Rating Matrix
Target Period
Potential Upside
YoY Growth (%)
(YoY Growth)
Net Sales
EBITDA
Net Profit
EPS (Rs)
FY11
10.7
(1.8)
4.7
5.8
Current & target multiple
P/E
Target P/E
EV / EBITDA
P/BV
RoNW
RoCE
Stock Data
FY11
53.5
48.9
44.7
46.8
87.6
94.1
Bloomberg/Reuters Code
Sensex
Average volumes
Market Cap (Rs crore)
: 12 months
: -9 %
FY12
12.0
21.9
16.7
16.6
FY12
45.8
41.9
36.2
35.1
76.6
87.5
52 week H/L
Equity Capital (Rs crore)
Promoter's Stake (%)
FII Holding (%)
DII Holding (%)
Comparative return matrix (%)
Return %
Hindustan Unilever L
ITC
GCPL
Colgate
Price movement
1M
5.2
6.3
3.9
1.7
3M
28.1
11.3
21.3
8.5
FY13E
10.2
12.7
31.1
31.2
FY13E
34.9
31.9
32.0
30.6
87.7
86.5
6M
40.6
25.0
38.7
12.1
FY14E
12.5
13.4
(3.3)
(3.3)
FY14E
36.1
33.0
28.2
27.9
77.3
89.5
HUVR.BO / HLL.NS
18,805.0
11,14,000
123,307.5
571 / 324
216.0
52.5
21.1
9.0
12M
72.7
40.6
75.3
26.8
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
Oct-11 Jan-12
Price (R.H.S)
Apr-12 Jul-12
Nifty (L.H.S)
0
Oct-12
200
100
600
500
400
300
Analyst’s name
Sanjay Manyal sanjay.manyal@icicisecurities.com
Parineeta Poddar parineeta.poddar@icicisecurities.com
October 11, 2012
| 571
Hindustan Unilever (HUL) is the brands behemoth of the Indian FMCG industry. Over the years, HUL has built a leadership position in the soaps, detergents, personal products and coffee segment along with a vast basket of ~35 brands spanning across 20 different categories. Being the country’s largest FMCG player, HUL’s revenue growth has been supported by the changing demographic profile of Indian consumers, increasing per capita income & rising affluence of consumers. HUL’s sales growth ratio to that of India’s GDP growth has risen from ~1.0x (FY04-10) to 1.5x (FY11-12). We expect the ratio to trail at these levels with revenues and earnings growing at a CAGR of 11.4% and 12.6%, respectively, in
FY12-14E. We are initiating coverage on HUL with a HOLD rating.
Leadership and strong brands across segments
HUL derives ~49% of its revenues (FY12) from soaps & detergents, ~32% from personal products, 12% from beverage (tea & coffee) and ~6% from packaged foods. The company has strong brand equity and a leadership position in soaps (~46% of market share by value in FY11), detergents
(~36% share by value in FY11), hair care (shampoos) and skin care
(fairness cream, body lotion) segments. It has capitalised on its brand strength in existing categories to expand its footprint into faster growing premium products and higher growth categories within each segment; encompassing the complete value pyramid in each segment. Going forward, we believe the extension of existing brands and innovation within brands would aid to maintain its leadership across categories.
Personal products the cynosure
HUL’s personal products (PP) contribute ~1/3 rd to gross revenues but more than half to the company’s PBIT. The segment has witnessed an impressive volume CAGR of 15.7% and value CAGR of 14.4% in CY04-
FY12. The company has the highest return on capital employed (~69x in
FY12) from this segment. Going ahead, with HUL’s aggressive expansion in PPs, we expect its contribution to HUL’s gross revenues to increase to
~35% by FY14E with the volume and value growth accelerating to 18.8% and 17.2% (CAGR FY12-14E), respectively.
Business on track; valuations expensive
The stock ran up (~73%) significantly in the last 12 months, led by HUL’s persistently high single/double digit volume growth (last 10 quarters), sustained margins and increasing market share across categories. At the
CMP, the stock is trading at 34.9x FY13E and 36.1x FY14E EPS of | 16.3 and | 15.8, respectively. We have valued HUL using DCF methodology as the stock is a long term play on the opportunity arising from the consumption boom in the country, arriving at a target price of | 522.
Exhibit 1: Financial Performance
(Year-end March) FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13E FY14E
Net Sales (| crore) 17,523.8
19,401.1
21,735.6
23,959.6
26,954.3
EBITDA (| crore)
Net Profit (| crore)
EPS (|)
P/E (x)
Mkt Cap/Sales (x)
RoCE (%)
RoNW (%)
2,750.0
2,202.0
10.1
55.9
7.0
99.3
85.2
2,699.3
2,306.0
10.7
52.8
6.3
94.1
87.6
3,291.3
2,691.4
12.5
45.3
5.6
87.5
76.6
3,708.2
3,529.3
16.3
34.5
5.1
86.5
87.7
4,206.4
3,414.1
15.8
35.7
4.5
89.5
77.3
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Shareholding pattern (Q1FY13)
Shareholder
Promoters
Institutional Investors
Public
FII & DII holding trend (%)
Holding (%)
52.5
29.9
17.6
25
20
15
10
5
0
21.1
9.0
20.1
9.9
19.4
10.3
18.7
11.4
17.7
12.1
Q2FY13 Q1FY13 Q4FY12 Q3FY12 Q2FY12
FII DII
Revenue break-up (FY12)
Foods
6.3%
Beverage
12.0%
Others
1.3%
Soap &
Detergent
48.9%
Personal
Products
31.5%
Hindustan Unilever Ltd (HUL) is the country’s largest FMCG company with an annual turnover of | 21735.6 crore (FY12). It is a subsidiary of Unilever
(the world’s leading supplier of fast moving consumer goods), which holds 52.5% share in the company.
HUL is headquartered in Mumbai and operates in the segments, soaps & detergents (48.9% of revenues FY12), personal products (31.5% of revenues FY12), beverages (12.0% of revenues FY12), packaged foods
(6.3% of revenues FY12) and other products such as scourers, water purifiers, etc (1.3% of revenues FY12). The company has a strong brand portfolio of ~35 brands in 20 different categories (refer Annexure) with a leadership position in soaps, detergents hair care, home care, skin care and deodorants. The most popular brands of the company are Lifebuoy and Lux in soaps, Surf Excel and Wheel in detergents, Lakme, Ponds and
Vaseline in Personal Products, Lipton, Taj Mahal and Bru in beverages and Kissan in foods.
Over the years, the company has constantly introduced new brands in each segment capturing the growth opportunity along with extension and innovation of mother brands into higher growth segments. Hence, the company’s net sales and earnings have more than doubled from | 9926.9 crore and |1197.3 crore in CY04 to | 21735.6 crore (CAGR 11.8%) and
| 2691.4 crore (CAGR 12.3%) in FY12, respectively.
Being the largest FMCG company in India, we believe HUL’s growth is coupled with the country’s economic growth and demographic changes.
Therefore, with India’s long term economic growth expected to remain healthy, we expect HUL’s revenues and earnings to grow at a CAGR
(FY12-14E) of 11.4% and 12.6%, respectively.
Exhibit 2: HUL's timeline
Set up its 3 subsidiaries;
Hindustan Vanaspati
Mfg, Lever Bros,
India Ltd. & United
Traders Limited
Head office at
Bombay
Reclamation,
Mumbai opens
Construction work at Haldia chemicals complex begins
Unilever's shareholding in the company comes down to 52%
Tata Oil Mills merges with HUL;
Entered into 50:50
JV with Kimberley
Clark USA
Pond's India
Ltd merges with HUL;
HUL acquires
100% stake in
Lakme
Project
Shakti , a rural initiative was launched
Name formally changed to
Hindustan
Unilever Limited
(HUL)
1931 1956 1963 1974 1976 1980 1993 1994 1996 1998 2000 2001 2002 2007
3 cos merged to form HUL offering
10% of its equity to public
Pilot Plant for industrial chemicals at Taloja opens
Acquired Kissan brand from UB group;
Dollops Ice Cream acquired from Cadbury
India
Brooke Bond
Lipton India Ltd merged with HUL;
Lakme Lever
Limited, a JV with
Lakme Limited is formed
HLL acquires
74% in Modern
Foods ; marking its entry in bread market
Made its foray into ayurvedic
Health &
Beauty
Centre
Category
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 2
Over the years, HUL’s revenue contribution has been dominated by soaps and detergents (S&D) being 48.9% in FY12 and personal products (PP) dominating the contribution to PBIT at 52.2% (FY12). We expect S&D’s dominance to slide to 44.5% by FY14E. This would be captured by the faster growing PP revenues, thereby increasing its share to 34.3% by
FY14E from 31.5% in FY12.
Exhibit 3: Sales revenue mix (%)
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
15.4
11.9
24.6
44.4
3.7
14.3
11.4
26.4
44.3
3.7
11.9
10.8
27.4
45.6
4.3
11.1
5.1
11.1
26.6
46.2
9.4
5.1
11.2
26.2
48.1
7.6
5.4
12.1
28.4
46.5
7.8
6.0
11.9
29.7
44.6
CY04 CY05 CY06 CY07 FY09 FY10 FY11
Soaps & Detergents Personal Products Beverages Foods Others
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
* FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
1.3
6.3
12.0
31.5
48.9
FY12
2.7
6.7
11.7
32.2
46.7
FY13E
3.1
6.9
11.3
34.3
44.5
FY14E
The S&D segment witnessed an increase in revenue contribution to 48.9% in FY12 from 44.6% in FY11 driven by a steep price increase (we assume
~25% YoY in FY12) taken in detergents with volume growth remaining muted. Going ahead, we believe that with S&D being a highly penetrated category, growth would largely be price led. Hence, the segment would lose its sheen in volume growth contribution for HUL.
In contrast, PP’s revenue growth of 17.1% in FY12 was largely driven by volumes with marginal price increases. With HUL’s dominance in the segment (~50% of PP brand in the industry are HUL’s brands) and the company’s rapid innovation within each category, we expect the S&D share loss to be captured by PP, thereby increasing its share to 34.3% by
FY14E.
The other two segments that are relatively smaller in HUL’s baskets are beverages and foods contributing 12.0% and 6.3% to its revenues (FY12).
We expect the foods contribution to increase marginally to 6.9% by
FY14E and beverages to slide marginally to 11.3% by FY14E.
The other business where HUL is actively ramping up its presence is the water purifiers under the brand ‘Pureit’. It is currently a very small revenue generator for the company but the company is ramping up its scale in this business at a faster rate to capture the untapped market and opportunity from this.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 3
Exhibit 4: Contribution to PBIT by segments (%)
0
-20
40
20
100
80
60
13.7
46.4
44.5
CY04
-5.0
1.2
13.6
47.4
38.4
CY05
11.2
47.9
39.3
10.4
46.0
44.1
9.6
44.6
46.3
11.4
46.2
42.3
CY06 CY07 FY09 FY10
Soaps & Detergents Personal Products Beverages Foods Others
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
* FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
1.2
13.1
54.6
30.5
FY11
11.0
52.2
36.9
FY12
Though personal products contribute only ~1/3 rd to revenues (FY12), they contributed 52.2% to the company’s PBIT. The contribution of other segments to PBIT in FY12 was S&D (36.9%), beverages (11%) and foods at less than 1%. Further, PP’s PBIT has been the fastest growing at 11.6%
CAGR FY04-12 compared to S&D at 6.9% and beverages at 6.3%.
