APPLEINC. GREENBOND FRAMEWORKOVERVIEWANDSECOND-PARTY OPINIONBYSUSTAINALYTICS February16,2016 VikramPuppala(Toronto) MeganWallingford(Toronto) RebeccaDreyfus(NewYork) AssociateDirector, SeniorAdvisor, SeniorAdvisor, AdvisoryServicesTeam AdvisoryServicesTeam InstitutionalRelations vikram.puppala@sustainalytics.com megan.wallingford@sustainalytics.com rebecca.dreyfus@sustainalytics.com (+1)6473173694 (+1)6473173689 (+1)6465618994|(+1)9172325117 www.sustainalytics.com ©Sustainalytics2016 TABLEOFCONTENTS 1. PREFACE 2 2. FRAMEWORKOVERVIEW 2.1 Introduction 2.2 UseofProceeds EligibilityCriteria EligibleProjects 2.2.1ProjectSelectionProcess 2.2.2ManagementofProceeds 2.2.3Reporting AllocationReporting ImpactReporting ProjectReporting 2.2.4ComplianceReview 2 2 2 2 6 6 6 7 7 7 8 8 3. SUSTAINALYTICS’OPINION 9 1 ©Sustainalytics2016 1. PREFACE SustainalyticshasbeenretainedbyAppleInc.tosupport,reviewandprovideanopiniononitsgreenbond framework and its alignment with the Green Bond Principles 2015. As part of this engagement, Sustainalytics reviewed relevant public and internal documents, and held conversations with Apple’s legal, treasury and sustainability teams to understand the planned use of proceeds, project selection process,andmanagementandreportingforitsgreenbond. Thisdocumentcontainstwosections: 1) FrameworkOverview,whichincludesasummaryofApple’sgreenbondframework;and 2) Sustainalytics’Opinion,whichisasecondpartyopinionontheframework. 2. FRAMEWORKOVERVIEW 2.1 Introduction Appleisissuingagreenbondthataimstofundprojectsthatarefocusedonenvironmentalsustainability acrossitsglobalbusinessdivisionsandoperations. Theseprojectswillalignwithitsthreeenvironmentalpriorities1: 1. reducing its impact on climate change by using renewable energy sources and driving energy efficiencyinitsfacilities,productsandsupplychain; 2. pioneeringtheuseofgreenermaterialsinitsproductsandprocesses;and, 3. conservingpreciousresources. The following section summarizes Apple’s green bond framework including the use of proceeds, the managementofproceeds,andreporting. 2.2 UseofProceeds Applewillallocateanamountequaltothenetproceedsfromsalesofthegreenbondtoinvestmentsin oneormoreprojectsthatareeligibleaccordingtothebelowcriteria. EligibilityCriteria Inorderforaprojecttobefundedwithgreenbondproceeds,theprojectmustmeetoneormoreofthe followingcriteria: 1 EnvironmentalResponsibilityReport2015,page3, http://images.apple.com/ca/environment/pdf/Apple_Environmental_Responsibility_Report_2015.pdf. 2 ©Sustainalytics2016 1. EXPENDITURESRELATEDTONEWANDONGOINGRENEWABLEENERGYPROJECTS ,SUCHASSOLARAND WINDPROJECTS ,ORTHEASSOCIATEDENERGYSTORAGESOLUTIONS . Context: As one of its environmental priorities, Apple has identified renewable energy use as a key strategytoreduceitsclimatechangeimpacts.Thecompanyhascommittedtopoweringallofitsfacilities globally,includingcorporateoffices,retailstoresanddatacentres,with100percentrenewableenergy2. Inits2015EnvironmentalResponsibilityReport,Applestatesthatithasto-datemadesignificantprogress infulfillingitsoperationalenergyuseneedswithrenewableenergybyinvestinginadiversityofrenewable energytechnologiesincludingsolar,wind,biogasfuelcells,micro-hydropower,andgeo-thermalpower. UseofProceeds:Proceedsofthegreenbondmaybeallocatedtonewandongoingrenewableenergy projects, including, but not limited to, solar and wind projects. Apple will also consider projects that provideenergystoragesolutionsforrenewableenergy. 