EXPORT STRATEGY AND PLANNING Leonardo Da Vinci 2011-1-HR1-LEO05-00827 Author: MAKRO Contents 1. THINKING ABOUT EXPORTING .........................................................................................................4 1.1 Going Global – SME Strategies in the Global Arena ....................................................................4 1.2 Getting Started with Exports .....................................................................................................7 1.2.1 Why Export? .......................................................................................................................7 1.2.2 Why not Export? .................................................................................................................8 1.2.3 Company Specific Reasons for Getting Started with Exports ...............................................8 1.2.4 Review of Company Profile .................................................................................................9 1.2.5 Review of Company Objectives ...........................................................................................9 1.2.6 Export Readiness ................................................................................................................9 1.3 Planning Exports...................................................................................................................... 10 1.3.1 Why Plan? ........................................................................................................................ 10 1.3.2 What is an Export Plan? .................................................................................................... 11 1.3.3 Export Plan, What is it for? ............................................................................................... 11 1.3.4 Structure of Export Plan.................................................................................................... 12 2. ANALYSIS OF INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT ....................................................................................... 12 2.1 The Company .......................................................................................................................... 12 2.1.1 The Product ...................................................................................................................... 13 2.1.2 Resources and Business Processes .................................................................................... 13 2.1.3 Operations and Production Capacity ................................................................................. 13 2.1.4 Financial Capacity ............................................................................................................. 13 2.2 SWOT Analysis......................................................................................................................... 13 2.2.1 Why and When SWOT Analysis? ....................................................................................... 13 2.2.2 How to make a SWOT Analysis? ........................................................................................ 14 3. ANALYSIS OF EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT ....................................................................................... 15 3.1 Analysis of Micro Environment ................................................................................................ 15 3.2 Market Characteristics ............................................................................................................ 16 3.3 Competition ............................................................................................................................ 16 3.3.1 Porter’s Five Forces Model of Competition ....................................................................... 16 3.2 Analysis of Macro Environment ............................................................................................... 18 3.2.1 PEST Analysis .................................................................................................................... 18 4. SETTING EXPORT OBJECTIVES ........................................................................................................ 20 5. EXPORT STRATEGY ....................................................................................................................... 20 5.1 Market Entry Strategy ............................................................................................................. 21 5.1.2 Market Entry Modes ......................................................................................................... 21 5.2 Product Strategy ..................................................................................................................... 21 5.2.1 Engineering & Redesign .................................................................................................... 22 5.2.2 Labelling & Packaging ....................................................................................................... 22 5.2.3 Installation & Warranties .................................................................................................. 22 5.2.4 Pricing .............................................................................................................................. 22 5.3 Business Process Strategy ........................................................................................................ 22 5.4 Production & Operations Strategy ........................................................................................... 23 5.5 Financial Strategy .................................................................................................................... 23 6. ACTION PLAN ................................................................................................................................ 23 REFERENCES ..................................................................................................................................... 24 1. THINKING ABOUT EXPORTING 1.1 Going Global – SME Strategies in the Global Arena Today globalization is one of the factors which affect most of the firms in the world. Globalization of trade markets affects and shapes the firms not directly but indirectly. As a result of competition policies established in the globalization process, the countries have decreased the import duties and abolished the trade barriers. Therefore, firms are facing tough competition even in their domestic markets. Competitors from foreign countries enter the national markets, which were previously protected, with new products and technologies and affect the behavior and preferences of the consumers in these countries. Globalization process is accelerating with the technological development. Especially innovations in the information and electronic technologies disparage the world quickly. Classic competitive advantage theories are no more applicable in the world trade. Digital technologies are imposing a new competition attitude in most of the sectors. Technological development in the logistics and distribution area give the opportunity of selling the products in the global market electronically to the most of the firms. This provides huge opportunities to the customers. Customers became able to compare the price and quality of the product they want globally through their computers, phones or other mass media instruments. Customers have the opportunity to order the product they want electronically and make these products sent to their addresses. As a result, even the small firms which prefer to operate only in the domestic market are affected by this global competition. Even if these firms do not prefer to export or import, they face global competition. Undoubtedly, the competitive advantage of the small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) compared to the big ones is that they establish close relations with their customers and their skills in protecting these relations. However, it is obvious that SMEs will no longer be able to maintain this advantage in such a competitive world. In this context, SMEs must catch up the recent developments to survive in the markets which are different from what they are used to. The following simple questions are to be asked by the SMEs to draw a new strategy: 1) Can collaborating with an international partner or supplier ensure providing better service to our customers and strengthen our relations with our customers? 