Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT What is Learning? Learning is gaining new knowledge, behaviors, skills, values or preferences. It may involve processing different types of information. Learning functions can be performed by different brain learning processes. It depends on the mental capacities of learning subject, the type of knowledge which needs to be acquired, as well as on environmental circumstances. Three main categories of learning theories: Behaviourism – a learning process which focuses only on the aspects of learning that are objectively observable. Cognitivism – a learning process that looks beyond behaviour to explain learning based on thinking. Constructivism – a learning process in which learner actively builds new ideas or concepts. Behaviourism As popularized by Russian psychologist, Ivan Pavlov and American psychologist, B.F skinner, Behaviorism Theory: Described as a developmental theory that measures observable behaviours produced by a learner’s response to stimuli. Responses to stimuli can be reinforced with positive or negative feedback to condition desired behaviours. Punishment is sometimes used in eliminating or reducing incorrect actions, followed by clarifying desired actions. The learner uses low level processing skills to understand material and the material is often isolated from real-world contexts or situations. The theory of behaviourism concentrates on the study of overt (obvious) behaviours that can be observed and measured It views the mind as a “black box” in the sense that response to stimulus can be observed quantitatively, ignoring the possibility of thought process occurring in the mind. The basic idea of behaviourism are: human behaviour is a product of the stimulusresponse interaction and that behaviour is modifiable Behaviourism is a learning theory that only focuses on objectively observable behaviours and discounts any independent activities of the mind. There are two different types of conditioning, each yielding a different behavioural pattern: Classic conditioning occurs when a natural reflex responds to a stimulus. Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 1 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT Behavioural or operant conditioning occurs when a response to a stimulus is reinforced. Behaviourism was the main approach in learning prior the 1950s. For behaviourism theory, learning is the process of acquisition of new behaviour based on environmental conditions. It relies only on observable behaviour and such that, behaviourism is a traditional approach of learning in which it mainly focused on behaviour modification with the use of “drill and practice” and also “reward and punishment.” Cognitivism Cognitivism focuses on the inner mental activities involving the mental processes such as thinking, memory, knowing, and problem-solving need to be explored. They (the constructivists) believe that knowledge arises from the interaction of a particular structure and a person’s own psychological environment. Learning involves the reorganization of experiences, either by attaining new insights or changing old ones. The key idea is to create a meaningful learning environment. As stated by Piaget, Cognitive development results from the interactions that children have with their physical and social environments. As a child explores his world, and eventually they began to discover that they hold a perspective of the world uniquely their own. Cognitive learning is the acquisition of knowledge and skill by mental or cognitive processes. It includes creating mental representations of physical objects and events, and other forms of information processing. In cognitive learning, the individual learns by listening, watching, touching, reading, or experiencing and then processing and remembering the information. Cognitive learning might seem to be passive learning, because there is no motor movement. However, the learner is quite active, in a cognitive way, in processing and remembering newly incoming information. Cognitive learning theories view learning as a process of understanding and internalizing facts and concepts about the world around us, each individual has a unique concept of things based on personal experience. These concepts are extremely subjective and very personal. Learning happens when the experiences grow. Cognitive theories attempts to answer how and why people learn by attributing the process to cognitive activity and take the perspective that students actively process information and learning takes place through the efforts of the students as they organize, store and find relationships between information, linking new to old knowledge, schema and scripts. Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 2 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT Cognitivism could be argued that this is the reason for the separation of schools into levels such as pre-school, primary and secondary. As Jean Piaget have classified in his cognitive theory of development, which emphasized thought processes such as thinking, understanding, and perceiving. Jean Piaget has stated that cognitive growth occurs through a series of stages, known as 'stages in development'. These are: sensorimotor (0 to 2 years), pre-operational (2-7 years), concrete-operational (7-12 years), and formal-operational (12 years –adult). The existence of these separate stages, has in it, own characteristic mode of thinking and the limitations involved. Constructivism We use Constructivist approach in our teaching: We need to use or reflect on the children’s experiences so that they can construct or build their own understanding. In this case, different people generates their own ‘rules’ and ‘mental models’ which is then use