2. EXPENDITURES RELATED TO PROJECTS THAT HAVE RECEIVED WITHIN THE LAST THREE YEARS , OR ARE EXPECTED TO RECEIVE , CERTIFICATION OF LEED GOLD OR PLATINUM OR BREEAM VERY GOOD, EXCELLENT,OROUTSTANDING“GREENBUILDING”STANDARDS. Context:Applereportsthatenvironmentaldesign,managementandoperationoffacilitiesareapriority forthecompany.ItsMaiden,NorthCarolinadatacenter,forexample,hasalreadyearnedLEEDPlatinum certification. Use of Proceeds: Proceeds of the green bond may be allocated to green buildings that have or are expectedtoreceiveeitherLEEDorBREEAMcertificationatthehighestlevels:LEEDGoldorPlatinum,or BREEAM Very Good, Excellent, or Outstanding. For existing buildings, certification must have been receivedwithinthelastthreeyears. 3. EXPENDITURESRELATEDTOTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFENVIRONMENTALDESIGNELEMENTSFORNEWOR ONGOINGBUILDINGDEVELOPMENTS ,SUCHASHIGHPERFORMANCEMECHANICALSYSTEMS ,NATURAL VENTILATION ,ON -SITERENEWABLEENERGYANDHIGHPERFORMANCELIGHTINGSYSTEMS . Context:Applestatesthatconsideringtheenvironmentinthedesignofanewbuildingorrenovationsof existingfacilitiesisapriority.ThecompanyarticulatesinitsEnvironmental,HealthandSafetyPolicy3a commitment to designing its facilities in a manner that promotes energy efficiency and protects the environment. For example, environmental design is a key consideration in its new Apple campus in Cupertino, where it aims to construct a facility that is highly energy efficient and entirely powered by renewableenergy. 2 EnvironmentalResponsibilityReport, http://images.apple.com/ca/environment/pdf/Apple_Environmental_Responsibility_Report_2015.pdf. 3 Apple’sEnvironmental,HealthandSafetyPolicyStatement, http://images.apple.com/ca/environment/pdf/Apple_Environmental_Responsibility_Report_2015.pdf. 3 ©Sustainalytics2016 UseofProceeds:Proceedsofthegreenbondmaybeallocatedtoprojectsthatenabletheimplementation ofenvironmentaldesignelementsintoneworongoingbuildingdevelopments,orrenovations.These projects may or may not be part of LEED- or BREEAM-certified buildings or include energy efficiency projectsatexistingfacilities.Projectsthatmeetcriteria#2and/or#4areexcludedinthiscriterioninorder to avoid double counting. Projects may include, but are not limited to, high-performance mechanical systems,naturalventilation,on-siterenewableenergyandhigh-performinglightingsystems. 4. EXPENDITURESRELATEDTOENERGYEFFICIENCYPROJECTSANDTECHNOLOGIESATITSCORPORATE FACILITIES ,SUCHASHEATING ,VENTILATIONANDAIRCONDITIONINGSYSTEMSUPGRADES ,LIGHTING RETROFITSANDENERGYMONITORSANDCONTROLS . Context: In its 2015 Environmental Responsibility Report, the company states that it considers energy efficiency to be the first step in achieving net zero energy, and the company views its own facilities, including its corporate campuses, retail offices and data centres, as an important starting point for fulfillingitsenvironmentalcommitments.In2014,Applelaunchedanenergyefficiencyprogramforits corporateandretailfacilitiesacrossAsia,EuropeandtheUnitedStates. Use of Proceeds: Proceeds of the green bond may be allocated to energy efficiency projects and technologies, including but not limited to, heating, ventilation, and air conditioning system upgrades, lightingretrofits,andtheinstallationofenergymonitorsandcontrolsatthecompany’sexistingcorporate facilities,retailofficesanddatacentres. 5. EXPENDITURESRELATEDTOWATEREFFICIENCYPROJECTSANDTECHNOLOGIESATITSCORPORATE FACILITIES ,SUCHASUPGRADESTOWATEREFFICIENTFIXTURESANDWATEREFFICIENTIRRIGATIONAND INCREASEDUSEOFRECYCLEDWATER . Context:Applestatesthatitrecognizestheimportanceofconservingnaturalresources,suchaswater,as one of its environmental priorities. The company seeks to conserve water by maximizing its use of recycled water, and reducing water use in manufacturing, cooling, landscaping, and sanitation. The companytracksanddisclosesinits2015EnvironmentalResponsibilityReport,itscompany-levelwater usage,aswellasitswaterusebyfacilitytype(datacentres,corporateoffices,andretailstores). UseofProceeds:Proceedsofthegreenbondmaybeallocatedtoprojectsandtechnologiesthatleadto greaterwaterefficienciesatitsexistingcorporate facilities,including,butnotlimitedto,upgradingto waterefficientfixtures,implementingwaterefficientirrigationsystems,andprojectsandtechnologies thatincreasetheuseofrecycledwater. 