We believe that with the increasing dominance of PP in the company’s revenue mix and expected improvement in the segment’s PBIT with expansion in the premium segment (higher margin products), earnings from the segment will increase at a faster rate simultaneously leading to an increase in the contribution in PBIT.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 4
According to IMRB, the penetration of toilet soaps and washing powder in urban India (2011) stood at 100% and
99%, respectively. The penetration of the same in rural India is 99% and 97%, respectively
Soaps and detergents: High penetration to drive growth through prices
HUL, the market leader in soaps and detergent (S&D), derived 48.9%
(| 10636.3 crore in FY12) of its gross revenues and 36.3% of its earnings
(PBIT) from the S&D segment (FY12). Revenues from this segment have grown at a CAGR of 13.2% (CY04-FY12), which we expect to moderate to
8.6% CAGR (FY12-14E), going ahead. We believe the revenue growth would largely be driven by price increases keeping the volume growth restrained due to the high penetration of >90% in the category.
Exhibit 5: Soaps & detergents sales (| crore) and YoY sales growth (%)
15000
2500
0
-2500
-5000
12500
10000
7500
5000
4470.7
CY04
4961.7
CY05
~21% jump was led by steep price increases in FY12
5595.9
CY06
6399.9
CY07
9880.6
FY09*
Soaps & Detergents (LHS)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
8265.6
FY10
8791.6
FY11
YoY Increase (RHS)
Premium
Mass
10636.3
FY12
11717.0
FY13E
12554.2
FY14E
Detergents
HUL has maintained its leadership position (~36% share by value and
~43% share by volume FY11) in the Indian detergent market (estimated at ~| 12000 crore as in FY11) with a strong portfolio of brands across the value chain. It has constantly strengthened and re-launched its existing brands to preserve its position.
Exhibit 6: Detergent portfolio
Brand
Active Wheel
Comfort
Rin
Surf Excel
Variants
Bar & Powder
Market Position
Largest selling detergent brand in India
Lily Fresh & Comfort Blue World's largest Fabric conditioner brand
Rin Bar, Rin Powder, Rin Matic Also sold in Africa, Asia & Latin America
Quick Wash, Excel Matic, Gentle Wash One of the oldest detergent powder brand in
India. Extended the brand to bars in FY12
Cif
Domex
Vim
Sunlight
Cif Blue & Cif Yellow
Floor cleaner, Disinfectant, Phenolic,
Toilet Block
Bars, Powders & Liquids
Bar & Powder
No.1 cream cleaner in the world
No.1 /2 bleach in the 9 countries
Leading dishwashing brand in India (~60% mkt share)
First brand of Unilever in India; No.1 band in
Kerala & West Bengal
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
60
10
0
-10
-20
50
40
30
20
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 5
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
In the detergent segment, HUL’s nearest competitor is P&G with brands like Tide and Ariel. The companies entered into a price war in 2004 and
2010 in order to garner a higher market share, which consequently led to
HUL’s fat margins from the segment to get leaner. HUL’s PBIT from S&D slid from ~25% (CY01-03) to ~15% (CY04-06) and further to ~12%
(FY10-12). We believe the significant skimming of margins leaves very little scope for further price wars between companies in this segment, thereby providing relief that the market share decline from here seems unlikely.
Further, the extension of HUL’s detergent portfolio into the premium category to tap consumers moving up the value chain will aid its volume growth and keep margins at current levels, going ahead.
The volume growth in detergents would also be supported by the increasing per capita consumption of detergents in India, which continues to remain lower in comparison to other countries. According to industry players, this opportunity could drive volume sales growth of detergents by ~7-9% per annum in the coming years.
Exhibit 7: Per capita detergent consumption (FY11)- kg per annum Exhibit 8: Per capita detergent consumption (FY11)- US$
2 2
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
2.7
3.7
25 22.9
10
20
15
16.6
12.1
10
5
1.4
1.9
2.2
0
India Indonesia China Brazil Germany USA
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
With HUL’s brand dominance in the category and presence across the value pyramid, we expect detergent revenues to grow through price increases of 4.5% (CAGR FY12-14E) and modest volume growth of 3.2%
(CAGR FY12-14E). The price led growth would have a higher contribution to the overall growth led by increasing sales of premium products in the detergents portfolio. The company reported volume and price growth of
6.8% and 8.9% CAGR from CY04-FY12.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 6
Exhibit 9: Detergents sales value and volume growth (%)
66.1
-10
-25
65
50
35
20
5
4.3
15.6
15.9
17.8
27.8
19.6
CY04
1.4
10.6
CY05
7.5
CY06
8.2
CY07 FY09*
Detergents Volume Growth
-22.5
FY10
-20.4
FY11
6.4
Detergents Value Growth
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
PREMIUM
POPULAR
MASS
Volume growth to be led by rise in per capita consumption & premium product sales
29.2
3.8
FY12
8.7
7.1
3.0
FY14E
Soaps
The leader in the soaps category (~46% share in toilet soaps FY11; category size ~| 8900 crore), HUL has an extensive portfolio of brands encompassing the premium, popular and economy price points through established brands Lux & Dove, Pears & Liril and Lifebuoy, respectively.
The soaps category in India is a mature category with ~100% penetration in urban India and ~99% in rural India. The category is growing at a moderate rate of ~10% per annum. We believe that with HUL’s share being far ahead of its competitor’s share (~10% share in FY12), it would continue to grow ahead of the category led by extension of the company’s product portfolio into premium products and increasing rural reach.
Exhibit 10: HUL’s brand portfolio for soaps
Brand
Breeze
Dove
Hamam
Lifebuoy
Liril
Lux
Pears
Rexona
Variants
Lemon Twist, Rose Mallika, Sandal Sparsh,
Rajni Gandha
Details
Launched in 1988
Bar & Skin Cleansing, Hair Care, Deodrants Leading brand of Unilever globally, fastest growing hair category brand in India
Sampoorna Snan, Scrub Bath, Abhyangana
Snan
Core Soaps, Handwash, Skin guard, clear skin
Only herbal soap brand with ~| 400 crore sales; 21.4% market share in Tamil Nadu
Undisputed leader in soaps market in India
(18.4% share); consumer base of ~140 mn households in India
Liril 2000 soap One of the oldest soap brands in India
Strawberry & Cream, Peach & Cream, Lotus
& Cream, International
A US$1 bn brand, it is the largest selling & No.1 soap brand in India
Pears Pure & Gentle, Pears Germ Shield,
Pears Oil Clear
Rexona Green, Rexona White
Has extended the brand to liquid soaps and shower gels.
Launched as early as 1947
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Going forward, we expect HUL’s soap sales to gain traction driven by increasing consumer preference towards liquid and premium soaps. We expect the volume led growth to be 4.2% (CAGR FY12-14E) and value growth to be 8.3% (CAGR FY12-14E). HUL’s volume growth in soaps has been 2.5% (CAGR CY07-FY12). However, the strength in the brands aided the value growth of 9.1% (CAGR CY07-FY12).
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 7
Exhibit 11: Soaps volume (LHS) and value growth (RHS)
6000
4000
On a annnualised basis, sales volumes dipped in FY09 &
FY10 and HUL lost market share by ~600 bps due to down trading by consumers. Howeve, aggressive marketing & strong brand equity has helped it ro regain its share in FY11 and FY12
41.5
2000
2.1
2381
6.8
2543
10.5
2809
8.3
3792 3041 4535 4302 3554 3727
0
CY04 CY05 CY06 CY07 FY09* FY10
-2000
Soaps (mn nos.)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
-13.4
Soaps (| crore)
5.7
3855 3940
FY11
4181
Soaps Value Growth (%)
9.2
4303
FY12
9.3
4362 4706
FY13E
4539
FY14E
45
30
15
0
-15
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Margin expansion for S&D to remain constricted
HUL’s margins from S&D have declined from 17.3% (CY04) to 11.6%
(FY12) on the back of increasing competition in the segment. The company undertook a significant price increase (~15% for FY12) to pull back margins to ~12% in FY12. Going ahead, we expect increasing competitive intensity and higher advertisement expenses (to promote usage of premium laundry products and newer products in pre and post wash categories) in S&D to keep margins capped at current levels until
FY14E.
Exhibit 12: Contribution to PBIT (percentage of total PBIT) and PBIT from S&D (percentage of gross sales)
Cut-throat price war with P&G led to the margin erosion
Margins dented drastically due to exceptional increase in RM costs from Q4FY11 onwards.
Substantial price hike to pass on the input cost pressure and introduction of premium products helped in margin improvement
17.3
45
13.8
38
13.8
39
15.3
44
15.0
46
14.3
42
9.5
30
11.6
37
25
20
15
10
5
0
CY04 CY05 CY06 CY07
Contrbution to overall PBIT from S&D (%) - LHS
FY09* FY10 FY11
S&D PBIT margins (% of gross sales) -RHS
FY12
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 8
HUL’s personal care business includes sales products under categories of hair care, skin care, oral care, grooming and other beauty services
Personal products: Biggest winners for HUL
Personal products contribute 31.5% (FY12) to HUL’s revenues and 52.2%
(FY12) to PBIT. With the PP segment expected to witness growth of
~19% CAGR 2011-15 (source: Report from Research on India, February,
2012) and HUL being the market leader in key categories, we expect
HUL’s revenues from the segment to grow at a CAGR of 18.8% (FY12-
14E). HUL’s constant effort at reshaping its PP portfolio through relaunching brands, extending established brands to growth categories and attracting consumers through integrated communication channel
(Annexure) has led HUL’s PP revenues to grow at a CAGR of 15.7%
(CY04-FY12).
Exhibit 13: Personal care segment- A snapshot across categories with respective brands
Category
Hair Care
Brand
Clear
Skin Care
Hair care & Skin Care
Oral Care
Men's grooming
Women's Grooming
Cosmetics
Sunsilk
Clinic Plus
Fair & Lovely
Pond's
Vaseline
Lakme
Dove
Close Up
Pepsodent
Axe
Rexona
Aviance
Services
Others
Lakme Salons
Lever Ayush Therapy
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Variants
Women (Soft & Shiny, Dry & Damaged, Anti-Hair Fall); Men
(Cool Sport, Hair Fall Defense, Itch Control); Unisex (Active
Care, Cool Menthol)
Soft & Smooth, Thick & Long, Damaged Repair, Hair Fall
Solution, Black Shine, Anti-Dandruff
Strong & Long, Anti Dandruff
Fair & Lovely Multivitamin, Ayurvedic Balance, Antimarks,
Menz Active, Winter Fairness Cream
Details & Market Position
World's No.1 anti-dandruff shampoo; reaches out to more than 1 billion people across the globe
Launched in 1964, No. 1 in Asia, latin America & Middle East
Largest selling shampoo brand in India, Most widely distributed shampoo brand in India
World's first fairness cream and is the market leader
Brand is synonymous with skin care Is exsistent since 1846
Skin Cleansing, Skin Lightening, Anti-ageing, Moisturising
Moisturiser, Lip Care, Petroleum Jelly
Lakme 9 to 5, Lakme Range, Lakme Bridal Sutra
Bathing Range, Hair Care Range & Deodrants Range
Close Up Red, Lemon Mint, Menthol, Milk Calcium
Largest selling body lotion in India
First major beauty brand in India
Launched the hair care range in 2007, Fastest growing shampoo brand in the country.