to make sense of their experiences. Therefore, constructivism is simply the process of adjusting our rules/mental models to accommodate new experiences. There are also several principles of constructivism: a) Learning is a search for meaning. b) Meaning requires understanding wholes as well as parts. And parts must be understood in the context of wholes. c) Teachers must understand the mental models that students used. d) The purpose of learning is for an individual to build up their own meaning/understanding. Constructivism refers to: the epistemological consideration focusing exclusively on the meaning-making activity of the individual mind It is a theory to guide understanding of how students acquire critical questioning skills It can become a guiding theoretical foundation and provide a theory of cognitive growth and learning that can be applied to several learning goals In constructivist learning environment, the role of the teacher shifts from being a source of knowledge to facilitating learning. Constructivism or Constructivist learning is based on students' active participation in problem-solving and critical thinking regarding a learning activity which they find relevant and engaging. They are "constructing" their own knowledge by testing ideas and approaches Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 3 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT based on their prior knowledge and experience, applying these to a new situation, and integrating the new knowledge gained with pre-existing intellectual constructs. The term refers to the idea that learners construct knowledge for themselves---each learner individually (and socially) constructs meaning---as he or she learns. Guiding principles in implementing constructivist learning In implementing constructivist approach in our lesson, we should bear in mind that: Learning is an active process in which the learner uses sensory input and constructs meaning out of it. People learn to learn as they learn: learning consists both of constructing meaning and constructing systems of meaning. The crucial action of constructing meaning is mental: it happens in the mind. Learning involves language: the language we use influences learning. It takes time to learn: learning is not instantaneous. Motivation is a key component in learning. The effective use of ICT in teaching and learning. There are evidences from numerous researches that ICT can help pupils to learn and teachers to teach effectively. ICT can be used effectively indifferent ways to improve the teaching and learning processes whether they are used by individual pupils, in groups and by the teacher to initiate discussion. ICT can also help to develop pupil’s thinking in a many ways including reasoning, understanding and creativity. Therefore, with creative approaches on ICT use, we can integrate the learning theories that we mentioned earlier in our teaching. Integration of ICT with behaviourism Behaviourism is one of the oldest teaching methods. It is characterized by rote learning drill-and-practice acquisition and a punishment-and-reward system of learning Behaviourism cares little about the mental processes that take place within the learner, who is considered a black box. The teacher plays a central role, being a master with responsibility for training the learner. Learning takes place in a highly controlled environment, through drill-and-practice technique. Learning using technology provides drill, practices, and tutorial using computer assisted/generated learning and the contents must be divided into several instructional steps from the easiest to the hardest. In order to improve the efficiency of learning, students are asked to repeat certain sections or do a diagnostic test. Students are expected to increase the skill through repetitive Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 4 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT practice with appropriate feedback. The messages of encouragement are used to increase learner motivation. For Behaviourism learning, it relies on observable behaviour. Behaviourism is often used by teachers who reward or punish student behaviours. Therefore, this type of learning can be used as a modification of behaviour. Teacher can use varieties of educational website or software such as spreadsheets, Microsoft word, Microsoft PowerPoint etc. This kind of learning is easier to conduct since it depends on the targeted behaviour. Teacher can directly identify pupils who have problem in their learning by looking at their performance in the activities given. Behaviourism learning is suitable to be used with lower primary as well as upper primary. What can we do about behaviourism in ICT is that; maybe we can use ICT as a reward for a good behaviour. We can give the pupils who get good grades and finish the tasks on time the opportunity to use ICT, for example, we let the pupils to play some educational games using the computer after they finished their tasks. Another example for using ICT in teaching and learning could be an online “gap fill” tutorial in a foreign language, as such learning English: students have to enter a word or phrase to complete the sentence (behaviour) and they receive an immediate response from the computer telling them if they were right or wrong (consequence). If they are incorrect the students will receive a hint or direction to the content where they can review the task. When they have consistently completed the exercise correctly they will be said to have learned and achieved the goal of the lesson. Integrating ICT usage with cognitivism In cognitivists’ view, mental activity is the primary focus of learning, where it measures by how one thinks and not how one behaves. There are 3 