limit the posting of such information, change it, as Vermont recently did. - Spread Self-Directed IRAs – Tax-deferred investing through an IRA or 401k today typically must be done through mutual funds, which means your money is stuck on Wall Street. By rolling over funds into a Self-Directed IRA, North Country residents can direct a custodian (for about $200-300 per year) to invest instead in any and all of the items above. 21 - Get Residents to Rethink Their Finances – There’s a widespread mythology, spread by the investment industry, that patiently leaving one’s money on Wall Street will generate the best returns for retirement, college, or other long-term needs. In fact, far better returns can be achieved through investing in one’s own home, in energy efficiency measures in your home, and in one’s own education. And the single best way to localize your money and improve your rate of return is to wean yourself off credit cards. - Start a Slow Money Chapter – Across the United States and in other countries as well, groups inspired by Woody Tasch’s book, Slow Money, are exploring all these strategies with the goal of placing 1 percent of investment in local farms and food businesses. The twenty active US chapters, which involve both professional investors and newbies, have created thirteen investment clubs and have already mobilized $38 million into more than 350 small food enterprises. The North Country residents should form a chapter as well. The list of somewhat challenging local investment tools includes nine initiatives that have been done elsewhere previously but nevertheless require a significant investment or time and money. - Start A Credit Union – For areas within North Country that lack a nearby local bank or credit union, they can start their own. Credit unions are easier and cheaper to launch than banks, and many communities have small credit unions managed by part-timers or volunteers. - Create Targeted CDs – By law, local banks and credit unions must be very conservative with their money, so they are often wary of loaning money to any local businesses without full collateral. A few banks, such as Ithaca’s Alternatives Credit Union, have agreed to set up special certificates of deposits that fully collateralize loans to high-priority local businesses. Eastern Bank in Boston has a CD that collateralizes a line of credit to Equal Exchange, a local fair-trade company. Local banks and credit unions in the North Country should be encouraged to implement these programs to support local businesses. - Harness Federal Programs – Various national programs provide generous tax deductions for local investors who support anti-poverty initiatives through New Markets Tax Credits and provide other benefits to designated Community-Development Corporations (CDCs) and Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs). The North Country should recruit accredited investors and foundations to take full advantage of these opportunities. - Stretch Your Coop – Because memberships in a cooperative are not deemed “securities,” they can be more easily used as vehicles for local investments. 22 Some coops, like Weaver Street Market in North Carolina, pay their members handsomely to borrow money for capital projects. Others, like Coop Power in western Massachusetts, invest some member capital in supplier businesses. The La Montanita Grocery Coop in New Mexico has created a revolving loan fund so that members’ capital can support local farmers and food processors. Existing coops within the North County should be encouraged to copy these models. - Promote Program Related Investments– By law, foundations must give away at least 5% of their assets each year. The other 95% is typically invested in distant stocks and bonds. North Country foundations should be encouraged to move that 95% (or even just 1%) into local business. If these businesses are “program related” and the investment does not succeed, a foundation can apply the losses to fulfill its annual grant-giving obligations. - Issue Slow Munis – Local governments issue bonds all the time, often to support traditional economic-development projects. How about creating bonds to finance local businesses? Several proposals over recent years have been discussed to create “food bonds,” the proceeds of which might go into a fund that collateralized loans from local banks and credit unions to highpriority local food businesses. Properly structured, the interest from these bonds could be tax exempt, and these bonds could be purchased by residents of your community. - Take Your Local Businesses Public – Until recently, it has been very expensive to restructure a small business so that it could accept investment from the 99% of non-wealthy people in your community who are “unaccredited.” But thanks to “crowdfunding reforms” signed into law by President Obama in 2012 in “The JOBS Act,” new web sites will soon be set up that bring down the costs of “going public” and allowing unaccredited investors to purchase as much as $2,000 of local stock. The North Country should encourage its local businesses and investors to take advantage of these sites. - Create a Local Investment Fund – Pools of capital are preferable to one-off investments because they diversify risk. There are thousands of localinvestment pools around the country, most of them linked with local economic-development programs, but nearly all of them are only open to accredited investors. Important exceptions that allow unaccredited investor participation include MountainBizWorks in North Carolina, the New Hampshire Community Loan Fund, and ECDI in Columbus, Ohio. The North Country needs a fund like this too. - Move Your Public Money – Where are county and local governments in the North Country doing their banking? If it’s not local, it’s time for a change. The cities of Phoenix and Tucson have just begun moving their banking into 23 local banks in exchange for promises that those banks would invest more heavily in local business. Finally, there are two ambitious local investment initiatives that have not been done yet: - Create A Local Stock Market – As crowdfunding spreads, there will be a growing number of local stock purchasers who wish to sell their shares. The North Country might facilitate this by creating its own regional stock exchange. Mission Markets of New York City has a turn-key web platform that can enable the region to get started with this, once the JOBS Act is implemented (probably in late 2015). - Create a Local Mutual Fund – There are 7,500 mutual funds in the United States (in which unaccredited investors can readily invest), but not a single one invests in local small business. But there is no legal reason why a locally focused mutual fund could not be formed in the North Country. The toughest requirement for mutual funds is that 85% of the fund be liquid, and that could be accomplished through local “slow munis.” The other 15% could be local stock. North Country investment professionals should be encouraged to start the first one! The ideas above invite the participation of all kinds of groups in the North Country: grassroots investors, philanthropists, economic developers, investment specialists, even policymakers. Some will counter, however, that capital alone cannot make an uncompetitive business competitive. And indeed it is important to pay attention to all the P’s for local economic development, not just “Purse”—to create a rich entrepreneurial ecosystem in the North Country. One new approach that the North Country might consider for the other P’s is to focus on nurturing self-financing economic-development programs called “pollinators.” The mission of a pollinator is to start, nurture, and spread local businesses throughout the economy, but to do so in revenue-generating framework. The North Country might study and replicate the following examples of pollinators around five of the six P’s (public policy, by definition, cannot be a private sector initiative). Examples of planning pollinators: The Main Street Genome Project in Washington, DC, analyzes data from local businesses to help them identify weak spots and remedy them by, for example, getting better prices from suppliers and sharing the savings with clients. The Village Well, based in Melbourne, Australia, is hired by public and private property owners to help stakeholders set in motion a plan to revitalize a place with many new kinds of work and play. 24 Examples of purchasing pollinators: Bernal Bucks in San Francisco has partnered with a local credit union to issue a debit card that rewards local business purchases. Supportland has 80,000 users in Portland, Oregon, who receive gifts and discounts for loyally making purchases at local stores and service providers. Examples of people pollinators: ZingTrain, pat of the Zingerman’s Community of Businesses in Ann Arbor, Michigan, provides training through two or three-day courses to more than one thousand entrepreneurs each year. Fundación Paraguaya now runs three high schools in Paraguay that pay all their expenses through the revenues generated by student-run food enterprises. Examples of partnership pollinators: The Calgary-based organization Respect the Earth and All People directs consumers to local ethical businesses through ads and an online directory and finances its work by positioning itself as a one-stop marketing firm for its 120 business members. The Reading Terminal Market in Philadelphia is one of a growing number of permanent “public markets” that are effectively shopping malls for local food providers, local artisans, and other local businesses. Examples of purse pollinators: Vancity is a pioneering locally owned credit union that serves 500,000 members in metro Vancouver and has staff who support 38,000 local business members with credit, partnerships, and technical assistance. FarmWorks is one of 60 investment funds that Novia Scotia permits grassroots groups to organize and through which locals can reinvest taxdeferred retirement savings into area food production and distribution enterprises. When the Burt Symposium was inaugurated in 2003, the region helped lead the country to reframe economic development around the goal of LOIS. Now, a dozen years later, it has the potential to demonstrate how economic developers can achieve this goal costeffectively. By embracing the tools of local investment and investment pollination outlined above, the North Country has an unprecedented shot at creating jobs for the 14,500 residents unemployed and at growing its economy for newcomers. 