6. EXPENDITURESRELATEDTOPROJECTSTHATENHANCERECYCLING ,MATERIALRECOVERYANDREUSE ,AND LANDFILLWASTEDIVERSIONFORITSPRODUCTSANDFACILITIES . Context:Asreflectedinits2015EnvironmentalResponsibilityReport,Appleiscommittedtoconserving resources,recyclingmaterials,andwastemanagement,bothwithrespecttoitsproductsanditsfacilities. Ontheproductandpackagingside,Applehassoughttousemorerecycled,recyclableandsustainable 4 ©Sustainalytics2016 plant-basedmaterials;reducetheamountofmaterialsusedinitsproducts;and,throughitsReuseand Recycling program, enable customers to recycle electronic waste. Within its facilities, the company maintainsrecyclingandcompostingprograms,andin2014itachieveda68percentrateofdivertingwaste fromlandfillsatitscorporateandretailfacilities. UseofProceeds:Proceedsofthegreenbondmaybeallocatedtoprojectsthatenhancerecycling,material recoveryandreuse,andlandfillwastediversion. 7. EXPENDITURES RELATED TO PROJECTS AND TECHNOLOGIES THAT FACILITATE THE USE OF GREENER MATERIALS IN ITS PRODUCTS THROUGH (I ) THE USE OF BIO -BASED MATERIALS , (II ) THE USE OF RECYCLABLEMATERIALSOR (III )ELIMINATIONOFTOXICSUBSTANCESTHATARECOMMONLYUSEDIN THE INDUSTRY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ITS REGULATED SUBSTANCES SPECIFICATION (AVAILABLE AT HTTP ://WWW .APPLE .COM /ENVIRONMENT /REPORTS /). Context: Using greener materials in its products is an important environmental goal reflected in the company’sthreeenvironmentalpriorities. AllofApple’sproductsmustcomplywiththerestrictionslistedinitsRegulatedSubstancesSpecification, whichdescribesApple’sglobalrestrictionsontheuseofcertainchemicalsubstancesormaterialsinits products,accessories,manufacturingprocesses,andpackagingusedforshippingproductstocustomers. This Regulated Substances Specification is a comprehensive list of substances with Chemical Abstracts Service(CAS)registrynumbersthatidentifyuniquesubstances.Applerequiresitssupplierstoadhereto thisRegulatedSubstancesSpecificationandtodemonstratecompliancebyprovidingtestreportsfrom certified labs as proof of compliance. Apple derives these restrictions from international laws or directives,agencyoreco-labelrequirements;anditspoliciesstatethatinmanycases,thecompanymust go beyond minimum legal requirements. Examples of international laws and directives focused on restrictingtoxicsubstanceuseinclude,butarenotlimitedto: • REACHSVHCs:EU’sRegistration,Evaluation,Authorisation,andRestrictionofChemicals(REACH). Substances that may have serious and often irreversible effects on human health and the environmentcanbeidentifiedassubstancesofveryhighconcern(SVHCs). • OzonedepletingchemicalscitedbytheMontrealProtocol. • OSPAR:OSPARListofChemicalsforPriorityAction,OSPARConventionfortheProtectionofthe MarineEnvironmentoftheNorth-EastAtlantic,2004. • CleanProductionAction(CPA):GreenScreen®forSaferChemicals,2014. Apple has also made progress in incorporating recycled and bio-based content in their products. For example,asreportedinthecompany’s2015EnvironmentalResponsibilityReporttheMacProspeakers andiPadAir2contain30percentpost-consumerrecycledplastic,andthebutterflymechanismofthe MacBookkeyboardcontains67percentbio-basedcontent. UseofProceeds:Proceedsofthegreenbondmaybeallocatedtoprojectsthatincreasetheuseofgreener materialsinApple’sproducts.Thecompanydefinesgreenermaterialsasthosematerialsthatarebio- 5 ©Sustainalytics2016 basedmaterials,and/orrecyclablematerialsandarenotconsideredtoxicsubstances(accordingtoits RegulatedSubstanceSpecification). EligibleProjects Anyprojectthatmeetstheaboveeligibilitycriteria,includingthenewandongoingdevelopmentsofsuch projects,areeligibletobefundedinwholeorinpartbyanallocationofthegreenbondproceeds. EligibleprojectsmayincludeprojectsofApple’ssubsidiariesthatmeettheeligibilitycriteria. 