Unit Title: The Great Depression and New Deal Grade and Subject: Eighth Grade Social Studies Classroom Teacher: Debra Krawetz Unit Introduction In this unit, students will develop an understanding of the effects of economic hardships on Americans during the Great Depression. The students will examine the programs set forth in the New Deal, and debate the question of whether government has a the responsibility or authority to intervene to establish social/economic programs to improve the quality of life for citizens. The students will also discuss how the use of mass media (the radio and Fireside Chats) helped to communicate the plans of the New Deal, secure public confidence it, and calm people’s fears. 1. Standards and Benchmarks The student will understand basic principles of economic decision-making. The student will understand business organizations, market structures, and financial institutions that operate within our economy. The student will understand the economic activities of government. The student will understand the concepts that measure the national economy. The student will acquire skills of chronological thinking. The student will understand and analyze the economic, social, and political transition of the United States before, during, and after World War II. The student will recognize the importance of individual action and character in shaping civic life. 2. Enduring Understanding: The students will understand the economic causes and the social effects and hardships of the Great Depression. The students will understand how the role of government changed through the New Deal. 3. Essential Questions What caused the Great Depression and how did it affect people’s daily lives? How did the New Deal change the role of government and impact American lives? How did “mass media” help to communicate information to the public and quell people’s fears? 4. Summative Assessment Note: This will be introduced in Lesson One, and re-introduced and assigned in Lesson Ten. Option #1: The New Deal Debate: Did the New Deal “Solve” the Great Depression? Option #2: Does the federal government have the authority and responsibility to establish social and economic programs to improve the quality of life for its citizens who need help? Students will research and debate a position posed in one of the Summative Assessment options, choosing from Option #1 or Option #2 Time will be provided in class to research their positions Students will write a five-paragraph essay stating their position Students will present their positions to class 5. Formative Instruction and Formative Assessments –See unit outline and daily lesson plan 6. Differentiation –See daily lesson plans for accommodations for specific students. 7. Vocabulary/Academic Language List 1 1. Crash of 1929 2. Depression 3. Recession 4. Recovery 5. Black Thursday 6. Black Tuesday 7. Margin account 8. Buying on the margin 9. Mortgage 10. Foreclosure 11. Wall Street 12. Bull Market 13. Bear Market 14. economic hysteria List 2 1. The New Deal 2. Brain Trust 3. Fireside Chats 4. Tennessee Valley Authority, TVA 5. National Labor Relations Act, NLR 6. Social Security Act, SSA 7. Works Progress Administration, WPA 8. Farm Security Administration, FSA 9. Emergency Banking Act, EBA 10. Congress of Industrial Organizations, CIO 11. Farm Credit Administration, FCA 12. Federal Project One Civilian Conservation Corps, CCC List 3 1. Dust Bowl 2. Dust Storms 3. Route 66 4. Okies 5. Migrant Farmers 6. Hoovervilles 7. Shantytowns 8. Erosion 9. Irrigation 10. Black Sunday List 4 1. Franklin Delano Roosevelt 2. Hubert Hoover 3. Eleanor Roosevelt 4. Marian Anderson 5. Dorothea Lange 6. Woody Guthrie 7. John Steinbeck 8. Langston Hughes 8. Skills /Concept Concepts: End of prosperity Buy now, pay later The common good Individual Responsibility Federal Responsibility Natural Disaster Vs. Human Generated Disaster Skills: Evaluating primary source material and texts Comparing and contrasting primary sources Working Collaboratively Writing: Creative, essays, current events review, etc. Reading: Literal, interpretive, evaluative Creating a thesis and supporting it. Speaking, listening and participating in class discussions. 9. Resources Call to Freedom textbook, Chapter 24 or History Alive Chapter, Chapter 28. Handouts and web based materials included in this packet; see Daily lesson plans for specific materials THE UNIT WHY A. Why Care about the Depression? 1. The Great Depression was a period of worldwide economic disaster. In the United States, the crash of 1929 left many people destitute. Most Americans have family stories from this period that are shared with younger family members. 2. In a democratic nation, we have responsibilities to help those in need as exemplified in the programs of the New Deal. 3. Understanding the factors that can lead to a major financial downturn will provide students with a better understanding of how economics plays a role in our daily lives. B. What skills will students learn? 