25 Appendix I (a) The Strongest Sectors in Clinton County NAICS Code 483114 326112 326150 322121 325412 332111 336510 323119 339994 324121 326160 311991 339113 454311 423460 424330 332911 321992 621410 323121 488510 562212 453930 523130 423440 325620 423920 326199 712190 519120 441210 481111 621420 515120 811211 485113 811112 445310 623210 492110 532310 445291 332114 445210 424920 722310 335122 493110 484110 811122 624190 Percent Industry Name Self-Reliant Coastal and Great Lakes Passenger Transportation 2851% Plastics Packaging Film and Sheet (including Laminated) Manufacturing 2248% Urethane and Other Foam Product (except Polystyrene) Manufacturing 1978% Paper (except Newsprint) Mills 1702% Pharmaceutical Preparation Manufacturing 1318% Iron and Steel Forging 1185% Railroad Rolling Stock Manufacturing 1152% Other Commercial Printing 1052% Broom, Brush, and Mop Manufacturing 858% Asphalt Paving Mixture and Block Manufacturing 744% Plastics Bottle Manufacturing 738% Perishable Prepared Food Manufacturing 712% Surgical Appliance and Supplies Manufacturing 654% Heating Oil Dealers 589% Ophthalmic Goods Merchant Wholesalers 565% Women's, Children's, and Infants' Clothing and Accessories Merchant Wholesalers 565% Industrial Valve Manufacturing 538% Prefabricated Wood Building Manufacturing 534% Family Planning Centers 528% Tradebinding and Related Work 524% Freight Transportation Arrangement 518% Solid Waste Landfill 511% Manufactured (Mobile) Home Dealers 500% Commodity Contracts Dealing 472% Other Commercial Equipment Merchant Wholesalers 468% Toilet Preparation Manufacturing 453% Toy and Hobby Goods and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers 451% All Other Plastics Product Manufacturing 449% Nature Parks and Other Similar Institutions 391% Libraries and Archives 387% Recreational Vehicle Dealers 365% Scheduled Passenger Air Transportation 315% Outpatient Mental Health and Substance Abuse Centers 312% Television Broadcasting 311% Consumer Electronics Repair and Maintenance 291% Bus and Other Motor Vehicle Transit Systems 286% Automotive Exhaust System Repair 257% Beer, Wine, and Liquor Stores 244% Residential Mental Retardation Facilities 244% Couriers 243% General Rental Centers 241% Baked Goods Stores 240% Custom Roll Forming 240% Meat Markets 239% Book, Periodical, and Newspaper Merchant Wholesalers 233% Food Service Contractors 218% Commercial, Industrial, and Institutional Electric Lighting Fixture Manufacturing 217% General Warehousing and Storage 217% General Freight Trucking, Local 216% Automotive Glass Replacement Shops 216% Other Individual and Family Services 212% 26 Appendix I (b) The Strongest Sectors in Essex County NAICS Code 212399 611430 721214 713930 721191 624210 454311 623210 611620 813312 236115 519120 314121 113110 712110 721199 721110 812331 444130 321113 454312 113310 337122 541350 813319 813990 523910 712120 611110 453220 623110 237130 311340 624229 424480 321999 444190 561591 813219 511110 541940 713950 238910 447110 423310 621498 562119 624110 485310 236118 451212 Industry Name All Other Nonmetallic Mineral Mining Professional and Management Development Training Recreational and Vacation Camps (except Campgrounds) Marinas Bed-and-Breakfast Inns Community Food Services Heating Oil Dealers Residential Mental Retardation Facilities Sports and Recreation Instruction Environment, Conservation and Wildlife Organizations New Single-Family Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) Libraries and Archives Curtain and Drapery Mills Timber Tract Operations Museums All Other Traveler Accommodation Hotels (except Casino Hotels) and Motels Linen Supply Hardware Stores Sawmills Liquefied Petroleum Gas (Bottled Gas) Dealers Logging Nonupholstered Wood Household Furniture Manufacturing Building Inspection Services Other Social Advocacy Organizations Other Similar Organizations (except Bus., Prof'l, Labor, and Pol. Orgs.) Miscellaneous Intermediation Historical Sites Elementary and Secondary Schools Gift, Novelty, and Souvenir Stores Nursing Care Facilities Power and Communication Line and Related Structures Construction Nonchocolate Confectionery Manufacturing Other Community Housing Services Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Merchant Wholesalers All Other Miscellaneous Wood Product Manufacturing Other Building Material Dealers Convention and Visitors Bureaus Other Grantmaking and Giving Services Newspaper Publishers Veterinary Services Bowling Centers Site Preparation Contractors Gasoline Stations with Convenience Stores Lumber, Plywood, Millwork, and Wood Panel Merchant Wholesalers All Other Outpatient Care Centers Other Waste Collection Child and Youth Services Taxi Service Residential Remodelers News Dealers and Newsstands 27 Percent Self-Reliant 12404% 3375% 2999% 1407% 1385% 1359% 1243% 794% 763% 738% 701% 676% 552% 547% 497% 473% 466% 453% 421% 412% 384% 371% 365% 360% 320% 318% 293% 276% 274% 254% 251% 251% 248% 242% 236% 233% 232% 221% 216% 212% 212% 210% 199% 189% 187% 185% 179% 175% 173% 172% 167% Appendix I (c) The Strongest Sectors in Franklin County NAICS Code 311513 454311 315299 515111 324121 337122 721214 713920 113310 623210 519120 541350 424940 624120 623220 424810 311119 444210 236115 424710 712110 237210 524128 444190 812310 326199 621420 721199 424420 812220 811490 624190 336612 522130 623990 337212 532230 446199 238130 621910 447110 446110 452990 611310 454390 441310 622110 484230 423730 541860 621410 Percent Self-Reliant Cheese Manufacturing 2752% Heating Oil Dealers 1580% All Other Cut and Sew Apparel Manufacturing 1195% Radio Networks 1159% Asphalt Paving Mixture and Block Manufacturing 1102% Nonupholstered Wood Household Furniture Manufacturing 702% Recreational and Vacation Camps (except Campgrounds) 628% Skiing Facilities 542% Logging 534% Residential Mental Retardation Facilities 494% Libraries and Archives 484% Building Inspection Services 481% Tobacco and Tobacco Product Merchant Wholesalers 438% Services for the Elderly and Persons with Disabilities 430% Residential Mental Health and Substance Abuse Facilities 398% Beer and Ale Merchant Wholesalers 329% Other Animal Food Manufacturing 310% Outdoor Power Equipment Stores 308% New Single-Family Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) 295% Petroleum Bulk Stations and Terminals 248% Museums 247% Land Subdivision 239% Other Direct Insurance (except Life, Health, and Medical) Carriers 238% Other Building Material Dealers 236% Coin-Operated Laundries and Drycleaners 227% All Other Plastics Product Manufacturing 217% Outpatient Mental Health and Substance Abuse Centers 214% All Other Traveler Accommodation 213% Packaged Frozen Food Merchant Wholesalers 209% Cemeteries and Crematories 208% Other Personal and Household Goods Repair and Maintenance 206% Other Individual and Family Services 185% Boat Building 185% Credit Unions 172% Other Residential Care Facilities 168% Custom Architectural Woodwork and Millwork Manufacturing 165% Video Tape and Disc Rental 163% All Other Health and Personal Care Stores 162% Framing Contractors 161% Ambulance Services 155% Gasoline Stations with Convenience Stores 153% Pharmacies and Drug Stores 151% All Other General Merchandise Stores 144% Colleges, Universities, and Professional Schools 141% Other Direct Selling Establishments 139% Automotive Parts and Accessories Stores 139% General Medical and Surgical Hospitals 137% Specialized Freight (except Used Goods) Trucking, Long-Distance 136% Warm Air Heating and Air-Conditioning Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers 135% Direct Mail Advertising 131% Family Planning Centers 131% Industry Name 28 Appendix I (d) The Strongest Sectors in Hamilton County NAICS Code 485991 332311 721199 713930 721214 721191 712110 113310 453920 454312 327212 441222 454311 236115 444130 712120 721310 321999 332312 721211 519120 236118 447110 813110 448120 236116 813910 484220 721110 453220 541191 423910 811111 722410 561499 444190 238910 238350 238330 511110 711110 722110 238130 Percent Industry Name Self-Reliant Special Needs Transportation 7606% Prefabricated Metal Building and Component Manufacturing 5540% All Other Traveler Accommodation 4997% Marinas 4896% Recreational and Vacation Camps (except Campgrounds) 4772% Bed-and-Breakfast Inns 2755% Museums 2211% Logging 2004% Art Dealers 1807% Liquefied Petroleum Gas (Bottled Gas) Dealers 1786% Other Pressed and Blown Glass and Glassware Manufacturing 1515% Boat Dealers 1498% Heating Oil Dealers 1266% New Single-Family Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) 1215% Hardware Stores 1127% Historical Sites 1042% Rooming and Boarding Houses 997% All Other Miscellaneous Wood Product Manufacturing 790% Fabricated Structural Metal Manufacturing 694% RV (Recreational Vehicle) Parks and Campgrounds 610% Libraries and Archives 468% Residential Remodelers 412% Gasoline Stations with Convenience Stores 302% Religious Organizations 294% Women's Clothing Stores 234% New Multifamily Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) 223% Business Associations 202% Specialized Freight (except Used Goods) Trucking, Local 199% Hotels (except Casino Hotels) and Motels 188% Gift, Novelty, and Souvenir Stores 163% Title Abstract and Settlement Offices 155% Sporting and Recreational Goods and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers 151% General Automotive Repair 149% Drinking Places (Alcoholic Beverages) 142% All Other Business Support Services 137% Other Building Material Dealers 137% Site Preparation Contractors 128% Finish Carpentry Contractors 122% Flooring Contractors 119% Newspaper Publishers 114% Theater Companies and Dinner Theaters 114% Full-Service Restaurants 103% Framing Contractors 100% 29 Appendix I (e) The Strongest Sectors in Jefferson County NAICS Code 325612 221119 488190 327332 322130 454319 339112 311511 519120 453930 454311 515111 424410 441222 311513 322121 444210 713930 713920 311119 221111 423220 621410 327331 324121 487110 212312 325314 339999 623990 624190 515120 813311 624210 811490 811113 314912 611513 484210 446130 423330 623220 238130 423110 712120 333999 441120 445299 485410 238910 811112 Percent Industry Name Self-Reliant Polish and Other Sanitation Good Manufacturing 2498% Other Electric Power Generation 1231% Other Support Activities for Air Transportation 1029% Concrete Pipe Manufacturing 952% Paperboard Mills 923% Other Fuel Dealers 736% Surgical and Medical Instrument Manufacturing 728% Fluid Milk Manufacturing 684% Libraries and Archives 640% Manufactured (Mobile) Home Dealers 604% Heating Oil Dealers 586% Radio Networks 496% General Line Grocery Merchant Wholesalers 465% Boat Dealers 463% Cheese Manufacturing 457% Paper (except Newsprint) Mills 449% Outdoor Power Equipment Stores 411% Marinas 401% Skiing Facilities 400% Other Animal Food Manufacturing 398% Hydroelectric Power Generation 380% Home Furnishing Merchant Wholesalers 376% Family Planning Centers 367% Concrete Block and Brick Manufacturing 358% Asphalt Paving Mixture and Block Manufacturing 355% Scenic and Sightseeing Transportation, Land 348% Crushed and Broken Limestone Mining and Quarrying 342% Fertilizer (Mixing Only) Manufacturing 336% All Other Miscellaneous Manufacturing 334% Other Residential Care Facilities 303% Other Individual and Family Services 282% Television Broadcasting 265% Human Rights Organizations 263% Community Food Services 250% Other Personal and Household Goods Repair and Maintenance 247% Automotive Transmission Repair 223% Canvas and Related Product Mills 223% Apprenticeship Training 222% Used Household and Office Goods Moving 221% Optical Goods Stores 221% Roofing, Siding, and Insulation Material Merchant Wholesalers 221% Residential Mental Health and Substance Abuse Facilities 215% Framing Contractors 213% Automobile and Other Motor Vehicle Merchant Wholesalers 201% Historical Sites 198% All Other Miscellaneous General Purpose Machinery Manufacturing 191% Used Car Dealers 190% All Other Specialty Food Stores 185% School and Employee Bus Transportation 179% Site Preparation Contractors 178% Automotive Exhaust System Repair 178% 30 Appendix I (f) The Strongest Sectors in Lewis County NAICS Code 322222 322212 221111 339991 113310 721214 322121 221119 713920 321999 519120 812220 811310 721211 423820 454311 441210 424430 445210 321113 444220 541370 621410 423130 484220 712120 221112 813410 624229 484110 447110 485410 327320 236115 236116 813930 624190 452910 424690 515112 561790 722410 623210 337122 811111 531110 624410 442210 441221 238910 238120 Percent Industry Name Self-Reliant Coated and Laminated Paper Manufacturing 6464% Folding Paperboard Box Manufacturing 4636% Hydroelectric Power Generation 3408% Gasket, Packing, and Sealing Device Manufacturing 3216% Logging 1386% Recreational and Vacation Camps (except Campgrounds) 1336% Paper (except Newsprint) Mills 