important processes when it comes into cognitive learning, which include: Acquiring new information Transforming old information to fit a particular task Evaluating or measuring to see whether the transformed information works. When it comes to technology, it is important to include specific principles: Interactive assignments. Moments of reflection Interaction with peers and teacher Problem-solving Levels of development Adapt to the learning styles of students Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 5 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT Be flexible and adaptive. Cognitivism theory and ICT Cognitivism learning can be acquired through listening, watching, touching, reading and then processing and remembering the information. Therefore, there is various range of software which can be used for this learning theory. For example, for the lower primary children, teacher can ask them to touch and identify the name of the computer equipments such as computer screen, keyboard, mouse, CPU and so forth. Through this kind of activity, pupils can touch, listen to the teacher and at the same time experience the learning by themselves and then the learning may proceed to process and remember the information. There are also some educational website which support and can be used for Cognitivism learning such as www.bbc.co.uk/schools, www.bbc.co.uk/science, http://nlum.usu.edu. Cognitivism relies on both teacher and learner. The teacher provides content and leads the learning. The learner is responsible for internalizing the material presented by the teacher Teacher can build meaningful activity using tools in ICT such as IWB, MS Office and so forth. Pupils can work with the available tools than can stimulate their curiosity and co-ordinate their sense of touch, hearing and seeing. In cognitivist model, learning takes place when the ‘correct’ materials are available to the learner and the teacher directs the learning. Cognitivism recognizes the individual differences between learners, each having preconceived ideas and preferred learning styles. Example of ICT activity in teaching Friction in Year 4 Ask the children to carry out an investigation into the effect of rolling a car down: a) Slopes with different surfaces b) Slopes of different elevations. Use a spreadsheet to record the results. Produce a graph to show results. Integrating the use of ICT into Constructivists’ approach How ICT is integrated in this theory? The Web is where constructivist learning can take place It provides access to rich sources of information, encourages meaningful interactions with contents and brings people together to challenge support or respond to each other. Here, the teacher is required to provide guidance or coaching to allow students to create their own meaning otherwise it does not guarantee constructivist learning. Example of activity: DFAQ (Dynamic Frequently Asked Questions) Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 6 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT The Dynamic Frequently Asked Question (DFAQ) tool was designed and developed as a special purpose question and consultation environment for students It aims to encourage learners to continually question thus they become lifelong learners. It provides an anonymous medium through which students consulted one another and with a teacher It is an educative, social and communicative space, which dynamically create a knowledge resource from student consultations Several advantages of DFAQ are: o Supports learning on and off-classroom o Consultations are anonymous o It is available 24 hours a day o It allows student the opportunity to learn from answers to questions that other students have posed. Constructivism theory and ICT Constructivism learning is suitable for high-ability pupils. It can be used for upper primary pupils. Since constructivism learning focuses on builds up knowledge based on experiences, therefore, it encourages pupils to learn independently. The effective use of ICT can help in the success of the learning. Pupils can use ICT to find extra information and relate it with their prior knowledge before construct a new knowledge. The use of programmes such as LOGO programming, Euclidean Reality and Geometer’s Sketchpad can be used for teaching Mathematics. These programmes are some of the examples of Constructivism learning. Pupils have the basic knowledge on shapes and with the use of the programmes; it helps the pupils to build up new knowledge by trying to draw shapes using those programmes. The cognitive learning also needed here, since the pupils have to reflect back their prior knowledge and practice hands on activity to construct new knowledge. Students will learn more because they are actively involved in their own learning process They are invited to perform investigation/exploration and find something by themselves. They are invited to interact with real environments and contextual, and therefore they will build their own knowledge. Moreover, students will learn to be active and will reach the ability to think critically and solve problems in a systemic / holistic approach. In the end they themselves will master the content as well as the processes. Constructivism in learning ICT: Learning through the internet, where pupils can explore and find the answers to some of the teacher questions. Using World Wide Web and search engine such as Google to gain more knowledge. Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 7 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT Using Enquiry where teachers can ask pupils a question and pupils try to find out the answers. Using some activities on the web such as http://www.e-learningforkids.org Conclusion: An increasing interest in constructivist theories has changed the reference paradigm within which the computer is considered for learning aims. The attention has been progressively focussed on the internal aspects of students, on their attitudes and behaviours and on the cognitive processes that are involved in learning interactions with the computer. One of the major forces which has driven change has been the assumption that meanings are lost if learning is simply seen as the transmission of information. Learning is progressively considered as being based on an active exploration and personal construction, rather than on a transmissive model. What are the advantages of integrating ICT into these learning theories? For Behaviourism, the advantages are that: Its positive and negative reinforcement techniques can be very effective. ICT can help pupils to enjoy their learning It can be used as treatments for human disorders including autism, anxiety disorders and antisocial behaviour. It is use by teachers to reward or punish pupil’s behaviour. It allows students of varying ability to work on exercises in their own time and at their own pace This way all students can achieve a similar level of competence and the teacher’s time is spent on teaching more complex knowledge and skills or focusing on student with particular needs It is more motivating than exercise books as they contain visual (still and moving images) and audio aids and are pleasing to look at and interact with The variety of written, visual and verbal clues can help students with different learning styles. Disadvantages in integrating ICT into behaviourism Behaviourism does not account for all kinds of learning, since it ignores the activities of the mind. Behaviourism does not explain some learning–such as the recognition of new language patterns by young children–for which there is no reinforcement mechanism. Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 8 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT Drill and practice does not concern on how students work problems out. What matters is they know the answers by rote learning. Students are not given the chance to explore things around them. As a result they will not know how far they understand certain things and the high-ability pupils will control the ICT activities. Advantages of using cognitivism in integration of ICT in the learning Cognitive learning is also a passive learning, because there is no motor movement. However, it makes the learner quite active, in a cognitive way, in processing and remembering newly incoming information. It also enables the students to create and transmit a complex culture that includes symbols, values, beliefs and norms. Cognitive strategies enhances learning because the effective use of such strategies minimizes the demands on working memory A student who is good at strategic learning may possess; o A broad range of strategies o Knowledge of when, why and how to use the strategies (metacognition) o A broad knowledge base o The ability to focus and ignore distractions Advantages in using constructivism in ICT The online environment provides opportunities for exploration and highly creative and individualised self-expression and for individualised learning, allowing students to progress at their own pace. It gives students access to a wide range of raw and real-world data which engages students in authentic learning tasks. It allows the student to be actively engaged with their learning and be at the centre of the process. These features of the online environment suggest that online learning activities designed using constructivist strategies highly effective. Disadvantages of using constructivism in ICT Not all children in the class have the same conceptual growth. Therefore, teacher needs to do extra work for preparing various activities suitable with the pupil’s abilities. Pupils with low skills in ICT will not enjoy learning and the more able students tend to dominate the activity, leaving out the less able students. Less able students tend to move away from the activity since they are not given the opportunity to give a shot. Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 9 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT In reality, creating environment, instruction, or activities that support student-centred learning are harder than just giving the lecture material to the students especially for old generation teacher. Problems also come from the students itself. Some students may not ready with this approach especially for passive students. Forcing the approach to this type of learner will only lead to poor outcomes. In my opinion, completely changed from the old teaching methods to the new teaching method (constructivism approach) methods cannot be done in full scale. We need to use combine the approach which will give active students the opportunity to build on their knowledge but also did not leave the passive students by giving them the lecture and also encourage them to become more active. It is Time consuming- to conduct this type of learning teacher and pupils need to spend more time. For examples: to find information, make hypothesis and testing. Computer ratios not support the pupil ratios. Limited computers lead to the failure of the constructivism learning. Lack of teachers’ ability in conducting ICT may hinders the constructivist theory of learning Lack of teachers’ questioning and answering skills may lower students’ confidence. This may include teacher’s content knowledge as well How can we relate this into the Brunei Context and with regard to the SPN21? The Ministry of Education’s Vision is: To transform Brunei Darussalam to a more knowledgeable, thoughtful, multi-skilled, competitive and smart nation based upon the