1. Analyzing the causes and the impact of the Great Depression and the of the New Deal 2. Empathizing with the experiences of others 3. Comparing and contrasting the different experiences of those who lived through this period 4. Drawing conclusions and forming possible new inferences 5. Understanding the sequence of events leading up to a situation or event. C. Why are those skills important? It is important to understand the role that the government can play in providing for the well being of all Americans. The New Deal established the principle of “federal responsibility” for maintaining a stable economy and providing for the health and welfare of citizens, and initiated the concept of government spending to help the poor. Unit Title: The Great Depression and New Deal Lesson Number: Lesson Title: Unit Title: Grade/Subject: Teacher: One Introduction Lesson The Great Depression and New Deal Eighth Grade U.S. History from 1880 Debra Krawetz This lesson will introduce the students to the Unit, The Great Depression and New Deal. This lesson provides students with many introductory and background materials to the unit, and it may take more than one day to teach. 1. Expectation: Students will be introduced to the new unit, take notes from an overhead, and answer questions relating to the idea of the government taking responsibility for the well being of citizens. 2. Engagement Display the overhead titled, “Overview of the Great Depression.” Read through the text while students takes notes on the main points on the transparency. OPTIONAL: Make a PowerPoint Show of pictures such as Hoover, Roosevelt, Wall Street, Migrant Mother, and hard times, news clippings, etc. and show it as you introduce the unit. Read the questions on the transparency, and have students discuss the questions with a partner/group and then write answers the (3) questions in their S.S. notebook. Share responses with the entire class. Present the transparency (handout #2) that asks students what they KNOW about the Great Depression, and what they’d like to LEARN. Allow them to work in small groups and then discus their responses as a class. Record their answers on a large sheet of paper. Present “The Unit Why” with the class. –Handout #3 Distribute the Vocabulary list to the class and go over words. –Handout #4. Introduce the Summative Assessment and ask students what they will need to learn to answer the questions posed in the Summative Assessment. 3. Exploration Working with a partner/group, students will discuss questions presented and explore possible answers. Students will examine what they already know about this period, and consider new areas of study that they would like to explore. Students will offer answers to the questions posed in the Summative Assessment. 4. Explanation The students will take notes, and then discuss and write answers to questions posed to them about “the responsibility of government” to its citizens. 5. Evaluation: These will be ungraded, but the teacher should walk around to check off that each student completed the assignment. Students will share their answers aloud. 6. Differentiation: For note taking, students who have difficulty writing will be required to record less information in their notebooks. Students’ answers will reflect their own prior knowledge and experiences. Enlarged copies of handouts and transparencies will be made for students who have visual difficulties. 7. Handouts and Materials Unit Overview The Unit Why? Know/Learn about the Great Depression Vocabulary Sheet. Summative Assessment -See Lesson One: Handout #5 Lesson One: Handout #1 Overview: The Great Depression The 1920s seemed a time when the United States was unbeatable, but then it all changed on October 29, 1929 when the stock market crashed. Billions and of dollars of stocks were lost, and the effects were felt throughout the country. By 1932 banks were closing daily, the lines at soup kitchens were becoming longer and longer, and more Americans than ever were out of work. After the prosperous 1920’s, few people expected this and it sent the country into a tailspin. By 1933, nearly 25% of the work force was unemployed and many families split up to find jobs. In 1932, Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR) was elected president, defeating Hubert Hoover. In his first 100 days, he created the “New Deal,” a program aimed at helping Americans survive the economic crisis. The New Deal created many agencies to help the poor, and to put people back to work. Discuss these questions with a partner, and answer each question in 3-4 sentences in your S.S. notebook: 1. Is the government is responsible for our economic and social well-being? (Explain your reasons why or why not.) 2. How should we help the poor out of poverty? As individual citizens? b. As a government 3. Today, what citizens in our country need more support? 4. Give examples of the “types” of support they need. Lesson One: Handout #2 What do you currently KNOW about the Great Depression? What would you like to LEARN about the Great Depression? Lesson One: Handout #3 The Unit Why? A. Why Care about the Depression? The Great Depression was a period of worldwide economic disaster. In the United States, the crash of 1929 left many people destitute. Most Americans have family stories from this period that are shared with younger family members. In a democratic nation, we have responsibilities to help those in need as exemplified in the programs of the New Deal. Understanding the factors that can lead to a major financial downturn will provide students with a better understanding of how economics plays a role in our daily lives. B. What skills will I learn? 