2) Does such collaboration increase our profitability? 3) Can a competitor enter our market and provide service to our customers through information technologies and today’s complicated marketing techniques? 4) How can our customers find new suppliers through internet? Change in the customers’ product preferences Change in the customers’ after sale service and price preferences Reduction in the concerns of the customers for doing business with a supplier which is not established in the national market If the firm gives positive answers to some of these questions and the change which is tried to be defined through the above questions is identified in the market, the firm must immediately develop a new strategy to adapt to the new conditions in the market. Export as a Strategic Choice for SMEs For the sustainable growth of SMEs which want to move forward and be developed, export is the necessary instrument to enter the global market. Export not only ensures growth in the sales but also provides other advantages; Enlargement of customer portfolio Mitigate the dependence on limited number of customers Mitigate the effect of conditional regional demand fluctuations Growth potential in the niche products which might not be demanded in the national market Enlargement of collaboration network, new experiences and as result better service for the domestic customers SMEs have unique characteristics like their size or ownership structures. Most of the SMEs are owned by families or small groups of regional entrepreneurs. In the globalization process, some of these characteristics provide advantages while some of them provide disadvantages. Characteristics Dependence on limited number of decision makers (Co-owners and managers are usually the same people) Advantages - Long-term perspective and stability - Consistency - Absence of pressure for short term success - Established business culture and identity - Responsibility and stability Close Relations with business partners and customers - Success in making future business relations permanent - Capability in collaborating successfully for common interests - Capability and desire in collaborating - High adaptation capability and flexibility - Quick reactions(decision making/answering) - Easy communication within the organization - Specialization opportunity and capability in getting successful Basic Organization Small Size Disadvantages - Limited thinking because of the limited knowledge and capacity of co-owners - Insufficient corporate culture and capacity in adapting to new opportunities and situations - Inconsistency between the corporate objectives and personal objectives of the firm’s owner - Risk of overly concentrating on the existing business and enterprise -Deficiency in capability of complicated planning and application for international - Unwilling to apply sophisticated organizations Limited financial and human resource opportunities: in the application of niche strategies - Difficulties in compensating new investments and business losses from new activities - Insufficiently compensating the cost of market research promotion activities - Insufficient number of employees to undertake additional duties - Lack of employee having international experience These characteristics are the prerequisites of success of SMEs in export. SMEs should overcome their certain weaknesses and satisfy certain prerequisites to enter the international market. These are: 1) The owners of the firms which want to enter the international market and export should have a strong vision, stability and commitment. Decision makers should believe that entering in the international markets as a strategy is necessary for the long-term development and success of the firm. Then they can overcome the problems on the way through globalization as entering in the export markets is a long and difficult process. Benefits can be achieved after a long, costly and difficult process. If the decision makers are not that committed, they will give up exporting as soon as they face a problem long before the success. 2) In addition to that, exporting requires certain amount of international knowledge and experience within the company. Without this knowledge and experience, the firms become dependent on third parties’ (consultants) advices. Moreover, dependence on third parties’ advices is always costly and sometimes unreliable. Therefore, in-house experiences should be established within the company in time. If the decision makers own the necessary knowledge and “know-how” to enter the international markets, reliability of the objectives determined and methods preferred increases. It is ideal that the co-owners of the firm or the next generation are being trained in this direction. It is essential that the co-owners of the firm in the future have the capacity for international commitments and to represent their firms in the international environment. If the firm does not own this experience within the organization, hiring a manager having this experience until gaining this experience or until the next generation grow up is suggested. There is another advantage of hiring a manager who is able to let the firm enter the international market. A person outside the organization will bring new thoughts which have never been considered before, new applications, a new attitude and a new culture. Globalization of a SME or another firm starts with making the co-owners and managers open to novelties. Without this, it is impossible for a firm to enter the international market. Therefore hiring a manager who has the authority to make decisions will ease the problem of resistance to entering the international markets and will help to overcome this problem. 3) Lastly, SMEs should understand that international activities are beyond finding new customers and buyers in foreign countries. Internationalization of a firm requires radical changes. This change requires taking risks, radical changes in business culture and intense learning capacity and these things cannot be achieved casually. In this process, painstaking and detailed inner change planning and leadership is needed as this change planning should be part of international activity planning. 