First gel toothpaste in India, market leader in gel segment for ~3 decades
Launched in 1993 and is among the most trusted brands in India GermiCheck, Whitening, Kids, Gumcare, Sensitive, Center
Fresh
After Shave Lotion & Deodrant
Rexona Green, Rexona White
Prestige, Skin Care, Hair Care & Color Range
No.1 male deodrant brand in India; Available in 60 countries
Extended the brand to deodorants and roll-ons
An exquisite range of high technology, high performance expert beauty solutions
Offers hair, skin and beauty solution
Has 5 categories across health & personal care range Endorsed by Arya Vaidya Pharmacy, Coimbatore
Exhibit 14: Personal products volume growth (%) - Quarterly
Personal products have witnessed exceptional volume growth over the quarters. This is due to the company’s aggressive expansion of the portfolio across categories and constant innovation within existing categories
25
20
15
10
5
0
23
19
18
11
4
15
13
15
19
11
15
20
16
19
18
14
17 17
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Page 9
Exhibit 15: PP brands across segments and value chain
Skin Care
Premium
Hair Care Oral Care
Popular
Mass
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
HUL’s presence across all categories of the PP segment with one strong brand in each category provides it an edge over competitors
Exhibit 16: HUL's dominance in segment
Players Bath &
Shower
Yes
Color
Cosmetic
Colgate Palmolive (India)
Dabur India Ltd.
Emami Ltd.
Gillette Ltd.
Godrej Consumer Products
HUL
ITC
Beiersdorf AG
L'Oreal
Johnson & Johnson
P&G Home Products
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Source: Research on India, ICICIdirect.com Research
Fragrance
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Hair Care Oral
Care
Yes Yes
Yes Yes
Skin
Care
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Men's
Grooming
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 10
Exhibit 17: Presence across growth categories
Category
Face Wash
Hand & Body
Handwash
Premium Skin Lightening
Anti-Aging
Conditioners
Size (| crore)
900
2300
250
800
250
250
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Growth Rate (%)
50
30
30
30
30
30
CY10 CY11
Skin care
HUL’s skin care portfolio comprises some of the strongest and oldest brands, Lakme, Fair and Lovely, Pond’s and Vaseline. It has been extending its existing mother brands’ strength to newer products targeting the aspirational beauty customers and capitalising on the growing opportunity in the categories of premium skin lightening (CAGR of ~42% CY08-11), hand and body lotion (CAGR of ~24% CY08-11) and face wash (CAGR of ~41% CY09-11).
Skin care products in India have a remarkably lower per-capita consumption of
€
0.6 compared to China and Indonesia at
€
5.9 and
€
3.2, respectively. Further, the monthly penetration of skin care products stands at only 45% (CY11) against 79% annually. Hence, we believe that increasing daily consumption would drive the increase in per capita consumption spend as well as penetration. With HUL’s presence across the value pyramid, we expect the company to benefit from the categories growth in both rural and urban India.
Exhibit 19: Skin care consumption per capita– Euros
100
80
60
40
20
0
Exhibit 18: All-India skin care penetration (%)
Increasing affluence is driving growth through multiple usage within a day, using variety of products (face wash, face cream, body wash) and increasing rural usage
(especially fairness creams) in small sachets, hence driving penetration
79 79
Annual
48 45
Monthly
65 63
Dec Qtr
10
8
6
4
2
0
5.3
5.9
China
2.7
3.2
Indonesia
CY2010 CY2011
0.6
0.6
India
Source: IMRB Fact Book, Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
HUL's Brands
Pears, Lakme, Ponds
Vaseline, Lakme, Dove
Lifebuoy, Pears, Lux, Hamam
Ponds, Lakme
Ponds
Dove, Sunsilk, Clinic Plus
Source: Euromonitor, Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 11
HUL’s market share in shampoos (2012)
Dabur
L'Oreal
4%
8%
ITC
1%
Cavin Kare
10%
HUL
46%
P &G
31%
Source: Business Standard, A.C. Nielsen, ICICI Direct Research
HUL is the market leader in shampoos with brands at all price points. With increasing demand for premium products in urban markets and increasing rural penetration of shampoos, growth in this category would continue to maintain momentum
Exhibit 20: All India Hair Care Penetration (CY10) in %
Hair Care
HUL is the leader in shampoos category (46% share by value) with its oldest brand Clinic Plus. Clinic Plus is the largest selling and most widely distributed shampoo brand in India. HUL also has a strong foothold in the anti-dandruff shampoo segment. Further, HUL’s entry into the high growth hair conditioners segment (CAGR of ~30% CY08-11) and extension of Dove into premium hair care products has contributed significantly to HUL’s growth in this category.
Comparing the per capita consumption of shampoos in India (
€
0.5) with other growing economies, China (
€
1.7) and Indonesia (
€
1.6), we believe there is a vast growth opportunity in the segment. Also, with the penetration of shampoos increasing at a faster pace than hair oil, HUL’s leadership position would help it to accelerate revenues from this segment. Having brands across all price points would aid in tapping consumers both in the rural and urban markets as penetration increases.
Exhibit 21: Shampoo penetration (CY10) – US$ & shampoo sales contribution in percentage (January, 2012)
100
80
60
40
Penetration is set to increase with the launch of recruiter packs in almost all hair care products especially in rural India.
Products
Shampoos
Hair Oil/Dressing
Penetration
Urban Rural
Jan-Jul,2010 Jan-Jul, 2011 Jan-Jul,2010 Jan-Jul, 2011
88 89 82 84
89 89 83 83
20
0
88 89
Annual
60 63
Monthly
CY10 CY11
75 79
Dec Qtr
Bottles
Sachets
Contribution by variant (%) - Jan, 2012
Value Wise (%)
54
46
Volume wise (%)
26
74
\
Source: IMRB Fact Book, , Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Source: Euromonitor, Business Standard, A.C, Nielsen Data,ICICIdirect.com Research
Exhibit 22: Shampoo market in India, 2012 (| crore) Exhibit 23: Shampoo consumption per capita– Euros
4500
3600
2700
1800
900
0
1987
2286
CAGR 15%
2629
3024
3478
4000
Jan, 2007 Jan, 2008 Jan, 2009 Jan, 2010 Jan, 2011 Jan, 2012
Source: Business Standard, A.C, Nielsen Data, ICICIdirect.com Research
1
0.5
0
2
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.5
1.6
Being the market leader in shampoos would help HUL to capitalise on this opportunity
0.4
0.5
China Indonesia
CY2010 CY2011
India
Source: Company, Euromonitor, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 12
Exhibit 24: All-India oral care penetration (FY10) in %
Oral Care
HUL occupies second position (~30% share by value in FY11) in the
~| 4400 crore (FY12) oral care market. HUL’s nearest competitor in oral care is Colgate-Palmolive India Ltd with a market share of ~55% by volume (FY12). With P&G postponing its plans to re-enter the toothpaste market in India, lower penetration (~55% for toothpastes) and per capita consumption (~138 gm per annum) in India there is sizeable scope for
HUL to grow. HUL expects to stimulate growth in the premium oral care portfolio by re-launching its existing products and increasing promotional activity.
In India, currently only 55% of the Indian population uses toothpaste among which only 15% brush twice daily in contrast to the developed markets where ~97% people use toothpaste and ~87% brush twice daily.
Hence, if toothpaste penetration increases to ~75% and brushing twice daily increases to ~35%, the toothpaste market (~|2700 crore in CY11) alone could double from current levels.
There is also a huge untapped market for premium oral care products with an increasing shift in urban consumption towards value-added toothpastes like gels (HUL is the leader in gel toothpastes with its brand
Close-Up), mouth washes, dental floss & teeth whitening products (HUL has limited presence). Rural India is witnessing growth with consumers shifting from twigs and toothpowders to toothpastes.
Exhibit 25: Oral care consumption per capita (FY10) – US$
100
80
60
40
20
0
Though penetration on an annual basis is high, the increase in monthly and daily consumption would be the key growth driver.
89 91
Annual
60 63
Monthly
CY10
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
CY11
78 80
Dec Qtr
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
The huge opporunity is characterized by lower consumption. Being the No.2 player, opportunity for growth is sustainable.
3.3
China
1.7
Indonesia
0.4
India
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Led by strong prospective demand across PP categories and HUL’s constant effort to drive sales through re-shaping its portfolio, extension of its brand equity into higher growth categories and attracting consumers through integrated communication channel, we expect revenues from PP to grow at a CAGR of 18.8% (FY12-14E). The growth would be chiefly volume driven (14.7% CAGR FY12-14E) as intense competition in PP would cap price led growth.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 13
Exhibit 26: Personal products volume and value growth (%)
50
40
30
20
-10
-20
10
0
11.4
2.6
CY04
26.0
19.4
CY05
13.8
21.7
CY06
9.7
10.0
CY07
45.6
34.8
FY09*
Personal Products Vol growth
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
-6.0
FY10
-10.3
15.8
15.1
FY11
Personal Products Value Growth
17.1
9.5
FY12E
17.8
15.3
FY13E
19.7
14.0
FY14E
PP is the largest contributor to HUL’s margins with ~51% share in FY12, having increased from ~45% in CY04. We believe HUL’s strong brand equity across the PP portfolio and expansion in the high growth and premium categories would sustain margins.
Exhibit 27: Profit before interest & tax (PBIT) and its contribution to HUL’s overall PBIT from PP segment
40
30
20
10
0
60
50
32.7
46
CY04
28.6
47
CY05
28.1
27.7
48 46
CY06 CY07
Contribution to overall PBIT from PP (%) - LHS
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
26.6
25.7
25.6
45 46 55
FY09* FY10
PP PBIT margins (% of gross sales) -RHS
FY11
25.5
52
FY12
Page 14
35
28
21
14
7
0
The organised coffee market in India is around | 950 crore, or 30% of the total domestic coffee consumption of | 3,000 crore (Source: Hindu, September, 2011)
In the branded tea sector in India, Tata Tea (Tata Global
Beverages) is the market leader with 19.5% (volume) closely followed by HUL. (Source: Financial Express, June,
2012)
PREMIUM
POPULAR
MASS
HUL has ventured into coffee retailing by opening eight pilot coffee outlets, Bru World Café, in Mumbai. Based on the response to these, the company would decide on national expansion of the franchisee
Beverages: ‘Bru’ing the premium market
Beverages contribute 12.0% to HUL’s revenues (FY12) and 11.0% to PBIT.
This segment constitutes sales of tea and coffee under the brands Lipton,
Taj Mahal, Red Label, Brooke Bond and Bru (only coffee brand). HUL’s revenue growth from this segment has been moderate at 11.9% CAGR
CY04-FY12, largely price led. Tea volume growth during the same period was -1.9% CAGR with price led growth (tea) being 7.7% CAGR CY04-
FY12.