1. Analyzing the causes and the impact of the Great Depression and the of the New Deal 2. Empathizing with the experiences of others 3. Comparing and contrasting the different experiences of those who lived through this period 4. Drawing conclusions and forming possible new inferences 5. Understanding the sequence of events leading up to a situation or event C. Why are those skills important? It is important to understand the role that the government can play in providing for the well being of all Americans. The New Deal established the principle of “federal responsibility” for maintaining a stable economy and providing for the health and welfare of citizens, and initiated the concept of government spending to help the poor. Before this time period, federal programs like this did not exist. Lesson One: Handout #4 Vocabulary List #1: The Stock Market Crash of 1929 1. Crash of 1929 The period from Sept. to Nov. 1929 when the stock market dropped violently 2. Bear Market When stockholders are selling in anticipation of falling prices. 3. Black Thursday 4. Black Tuesday 5. Bull Market 6. Depression 7. Economic Hysteria 8. Foreclosure 9. Margin account 10.Mortgage 11.Recession 12.Recovery 13.Stock 14.Speculation 15.Stock Market 16. Wall Street October 24, the day frightened investors tried to sell off all their stocks before prices fell lower/ October 29, 1929. This is the date of the most famous stock market crash in history. When stock prices are rising and are expected to continue rising. Period in the 30’s when business, employment, and stock values declined severely remained at a low level of activity. During the depression, a panic and sense of disorder experienced by stock and bank account holders afraid that their entire life savings was gone. The legal process by which an owner's right to a property is terminated, usually due to default. A brokerage account, which the brokerage lends the client cash. Buying on margin is a risky technique. A loan to finance the purchase of a home or farm, usually with payment periods and interest rates A period of reduced or declining economic activity lasting for about a year. an improvement in the economy marking the end of a recession or decline. A share of ownership in a company held by an individual investor. A financial transaction that involves potential risks with the hope of making a profit. General term for the organized trading of stocks through exchanges and over-the-counter. Financial district in lower Manhattan; street where the NYSE, banks and brokerage houses are located. Lesson One: Handout #5 Summative Assessment Lesson What will a great product look like for this assignment? –Show rubric Students will research and debate a position posed in one of the Summative Assessment options, choosing from Option #1 or Option #2 Time will be provided in class to research their positions Students will write a five-paragraph essay stating their position Students will present their positions to class Option 1: The New Deal Debate: Did the New Deal “Solve” the Great Depression? Position #1: Defend the New Deal The New Deal helped to solve the economic hardships that Americans experienced during the Great Depression, alleviating much of the economic stress that people faced in their daily lives and allowing the country to recover and get back to work. The New Deal prevented the economic and political collapse of the United States and created agencies to help prevent future depressions. Position #2: Oppose the New Deal The New Deal did not help to solve the economic hardships that Americans experienced during the Great Depression. The New Deal was a socialistic program that has overly expanded the role of the federal government. Too much power has been shifted to Washington, and too much money spent on its programs at a time that we should be reserving resources. Option 2: Does the federal government have the authority and responsibility to establish social and economic programs to improve the quality of life for its citizens who need help? Position #1: The federal should support the people who need help. It is the government’s duty to provide assistance to the underprivileged and those with fewer resources. It is the federal government’s responsibility to establish social and economic programs to improve the quality of life for its citizens. Government involvement in caring for the needy should be expected. Position #2: The federal should not support the people who need help. America is the land of opportunity, and individuals should “work hard” to improve the economic situation for their family. It is not the federal government’s responsibility to establish social and economic programs to improve the quality of life for its citizens. Government involvement in caring for the needy should be not expected. You will receive this Summative Assessment at the end of this unit. What questions will you need to explore to answer the questions and take a position posed in this Summative Assessment? Rubric for Summative Assessment Five Paragraph Essay for Option #1 or Option #2 Introduction and thesis Content Information Paragraph Organization and Flow Five Primary Sources - Explanation and Interpretation Conclusion Mechanics and Grammar Presentation of Position to Class Lesson Number: Lesson Title: Unit Title: Grade/Subject: Teacher: Two The Causes of the Depression The Great Depression and New Deal Eighth Grade U.S. History from 1880 Debra Krawetz 1. Expectations Students will… learn about of the factors and causes leading up to 1929 Market Crash, read and discuss news headlines from 1929, and examine how the news and financial industries created a “false sense of security” for people, denying the reality that a severe economic depression had begun. 