1 Table of Contents Introduction……………………………………………………………………………..2 The Industry in Canada…………………………………………………………………2 Sony in Canada – An Overview………………………………………………………..3 Vision, Mission, Goals for the Company……………………………………………...3 Company Background………………………………………………………………..4 Current Annual Company Sales in Canada………………………………………….4 Company’s Major Customers and Channels of Distribution………………………..4 Target Market……………………………………………………………………………5 Company Official Interviewed………………………………………………………….6 Major Competitors for Main Product……………………………………………….9 Main Product…………………………………………………………………………….9 Direct Competitors………………………………………………………………………9 Market Share…………………………………………………………………………...10 Indirect Competition……………………………………………………………………10 Main Product…………………………………………………………………………..11 Description……………………………………………………………………………...11 Market Positioning……………………………………………………………….…….12 Pricing Theories and Strategies……………………………………………………...13 BRAVIA FABs………………………………………………………………………….14 FABs of Major Competitor – Sharp AQUOS………………………………………..14 Promotional Strategies………………………………………………………………..15 Promotional Activities of Competitors Compared………………………………….17 Buying Factors and Typical Objections………………………………………….18 Important Factors………………………………………………………………………18 Typical Challenges…………………………………………………………………….18 Dealing with Challenges………………………………………………………………19 Preplanning……………………………………………………………………………..20 Appendices……………………………………………………………………………21 Appendix A: Sony of Canada Sales Organization Chart…………………………..21 Appendix B: Sony of Canada Marketing Organization Chart……………………..23 Appendix C: Sony Location-Free TV Sales Guide…………………………………24 Appendix D: Sharp AQUOS Advert………………………………………………….24 Appendix E: Canadian LCD TV Market Share……………………………………...25 Appendix F: $100 Rebate Coupon for Sony Home Theatre Systems……………25 Appendix G: October 2005 Top 25 LCD TV Model List / BRAVIA Models………26 Appendix H: Endnotes and Bibliography……………………………………………27 Appendix I: Business Cards/ Documentation of Company Contact……………...29 2 Introduction The Industry in Canada With the end of World War II, as many people began to settle back into a calm, more relaxed life without the stresses of an ongoing global conflict and political upheaval, they looked to diversify their free time with many electronic gadgets available on the market. Though primitive by today’s standards, the consumer electronics industry presented customers with windows into the future. Things like telephones and record players had already become readily available, and now the television was making its way into the average Canadian household amongst other inventions. Since then the industry has expanded at a breakneck speed, providing consumers with more and more products and options. Today we need only to look at the composition of a typical Christmas wish list to realize how big and important the consumer electronics industry is in Canada. Products such as digital cameras, DVD players, ipods, and more are flying off the shelves only to be replaced with new models every year. Also, the industry is showing no signs of slowing down. A perfect example is the amount of times the standard formats of audio and video playback have changed since those post-war years, leaving us to repurchase that beloved Beatles collection on yet another form of media storage. The Canadian marketplace is dominated by 5 multinational corporations; Sony, Toshiba, Panasonic, Hitachi, and Samsung. Certain categories of consumer electronics, like personal music players, involve other companies in the mix, but the above mentioned firms are the overall leaders in the entire industry. Competition is tight with most of the products being sold through retailers such as Future Shop, Best Buy, and department 3 stores. Price is often the differentiation point as companies constantly strive to produce their products at lower costs. Sony in Canada – An Overview Sony’s history in Canada began in 1955 when Albert Cohen, an entrepreneur from Winnipeg came in contact with TTK Ltd. (which would later become the Sony Corporation) and began importing transistor radios from Japan. The radios were so successful in Canada that they propelled Mr. Cohen’s company, General Distributors, to success. Throughout the years that followed, the relationship between Sony and General Distributors grew stronger as the product line expanded. In the 1960s Sony created its own subsidiary under the care of General Distributors, and then bought out the company outright to establish Sony of Canada.3 In 2005 the company is doing extremely well for itself on Canadian soil. Of the five main consumer electronics manufacturers, Sony currently holds 26% market share and has been averaging 25% yearly for the last