1.2 Getting Started with Exports 1.2.1 Why Export? Emergence of recent technological developments eased the individuals to move and communicate faster with lower or no costs. These opportunities also highly affected the business world; the new age opened the businessmen the gates of foreign markets. Even if there are also several risks of entering foreign markets, exporting mostly serve the advantages given below: - - - - - - Increased sales and increased profits: If the firm is performing well in domestic market in terms of sales, exporting presumably would increase the demand by extending the market base to overseas countries and thus the profitability of the firm. Faster growth: Selling in overseas markets may help the business grow in size and scope at a faster rate. Reduced local market dependence and overcoming of local market fluctuations and vulnerability: If the firm diversify sales into international markets, it would avoid depending on a single market. In this case a local economic downturn would damage less if the demand in overseas markets remains high. Economies of scale: With a larger market base, the firm can save costs by producing on a scale that makes better use of resources; reduce waste by utilizing maximum production capacity and thus increase efficiency. Innovativeness by gaining new knowledge and experience in the global market: Exposure to new ideas, approaches, marketing techniques, technology and processes can help the firm develop innovative products and services. Domestic and global competitiveness: Trading in the global marketplace increases the exposure to international best practice, ideas and alternative ways of doing business while improving the chances of competing at home and overseas. Improvement of quality and price combination of products and product life cycle Enhancement of the company image Benefits for domestic economy: With the increase of production capacity there will be a need and chance of employment creation. Besides, turning into an exporting firm and having higher exports than imports may help domestic economy in the reduction of foreign trade deficit, if any. 1.2.2 Why not Export? Exporting also brings its own set of challenges and risks. These may include: - - - - - Increased costs and risk of lower profit margins: Exporting means costs which are mostly caused by the desire to gain market share, such as the costs of; extra travel, new marketing materials and maybe additional staff. Lower sales than expected: Sales may be lower in the beginning and it may take time to see a significant return on the export investment. Intense competition: Competition in foreign markets may be higher than expected. Late or non-payment risks: To avoid or minimise the risks of non-payment, the firms should research the market conditions in the target country and the credit worthiness of the potential customers before starting exports. Legal and regulatory issues: There may be different legal and regulatory issues than the home market such as; border-custom types, legal procedures in the cases of corruption, online security and bribery. It is very crucial to get a good grasp of how the procedures work in the chosen country before starting exports. Heavy paperwork: Authorities in the chosen markets may require a lot of documentation from the exporters. Cultural differences and language barriers: The firm will be dealing with a new culture by entering a new market. Business culture can even vary between regions of the same country, so local knowledge is vital in building valuable foreign working relationships. Economic and political risks: Risks such as unpredictable economic and political systems issues can deter the firm from expanding into a new market. Awareness about what is happening in the target market may help the firm avoid these issues. It is generally accepted that starting an export venture despite several risks would still benefit the firm, if the firm carefully assess the above listed advantages and disadvantages and take measures when necessary before entering a new market. Exporting activity would lead to changes in the way the business done and increase awareness within the firm’s own domain making it more innovative and responsive to changes in the market than otherwise it could be. 1.2.3 Company Specific Reasons for Getting Started with Exports The firm should answer several questions before starting an export venture and reach company specific reasons and advantages for export activities. The base for this short preliminary self recognition should be based upon what role the company expect export to play. Specific reasons should be drafted from the answers to the questions asking whether; the company is seeking an increase in profit or sales volume; it would like to develop a broader customer base, to learn more from overseas companies, to become more competitive in the domestic market, to make use of excess production capacity; the company is seeking for a specified level of return on investment from export activities and the company is expecting the export activities to become self sustaining (one year, two years ect.). After deciding upon the overweighing reasons, the company may then establish their export strategy accordingly. This way the strategy will be more realistic and precise while pulled away from being general and useless. 1.2.4 Review of Company Profile After drafting a rough outline of export objectives, the company should again draft an outline of the business being done; in terms of products, services, capability and business functions. The very first question of this phase should be; is my product/service appropriate for exporting? The answer of course would necessitate a very detailed analysis which will be needed later on in the strategy development. However, a rough answer “yes” or “no” would help the development of following phases. Afterwards, a short review of the capabilities of company and availability of business functions for export activities is necessary. Overall result from this phase should answer the following questions; is my company ready for exporting at a very first glance and does exporting alter the essence of my business any way? 1.2.5 Review of Company Objectives In this phase, the company should measure whether the management will be available to be fully committed to a concerted, long-term export effort. It should be very well understood by all relevant bodies in the company that the export activities are not based on short-term objectives. On the contrary, exporting should be recognized as a typical long-termed activity and the objectives should be developed in this sense. So the management’s export expectations should not be short-sighted or short-termed as exporting is a long term objective. 1.2.6 Export Readiness Export activities require a considerable level of use of relevant administrative, financial and productive resources. That is why there is a need of preliminary evaluation before deciding on taking start in export activities by answering some specific questions. Even if the context of this evaluation may take different forms, the questions given below are the ones that generally asked. Domestic Performance Why is the firm performing well in the domestic market? What is the present market share of the product that will be exported? Commitment and desire of the company for exporting What is the export purpose of the company? What is the level of export department in the hierarchical structure of the company? In which level of staff will be assigned for export activities? Is there a need for new recruitments? What are the experiences of the company or its staff regarding foreign markets and exports? Is the company willing to take start in exports? Is the company willing to take risks? Competitiveness What will make the products or services of the company competitive in a foreign market? What are the unique aspects of the products or services? What are the general competitive advantages of the company? (technology, patents, skills, and etc.) Target Markets Which groups in the market are targeted? How are the foreign competitors performing in the target market? Will the product be restricted by tariffs, quotas and other obstacles? Is the product appropriate for the foreign customers’ culture, traditions and beliefs? Is there a need for protection of product by patent/trademark rights? What are the requirements of labelling? Are there environmental restrictions? Is there a need for adaptation to environmental rules? Product Marketing How will the product advertised? Who will represent the company in the target market? Will the company assign an intermediate agency for the operations in export market? Is there a prototype of the product that can be presented to the target customers? Will the product be sold with the same name? Pricing and Trading Conditions How will the price be calculated? What are the service conditions? What are the payment and credit conditions? How long is the warranty period of the product? What are discount conditions? 