2. Engagement: In small groups, students will read the handout on the Causes of the Stock Market Crash of 1929. Handout #1 Show graph of the decline of the market. Handout #2 Optional: Students will look at the textbook pages that outline reasons for the Stock Market Crash. (Call the Freedom, pp. 732-725 or check your school’s textbook.) Students will fill out a Cause and Effect worksheet or write in S.S. notebook in groups on the causes, reasons, and effects of the depression. Handout #3 Students will receive a document showing New York Times 1929 Headlines, Handout #4, occurring before and after the crash. They’ll read the list aloud with their tables.. Tell students, “As you read through the headlines, imagine you are an amateur investment group in that time trying to decide what to do with your money. Come up a plan based on the headlines, of how you will invest your money. Plans will be shared with the class Each group/table will share their plan with the class. Some questions you can present to the class about the headlines to have as a guide: Guiding Questions….. What did you read in the newspaper headlines in the summer and fall of 1929? What did you see that might have warned of the impending trouble? What were the different views on what is going on with the stock market? How do Babson’s and Fisher’s views differ? Whose view was more popular? Why? Why were most of the articles at the time more optimistic? Wrap Up Questions. Why was Babson’s advice (and others who warned people of the crash) ignored? What are (3) things you would like to learn about the Stock Market Crash of 1929? OPTIONAL: Red full texts of the BABSON and FISHER articles -PDF format included. Or read personal accounts of the market crash. 3. Exploration Working in student groups, students will list causes, reasons , and effects of the Stock Market Crash of 1929. Working in student groups, students will read a list of Summer/Fall 1929 headlines, and conclude based on the information what kind of an investment plan they should follow. . 4. Explanation Student groups will write out and then present their list of “Causes, Reasons & Effect” of the crash to the class Student groups will write and present their investment plan to the class based on the 1929 headlines. 5. Evaluation Student work will be un-graded. The teacher will walk around to see what the different groups are discussing and writing. At the end of the lesson, the teacher will walk around the room to check off each student’s work. 6. Differentiation For note taking, students who have difficulty writing will be required to record less information in their notebooks. Students’ answers will reflect their own prior knowledge and experiences. Enlarged copies of handouts and transparencies will be made for students who have visual difficulties. 7. Handouts and Materials Handout #1: Causes of the Great Depression Handout Handout #2: Graph of Stock Market 1920-1932 Handout #3: Cause/Effect Worksheet/Transparency Handout #4: NYT 1929 Headlines Lesson Two: Handout #1 Events that Caused the Great Depression The American public found the Three B's responsible for the crash and the depression: Bankers, Brokers, and Businessmen. Here are some other reasons: 1. War Debts: War debts form WWI needed to be paid. WWI Veterans demand their government war bonuses. 2. Unequal Distribution of Wealth: The rich got richer, the poor got poorer, but people’s wages stayed the same as prices for goods soared. The top 2% of Americans earned 28% of all income; 2-3% owned stocks. 3. Brokers Encouraged: Buy Now, Pay: Many people bought expensive items (cars, radios, and stocks) “on credit.” Buying stocks from a broker “on the margin” meant that the stocks were purchased “on credit” in the hopes that stock prices would go up. Brokers encouraged this practice. 4. Decline of World Trade: The market for U.S. good dropped, as Europeans consumers did not have enough money to purchase American goods. Concerned that U.S. goods were not selling well in Europe, lawmakers set high tariffs/taxes on imported goods. 5. Supply and Demand in U.S.: Over production in industry and factories dropped in the 1920’s. Americans bought fewer items such as cars and radios because they were worried buying on credit. 6. Farmers, Coal & Textile Workers Suffered in the 1920’s: The 1920’s were not a prosperous period for farmers, miners, and textile workers. Prices fell throughout the 1920’s and remained low. Some farmers lost so much money they lost their farms. 7. Weakness in Banking System: Banks had invested heavily in stocks so they suffered along with the small investors. Banks deposits were not insured (like FDIC today) and did not have money on hand when people came to withdraw their savings. 8. Stock Market Crash: The stock market reached a high point in September 1929, but on Oct. 23 the market dropped slightly. On Oct. 24 (“Black Thursday”) afraid the market would fall lower, thousands of investors sold their stocks off. Then on the Tuesday October 29, a day called, “Black Tuesday,” the market collapsed. At first, many people thought that the market would recover. Most newspapers features articles with quotes from “the experts” that led the public to believe the market would recover soon. Lesson Two: Handout #2 The Stock Market: 1920-1930s 1. What does this graph show about the time- period? 