1203% Other Electric Power Generation 1200% Skiing Facilities 1040% All Other Miscellaneous Wood Product Manufacturing 796% Libraries and Archives 713% Cemeteries and Crematories 469% Commercial and Industrial Machinery and Equipment (except Automotive and Electronic) Repair and Maintenance 447% RV (Recreational Vehicle) Parks and Campgrounds 397% Farm and Garden Machinery and Equipment Merchant Wholesalers 393% Heating Oil Dealers 379% Recreational Vehicle Dealers 370% Dairy Product (except Dried or Canned) Merchant Wholesalers 361% Meat Markets 352% Sawmills 304% Nursery, Garden Center, and Farm Supply Stores 296% Surveying and Mapping (except Geophysical) Services 261% Family Planning Centers 251% Tire and Tube Merchant Wholesalers 219% Specialized Freight (except Used Goods) Trucking, Local 207% Historical Sites 199% Fossil Fuel Electric Power Generation 197% Civic and Social Organizations 188% Other Community Housing Services 179% General Freight Trucking, Local 178% Gasoline Stations with Convenience Stores 176% School and Employee Bus Transportation 173% Ready-Mix Concrete Manufacturing 164% New Single-Family Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) 153% New Multifamily Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) 153% Labor Unions and Similar Labor Organizations 148% Other Individual and Family Services 148% Warehouse Clubs and Supercenters 145% Other Chemical and Allied Products Merchant Wholesalers 139% Radio Stations 137% Other Services to Buildings and Dwellings 133% Drinking Places (Alcoholic Beverages) 128% Residential Mental Retardation Facilities 127% Nonupholstered Wood Household Furniture Manufacturing 124% General Automotive Repair 120% Lessors of Residential Buildings and Dwellings 120% Child Day Care Services 118% Floor Covering Stores 117% Motorcycle Dealers 113% Site Preparation Contractors 112% Structural Steel and Precast Concrete Contractors 111% 31 Appendix I (g) The Strongest Sectors in St. Lawrence County NAICS Code 212399 323118 327113 611310 221111 311511 561492 453930 519120 454311 322130 622210 334412 311513 311119 721310 485991 722310 445220 334519 332312 444130 238290 485410 324121 624120 623210 541380 812210 325611 113310 621410 447110 452990 423820 813212 562910 339112 114210 441120 624229 712120 423850 327331 323119 453110 812331 532291 813930 532310 424810 Industry Name All Other Nonmetallic Mineral Mining Blankbook, Looseleaf Binders, and Devices Manufacturing Porcelain Electrical Supply Manufacturing Colleges, Universities, and Professional Schools Hydroelectric Power Generation Fluid Milk Manufacturing Court Reporting and Stenotype Services Manufactured (Mobile) Home Dealers Libraries and Archives Heating Oil Dealers Paperboard Mills Psychiatric and Substance Abuse Hospitals Bare Printed Circuit Board Manufacturing Cheese Manufacturing Other Animal Food Manufacturing Rooming and Boarding Houses Special Needs Transportation Food Service Contractors Fish and Seafood Markets Other Measuring and Controlling Device Manufacturing Fabricated Structural Metal Manufacturing Hardware Stores Other Building Equipment Contractors School and Employee Bus Transportation Asphalt Paving Mixture and Block Manufacturing Services for the Elderly and Persons with Disabilities Residential Mental Retardation Facilities Testing Laboratories Funeral Homes and Funeral Services Soap and Other Detergent Manufacturing Logging Family Planning Centers Gasoline Stations with Convenience Stores All Other General Merchandise Stores Farm and Garden Machinery and Equipment Merchant Wholesalers Voluntary Health Organizations Remediation Services Surgical and Medical Instrument Manufacturing Hunting and Trapping Used Car Dealers Other Community Housing Services Historical Sites Service Establishment Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers Concrete Block and Brick Manufacturing Other Commercial Printing Florists Linen Supply Home Health Equipment Rental Labor Unions and Similar Labor Organizations General Rental Centers Beer and Ale Merchant Wholesalers 32 Percent Self-Reliant 4285% 2977% 2462% 1090% 819% 736% 646% 609% 572% 547% 496% 482% 479% 446% 429% 405% 384% 377% 362% 344% 300% 290% 289% 281% 254% 246% 231% 213% 211% 197% 196% 194% 192% 189% 181% 175% 174% 171% 171% 170% 167% 166% 162% 162% 161% 158% 157% 156% 155% 153% 151% Appendix II (a) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Agriculture 113110 113210 114111 114112 114119 114210 115111 115112 115113 115114 115115 115116 115210 115310 Timber Tract Operations Forest Nurseries and Gathering of Forest Products Finfish Fishing Shellfish Fishing Other Marine Fishing Hunting and Trapping Cotton Ginning Soil Preparation, Planting, and Cultivating Crop Harvesting, Primarily by Machine Postharvest Crop Activities (except Cotton Ginning) Farm Labor Contractors and Crew Leaders Farm Management Services Support Activities for Animal Production Support Activities for Forestry 33 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 48% 3 0% 3 0% 5 0% 3 0% 0 44% 2 0% 4 0% 16 0% 3 0% 51 0% 15 0% 5 33% 20 0% 17 147 Potential New Wages $108,893 $99,242 $156,448 $90,031 $6,366 $63,237 $114,413 $539,980 $105,604 $1,625,980 $460,586 $164,530 $607,599 $548,153 $4,691,063 Appendix II (b) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Mining, Oil, and Gas 211111 211112 212111 212112 212113 212210 212221 212222 212231 212234 212291 212299 212311 212313 212319 212321 212322 212324 212325 212391 212393 213111 213112 213113 213114 213115 Crude Petroleum and Natural Gas Extraction Natural Gas Liquid Extraction Bituminous Coal and Lignite Surface Mining Bituminous Coal Underground Mining Anthracite Mining Iron Ore Mining Gold Ore Mining Silver Ore Mining Lead Ore and Zinc Ore Mining Copper Ore and Nickel Ore Mining Uranium-Radium-Vanadium Ore Mining All Other Metal Ore Mining Dimension Stone Mining and Quarrying Crushed and Broken Granite Mining and Quarrying Other Crushed and Broken Stone Mining and Quarrying Construction Sand and Gravel Mining Industrial Sand Mining Kaolin and Ball Clay Mining Clay and Ceramic and Refractory Minerals Mining Potash, Soda, and Borate Mineral Mining Other Chemical and Fertilizer Mineral Mining Drilling Oil and Gas Wells Support Activities for Oil and Gas Operations Support Activities for Coal Mining Support Activities for Metal Mining Support Activities for Nonmetallic Minerals (except Fuels) 34 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 0% 141 0% 12 0% 55 0% 60 0% 1 0% 7 0% 15 0% 1 0% 3 0% 13 0% 1 0% 6 0% 6 0% 11 0% 11 59% 17 0% 4 0% 4 0% 3 0% 3 0% 2 0% 137 0% 288 0% 12 0% 8 0% 5 828 Potential New Wages $8,076,324 $671,393 $3,172,702 $3,465,926 $53,908 $409,860 $861,050 $46,638 $183,491 $766,058 $64,771 $358,893 $300,485 $616,997 $664,122 $998,648 $254,100 $228,127 $189,493 $176,751 $141,875 $7,872,946 $16,549,768 $688,475 $468,342 $279,992 $47,561,136 Appendix II (c) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Utilities 221112 221113 221121 221122 221210 221310 221320 221330 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 12% 98 0% 54 0% 9 56% 247 33% 91 0% 49 0% 9 0% 3 408 Fossil Fuel Electric Power Generation Nuclear Electric Power Generation Electric Bulk Power Transmission and Control Electric Power Distribution Natural Gas Distribution Water Supply and Irrigation Systems Sewage Treatment Facilities Steam and Air-Conditioning Supply 35 Potential New Wages $9,329,872 $5,133,025 $870,869 $23,214,891 $8,597,172 $3,445,564 $858,856 $275,217 $37,262,570 Appendix II (d) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Construction 236116 236117 236210 237110 237120 237130 237210 237310 237990 238110 238120 238130 238140 238150 238160 238170 238190 238210 238220 238290 238310 238320 238330 238340 238350 238390 238910 238990 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Multifamily Housing Construction (except Operative Builders) 29% 53 New Housing Operative Builders 38% 166 Industrial Building Construction 47% 62 Water and Sewer Line and Related Structures Construction 40% 163 Oil and Gas Pipeline and Related Structures Construction 0% 224 Power and Communication Line and Related Structures Construction 39% 212 Land Subdivision 46% 67 Highway, Street, and Bridge Construction 41% 261 Other Heavy and Civil Engineering Construction 48% 51 Poured Concrete Foundation and Structure Contractors 9% 370 Structural Steel and Precast Concrete Contractors 47% 65 Framing Contractors 88% 77 Masonry Contractors 29% 213 Glass and Glazing Contractors 28% 61 Roofing Contractors 49% 131 Siding Contractors 29% 45 Other Foundation, Structure, and Building Exterior Contractors 28% 50 Electrical Contractors 45% 673 Plumbing, Heating, and Air-Conditioning Contractors 54% 670 Other Building Equipment Contractors 74% 151 Drywall and Insulation Contractors 22% 322 Painting and Wall Covering Contractors 47% 165 Flooring Contractors 38% 72 Tile and Terrazzo Contractors 2% 95 Finish Carpentry Contractors 44% 122 Other Building Finishing Contractors 15% 88 Site Preparation Contractors 91% 200 All Other Specialty Trade Contractors 25% 241 5,070 36 Potential New Wages $3,984,020 $7,300,789 $3,365,652 $10,935,426 $12,976,488 $13,439,238 $3,982,412 $25,232,933 $3,133,045 $23,100,542 $3,766,042 $3,653,663 $9,738,973 $3,459,344 $7,230,357 $2,138,252 $2,589,134 $38,189,608 $28,901,562 $9,704,878 $16,222,894 $5,646,447 $3,437,809 $5,422,716 $4,465,951 $4,302,689 $10,671,343 $13,162,357 $280,154,565 Appendix II (e) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Food & Beverage 311111 311211 311212 311213 311221 311222 311225 311230 311311 311312 311313 311320 311330 311340 311411 311412 311421 311422 311423 311512 311514 311520 311611 311612 311613 311615 311711 311712 311811 311812 311813 311821 311822 311823 311830 311911 311919 311920 311930 311941 311942 311999 312111 312112 312113 312120 312130 312140 312221 312229 Dog and Cat Food Manufacturing Flour Milling Rice Milling Malt Manufacturing Wet Corn Milling Soybean Processing Fats and Oils Refining and Blending Breakfast Cereal Manufacturing Sugarcane Mills Cane Sugar Refining Beet Sugar Manufacturing Chocolate and Confectionery Manufacturing from Cacao Beans Confectionery Manufacturing from Purchased Chocolate Nonchocolate Confectionery Manufacturing Frozen Fruit, Juice, and Vegetable Manufacturing Frozen Specialty Food Manufacturing Fruit and Vegetable Canning Specialty Canning Dried and Dehydrated Food Manufacturing Creamery Butter Manufacturing Dry, Condensed, and Evaporated Dairy Product Manufacturing Ice Cream and Frozen Dessert Manufacturing Animal (except Poultry) Slaughtering Meat Processed from Carcasses Rendering and Meat Byproduct Processing Poultry Processing Seafood Canning Fresh and Frozen Seafood Processing Retail Bakeries Commercial Bakeries Frozen Cakes, Pies, and Other Pastries Manufacturing Cookie and Cracker Manufacturing Flour Mixes and Dough Manufacturing from Purchased Flour Dry Pasta Manufacturing Tortilla Manufacturing Roasted Nuts and Peanut Butter Manufacturing Other Snack Food Manufacturing Coffee and Tea Manufacturing Flavoring Syrup and Concentrate Manufacturing Mayonnaise, Dressing, and Other Prepared Sauce Manufacturing Spice and Extract Manufacturing All Other Miscellaneous Food Manufacturing Soft Drink Manufacturing Bottled Water Manufacturing Ice Manufacturing Breweries Wineries Distilleries Cigarette Manufacturing Other Tobacco Product Manufacturing 37 Potential Percent Self-Reliant New Jobs 30 0% 15 0% 5 0% 1 0% 16 0% 9 0% 13 0% 20 0% 6 0% 4 0% 9 0% 11 0% 40 14% 22 22% 51 0% 76 0% 67 0% 22 0% 19 0% 2 0% 21 0% 29 0% 198 7% 135 9% 13 0% 337 0% 3 0% 45 0% 46 51% 116 52% 27 0% 45 0% 25 0% 6 0% 23 0% 21 0% 43 0% 20 0% 8 0% 23 