ten years. Currently, the company has just unveiled its newest line of LCD Television, named Bravia (Best Resolution Audio Video Integrated Architecture), which will be the focus of this report.1 4 Vision, Mission, Goals for the Company Sony of Canada is looking towards the future while building on its past successes and lessons learned. The company hopes to reach one million yen by its 50th anniversary in Canada and remain the leader in consumer electronics. Its mission: “To lead the Canadian market by creating and satisfying demand for superior-quality, innovative audio-visual and information technology products.”3 4 Company Background Current Annual Company Sales in Canada In 2004, total Sony Canada sales were around $1.425 Billion of which $1.14 Billion, or 80%, was generated by consumer electronics. This sector of the company experienced a 10% growth over 2003. The other 20% of sales came from other products Sony manufactures, such as broadcasting equipment.1 Company’s Major Customers and Channels of Distribution Channel of Distribution Major Current Customers Power Retailers Future Shop, Best Buy Department Stores Sears Canada, The Bay Specialist Stores Staples Business Depot Warehouse Clubs Costco, Sam’s Club A channel of distribution which is very important to the company but is not mentioned above because it is part of the firm is The Sony Store. Sony does not look to its 72 stores to generate most of its revenue but relies on them to provide customers with valuable information presented in a friendly, Sony-controlled environment, by very knowledgeable Sony staff. Hence, it is a very valuable marketing tool. Customers who visit the Sony Store will often make their actual purchase through one of the other channels of distribution as stores in those channels are able to offer lower prices. A product will be pushed through a particular channel of distribution depending on its position in the product life cycle.1 5 Target Market Portable Audio: With regards to portable audio, Sony targets both males and females (split equally) aged 16 to 34. Target customers have a higher than average income and typically hold a diploma or degree from university or college. They are tech savvy and musically inclined, living mostly in urban rather than rural areas. 1 Digital Imaging: The target market for digital imaging consists of males and females aged 25 to 44 with a higher than average income. Just as the target market for portable audio, they are tech savvy, hold credentials from a post secondary institution, and live mostly in urban centers. 1 6 Televisions: In this category, Sony leans towards the male customers when marketing its products, using such themes as watching the game with the boys. The age range of the target market is 25 to 54. It is a market with a higher than average income, typically college or university educated. However, women are very important to the marketing of televisions, as they influence 70% of TV sales. Also, they are being targeted more often with regards to LCD TVs, as the designs are sleeker and appeal to the home décor. 1 Company Official Interviewed Initial contact within the company was made with Mr. John Challinor II, General Manager of Advertising & Corporate Communications. Upon review of the requirements, Mr. Challinor decided that Mr. Mark Saddleton, Sales Manager of National Accounts would be best suited to answer questions related to Sony’s sales to distributors. Mr. Saddleton was interviewed and provided the bulk of the information, with help from Marketing Manager of Consumer Displays, Mr. Patrick Lapointe. (See appendix B) 7 Mark Saddleton Sales Manager, National Accounts AVIT Sales Group Sony of Canada Ltd Tel: 416 791 4018 Fax: 416 499 2093 Mr. Saddleton hails from the United Kingdom where he began his career with Sony UK. He was employed by the company for four and a half years and rose to the rank of Product Manager for Sony VAIO notebook computers. His responsibilities included pricing and positioning of the VAIO laptops as well as inventory management. Five years ago he was transferred to Sony Canada and began working as a Strategic Account Manager. In March of this year he was promoted to Sales Manager of National Accounts. He currently oversees two Strategic Account Managers, a Sales Representative, and a Sr. Strategic Account Manager. (See appendix A) Mr. Saddleton is responsible for managing all national accounts with Sony’s distributors. While his Strategic Account Managers handle most of the face to face selling to the retailers, he plans out the overall strategy for the accounts and coordinates their selling efforts. This is done through extensive data mining, reviewing sales figure and forecasts, as