2. What accounts for the temporary recovery in Dec. 1929? Lesson Two: Handout #3 THE GREAT DEPRESSION Cause 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. Reasons for the Cause Effect Lesson Two: Handout #4 New York Times 1929 Summer & Fall Headlines Before the Crash... Wednesday, July 3, 1929, Page 31, Col. 5 SEES STOCK RISE JUSTIFIED Moody's Says Returns Are In Line With Industrial Activity Friday, September 6, 1929, Page 1, Col. 7 STOCK PRICES BREAK ON DARK PROPHECY Drop In Hectic Last Hour As Babson's Prediction Of A Big Slump Is Printed Page 12, Col. 2 BABSON PREDICTS CRASH' IN STOCKS Says Wise Investors Will Pay Up Loans And Avoid Marging [sic] Trading ---------- NOTE: Roger Babson was a statistician who predicted of a coming stock market crash. His views were not popular on Wall Street, but he was correct. FISHER VIEW IS OPPOSITE Declares No Big Recession In Market Is Due, Because Inventions Are Adding To Health NOTE: Irving Fisher was a Professor of Economics at Yale. He was quoted many times in the NYT predicting continued high prices and growth in the market. He was wrong! August 24, 1929 Stock Market Goes Up, Surprising Wall Street; Brokers' Loans at Peak Had Indicated a Drop -------------- 133,000,000 in brokers’ loans August 28, 1929 STOCK MARKET BEARISH THIS YEAR, SAYS BANK, FIGURING 60% OF LISTED ISSUES DECLINING -------------…The stock market of 1929 has not been so rampantly “bullish” as generally believed…. Lesson Two: Handout #4, p.2 September 8, 1929 FINANCIAL MARKETS; Stocks Move Irregularly With Both Advances and Declines --Sterling Unchanged. “Wall Street has a very natural dislike of making forecasts of an immediate decline…” ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- After the Crash Wednesday, October 2, 1929, Page 5, Col. 1 WARNS BANKERS ON CREDITS He Tells Convention Tendency is to "Pass the Buck" On Market Loans to Reserve Board ---------- CALLS THEM RESPONSIBLE ---------Not Reserve System's Duty to Assume Burden, Says President at San Francisco Meeting ---------- CONFIDENCE IS UNSHAKEN But He Declares That Some Institutions Are Overloaded At The Present Time Sunday, October 13, 1929, II, Page 7, Col. 2 STOCK PRICES WILL STAY AT HIGH LEVEL FOR YEARS TO COME, SAYS OHIO ECONOMIST FINANCIAL MARKETS; Stocks Decline Sharply as Brokers' Loans Reach a New Peak at $6,474,000,000 Acute weakness in stocks due to an expansion in brokers loans of $12,000,000., to a new peak. Wednesday, October 16, 1929, Page 8, Col. 4 FISHER SEES STOCKS PERMANENTLY HIGH Yale Economist Tells Purchasing Agents Increased Earnings Justify Rise ---------- SAYS TRUSTS AID SALES, Page 41, Col. 1 AYRES SEES MARKET AS 'CREEPING BEAR' Fall of Prices Began Months Ago, He Says, but Was Hidden by Rising Averages DECLINE IN AUTUMN USUAL Lesson Two: Handout #4, p.3 Recession This Season About 14 Per Cent, Against Normal Drop of 9, He Reports MITCHELL ASSERTS STOCKS ARE SOUND Banker, Sailing From Europe, Says He Sees No Signs of Wall Street Slump Tuesday, October 22, 1929, Page 24, Col. 1 FISHER SAYS PRICES OF STOCKS ARE LOW Quotations Have Not Caught Up With Real Values As Yet, He Declares ---------- SEES NO CAUSE FOR SLUMP ---------- Economist Tells Credit Men that Market Has Not Been Inflated, But Merely Readjusted “Fisher dismissed yesterday's break in the market as a shaking out of the lunatic fringe that attempts to speculate on margin. He predicted ragged market, returning eventually to further steady increases.” Wednesday, October 23, 1929, Page 1, Col. 4 STOCKS GAIN SHARPLY BUT SLIP NEAR CLOSE Vigorous Recovery Marks Most of Day and Many Issues Show Net Advances ---------MARKET GLOOM LESSENED ---------- October 5, 1929 FINANCIAL MARKETS; Stocks Decline Sharply, as Trading Volume Increases Margin Accounts Impaired ------------------------October 20, 1929 FINANCIAL MARKETS; Stocks Sweep Downward Under Heavy Liquidation--Trading Almost at Record Pace. ---------------------------------------Friday, November 1, 1929, Page 3, Col. 3 SISSON DECRIES INFLATION Lays Crash to Small Investors' Lack of Experience Lesson Two: Handout #4, p.4 Thursday, December 19, 1929, Page 36, Col. 1 LAYS STOCK BREAKS TO MOB PSYCHOLOGY W.W. Price Says Crashes Will Come So Long as Facilities for Speculation Exist. Wall Street Headlines, Spring & Fall 1929 Note: Immediately after the market opened on the Black Thursday, October 24, 1929, prices began to slump so fast that all the profit and gain made in the previous year was wiped out. During the period form October 24 to November 13, 1929, $30 billion was lost permanently by the United economy. One lone voice was publicly warning of a gigantic stock market crash, the market analyst, Roger Babson. However, the oracle of disaster was shouted down and scoffed by a chorus of Wall Street brokerage houses. Furthermore, the self-proclaimed market guru, Economist Irving Fisher also took issue with Babson's prediction of a market debacle, saying, “There may be a recession in stock prices, but not anything in the nature of a crash.” Photo: People on Wall St. scurrying to sell their stocks and recover their money. Cartoon: Rollin Kirby, 1929 Repercussions of the Stock Market Crash Lesson Two: Handout #5, p 1 Stock Buying Activity Select stocks to buy plan based on NYT 1929 Headlines Referring to the articles published before Black Thursday…. IMAGINE that you are an “amateur” investment club deciding how to invest $100,000 with a broker from the “People’s Bank.” The time is early September of 1929, just a few weeks before the crash. INFORMATION: The date is September 1, 1929 Your club/group has a day to decide what stocks