Economic Policies of UK Coalition
Government: A Return to the Male
Breadwinner Model?
Diane Elson, University of Essex and UK
Women’s Budget Group
WISE Conference, May 24-26, 2011
UK Women’s Budget Group
• Network of about 200 academics, members of NGOs and trade
unions, mainly women but also some men
• Analysing gender dimensions of government budgets and
expenditure reviews since 1989
• Sharing results with politicians, journalists, women’s organizations,
poverty organizations
•
•
•
•
Voluntary work, except for part-time co-ordinator
Website : www.wbg.uk.org
This presentation draws on collective work of WBG
It focuses on mainly on taxation and welfare benefits, which are
determined by UK government.
• Regional autonomy in expenditure on public services, so will not
consider in detail
UK Budget June 2010
•
•
•
•
•
A few individual measures that help to offset gender inequality,
such as the increase in the income tax personal allowance, and the
exemption of low income workers from the public sector pay
freeze.
The budget taken as a whole is unfair in its impact on women as
compared to men. House of Commons Library research shows that
of the £8 billion raised by budget measures , £5.8 billion will come
from women and £2.2 billion from men.
No attention is paid to the need for women in couples to have an
independent income.
It runs the risk of fostering, in the long run, a fall in participation in
the labour market of women in couples.
But lone parents are penalized if they do not participate after their
children reach age of 5.
Changes to Child Benefit and Grants to New
Mothers
• Child benefit was a universal benefit, not means tested,
usually claimed by the mother of the child, and up-rated in
line with Retail Price Index.
• In June 2010 budget, decision was announced to freeze child
benefit for 3 years from April 2011.
• In October 2010 Spending Review, decision announced to
means-test child benefit, and withdraw it from any parent
living in a household in which some one earns enough to pay
income tax at the higher rate ( around £44,000).
• June 2010 Budget scrapped two one-off payments to new
mothers: the health in pregnancy grant and the Sure Start
maternity grant for second and subsequent children.
Changes to Child Tax Credits in June 2010
Budget
• In the UK, tax credits are income transfers that top-up low earnings, with
the aim of ‘making work pay’.
• They are means-tested in relation to household income, but paid to an
individual in the household. The system is complex and extends to middle
income households.
• Child Tax Credit is paid to whoever is nominated the main carer in the
family, most often the woman.
• Child Tax Credits reduced for middle-income families, with loss of
independent income for women, who may have a low or no income of
their own, making them more reliant on their husbands.
• If they have to pay for child care from their own pockets, they may no
longer be able to afford it and may be pushed out of the labour market .
• The increase in Child Tax Credit for low-income families boosts the income
of mothers if they are nominated as the main carer. However, the extra
£150 will quickly be absorbed by the rising costs associated with rise of
VAT to 20% in January 2011.
Lone Parents
• Budget June 2010 required lone parents to look for
paid work when youngest child is 5.
• At this point lone parents will lose Income Support, and
will be moved to Jobseekers Allowance, which pays
less.
• In 2011, Child Support Agency is being replaced by
Child Maintenance and Enforcement Commission. Lone
parents who use the Commission to enforce
maintenance orders will be charged an application fee
of £100 and between 7% and 12% of any maintenance
obtained.
UK October 2010 Spending Review
• Multi-year plan for large cuts in public expenditure on
public services- in real terms ,about 12% in total over
period 2010/11 to 2014/15.
• Likely to reduce services that enable women to combine
paid work and unpaid care.
• Office of Budgetary Responsibility estimates will reduce
public sector employment by 500,000.
• 65% of public sector jobs held by women.
• Spring 2011: Women’s unemployment rising , while
men’s is falling( though still remains higher).
• Rhetoric of the ‘Big Society’ based on unpaid volunteer
labour.
Budget March 2011
• Further rise in income tax personal allowance to £8,105 in 2012/13
• Will lift 260,000 people out of tax, 56% of whom are women.
• But will not benefit those earning below this threshold, 73% of whom are
women
• Commitments to tax breaks, promoting enterprise and improving skills.
• Attack on rights: ‘bonfire of red tape’.
• Hopes this will lead to job creation in private sector.
• If there is job growth in the private sector, it will not necessarily benefit
women: gender pay gap; less compatible with caring responsibilities.
• Investment in 50,000 new apprenticeships but no commitment to gender
equality in allocation or quality.
Welfare Reform Bill, February 2011
• Sets out proposals for Universal Credit: means-tested,
single monthly payment to household intended to increase
incentives to get one adult into work and to ‘mimic wages’.
• Strengthens work incentive for one working adult; but
benefit withdrawal rate will be faster for second earners.
• Maximum subsidy for childcare costs down from 80 to 70%.
• Single household payment. Couples can nominate who the
payment should go to; it will only be split in emergencies.
• Women manage budgets and day to day spending; a single
monthly payment makes it harder to budget on low
incomes.
Some Contradictions
• Male breadwinner households need male
breadwinner jobs- but will private sector
produce them?
• Two wages needed to buy a house- prices still
high, and required deposits have risen.
• Women value financial autonomy from men.