well as keeping up to date with industry trends. Mr. Saddleton sees himself in the business of ‘people management’. He reports directly to the Senior Vice President of Audio/Video and Information Technology, Mr. Martin Huntington. With regards to the company’s sales recruitment strategy, Sony brings in most of its salespeople from within the Sony Stores. This ensures that they are acquainted with the Sony culture and have had ample opportunity to familiarize themselves with the family of products. Once promoted, they become Retail Support Specialists (RSS), who train floor sales people in the other channels of distribution on the sales of Sony products 8 using such sales tools as product guides (See appendix C). They are also responsible for merchandising. Opportunity exists for promotion to Sales Representative, a position which reports to Mr. Saddleton as seen in appendix A. Sales representatives receive a base salary with a quarterly bonus program. Quarterly bonuses are handed out based on forecast accuracy and in-store activity for the Sales Reps and for in-store activity for the RSSs. 9 Major Competitors for Main Product Main Product The main product being focused on is Sony’s new line of LCD televisions, BRAVIA. Direct Competitors Sony’s top 5 direct competitors are: Sharp, Panasonic, Toshiba, Hitachi, and Samsung.2 These firms compete directly with Sony in almost every single product category. With regards to LCD TVs, Sharp has been the historical market leader, with over 35% of the market share in June of 2005 thanks to such successful LCD models as the popular AQUOS series (appendix D). The Sharp product enjoyed this position because of its superior picture quality and rave reviews. The other competitors, including Sony, hovered in the 3-13% range of market share. (See appendix E) In October of this year however, Sharp lost its market share leader position for the first time to none other than Sony. This unprecedented development is being attributed to the very successful launch of the BRAVIA series and the marketing efforts behind it. In the month of October, four BRAVIA models made it into the top ten models by sales, the KDL-V40XBR1, KLV-S32A10, KDL-V32XBR1, and KLV-S26A10.1 (See appendix G) Sony has also taken great steps to reduce the cost of producing flat panel displays by recently teaming up with Samsung in a 200 billion yen deal to construct a flat panel factory together in Korea. This will allow them to share some costs associated with production as well as take advantage of quantity discounts on the glass purchased.1 5 10 Market Share Canadian Consumer Electronics Market Share 2004 26.0% 29.0% Sony Toshiba Samsung Panasonic Hitachi 13.0% 10.0% 13.0% Other 9.0% *NOTE: The ‘other’ category includes Sharp Indirect Competition At the moment, the biggest indirect threat for Sony’s LCD Televisions are plasma TVs. This popular format is doing quite well especially in North America, although in Europe and Asia it is the LCDs that are coming out on top.1 Any company selling a part of the home theatre experience must be prepared to face indirect competition from other products which make up that home theatre. Many customers must often make the choice between a new television set and a sound or gaming system. Because of this, Sony must always be aware of how much money is being spent on televisions as opposed to other parts of the home theatre. 11 Main Product Description A Liquid Crystal Display Television is a television using LCD technology as opposed to traditional cathode ray or the now popular plasma technology. This technology utilizes two sheets of polarizing material with a liquid crystal solution between them to create a superior image and colour.6 7 In August of this year, Sony announced a new line of LCD televisions in its Trinitron brand category. The brand is named BRAVIA, which stands for Best Resolution Audio Visual Integrated Architecture, and features 7 models ranging from 26” to 40”. (See appendix G) BRAVIA offers a higher definition picture, clearer contrast, and a wider viewing angle. Also, with the new televisions, Sony has almost completely done away with the delay between turning on your set and the picture flickering into view.4 All models feature HDTV screen resolution of 1,366 x 768 pixels, 178-degree viewing angle, 8-millisecond response time, and 1,000:1 contrast.8 I chose this product because it is a brand new and exciting item, in a fast paced, innovative industry, being introduced by a market leader in consumer electronics. I have been a loyal Sony customer for many years and enjoyed the chance to learn about how the company works. 