to buy You have $100,000 in your portfolio to spend Stocks are sold in $100 lot shares only You can buy some or all of the 12 stocks listed the next page. You can also keep some of the money in a bank account. TASK: As a group, decide on how you will invest your $100,000. What stocks do you think will be good investments? Why? *The stock list is attached to this sheet. NOTE: You may look at articles on Historic NYT or Historic Wall Street Journal but you may not look for dates after Black Thursday, September 24, 1929. Lesson Two: Handout #5, p 2 Stock Buying Activity Directions: You have $100,000 to invest. Choose stocks and the number of shares your club wants to buy. List the reason why you think the stock would be a good investment. Name of Stock # of $100. Reason for buying this stock? Lot Shares Ex. Eastman Kodak 100 Lot Shares Price/share up 2 years in a row. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. Leave for other purpose Total = $10,000 Total Amount $10,000 Signatures /Club Members: Date Signature: People’s Bank Broker: Lesson Two: Handout #6 -Optional Photo images following the Stock Market Crash on Black Tuesday, October 29, 1929 Write a ONE full paragraph news article describing what is going on in each photo. Answer the 5-W’s in each paragraph. QuickTime™ and a TIFF (LZW) decompressor are needed to see this picture. Image #1: The Rush to withdraw their Savings from a bank, October 1929. QuickTime™ and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture. Image #2: Trying to cover his Wall Street losses, this man attempts to sell his roadster on NYC streets for $100 cash. Image #3: People crowd Wall Street after the Stock Market Crash of 1929. Lesson Two: Handout #7 -Optional Personal Account of the Stock Market Crash, October 1929 -Anonymous Source: DISCovering US *Margin account = buying on credit I came into the business, out of the University of Chicago, about Christmas 1924. I had about $3,000 in the stock market, which was all the money I had. On Black Friday--Thursday, was it?--that margin account went out of the window. I may have had about $62 left. My wife had a colossal $125 a week job with a Shakespearean theater company. That night, she came home to our little apartment, and she said, “Guess what happened today?” I said, "What?" She said, "I quit." I was making about $60 a week and she was making $125. Two-thirds of our income and all of our savings disappeared that day. I was a margin clerk. He's a man who keeps the figures on individual accounts if they're carrying stocks on margin--that is, if they're carrying stocks without paying for them. When the break started, you had a deluge of selling, from weakened margin accounts. We had to stay up all night figuring. We'd work till one o'clock and go to the LaSalle Hotel and get up about five and get some breakfast and continue figuring margin accounts. 'Cause everybody was in trouble. But everybody. The guy I worked for was sitting in the wire room, watching the tape. The tape was something to see, because Radio Corporation, let's say, would be ninety-five on the tape ... they'd flash you sixty on the floor. The floor was a madhouse. I said to him: "Are we solvent?" He says, "I won't know till about twelve tonight." He was half-serious. It was brutal. The Crash--it didn't happen in one day. There were a great many warnings. The country was crazy. Everybody was in the stock market, whether he could afford it or not. Shoeshine boys and waiters and capitalists. ... A great many holding company pyramids were unsound, really fictitious values. Mr. Insull was a case in point. It was a mad dream of get-rich-quick. It wasn't only brokers involved in margin accounts. It was banks. They had a lot of stinking loans. The banks worked in as casual a way as the brokers did. And when they folded. ... I had a friend in Cincinnati who was young and attractive. He had a wife and children and he was insured for $100,000. Life was over as far as he was concerned. He took a dive, to take care of his wife and kids. There was a number who took the dive, to collect on insurance policies. It’s unthinkable now, when you know how many people have been able to come back. There were others that impress me. I kept hearing about town that their businesses were in trouble. But they never lowered their standard of living a bit. They lived like kings, right through the Depression. I’ve never been able to figure this out. I knew some people who maintained their Lake Shore Drive apartments and cars, and everybody knew they were in trouble. I never knew how they did it, and I didn't care particularly. My friends and I were all broke, and we had no pretensions. You had no governmental control of margins, so people could buy on a shoestring. And when they began pulling the plug ... you had a deluge of weakness. You also had short-selling and a lack of rules. There were many cases of staid, reputable bankers making securities available on special deals--below the market price--for their friends. Anything went, and everything did go. Today, there are very few bankers of any repute who have objected to the Securities Exchange Commission. They believe that the regulation in 1933 was a very, very sound thing for our business. History See: http://galenet.galegroup.com/servlet/HistRC/ Lesson Number: Three Lesson Title: The 1932 Election Unit Title: The Great Depression and New Deal Grade/Subject: Eighth Grade U.S. History from 1880 Teacher: Debra Krawetz 1. Expectations Students will learn about the candidates and issues involved in the 1932 Presidential election. Students will read and listen to an audio excerpt of a speech given by Herbert Hoover in Oct. 1932 and discuss the themes conveyed in his address. Students will write a letter to President Hoover explaining to him how difficult their daily lives have become since the depression hit. . 