0% 25 0% 46 0% 80 0% 14 0% 7 0% 38 0% 48 9% 10 0% 15 0% 8 0% 1,914 Potential New Wages $1,414,286 $712,923 $253,154 $60,757 $761,419 $428,809 $630,589 $932,416 $295,616 $197,865 $430,226 $495,640 $1,720,150 $1,037,765 $2,397,468 $3,622,935 $3,173,468 $1,038,808 $913,919 $103,152 $995,671 $1,370,608 $8,596,986 $5,899,294 $638,015 $15,999,860 $136,771 $2,112,788 $1,172,703 $5,200,531 $1,275,288 $2,130,205 $1,187,190 $274,554 $1,101,118 $980,684 $2,052,233 $931,944 $394,447 $1,070,469 $1,207,510 $2,180,903 $3,803,450 $683,853 $386,215 $1,823,058 $2,048,868 $451,154 $695,162 $396,135 $87,819,030 Appendix II (f) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Potential Percent Self-Reliant New Jobs 32 0% Yarn Spinning Mills 23 0% Yarn Texturizing, Throwing, and Twisting Mills 2 0% Thread Mills 42 0% Broadwoven Fabric Mills 12 0% Narrow Fabric Mills 1 0% Schiffli Machine Embroidery 27 0% Nonwoven Fabric Mills 6 0% Weft Knit Fabric Mills 8 0% Other Knit Fabric and Lace Mills 23 0% Broadwoven Fabric Finishing Mills 24 0% Textile and Fabric Finishing (except Broadwoven Fabric) Mills 12 0% Fabric Coating Mills 57 0% Carpet and Rug Mills 14 55% Curtain and Drapery Mills 26 22% Other Household Textile Product Mills 8 0% Textile Bag Mills 19 61% Canvas and Related Product Mills 6 0% Rope, Cordage, and Twine Mills 5 0% Tire Cord and Tire Fabric Mills 53 18% All Other Miscellaneous Textile Product Mills 6 0% Sheer Hosiery Mills 15 0% Other Hosiery and Sock Mills 7 0% Outerwear Knitting Mills 1 0% Underwear and Nightwear Knitting Mills 24 0% Men's and Boys' Cut and Sew Apparel Contractors 64 0% Women's, Girls', and Infants' Cut and Sew Apparel Contractors 1 0% Men's and Boys' Cut and Sew Underwear and Nightwear Manufacturing 9 0% Men's and Boys' Cut and Sew Suit, Coat, and Overcoat Manufacturing 6 0% Men's and Boys' Cut and Sew Shirt (except Work Shirt) Manufacturing 2 0% Men's and Boys' Cut and Sew Trouser, Slack, and Jean Manufacturing 10 0% Men's and Boys' Cut and Sew Work Clothing Manufacturing 6 0% Men's and Boys' Cut and Sew Other Outerwear Manufacturing 2 0% Women's and Girls' Cut and Sew Lingerie, Loungewear, and Nightwear Manufacturing 20 0% Women's and Girls' Cut and Sew Blouse and Shirt Manufacturing 13 0% Women's and Girls' Cut and Sew Dress Manufacturing 3 0% Women's and Girls' Cut and Sew Suit, Coat, Tailored Jacket, and Skirt Manufacturing 36 0% Women's and Girls' Cut and Sew Other Outerwear Manufacturing 0 0% Infants' Cut and Sew Apparel Manufacturing 1 0% Fur and Leather Apparel Manufacturing 6 0% Hat, Cap, and Millinery Manufacturing 3 0% Glove and Mitten Manufacturing 2 0% Men's and Boys' Neckwear Manufacturing 8 0% Other Apparel Accessories and Other Apparel Manufacturing 8 0% Leather and Hide Tanning and Finishing 3 0% Rubber and Plastics Footwear Manufacturing 8 0% Men's Footwear (except Athletic) Manufacturing 5 0% Women's Footwear (except Athletic) Manufacturing 2 0% Other Footwear Manufacturing 7 0% Luggage Manufacturing 3 Personal Leather Good (except Women's Handbag and Purse) Manufacturing 0% 9 0% All Other Leather Good Manufacturing 689 Fiber, Textiles, and Clothing 313111 313112 313113 313210 313221 313222 313230 313241 313249 313311 313312 313320 314110 314121 314129 314911 314912 314991 314992 314999 315111 315119 315191 315192 315211 315212 315221 315222 315223 315224 315225 315228 315231 315232 315233 315234 315239 315291 315292 315991 315992 315993 315999 316110 316211 316213 316214 316219 316991 316993 316999 38 Potential New Wages $1,530,264 $1,069,862 $88,300 $1,985,494 $550,795 $69,533 $1,302,493 $281,845 $371,832 $1,094,705 $1,152,424 $589,545 $2,712,459 $662,729 $1,136,401 $392,962 $898,818 $284,410 $223,990 $2,325,592 $275,566 $713,219 $313,101 $24,505 $996,012 $3,052,292 $38,142 $430,699 $271,516 $111,388 $497,734 $266,318 $103,624 $952,466 $603,114 $121,919 $1,451,903 $21,737 $60,217 $306,080 $127,319 $104,907 $355,900 $328,873 $157,225 $401,671 $222,100 $75,811 $317,354 $154,660 $427,931 $32,009,754 Appendix II (g) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Wood & Paper 321113 321114 321211 321212 321213 321214 321219 321911 321912 321918 321920 321991 321999 322110 322122 322211 322213 322214 322215 322221 322223 322224 322225 322226 322231 322232 322233 322291 322299 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs Sawmills 73% 105 Wood Preservation 0% 19 Hardwood Veneer and Plywood Manufacturing 0% 26 Softwood Veneer and Plywood Manufacturing 0% 26 Engineered Wood Member (except Truss) Manufacturing 0% 11 Truss Manufacturing 0% 47 Reconstituted Wood Product Manufacturing 0% 26 Wood Window and Door Manufacturing 8% 93 Cut Stock, Resawing Lumber, and Planing 5% 39 Other Millwork (including Flooring) 3% 58 Wood Container and Pallet Manufacturing 65% 40 Manufactured Home (Mobile Home) Manufacturing 0% 57 All Other Miscellaneous Wood Product Manufacturing 79% 40 Pulp Mills 0% 10 Newsprint Mills 0% 7 Corrugated and Solid Fiber Box Manufacturing 23% 110 Setup Paperboard Box Manufacturing 0% 6 Fiber Can, Tube, Drum, and Similar Products Manufacturing 0% 12 Nonfolding Sanitary Food Container Manufacturing 0% 15 Coated and Laminated Packaging Paper and Plastics Film Manufacturing 0% 7 Plastics, Foil, and Coated Paper Bag Manufacturing 0% 5 Uncoated Paper and Multiwall Bag Manufacturing 0% 15 Laminated Aluminum Foil Manufacturing for Flexible Packaging Uses 0% 8 Surface-Coated Paperboard Manufacturing 0% 4 Die-Cut Paper and Paperboard Office Supplies Manufacturing 0% 12 Envelope Manufacturing 0% 25 Stationery, Tablet, and Related Product Manufacturing 0% 6 Sanitary Paper Product Manufacturing 0% 27 All Other Converted Paper Product Manufacturing 0% 26 883 39 Potential New Wages $3,174,941 $865,147 $1,243,019 $1,163,605 $517,311 $2,016,295 $1,251,322 $4,022,069 $1,827,307 $2,585,724 $1,595,014 $2,594,264 $1,887,708 $474,579 $324,307 $5,260,993 $273,946 $550,525 $732,391 $329,843 $214,337 $723,750 $380,676 $168,972 $589,275 $1,182,465 $303,852 $1,267,524 $1,175,877 $38,697,036 Appendix II (h) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Printing 323110 323111 323112 323113 323114 323115 323116 323117 323122 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 30% 328 0% 24 0% 49 28% 73 27% 36 0% 57 0% 31 0% 48 19% 27 670 Commercial Lithographic Printing Commercial Gravure Printing Commercial Flexographic Printing Commercial Screen Printing Quick Printing Digital Printing Manifold Business Forms Printing Books Printing Prepress Services 40 Potential New Wages $14,659,823 $1,123,260 $2,307,547 $2,684,626 $1,261,046 $2,690,316 $1,456,073 $2,271,498 $1,265,133 $29,719,323 Appendix II (i) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Chemicals and Plastics 324110 324122 324191 324199 325110 325131 325132 325182 325188 325191 325192 325193 325199 325211 325212 325221 325222 325311 325312 325314 325320 325411 325413 325414 325510 325520 325611 325613 325620 325910 325920 325991 325992 325998 326111 326113 326121 326122 326130 326140 326191 326192 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs Petroleum Refineries 0% 93 Asphalt Shingle and Coating Materials Manufacturing 0% 16 Petroleum Lubricating Oil and Grease Manufacturing 0% 15 All Other Petroleum and Coal Products Manufacturing 0% 4 Petrochemical Manufacturing 0% 13 Inorganic Dye and Pigment Manufacturing 0% 10 Synthetic Organic Dye and Pigment Manufacturing 0% 7 Carbon Black Manufacturing 0% 2 All Other Basic Inorganic Chemical Manufacturing 0% 55 Gum and Wood Chemical Manufacturing 0% 3 Cyclic Crude and Intermediate Manufacturing 0% 5 Ethyl Alcohol Manufacturing 0% 11 All Other Basic Organic Chemical Manufacturing 0% 103 Plastics Material and Resin Manufacturing 0% 104 Synthetic Rubber Manufacturing 0% 14 Cellulosic Organic Fiber Manufacturing 0% 2 Noncellulosic Organic Fiber Manufacturing 0% 22 Nitrogenous Fertilizer Manufacturing 0% 6 Phosphatic Fertilizer Manufacturing 0% 9 Fertilizer (Mixing Only) Manufacturing 93% 9 Pesticide and Other Agricultural Chemical Manufacturing 0% 16 Medicinal and Botanical Manufacturing 0% 39 In-Vitro Diagnostic Substance Manufacturing 0% 40 Biological Product (except Diagnostic) Manufacturing 0% 51 Paint and Coating Manufacturing 0% 58 Adhesive Manufacturing 0% 32 Soap and Other Detergent Manufacturing 50% 23 Surface Active Agent Manufacturing 0% 9 Toilet Preparation Manufacturing 86% 69 Printing Ink Manufacturing 0% 17 Explosives Manufacturing 0% 9 Custom Compounding of Purchased Resins 0% 29 Photographic Film, Paper, Plate, and Chemical Manufacturing 0% 29 All Other Miscellaneous Chemical Product and Preparation Manufacturing 4% 49 Plastics Bag Manufacturing 0% 46 Unlaminated Plastics Film and Sheet (except Packaging) Manufacturing 0% 57 Unlaminated Plastics Profile Shape Manufacturing 0% 28 Plastics Pipe and Pipe Fitting Manufacturing 0% 35 Laminated Plastics Plate, Sheet (except Packaging), and Shape Manufacturing 0% 18 Polystyrene Foam Product Manufacturing 0% 40 Plastics Plumbing Fixture Manufacturing 0% 32 Resilient Floor Covering Manufacturing 0% 6 1,233 41 Potential New Wages $4,408,454 $788,304 $691,954 $185,039 $613,240 $494,426 $318,434 $114,493 $2,752,340 $120,974 $225,138 $535,471 $4,882,965 $4,919,825 $650,639 $99,506 $1,041,171 $266,183 $406,599 $415,389 $769,925 $1,849,980 $1,898,518 $2,421,298 $2,731,901 $1,506,704 $1,099,610 $446,361 $3,258,458 $817,248 $446,293 $1,378,237 $1,374,659 $2,317,394 $2,167,199 $2,719,277 $1,292,383 $1,647,052 $867,676 $1,891,970 $1,503,396 $303,177 $58,639,258 Appendix II (j) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Rubber, Stone & Glass 326211 326212 326220 326291 326299 327111 327112 327121 327122 327123 327124 327125 327211 327212 327215 327310 327320 327390 327410 327420 327910 327991 327992 327993 327999 Percent Potential Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages Tire Manufacturing (except Retreading) 0% 71 $3,391,991 Tire Retreading 0% 11 $537,429 Rubber and Plastics Hoses and Belting Manufacturing 0% 28 $1,343,268 Rubber Product Manufacturing for Mechanical Use 0% 49 $2,273,205 All Other Rubber Product Manufacturing 0% 48 $2,297,084 Vitreous China Plumbing Fixture and China and Earthenware Bathroom Accessories 0% Manufacturing 6 $275,499 Vitreous China, Fine Earthenware, and Other Pottery Product Manufacturing 0% 11 $536,484 Brick and Structural Clay Tile Manufacturing 0% 16 $748,593 Ceramic Wall and Floor Tile Manufacturing 0% 9 $435,019 Other Structural Clay Product Manufacturing 0% 2 $98,291 Clay Refractory Manufacturing 0% 6 $290,013 Nonclay Refractory Manufacturing 0% 7 $328,087 Flat Glass Manufacturing 0% 15 $702,282 Other Pressed and Blown Glass and Glassware Manufacturing 18% 31 $1,448,277 Glass Product Manufacturing Made of Purchased Glass 8% 70 $3,220,816 Cement Manufacturing 0% 25 $1,191,376 Ready-Mix Concrete Manufacturing 87% 42 $2,203,050 Other Concrete Product Manufacturing 19% 79 $3,781,658 Lime Manufacturing 0% 6 $307,970 Gypsum Product Manufacturing 0% 17 $810,694 Abrasive Product Manufacturing 0% 20 $971,976 Cut Stone and Stone Product Manufacturing 7% 60 $2,613,493 Ground or Treated Mineral and Earth Manufacturing 17% 8 $380,522 Mineral Wool Manufacturing 0% 25 $1,255,690 All Other Miscellaneous Nonmetallic Mineral Product Manufacturing 0% 15 $709,641 679 $32,152,407 42 Appendix II (k) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Metals & Fixtures 331111 331112 331210 331221 331222 331311 331312 331314 331315 331316 331319 331411 331419 331421 331422 331423 331491 331492 331511 331512 331513 331521 331522 331524 331525 331528 332112 332114 332115 332116 332117 332211 332212 332213 332214 332311 332312 332313 332321 332322 332323 332410 332420 332431 332439 332510 332611 332612 332618 