2.2.1 ProjectSelectionProcess Apple’sEnvironment,PolicyandSocialInitiatives(EPSI)teamwill: (i) assessanddetermineprojecteligibility;and, (ii) recommendanallocationofproceedstoeligibleprojects. Theseprojectsaredevelopedandmanagedbycentralteams,whichareprimarilybasedinCupertino. Forexample,ApplehasaGlobalEnergyTeamthatmanagesallcorporaterenewableenergyandenergy efficiencyprojects;centralizedRealEstate&Facilitiesteamsthattrackandplanforallfacilities worldwide,includinggreenbuildingsanditsnewcampus;andaGlobalDataCentreteamthatmanages theglobalexpansionofitsdatacentres. Apple’sfinancedepartmentwilltracktheallocationofthegreenbondproceedsandproduceaninternal quarterlyreportthatwillbereviewedbymembersofApple’sEPSIteam.Thisinternalreportwillinclude detailsforprojectsthathavebeenrecommendedforallocation,suchasabriefdescriptionoftheproject, thecountryinwhichtheprojectislocated,andtheamountofproceedsallocatedtotheproject.Apple’s EPSIteamwillallocategreenbondproceedsonasemi-annualbasisandensurethateachprojectmeets theeligibilitycriteriaandatleastoneofApple’sthreeenvironmentalpriorities. Thecompany’sVicePresidentofEnvironment,PolicyandSocialInitiativeswillapprovethefinalallocation ofproceeds. 2.2.2 ManagementofProceeds The proceeds from the green bond will be managed by Apple’s finance department. Pending the allocation of the green bond proceeds, the company will temporarily invest an amount equal to the balanceoftheproceedsincash,cashequivalentsand/orU.S.treasurysecurities.Paymentofprincipal andinterestonthegreenbondwillbemadefromthecompany’sgeneralfundsandwillnotbedirectly linkedtotheperformanceofanyeligibleprojects. Appleexpectstospendthemajorityofgreenbondproceedswithintwoyearsofthedateofissuance. 6 ©Sustainalytics2016 2.2.3 Reporting Throughoutthetermofthegreenbond,untiltheproceedshavebeenfullyallocatedtoeligibleprojects, Applecommitstopublishingannualupdatesoftheallocationoftheproceedsandimpactofprojectsthat havereceivedallocations.Theannualallocationandexpectedimpactevaluationwillbereportedasa separate green bond report. These updates will be published on the company’s website at investor.apple.com. ApplemayincludeitsgreenbondreporteitherbyreferenceorasanappendixinitsannualEnvironmental ResponsibilityReport. AllocationReporting Applecommitstopublishinganannualreportdetailingtheaggregateallocationoftheproceeds. Totheextentpracticable,Applealsointendstoreporttheallocationtoeligibleprojectsatacategory level,whichisconsistentwiththeeligibilitycriteria,subjecttoconfidentialityobligations.Thesereports willbeaccompaniedby: a. AletterfromSustainalytics,withrespecttothecomplianceofprojects,withtheeligibilitycriteria (seesection2.2.4ComplianceReviewforfurtherdetails); b. Anassertionbymanagementthatthenetproceedsofthisofferingwereallocatedtoqualifying eligibleprojects;and c. Areportfromanindependentregisteredpublicaccountingfirminrespectofitsexaminationof management’sassertionconductedinaccordancewithattestationstandardsestablishedbythe AmericanInstituteofCertifiedPublicAccountants. Allocationreportingwillbeavailabletotheinvestorswithinoneyearfromthedateofthegreenbond’s issuance,andannuallythereafter. ImpactReporting Inadditiontoitsallocationreporting,Applecommitstopublishingannualupdatesonthe environmentalimpactsoftheprojectsfundedwithgreenbondproceeds. Whererelevant,ApplewillreportonthefollowingKeyPerformanceIndicators(KPIs)inaggregatefor greenbondprojects: 7 ©Sustainalytics2016 