2. Engagement Distribute the handout (Lesson Three: Handout #1) on the election and 1932 and read it aloud together. Ask the students: these questions: How do Hoover and Roosevelt differ? Why was Hoover blamed for the Great Depression? Do you think that anyone felt that Roosevelt’s polio would present challenges to him? How could it work to his favor? Play the speech (Lesson Three: Handout #2) excerpt on audio of Hoover’s Oct. 1932 address. Tell students, Hoover maintained in March of 1930, that the worst had passed, but the economic situation only got worse. Audio at: http://historymatters.gmu.edu/d/5062/ Why did Hoover think that America would recover quickly from the 1929 depression? Go over the three quotes by Hoover at the bottom of the page on Handout #2. Read the anonymous letter to President Hoover aloud with the class. Activities: Option 1: Students can write a letter to President Hoover from the perspective of a homeless person living in a Hooverville camp, telling Hoover about the troubles in their life and what they feel should be done. Option 2: Students can draw 4 pictures (1928, 1929, 1930, & 1932) with captions that show Hoover’s attitudes about the economy and helping the poor. –Refer to the 4 quotes at the bottom of Handout #4, and illustrate each quote. 3. Exploration Students will be told that they will read information about the 1929 election and an excerpt from a Hoover speech from Oct. 1932. During the reading, the students will be asked specific question listed above. After this, the students will apply this information to a letter that they will write to President Hoover. 4. Explanation After the information about the 1932 election and the speech are discussed, each student will write a letter to President Hoover, pretending that they are an unemployed worker in the early 1930’s. In the letter, students will show and provide specific examples of what life was like at that time, and difficulties their family is experiencing. 5. Evaluation The teacher will grade the letters or drawings that the student create. Students will share their letters at the end of class. The work will be collected, and will be graded on the following criteria: 1. 2. 3. 4. Demonstrates an understanding of period. Shows Empathy New vocabulary Usage Grammar/Spelling. 6. Differentiation For note taking, students who have difficulty writing will be required to record less information in their notebooks. Students’ written work will reflect their own prior knowledge and experiences. Enlarged copies of handouts and transparencies will be made for students who have visual difficulties. Allow students the choice of completing the letter or drawing activity. 7. Resources http://www.fdrlibrary.marist.edu/ http://www.whitehouse.gov/history/presidents/fr32.html http://www.whitehouse.gov/history/presidents/hh31.html Lesson Three: Handout #1 Presidential Election of 1932 HOOVER b. 1874 d. 1964 ROOSEVELT b. 1882 d. 1945 Incumbent/ Republican Herbert Hoover Challenger/ Democrat Franklin Delano Roosevelt 31st President, won 59 electoral votes 32nd President, won 472 electoral votes. Policies Hoover believed in lowering taxes and he refused to give out any national welfare, believing it demeaned proud Americans. His view was that while people must not suffer from hunger and cold, but caring for them must be a local and voluntary responsibility, not that of the federal government. Bio Herbert Clark Hoover was born in Iowa into in a poor family and felt that Americans should work hard the way he did. He studied engineering at Stanford University before he got into politics. After serving as Secretary of Commerce under Presidents Harding and Coolidge, he became the Republican Presidential candidate in 1928. Policies FDR, promoted a platform with Three R’s: Relief, Recovery, and Reform. He introduced the New Deal saying: “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people.” However, he said little about the specifics of his plan. He felt that it was the federal government’s responsibility to care for the poor. Bio Franklin Delano Roosevelt was born into a wealthy New York family. He went to Harvard University, and Columbia Law School. He was married to Eleanor who became a very active first lady during his four terms in office. He was a fiscal conservative who opposed payments to the poor because he felt it created a dependency on a welfare system. He cited the importance of a balanced budge and low taxes. Homeless people began to make camps on the outskirts of cites and called them “Hoovervilles,” named after President Hoover who they blamed for the depression. He served one term after being defeated in 1932 by FDR. Many critics believe that Hoover failed to recognize the severity of the depression . Although he was stricken with polio in 1921, he did not give up his desire to be active in politics. In 1928, he was elected governor of NY, and in 1932 won the presidential election in a landslide victory. He took the first 100 days to develop a New Deal plan. The federal government paid for theses programs by raising taxes and by spending