Lately, HUL has been actively ramping up its beverages portfolio to tap the budding under-penetrated coffee consumption in the country. Hence, we expect the contribution of coffee in beverages sales to increase and growth in tea sales volume to remain subdued. Going ahead, we expect beverage revenues to increase at 10.5% (CAGR FY12-14E).
Exhibit 28: HUL's beverages product portfolio
Brand
Brooke Bond
Sub Brand Variants
Red label Dust, Natural Care & Special
3 Roses
TajMahal
Taaza
Mind Sharp & Natural care
Taaza Leaf & Taaza Dust
Sehatmand
Bru (Only coffee brand of HUL)
Lipton
Roast & Ground, Instant, Gold,
Gold, Exotica, Lite,Select, Ice
Cappuccino, Hot Cappuccino
Yellow Label, Green Tea,
Darjelling Tea, Iced Tea
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Market Position
Second largest tea brand in India, 107 year old brand
HUL's largest food brand; market leader in
Tamil Nadu & South India
Most Premium tea brand in India
Twenty year old brand with strong presence in north, west & east India. Fourth largest tea brand in India
Tea brand enriched with vitamins
Launched in 1962 under the name Deluxe
Green Label; No. 1 coffee brand in India
Lipton is world's No.1 tea brand
India is largely a tea consuming nation with tea penetration as high as
96% and coffee penetration only at 12-15% (The Hindu, September,
2011). Coffee consumption is largely an urban phenomenon with consumption growing at ~20% per annum compared to tea where consumption is increasing at only 2-3% per annum. We believe HUL’s sales of tea gardens have also impacted the company’s revenue growth negatively. Since the company sold its tea gardens in 2005 tea prices have been on an uptrend, which has consequently increased HUL’s cost of purchases, hurting the PBIT from the segment. Currently, HUL is aggressively aiming to tap the rising trend of coffee consumption at home
(largely high end premium demand) and cafés.
‘Bru’, the 50 year old coffee brand of HUL, is rapidly being extended to the premium end coffee market. Currently, there is just one brand in the premium segment, Nescafe Gold by Nestle India (HUL’s nearest competitor) and HUL is aiming to capture this opportunity to tap into the increasing trend of consuming high-end coffee at home. It is also expanding through opening coffee retail chains under the name ‘Bru Café
World’ (Annexure)
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 15
Exhibit 29: Beverages (tea & coffee) and tea sales growth for HUL
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
-10
-20
-30
0.9
CY04
6.9
CY05
4.2
CY06
15.8
CY07
48.9
FY09*
-6.6
FY10
Tea sales volume growth (%) Tea sales value growth (%)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
9.4
FY11
11.7
FY12
Beverages Sales Growth (tea & coffee)-%
12.6
FY13E
8.4
FY14E
We expect beverages sales to grow at 10.5% CAGR FY12-14E largely led by higher realisation from tea (10.5% CAGR FY12-14E) with tea volumes remaining muted (CAGR -0.6% FY12-14E). Further, we also believe that with the shift in consumer consumption to coffee (~25% of beverage sales in FY12E) and a steadily evolving café culture, the contribution of coffee sales would increase in total beverage sales.
We expect margins from the beverages segment to remain under pressure until FY14E due to mounting commodity prices (tea and coffee beans) and limited ability of HUL to pass on the complete impact of commodity inflation with the risk of losing market share to the market leader (Tata Global Beverages) and the unorganised market. Moreover, higher investments on brand building and investments in ‘Bru Café World’ for coffee would keep earnings growth from the segment capped.
Exhibit 30: PBIT margins from beverages and segment’s PBIT contribution to HUL’s overall PBIT
15
12
9
6
3
0
20.0
19.0
16.6
14.9
13.7
CY04
13.6
11.2
10.4
CY05 CY06 CY07
Contribution to overall PBIT from Beverages (%) - LHS
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
13.4
14.9
15.3
9.6
11.4
13.1
FY09* FY10 FY11
Beverages PBIT margins (% of gross sales) -RHS
14.0
11.0
FY12
Page 16
20
16
12
8
4
0
POPULAR
MASS
Foods: Building strength
HUL’s foods business contributes 6.3% (FY12) to revenues and less than
1% to PBIT (FY12). The portfolio comprises products in processed foods
(Kissan, Knorr and Annapurna), frozen dessert (Kwality Walls) and bakery
(Modern Foods) categories. Revenues from the foods segment have grown at a healthy rate of 20.2% CAGR (CY04-FY11). We expect the segment’s overall growth to be maintained at 19.7% CAGR (FY12-14E) led by a combination of volume and price growth in frozen desserts at 10.2% and 11.1% CAGR FY12-14E and a higher price led growth over volumes in processed foods at 11.8% and 6.1% CAGR FY12-14E, respectively.
Exhibit 31: Foods portfolio of brands and products
Brand
Annapurna
Kissan
Knorr
Kwality Walls
Modern
Sub Brand Variants
Annapurna Salt Iodised Salt, Crystal Salt, Low
Sodium Salt, Captain Cook
Annapurna Atta Farm Fresh & Multi Grain
Creamy Spread, Jams, Ketchup,
Soya Juice
Classic, Chinese, Indian, Meal makers, Soupy Noodles
Cornetto, Feast, Paddle Pop,
Selections
White -Family Shakti, Oven Fresh,
Regular
Premium -Milk, Butter, Kairali
Health & Wellness -Atta Shakti, 7
Must, Whole Wheat, Brown
Fun/Taste, Sweet, Cream Rolls
Cakes, Cookies, Rusks
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Market Position
Crystal Salt has a presence largely in South India
Tough competition from ITC's Aashirvaad
75th year in India; category leaders in India
Largest soup brand in India with ~70% share of the country's soup market
Kwality Walls present in India since 1993 and has
~18% share by value (FY11)
India's No.1 brand in breads
Exhibit 32: Foods sales (| crore) and growth (%)
2000
49.1
1500
34.4
26.7
1000
235.1
231.0
500
10.1
98.1
313.7
CY05
137.1
384.9
CY06
161.5
0
-500
88.9
285.1
CY04
540.1
CY07
810.7
FY09*
730.8
FY10
-8.0
Foods (| crore) - excl ice creams Ice-creams (| crore)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
274.6
22.4
902.6
FY11
354.3
15.5
1005.1
FY12
Foods (total) - value growth (%)
441.9
22.9
1229.3
FY13E
531.0
16.5
1416.0
FY14E
Low-margin nature of atta business compelled HUL to withdraw the brand from the north Indian markets
HUL faces strong competition in the soups and noodles category from the market leader, Nestle (~85% share)
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
HUL’s foods revenues (excluding ice-creams) grew at a CAGR of 19.7%
(CY04-FY12) driven by price growth of 23.6% and meagre volume growth of -3.1%. Though it is the market leader in the ketchup and spreads category (Kissan), the branded staples (Annapurna), soups, noodles
(Knorr) and bakery (Modern) products have been a drag on the
Page 17
50
40
30
20
10
0
-10
The per capita ice-cream consumption (value and volume) in
India is significantly low. However, the changing consumption pattern (increasing demand for ice-cream parlours and exotic take home flavours) has helped ice cream sales in the country to witness a CAGR of ~15% from | 1429 crore in 2007 to | 2500 crore in 2011. (Source: Business Standard, March, 2012). company’s portfolio. Foods, as a whole, are not a big money-spinner for
HUL compared to its parent (51% of Unilever’s revenues in FY11) but the company is baking revival plans for its brands through re-launching, thereby entailing huge brand investments, going ahead.
Though there is a slowdown in the packaged foods portfolio for HUL
(volumes), ice-cream sales have been hearty recording volume growth of
13.3% and value growth of 21.8% (CAGR CY04-FY12). With HUL occupying ~18% (FY11) of the branded ice-cream market (~| 1500 crore in FY11), we expect price led sales growth to be higher at 11.1% (CAGR
FY12-14E) and volume growth of 10.2% (CAGR FY12-14E).
Exhibit 33: Ice-cream volume sales (million litres) and growth (%)
35
30
25
20
15
10
-5
-10
5
0
11.0
15.0
15.0
CY04 CY05 CY06
17.0
22.0
22.0
CY07 FY09* FY10
23.0
FY11
26.4
29.3
32.1
50
40
30
20
10
FY12 FY13E FY14E
0
-10
Ice-creams (LHS) Ice-creams Vol Growth (RHS) Ice-creams Value Growth (RHS)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
* FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
Exhibit 34: Per capita ice cream consumption (FY11)- US$ Exhibit 35: Per capita Ice cream consumption (FY11)- litres/per annum
4
3
2
3.3
1.7
28
21
14
26
1 7
0.4
0.6
0.3
0 0
China Indonesia India USA Pakistan India
Source: Business Standard, March,2012, ICICIdirect.com Research
The size of the water purifier market in India is ~ | 3500 crore (FY12). The market leader in purifiers is Eureka
Forbes with ~52% share
Source: Business Standard, March,2012, ICICIdirect.com Research
Water business: Exploring and growing
HUL entered the water purifier segment in 2008 with its brand ‘Pureit’ and has seven models in the segment ranging from | 900-13000 crore. This is currently a small revenue business for the company. Its direct competitor in this business is Eureka Forbes and Tata Group’s Swach (priced at | 899 and | 1199). HUL ventured into the segment to provide safe drinking water across the globe (HUL’s sustainable action plan) and tap the share from the ~| 13000 crore bottled water market.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 18
With numerous brands present across categories, HUL has garnered the complete value pyramid in each category by having products across each price point. It has efficiently used the brand extension strategy to reach out to consumers across the pyramid by launching a brand in a particular category initially (for instance: Vaseline body lotion in the popular category) and further extending the established brand equity to other segments (men’s range) and a position in the value chain (from popular to premium).
Similarly, the extension of its premium soap brand ‘Dove’ to premium hair care range (shampoos, conditioners and expected to enter hair oils) was done in 2007. HUL launched the Dove soap in India in 1993, positioning it as a premium range of soap. In 2007, with the established brand positioning in the consumer’s mind it ventured into the premium hair care range by launching Dove shampoos. Dove Shampoo has been recognised as the fastest growing shampoo in the country.
The company also extended its Surf brand (initially a popular segment brand) to the premium category through Surf Excel, Surf Blue and Surf
Excel Matic. Having done this, it slowly phased out Surf and now markets
Rin in the popular segment.
Hence, the company has efficiently introduced and re-shuffled its portfolio periodically to garner the upcoming demand (Surf for machines, Pond’s
Age Miracle targeting the older working women) and simultaneously addressing all segments of the society. We believe this gives HUL an edge over competitors in times of up trading and down trading by consumers.