1.3 Planning Exports 1.3.1 Why Plan? Planning defined as a basic management function involving formulation of one or more detailed plans to achieve optimum balance of needs or demands with the available resources. By containing optimisation and resource allocation together, planning is a key for the future success in business life. Planning as process; identifies the goals or objectives to be achieved; formulates strategies to achieve them; arranges required resources; and implements, directs, and monitors all steps in their proper sequence.1 When planning comes to trading in the global arena, there should be some other issues to consider in this process. These issues can be regarded as unpredictability or riskiness of global market. Planning and determining an export marketing strategy should therefore include these elements in order to achieve the optimum level of success in international trade. Starting an export business without an appropriate planning would undermine the prospects of success and this failure in international trade would eventually affect the course of domestic trade. That is why enterprises that intend start an export business should carefully screen the available markets, options for entry to those markets and etc. in order not to overlook any of exporting opportunities. 1 (http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/planning.html) In the case of lack of success in early exporting efforts, the company may be led to abandoning all exporting activities. Formulation of an export strategy which is based on proper information and assessment increases the possibility of choosing the best options, efficient allocation of available resources and the success of all efforts as an ultimate goal. 1.3.2 What is an Export Plan? Export plan is actually a business plan that focuses on international markets and a guideline for the development on a global scale. It identifies the target market(s), export goals, necessary resources and anticipated results in a quite comprehensive manner. 1.3.3 Export Plan, What is it for? The main purpose of export plan is to show everything devised for commercial operations abroad. Its purpose, function and content make it one of the most important strategic and tactical documents in the business. Individual purposes of export plan are; To bring all relevant exporting instruments together in a productive “mix”. To give direction to all planned activities for optimal effect. This direction is outlined in the objectives; - Estimation of which activity should take place and when. This timing will clarify the logical sequence, - Estimation of how much the activities are going to cost, in order to make the financial resources available whenever necessary, - Estimation of feasibility by deducting all costs from the profit to establish if the results are worth those costs. Export plan functions as to; Inform all people involved in the accomplishment of objectives defined for export activities, Give them specific instructions as to what their contributions to these activities will be, Provide a certain justification for the financial resources that will be spent in the export process. The plan should be prepared as short, precise and complete. The answers to the following questions should be contained therein; Which products are selected to be exported? Are there modifications needed in the product(s) to go beyond the domestic market? What are the target market(s) for the export business? What is the basic customer profile? Which marketing and distribution channels will be used to reach customers? Are there special challenges to be faced in target market(s)? How will be the pricing strategy? What are the human and/or company resources to be used in exporting activities? What are the operational actions? What about timing? What is the amount of budget? What are the feedback actions? An export plan should include specific and clear set of instructions and to identify every step of the process. The initial plan may need to be modified as the process goes on and results obtained. 1.3.4 Structure of Export Plan Export plan has similar content with a business plan. Much like business plan, export plan focuses on key factors such as strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats in the global arena. The main differences between business and export plans lie in their purposes of use. While business plan is generally used for having an overall picture of future of company, export plan focuses mainly on international markets and used for the development in a global scale. Both give the company more credibility with investors, who will ask the company to prove the capacity for exporting. Export plan should cover a period of at least 3 to 5 years – although long-term plans can cover a period of up to 10 years. 2. ANALYSIS OF INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT Environmental analysis of a business enterprise includes both internal and external forces that affect the operations of the business. The internal factors are generally regarded as controllable, while the external factors are by and large beyond the control of the business. So, the success in the external environment mostly depends on a large extent on the adaptability to the environment. Expansion to international markets requires a testing of all organisational factors affecting current operations of the business. The way that the company operates in the domestic market does not always fit to international markets and that is why the company has to re-evaluate its business functions and strategic actions in detail. Planning of export operations requires a clear vision of the present situation and future expectations. An internal analysis then leads to a realistic company profile, which is the determination of the firm’s strategic competencies and weaknesses. 2.1 The Company Development of company profile can be done in a four-step process: Examination of key aspects of the business’s operation and target areas for further assessment, Comparison of these aspects with past abilities of the firm, Establishment of a comparative basis in relation to key market or product conditions in order to more accurately determine whether the company’s condition on a particular factor represents a potential strength or weakness, Provision of results from previous steps as an input into the strategic management process and decisions made for the entrance the foreign arena. The objective of company analysis is to determine how export will affect the current business and to identify the main capabilities and needs. This process should be done as objectively and honestly as possible. The aim is to determine if the benefits of exporting exceed the anticipated costs. 