332710 332721 332722 332811 332812 332813 332912 332913 332919 332991 332992 332993 332994 332995 332996 332997 332998 332999 Percent Potential Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages Iron and Steel Mills 0% 168 $8,818,366 Electrometallurgical Ferroalloy Product Manufacturing 0% 4 $169,984 Iron and Steel Pipe and Tube Manufacturing from Purchased Steel 0% 26 $1,233,703 Rolled Steel Shape Manufacturing 0% 15 $705,995 Steel Wire Drawing 0% 21 $988,650 Alumina Refining 0% 2 $109,632 Primary Aluminum Production 0% 13 $655,787 Secondary Smelting and Alloying of Aluminum 0% 10 $489,151 Aluminum Sheet, Plate, and Foil Manufacturing 0% 25 $1,206,092 Aluminum Extruded Product Manufacturing 0% 362 $14,403,337 Other Aluminum Rolling and Drawing 0% 4 $195,705 Primary Smelting and Refining of Copper 0% 2 $106,662 Primary Smelting and Refining of Nonferrous Metal (except Copper and Aluminum) 0% 15 $885,639 Copper Rolling, Drawing, and Extruding 0% 19 $893,734 Copper Wire (except Mechanical) Drawing 0% 18 $855,930 Secondary Smelting, Refining, and Alloying of Copper 0% 2 $71,221 Nonferrous Metal (except Copper and Aluminum) Rolling, Drawing, and Extruding 0% 26 $1,256,723 Secondary Smelting, Refining, and Alloying of Nonferrous Metal (except Copper0% and Aluminum) 15 $713,286 Iron Foundries 0% 70 $3,326,508 Steel Investment Foundries 0% 25 $1,200,692 Steel Foundries (except Investment) 0% 25 $1,162,482 Aluminum Die-Casting Foundries 0% 37 $1,911,434 Nonferrous (except Aluminum) Die-Casting Foundries 0% 10 $483,085 Aluminum Foundries (except Die-Casting) 0% 32 $1,513,792 Copper Foundries (except Die-Casting) 0% 10 $468,706 Other Nonferrous Foundries (except Die-Casting) 0% 8 $365,892 Nonferrous Forging 0% 11 $538,711 Custom Roll Forming 46% 24 $1,154,511 Crown and Closure Manufacturing 0% 5 $235,534 Metal Stamping 0% 87 $4,142,001 Powder Metallurgy Part Manufacturing 0% 12 $589,477 Cutlery and Flatware (except Precious) Manufacturing 0% 7 $328,357 Hand and Edge Tool Manufacturing 0% 54 $2,437,889 Saw Blade and Handsaw Manufacturing 0% 9 $408,286 Kitchen Utensil, Pot, and Pan Manufacturing 0% 5 $244,040 Prefabricated Metal Building and Component Manufacturing 65% 45 $2,022,873 Fabricated Structural Metal Manufacturing 85% 120 $5,727,508 Plate Work Manufacturing 0% 53 $2,530,930 Metal Window and Door Manufacturing 16% 81 $3,581,990 Sheet Metal Work Manufacturing 0% 164 $7,761,041 Ornamental and Architectural Metal Work Manufacturing 27% 40 $1,937,869 Power Boiler and Heat Exchanger Manufacturing 0% 31 $1,481,051 Metal Tank (Heavy Gauge) Manufacturing 0% 51 $2,404,759 Metal Can Manufacturing 0% 27 $1,292,772 Other Metal Container Manufacturing 0% 21 $994,861 Hardware Manufacturing 0% 55 $2,632,597 Spring (Heavy Gauge) Manufacturing 0% 7 $326,940 Spring (Light Gauge) Manufacturing 0% 18 $863,423 Other Fabricated Wire Product Manufacturing 4% 46 $2,083,046 Machine Shops 13% 328 $14,590,783 Precision Turned Product Manufacturing 5% 128 $5,933,800 Bolt, Nut, Screw, Rivet, and Washer Manufacturing 0% 60 $2,837,280 Metal Heat Treating 0% 34 $1,623,627 Metal Coating, Engraving (except Jewelry and Silverware), and Allied Services to 17% Manufacturers 65 $3,067,505 Electroplating, Plating, Polishing, Anodizing, and Coloring 0% 83 $3,932,255 Fluid Power Valve and Hose Fitting Manufacturing 0% 54 $2,540,786 Plumbing Fixture Fitting and Trim Manufacturing 0% 14 $657,052 Other Metal Valve and Pipe Fitting Manufacturing 0% 24 $1,133,116 Ball and Roller Bearing Manufacturing 0% 38 $1,813,324 Small Arms Ammunition Manufacturing 0% 15 $712,341 Ammunition (except Small Arms) Manufacturing 0% 15 $691,819 Small Arms Manufacturing 0% 15 $712,139 Other Ordnance and Accessories Manufacturing 0% 7 $324,347 Fabricated Pipe and Pipe Fitting Manufacturing 0% 45 $2,123,387 Industrial Pattern Manufacturing 0% 8 $367,579 Enameled Iron and Metal Sanitary Ware Manufacturing 0% 6 $300,342 All Other Miscellaneous Fabricated Metal Product Manufacturing 0% 114 $5,396,294 2,990 $138,670,431 43 Appendix II (l) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Potential Potential Percent Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages $4,147,604 87 0% Farm Machinery and Equipment Manufacturing $1,543,631 33 0% Lawn and Garden Tractor and Home Lawn and Garden Equipment Manufacturing $4,504,506 96 0% Construction Machinery Manufacturing $744,610 16 0% Mining Machinery and Equipment Manufacturing $2,995,451 63 0% Oil and Gas Field Machinery and Equipment Manufacturing $357,318 8 0% Sawmill and Woodworking Machinery Manufacturing $999,813 21 0% Plastics and Rubber Industry Machinery Manufacturing $683,988 14 0% Paper Industry Machinery Manufacturing $470,394 10 0% Textile Machinery Manufacturing $962,246 19 0% Printing Machinery and Equipment Manufacturing $1,183,680 25 0% Food Product Machinery Manufacturing $1,351,706 28 0% Semiconductor Machinery Manufacturing $2,673,912 56 0% All Other Industrial Machinery Manufacturing $267,330 6 0% Automatic Vending Machine Manufacturing $239,990 5 0% Commercial Laundry, Drycleaning, and Pressing Machine Manufacturing $521,159 11 0% Office Machinery Manufacturing $1,148,643 24 0% Optical Instrument and Lens Manufacturing $400,456 8 0% Photographic and Photocopying Equipment Manufacturing $3,417,644 72 0% Other Commercial and Service Industry Machinery Manufacturing $1,037,931 22 0% Air Purification Equipment Manufacturing $665,491 14 0% Industrial and Commercial Fan and Blower Manufacturing $1,384,459 30 0% Heating Equipment (except Warm Air Furnaces) Manufacturing Manufacturing $6,946,945 146 Equipment 0% Refrigeration Air-Conditioning and Warm Air Heating Equipment and Commercial and Industrial $2,625,247 56 0% Industrial Mold Manufacturing $1,430,825 30 0% Machine Tool (Metal Cutting Types) Manufacturing $607,164 13 0% Machine Tool (Metal Forming Types) Manufacturing $3,434,656 72 0% Special Die and Tool, Die Set, Jig, and Fixture Manufacturing $2,235,179 47 0% Cutting Tool and Machine Tool Accessory Manufacturing $193,950 4 0% Rolling Mill Machinery and Equipment Manufacturing $699,785 15 0% Other Metalworking Machinery Manufacturing $1,769,916 37 0% Turbine and Turbine Generator Set Units Manufacturing $1,020,649 22 0% Speed Changer, Industrial High-Speed Drive, and Gear Manufacturing $1,129,387 24 0% Mechanical Power Transmission Equipment Manufacturing $3,512,154 74 0% Other Engine Equipment Manufacturing $2,334,010 49 0% Pump and Pumping Equipment Manufacturing $1,566,313 33 0% Air and Gas Compressor Manufacturing $300,409 6 0% Measuring and Dispensing Pump Manufacturing $615,696 13 0% Elevator and Moving Stairway Manufacturing $2,386,869 50 0% Conveyor and Conveying Equipment Manufacturing $1,453,980 31 0% Overhead Traveling Crane, Hoist, and Monorail System Manufacturing $1,772,954 37 0% Industrial Truck, Tractor, Trailer, and Stacker Machinery Manufacturing $535,133 11 0% Power-Driven Handtool Manufacturing $1,113,134 23 0% Welding and Soldering Equipment Manufacturing $1,374,389 29 0% Packaging Machinery Manufacturing $803,206 17 0% Industrial Process Furnace and Oven Manufacturing $1,169,432 24 19% Fluid Power Cylinder and Actuator Manufacturing $857,010 18 0% Fluid Power Pump and Motor Manufacturing $259,635 5 0% Scale and Balance (except Laboratory) Manufacturing $2,011,238 43 64% All Other Miscellaneous General Purpose Machinery Manufacturing $75,861,226 1,600 Machinery 333111 333112 333120 333131 333132 333210 333220 333291 333292 333293 333294 333295 333298 333311 333312 333313 333314 333315 333319 333411 333412 333414 333415 333511 333512 333513 333514 333515 333516 333518 333611 333612 333613 333618 333911 333912 333913 333921 333922 333923 333924 333991 333992 333993 333994 333995 333996 333997 333999 44 Appendix II (m) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Electronics and Computers 334111 334112 334113 334119 334210 334220 334290 334310 334411 334413 334414 334415 334416 334417 334418 334419 334510 334511 334512 334513 334514 334515 334516 334517 334518 334519 334611 334612 334613 335110 335121 335122 335129 335211 335212 335221 335222 335224 335228 335311 335312 335313 335314 335911 335912 335921 335929 335931 335932 335991 335999 Percent Potential Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages Electronic Computer Manufacturing 0% 49 $2,309,978 Computer Storage Device Manufacturing 0% 27 $1,265,836 Computer Terminal Manufacturing 0% 1 $62,985 Other Computer Peripheral Equipment Manufacturing 0% 53 $2,531,268 Telephone Apparatus Manufacturing 0% 32 $1,660,560 Radio and Television Broadcasting and Wireless Communications Equipment Manufacturing 0% 153 $8,841,018 Other Communications Equipment Manufacturing 0% 26 $1,239,306 Audio and Video Equipment Manufacturing 0% 20 $951,521 Electron Tube Manufacturing 0% 8 $387,967 Semiconductor and Related Device Manufacturing 0% 184 $8,717,334 Electronic Capacitor Manufacturing 0% 9 $421,788 Electronic Resistor Manufacturing 0% 7 $310,670 Electronic Coil, Transformer, and Other Inductor Manufacturing 0% 17 $803,341 Electronic Connector Manufacturing 0% 32 $1,514,197 Printed Circuit Assembly (Electronic Assembly) Manufacturing 0% 108 $5,140,777 Other Electronic Component Manufacturing 0% 77 $3,673,768 Electromedical and Electrotherapeutic Apparatus Manufacturing 2% 88 $4,449,611 Search, Detection, Navigation, Guidance, Aeronautical, and Nautical System and 0%Instrument 204Manufacturing $9,700,786 Automatic Environmental Control Manufacturing for Residential, Commercial, 0% and Appliance 18 Use $841,888 Instruments and Related Products Manufacturing for Measuring, Displaying, and 0%Controlling 50Industrial $2,367,629 Process Variables Totalizing Fluid Meter and Counting Device Manufacturing 0% 22 $1,079,345 Instrument Manufacturing for Measuring and Testing Electricity and Electrical Signals 0% 70 $3,326,913 Analytical Laboratory Instrument Manufacturing 0% 51 $2,413,197 Irradiation Apparatus Manufacturing 0% 26 $1,228,100 Watch, Clock, and Part Manufacturing 0% 3 $163,099 Other Measuring and Controlling Device Manufacturing 91% 34 $1,700,688 Software Reproducing 0% 4 $181,866 Prerecorded Compact Disc (except Software), Tape, and Record Reproducing 0% 25 $1,159,410 Magnetic and Optical Recording Media Manufacturing 0% 9 $412,404 Electric Lamp Bulb and Part Manufacturing 0% 13 $605,206 Residential Electric Lighting Fixture Manufacturing 0% 16 $729,418 Commercial, Industrial, and Institutional Electric Lighting Fixture Manufacturing 41% 23 $1,072,623 Other Lighting Equipment Manufacturing 0% 22 $1,065,069 Electric Housewares and Household Fan Manufacturing 0% 17 $767,928 Household Vacuum Cleaner Manufacturing 0% 5 $228,784 Household Cooking Appliance Manufacturing 0% 18 $831,897 Household Refrigerator and Home Freezer Manufacturing 0% 19 $885,161 Household Laundry Equipment Manufacturing 0% 15 $706,738 Other Major Household Appliance Manufacturing 0% 16 $767,630 Power, Distribution, and Specialty Transformer Manufacturing 0% 31 $1,449,862 Motor and Generator Manufacturing 42% 43 $2,047,231 Switchgear and Switchboard Apparatus Manufacturing 0% 49 $2,317,066 Relay and Industrial Control Manufacturing 4% 55 $2,584,941 Storage Battery Manufacturing 0% 28 $1,339,892 Primary Battery Manufacturing 0% 8 $402,143 Fiber Optic Cable Manufacturing 0% 9 $420,573 Other Communication and Energy Wire Manufacturing 0% 41 $1,955,495 Current-Carrying Wiring Device Manufacturing 0% 46 $2,189,679 Noncurrent-Carrying Wiring Device Manufacturing 0% 24 $1,139,665 Carbon and Graphite Product Manufacturing 0% 12 $580,431 All Other Miscellaneous Electrical Equipment and Component Manufacturing 0% 49 $2,339,546 1,965 $95,284,228 45 Appendix II (n) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Autos, Trucks, and Transport 336111 336112 336120 336211 336212 336213 336214 336311 336312 336321 336322 336330 336340 336350 336360 336370 336391 336399 336411 336412 336413 336414 336415 336419 336611 336612 336991 336992 336999 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs Automobile Manufacturing 0% 103 Light Truck and Utility Vehicle Manufacturing 0% 115 Heavy Duty Truck Manufacturing 0% 44 Motor Vehicle Body Manufacturing 2% 67 Truck Trailer Manufacturing 0% 37 Motor Home Manufacturing 0% 23 Travel Trailer and Camper Manufacturing 0% 67 Carburetor, Piston, Piston Ring, and Valve Manufacturing 0% 13 Gasoline Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing 0% 74 Vehicular Lighting Equipment Manufacturing 0% 19 Other Motor Vehicle Electrical and Electronic Equipment Manufacturing 0% 75 Motor Vehicle Steering and Suspension Components (except Spring) Manufacturing 0% 53 Motor Vehicle Brake System Manufacturing 0% 39 Motor Vehicle Transmission and Power Train Parts Manufacturing 0% 107 Motor Vehicle Seating and Interior Trim Manufacturing 0% 71 Motor Vehicle Metal Stamping 0% 134 Motor Vehicle Air-Conditioning Manufacturing 0% 22 All Other Motor Vehicle Parts Manufacturing 0% 191 Aircraft Manufacturing 0% 229 Aircraft Engine and Engine Parts Manufacturing 0% 100 Other Aircraft Parts and Auxiliary Equipment Manufacturing 0% 160 Guided Missile and Space Vehicle Manufacturing 0% 70 Guided Missile and Space Vehicle Propulsion Unit and Propulsion Unit Parts Manufacturing 0% 21 Other Guided Missile and Space Vehicle Parts and Auxiliary Equipment Manufacturing 0% 10 Ship Building and Repairing 0% 150 Boat Building 36% 53 Motorcycle, Bicycle, and Parts Manufacturing 0% 20 Military Armored Vehicle, Tank, and Tank Component Manufacturing 0% 21 All Other Transportation Equipment Manufacturing 0% 21 2,109 46 Potential New Wages $4,885,328 $5,472,105 $2,061,246 $3,117,800 $1,745,276 $1,080,730 $3,172,456 $596,903 $3,490,687 $883,405 $3,580,742 $2,526,745 $1,847,685 $5,081,235 $3,372,549 $6,363,476 $1,043,061 $9,080,053 $10,885,006 $4,740,727 $7,614,461 $3,333,259 $1,008,362 $452,842 $7,115,107 $2,275,803 $956,516 $992,430 $988,245 $99,764,241 Appendix II (o) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Furniture and Household Goods Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 337110 Wood Kitchen Cabinet and Countertop Manufacturing 6% 173 337121 Upholstered Household Furniture Manufacturing 0% 100 337124 Metal Household Furniture Manufacturing 0% 17 337125 Household Furniture (except Wood and Metal) Manufacturing 0% 6 337127 Institutional Furniture Manufacturing 0% 52 337129 Wood Television, Radio, and Sewing Machine Cabinet Manufacturing 0% 4 337211 Wood Office Furniture Manufacturing 0% 24 337212 Custom Architectural Woodwork and Millwork Manufacturing 22% 58 337214 Office Furniture (except Wood) Manufacturing 0% 41 337215 Showcase, Partition, Shelving, and Locker Manufacturing 0% 68 337910 Mattress Manufacturing 0% 34 337920 Blind and Shade Manufacturing 0% 25 602 Misc. Manufacturing Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 339111 Laboratory Apparatus and Furniture Manufacturing 0% 27 339114 Dental Equipment and Supplies Manufacturing 0% 23 339115 Ophthalmic Goods Manufacturing 0% 34 339116 Dental Laboratories 13% 60 339911 Jewelry (except Costume) Manufacturing 4% 35 339912 Silverware and Hollowware Manufacturing 0% 2 339913 Jewelers' Material and Lapidary Work Manufacturing 0% 3 339914 Costume Jewelry and Novelty Manufacturing 0% 8 339920 Sporting and Athletic Goods Manufacturing 18% 62 339932 Game, Toy, and Children's Vehicle Manufacturing 0% 13 339941 Pen and Mechanical Pencil Manufacturing 0% 6 339942 Lead Pencil and Art Good Manufacturing 0% 7 339943 Marking Device Manufacturing 0% 7 339944 Carbon Paper and Inked Ribbon Manufacturing 0% 2 339950 Sign Manufacturing 21% 100 339992 Musical Instrument Manufacturing 0% 18 339993 Fastener, Button, Needle, and Pin Manufacturing 0% 7 339995 Burial Casket Manufacturing 0% 7 277 47 Potential New Wages $6,939,479 $4,743,630 $826,902 $269,896 $2,488,738 $205,156 $1,145,200 $2,776,350 $1,936,525 $3,221,736 $1,598,919 $1,185,435 $27,337,966 Potential New Wages $1,301,075 $1,070,402 $1,618,969 $2,464,929 $1,681,103 $71,423 $159,858 $360,559 $2,651,895 $618,573 $287,785 $325,320 $353,133 $111,523 $3,984,215 $862,478 $340,306 $308,713 $12,116,882 Appendix II (p) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Wholesale 423110 423120 423130 423140 423210 423310 423320 423330 423390 423410 423420 423430 423440 423450 423490 423510 423520 423610 423620 423690 423710 423720 423730 423740 423810 423830 423840 423850 423860 423910 423920 423930 423940 423990 424110 424120 424130 424210 424310 424320 424340 424420 424430 424440 424450 424460 424470 424480 424490 424510 424520 424590 424610 424690 424710 424720 424820 424910 424920 424930 424950 424990 425110 425120 Potential Potential Percent Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages $5,350,923 101 73% Automobile and Other Motor Vehicle Merchant Wholesalers $6,024,675 163 47% Motor Vehicle Supplies and New Parts Merchant Wholesalers $1,939,929 32 39% Tire and Tube Merchant Wholesalers $1,510,617 25 0% Motor Vehicle Parts (Used) Merchant Wholesalers $6,239,106 104 0% Furniture Merchant Wholesalers $4,942,634 88 63% Lumber, Plywood, Millwork, and Wood Panel Merchant Wholesalers $2,339,110 46 19% Brick, Stone, and Related Construction Material Merchant Wholesalers $1,977,696 33 61% Roofing, Siding, and Insulation Material Merchant Wholesalers $3,346,704 62 5% Other Construction Material Merchant Wholesalers $1,552,619 26 0% Photographic Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $7,408,899 122 51% Office Equipment Merchant Wholesalers $31,065,136 391 5% Computer and Computer Peripheral Equipment and Software Merchant Wholesalers $2,833,071 51 99% Other Commercial Equipment Merchant Wholesalers $15,572,662 247 Medical, Dental, and Hospital Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers 1% $2,357,757 39 18% Other Professional Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $10,531,703 166 29% Metal Service Centers and Other Metal Merchant Wholesalers $341,760 6 0% Coal and Other Mineral and Ore Merchant Wholesalers $10,049,944 157 Wholesalers 48% Electrical Apparatus and Equipment, Wiring Supplies, and Related Equipment Merchant $3,968,509 66 0% Electrical and Electronic Appliance, Television, and Radio Set Merchant Wholesalers $25,054,656 344 13% Other Electronic Parts and Equipment Merchant Wholesalers $4,885,883 92 27% Hardware Merchant Wholesalers $6,309,432 110 10% Plumbing and Heating Equipment and Supplies (Hydronics) Merchant Wholesalers $2,608,890 43 73% Warm Air Heating and Air-Conditioning Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $1,128,998 19 0% Refrigeration Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $6,839,188 115 Wholesalers 23% Construction and Mining (except Oil Well) Machinery and Equipment Merchant $25,328,126 438 12% Industrial Machinery and Equipment Merchant Wholesalers $4,654,006 82 39% Industrial Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $2,618,499 46 51% Service Establishment Equipment and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $3,454,798 57 0% Transportation Equipment and Supplies (except Motor Vehicle) Merchant Wholesalers $3,563,780 63 29% Sporting and Recreational Goods and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $2,422,280 40 86% Toy and Hobby Goods and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $5,903,900 114 37% Recyclable Material Merchant Wholesalers $3,426,804 59 Jewelry, Watch, Precious Stone, and Precious Metal Merchant Wholesalers 18% $6,401,128 108 27% Other Miscellaneous Durable Goods Merchant Wholesalers $1,196,475 20 49% Printing and Writing Paper Merchant Wholesalers $5,241,485 98 19% Stationery and Office Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $3,645,041 61 47% Industrial and Personal Service Paper Merchant Wholesalers $17,799,836 308 30% Drugs and Druggists' Sundries Merchant Wholesalers $2,340,870 38 9% Piece Goods, Notions, and Other Dry Goods Merchant Wholesalers $4,629,054 70 37% Men's and Boys' Clothing and Furnishings Merchant Wholesalers $1,960,395 31 18% Footwear Merchant Wholesalers $6,269,214 104 25% Packaged Frozen Food Merchant Wholesalers $1,687,412 29 79% Dairy Product (except Dried or Canned) Merchant Wholesalers $1,134,399 19 0% Poultry and Poultry Product Merchant Wholesalers $3,898,210 72 10% Confectionery Merchant Wholesalers $1,724,313 29 0% Fish and Seafood Merchant Wholesalers $3,925,221 65 0% Meat and Meat Product Merchant Wholesalers $5,125,034 97 48% Fresh Fruit and Vegetable Merchant Wholesalers $14,285,043 272 35% Other Grocery and Related Products Merchant Wholesalers $4,120,488 68 0% Grain and Field Bean Merchant Wholesalers $501,237 10 0% Livestock Merchant Wholesalers $407,933 7 19% Other Farm Product Raw Material Merchant Wholesalers $3,062,478 49 4% Plastics Materials and Basic Forms and Shapes Merchant Wholesalers $7,843,998 98 59% Other Chemical and Allied Products Merchant Wholesalers $4,334,487 72 58% Petroleum Bulk Stations and Terminals $2,307,299 33 26%and Terminals) Petroleum and Petroleum Products Merchant Wholesalers (except Bulk Stations $6,791,945 105 0% Wine and Distilled Alcoholic Beverage Merchant Wholesalers $3,408,599 60 52% Farm Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $3,212,509 51 68% Book, Periodical, and Newspaper Merchant Wholesalers $4,745,204 79 0% Flower, Nursery Stock, and Florists' Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $1,664,482 28 0% Paint, Varnish, and Supplies Merchant Wholesalers $6,633,176 115 13% Other Miscellaneous Nondurable Goods Merchant Wholesalers $254,241 4 0% Business to Business Electronic Markets $20,533,944 355 16% Wholesale Trade Agents and Brokers $368,637,845 6,100 48 Appendix II (r) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Retail 441229 441320 442110 442210 442291 442299 443111 443112 443120 443130 444120 444220 445110 445120 445220 445230 445291 445292 445299 446120 446191 447190 448110 448120 448130 448150 448190 448210 448310 448320 451110 451120 451130 451140 451211 451212 451220 452111 452910 453210 453220 453310 453910 453920 453991 453998 454111 454112 454113 454210 454390 All Other Motor Vehicle Dealers Tire Dealers Furniture Stores Floor Covering Stores Window Treatment Stores All Other Home Furnishings Stores Household Appliance Stores Radio, Television, and Other Electronics Stores Computer and Software Stores Camera and Photographic Supplies Stores Paint and Wallpaper Stores Nursery, Garden Center, and Farm Supply Stores Supermarkets and Other Grocery (except Convenience) Stores Convenience Stores Fish and Seafood Markets Fruit and Vegetable Markets Baked Goods Stores Confectionery and Nut Stores All Other Specialty Food Stores Cosmetics, Beauty Supplies, and Perfume Stores Food (Health) Supplement Stores Other Gasoline Stations Men's Clothing Stores Women's Clothing Stores Children's and Infants' Clothing Stores Clothing Accessories Stores Other Clothing Stores Shoe Stores Jewelry Stores Luggage and Leather Goods Stores Sporting Goods Stores Hobby, Toy, and Game Stores Sewing, Needlework, and Piece Goods Stores Musical Instrument and Supplies Stores Book Stores News Dealers and Newsstands Prerecorded Tape, Compact Disc, and Record Stores Department Stores (except Discount Department Stores) Warehouse Clubs and Supercenters Office Supplies and Stationery Stores Gift, Novelty, and Souvenir Stores Used Merchandise Stores Pet and Pet Supplies Stores Art Dealers Tobacco Stores All Other Miscellaneous Store Retailers (except Tobacco Stores) Electronic Shopping Electronic Auctions Mail-Order Houses Vending Machine Operators Other Direct Selling Establishments 49 Potential Percent Self-Reliant New Jobs 20 0% 81 73% 106 91% 30 89% 10 15% 254 5% 58 41% 166 64% 106 15% 10 69% 42 22% 90 66% 461 89% 52 70% 10 93% 17 44% 15 91% 23 12% 30 63% 96 29% 33 46% 79 87% 52 48% 224 56% 94 34% 33 58% 107 20% 105 69% 97 56% 10 0% 134 62% 109 38% 52 20% 40 15% 87 73% 8 29% 12 88% 427 45% 1,315 36% 156 4% 91 83% 89 59% 73 56% 26 38% 34 10% 56 54% 154 14% 9 0% 265 7% 48 28% 78 72% 5,775 Potential New Wages $517,751 $2,379,480 $2,648,652 $1,001,509 $281,005 $5,552,003 $1,820,281 $3,567,890 $2,529,384 $253,531 $1,372,645 $2,499,403 $9,233,958 $876,896 $266,748 $393,466 $390,544 $501,319 $634,949 $2,131,405 $703,452 $1,888,467 $1,462,115 $4,303,273 $2,318,450 $963,314 $2,358,872 $2,219,568 $2,852,509 $264,600 $2,733,890 $1,824,148 $1,051,951 $965,346 $1,646,910 $213,158 $310,502 $9,998,561 $29,500,399 $3,342,644 $1,403,419 $2,395,141 $1,457,169 $1,178,225 $834,532 $1,806,500 $6,939,983 $220,058 $11,375,870 $1,305,788 $2,417,993 $141,109,630 Appendix II (s) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Transportation 481111 481112 481211 481212 481219 483111 483113 483211 483212 484110 484121 484122 484210 484230 485113 485210 485310 485320 485510 485999 486110 486210 486990 487110 487210 487990 488111 488119 488210 488310 488320 488330 488390 488410 488490 488991 Scheduled Passenger Air Transportation Scheduled Freight Air Transportation Nonscheduled Chartered Passenger Air Transportation Nonscheduled Chartered Freight Air Transportation Other Nonscheduled Air Transportation Deep Sea Freight Transportation Coastal and Great Lakes Freight Transportation Inland Water Freight Transportation Inland Water Passenger Transportation General Freight Trucking, Local General Freight Trucking, Long-Distance, Truckload General Freight Trucking, Long-Distance, Less Than Truckload Used Household and Office Goods Moving Specialized Freight (except Used Goods) Trucking, Long-Distance Bus and Other Motor Vehicle Transit Systems Interurban and Rural Bus Transportation Taxi Service Limousine Service Charter Bus Industry All Other Transit and Ground Passenger Transportation Pipeline Transportation of Crude Oil Pipeline Transportation of Natural Gas All Other Pipeline Transportation Scenic and Sightseeing Transportation, Land Scenic and Sightseeing Transportation, Water Scenic and Sightseeing Transportation, Other Air Traffic Control Other Airport Operations Support Activities for Rail Transportation Port and Harbor Operations Marine Cargo Handling Navigational Services to Shipping Other Support Activities for Water Transportation Motor Vehicle Towing Other Support Activities for Road Transportation Packing and Crating 50 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 70% 424 0% 32 30% 35 0% 7 0% 7 0% 15 0% 30 0% 24 0% 4 74% 133 30% 489 29% 284 89% 63 50% 165 55% 48 0% 21 46% 27 22% 48 0% 44 0% 19 0% 9 0% 34 0% 1 96% 10 0% 16 0% 3 0% 3 27% 99 0% 37 0% 8 0% 91 7% 18 0% 16 26% 58 0% 32 0% 24 2,376 Potential New Wages $14,515,140 $1,238,371 $1,477,362 $278,281 $290,778 $570,788 $1,172,651 $941,624 $164,617 $4,913,158 $17,119,217 $12,602,709 $2,317,080 $6,684,493 $2,191,276 $837,743 $776,473 $1,692,208 $1,712,363 $729,510 $341,881 $1,442,795 $31,689 $378,178 $670,356 $116,378 $109,572 $3,410,783 $1,439,494 $312,870 $3,555,833 $778,200 $738,059 $2,027,081 $1,271,232 $861,571 $89,711,812 Appendix II (t) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Delivery, Warehouse, Storage 492110 492210 493110 493120 493130 493190 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 76% 407 3% 51 70% 453 0% 62 0% 10 16% 88 1,072 Couriers Local Messengers and Local Delivery General Warehousing and Storage Refrigerated Warehousing and Storage Farm Product Warehousing and Storage Other Warehousing and Storage 51 Potential New Wages $15,663,107 $1,959,139 $17,895,415 $2,418,662 $403,976 $3,460,868 $41,801,166 Appendix II (u) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Publishing, Movies, and Information Services 511120 511130 511140 511191 511199 511210 512110 512120 512131 512132 512191 512199 512210 512220 512230 512240 512290 515112 515210 516110 517110 517211 517212 517310 517410 517510 517910 518111 518112 518210 519110 519190 Periodical Publishers Book Publishers Directory and Mailing List Publishers Greeting Card Publishers All Other Publishers Software Publishers Motion Picture and Video Production Motion Picture and Video Distribution Motion Picture Theaters (except Drive-Ins) Drive-In Motion Picture Theaters Teleproduction and Other Postproduction Services Other Motion Picture and Video Industries Record Production Integrated Record Production/Distribution Music Publishers Sound Recording Studios Other Sound Recording Industries Radio Stations Cable and Other Subscription Programming Internet Publishing and Broadcasting Wired Telecommunications Carriers Paging Cellular and Other Wireless Telecommunications Telecommunications Resellers Satellite Telecommunications Cable and Other Program Distribution Other Telecommunications Internet Service Providers Web Search Portals Data Processing, Hosting, and Related Services News Syndicates All Other Information Services 52 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 31% 165 2% 132 18% 62 0% 17 0% 14 1% 542 34% 177 0% 13 60% 75 0% 2 0% 34 0% 5 0% 2 0% 11 0% 8 0% 8 0% 5 84% 28 0% 59 0% 66 23% 926 0% 7 0% 388 0% 50 0% 14 0% 341 0% 21 0% 66 0% 36 3% 510 0% 13 0% 17 3,813 Potential New Wages $14,468,742 $10,695,900 $4,784,655 $1,369,126 $1,155,956 $58,280,847 $14,084,592 $1,039,671 $1,122,170 $145,687 $2,816,438 $394,201 $128,907 $943,371 $673,052 $694,789 $395,486 $1,888,527 $4,820,166 $5,449,275 $65,501,881 $572,894 $31,872,653 $4,087,277 $1,159,346 $28,053,124 $1,686,193 $5,393,060 $2,940,554 $34,956,027 $1,250,434 $1,382,683 $304,207,683 Appendix II (v) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Finance, Insurance, and Real Estate 521110 522110 522120 522130 522210 522220 522291 522292 522293 522294 522298 522310 522320 522390 523110 523120 523130 523140 523910 523920 523930 523991 523999 524113 524114 524126 524127 524128 524130 524210 524291 524292 524298 525930 525990 531110 531120 531130 531190 531210 531311 531312 531320 531390 Percent Potential Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages Monetary Authorities - Central Bank 0% 27 $5,180,612 Commercial Banking 43% 1,344 $130,427,194 Savings Institutions 81% 157 $24,498,264 Credit Unions 92% 75 $3,620,643 Credit Card Issuing 0% 102 $19,514,882 Sales Financing 0% 171 $29,059,708 Consumer Lending 0% 138 $10,392,801 Real Estate Credit 10% 352 $40,587,139 International Trade Financing 0% 2 $335,375 Secondary Market Financing 0% 31 $5,924,588 All Other Nondepository Credit Intermediation 2% 79 $14,507,504 Mortgage and Nonmortgage Loan Brokers 15% 94 $13,654,328 Financial Transactions Processing, Reserve, and Clearinghouse Activities 8% 174 $29,011,230 Other Activities Related to Credit Intermediation 0% 122 $23,407,895 Investment Banking and Securities Dealing 0% 195 $37,220,864 Securities Brokerage 10% 479 $119,889,439 Commodity Contracts Dealing 90% 12 $2,221,782 Commodity Contracts Brokerage 0% 17 $3,161,559 Miscellaneous Intermediation 26% 50 $9,545,409 Portfolio Management 4% 333 $115,401,594 Investment Advice 15% 110 $21,542,674 Trust, Fiduciary, and Custody Activities 0% 68 $11,227,484 Miscellaneous Financial Investment Activities 0% 17 $3,166,731 Direct Life Insurance Carriers 4% 547 $87,514,143 Direct Health and Medical Insurance Carriers 2% 654 $87,462,904 Direct Property and Casualty Insurance Carriers 8% 715 $62,471,210 Direct Title Insurance Carriers 0% 100 $17,589,517 Other Direct Insurance (except Life, Health, and Medical) Carriers 28% 23 $3,460,045 Reinsurance Carriers 0% 19 $3,663,532 Insurance Agencies and Brokerages 65% 342 $15,602,214 Claims Adjusting 44% 33 $4,020,716 Third Party Administration of Insurance and Pension Funds 1% 216 $33,993,490 All Other Insurance Related Activities 0% 35 $6,696,331 Real Estate Investment Trusts 0% 33 $6,222,669 Other Financial Vehicles 0% 7 $1,409,553 Lessors of Residential Buildings and Dwellings 72% 126 $3,153,463 Lessors of Nonresidential Buildings (except Miniwarehouses) 96% 68 $3,174,012 Lessors of Miniwarehouses and Self-Storage Units 19% 44 $1,956,274 Lessors of Other Real Estate Property 58% 23 $877,150 Offices of Real Estate Agents and Brokers 31% 336 $18,845,942 Residential Property Managers 31% 386 $16,922,888 Nonresidential Property Managers 30% 149 $9,827,522 Offices of Real Estate Appraisers 30% 39 $1,990,620 Other Activities Related to Real Estate 0% 96 $6,085,532 8,138 $1,066,439,425 53 Appendix II (w) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Rental and Leasing 532112 532120 532220 532230 532291 532292 532299 532411 532412 532420 532490 533110 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs Passenger Car Leasing 0% 10 Truck, Utility Trailer, and RV (Recreational Vehicle) Rental and Leasing 0% 78 Formal Wear and Costume Rental 0% 15 Video Tape and Disc Rental 82% 42 Home Health Equipment Rental 93% 11 Recreational Goods Rental 0% 11 All Other Consumer Goods Rental 30% 45 Commercial Air, Rail, and Water Transportation Equipment Rental and Leasing0% 9 Construction, Mining, and Forestry Machinery and Equipment Rental and Leasing 16% 69 Office Machinery and Equipment Rental and Leasing 18% 8 Other Commercial and Industrial Machinery and Equipment Rental and Leasing 23% 104 Lessors of Nonfinancial Intangible Assets (except Copyrighted Works) 0% 46 448 54 Potential New Wages $484,333 $3,634,689 $683,842 $618,363 $559,421 $378,773 $1,809,046 $455,214 $4,065,643 $418,597 $5,456,770 $2,351,070 $20,915,761 Appendix II (x) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Professional Services 541110 541191 541199 541211 541213 541214 541219 541310 541320 541330 541340 541350 541360 541380 541410 541420 541430 541490 541511 541512 541513 541519 541611 541612 541613 541614 541618 541620 541690 541710 541720 541810 541820 541830 541840 541850 541860 541870 541890 541910 541921 541922 541930 541940 541990 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs Offices of Lawyers 31% 1,095 Title Abstract and Settlement Offices 68% 35 All Other Legal Services 0% 27 Offices of Certified Public Accountants 41% 369 Tax Preparation Services 41% 178 Payroll Services 4% 613 Other Accounting Services 38% 192 Architectural Services 49% 162 Landscape Architectural Services 6% 45 Engineering Services 12% 1,243 Drafting Services 25% 12 Building Inspection Services 88% 19 Geophysical Surveying and Mapping Services 0% 18 Testing Laboratories 86% 69 Interior Design Services 9% 59 Industrial Design Services 0% 25 Graphic Design Services 10% 76 Other Specialized Design Services 0% 10 Custom Computer Programming Services 3% 804 Computer Systems Design Services 20% 570 Computer Facilities Management Services 4% 152 Other Computer Related Services 0% 184 Administrative Management and General Management Consulting Services 8% 491 Human Resources and Executive Search Consulting Services 11% 107 Marketing Consulting Services 15% 171 Process, Physical Distribution, and Logistics Consulting Services 22% 99 Other Management Consulting Services 0% 23 Environmental Consulting Services 20% 83 Other Scientific and Technical Consulting Services 15% 116 Research and Development in the Physical, Engineering, and Life Sciences 0% 898 Research and Development in the Social Sciences and Humanities 14% 50 Advertising Agencies 15% 209 Public Relations Agencies 0% 75 Media Buying Agencies 0% 21 Media Representatives 9% 19 