Exhibit 36: Product portfolio in each category and segment
Premium
Detergents
Brands
Prices (per kg)
Brands
Soaps
Surf Excel Blue;Excel Matic; Surf Quick Wash
|123; |213; |170
Dove; Pears
Shampoos
Skin Care
Oral Care
Tea
Coffee
Processed Foods
Ice-Creams
Prices (per 100gm) |56; |43-45
Brands Dove, Tresemme; Clear;Sunsilk Keritanilogy
Prices (100 ml)
Prices
|60-80; |55-65; |60-65; |100
Brands Red Label 3 Roses Natural, Lipton Yellow
Label.Green & Darjelling,Brooke Bond Tajmahal
Prices (per 500gm) |200; |275-|550; |200
Brands Bru Gold, Bru Exotica
Prices
Brands
100gm- |200; 100gm- |300-640
Kissan Spreads, Knorr Soups & Meal Makers
Prices (per 100gm) |33; 100gm-|66-83
Brands Selections, Shahi Delights
1litre- |145-215; 1 kg- |400-460
Popular
Rin (Powder); Rin Matic; Sunlight (Powder)
|77; |98
Lux, Liril; Lifebuoy Clinic care
|32; |36; |30-36
Sunsilk
|45-|62
Brands
Prices (100 ml)
Brands
Vaseline Men's,Lakme,Pond's White Beauty & age miracle
|58-300; |115-350; |100-575;
Close-Up (Freeze,Calcium & Lemon Mint);
Pepsodent (Whitening,kids & expert)
Prices (per 100gm) |47-50; |60-70
Vaseline, Pears; Axe men; Pond's popular range;
Fair & Lovely
|75-85; |55-85; |75-200; |45-100; |105-192
Pepsodent (2 in1 & germi check)
100 gm- |35-45
Red Label 2 roses
|120-175
Bru Instant,Choco Mint; Mochaberg
100gm -|175; 100gm- |80; 100 gm- |80
Kissan Jam & Ketchup; Knorr Noodles
|20-25; |11-20; 17-22
Cornetto; Chocobar; Feast; Fruit & Nut
~35-70 gm- |25-|70
Mass
Active Wheel; Active Wheel Gold
|42; |50
Rexona; Hamam
|22-23; |23
Clinic Plus
|35-|50
Fair & Lovely recruiter packs
Close-Up recruiter packs
15 gm - |5
Brookebond Sehatmand, Arogya & Ruby
Bru recruiter packs
12gm- |8-10
Kissan ketchup (packs of ~10 gm)
|1 packs
Fruitarre, Paddle Pop, Walls cups
~40-50 gm- |10-15; 20-40gm- |5-10
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 19
Exhibit 37: An example (detergents) of how consumer up-trading is benefiting HUL due to its presence across the pyramid
Increasing affluence in cities is driving the shift to usage of premium products (detergents for machine wash and liquid detergents)
Rising middle income population in semi-urban and rural areas leads to the shift in consumption from mass to popular products
Branded
Unbranded
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
The increasing shift of rural consumers from un-branded to affordable branded products is delivering well for HUL with a presence in the mass segment with brands
Wheel’ and ‘Sunlight’. This conversion is getting ramped up with the availability of | 1 packs, which are helping to increase the daily and monthly detergents penetration
Page 20
HUL is extending its presence in the premium segment across all categories, tapping the demand arising out of the changing demographics of the Indian consumer. Along with inclusion of premium products in the portfolio it is also extending its offerings to higher growth segments by building on its existing brand equity in the respective segment. HUL’s portfolio of premium products is relatively larger than any of its competitors. Hence, we believe that increasing premiumisation across
FMCG categories would considerably benefit this brand-master.
Exhibit 38: HUL's premium product offerings across segments
Segment
Detergents
Soaps
Shampoos
Skin Care
Oral Care
Product
Surf Excel Blue, Surf Quick wash & Excel Matic
Dove & Pears
Dove, Clear, Tresemme, Sunsilk Keritonology
Vaseline Men's Range,Lakme, Pond's White Beauty
Close-Up, Pepsodent
Tea
Coffee
Red Label natural, Lipton Yellow, Green & Darjelling, Brooke Bond Tajmahal
Bru Gold, Bru Exotica
Processed Foods Kissan Spreads, Knorr Soups & Meal Makers
Ice-Creams Selections, Shahi Delights
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Price
1 kg- |125-|170
100 gm -|43-56
100 ml - |55-100
100 ml- |58 - |575
100 gm- |47-70
500 gm- |200-550
100gm- |200-640
100 gm- |33-83
1 litre- |145-460
Competitors
P&G. Jyothy Lab (Henko)
ITC (Vivel), P&G (Olay)
P&G (Head & Shoulders), Lo'real
Johnson & Jhnson (Neutrogena), Orflame, Emami
Colgate (Active Salt, sensitive, Max Fresh)
Tata Global (Tata Tea)
Nestle (Nestle Gold), Davidoff; Lavazza
Nestle (Maggi Pazzata), Fun n Food Spreads
Amul , Baskin Robbins
Exhibit 39: Driving mix through premiumisation
Skin Cleansing Laundry Skin Care (Face) a t i s i o n
P r e m i u m
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 21
Exhibit 40: Skin care (Face)
Market Construct (%)
20
30
50
Premium
Mid
Mass
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Though the premium category is relatively the smallest in size it has the highest growth potential with the increasing demand shift of consumers especially in urban India
Market CAGR 2009-11 (%)
40
35
10
Exhibit 41: India premium F&B markets future outlook
10%
Share in overall packaged F&B
16%
500
400
300
200
100
0
140
26% p.a.
450
FY11
Prem. F&B mkt in | bn
FY16E
Source: Brand Equity, ICICIdirect.com Research
Exhibit 42: Per capita spending on premium cosmetics ($/capita)
Thailand
Brazil
China
Nigeria 0.3
3.1
3.5
10.9
There is a huge scope to increase the per capita consumption of premium products with the rate of increase in income and work force labour in India expected to be higher than other developing nations
India 0.2
0 2 4
Source: Economic Times, ICICIdirect.com Research
6 8 10 12
According to a report by McKinsey Global Research Institute (MGI), urban
India is witnessing rapid growth in global consumers (annual household income of more than | 10,00,000) who have tastes and preferences similar to that of the rich across the world. By 2025, the number of these global consumers in urban India is expected to increase at a CAGR of
14% and reach ~15 million (~1.1 million in 2005). Further, the total real disposable income and consumption of global households is estimated to increase more than 12x. Hence, we believe the upsurge in this class would keep up the demand for premium products across categories.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 22
Exhibit 43: Urban global class to witness rapid growth
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
1.1
1.7
14%
3.4
6.9
14.6
2005E 2010F 2015F 2020F 2025F
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
According to Brand Equity analysis of 86 million urban households in
FY11, ~22% belonged to the poor category (deprived), ~76% to the middle and upper middle class (aspirers, seekers and strivers) and mere
2% to the rich class. However, with the changing demographics of the country the proportion is expected to transform to ~15% poor, ~87% to the middle and upper middle class and ~3% to the rich. Also, the number of urban households is expected to increase by ~40%.
Exhibit 44: India income pyramid
No. of Urban household (HH) in Mn
123
*Figures in brackets are the estimated per capita income,
FY11, in | lakh
86
1.5
2.1
21
42
19
FY2011
Clear to Super Rich (more than 7.7)
Near Rich (3.8-7.7)
Seekers & Strivers (0.8-3.8)
Aspirers (0.4-0.8)
Deprived (less than 0.4*)
Source: Brand Equity, ICICIdirect.com Research
4.2
5.3
40
62
19
FY2016E
~5.3 million households with per capita income greater than
US national per capita income in 2010 on PPP basis
Earnings of women in India (in $ trillion)
2011 13
2016E 18
Average monthly income of urban Indian women
(|)
2001 4492
2010 9457
Projected growth in new entrants in workforce in next 30 years
Women
Men
38%
33%
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
We believe this income shift for the population would be driven by the increasing per capita income ($1527 in 2011 and is expected to increase at the rate of ~13% per annum), faster urbanisation (30% by 2008 to increase to ~40% by 2030), rising young working population (India is expected to add a workforce of ~170 million from 2005-2025), more working women and trending towards nuclear family culture. Hence, these changes would increase the affordability, acceptability, awareness and availability among Indian consumers leading to evolution of new categories and shifting demand across and categories apart from uptrading (premiumisation).
Page 23
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Keeping the changing trends in mind, HUL’s early move of extending its established brand equity (across segments) to higher growth segments has helped the company to clock impressive growth rate across categories and maintain healthy volume growth consecutively over the quarters (FY10-12).
Exhibit 45: HUL's presence and extension into high growth categories
Segment
Facewashes
Handwashes
Hand & Body Care
Noodles
Premium Skin Lightening
Anti Aging
Conditioners
Tea Bags
Size (| crore)
>900
>250
>2300
>1700
>800
>250
>250
>140
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Segment
Growth
50%
30%
30%
30%
30%
30%
30%
40%
HUL's Brands & Products
Fair & Lovely, Lakme fruit, Dove, Pond's, Pears
Lifebuoy, Pears & Lux
Dove, Pond's, Lakme, Vaseline
Knorr
Pond's, Lakme, Fair & Lovely
Pond's
Dove, Clinic Plus, Sunsilk
Tajmahal
We believe the venture into the fast growing segments and strong presence in the existing segments would continue to provide HUL an edge over competitors, especially in the fastest growing (by volume) personal care segment, at a CAGR of 15.7% CY04-FY12. However, the company needs to pull up its strings to drive growth in foods (excluding ice-creams) and beverages (only tea) where volume growth has suffered a setback at -3.1% and -1.9% (CAGR CY04-FY12), respectively.
Page 24
HUL is targeting growth in the higher potential rural markets and actively expanding its network there through its initiatives of ‘Project Shakti’
(started in 2001), ‘Khushiyon ki Doli’ and ‘Project Express’. By the end of
2012, HUL’s Shakti network covered ~1,00,000+ villages across 15 states reaching ~5 million households (tripled its rural coverage in past two years) with ~45,000 Shaktiammas and ~30,000 Shaktimaans. Currently,
HUL generates almost 40% of its sales from rural India.
Exhibit 46: HUL’s rural initiatives
Project Shakti Khushiyon Ki Doli Project Express
45,000 Shaktiammas 70,000 villages HUL-Tata Tele Services Limited Alliance
30,000 Shaktimaans 25 million customers >20,000 markets across India
1,00,000 villages 4,00,000 retailers Rolled out in 4 states, 4 more WIP
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Rural Urban sales break-up (%)
Company
Dabur
Rural
40
Emami
HUL
Godrej Consumer
Marico
50
40
30
30
Urban
60
50
60
70
70
According to the Census of 2011, ~69% of India’s population resides in rural areas. In the past four years (FY08-12), India’s nominal GDP (at constant prices) has grown at a CAGR of 13.7% with the rural GDP CAGR being 14.0% and urban GDP CAGR being 13.6%.
According to a Crisil Research Report, the additional spending between
2009-10 and 2011-12 by rural India was | 3.75 lakh crore compared to urban India at | 2.9 lakh crore. The report also stated that there was a visible shift in rural consumption pattern from necessities to discretionary goods. Hence, we believe that with HUL’s highest presence in rural India among all FMCG players, it would be the largest beneficiary of this growing consumption.