2.1.1 The Product Review of the products and services is necessary in order to determine whether they have export potential. Other important aspects about the products or services to be exported are; their prices and costs, channels that they perform best, their suitability for overseas markets in their current form and the necessary modifications, requirement of licence or permit for export, additional marketing materials or support. 2.1.2 Resources and Business Processes - Management and Human Resources – The evaluation of current in-house expertise in export and identification of whether additional facilities/manpower needed is very crucial to grow the export capability of the company. The company management should also develop the operational structure and lines for authority for the export department. - Legal and Intellectual Property (IP) – Evaluation of trademark and other IP; the need to seek additional IP protection in potential overseas markets. 2.1.3 Operations and Production Capacity Evaluation of production capacity consists of; identification of the current production/service capacity and the capacity levels available for export markets, expandability of product/service capabilities to meet market demand and the cost, the existence of seasonal fluctuations in demand for the product/service, the minimum viable order quantity for orders placed to ensure corporate profitability, changes required to design packaging for products specifically for export. 2.1.4 Financial Capacity Evaluation of the availability of current financial situation for export consists of; determination of whether additional capital commitment required by the company to enter export markets, other company financial initiatives that may affect the export plans, approximate time that export effort become self-sustaining financially. 2.2 SWOT Analysis As an acronym for the (internal) Strengths and Weaknesses, (external) Opportunities and Threats of an organization, SWOT Analysis is a well known and commonly used method for assessing a business, its resources and environment. Businesses are not the only type of organizations that can be analysed with this method; for products, places and persons, a SWOT Analysis can be carried out as well. The method has been created by Albert S. Humphrey in the 1960s and since then it kept its importance and usefulness as the same it was then. SWOT Analysis is generally used in the form of a 2x2 matrix, strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats are listed singly in each of the matrix boxes. This method is used to make easier the matching strengths to opportunities and converting weaknesses or threats into strengths and opportunities. 2.2.1 Why and When SWOT Analysis? The main idea of SWOT Analysis is; making the most of existing strengths and opportunities and, setting plans and strategies to lower the adverse affects of weaknesses and threats to minimum, all by identifying the internal and external factors of the organization. By analysing the activities being performed well and the areas which need to be improved, one can easily set objectives; generate an effective and comprehensive strategy towards. SWOT Analysis will be a good pathfinder, when there is a need for; a strategic plan to be developed to achieve a specific outcome, clarification of a problem and fast response to it. SWOT Analysis is a good way to list down the facts in an easy manner and then picking the ones to be turned into opportunities. This feature of the method is useful also when the quantitative information is not enough and the facts are tacitly embedded in the people. 2.2.2 How to make a SWOT Analysis? First of all, there are some prerequisites to be kept in mind before starting the analysis: - SWOT Analysis needs to be made by the collective work of people from various departments of the organization in order discuss the facts in detail with different points of view. Having a realistic and objective stance would yield better results and thus correct strategies. Looking from a wide angle and not focusing on just a few perfect or problematic areas are important to clarify the missing pieces. By considering the issues above, the elements of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats can be listed down. Strengths The very basic question of revealing the internal strengths of a company is; what do you do better than anyone else? The question is narrowed down with the competitors around the company. Because a good performance is not a strength anymore if others also has the same level of it. However, for example, if you serve your customers by differentiating just a little part of your process and if this increases the customer loyalty more than the others, this can be classified as a strength. Strengths can be seen in terms of the staff, product or service quality, process, technology and etc. and also customers’ opinion about your company. Listing down all the characteristics would help to pick the ones fall under the strengths. Exaggeration of basic characteristics would not create realistic results. Weaknesses The answers to the question of “What are the areas to be improved for not to fall behind the competitors? ” would serve as weaknesses of the company. This can be considered again from both internal and external basis; paying attention to the opinions of the people outside the company would keep objectivity. Thinking about the competitors with realistic comparison of the main characteristics and being ready for unpleasant results would again yield in realistic results and thus better decisions. Opportunities What are the recent developments involving the company and how would they benefit it? Opportunities in the external environment can be listed as; changes in technology and market both in local and global, changes in the government policies in relation to the company’s field of activity, changes in the socio-cultural environment and local events. One could look at internal strengths and consider ways to convert them into opportunities. Alternatively, another good idea would be considering the internal weaknesses, ways for addressing them and making use of them by generating new opportunities. Threats What are the external obstacles that the company faces? The above listed conditions in the external environment can also be threats as well, for instance; changing technology could be threatening the company while some of the competitors have enough capacity to easily adapt the changes. There could be danger of new competitors moving to the field or political environment is acting against company’s field of activity and etc. Thinking about the worst case is important in order to create contingency plans to deal with the possible threats, before they already start to affect the business. 3. ANALYSIS OF EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT Before entering into a new market, the business should look around carefully and decide whether it will bring success to start operations in that market. Analysis of this new environment should be done in both micro and macro level. While micro environment consists of actors in the immediate one that affect the performance of the firm, such as suppliers, competitors, marketing intermediaries, customers etc.; macro environment consists of larger societal forces that affect the actors in the company’s micro environment, such as demographic, economic, natural, legal, technical, political and cultural forces. 