Press release 17 July 2009 12:00 UK time.
Cooking with sound — Score Stove enters test stage
A low-cost generator with the potential to transform lives in the world’s poorest communities is now
being tested across the UK and in Nepal. The Score project, led by The University of Nottingham in
the UK, is developing a bio-mass burning cooking stove which also converts heat into acoustic energy
and then into electricity, all in one unit.
The £2m Score Stove (for Cooking, Refrigeration and Electricity) project brings together experts from
across the world to develop the biomass-powered generator. By developing an affordable, versatile
domestic appliance Score aims to address the energy needs of rural communities in Africa and Asia,
where access to power is extremely limited.
Researchers in the Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering at the University of
Nottingham are working on the generator’s Linear Alternator — the part which turns the sound
energy into electricity. The system uses special configurations of magnets which generate electrical
energy from sound. Computer simulations of the linear alternator have proved successful, and test
models are currently being constructed in the department’s workshops.
Nottingham researchers are working with Dai-ichi, one of Malaysia’s largest loudspeaker
manufacturers, to bring down production costs through good design practice. Though the Score unit
does not physically resemble the average loudspeaker, it is compatible with the Dai-ichi
manufacturing process.
The research team at City University London are working on the actual stove design and the thermoacoustic engine. The team has developed a low cost, repeatable, stove manufacturing technique which
is currently being tested in the laboratory and in communities in Nepal. Early results are highly
encouraging and further tests are planned in Nepal and Kenya. City University London is also
assisting with the structural analysis of the thermo-acoustic engine and the development of low cost
manufacturing methods for the engine components.
Ron Dennis, one of the researchers at City University London, has spent over 20 years developing
appropriate technology for the developing world and also coordinates the activities of the charity,
“Developing Technologies”, based at City University London.
Ron says, “The Score project brings the possibility of a new solution to meet the demand for electrical
power in rural areas and will promote the uptake of clean stoves as a major side benefit. Solar voltaics
are the only other real alternative at present, but Score offers the possibility of generating electrical
power at the time of need and at an affordable cost.”
The University of Manchester contribution is being headed up by Dr Artur Jaworski, an expert in
thermo-acoustic engineering in The School of Mechanical, Aerospace and Civil Engineering
(MACE). He is leading vital research into the design of the thermo-acoustic engine that will sit at the
heart of the appliance.
The technology demonstrator being developed at Manchester already delivers five Watts of electricity
and will be scaled up in the coming months. Preliminary test results are being presented at the 7th
International Energy Conversion Engineering Conference in Denver next month. [August 2009]
Dr Artur Jaworski said: “The Score project brings the possibility of a new solution to meet the
demand for electrical power in rural areas and will promote the uptake of clean stoves as a major side
benefit. It offers the possibility of generating electrical power at the time of need and at an affordable
cost.”
Researchers in the School of Engineering and Materials Science at Queen Mary University of
London are working on the heat transfer aspects of the device. In the basic design, two heat
exchangers produce a temperature gradient in a porous material in which some of the thermal energy
is converted into sound. One heat exchanger takes heat from a wood-burning stove: the other rejects a
slightly smaller amount to a hot-water store, or makes use of it in some other way. The sound is then
turned into electricity by a ‘linear alternator’.
Professor Chris Lawn commented: “There are many ways in which conventional technology makes
this possible. However, the emphasis here is on doing it in a design which is potentially cheap and
robust, with virtually no need for maintenance. Moreover, heat transfer to the oscillating flows
associated with sound waves is not well-characterised, so we are building a rig with some prototype
components to confirm our calculations.”
Dr Cat Gardner, who is responsible for building the rig, added: “A significant challenge is generating
the high intensity sound, to acoustically excite the complete device, which will occur naturally in the
finished product. With help from Pioneer, a drive system consisting of two mega sub-woofers has
been devised that will give us the acoustic power required to fully test the heat exchanger
performance”
Teo Sanchez, Practical Action's Energy Policy Adviser, said:
"With more than 1.6 billion people in the developing world relying on biomass - including low grade
fuels such as wood or dung - the Score project is providing valuable lessons in how to convert these
into energy and electricity. For a number of years Practical Action has been exploring with
communities how cleaner stoves can make a difference to health and reduce the number of people
suffering from indoor air pollution, which claims more lives than malaria. Through exploring new
ways to provide rural communities with energy we can provide people with new ways to lift
themselves out of poverty through increased productivity and education opportunties."