Display Advertising 0% 48 Direct Mail Advertising 15% 91 Advertising Material Distribution Services 0% 26 Other Services Related to Advertising 1% 152 Marketing Research and Public Opinion Polling 17% 143 Photography Studios, Portrait 51% 55 Commercial Photography 25% 13 Translation and Interpretation Services 0% 22 Veterinary Services 83% 114 All Other Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 8% 118 9,101 55 Potential New Wages $46,516,333 $1,977,082 $2,111,710 $17,326,422 $1,630,900 $33,299,954 $7,905,037 $11,021,252 $3,474,994 $74,983,701 $721,555 $1,464,866 $1,401,104 $4,207,997 $4,361,023 $1,924,504 $5,151,945 $802,932 $68,537,656 $24,589,926 $11,871,031 $14,380,340 $58,755,085 $9,017,386 $16,450,488 $7,062,457 $1,659,417 $5,713,153 $9,489,327 $70,157,958 $3,892,802 $18,175,209 $5,895,390 $1,658,860 $1,476,067 $3,713,353 $7,125,661 $1,999,053 $10,799,488 $10,021,474 $2,175,779 $1,027,037 $1,720,299 $3,479,302 $6,385,073 $597,512,383 Appendix II (y) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Holding Companies and Subsidiaries 551111 Offices of Bank Holding Companies 551112 Offices of Other Holding Companies 551114 Corporate, Subsidiary, and Regional Managing Offices 56 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 0% 21 3% 200 20% 3,112 3,333 Potential New Wages $2,571,601 $25,741,299 $263,337,280 $291,650,180 Appendix II (z) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Administrative, Support, and Waste Management 561110 561210 561310 561320 561330 561410 561421 561422 561431 561439 561440 561450 561491 561499 561510 561520 561591 561599 561611 561612 561613 561621 561622 561710 561720 561730 561740 561790 561910 561920 561990 562111 562112 562119 562211 562212 562213 562219 562910 562920 562991 562998 Office Administrative Services Facilities Support Services Employment Placement Agencies Temporary Help Services Professional Employer Organizations Document Preparation Services Telephone Answering Services Telemarketing Bureaus Private Mail Centers Other Business Service Centers (including Copy Shops) Collection Agencies Credit Bureaus Repossession Services All Other Business Support Services Travel Agencies Tour Operators Convention and Visitors Bureaus All Other Travel Arrangement and Reservation Services Investigation Services Security Guards and Patrol Services Armored Car Services Security Systems Services (except Locksmiths) Locksmiths Exterminating and Pest Control Services Janitorial Services Landscaping Services Carpet and Upholstery Cleaning Services Other Services to Buildings and Dwellings Packaging and Labeling Services Convention and Trade Show Organizers All Other Support Services Solid Waste Collection Hazardous Waste Collection Other Waste Collection Hazardous Waste Treatment and Disposal Solid Waste Landfill Solid Waste Combustors and Incinerators Other Nonhazardous Waste Treatment and Disposal Remediation Services Materials Recovery Facilities Septic Tank and Related Services All Other Miscellaneous Waste Management Services 57 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 31% 438 12% 315 0% 351 45% 2,880 2% 2,875 17% 53 53% 49 32% 425 41% 18 12% 94 7% 200 0% 30 16% 8 15% 80 26% 129 4% 43 20% 15 8% 123 0% 61 0% 905 34% 33 24% 114 16% 19 21% 111 16% 1,132 18% 656 26% 42 35% 52 19% 54 0% 124 15% 208 72% 83 0% 14 16% 9 0% 33 98% 23 0% 6 0% 4 76% 57 14% 20 56% 16 11% 13 11,915 Potential New Wages $24,301,763 $12,234,356 $14,164,300 $89,759,597 $117,595,032 $2,357,201 $1,492,948 $14,480,524 $459,273 $3,793,960 $7,503,286 $1,194,066 $334,128 $3,419,095 $6,477,897 $1,799,457 $692,903 $5,462,405 $2,403,318 $31,387,413 $1,228,142 $4,636,616 $757,390 $4,451,285 $27,613,901 $28,686,137 $1,199,662 $1,744,037 $2,114,867 $4,982,834 $9,170,656 $2,868,716 $576,198 $382,078 $1,319,247 $932,535 $251,911 $164,325 $2,510,621 $793,413 $753,043 $538,885 $438,989,424 Appendix II (aa) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Education 611110 611210 611410 611420 611511 611512 611513 611519 611610 611620 611630 611691 611692 611699 611710 Elementary and Secondary Schools Junior Colleges Business and Secretarial Schools Computer Training Cosmetology and Barber Schools Flight Training Apprenticeship Training Other Technical and Trade Schools Fine Arts Schools Sports and Recreation Instruction Language Schools Exam Preparation and Tutoring Automobile Driving Schools All Other Miscellaneous Schools and Instruction Educational Support Services 58 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 67% 585 12% 107 0% 13 0% 24 0% 24 0% 23 61% 16 0% 109 15% 91 75% 95 0% 28 7% 131 18% 15 0% 45 11% 103 1,409 Potential New Wages $12,000,339 $3,928,687 $476,892 $865,511 $872,273 $868,457 $582,736 $3,984,605 $2,594,460 $2,503,734 $1,010,950 $3,630,821 $427,288 $1,628,184 $4,011,655 $39,386,590 Appendix II (bb) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Health Care & Social Services 621111 621112 621210 621310 621320 621330 621340 621391 621399 621491 621492 621493 621498 621511 621512 621610 621991 621999 622310 623311 623312 624110 624221 624230 624310 624410 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs Offices of Physicians (except Mental Health Specialists) 71% 910 Offices of Physicians, Mental Health Specialists 23% 45 Offices of Dentists 70% 359 Offices of Chiropractors 66% 60 Offices of Optometrists 28% 110 Offices of Mental Health Practitioners (except Physicians) 23% 90 Offices of Physical, Occupational and Speech Therapists, and Audiologists 42% 201 Offices of Podiatrists 56% 28 Offices of All Other Miscellaneous Health Practitioners 21% 48 HMO Medical Centers 0% 44 Kidney Dialysis Centers 29% 83 Freestanding Ambulatory Surgical and Emergency Centers 29% 109 All Other Outpatient Care Centers 84% 149 Medical Laboratories 6% 195 Diagnostic Imaging Centers 15% 116 Home Health Care Services 52% 706 Blood and Organ Banks 0% 103 All Other Miscellaneous Ambulatory Health Care Services 6% 86 Specialty (except Psychiatric and Substance Abuse) Hospitals 0% 338 Continuing Care Retirement Communities 7% 619 Homes for the Elderly 63% 174 Child and Youth Services 84% 52 Temporary Shelters 7% 90 Emergency and Other Relief Services 0% 35 Vocational Rehabilitation Services 62% 214 Child Day Care Services 57% 598 5,563 59 Potential New Wages $50,198,347 $2,357,381 $13,728,423 $1,729,548 $4,210,503 $3,392,029 $7,493,193 $947,697 $1,660,952 $1,896,491 $3,567,683 $5,544,226 $7,029,515 $9,656,596 $6,279,964 $16,837,525 $4,428,771 $3,980,690 $14,524,416 $23,962,344 $3,870,486 $1,654,803 $3,605,312 $1,500,125 $7,505,805 $10,893,972 $212,456,797 Appendix II (cc) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Entertainment 711110 711120 711130 711190 711211 711212 711219 711310 711320 711410 711510 712130 712190 713110 713120 713210 713290 713910 713940 713950 713990 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs Theater Companies and Dinner Theaters 18% 87 Dance Companies 0% 13 Musical Groups and Artists 7% 54 Other Performing Arts Companies 0% 14 Sports Teams and Clubs 0% 80 Racetracks 0% 72 Other Spectator Sports 0% 29 Promoters of Performing Arts, Sports, and Similar Events with Facilities 9% 134 Promoters of Performing Arts, Sports, and Similar Events without Facilities 23% 30 Agents and Managers for Artists, Athletes, Entertainers, and Other Public Figures 0% 27 Independent Artists, Writers, and Performers 10% 58 Zoos and Botanical Gardens 36% 32 Nature Parks and Other Similar Institutions 75% 7 Amusement and Theme Parks 9% 144 Amusement Arcades 21% 36 Casinos (except Casino Hotels) 0% 163 Other Gambling Industries 0% 85 Golf Courses and Country Clubs 15% 388 Fitness and Recreational Sports Centers 33% 543 Bowling Centers 97% 23 All Other Amusement and Recreation Industries 66% 46 2,065 60 Potential New Wages $3,756,205 $534,866 $2,471,738 $569,890 $3,369,731 $2,800,173 $1,205,226 $5,654,280 $1,160,221 $1,126,989 $7,192,654 $1,361,983 $307,419 $6,028,574 $815,306 $6,607,095 $3,516,178 $17,845,311 $5,765,745 $331,064 $1,054,278 $73,474,924 Appendix II (dd) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Food and Accommodations 721110 721120 722110 722211 722212 722213 722320 722330 722410 Percent Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs 91% 895 0% 590 77% 1,705 71% 1,453 24% 168 45% 436 16% 161 0% 10 86% 82 5,500 Hotels (except Casino Hotels) and Motels Casino Hotels Full-Service Restaurants Limited-Service Restaurants Cafeterias Snack and Nonalcoholic Beverage Bars Caterers Mobile Food Services Drinking Places (Alcoholic Beverages) 61 Potential New Wages $15,727,175 $11,525,748 $21,509,657 $19,499,331 $2,709,307 $5,875,758 $3,166,833 $207,438 $1,014,058 $81,235,304 Appendix II (ee) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Household Services 811111 811112 811113 811118 811121 811122 811191 811192 811198 811211 811212 811213 811219 811310 811411 811412 811420 811430 Percent Potential Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages General Automotive Repair 85% 81 $2,180,567 Automotive Exhaust System Repair 98% 6 $200,469 Automotive Transmission Repair 92% 14 $408,032 Other Automotive Mechanical and Electrical Repair and Maintenance 6% 29 $903,628 Automotive Body, Paint, and Interior Repair and Maintenance 64% 121 $3,699,943 Automotive Glass Replacement Shops 97% 15 $487,741 Automotive Oil Change and Lubrication Shops 7% 88 $2,087,688 Car Washes 23% 158 $3,157,078 All Other Automotive Repair and Maintenance 7% 21 $630,651 Consumer Electronics Repair and Maintenance 56% 19 $626,608 Computer and Office Machine Repair and Maintenance 19% 51 $1,883,559 Communication Equipment Repair and Maintenance 0% 30 $1,194,575 Other Electronic and Precision Equipment Repair and Maintenance 6% 55 $1,971,737 Commercial and Industrial Machinery and Equipment (except Automotive and55% Electronic)161 Repair and $7,421,758 Maintenance Home and Garden Equipment Repair and Maintenance 0% 7 $214,080 Appliance Repair and Maintenance 52% 20 $657,787 Reupholstery and Furniture Repair 33% 15 $467,610 Footwear and Leather Goods Repair 0% 3 $103,221 895 $28,296,733 62 Appendix II (ff) Job & Wage Opportunities in the North Country – Detailed Version Personal Services Percent Potential Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages 812111 Barber Shops 0% 21 $568,797 812112 Beauty Salons 55% 316 $5,537,219 812113 Nail Salons 3% 48 $1,311,893 812199 Other Personal Care Services 22% 107 $2,127,341 812310 Coin-Operated Laundries and Drycleaners 65% 28 $484,038 812320 Drycleaning and Laundry Services (except Coin-Operated) 25% 179 $3,662,940 812331 Linen Supply 96% 42 $1,315,115 812332 Industrial Launderers 40% 66 $2,073,270 812910 Pet Care (except Veterinary) Services 26% 59 $1,379,501 812921 Photofinishing Laboratories (except One-Hour) 0% 23 $724,376 812922 One-Hour Photofinishing 0% 3 $91,248 812930 Parking Lots and Garages 0% 190 $5,954,603 812990 All Other Personal Services 6% 75 $2,299,868 1,157 $27,530,210 Civic Organizations Percent Potential Potential Self-Reliant New Jobs New Wages 813110 Religious Organizations 53% 1,202 $16,997,473 813211 Grantmaking Foundations 40% 92 $4,217,617 813212 Voluntary Health Organizations 64% 42 $2,166,561 813219 Other Grantmaking and Giving Services 46% 26 $1,145,744 813311 Human Rights Organizations 77% 30 $985,236 813319 Other Social Advocacy Organizations 64% 40 $1,363,566 813910 Business Associations 44% 97 $4,889,470 813920 Professional Organizations 19% 92 $4,811,550 813930 Labor Unions and Similar Labor Organizations 96% 59 $1,402,064 813940 Political Organizations 7% 18 $614,219 813990 Other Similar Organizations (except Business, Professional, Labor, and Political56% Organizations) 122 $5,817,776 1,821 $44,411,275 63