3.1 Analysis of Micro Environment Analysis of micro environment consists of identification of current internal status of the business in relation to the external environment. This process also represents the export potential of the company. In this step, company’s possible competitive advantages abroad should be analysed and a decision made whether the available resources support export activities. As a summary of micro environment analysis, main dimensions are given below: 1) Analysis of pros and cons of market expansion: Identification of success factors within the domestic market and determination of whether the same factors, such as price and brand image, can be replicated in foreign markets. Exploration of expansion possibilities in the domestic market, whether or not to expand at all, or innovating new products for the domestic market. 2) Research of business’s competitive advantages abroad: Comparison of the product or service advantages and disadvantages with those of likely competitors. Some questions to be asked while determining these advantages and disadvantages would include: Can we sell the product abroad without changing its form or the manner in which it is marketed? Can we sell the same product but for a different use? Will we have to change the product to make it export worthy? Should we develop a new product for targeted foreign markets? 3) Determination of financial resources: Once the competitive advantages, pros and cons of market expansion are determined, necessary financial resources to support exporting and whether there is a need for additional capital should be specified. 3.2 Market Characteristics The ability to make successful export plans depends on the ability to collect appropriate and valid information about international markets (Morgan et al., 2003). Without a deep understanding of the foreign market, companies will not be able to develop efficient and effective export marketing programmes. Therefore they should establish a clear system for collection, dissemination and utilisation of information necessary for export activities. The necessary information that the company should seek for consist of; the magnitude of the target market, its growth rate, demographics, targeted segments or niches, consumption capacity of each segment, total expenditure on similar products, the possibility of the product to be popular and competitive in sophisticated markets or in developing countries, new trends, general future outlook of the market and other opportunities, requirements for after-sales services. 3.3 Competition Research and analysis of competitive conditions in the target market, starts with identifying the main competitors in that markets. A SWOT analysis should be conducted for these competitors as well. An outline of their strengths and weaknesses and which strategic moves they likely to make in response to the opportunities and threats presented by the market would be helpful. Because these opportunities and threats are not only drivers for the company’s own performance, but will also direct the other players and possible new market entrants. To make a specified identification for competitors, the information that will be collected should include following dimensions; major and minor competitor details, their number, market share and level of sales, which competitor dominates in which product segment/distribution channel; assessment of the competitors in terms of quality, price, packaging/presentation, advertising and promotion, delivery, performance, level of customer loyalty, credit terms and customer service; need for emulating them for the purpose of penetration to the market; potential threats from substitute products and new competitors and etc. To have a more general picture or the competitive conditions in the target market, a useful tool, Porter’s Five Forces Model, can be developed. 3.3.1 Porter’s Five Forces Model of Competition The model is one of the various vital frameworks of Michael Porter (Management Researcher in Harvard Business School) for developing an organization’s strategy. The model is useful because it helps companies identify both strength of their current position, and strength of a position that is desired to be moved into. According to Porter, the nature of competition in any industry is personified in the following five forces:2 Bargaining Power of Suppliers: Suppliers refer to the firms that provide inputs to the industry. Bargaining power of the suppliers refer to the potential of the suppliers to increase the prices of inputs (labour, raw materials, services, etc) or the costs of industry in other ways. Strong suppliers can extract profits out of an industry by increasing costs of firms in the industry. Supplier’s products have a few substitutes. Strong suppliers’ products are unique. They have high switching cost. Their product is an important input to buyer’s product. They pose credible threat of forward integration. Buyers are not significant to strong suppliers. In this way, they are regarded as a threat. Bargaining Power of Buyers: Buyers refer to the customers who finally consume the product or the firms who distribute the industry’s product to the final consumers. Bargaining power of buyers refer to the potential of buyers to bargain down the prices charged by the firms in the industry or to increase the firms cost in the industry by demanding better quality and service of product. Strong buyers can extract profits out of an industry by lowering the prices and increasing the costs. They purchase in large quantities. They have full information about the product and the market. They emphasize upon quality products. They pose credible threat of backward integration. In this way, they are regarded as a threat. 2 http://www.managementstudyguide.com/porters-model-of-competetion.htm (accessed on 27.02.2013) Threat of Substitute Products: Substitute products refer to the products having ability of satisfying customers’ needs effectively. Substitutes pose a ceiling (upper limit) on the potential returns of an industry by putting a setting a limit on the price that firms can charge for their product in an industry. Lesser the number of close substitutes a product has, greater is the opportunity for the firms in industry to raise their product prices and earn greater profits (other things being equal). Threat of New Entrants: Potential competitors refer to the firms which are not currently competing in the industry but have the potential to do so if given a choice. Entry of new players increases the industry capacity, begins a competition for market share and lowers the current costs. The threat of entry by potential competitors is partially a function of extent of barriers to entry. The various barriers to entry are: Economies of scale Brand loyalty Government Regulation Customer Switching Costs Absolute Cost Advantage Ease in distribution Strong Capital base Rivalry among Current Competitors: Rivalry refers to the competitive struggle for market share between firms in an industry. Extreme rivalry among established firms poses a strong threat to profitability. The strength of rivalry among established firms within an industry is a function of following factors: Extent of exit barriers Amount of fixed cost Competitive structure of industry Presence of global customers Absence of switching costs Growth Rate of industry Demand conditions 3.2 Analysis of Macro Environment Macro Environment analysis is a review of all the factors that a company unable to control. The market dictates the rules of the global play that the company is about to enter. The key questions here: Can you deal with the market trends? Do the trends offer you chances or challenges for export success? Together with the competitor analysis (Porters Five Forces), it will determine the decision making for final market selection and market entry strategy. 