12 Market Positioning Higher End PRICE Cheaper Worse Quality Top of the Line SONY SHARP TOSHIBA PANASONIC HITACHI SAMSUNG In the LCD market, Sony holds a position which is quite high relative to its competition on quality and price. Sony wants to be seen as the choice which may cost you a little more than the competition, but is worth it because of the superiority of the product. For this reason, Sony targets people with above average incomes, something which is visible in its market communications as seen below. 13 Pricing Theories & Strategies 9 Company Pricing Strategy Sony Premium Sharp Premium Toshiba Premium/Economy Panasonic Skimming/Penetration Hitachi Skimming/Penetration Samsung Premium/Penetration Sony BRAVIA occupies the ‘Premium’ quadrant of the Pricing Strategies Matrix. The LCDs are priced 8-10% higher than the competition because of the premium offering of design and picture quality.2 Sharp is the competitor which prices its products closest to Sony’s. Sony also utilizes psychological pricing10, by setting their Manufacturer’s 14 Suggested Retail Prices such that a customer may perceive a price to be lower than it is. For example, a price of $3,499.99, gives the illusion that the price is lower than $3,500. BRAVIA FABs Features Advantages Benefits 16:9 Aspect Ratio Bigger Picture Compact flat-panel design Space Saving 178-degree viewing angle 8-milliisecond response time Screen visible clearly from many angles No delay between powering on and viewing picture 1,000:1 Contrast Ratio Clearer, sharper images Enjoying full film look and feel of DVD movies Aesthetically pleasing. Put in anywhere in the home. See the picture perfectly from anywhere in the room You don’t miss a single second of what you want to watch Enjoy breathtaking picture quality and don’t miss any details FAB’s of Major Competitor – Sharp AQUOS Features Advantages Benefits Detachable Speakers Customization of Home Theatre 20 years of 8 hour/day viewing with no colour degradation Connects easily with other parts of home theatre Modifiable to suit the conditions of your room Longer life of product 60,000 Hour Lamp Life Connectivity 170-degree viewing angle 800:1 Contrast Ratio Screen visible clearly from many angles Clearer, sharper images Compatibility with all your existing audio/video components See the screen from anywhere in the room Enjoy breathtaking picture quality and don’t miss any details 15 While both products are of high quality and premium price and boast some similar features, Sony has an edge on Sharp. It is a solid advantage coming in the form of better specifications. BRAVIA boasts a better viewing angle and a higher contrast ratio while its 8 millisecond response rate leaves Sharp in the dust. Sony’s competitive advantage is that it has created a superior product with many distinguishing features. Promotional Strategies Selling: Sales to retailers are handled by the sales representative and strategic account managers. They meet with the buyers to discuss new developments in their relationship, the re-stocking of current products, new product launches, and other issues. Product information brochures are often used to demonstrate and discuss product attributes and benefits, since it is often impractical to bring the product to the meeting, as in the case of LCD TVs. Advertising: The retailers Sony sells to, get most of their information about products from the sales people who visit them personally. Therefore there is not a lot of advertising aimed specifically at the distributors, since that would mean duplicating expenses. However, advertising which appears in consumer electronics magazines can be considered a form of advertising to distributors, since it is viewed as an unbiased source of information for the newest technologies. At times, this advertising takes on very simple tones, with its main goal to make potential buyers aware that a new product exists, as seen in the ad on the next page. 16 Sales Promotion: Sony does a very thorough job of providing its distributors with a lot of POP material, in-store information pamphlets, and discount coupons. (See appendix F) All of these play a strategic role in marketing Sony’s product in the store. Also, they help the retailer as they contribute to the store’s ability to provide their customers with information. Below is an example of POP displays for the new BRAVIA line. Unfortunately I was not privy to information regarding price discounts to retailers, though it was confirmed that some exist.1 17 Public Relations: Sony is an expert in the Public Relations game. After all, you don’t become a market leader without having a great PR strategy. Sony has a strong PR team which is always at the forefront of any product or line launch, as was the case with BRAVIA. The company commands