We believe the government’s proactive measures in FY09 contributed significantly in driving the rural sales growth thereafter (FY09-12), especially in categories with lower penetration [skin care monthly penetration (CY11) at 45%, shampoos (CY11) at ~80%, and oral care
(FY11) at ~55%] and higher aspirational value. Further, there has also been an evident shift in the demand pattern of these consumers from unbranded to branded products across categories, benefiting players like
HUL who have a portfolio to cater across the value pyramid.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 25
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Exhibit 47: Measures taken by government to boost rural growth
Measures taken by the government
Per Capita Rural Subsidy (in |)
Growth (%)
Total Outgo in social spending (| crore)
Growth (%)
Budget allocation for MGNREGA (| crore)
Growth (%)
Government spending for rural social schemes (| crore)
Growth (%)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
FY07
972
FY08
1342
38.1
FY09
1965
46.4
FY10
2217
12.8
FY11
2365
6.7
154500 230100 263900 286200 344200
48.9
14.7
8.5
20.3
11250 11700 29700 39060 40095
4.0
153.8
31.5
2.6
61400 74000 79100 84900 120600
20.5
6.9
7.3
42.0
Exhibit 48: YoY increase in minimum support prices of crops (%)
Khariff Crop
Paddy
Jowar
Maize
Groundnut In Shell
Soyabeen
Rabi Crops
Wheat
2006-07
1.8
-
0.0
Moong
Urad
0.0
0.0
Cotton 0.6
0.0
0.0
Barley
Gram
Masur (Lentil)
15.4
2.7
0.7
0.7
Rapeseed/Mustard
Sugarcane@
0.0
0.9
Source: MOSPI, ICICIdirect.com Research
2007-08
11.2
11.71
14.8
11.8
11.8
1.7
2.0
1.1
33.3
15.0
10.7
10.0
5.0
1.2
2008-09
31.8
38.7
35.5
48.2
48.2
38.9
35.5
48.4
8.0
4.6
8.1
10.0
1.7
0.0
2009-10
11.8
0.0
0.0
9.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
1.9
10.3
1.7
0.0
0.0
59.9
2010-11
5.3
4.7
4.8
14.9
15.1
0.0
9.5
3.7
1.8
4.0
19.3
20.3
1.1
7.1
2011-12
8.0
11.1
11.4
10.4
10.3
12.0
17.4
17.9
2012-13
15.7
52.0
19.9
0.0
34.4
28.6
37.0
33.3
14.7
25.6
33.3
24.4
35.1
0.0
Further, the monthly per capita expenditure (MPCE) figures by NSSO for the first half of 2012 also show that growth in average MPCE in rural India has been 14.0% while that in urban India is 13.5% (during FY08-12). With
~40% of India’s total consumption currently accounted for by rural India, which is expected to grow by more than 10x to US$ ~10 billion by 2025, there lies a huge opportunity for retail spending.
Page 26
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
According to RBI data, India’s GDP growth is expected to slow down to
~6% in FY13E along with the growing concerns about negative real wage inflation and lack of employment opportunities. Further, if the government fails to take any populist measure (increase in MSP, Food Security Bill) in the upcoming Budget, we believe consumption growth would be effected. Hence, the robust volume growth witnessed by HUL in the past
10 quarters consecutively would face a setback. Also, any further increase in prices could lead to down trading by consumers, impacting sales growth. Hence, the company needs to remain cautiously strategic to manage its sales growth and margins simultaneously.
HUL has already been facing tough competition from P&G in the detergents space that has led to the company’s margins sliding from
~25% in CY04 to ~11% in FY12. Currently, with the attractiveness in the higher growth categories of personal products and rising aspirations of consumers for premium products it is facing challenges from players such as P&G in detergents and shampoos, ITC in soaps and skin care,
Godrej Consumer in soaps, Jyothy Laboratories in homecare, Nestle in coffee and Dabur in oral care. We believe that, going ahead, the intensifying competition could impact the margins of the company in each segment. Also, the company would have to keep its advertisement expenses higher in order to maintain its brand equity.
Being the market leader in S&D, skin care and hair care, HUL has commanded a pricing power in the industry. However, with early signs of an economic slowdown and volatility in input prices in the past year
(crude +11%, palm oil -14%, coffee -23%, tea +16%), margins could remain vulnerable. Further, the increasing competition in the FMCG space would continue to demand a higher advertisement expense for branded players to maintain their volume growth, keeping margin expansion capped from current levels.
With the packaging norms to kick in from November 1, 2012 the sales growth in larger packs could be impacted. Companies were tactfully sustaining margins by reducing the grammage in the products, keeping the same prices points of products. Hence forth the norms taking away this freedom from the companies, passing on prices could lead to slowdown in volume growth. Hence, in spite of being the market leader passing on higher costs and maintaining margins would be tough.
According to the Ministry of Food Processing of India, the Indian food industry is ~| 10,36,000 crore (FY10) growing at a CAGR of 8.1% (FY10-
15E). Among various food categories, packaged food is expected to record the highest growth at 24.4% per annum supported by the changing lifestyle of Indian consumers. Further, backed by the lower penetration of packaged foods currently we believe there lies a huge untapped opportunity for HUL, on which it has failed to capitalise.
In spite of HUL’s presence in the segment since inception and the parent
Unilever deriving ~50% of its revenues from food, HUL has been unable to capitalise on this opportunity.
Page 27
HUL’s revenues have grown at a CAGR of 11.8% from CY04 to FY12 led by an equal mix of volume and prices. However, with the company getting refreshed portfolio and brand extensions in the personal care and detergents segment, volume growth (average of ~9%) gained traction over price growth (~2%) in FY10-12. Going ahead, we expect revenues to grow at a CAGR of 11.4% (FY12-14E) led by an equal mix of prices and volumes.
Exhibit 49: Sales growth trend
27000
22500
18000
13500
9000
4500
0
-4500
-9000
9927
11061
11.4
CY05
9.4
12103
13675
13.0
CY07
48.0
20239
17524
19401
10.7
21736
12.0
23960
10.2
26954
12.5
CY04
-2.1
CY06 FY09 FY10
-13.4
FY11
Value Growth (%) - RHS
FY12 FY13E FY14E
Sales (| crore) - LHS
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
In the past, HUL’s volume growth has been an inverse function of prices
(Q1FY09-Q4FY11) but this trend changed during Q1FY12-Q1FY13 with strong volume growth in spite of price increases. We believe that the change was driven by the increasing market size of the company’s segments led by the shifting consumer preferences to liquid soaps, post wash detergents, liquid detergents, premium personal products and packaged foods along with HUL’s presence across the value pyramid.
Exhibit 50: Volume and realisation growth (quarterly) in %
20
15
10
10
5
0
8
11
7
15
2
18
17
2
10
1
6
4.6
0
10.9 10.3
14
13
14
0
8
6
10
8
9
7
10
9
-5
-5
-3
-3
-3
-2
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
-10
-20
-10
Volume Growth Realization Growth
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 28
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Going forward, we expect volume growth (CAGR FY12-14E) in soaps, personal products, foods and ice-creams to be higher at 4.2%, 17.2%,
6.1% and 10.2% against their past growth (CAGR CY04-FY12) of 0.6%,
15.3%, -4.6% and 13.1%, respectively. The higher volume growth would be driven by the company’s extension into high growth categories (in foods and personal products), a series of new launches and extending footprint in the faster growing rural markets. Volume growth for detergents and tea during the same period is expected to slide to 3.2% and -0.6%, from 7.3% and -0.4% (CAGR CY04-FY12), respectively.
HUL has maintained its raw material (RM) cost to sales ratio at ~54% over the years (CY04-FY12). In spite of an unprecedented increase in RM costs in FY12, the company’s strong brand equity across categories helped it to pass on the impact through higher prices simultaneously maintaining margins and volume growth. Going ahead, with HUL shifting its focus towards higher growth and premium product categories that would drive higher realisation, we expect raw material cost as a percentage of sales to decline to ~53% by FY14E.
Exhibit 51: Raw material cost to sales ratio
16
15
14
13
12
11
10
15.6
54.5
55.7
14.2
14.8
14.9
53.7
53.2
Inclusion of higher priced premium products would bring down the costs to sales ratio
14.7
53.4
15.5
50.7
13.7
51.8
14.9
54.0
15.2
53.7
15.3
52.8
CY04 CY05 CY06 CY07 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13E FY14E
EBITDA Margin (%) - RHS RM cost to sales (%)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
56
55
54
53
52
51
50
Along with higher realisation from a changing product mix, efficient cost management would also aid in reducing the operating expenses to sales ratio, aiding margins and earnings. Hence, we expect margins to improve by ~400 bps to 15.3% by FY14E and earnings growth to accelerate to
12.6% (CAGR FY12-14E) from 12.3% (CAGR CY04-FY12).
Page 29
Exhibit 52: PAT before exceptional items (| crore)
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
CY04 CY05 CY06 CY07 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13E FY14E
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
HUL’s advertisement expense to sales ratio has remained at an average of
~11% in CY04-FY12. We expect this to increase to ~14% of net sales in
FY13E and FY14E on the back of numerous new launches, entry into new categories and increasing competition.
In spite of increasing advertisement expenses we do not expect margins to get impacted as the gains from higher ad expenses in volumes and revenues (higher growth and margin products) would nullify the impact of increased expenses.
Exhibit 53: Advertisement Expenses to Sales ratio and EBITDA margins
12
8
4
0
20
16
15.6
8.4
CY04
14.2
9.1
14.8
10.5
14.9
10.5
14.7
10.5
15.5
13.6
13.7
14.2
14.9
12.1
15.2
13.8
15.3
14.5
CY05 CY06 CY07 FY09 FY10
Advertisment Expenses to Sales (%)
FY11 FY12
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
FY13E
EBITDA Margin (%)
FY14E
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Over the years, HUL has remained the biggest FMCG advertiser in the country thereby acquiring a substantial share of voice and mind of consumers that has enabled it to maintain sales growth in-spite of reducing its advertisement expenses (as percentage of sales) in FY12.
Though an increase in commodity prices in FY12 forced the company to cut back its ad expenses, we expect the higher margin products (premium products) to help it to maintain its advertisement expenditure and simultaneously manage margins.
Page 30
Historically, HUL’s dividend payout has been ~60% (FY09-12). We expect this to scale up to ~75% by FY14E on the back of no major capex plans of the company. We expect the EPS to increase to | 15.8 by FY14E against
| 12.5 in FY12. We believe that dividend for FY13E could jump to
| 11.5/share due to the high extraordinary income earned in Q1FY13E
(sale of property for | 604.7 crore), which the company could pay as special dividend (I-direct estimate: | 2.0/share). Thus, the increasing dividend per share (DPS) would consequently increase the dividend yield to 2.1% by FY14E from 1.3% in FY12.
Exhibit 54: Dividend per share and dividend yield trend
2.3
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
1.7
1.4
1.2
1.3
1.4
2.3
0.5
0.0
8.8
CY07
7.5
FY09
6.5
6.5
7.5
12.0
FY10
DPS (|) - RHS
FY11 FY12 FY13E
Dividend Yield (%) - LHS
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
12.0
FY14E
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
HUL’s return on equity (RoE) has been on a declining trend since FY09 falling from 121.1% to 76.6% in FY12 on the back of reducing dividend payout by the company. We believe the higher retention by the company has been under utilised thereby pulling down the return ratios. Though we expect the dividend payout to increase to ~74% (FY13E) and ~76%
(FY14E), the return ratios would remain at current levels (~77% in FY14E) as the increase in dividend payout is lower than the increase in earnings.