3.2.1 PEST Analysis An ideal tool for assessing macro-environment of business is PEST analysis which stands for “Political, Economic, Social and Technological” analysis. There are several extended or varied versions of this tool, in which some factors are dissociated from their families in PEST method and included separately as Ecological, Ethical, Ethical or Legal. It is a matter of personal choice, but for most situations original PEST analysis model arguably covers all of the ‘additional’ factors within the original four main sections. The main items that should be included in the analysis are given in the table below3. The items can be described as whether they represent an opportunity or threat for the company to operate in the target market. Another method to conduct the analysis would be scoring the items in each of the sections. Scoring is particularly beneficial if more than one market is being analysed, for the purpose of comparing which market or opportunity holds most potential and/or obstacles. Political Ecological/environmental issues Current legislation home market Future legislation International legislation Regulatory bodies and processes Government policies Government term and change Trading policies Funding, grants and initiatives Home market lobbying/pressure groups International pressure groups Wars and conflicts Social 3 Economic Home economy situation Home economy trends Overseas economies and trends General taxation issues Taxation specific to product/services Seasonality/weather issues Market and trade cycles Specific industry factors Market routes and distribution trends Customer/end-user drivers Interest and exchange rates International trade/monetary issues Technological Lifestyle trends Demographics Consumer attitudes and opinions Media views Law changes affecting social factors Brand, company, technology image Consumer buying patterns Fashion and role models Major events and influences Buying access and trends Ethnic/religious factors Advertising and publicity Ethical issues http://www.businessballs.com/pestanalysisfreetemplate.htm Competing technology development Research funding Associated/dependent technologies Replacement technology/solutions Maturity of technology Manufacturing maturity and capacity Information and communications Consumer buying mechanisms/technology Technology legislation Innovation potential Technology access, licensing, patents Intellectual property issues Global communications 4. SETTING EXPORT OBJECTIVES Formulation of export objectives marks the start of strategy stage. This stage is meant to provide the company with a sense of direction: a clear understanding of the future business activities, elimination of doubts, second thoughts and a clear view of the tasks and challenges that lay ahead. Based on the market conditions and developments analysed before and company’s state of export readiness, it is time to define into detail what the company really want to achieve, where, when and how. In other words, the company now should be able to formulate sound objectives. These objectives should provide the building blocks for the company’s targets. Therefore they should be SMART: Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic and Time-led. Specific: Goals need to be clearly defined and unambiguous. When goals are specific they tell you what you need to achieve, by when, by whom and how much it is going to cost. Measurable: Objectives should be quantitative, expressed in terms of sales value, sales growth, market share, number of customers and etc. Achievable: Objectives should be set as attainable as possible. There is no point in setting goals that are impossible to reach. They should be based on the company’s strengths and its critical success factors (internal) and market opportunities (external). Realistic: Realistic goals are also the ones that are achievable. To be realistic, one should be willing and able to work towards the main objective and all the necessary resources should be available. Time-led: The goal should be set as they will be attained in a specific time period. Specific objectives and their contexts can be regarded as follows: Financial Objectives: The level of profit and return on investment desired to achieve, Sales Objectives: Number of foreign markets desired to export to and timing, level of export sales desired to achieve in a specified time period, Learning Objectives: New skills and knowledge desired to acquire, Production Objectives: Level of production capacity that desired to operate. 5. EXPORT STRATEGY Strategy is all about developing a sense of direction for the company. On the basis of the conclusions of the environmental and competitor analyses, now it is time to develop a strategy for realising the objectives. The selected strategy will be determined by the nature of the product or service and by the conditions and requirements in the company’s potential markets. Development of an export strategy involves development of; market entry, product, business process, operations and financial strategies. The management team committed to exporting will take sufficient time to work through and accurately address the below issues. They will establish the levels of corporate commitment and responsibility the company is prepared to undertake to identify and develop expected export opportunities. 5.1 Market Entry Strategy This stage involves determining target market segments, choosing the market entry mode and selecting the right trade partners. After selecting target markets it is time decide on the mode of sales in overseas markets. There are several ways of getting started in exports. Which path to chose will depend on the business’s broad strategy, its commitment to export and its capacity to handle complexity. 5.1.2 Market Entry Modes4 Export Entry Modes: Direct exporting through local sales representatives or distributors, Indirect exporting through intermediaries – agents, Countertrade through barter or payment in kind or promises to make future purchases. Contractual Entry Modes: Licensing - patents, copyrights, special formulas, designs, trademarks and brand names, Franchising – hotels, fast food chains, car rentals and etc. Investment Entry Modes – Foreign Direct Investment: Strategic alliances Joint ventures Wholly owned subsidiaries 5.2 Product Strategy Selecting and preparing the product for export require not only product knowledge but also knowledge of the unique characteristics of each target market. The company may need to do some degree of adapting the selected product for sale outside domestic markets before starting exports. The company will also need to conduct consultancy with prospective customers, wholesalers, agents and other bodies to determine the best strategy for selling the products in overseas markets. The company should carefully screen; the ability of product to satisfy foreign needs; the need for modification or development of a new version for the foreign market; specific features, such as design, colour, size, packaging, brand, labels and warranty that the product should have; pre and post sale service requirements and etc. The product may need to be adapted to target market’s government regulations, geographic and climatic conditions, buyer preferences or standards of living. The most important aspect for product adaptation is conforming to the foreign government product regulations. These regulations are being imposed by the governments for the purposes of protection of domestic industries from foreign competition, customer rights and etc. 4 Victorian Government Business Centre (2009), Opening Doors to Export – connects you to world-class export assistance, Melbourne, Australia 5.2.1 Engineering & Redesign Exporting may necessitate some fundamental changes in engineering and design of the products before it is ready to be sold abroad. If the company is producing and planning to export electrical products, it should consider the electrical standards of the target country. Because phases, cycles or voltages may differ from region to region or country to country. 