a lot of attention with regards to any announcements they make because of their size and impact on the industry. Therefore, press conferences or launches put on by the PR department are very closely watched and anticipated. A perfect example of the integration of these functions was the launch of the BRAVIA line in the summer. Before the official launch and public awareness, the sales team visited the distributors armed with sales promotion tools discussed above, and ensured that the product would be in the stores and available after the launch. The Public Relations team then came out with press releases and a news conference to make the market aware of the new products available. The advertising was almost simultaneous so as to boost the awareness of the new line. Effectively, customers could go out and purchase the product soon after being informed of its existence. 1 Promotional Activities of Competitors Compared Sony’s main competition consists of large firms who, like Sony, have had a long time to perfect their promotional strategies and activities. With the passage of time, most promotional practices have become standard across the industry. Hence, Sony’s competitors use similar strategies to promote their top selling products. They share the same long standing relationships with retailers as Sony, due to the time they have been around and dealing with these distributors. 18 Buying Factors and Typical Objections Important Factors The first thing business customers consider when buying LCD Televisions from Sony or its competitors is the current market situation. Depending on how the market is doing, retailers will decide how much product they wish to purchase and from which company. For this reason, Sony salespeople meet with retailers every April, when products change, and present the products to them along with the market situation and Sony’s position within it. Other important factors are company performance and new product lines. A retailer does not want to stock the merchandise of a supplier who is doing poorly, as this will reflect badly on its sales. Conversely, carrying the products of a successful manufacturer will be beneficial to the store and its bottom line. New product lines have the potential to be a big boost for the retailer, especially if well marketed. This is due to the nature of the industry in which many customers pride themselves on being the first to own new models of electronics. Typical Challenges The first major challenge that Sony salespeople encounter with regards to BRAVIA and other LCD TVs is that retailers in Canada do not give these type of televisions priority. At the moment the HDTV and Plasma technologies are still more popular in North America and this means that LCDs have the burden of trying to catch up. Another objection faced by Sony is that its LCD TVs do not make up as big a part of TVs produced as other companies such as Sharp. 50% of Sony’s consumer electronics 19 produced are TVs, but only 10% of those are LCDs. Some retailers feel that companies who devote more resources to the technology may be better suited to provide the product. Finally, BRAVIA has the disadvantage of entering the LCD market fairly late. This presents a challenge when competing with brands who have established product lines and track records with regards to selling LCDs to distributors. Having already dealt with the other companies, retailers will often go back to them and make repeat purchases, something Sony must combat. Dealing with Challenges Objections relating to LCDs popularity compared to Plasma and HDTV are tough to deal with. Salespeople tackle this challenge by pointing out LCDs popularity in other regions of the world such as Asia. Also they compare the product directly to the more popular technologies, with feature comparisons which show LCD’s edge. When encountering objections related to the small percentage of Sony’s business spent on LCDs, they use such figures as seen in appendix G, which clearly show how well the new BRAVIA series is doing. It is hard to argue with hard figures which clearly show Sony’s success in the field. Sony has more than made up for its late entry into the LCD market. Objections dealing with this issue are countered with such facts as BRAVIA’s share of the market achieved in October 2005, only 5 months after its introduction. (see appendix E) These kinds of results show retailers that although new in the LCD game, Sony is a competitor to be reckoned with. 20 According to Mr. Saddleton, Sony’s biggest asset in dealing with challenges from retailers is being credible, not pushing too hard for sales, and never letting a customer down.1 Preplanning Before a meeting with a new