Accordingly, we believe that with no capex plans on board, the company should improve its cash utilisation.
Exhibit 55: Return on equity (%)
133.8
121.1
85.2
87.6
76.6
87.7
77.3
CY07 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13E FY14E
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*FY09 corresponds to 15 months data due to change in company’s reporting from CY to FY
Page 31
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
The stock has witnessed a significant run up (~73%) in the last 12 months led by company’s persistent high single/double digit volume growth (last
10 quarters), sustained margins and increasing market share across categories. At the CMP, the stock is trading at 34.9x FY13E and 36.1x
FY14E EPS of | 16.3 and | 15.8, respectively. We have valued HUL using the DCF methodology, as the stock is a long term play on the opportunity arising from the consumption boom in the country, and arrived at a target price of | 522.
At the current market price of | 571, with a WACC assumption of 10.1% the stock is discounting terminal growth of more than 6% or continuing high double digit growth in the near term. We believe the high volume growth (experienced in the last 10 quarters) would not sustain in the long run. Moreover, the 6% terminal growth is not justifiable. Therefore, it gives us a sense that the current market price has fairly discounted an optimistic future growth for the company.
We believe the simultaneous existence of underperforming markets (high liquidity being parked in defensives like HUL) and HUL’s high single digit/double digit volume growth has led to the run up in the stock price.
As the market conditions improve the money parked in defensives would be shifted to the undervalued sectors and stocks. Hence, though we remain confident on the company’s long term business performance, we believe that at the CMP the stock is richly valued.
According to our DCF based valuation, assuming a WACC of 10.1% and terminal growth of 6%, we have arrived at a target price of | 522/share.
Hence, at the current price and market conditions we believe the risk reward ratio is not favourable.
Exhibit 56: DCF calculation
Terminal Growth Rate
Terminal Value
Discounting Factor
PV of Terminal Value
6.0%
227,157.7
0.3
78,825.6
Revenue CAGR over FY12 - FY22E
FCF CAGR over FY12 - FY22E
PV of Cash Flow Till Terminal Year
Total Value of Firm
Current Debt
Total Present Value of Equity (Excluding Cash)
Total Cash on Balance Sheet
No. of Equity Shares
Per Share Value (Excluding Cash)
Cash Per Share
DCF Target Price
Upside / (Downside) (%)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
*All figures are in |crore except per share data
11.9%
12.5%
32,133.0
110,958.6
-
110,958.6
1,830.0
216.0
513.8
8.5
522.3
-9%
Page 32
300
200
500
400
At a current WACC of 10.1% and terminal growth of 6% the fair value of the stock is | 522. However, as markets improve and the WACC increases to 11.3% (terminal growth constant), the fair value of the stock would be
| 399/share as investors would shift to attractively valued stocks and sectors. On the other hand, if markets continue to underperform, HUL’s share could see further upsides from here.
Exhibit 57: DCF sensitivity
5.0%
5.5%
6.0%
6.5%
7.0%
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
8.9%
596
662
750
874
1,064
9.5%
512
558
616
694
804
WACC %
10.1%
448
481
522
575
645
10.7%
398
422
453
490
537
11.3%
357
376
399
426
460
In the past, HUL has traded at an average multiple of 25-30x its one year forward EPS. The company’s strong performance in FY11 and FY12 led the multiples to shift to 35-40x its one year forward EPS. However, we believe that with looming short-term concerns over the economic slowdown the stock is trading at very high multiples.
Exhibit 58: One year forward P/E multiple
600
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Price (|)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
25x 30x 35x 40x
Page 33
21
16
11
6
31
26
Historically, HUL has traded at P/E of ~1.8x the Nifty’s P/E. However, with the recent underperformance of the markets, HUL’s strong performance along with it being a defensive shed for the investors, the gap has expanded to ~2.8x to Nifty. The stock is trading at its all-time high P/E of
32x FY13E EPS. We believe this premium in multiple would shrink as market conditions improve.
Exhibit 59: HUL's P/E with respect to Nifty’s P/E based on 1-year forward earnings
30
25
20
15
10
40
35
Nifty P/E HUL P/E
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
HUL is commanding a premium in multiples (premium of ~25% over oneyear forward average P/E of its peers) on the back of its strong volume growth, consecutively in the last 10 quarters, highest rural reach and its presence across the value pyramid in soaps, detergents, personal care and beverages category. However, we believe that with margins being already lower than its peers ITC, Colgate, Nestle and Godrej, the stock could witness a downside if there is a slowdown in demand or increase in operating expenses that could unfavourably impact its performance.
Exhibit 60: Peer Comparison
HUL
ITC
Nestle India
P&G Health & Hygiene
Tata Global Beverages
Sales (| cr)
21735.6
Colgate-Palmolive 2693.2
Godrej Consumer Products 2980.1
24798.4
7490.8
1000.3
6585.3
FY12 Performance
EBITDA Margin
(%) EPS in |
14.9
12.5
21.7
19.3
36.0
21.0
16.6
9.5
46.5
5.8
32.8
18.6
7.9
99.7
RoE (%)
87.3
109.0
29.8
35.5
80.0
26.6
8.4
CAGR in % (FY08-12)
Sales EBITDA
Valuation Multiples
PAT P/E (current)
P/E (1-yr forward)
12.3
16.3
35.4
15.5
20.9
16.8
10.8
12.3
10.2
20.7
30.4
19.3
25.6
3.2
0.0
17.8
42.1
18.6
19.8
13.8
-31.8
45.7
37.7
36.1
35.8
46.6
44.4
17.0
42.3
32.8
38.7
30.5
40.5
35.8
24.6
Price/
Sales
3.8
4.7
3.2
6.7
5.3
5.5
1.1
Nestle India data corresponds to CY07-CY11; P&G’s data is for June, 2007-June,2011; Tata Global data is consolidated performance; HUL data is for CY07-FY12; HUL’s 1 yr fwd P/E is calculated on Adj. EPS
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 34
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Exhibit 61: Profit & Loss Account (Standalone)
(Year-end March)
Net Sales
Other Operating Income
Total Operating Income
Raw Material Expenses
Employee Expenses
Marketing Expenses
Administrative Expenses
Power & Fuel
Royalty
Other Manufacturing Expenses
Miscellaneous Expenses
Total Operating Expenditure
EBITDA
Interest
Less: Non Operating Expenses
PBDT
Depreciation
PBT before Exceptional Items
Less: Exceptional Items
PBT
Total Tax
PAT before MI
PAT
EPS (|)
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
FY10
17,523.8
201.5
17,725.3
-
8,877.9
936.3
2,391.4
1,356.3
244.3
157.8
282.7
728.6
14,975.4
2,750.0
7.0
(148.1)
2,891.1
184.0
2,707.1
(99.4)
2,806.4
604.4
2,202.0
2,202.0
10.1
FY12
21,735.6
380.8
22,116.4
-
11,737.8
1,107.3
2,634.8
1,650.8
285.2
293.3
338.4
777.5
18,825.0
3,291.3
1.2
(278.3)
3,568.4
218.3
3,350.2
(118.9)
3,469.0
777.6
2,691.4
2,691.4
12.5
FY11
19,401.1
334.1
19,735.2
-
10,056.9
961.3
2,764.2
1,594.6
274.7
268.9
343.4
771.9
17,035.9
2,699.3
0.2
(252.0)
2,951.0
220.8
2,730.2
(152.7)
2,882.9
576.9
2,306.0
2,306.0
10.7
FY13E
23,959.6
419.3
24,378.9
-
12,859.9
1,198.0
3,294.4
1,701.1
311.5
311.5
335.4
658.9
20,670.7
3,708.2
5.3
(479.2)
4,182.1
230.0
3,952.1
(604.7)
4,556.8
1,027.6
3,529.3
3,529.3
16.3
(| Crore)
FY14E
26,954.3
471.7
27,426.0
-
14,243.9
1,347.7
3,908.4
1,886.8
377.4
323.5
390.8
741.2
23,219.6
4,206.4
-
(539.1)
4,745.4
253.2
4,492.2
-
4,492.2
1,078.1
3,414.1
3,414.1
15.8
Page 35
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Exhibit 62: Balance Sheet (Standalone)
(Year-end March)
Equity Capital
Reserve and Surplus
Total Shareholders funds
Deferred Tax Liability
Other Non Current Liabilities
Long Term Provisions
Total Liability
Total Gross Block
Less: Acc. Depreciation
Net Block
CWIP
Total Fixed Assets
Net Intangible Assets
Other Investments
Inventory
Debtors
Loans and Advances
Other Current Assets
Cash
Total Current Assets
Creditors
Provisions
Other CL
Total Current Liabilities
Deferred Tax Assets
Loans & Advances
Total Asset
FY10
218.2
2,364.9
2,583.1
202.3
-
-
2,785.4
-
3,318.3
1,211.4
2,106.9
274.0
2,380.9
55.2
1,264.1
-
-
2,179.9
671.6
607.4
16.6
1,891.7
5,367.3
-
5,291.7
1,441.6
-
6,733.2
451.1
-
2,785.4
-
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
FY11
216.0
2,417.5
2,633.5
-
219.2
663.9
3,516.5
-
3,496.0
1,362.4
2,133.6
288.8
2,422.3
107.7
120.6
1,140.1
-
2,810.8
943.2
416.4
35.4
1,530.2
5,735.9
-
5,009.1
1,056.4
554.6
6,620.1
209.7
400.3
3,516.5
-
FY13E
216.2
3,807.1
4,023.2
-
329.7
667.0
5,019.9
-
3,884.4
1,646.9
2,237.5
205.1
2,442.7
40.3
286.3
2,601.9
-
2,472.2
787.7
472.6
34.2
2,007.9
5,774.6
-
4,923.2
1,280.0
555.4
6,758.6
214.2
418.4
5,019.9
-
FY12
216.2
3,296.8
3,512.9
-
329.7
667.0
4,509.6
-
3,534.4
1,416.9
2,117.5
205.1
2,322.7
40.3
186.3
2,251.9
-
2,516.7
679.0
485.8
35.3
1,830.0
5,546.7
-
4,623.0
1,279.0
546.8
6,448.7
214.2
396.2
4,509.6
-
(| Crore)
FY14E
216.2
4,202.2
4,418.3
-
329.7
667.0
5,415.0
-
4,284.4
1,900.1
2,384.3
205.1
2,589.4
40.3
386.3
3,001.9
-
2,992.5
812.3
497.8
35.8
1,490.3
5,828.8
-
5,169.3
1,344.0
630.6
7,144.0
214.2
498.0
5,415.0
-
Page 36
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Exhibit 63: Cash Flow Statement (Standalone)
(Year-end March)
Profit after Tax
Add: Depreciation
CF before WC changes
Changes in Inventory
Change in debtors
Change in loans & advance
Change in CA
Net increase in CA
Change in creditors
Change in Provisions
Change in other CL
Net increase in CL
Net CF from operating activities
Change in Deferred Tax Liab
Change in loans & advances
Changes in other investments
Changes in liquid investments
(Purchase)/Sale of Fixed Assets
Change in Deferred Tax Asset
Net CF from Investing Activities
Proceeds from Equity Capital
Proceeds from secured loan
Proceeds from unsecured loans
Payment of dividend/dividend tax
One time adj. in P/L Appropriation
Transfers to General Reserve
Transfers to Capital Red. Reserve
Transfers to Capital Sub. Reserve
Changes in ESOP
Changes in Securities Prem. Acc.