5.2.2 Labelling & Packaging Language and culture of the target country are important factors to consider when preparing the product for export. The package of the product is as important as the product itself when the cultural differences are considered. Because what they first see is its package and they always prefer the product to be labelled in their own language. When labelling the product, the company may consult with its foreign partners and learn what kind of a label would be more appealing in that market. 5.2.3 Installation & Warranties Another element of product preparation that the company should consider is the ease of installing the product overseas. Installation instructions are worthless unless they can be easily understood by customers or technicians that are assigned for installation. Translations for installation instructions should be made for target country language or to minimize confusion in any case, preassembling certain parts of the product before shipping may help installation after purchase. Likewise, warranty information can be source of confusion for foreign customers. The scope of warranty should be clearly stated in customers’ language. Besides, the fact is that the stronger the scope of warranty the easier to break into a new market. 5.2.4 Pricing The last, but not least, issue about the preparation of the product for foreign markets is pricing strategy. Price is important, because it is the only element of the marketing mix that generates income, all others cost money. That is why all the aspects of pricing strategy should be carefully screened. These aspects can be summarised as; the factors affect the prices settings, product sensitivity to prices changes, type of pricing policy to be implemented (high profit/low turnover and/or low profit/high turnover), discount policies and etc. Detailed information about pricing strategy can be found in “Pricing, Financing and Payment Methods” 5.3 Business Process Strategy Export process has some other aspects like shipping, insurance, negotiation with buyers, intellectual property rights, organisational and staff requirements. Shipping: In consultation with shippers, the company should find the right shipping method for the delivery on time and affordable cost. The options are; trucking - still popular, but declining; rail – a good option for shipping to seaports for transport abroad; air – faster and safe but expensive and not covering all destinations; ocean - most common method, economic but slow delivery. Insurance: The company should decide whether to insure the goods for loss or damage during transit and/or for default by the buyer. Negotiations: Through negotiations with buyers, the company should determine terms of trade that will govern the sale. Detailed information can be found in “Trade Negotiations”. Intellectual property protection needs should be determined. Organisational Structure: The company should outline how the export function will be organised, determine the place of this function in the organisational chart, and outline roles and responsibilities, determine whether there is a need for additional staff and expertise. 5.4 Production & Operations Strategy After a comprehensive evaluation of production capacity, the company should be able to determine whether; the current production capacity will allow market expansion and thus the need for more production, to expand product capabilities to meet market demand and additional cost, there are seasonal fluctuations in demand for the product, the viable order quantity could be achieved to ensure corporate profitability and there are changes required for design of packaging and labelling of products. 5.5 Financial Strategy The last, but certainly not the least important aspect of the export strategy is of course the export financing. The company should finalise the decision of whether there will be a need for additional capital commitment required for the entrance to export markets. An outline of financial needs in relation to additional production capacity, pre-shipment finance, working capital and post-shipment finance will be needed. It is a fact that, the export drive needs the financial stability and strength that comes from a reliable cash flow. So, a comprehensive financial plan that reflects the financial strength of company would be helpful for the export venture. The most important objective of the plan is ensuring the company always has sufficient cash or operating lines of credit. Other important details about export financing and payment methods can be found in “Pricing, Financing and Payment Methods” 6. ACTION PLAN Putting all together the above issues, now it is time to prepare a clear outline for taking action in exporting. Until now, the company should have the following: - A full commitment to exporting, Necessary skills and resources to undertake the challenge, Knowledge about the target market, export and financial plan, Market entry strategy and the support system – shippers and other intermediary bodies in place. A good way of drafting an outline for what needs to be done to achieve the previously set objectives is using a simple table representing tasks, responsibilities and deadlines for getting started. Outlining single tables for each activity, such as market entry, target market visit, product preparations, marketing, business process, staffing and financial requirements would be helpful and each table should include specific information about tasks to be realised, description of sub activities, by whom and when these will be realised . REFERENCES - - - Saudi Industrial Development Fund, Guidelines for Export Plan (http://www.sidf.gov.sa/En/MediaCenter/Documents/Export-Plan.pdf - Accessed on 01.03.2013) New Zealand Trade & Enterprise (2002), Exporter Information Tools: Export Plan – A How to Guide Centre for the Promotion of Imports from Developing Countries (2009), Export Marketing Planner – A Manual on How to Enter European Markets, Rotterdam, The Netherlands Centre for the Promotion of Imports from Developing Countries (2009), Export Planner – A comprehensive guide for prospective exporters in developing countries, Rotterdam, The Netherlands Köksal M. H. (2008), How export marketing research affects company export performance – Evidence from Turkish companies, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon http://www.managementstudyguide.com/porters-model-of-competetion.htm - Accessed on 27.02.2013 Victorian Government Business Centre (2009), Opening Doors to Export – connects you to world-class export assistance, Melbourne, Australia