Score has been invited by Dai-ichi to exhibit at the “Better City Better Life” EXPO 2010 in Shanghai
China from May to October 2010 to showcase its new advanced technology to 70 million expected
visitors.
The aim of the Score project is to make a low-cost, high efficiency generator that can be used in the
world’s poorest countries. The generator has a cost target of £20 per household, based on the
production of a million units. The generator will weigh between 10 and 20kg. The target is to generate
an hour’s use per kilogram of fuel — which could be wood, dung or any other locally-available
biomass material.
Dr Chitta Saha, Research Assistant at Nottingham said: “The current Linear Alternator design is very
exciting for me as it solves many of the problems we had with using loudspeakers as alternators, but
can still be made cheaply. My mum lives in Bangladesh — she is so proud that I am working on such
a worthwhile project that she can see will help her community.”
The University of Manchester, City University London and Queen Mary, University of London and
the Charity Practical Action are partners in the project — from researching engine design to the
manufacture and distribution of the stove in the developing world. The project will work with
governments, universities and civil organisation across Africa and Asia, many of whom have already
offered support. This collaboration will ensure the device is affordable, socially acceptable and that
there is scope for communities to develop businesses to manufacture and repair locally.
Mark Johnson, Professor of Advanced Power Conversion at Nottingham, said: "I am particularly
pleased with the way that the Score consortium, with partners from very different technical
backgrounds, has developed into a cohesive research team. We now have solutions to the fundamental
technical problems and the first demonstrators delivering significant electrical power, have been
realised"
The Score team is now looking for sponsorship to fund testing in the countries in which the generator
will eventually be deployed. Indeed Germany’s Department of International Development (GTZ
South Africa) has already signed a Memorandum of Understanding to provide funding to test the
stove in southern Africa.
Paul H Riley, Score Project Director says “We have had tremendous interest in the Score project from
around the world and the Score community —launched a few months ago — is working extremely
well. This includes entrepreneurs and volunteers that adapt the stove for local use among its
members.”
Practical Action, a charity which promotes the development of sustainable technology to tackle
poverty in developing countries, is already leading field trials in Nepal and Kenya. The charity will
expand the test sites when more units are made available.
Score community member Mark Loweth works in Tajikistan, one of the poorer countries in Central
Asia. He has adapted a variation of a Score Stove to ensure it is suitable for the communities it is
aimed at.
“We are very excited with the Score technology as it has the capability of bringing small scale
electrical generation to households in the developing world,” he said.
“We plan to field test 20 units in Tajikistan when funding is available through a jointly owned, locally
registered company utilising the experience and extensive local knowledge of expatriates and
nationals with strong links to rural communities.”
Other members of the international Score Community are investigating how a Score Stove could best
be adapted for their local environments.
South African Score community member Rynier Ferreira said: “We are adapting a Score Stove to
work with paraffin (kerosene) as many rural communities in South Africa are still highly dependant
on it as a major fuel source for cooking. Adapting a Score Stove for paraffin will increase not only the
safety aspect for stoves using this type of fuel, but will give the people in these rural communities the
additional advantage of electricity and refrigeration.”
Gorge Crowson is also testing the stove in southern Africa after joining the Score community: He
said: “We have identified a number of waste materials that can be burnt in a Score Stove and are
actively seeking financial support to set up assembly plants in Southern Africa and a distribution
network, once the test phase is completed.”
It’s thought that more units will be available for testing in field trials at the start of next year, with full
production of the Score generator taking place after 2012.
The Score consortium is funded by grants from the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research
Council as part of its initiative on energy and international development.
Kees deBlok of Aster Thermoakoestische Systemen in the Netherlands and Scott Backhaus of Los
Alamos International Laboratories are acting as consultants to the Score project.
More information is available from the web site www.score.uk.com, Paul Riley, Score Project
Director, on +44 (0) 0115 951 5600, paul.riley@nottingham.ac.uk or Internal Communications
Manager Tara de Cozar in the University’s Communications Office on +44 (0)115 8468545,
tara.decozar@nottingham.ac.uk
And images here:
http://www.score.uk.com/research/Scorepics/Alternator_demonstrator_nott.JPG
http://www.score.uk.com/research/Scorepics/Appropriate_technology_demonstrator_city.jpg
http://www.score.uk.com/research/Scorepics/Technology_demonstrator_Man.JPG
http://www.score.uk.com/research/Shared%20Documents/TechnoSocial/Technology_Acceptance_PA.ppt
http://www.score.uk.com/research/Scorepics/heat_exchanger_rig_QMUL.png