Net CF from financing activities
Net Cash Flow
Opening Cash
Closing Cash
-
(1,642.0)
-
(543.1)
2.3
-
(0.2)
(70.3)
(2,255.6)
(361.5)
1,891.7
1,530.2
-
FY11
2,306.0
220.8
2,526.8
(630.8)
(271.6)
191.1
(18.7)
(730.1)
(282.6)
(385.1)
554.6
(113.1)
1,683.5
-
(202.3)
(400.3)
1,143.5
(1,140.1)
(314.8)
241.5
219.2
663.9
210.5
-
(2.2)
-
(277.3)
(1,656.0)
(55.3)
-
-
-
(0.9)
32.0
(2,102.0)
(357.2)
2,249.0
1,891.7
-
FY10
2,202.0
184.0
2,386.1
348.9
(134.7)
134.7
(0.9)
348.1
1,035.8
(86.4)
-
949.4
3,683.5
-
18.1
-
(931.5)
-
(1,013.3)
(12.0)
-
-
(1,938.8)
-
0.2
(144.6)
-
(1,883.9)
-
0.5
-
0.6
32.8
37.9
(1,811.9)
299.8
1,530.2
1,830.0
-
FY12
2,691.4
218.3
2,909.7
294.1
264.2
(69.4)
0.1
489.0
(386.1)
222.5
(7.8)
(171.4)
3,227.3
-
-
4.1
(65.7)
(1,111.8)
(51.1)
(4.6)
110.5
3.1
(1,115.6)
-
0.2
-
(| Crore)
FY14E
3,414.1
253.2
3,667.3
(520.3)
(24.6)
(25.2)
(1.6)
(571.7)
246.1
64.0
75.2
385.3
3,481.0
-
-
(79.6)
(100.0)
(400.0)
(400.0)
-
-
-
(979.6)
-
-
-
-
(3,019.0)
-
-
-
-
-
-
(3,019.0)
(517.6)
2,007.9
1,490.3
-
FY13E
3,529.3
230.0
3,759.3
44.4
(108.7)
13.2
1.0
(50.1)
300.3
1.1
8.6
309.9
4,019.1
-
-
(22.3)
(100.0)
(350.0)
(350.0)
-
-
-
(822.3)
-
-
-
-
(3,019.0)
-
-
-
-
-
-
(3,019.0)
177.9
1,830.0
2,007.9
-
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Page 37
Exhibit 64: Ratio Analysis
(Year-end March)
Per Share Data
EPS
Cash EPS
Cash per Share
Revenue per Share
Operating profit per share
DPS
Operating Ratios
EBITDA / Net Sales
PAT / Total Operating Income
Return Ratios
RoE
RoCE
RoIC
Valuation Ratios
P/E
Target P/E
EV / EBITDA
EV / Net Sales
Market Cap / Sales
Target Market Cap / Sales
Dividend yield
FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13E FY14E
10.1
10.9
8.7
80.3
12.6
6.5
10.7
11.7
7.1
89.8
12.5
6.5
12.5
13.5
8.5
100.6
15.2
7.5
16.3
17.4
9.3
110.9
17.2
12.0
15.8
17.0
6.9
124.8
19.5
12.0
15.7
12.4
13.9
11.7
15.1
12.2
15.5
14.5
15.6
12.4
85.2
99.3
455.0
87.6
94.1
144.0
76.6
87.5
115.2
87.7
86.5
113.2
77.3
89.5
93.5
56.6
51.7
44.2
6.9
7.0
6.4
1.1
53.5
48.9
44.7
6.2
6.4
5.8
1.1
45.8
41.9
36.2
5.5
5.7
5.2
1.3
34.9
31.9
32.0
5.0
5.1
4.7
2.1
36.1
33.0
28.2
4.4
4.6
4.2
2.1
Turnover Ratios
Asset turnover
Debtors Turnover Ratio
Creditors Turnover Ratio
Inventory Turnover
6.4
26.1
3.3
7.4
6.2
20.6
3.9
7.8
5.4
32.0
4.7
8.2
5.0
30.4
4.9
9.6
5.2
33.2
5.2
9.9
Solvency Ratios
Current Ratio
Quick Ratio
0.8
0.5
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
0.9
0.6
0.9
0.6
0.9
0.6
0.8
0.6
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 38
The annexure represent the various ways in which HUL has churned its portfolio across categories in order to maintain its position in the respective category as well as stage itself successfully in the growing categories.
Exhibit 65: HUL's efforts in re-shaping its PP portfolio by extending its brand strength to emerging and faster growing categories
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 39
Exhibit 66: Engaging more consumers through its expanding portfolio in skin and hair care
More Users More Usage More Benefits
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Exhibit 67: Re-launches, innovations in soaps & detergents portfolio to capture changing demand pattern
Lux re-launch with silk protein extract
Rin Bar re-launch with superior formulation & packaging
Comfort: New variant with anti-bacterial action
Vim: Relaunched with
100 Nimboon ki Shakti
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Page 40
Exhibit 68: Innovating PP portfolio to tap higher growth markets, induce higher usage and drive penetration
Fair & Lovely Future Tube: Relaunch of Lakme Fruit Vaseline Relaunched: Vaseline Lip Therapy
Aspirational and Affordable Moisture Range Multi layer moisture with four new variants
Face Wash: Range expansion across brands Sunsilk Keratinology for salon Increasing accessibility
treated hair through | 1 sachets
Expanding the Deo Range Relaunched Pepsodent- G Relaunched Clear
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 41
Exhibit 69: Re-launches and Innovations in soaps and detergents portfolio to capture the changing demand pattern
Extending the Taj Mahal brand to green tea
Launching Taj Mahal tea bags in 7 flavours for 7 days
Extending the premium segment of Bru to cold coffee and Bru Exotica
Exhibit 70: Revamping foods portfolio to gain strength
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Kissan range expanded and re-launched Launch of | 5 Cup-a-Soups 100% fruit flavoured Selection Rich in 5
accessible packs instant soups ice-creams international flavours
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 42
Exhibit 71: Bru World Cafe Exhibit 72: Bru World Café at Juhu, Mumbai
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research
Source: Company, ICICIdirect.com Research
Page 43
RATING RATIONALE
st
We /I, Sanjay Manyal M.B.A.(FINANCE) Parineeta Poddar M.B.A.(FINANCE) research analysts, authors and the names subscribed to this report, hereby certify that all of the views expressed in this research report accurately reflect our personal views about any and all of the subject issuer(s) or securities. We also certify that no part of our compensation was, is, or will be directly or indirectly related to the specific recommendation(s) or view(s) in this report. Analysts aren't registered as research analysts by FINRA and might not be an associated person of the ICICI Securities Inc.
ICICI Securities Limited (ICICI Securities) and its affiliates are a full-service, integrated investment banking, investment management and brokerage and financing group. We along with affiliates are leading underwriter of securities and participate in virtually all securities trading markets in India. We and our affiliates have investment banking and other business relationship with a significant percentage of companies covered by our Investment Research Department. Our research professionals provide important input into our investment banking and other business selection processes. ICICI Securities generally prohibits its analysts, persons reporting to analysts and their dependent family members from maintaining a financial interest in the securities or derivatives of any companies that the analysts cover.
The information and opinions in this report have been prepared by ICICI Securities and are subject to change without any notice. The report and information contained herein is strictly confidential and meant solely for the selected recipient and may not be altered in any way, transmitted to, copied or distributed, in part or in whole, to any other person or to the media or reproduced in any form, without prior written consent of ICICI Securities. While we would endeavour to update the information herein on reasonable basis, ICICI Securities, its subsidiaries and associated companies, their directors and employees (“ICICI Securities and affiliates”) are under no obligation to update or keep the information current. Also, there may be regulatory, compliance or other reasons that may prevent ICICI Securities from doing so. Non-rated securities indicate that rating on a particular security has been suspended temporarily and such suspension is in compliance with applicable regulations and/or ICICI Securities policies, in circumstances where ICICI Securities is acting in an advisory capacity to this company, or in certain other circumstances.
This report is based on information obtained from public sources and sources believed to be reliable, but no independent verification has been made nor is its accuracy or completeness guaranteed. This report and information herein is solely for informational purpose and may not be used or considered as an offer document or solicitation of offer to buy or sell or subscribe for securities or other financial instruments. Though disseminated to all the customers simultaneously, not all customers may receive this report at the same time. ICICI Securities will not treat recipients as customers by virtue of their receiving this report. Nothing in this report constitutes investment, legal, accounting and tax advice or a representation that any investment or strategy is suitable or appropriate to your specific circumstances. The securities discussed and opinions expressed in this report may not be suitable for all investors, who must make their own investment decisions, based on their own investment objectives, financial positions and needs of specific recipient. This may not be taken in substitution for the exercise of independent judgment by any recipient. The recipient should independently evaluate the investment risks. The value and return of investment may vary because of changes in interest rates, foreign exchange rates or any other reason. ICICI Securities and affiliates accept no liabilities for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of this report. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. Investors are advised to see Risk Disclosure Document to understand the risks associated before investing in the securities markets. Actual results may differ materially from those set forth in projections. Forward-looking statements are not predictions and may be subject to change without notice.
ICICI Securities and its affiliates might have managed or co-managed a public offering for the subject company in the preceding twelve months. ICICI Securities and affiliates might have received compensation from the companies mentioned in the report during the period preceding twelve months from the date of this report for services in respect of public offerings, corporate finance, investment banking or other advisory services in a merger or specific transaction. It is confirmed that Sanjay Manyal M.B.A.(FINANCE) Parineeta Poddar M.B.A.(FINANCE) research analysts and the authors of this report have not received any compensation from the companies mentioned in the report in the preceding twelve months. Our research professionals are paid in part based on the profitability of ICICI
Securities, which include earnings from Investment Banking and other business.
ICICI Securities or its subsidiaries collectively do not own 1% or more of the equity securities of the Company mentioned in the report as of the last day of the month preceding the publication of the research report.
It is confirmed that Sanjay Manyal M.B.A.(FINANCE) Parineeta Poddar M.B.A.(FINANCE) research analysts and the authors of this report or any of their family members does not serve as an officer, director or advisory board member of the companies mentioned in the report.
ICICI Securities may have issued other reports that are inconsistent with and reach different conclusion from the information presented in this report. ICICI Securities and affiliates may act upon or make use of information contained in the report prior to the publication thereof.
This report is not directed or intended for distribution to, or use by, any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of or located in any locality, state, country or other jurisdiction, where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to law, regulation or which would subject ICICI Securities and affiliates to any registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction. The securities described herein may or may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to certain category of investors. Persons in whose possession this document may come are required to inform themselves of and to observe such restriction.
ICICI Securities Ltd | Retail Equity Research Page 44