prospect, salespeople go through a slew of preparations. The market is thoroughly researched and all current trends are identified. This information is then examined again to determine how it can be used to show Sony in the best possible light. Market share figures are reviewed and prepared to show retailers how well Sony is doing. The competition is also researched, so the salesperson can be prepared to answer questions on the benefits Sony’s products offer versus competing products. The company’s relationship (if any) with the retailer is reviewed, as well as the relationship with similar retailers, so as to show Sony’s strengths in dealing with these companies. Most importantly of all, the salesperson thoroughly familiarizes himself with the product he is selling and prepares brochures, POP material, and other product support info for the meeting with the prospect. He is then ready for the exciting challenge of winning over a new customer.1 21 Appendix A Sony of Canada Sales Organizational Chart 22 Appendix A cont. 23 Appendix B Sony of Canada Marketing Organizational Chart 24 Appendix C Sony Location-Free TV Sales Guide Appendix D Sharp AQUOS Advert 25 Appendix E Canadian LCD TV Market Share LCD TV Market Share (CAN$ amount) Sony attains #1 ranking in LCD in Canada for the first time thanks to Bravia! Sharp loses historical first place. 40” analog (KLV-S40A10) not even fully launched in the market (%) 35 Sony 23.3 % 30 25 Sharp 22.5 % 20 15 Panasonic 9.4% Toshiba 5.3 % Samsung 5.3 % LG 3.6% 10 5 0 Apr-05 May-05 Jun-05 Jul-05 Aug-05 Sep-05 Oct-05 Source: INTELECT Appendix F $100 Rebate Coupon for Sony Home Theatre Systems 26 Appendix G October 2005 Top 25 LCD TV Model List / BRAVIA Models LCD TV Top 25 model list – CAN$ base (Oct., 2005) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Brand / Model Name SONY KDLV40XBR1 SONY KLVS32A10 SHARP LC32DA5U SHARP LC37DB5U PANASONIC TC32LX50 PANASONIC TC26LX50 SHARP LC26DA5U SONY KDLV32XBR1 ACER AT3201 SONY KLVS26A10 TOSHIBA 32HL85 SHARP LC26GA5U SONY KLVS40A10 TOSHIBA 20DL75 PANASONIC TC23LX50 SAMSUNG LNR328W SHARP LC32GA5U LG ELECTRONICS RM26LZ50 SHARP LC20S4US SHARP LC37GB5U SONY KDLV26XBR1 SONY KLVS23A10 TOSHIBA 27HL85 ACER AL2671 JVC LT32X506 Can $ Can $ % UNITS UNITS % Ave. Price $3,000,177 8 738 2.4 $4,065 $2,045,934 5.5 857 2.8 $2,387 $1,760,217 4.7 815 2.6 $2,160 $1,470,657 3.9 492 1.6 $2,989 $1,366,023 3.7 605 2 $2,258 $1,140,296 3.1 703 2.3 $1,622 $1,087,424 2.9 740 2.4 $1,469 $990,274 2.7 311 1 $3,184 $769,023 2.1 557 1.8 $1,381 $704,711 1.9 381 1.2 $1,850 $652,918 1.7 336 1.1 $1,943 $527,767 1.4 427 1.4 $1,236 $495,972 1.3 156 0.5 $3,179 $503,062 1.3 687 2.2 $732 $444,721 1.2 335 1.1 $1,328 $404,112 1.1 177 0.6 $2,283 $398,133 1.1 212 0.7 $1,878 $349,945 0.9 252 0.8 $1,389 $335,861 0.9 412 1.3 $815 $324,055 0.9 118 0.4 $2,746 $332,206 0.9 138 0.4 $2,407 $320,528 0.9 197 0.6 $1,627 $329,745 0.9 210 0.7 $1,570 $307,688 0.8 315 1 $977 $294,643 0.8 141 0.5 $2,090 KDLV26XBR1 || KDLV32XBR1 || KDLV40XBR1 || KLVS26A10 26” 32” 40” 26” KLVS26A10W || KLVS32A10 || KLVS40A10 26” 32” 40” 27 Appendix H Endnotes and Bibliography 1 Saddleton, Mark. Sony of Canada Ltd., Sales Manager, National Accounts AVIT Sales Group. Personal Interview, October 21, 2005 2 Lapointe, Patrick. Sony of Canada Ltd., Marketing Manager, Consumer Displays LCD TV, Location-Free TV, Front Projectors Consumer AVIT Group. E-mail questionnaire, November 24, 2005. 3 “Sony of Canada History” Sony.ca. 2005. Retrieved 29 October 2005. <http://www.sony.ca/sonyca/view/english/corporate/corporate.shtml> 4 “Sony hopes fortune favors the BRAVIA” JoongAng Daily. 17 November 2005. Retrieved 21 November 2005. <http://joongangdaily.joins.com/200511/16/20051116215816210990009060906 1.html> 5 “Sony’s market strategy for TVs” CNET Asia. 16 November 2005. Retrieved 21 November 2005. <http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/home_av/tvs/0,39037594,39252757-2,00.htm> 6 “Liquid crystal display television” Wikipedia. 2005. Retrieved 21 November 2005. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_crystal_display_television> 7 “LCD” Webopedia. 2005. Retrieved 21 November 2005. <http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/L/LCD.html> 8 “Sony Unveils New Bravia Flat-Panel LCD TVs” Marketnews.ca. 19 September 2005. Retrieved 29 October 2005. <http://www.marketnews.ca/news_archive_detail.asp?nid=1161> 28 9 “Pricing Strategies” Marketing Teacher. 2005. Retrieved 29 October 2005. <http://www.marketingteacher.com/Lessons/lesson_pricing.htm> 10 “Psychological Pricing” Wikipedia. 2005. Retrieved 21 November 2005. <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_pricing> 29 Appendix I Business Cards/ Documentation of Company Contact