teachings of Islam according to AhliSunnahWalJamaah And its Mission is: To enable access for all to e-Education by providing a strong foundation in ICT thereby promoting excellence in human capacity building. When we talked about SPN21, As we all know, ICT plays a big part in our life today. According to our SPN21, in order for our students to achieve success in the 21st century, they need to attain certain levels of mastery in the fields of technology and to acquire full understanding of any information that they acquire through various means. The aims for the learning outcomes: • ICT skills for creative learning • Obtain information • Analyse and process information • Present information Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 10 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT • Communicate electronically through the local and global network In addition, we all aware that at the primary level, the curriculum is now integrated across subject areas using themes and topics that are based on understanding, experience and the surrounding environment. The use of discussion forums, blogs, wiki and on-line collaborative activities can help the students to experience connectivity across the learning areas, learning with understanding and also made aware that ideas do not exist in isolation but connected. Examples of how these three learning theories can be integrated with ICT in Brunei context? ICT across the curriculum had been implemented to the primary school in Brunei. Therefore, all teachers of different subjects are encouraged to use ICT as their teaching tools. The implementing of SPN 21 in our education requires our young children to be skilful in ICT. In relation to this, teacher needs to be well prepared especially in technical skills and pedagogical skills. These three learning theories can be used as to cope with the pupils abilities in learning. Although our education in Brunei is more to exam-oriented but with the use of ICT, it might helps pupils to be more active and develop their thinking skills in their learning process. How should the teachers use ICT in Brunei context? Teachers should use interactive methods of teaching such as hands on activities and group work by using ICT so that pupils will enjoy their learning. Teachers should present students with challenges to increase problem solving abilities as in line with what is required in SPN 21. Teachers need awareness of how different learning styles can be used as a way to measure the ‘whole person’ rather than the small part of intelligence represented by IQ tests. MOE should encourage teachers to use ICT in their teaching and provide teachers with ICT training and workshops. Barriers in implementing these in the teaching From the teachers’ own experiences in conducting these three learning theories in teaching, of course they are some implications especially with the integration of ICT such as: We have limited computers for the pupils and some of the computers in schools are not working. We also have limited internet access. Not all schools in Brunei have a good internet access. Some teachers have to use their own broadband for teaching. Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 11 Seminar for Week 11: Learning Theories and ICT Some teachers have less support from the ICT teachers. When the teachers needed some help and cooperation from the ICT teachers, some of them refused. Some of them also dominate the ICT room and did not give chances to other teachers to use it. This can demotivate the teachers to use ICT in their teaching. The pupils must have basic computer literacy skills or otherwise the teachers might find it difficult to achieve their target in their teaching. Some teachers are also technophobia, they lack computer the much-needed skills to use ICT in teaching. Therefore, they need support to develop both technical and new pedagogical skills. As Brunei curriculum is still exam-oriented, drill and practice is still a crucial strategy in order to get the students move to the upper level. This is especially for Year 6 in which they are facing PSR. Not much activity can be done with them since they have to complete the syllabus before the event. Students are not strategic learners. They have to be taught how to use particular strategies. Some teachers do not browse for educational websites that can be used to support cognitivist theory of learning Insufficient facilities may prevent the teaching and learning using ICT Some teachers do not have sufficient knowledge in conducting such activity using ICT. This may be because they are too occupied with the traditional teaching strategy. They have lack of confidence in teaching using ICT. Therefore, they need to undergo trainings in order to be able to apply it with the students It is quite time consuming where teacher has to wait for students’ responds and the teacher may think that the syllabus may not be completed in time. Conclusion: Every approach has its own advantages and disadvantages. The best strategy that we can use is by combining those approaches to take benefits from all. How? It is very important for teachers for understand the basic concepts of information and communication technologies that can be used to enhance effective, constructive and interesting learning process. Teachers are also required to creatively mix learning strategies that take advantages of ICT, such as chat, e-mail, mailing list, blogs, presentations with PowerPoint slides, simulations, and others. Teacher should also be aware about student’s motivation and self-regulation because this will affects the outcome of the learning process. Done by: Norazlina (08B1035), Saifull (08B1036), Mudianawati (08B1040), Norfirzanah (08B1041), Tinidiana (08B1048). Page 12