KeyPerformanceIndicators RenewableEnergy • • • Renewableenergyinstalledcapacity(kWorMW) Energyproducedfromrenewablesources(kWhorMWh) GHGemissionsavoided(inCO2etons) EnergyEfficiency • • Energysavedaggregate(kWh) Energysavedduetobuildingretrofitsordesign(kW) Water • Waterusesavings(gallons) Waste • • Wastedivertedfromlandfills(tonsor%diversion) Wasterecycledorcomposted(tons) ResourceUse • • Bio-basedmaterialuse(%ofmaterialinproduct) Recycledcontentuse(%materialinproduct) Inaddition,ifrelevant,Applewillprovidealistofbuildingsthatarecertified,orareexpectedtobecome certified, LEED Gold or Platinum, or BREEAM Very Good, Excellent, or Outstanding, to which bond proceedshavebeenallocated;andwillreportthenumberandtypeoftoxicsubstancesremovedfromits productsandaccessories. ProjectReporting Subjecttoconfidentialityconsiderations,Applewillprovideadditionaldescriptionsofselectprojects fundedwithgreenbondproceeds. 2.2.4ComplianceReview In addition to its own annual reporting, Apple will obtain a letter from Sustainalytics, with respect to Apple’s green bond projects’ compliance with the eligibility criteria. Sustainalytics will review a broad sampleofprojectsfromthetotalallocatedprojectsinordertodeterminewhethertheymeettheuseof proceedscriteriadefinedintheframework.Sustainalyticswillprovideareportoftheevaluation,which Applemaydisclosepublicly.Inanunlikelyeventthataprojectdoesnotmeettheeligibilitycriteria,Apple willreallocatethegreenbondproceedstoadifferentprojectthatmeetsthecriteria. 8 ©Sustainalytics2016 3. SUSTAINALYTICS’OPINION EnvironmentalPrioritiesandESGPerformance:Inits2015EnvironmentalResponsibilityReport,Apple outlinesthreeenvironmentalpriorities:(1)reducingitsimpactonclimatechangebyusingrenewable energyandachievingenergyefficiencyinitsproducts;(2)conservingpreciousresources;and(3)using greenermaterialsinitsproductsandservices.Apple’sgreenbondalignswithitsenvironmentalpriorities: each one of Apple’s green bond eligibility criteria supports at least one of its three environmental priorities.Inaddition,thecompanyhasnotbeeninvolvedinanysignificantenvironmentalcontroversies. Taking into consideration its strategic approach, commitments, and overall ESG rating, Sustainalytics believesthatAppleiswellpositionedtoissueagreenbond. Use of Proceeds: Apple’s project eligibility criteria address specific areas for environmental impact includingrenewableenergy;greenbuildingdesign,constructionandretrofit;energyandwaterefficiency; andwastemanagement.Itsgreenbuildingeligibilitycriteriaisbasedonthirdpartycertificationstandards ofLEEDandBREEAM,andthecompanyisaligningwithindustrybestpracticesbyfocusingonLEEDGold or Platinum, or BREEAM Very Good, Excellent, or Outstanding, levels of certification. Further, after reviewing the use of proceeds criteria regarding projects and technologies that facilitate the use of greener materials in its products through: (i) the use of bio-based materials, (ii) the use of recyclable materialsor(iii)eliminationoftoxicsubstancesthatarecommonlyusedintheindustry,Sustainalytics believesthattheseprojectsarelikelytopositivelyimpactthesustainabilityofApple’sproducts.Overall, SustainalyticsisoftheopinionthatApple’sprojecteligibilitycriteriaarecredibleandrobust,andthatby selectingprojectsbasedonthesecriteria,Appleiseffectivelytargetingitsgreenbondproceedsatprojects thatwillcontributetoreducingApple’soverallenvironmentalimpact. ProjectSelectionProcess:Applehasacentralizedaccountingandfinancesystemthatcapturesbudgets andactualspendforalleligibleprojectcategories.Inaddition,these projects aremanagedby central teams,whichareprimarilybasedinCupertino,California.Forexample,ApplehasaGlobalEnergyTeam thatmanagesallcorporaterenewableenergyandenergyefficiencyprojects;andcentralizedRealEstate &Facilitiesteamsthattrackandplanprojectsforitsfacilitiesworldwide.Havingacentralizedaccounting system,andcentralizedmanagementandoversightforprojectsthatreceiveanallocationofthegreen bond proceeds will ensure consistency in complying with the eligibility criteria. The aforementioned projectselectionprocessesandcommitmentsaregreenbondmarketbestpractices. ManagementofProceeds:Pendingallocationofgreenbondproceeds,themanagementofgreenbond proceedsisinlinewithacceptedpracticesofagreenbondissuanceandwithGreenBondPrinciples2015. Reporting: Apple will publish annual updates on the allocation of its green bond proceeds and the estimated environmental impact of projects that have received allocation. Due to confidentiality concerns, where possible Apple intends to disclose its allocation at an aggregate, category-level, consistentwiththeeligibilitycriteria.Inaddition,onacase-by-casebasis,Applewillprovideadditional descriptions of select projects that have received allocations. Apple’s commitment to undertake an annualthirdpartycompliancereviewandthirdpartyuseofproceedsattestationassuresinvestorsthat the selected projects meet the eligibility criteria and that the funds are properly allocated. Finally, 9 ©Sustainalytics2016 Sustainalytics believes that Apple has selected Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that will provide a meaningfulmeasureoftheenvironmentalbenefitsofitsgreenbond. Conclusion: Through its green bond, Apple aims to invest in projects that contribute to achieving its environmentalprioritiesacrossitsglobaloperationsandproducts.Apple’sgreenbondframeworkaligns with the four pillars of the Green Bond Principles 2015. The company has established clear project eligibilitycriteriathatalignwithitsenvironmentalprioritiesandsupportitseffortstoreduceitsoverall environmentalimpact.Apple’splantousetheproceedsofthegreenbondforrenewableenergy,green building, energy and water efficiency, and waste management projects aligns with green bond best practices. The company’s plan to undertake projects that eliminate the use of toxic substances in its productsthatadverselyimpacthumanhealthandtheenvironmentisespeciallynoteworthy.Finally,the company’sapproachtoselectingprojectsandmanaginggreenbondproceedsisrobust,anditsreporting ontheuseofproceeds,withKPIsthatcaptureenvironmentalimpact,isreasonablytransparent.These processeswillprovideassurancetoinvestorsthatfundsarebeingappropriatelytracked,managedand allocated. Based on the above considerations, Sustainalytics is of the view that Apple’s green bond is robustandcredible. 10 ©Sustainalytics2016 Disclaimer Allrightsreserved.Nopartofthissecondpartyopinion(the“Opinion”)maybereproduced,transmitted orpublishedinanyformorbyanymeanswithoutthepriorwrittenpermissionofSustainalytics. TheOpinionwasdrawnupwiththeaimtoexplainwhytheanalyzedbondisconsideredsustainableand responsible.Consequently,thisOpinionisforinformationpurposesonlyandSustainalyticswillnot acceptanyformofliabilityforthesubstanceoftheopinionand/oranyliabilityfordamagearisingfrom theuseofthisOpinionand/ortheinformationprovidedinit. AstheOpinionisbasedoninformationmadeavailablebytheclient,Sustainalyticsdoesnotwarrantthat theinformationpresentedinthisOpinioniscomplete,accurateoruptodate. NothingcontainedinthisOpinionshallbeconstruedastomakearepresentationorwarranty,expressor implied,regardingtheadvisabilitytoinvestinorincludecompaniesininvestableuniversesand/or portfolios.Furthermore,thisOpinionshallinnoeventbeinterpretedandconstruedasanassessmentof theeconomicperformanceandcreditworthinessofthebond,nortohavefocusedontheeffective allocationofthefunds’useofproceeds. Theclientisfullyresponsibleforcertifyingandensuringitscommitments`compliance,implementation andmonitoring. 11