more money then it took in. FDR was reelected for four terms and died in office in 1945. FDR, a popular president, was a good communicator who reassured people during hard times. Lesson Three: Handout #2 Electoral College Results: Election of 1932 Herbert Hoover (Incumbent): Votes Franklin Roosevelt (Challenger): Votes 59 Electoral 472 Electoral Lesson Three: Handout #3 Hoover Insists That Things are Getting Better “The Gigantic Forces of Depression are Today in Retreat” –Excerpt of a speech from Oct. 22, 1932 in Detroit Michigan *Herbert Hoover Library To win reelection in 1932, Hoover would have to convince voters that his policies were bringing recovery. In this excerpt from an Oct. 22, 1932, campaign speech Hoover told a partisan crowd of twenty-two thousand in Detroit that success would have come even sooner if not for Democratic obstruction. In this speech, the audiences heard Hoover hail ten sure signs of “economic recovery.” Play Audio Speech: http://historymatters.gmu.edu/d/5062/ Herbert Hoover’s Speech: My fellow citizens, the most important issue before the American people right now is to overcome this crisis. What our people need is the restoration of their normal jobs, the recovery of agricultural prices and of business. They need help in the meantime to tide them over until these things can be accomplished and that they may not go hungry nor lose their farms and their homes. Now I wish to present to you the evidence that the measures and the policies of the Republican administration are winning this major battle for recovery, and we are taking care of distress in the meantime. It can be demonstrated that the tide has turned and that the gigantic forces of depression are today in retreat. Our measures and policies have demonstrated their effectiveness. They have preserved the American people from certain chaos. They have preserved a final fortress of stability in the world. Recovery would have been faster but for four months of paralysis during the spring months while we were defeating proposals of the Democratic House of Representatives. Much has been accomplished despite the opposition of selfish groups and sections of our country and the unwillingness of a Democratic House of Representatives to cooperate, and much more must be done. The Democratic candidate says we have been extravagant, and in his various statements implies that we should make a defense of our actions. There will be no defense because none is needed. Hoover Quotes: August 11, 1928: “Unemployment in the sense of distress is widely disappearing. . . We in America today are nearer to the final triumph over poverty than ever before in the history of any land. The poorhouse is vanishing from among us. … There is no guarantee against poverty equal to a job for every man. That is the primary purpose of the economic policies we advocate” November, 1929: “Any lack of confidence in the economic future or the basic strength of business in the United States is foolish.” March 8, 1930: “Today the worst effect of the crash upon unemployment will have been passed during the next sixty days.”1932: “The government should not support the people.”…. and its role should no “be extended to the relief of individual suffering.” Lesson Three: Handout #4 An Anonymous Letter to Herbert Hoover November 18, 1930 Could we not have employment and food to Eat. and this for our Children Why Should we hafto [illegible] now and Have foodless days and [illegible] days. and our children have Schoolless days and Shoeless days and the land full of plenty and Banks bursting with money. Why does Every Thing have Exceptional Value. Except the Human being--why are we reduced to poverty and starving and anxiety and Sorrow So quickly under your administration as Chief Executor Can not you find a quicker way of Executing us than to Starve us to death. . . . Why not End the Depression have you not a Heart. . . . Yet we are served from the Source of Life by setch an unjust System. . . . Why Isnt there an limitation to you people planning to get It all and Starve the rest of use. . . . Yet you have cut us of with plenty before our eyes--for your Selves. Yet You Can not use It. The people are desperate and this I have written, only typical of the masses of your Subjects. how can we be Law abiding citizens and Educate our children and be Happy Content with nothing to do nothing to Eat. when your System has Every Thing under control and cant use It. nor will you give any thing a way. why take more than you need. why make Laws. and allow Industry to take It all. why Isnt the Law fixed so Its Just as Just for one or the others then Industry couldnt take it all. and make us all victims of your Special arrangement. of things. . . . I am an Ignorant man and you are Supposed to have great Brains yet I appeal to you In behalf of thousands In your dominion who would be good americans Citizins If you would make It Possible. -Anonymous Lesson Three: Handout #5 -Optional Hoovervil les were homeless camps built on the outskirts of cities to house the poor, This term was named after President Hoover who was blamed for the problems that led to the Great Depression. QuickTime™ and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture. ASSIGNMENT Write a 3-Paragraph letter to President Hoover, pretending that you are an unemployed worker in the early 1930’s living in a Hooverville. In your letter, provide specific examples of what life is like for you and the troubles your family faces.